Live Weekly Demo | Led by a Rev Workflow Specialist
Save Your Spot
GA v. Lacy Boles Day 5

GA v. Lacy Boles Day 5

Day five of the trial of Lacy Boles, charged with murdering husband Daniel Akers in 2019. Read the transcript here.

Day five of the trial of Lacy Boles, charged with murdering husband Daniel Akers in 2019.
Hungry For More?

Luckily for you, we deliver. Subscribe to our blog today.

Thank You for Subscribing!

A confirmation email is on it’s way to your inbox.

Share this post

Copyright Disclaimer

Under Title 17 U.S.C. Section 107, allowance is made for "fair use" for purposes such as criticism, comment, news reporting, teaching, scholarship, and research. Fair use is permitted by copyright statute that might otherwise be infringing.

Judge (15:48):

Mr. Steel, this is yours. This is an exhibit.

Mr. Steel (15:51):

Thank you, sir.

Judge (15:55):

Yes, sir. All right. Anything before we call in the jury?

Mr. Treadaway (16:00):

[inaudible 00:16:01] State, may I call the witness?

Mr. Steel (16:02):

Yes, sir. Good morning, Your Honor. Good morning, everyone. And I told the Honorable Mr. Cole this last night.

Judge (16:08):

Okay.

Mr. Steel (16:09):

Or when we ... I know it wasn't last night, but when we were leaving. Here's the way I understand it, but I don't have a copy of the transcript, but I need your Honorable Court to please permit me to inquire of the witness the following. Shocking to me, shocking to me, this Honorable Court made a ruling that everybody follows. This Honorable Court's been nothing but giving of itself and energized to try to do the law and fairness. And I wanted to get in the fact that there is a conviction in 2009, arrest in Douglas County, 15 year sentence. There was prison part of the sentence. It continues till 2024. In the interim, Mr. Akers gets arrested in Cobb County for drugs, enters a guilty plea. There's a revocation. He's back on probation. He spends time in jail. He's back on probation.

(17:28)
It corroborates his belief, his state of mind that came in through a text message that he's looking at the relevant period of time around the date of his suicide at going to prison on top of losing his wife, on top of losing his kids, on top of losing his job, on top of the failures that he wrote in October, on Halloween, November and December, saying how he is depressed, how he has inner demons. That's not the word though. And how he will bury Lacy and himself. That's a murder-suicide and leave the kids to go to foster care.

(18:20)
The prosecutor, the prosecutor, on redirect, shockingly, the Court kept me away from introducing the fact that there is a live probation case, knows there's a live probation case, knows that Mr. Akers did not fulfill his requirements of the court of his sentence, and has the nerve, the audacity as a lawyer to say to the witness, "You don't know," and then I'd like it to be whatever the record is because my memory may not be perfect, but it was something to the effect of, "You don't know whether Mr. Akers really didn't care and wasn't concerned about going to prison because he fulfilled his community service, because he paid-"

Judge (19:13):

I have the exchange right here.

Mr. Steel (19:15):

Can I look at it?

Judge (19:16):

Yes.

Mr. Steel (19:17):

Thank you. May I approach?

Judge (19:18):

Yes.

Mr. Steel (19:43):

Thank you, Your Honor. I'd like to mark this for the record, but it states, and I'm reading it accurately. There's no page number on it. It's the second question on the page. "Do you know the status of Mr. Akers having caught up on all of his probation requirements in the next month of his life?"

(20:02)
Answer: "I don't know."

(20:03)
"So you don't know if he was caught up with his community service?"

(20:08)
"I do not."

(20:09)
Question: "Do you know if he was caught up with any kind of evaluations or testings or anything else he had to do, his fine payments? Do you know anything about whether or not he was caught up in that next 20 or 32 or 33 days?"

(20:27)
Answer: "No, sir." It doesn't end there.

(20:29)
Question: "No idea?"

(20:31)
Answer: "No idea."

(20:35)
Outrageous. I would never do ... That's a lie. I have been called-

Mr. Treadaway (20:40):

I'm not going to sit here-

Mr. Steel (20:41):

I have been called hyperbole.

Mr. Treadaway (20:41):

... Listen to this man call me a liar-

Mr. Steel (20:41):

I have been called-

Judge (20:41):

Y'all both stop-

Mr. Treadaway (20:42):

Your Honor-

Judge (20:46):

Y'all both stop.

Mr. Steel (20:47):

I have been called-

Judge (20:49):

Both stop. Please. Please. All right. Please have a seat. I don't know what to say. Let's continue. I'm going to give you a chance to respond.

Mr. Steel (21:03):

I know what to say. I sat here during an opening statement. Ms. Boles was compared to Bonnie and Clyde and The Sex Pistols. This is not a murder-suicide. This is not a traveling murderer. No place in this trial. I have sat here and listened to wrong information. Ms. Boles is laughing. I asked Mr. Lale, he's right here. Raymond Lale said, "I'm sitting right next to her. That never happened, ever." The witness said, "No, I didn't notice that. I just saw her put her head down."

Judge (21:37):

Let's get back. Let's get to-

Mr. Steel (21:39):

I've been called, I'm using hyperbole. I never ... I love this. I love doing it. I'm honored to do this. I respect this. This is outrageous conduct. It's misconduct. I know judges who would've said approach the bench. I'm not criticizing. I know judges who have said approach the bench. Not only did you just open the door, I'm admonishing you in front of the jury. You had no good faith belief to ask any of these questions because you know he's on open probation. You know there's a warrant for him. You know Mr. Steel was just trying to keep it in, you objected and I kept it out. And now you are misinforming, misleading and obstructing justice to this jury by giving them the impression that really that maybe he wasn't worried about prison.

(22:36)
We don't know. That's going to be the closing argument. We don't know. The detective said he doesn't know if [inaudible 00:22:42] he was on probation. He doesn't know if all the requirements ... So Mr. Steel shows you a text message, but that may not have been his state of mind. It has to be corrected. The ball game has changed. I accepted the Court's ruling. The Court said it's really his state of mind. Who cares? Who cares if it's really a probation revocation case? Why ask these questions knowing that it's untrue? What lawyer does that? So I'm asking the Court ... I'm going to ... It's certified copies. They come right in. I'm going to put it into evidence and I'm going to clear it up with this witness. I'm going to argue in closing argument that that was a sham, just like this whole trial. And I don't know how the trial's even going forward.

(23:38)
I know it's not directed verdict time, but there's two lead detectives. They both said they have no idea if Lacy Boles introduced the gun. I asked both of them, open-ended question. I don't lead them. I sat here all day yesterday as patient as can be. I was naked. I let the guy ... I asked him about every single issue in this case that he touched. I played the 911 recording. There's no evidence here to go to a jury and the prosecutors know it. This is wrong. And this is one example.

(24:18)
I ask the Court to permit the truth to come out, or if you don't want me to do it, then the Court should do it and admonish the prosecutor in front of the jury and say, "These questions, ladies and gentlemen, I'm going to read them to you." The prosecutor knew. He knew when he was asking those questions that his community service was not caught up, that there wasn't ... Caught up on any evaluations or testing or anything else he had to do. His fines were paid. Anything, whether or not he was caught up in the next 30, 20, 32 or 33 days. Where does this come from?

Judge (25:00):

I understand.

Mr. Steel (25:01):

So that's my point.

Judge (25:02):

I understand.

Mr. Steel (25:02):

And I'd like the Court to allow me to do it, but if you don't want me to do it, then I'll ask the Court to do it in front of jurors because this has to be corrected. This is a misstatement, knowing misstatement of fact.

Judge (25:19):

Do me a favor and pass that transcript over to them. Yes, sir. Whenever you're ready.

Mr. Treadaway (25:35):

May it please the Court, Your Honor, I'm not going to dignify this man or his statements by defending my ethical integrity in this process or this courtroom. If he wants to question that, let's settle it outside by the Christmas tree in front of the courthouse.

Judge (25:50):

That's out of line.

Mr. Treadaway (25:51):

Well-

Judge (25:52):

Inviting opposing counsel to a fist fight in front of the courthouse is out of line, and you know that.

Mr. Treadaway (25:58):

So is it out of line for him to call me a liar stating that I have introduced this evidence purposely and willfully to mislead a jury, that I'm a liar? He called me a liar in open court-

Judge (26:09):

I don't think you're a liar at all. You've practiced in front of me for a long time. I don't think you're a liar, but you can't call opposing counsel out to fight in front of the courthouse.

Mr. Treadaway (26:17):

I said we settle it on our own with-

Judge (26:19):

You know what that means. You know what that means.

Mr. Treadaway (26:22):

Judge, how many times have you presided over a probation revocation where every allegation against the person is alleged in the petition and they come to court on the probation revocation date and they've caught up? They've done things to improve their position by the time they come to court. Where is there any evidence at all that this man hasn't done that? There's evidence that a probation revocation warrant was issued for this man. I asked the ... Oh, and one thing I will point out, isn't it interesting how Mr. Steel paraphrased what was said and got caught flatfooted when Your Honor actually had the transcript prepared and it's not at all what Mr. Steel paraphrased it as. Did he fear going back to jail? I didn't ask anything like that. It's not here. He mischaracterizes entirely what I asked, which thank God we have a record. All I said to the detective was, "Do you know if he did any of his community service, if he tried to become compliant?" How is that a lie? How is that something that I know not to be true?

(27:28)
I don't know Daniel Akers. I don't know what community service he performed after getting the warrant. This very communication that the Defense highlighted says he's talking about taking off work from his job to do the community service. And that was a month before he died. "They want me to do community service, but it's always during the daytime. I'm worried I'll lose my job. Well, I guess I'd rather lose my job than spend four years in jail." How do we know he wasn't working toward it? That's all I'm asking. And the detective said, "I don't know."But to this opposing counsel, that's a lie. And how does this line of questioning, "Do you know if he ever completed any community service? Do you know if he became compliant before he was to go to court?" Which he would've done and had to do before he was executed. "Do you know if he did anything to improve his position before he went to court?"

(28:22)
"No, I don't." How does that open the door to an allegation coming in which the Defense sought to bring in, that he was facing an accusation in Cobb Superior Court that was ultimately dismissed completely because he died? That doesn't prove ... It's just that there was no reverse 404(b) filed. This is just a thinly veiled attempt to drag his name through the mud, to impugn the character of a victim who's no longer able to defend himself or his character. That's what this whole package is meant to do. But that's an absolutely permissible question. Do you know if he did any ... What was it? "Do you know if he was caught up with his community service?" There were other violations on that revocation petition. There were fines, fees that he allegedly didn't do. All I asked is, "Do you know if he did any of his community services? Was he caught up?"

(29:17)
"I don't know."

(29:18)
Answer: "I don't know. I do not know."

(29:19)
"Do you know if he was caught up on any kind of evaluations or testing or anything else he had to do? His [inaudible 00:29:25]. Do you know anything about whether or not he was caught up in the next 20, 30, 32, 33 days?"

(29:29)
" No, sir. No, I don't know."

(29:31)
Now that is what I am supposed to do on redirect. He makes a big point, the Defense makes a big point that this man was in the state of mind that he was worried about being revoked on probation. So I asked the witness, "Do you know if he got caught up at all?"

(29:50)
"No."

(29:50)
How is that a lie? This man, had he lived, could have come in the day of his probation revocation, "Hey, I've done everything." We don't know. We don't know what he did after he sent I sent that email to Mr. Sosaby, "I'm worried about community service. I procrastinated." We don't know what he did after that. So it's not improper and it certainly shouldn't rise to the level impugning the dignity and ethical values of another member of the bar. It shouldn't rise to that level, but that seems to be par for the course. May I return this transcript?

Judge (30:27):

Yes, sir.

Mr. Treadaway (30:28):

Thank you.

Judge (30:30):

All right. Anything else, Mr. Treadaway?

Mr. Treadaway (30:32):

No, Your Honor. Thank you.

Judge (30:33):

Okay.

Mr. Treadaway (30:33):

And please, Your Honor, yes, there is one other thing. As you know, I wear my emotions on my sleeve. I take my job and my responsibility seriously, just like this learned counsel, learned colleague, and I apologize for my comment to this attorney and mostly to this Honorable Court. I did not mean to impugn the dignity of this Honorable Court, but hopefully the Court appreciates the seriousness with which I take this as well as Mr. Steel. And when someone just calls me a liar in open court on the record, it rubs me the wrong way. But I apologize to this court. Thank you.

Judge (31:09):

All right. Well, I don't think any of these lawyers are liars, but I do think the door's been opened. And let me explain to you why I think that. So the questions were, we've seen them, we've read them. I think what the questions elicit is kind of this impression that maybe during the time period between when whatever those text messages were and the date of death, maybe he was caught up. And so since that possibility has been raised, I think now the Defense should be allowed to present evidence that no, he was not caught up. So that's number one. Next question is, the door's been opened, so what does that allow the Defense to bring in? If the Defense wanted to, for example, call in a probation officer, I think that'd probably be appropriate. But does that mean that all of those documents, and I haven't even seen them, you've referenced them a couple of times, does that mean that all comes in now? I'm not so sure.

Mr. Steel (32:22):

Yes, they all come in. The detective ran the criminal history. He said he didn't know. That's what his answer is. He did know. The criminal history does not show the probation was completed at all. It's still an open case. So I get to use all ... They're all certified copies. I get to use the conviction, what he pled to, which drug offenses. I get to use the sentence. It goes up to 2024, just like the text message said. He then gets arrested in Cobb County. He pleads guilty in Cobb County to new drug felony offenses. He then ... Placed on another sentence. He gets revoked in Douglas County. That's why if you remember the text message, it's my second time. I'm going to get revoked on the bigger one, the bigger sentence. And then it shows that there's a probation warrant for his arrest for violating probation. So they all come in and that's what the package is. And every one of them is a certified copy.

Judge (33:19):

All right. Well, let's see your exhibits and let's let the State see the exhibits. And I guess we'll have to go through them one by one.

Mr. Steel (33:25):

Okay. I think it's up with the court reporter. And I gave it to the State already. Can I approach?

Judge (33:34):

Yes, sir.

Mr. Steel (33:35):

May I approach you? It's [inaudible 00:33:36] number 116. Do you not have a copy?

Judge (33:35):

No, sir.

Mr. Steel (33:36):

I'm sorry. May I approach?

Judge (34:03):

Sure. You want to ... Okay. This is everything?

Mr. Steel (34:09):

It should be. Well, that is everything. Yes. I'm working off a copy now.

Judge (34:14):

All right.

Mr. Steel (34:18):

So the first document should be State of Georgia v. Mr. Akers. It's the same person. It's an accusation from Douglas County, the Honorable Judge Emerson, E-M-E-R-S-O-N, certified on June 11th, 2026. The first, second page of the document should be a felony accusation to sale of marijuana on two different dates and then sale of oxycodone on another date. These are undercover sales on different dates. Mr. Akers is selling drugs and there's a witness list on the fourth page. And then ...

Mr. Steel (35:00):

... page. And then on the fifth page should be his plea, Mr. Akers' plea.

Judge (35:12):

If you have the... Sorry for interrupting. If you have the sentence, why do you need the charging documents?

Mr. Steel (35:17):

It shows what he was charged with. And then of course the sentence, as the court just said. And that's also certified at the top center, July 11th, 2010 plea. And that's where you get the sentence of total of 15 years to serve three years in prison. Excuse me, five years in prison. It's a 15 to do five sentence. And that's on July 12th, 2010. And he gets credit for the time that he previously served. The next document should be... That's a two-page document. The next document should be the warrant for arrest of probationer. December 22, 2019 is the notary date. It is dated April 11th, 2016. And this is the arrest warrant for Mr. Akers. It's the same person. It's the same... It's a different case number, I believe. So let me just make... Yeah, it's a different case number. It's 08CR01049. Case number signed by the Honorable Judge Emerson, April 11th, 2016 for violating criminal laws. It's general condition one. He gets arrested on another case. Special conditions is violated. Defendant shall report all arrests for any reason to community service. Within 48 hours he did not. He concealed the arrest and he was arrested for acquiring a license plate for the purpose of concealing driving without a valid license plate on 3/29/16. That case then on the next one is a probation revocation order also from Douglas County.

(37:19)
It's certified again June 11th, 2026. And it says in paragraph one that he was sentenced 15 years to serve five years balanced on probation and his sentence ends on September 13th, 2024, coincides with his text message. And the X is under committed an offense of... And it's the same offense I just said, in Highland, Georgia on March 29th, 2016. Theft by shoplifting Highland, Georgia on June 16th, 2016. He admitted the allegations in the petition. He's been given credit for the time served, that he was in custody. And then there he shall complete a drug and alcohol program on page two and he's reinstated on probation.

(38:05)
The next document is the pre-trial court services. This is now from Cobb County and this is also certified copy on April 22, 2026 from Mr. Akers. And it's a petition for bond revocation hearing because he fails to report to his pretrial services officer by phone. We do not need this. So I will remove that one document from the court's consideration. There's an order modifying his bond and it requires him a bond modification. I'm not looking to add that either. That's also from Cobb County Superior Court.

(38:48)
The next one is the warrant from Cobb County Superior Court. He is arrested. He being Mr. Akers, is arrested for possession of methamphetamine. This date is the 29th day of August 2016. It is signed by the magistrate judge and he's admittedly transferred without waiving any rights. He did not get bond at his initial appearance. And that is a four-page document. I don't need that document.

(39:19)
The next one is an arrest for Mr. Akers. It's a warrant for an arrest for Mr. Akers. It is sworn to on September 28th, 2016. And this again, we're back in Douglas County before the Honorable Judge Emerson, and it's going to be the same probation. And it alleges that he's charged with violations of the conditions that he violated, which is number one, do not violate criminal laws and general condition two, avoid all injurious and vicious habits, especially alcohol, intoxication, narcotics, and other dangerous drugs unless prescribed lawfully.

(39:56)
It is a certified copy. Your Honor, the next document is the probation revocation order. And here it is August 6th, 2018, also Douglas County, same case number as we saw earlier. And this one finds the same sentence, 15 years to serve five years. It goes up to September 13th, 2024. And failure to pay as directed whereas defendant has failed to make payments. As directed, he owes $863. His last payment was on 8/19/16. Also committed the offense on 8/29/16, committed the offense of possession of methamphetamine, a felony in Cobb County.

(40:36)
The next check is Mr. Akers admitted the allegations in the petition to revoke his bond and there is sufficient evidence his failure and needs to be revoked. And subject, however, to the further provisions, he shall serve the remainder of his or her sentence under probation until release from confinement. So he gets no short time. He's going to do every day of that sentence. And then the second page what is checked is, "In addition, defendant shall report to Douglas County Probation Supervision in person." And it gives a date that's signed by the honorable Judge Emerson. It's also signed by Mr. Akers and his counsel. We move for the admission of that.

(41:19)
The next one is the accusation that he admitted in Douglas County. It's in Cobb County before the Honorable Judge Hill, H-I-L-L, and it charges Mr. Akers with possession of methamphetamine and operating an unregistered vehicle. And this was while he's on probation on August 29th, 2016. It's a two count and it's verified and certified on April 21st, 2026. We move for the admission of that because it brings us to another warrant on the 7th day of January 2020, again before the Honorable Judge Emerson in Douglas County. And this is for Mr. Akers' arrest because he violated general condition number four. He failed to report to the probation officer as directed and permit the probation officer to visit his home or elsewhere and he failed to pay monies. That's the allegations and talks about he's outstanding more than $1,300 in probation fees.

(42:22)
The next one is Superior Court of Douglas County and this is administrative closure order whereby on the 12th day... excuse me, third day of February 2020, Judge Emerson with the offense of marijuana, two counts and controlled substance, felonies selling controlled substance, he's deceased December 22, 2019. That's how the case got closed. That's on February 5, 2020. We would like that to be going in. And then the next one in Douglas County, which is also January 30th, 2020, that's the order dismissing his warrant and the warrant was taken out on January 7th, 2020 and it was dismissed because he is deceased and that is a certified copy as well.

(43:18)
That's why. That's how his probation ended. And then the next one is the nol pros of the Cobb County case. And it's for the same reason, Your Honor. If you look at, it states that somewhere on here it's nol pros because he passed away. This is going to be on January 23rd, 2020. I'm looking for the reason and I know I've seen it before, but I don't see it. Oh yeah, there it is. It's check marked. Under paragraph one it says other and it says defendant deceased. And that's what happened in the Cobb County case. So I would like those documents except for the documents I mentioned, which is pretrial court services document, criminal arrest warrant in Cobb County and the warrant for arrest in Douglas County dated October 3rd, 2016. I would like the other ones to be admitted.

Judge (44:17):

All right. Anything else, Mr. Steel?

Mr. Steel (44:19):

No, they're all certified copies and I have them. I think yours copy may be a continuous copy, but these are all the... They're all certified, but these are the original certifications that were also taken. So either one has two original copies.

Judge (44:35):

I understand. All right. Mr. Cole, Mr. Treadaway?

Mr. Treadaway (44:40):

Your Honor, may it please the court, this goes back to my line of questioning to Detective Harvey because the documents sought to be admitted specifically toward the end, the probation revocation petition that was taken out, was taken out 7th of January 2020. So it appears from the documents that Mr. Steel has produced that there was no active probation revocation warrant at all at the time that the text messages were going back and forth about the lack of community service. It doesn't even appear there was an active warrant at all, if I'm reading it properly. The warrant was being taken out until unfortunately after this man had died.

(45:18)
But again, the fact that the warrant, probation... There was no looming probation revocation warrant over this man. Obviously, he was worried about completing the community service in time. And according to this allegation contained in the warrant or petition to revoke, he did not complete the community service in time.

(45:37)
Or if he did, he wasn't able to show it before his death to the probation officer because on January 7th they took a warrant for him. But this actually supports my line of questioning to Detective Hardy. I know you ruled on it, but again, giving the court idea of why I asked those questions, we don't know what he did or Detective Hardy didn't know by his own testimony under oath, he didn't know what he had done to try to get compliant with probation. And we still don't know. We know that a warrant was taken on January 7th for his probation revocation. But putting that aside, this type of information just opens up an incredible Pandora's box.

(46:15)
But for one thing, speaking of people who could be called, let's just say less than truthful, I see that the arrest out of Cobb County was the principal, in fact, only witness named on the accusation, accusation 192937 is Colin Robles. Colin Robles was fired in complete disgrace from the Cobb County Police Department for lying under oath about probable cause during his drug searches and drug stops. He was a undercover special narcotics officer. I've dealt with him in my career many times as a defense attorney and he was ultimately fired for lying under oath. They had caught him on some kind of audio recording that did not support why he said he had probable cause to search.

(47:03)
I believe he lost his post certification. He's never, to my knowledge, been employed to law enforcement again. So you get into stuff like this when you just carte blanche, let stuff like this come in. I don't have any problem with this warrant for his arrest being entered in for probation violation. It was taken out after he died. I still think the line of questioning is appropriate and I don't see if this probation warrant comes in, I still don't see how it's inappropriate to follow up with Detective Hardy if this comes in.

(47:37)
Do you know what he did up to January 7th or December 22nd, 2019? Do you know what he did to catch up? How is that improper? I just can't wrap my mind around it. There was not even a revo warrant for it at all. But certainly the court asked a good question. Why do you need this felony accusation if you have the sentence? And then the defense responded, well, it shows what the charges are. The charges are on the sentence. They're right there. Count one, count two, count three. So again, it's just surplusage to pile on.

(48:14)
And then you have a series of revocations that have been alleged and then adjudicated that he did violate probation and there was an order issued that he violated and there was sentencing imposed. How is that relevant to what he was facing in the state of mind in December of 2019? Revocations that had been adjudicated and disposed of. How is that relevant? Those were matters that occurred in some cases years before his death. I don't see how that's relevant at all to his state of mind in 2019. But as the court said, I guess the defense can call... They're free to call whatever witnesses they want. They can get probation officers from Douglas. "Hey, did you supervise this guy? Had he been revoked before? What for?" They can call this officer who issued the warrant in 2020 on January 7th. "Hey, what had he done by then?

(49:09)
And maybe by then we'll find out that he had made an attempt to catch up with his probation. If he had been sending this lady proof of community service, this Wauketa Hill, W-A-U-K-K-E-T-A Hill, his probation officer at the time in Douglas County. Maybe we'll find out that he had caught up at least some partial compliance. We don't know if he was compliant, hence the question. But a lot of this is not necessary at all to get to the heart of the matter, which I believe is for the defense. He was concerned about being revoked again. He had been revoked and he was concerned he could be revoked again.

(49:52)
I think a lot of it can be confusing to the jury. I think it can cause jury confusion when you... I don't know how much probation revocations that Mr. Steel engages in or works in. I work in them twice a month. Obviously, I think to suggest to the jury that just because you have a probation warrant out for you, actually he didn't, but one ultimately came on January 7th. To suggest that someone is going to be revoked for the entirety of their probation and do every day of it, that's not reality. That rarely happens. That would rarely occur. Sometimes it happens, but it would be rare.

(50:33)
But to suggest with the exaggeration, he's facing four years and he knows that he's going to do four years in prison to the day. Look at the other Douglas County order, which is why Mr. Steel brought that up to the court. He did every day of it. He was told to go back and do every day of it. To suggest things like that to this jury that Mr. Akers was going to do four years to the day and that's why he committed suicide, that's just not a statement that's realistic or reasonable.

(51:02)
But the jury is not going to know that because they're laypeople. And that's when stuff like this coming into evidence is really... It can be misleading for lay people. Thank you.

Judge (51:16):

All right. Well, I'll try to go through them one by one. So I don't think we need the accusation. I'm sorry, you want to say something else? Go ahead.

Mr. Steel (51:26):

Yeah.

Judge (51:35):

All right. I thought you were going to argue further.

Mr. Steel (51:36):

No, I was listening to your ruling.

Judge (51:37):

Oh, okay. All right.

Mr. Steel (51:39):

I have the documents in front of me.

Judge (51:40):

All right. So I don't think we need the accusation. So that would be one, two, three, four, I think the first five pages, if I'm keeping up with that right. Then we have a felony sentence. Is that the sentence for which he is on probation or was he on probation?

Mr. Steel (51:55):

Correct.

Judge (51:57):

Okay. So I'm going to admit the sentence. So that comes in. Then we have a warrant from 2016. I don't really see the relevance of that. He wasn't worried about a past warrant. He's worried about what's going to happen in the future. Then we have a probation revocation order, which is next. And so he was revoked previously in 2016. I don't see how that goes to the state of mind.

Mr. Steel (52:26):

Doesn't it go to the state of... May I speak?

Judge (52:29):

Sure.

Mr. Steel (52:29):

Doesn't it go to the state of mind? Because he knows in the text message... he knows I'm going to look at going to prison for 2024. He's been before the court before.

Judge (52:40):

That's a pretty good argument. I'll admit it. Then we have a warrant from 16 and another revocation order. I'll admit the order. This is the same case?

Mr. Steel (53:01):

Yeah.

Judge (53:02):

I'll admit the order, but not the warrant.

Mr. Treadaway (53:04):

The order? I'm sorry, Your Honor. The order-

Judge (53:14):

I've got two revocation orders that I'm admitting, but not the warrant. I'll hand you my stack of what's being admitted. Then I've got something from Cobb, an accusation from Cobb, from April. New criminal charges, right?

Mr. Steel (53:46):

Yes.

Judge (53:46):

How's that go to his state of mind?

Mr. Steel (53:49):

I mean, this is why he got revoked.

Judge (53:53):

This was the basis of the revocation?

Mr. Steel (53:55):

This is one of them, yes. He admitted the charges of methamphetamine to the Douglas County Court and got revoked.

Mr. Treadaway (54:05):

Your Honor, he admitted to violating his probation. He didn't admit to the charges. His charges were dismissed.

Mr. Steel (54:13):

Well, that's... May I address that, Your Honor?

Judge (54:13):

I'm going to admit the rest of them.

Mr. Steel (54:13):

Okay.

Judge (54:20):

So here's what I'm admitting. It might be easier.

Mr. Steel (54:24):

May I approach?

Judge (54:24):

Yes, sir. Might be easier to do it that way. If you could please share that with the state. And Mr. Steel, I'll hand you back, this has an original label on it, but these are not being admitted.

Mr. Steel (54:51):

Can I leave with the court reporter what was not admitted as Ms. Boles number 116 and then what will be-

Judge (54:56):

Yes.

Mr. Steel (54:56):

... admitted to Ms. Boles 116A was admitted [inaudible 00:55:00]?

Judge (55:01):

We're just going to have to keep up with all that, so later we don't send something back that shouldn't go back.

Mr. Treadaway (55:09):

Let me get that back. [inaudible 00:55:10] Let's compare.

Mr. Steel (55:36):

Your Honor, can I use the transcript, that one page? May I approach?

Judge (55:44):

Yes.

Mr. Steel (55:46):

Thank you.

Judge (56:18):

Diane, why don't you tell the jury that we had some unexpected things we had to deal with and we're starting in five minutes and then I'll give the lawyers five minutes and then we'll start. Okay? Thank you. All right, gentlemen. I'll call the jury back in. I think we're all very aware of the time this case has taken. I think we've had a witness on the stand for like a day and a half and the holidays are coming up, so just do your best.

Mr. Steel (01:03:41):

Where is the [inaudible 01:03:44] I understand. Whatever the judge said.

Witness (01:03:51):

That's what you got in your hands [inaudible 01:03:52]

Mr. Steel (01:03:52):

Okay. Thank you.

Judge (01:04:15):

Hey, good morning.

Speaker 1 (01:04:40):

Good morning, Judge.

Judge (01:04:48):

Good morning, ladies and gentlemen. So good to see you all this morning. Thank you for waiting while we work through some things we just had to work through. Let's resume examination of the witness who is still under oath.

Mr. Steel (01:05:04):

Do you remember yesterday the prosecutor asking you questions about Mr. Akers' current sentence that he was on at the time of his death?

Witness (01:05:18):

Yes.

Mr. Steel (01:05:19):

And you knew that sentence because you ran his criminal history, his being Mr. Akers, right?

Witness (01:05:24):

Yes.

Mr. Steel (01:05:24):

You knew he was under sentence from Douglas County, true?

Witness (01:05:27):

I believe so, yes.

Mr. Steel (01:05:28):

And it was a 15-year to serve five years in prison sentence in 2010?

Witness (01:05:35):

I would need to look back at the criminal history.

Mr. Steel (01:05:37):

Your Honor, I'm going to ask to admit Ms. Boles Exhibit number 116A as in Elisa.

Mr. Treadaway (01:05:47):

No objection, Your Honor.

Judge (01:05:48):

All right. [inaudible 01:05:51]

Mr. Steel (01:05:50):

Yes.

Judge (01:05:50):

It's admitted.

Mr. Steel (01:05:51):

May I approach?

Judge (01:05:51):

Yes.

Mr. Steel (01:05:51):

May I approach you?

Witness (01:05:54):

Yes, sir.

Mr. Steel (01:05:55):

You can look at this document if you need to. It's in evidence. And it's several pages. But you will note, do you not, that the sentence imposed by Douglas County is 15 years since her five years in prison? You see that?

Witness (01:06:16):

I do see that, sir.

Mr. Steel (01:06:18):

And that ran from the arrest date of 2009. Did you notice that? I can show it to you.

Witness (01:06:37):

Yeah, if you would point it out. I don't see it on here, sir.

Mr. Steel (01:06:38):

Okay. I'm just going to use this screen if that's okay. May I approach, Your Honor?

Judge (01:06:50):

Yes.

Mr. Steel (01:06:50):

May I hand it to you?

Judge (01:06:51):

Yeah.

Mr. Steel (01:06:51):

Your Honor, can you display Ms. Boles number 116A as in Alisa? And if you could just... This is Superior Court Douglas County. It's a neighboring county, fair?

Witness (01:07:08):

Yes, sir.

Mr. Steel (01:07:09):

All right. This is a certified document. You recognize that from the courts?

Witness (01:07:13):

Yes.

Mr. Steel (01:07:14):

And then you see here where it says felony sentence? Can you blow that up please? Can you blow that up? And it's three counts. You see them here, sale of marijuana, sale of marijuana, sale of controlled substance drugs. You see that?

Witness (01:07:41):

I see it.

Mr. Steel (01:07:42):

And that's the sentence. It was a guilty plea by Mr. Akers, right?

Judge (01:07:48):

Yes.

Mr. Steel (01:07:49):

His name is up here. Can you just pull it down a little bit, please? See that Daniel Lee Akers, same person we're talking about, right?

Judge (01:07:56):

Yes, sir.

Mr. Steel (01:07:56):

All right. And then in felony sentence, the honorable court in Douglas County gave a sentence of 10 years on each, on count one and two and 15 years on count three. All counts run concurrently credit for the time served from December 6th, 2009 to July 12th, 2010. You got that?

Witness (01:08:19):

That's what the paper says, sir.

Mr. Steel (01:08:20):

All right. And then it gets upon the service of five years in prison, the remainder on probation. That's where you get the 10... the 15 to do five, right?

Witness (01:08:28):

That's what it says.

Mr. Steel (01:08:29):

And the five years in prison, the 10 years then follows probation. And if you use the 15 years from the date of 12/6/2009 and add 15 years to it, you get 12/5/2024, right?

Witness (01:08:45):

Yes, sir.

Mr. Steel (01:08:45):

All right. And then if you go to the next page of 116A as in Alisa, this is the special conditions of probation. The jurors will have this out with them. I'm not going to go over it, but it's signed by the Honorable Judge Emerson. If you just pull it up, July 12th, 2010. And that shows the credit for time served. Mr. Akers was in custody until July 12th, 2010. And then he has to serve the five-year sentence, right?

Witness (01:09:17):

Correct.

Mr. Steel (01:09:17):

All right. Next number, please. This shows that on or about September 20th, 2016, so it's a couple years later, Mr. Akers is again before the Douglas County Superior Court and he gets revoked on probation. You know what that term means, right?

Witness (01:09:37):

Yes, sir.

Mr. Steel (01:09:38):

So probation is like a privilege of the court in serving the sentence out of the penitentiary?

Witness (01:09:43):

I'm familiar with what probation is.

Mr. Steel (01:09:44):

And probation is like a tether around the person's neck. If they don't do what they're supposed to do that's ordered by the court, they could be revoked and go to prison, true?

Witness (01:09:52):

That is correct.

Mr. Steel (01:09:52):

And here's a probation revocation, and it's the same sentence, 15 years to survive balance of probation, which ends, and this has it ending September 13th, 2024, right?

Witness (01:10:03):

That's what the paper says.

Speaker 2 (01:10:00):

September 13th, 2024, right?

Speaker 3 (01:10:03):

That's what the paper says.

Speaker 2 (01:10:04):

Just like Mr. Akers' text messages you ever saw, he was concerned about going to prison until 2024. Remember that?

Speaker 3 (01:10:11):

I do.

Speaker 2 (01:10:13):

All right. And he gets revoked on probation. We can go to ... and if you just scroll up a little bit, if you don't mind. He committed other offenses including driving while license suspended in Hiram, Georgia, concealing identification and theft by shoplifting on two different dates, March of 2016, June 2016. And he admits to the allegations. Mr. Akers admitted to committing these crimes, right?

Speaker 3 (01:10:43):

That is what it reads.

Speaker 2 (01:10:44):

All right. And he gets revoked and that's the bottom of the... He gets revoked and he's back on probation. True?

Speaker 3 (01:10:52):

That's what the paperwork says.

Speaker 2 (01:10:53):

All right. Next. This is just the second page of that order revoking probation and it's signed here, Judge Emerson, September 26th, 2016. And he has to complete a drug and alcohol evaluation. Any treatment is necessary and he's reinstated on probation with all the original concerns and effects and conditions and he has to report to his probation officer. Fair?

Speaker 3 (01:11:22):

Yes.

Speaker 2 (01:11:23):

All right. Next page. This is a different, this is August 6th, 2018. This is also from Douglas County, also against Mr. Akers, another probation revocation order. It's the same sentence we're talking about, the 15 years to serve five years in prison from September 13th, 2024. And if you scroll up a little bit. And here, Mr. Akers failed to pay as directed. He owes about $863. You see that?

Speaker 3 (01:11:56):

I see that, sir.

Speaker 2 (01:11:57):

And he committed the offense on, I think that's August 29th, 2016. He possessed methamphetamine in Cobb County, a felony. You see that?

Speaker 3 (01:12:06):

I see that.

Speaker 2 (01:12:07):

And he admit, he being Mr. Akers, admitted the allegations contained in the petition, meaning he admitted that he didn't pay the money and he admitted that he was possessing methamphetamine. True?

Speaker 3 (01:12:18):

That's what it reads, sir.

Speaker 2 (01:12:19):

And then the judge revoked to Judge Emerson again.

Speaker 3 (01:12:24):

Yes.

Speaker 2 (01:12:24):

Okay. If you could just scroll up. And it gives all the dates. And then after serving time in prison, he can serve the remainder of time on probation and his probation is going to go the whole way, it says. True?

Speaker 3 (01:12:39):

That's what it says, sir.

Speaker 2 (01:12:40):

All right. Next page. And here's just more conditions and the judge put on an addition, another condition report to Douglas County probation office in person on August 13th, 2018 and gives a time. And that's the sixth day of August 2018 revocation order. Fair?

Speaker 3 (01:13:09):

That's what it reads, sir.

Speaker 2 (01:13:10):

All right. Next. And you saw Mr. Akers' signature at the bottom of that?

Speaker 3 (01:13:15):

I do.

Speaker 2 (01:13:19):

Okay. This is the accusation that's a charging document. You're familiar with that, I'm assuming?

Speaker 3 (01:13:24):

Yes.

Speaker 2 (01:13:24):

And this is by the district attorney's office in Cobb County, so another neighboring county, right?

Speaker 3 (01:13:33):

Yes.

Speaker 2 (01:13:34):

And this is possession of methamphetamine and operating an unregistered vehicle. And it's state of Georgia, if you just pull down a little bit. And it's stated down... Yeah. This is the accusation, this is the warrant and state of Georgia versus Mr. Akers, same person you're dealing with, fair?

Speaker 3 (01:13:55):

Yes.

Speaker 2 (01:13:56):

And it's charged by then District Attorney Holmes. She was the former Cobb County elected district attorney or appointed district attorney, true?

Speaker 3 (01:14:05):

I'm familiar, yes.

Speaker 2 (01:14:06):

Okay. Next. And here are the two counts that the district attorney charged and it's Mr. Akers charging again with possession of methamphetamine. And it's now the 29th day of August 2016, and then a second count of operating an unregistered vehicle, right?

Speaker 3 (01:14:27):

Yes, sir.

Speaker 2 (01:14:28):

Okay. Next page. Please. And this is again in Douglas County and it's another arrest for Mr. Akers and arrest warrant for Mr. Akers. And it shows his address and it's the same address that you came out to in March 5th, 2020, right?

Speaker 3 (01:14:51):

That's correct.

Speaker 2 (01:14:52):

And it gives his weight and height here and that he has to answer to the following violations of his probation again, which is report to probation officer as directed and permit the probation officer to visit him as a home, pay monies, and he's charged with new offenses in willful disregard of the court order. Charged with, excuse me, violation of these conditions, willful disregard of the court order. And then at the bottom of it, if you go, that again is by the probation officer, Probation Officer Hill. It's now the 7th day of January 2020. He's already deceased, right?

Speaker 3 (01:15:32):

Yes.

Speaker 2 (01:15:33):

And it's signed by the Honorable Judge Emerson, right?

Speaker 3 (01:15:36):

Yes.

Speaker 2 (01:15:37):

Okay. Next. And because Mr. Akers is deceased, this is February 5th, 2020, Douglas County gets wind of it and they dismiss his revocation hearing, his revocation petition. You see that?

Speaker 3 (01:15:54):

I see it.

Speaker 2 (01:15:55):

And that's the 3rd day of February 2020. Obviously Mr. Akers has deceased them tragically on December 22, 2019.

Speaker 3 (01:16:02):

That is correct.

Speaker 2 (01:16:02):

So the case vanishes that it's moot, M-O-O-T, right?

Speaker 3 (01:16:07):

Correct.

Speaker 2 (01:16:08):

And then the same thing with Cobb County. Do you have any more? Next page. And this is Douglas County and then they're dismissing the probation warrant, meaning they're not going to go after Mr. Akers for violating his probation for a third time, right?

Speaker 3 (01:16:30):

That's what it reads, sir.

Speaker 2 (01:16:32):

Because he's deceased. And it says here, if you go down, "Due to the fact that defendant," that's Mr. Akers, "being deceased as of December 22, 2019." That's what the jurors are trying, right?

Speaker 3 (01:16:44):

Yes.

Speaker 2 (01:16:44):

All right. Next. This is Cobb County and they're dismissing their case also because defendant, Mr. Akers is called the defendant. It says deceased. Do you see that?

Speaker 3 (01:17:00):

I see that, sir.

Speaker 2 (01:17:01):

Okay. And this case goes away too because he's not here to be prosecuted, right?

Speaker 3 (01:17:05):

That's correct.

Speaker 2 (01:17:09):

And that's the last page from Cobb County. It just shows January 23rd, 2020. So that's about a month and a day after Mr. Akers is no longer with us, right?

Speaker 3 (01:17:20):

Correct.

Speaker 2 (01:17:20):

So when the prosecutor asked you yesterday whether you knew if Mr. Akers was caught up with his probation requirements, do you remember that, those questions?

Speaker 3 (01:17:35):

Yes, sir.

Speaker 2 (01:17:36):

And it included community service, any evaluations, any testing, any fines. Do you know whether Mr. Akers caught up in the next 20 or 32 or 33 days? Your answer was you have no idea, right?

Speaker 3 (01:17:51):

That's correct.

Speaker 2 (01:17:52):

We have these documents showing that he was on active probation at the time of his death, true?

Speaker 3 (01:17:57):

Yes.

Speaker 2 (01:17:57):

No doubt about it, right?

Speaker 3 (01:17:59):

I'm seeing those documents for the first time today.

Speaker 2 (01:18:01):

That's fine. They're available to you though, if you wanted to see them in March 5th, 2020, right?

Speaker 3 (01:18:07):

Yes.

Speaker 2 (01:18:07):

They're all in the clerk's office.

Speaker 3 (01:18:09):

Correct.

Speaker 2 (01:18:10):

Two different counties you'd have to go to, right?

Speaker 3 (01:18:12):

Correct.

Speaker 2 (01:18:12):

And you had his criminal history run, right?

Speaker 3 (01:18:15):

I did.

Speaker 2 (01:18:15):

You knew his date of birth and you knew he was on probation and arrested for the methamphetamine, right?

Speaker 3 (01:18:20):

Yes.

Speaker 2 (01:18:20):

Yeah. But you didn't do that, did you?

Speaker 3 (01:18:23):

I didn't go and get those paperwork, no.

Speaker 2 (01:18:25):

But when the prosecutor asked you, "Do you have any evidence that he fulfilled his requirements of probation?" Actually, the text message that Mr. Akers wrote said he was concerned about going to prison for four years. I say four years because 2024 to the very end of 2019, right?

Speaker 3 (01:18:45):

Yes, sir.

Speaker 2 (01:18:46):

Yeah. That's a heavy weight on somebody, right?

Speaker 3 (01:18:49):

That's an opinion.

Speaker 2 (01:18:51):

Prison for four days is a disaster. Would you agree with that?

Speaker 3 (01:18:55):

I've never had to serve prison time, so I don't know.

Speaker 2 (01:18:58):

Do you ever visit a prison?

Speaker 3 (01:18:59):

Yes.

Speaker 2 (01:19:00):

Do you think it's a comfortable place?

Speaker 3 (01:19:03):

No.

Speaker 2 (01:19:07):

When the prosecutor asked you yesterday on redirect examination, did you ever hear Ms. Boles say on the 911 recording, "Help Dan, help Dan." Remember those questions?

Speaker 3 (01:19:20):

Yes.

Speaker 2 (01:19:21):

And it was always, "Help me, help me," right?

Speaker 3 (01:19:23):

Correct.

Speaker 2 (01:19:23):

The 911 recording was played for the jury a couple of times with you, I did, right?

Speaker 3 (01:19:31):

Yes, sir.

Speaker 2 (01:19:32):

And it starts out with the 911 operator. If you don't remember, just say they've heard it, saying at 35 seconds, "What are you calling to report?" to Ms. Boles and she's saying, "Help me, please, help me, please." Remember that?

Speaker 3 (01:19:45):

I do.

Speaker 2 (01:19:46):

And then the 911 operator at 39 seconds said, "What are you calling to report?" And Ms. Boles said, "My husband just shot himself. Oh my God. Oh my God. My husband just shot himself. Oh my God." Remember that?

Speaker 3 (01:19:59):

I do.

Speaker 2 (01:20:01):

She makes it clear to everybody she's calling on behalf of her husband to get help, right?

Speaker 3 (01:20:06):

Correct.

Speaker 2 (01:20:07):

Okay. I want to talk to you about Lacy Boles not having tattoos on her right arm. To your knowledge, she doesn't have tattoos on her right arm, right?

Speaker 3 (01:20:27):

I don't know for sure, sir.

Speaker 2 (01:20:28):

Well, okay. She had tattoos on one of her hands, right?

Speaker 3 (01:20:32):

Yes.

Speaker 2 (01:20:33):

Okay. And regardless of the tattoo or the timing, you know that photograph we put up that-

Speaker 3 (01:20:38):

Yes, sir. I'm familiar.

Speaker 2 (01:20:39):

... you did not recognize when you were in her home on March 5th, 2020, right?

Speaker 3 (01:20:43):

That's correct.

Speaker 2 (01:20:44):

But when I saw it, or somebody saw it, but when I was asking you questions, I specifically wanted you to give you an opportunity to correct because you don't want to mislead a jury, right?

Speaker 3 (01:20:56):

Yes, and I believe I answered that.

Speaker 2 (01:20:57):

Right. You said you missed it, right? You made a mistake.

Speaker 3 (01:21:01):

Yes, I have answered that several times.

Speaker 2 (01:21:02):

But am I correct?

Speaker 3 (01:21:03):

Yes.

‍

Speaker 2 (01:21:05):

And you missed the photograph not because they're young, you just... It wasn't intentional, you just missed it. You could have asked somebody, "Is this Dan Akers?" Right? I mean, you could have said, "I'm not sure. They look young."

Speaker 3 (01:21:17):

Yes, sir. I missed it.

Speaker 2 (01:21:19):

Right. But then you tell the jurors, with the prosecutor, that there are no other photographs of Daniel Akers displayed.

Speaker 3 (01:21:26):

Not that I can recall, sir.

Speaker 2 (01:21:27):

That again is on your word, right?

Speaker 3 (01:21:32):

Yes.

Speaker 2 (01:21:33):

Where are the other pictures that are up in the house so the jurors can see whether Daniel Akers' photographs are there?

Speaker 3 (01:21:39):

The other pictures of the residence? They should be in the case file.

Speaker 2 (01:21:42):

Well, you bring them to us and show us the pictures of the family and whether Dan Akers in other photographs, okay?

Speaker 3 (01:21:49):

They should be in evidence, sir.

Speaker 2 (01:21:50):

Okay. Well, if you find any, bring them up.

Speaker 3 (01:21:53):

I will.

Speaker 2 (01:21:54):

Okay. And then how many photographs of Dan Akers was there in the family home on December 22, 2019?

Speaker 3 (01:22:09):

Was that a question, sir?

Speaker 2 (01:22:10):

Yeah.

Speaker 3 (01:22:11):

The only one I know of is the one you pointed out.

Speaker 2 (01:22:14):

On December 20...

Speaker 3 (01:22:16):

Oh, I'm sorry, sir. I didn't hear the date.

Speaker 2 (01:22:17):

On December 22, 2019, the date that this man, God forbid, either took his life or was shot by Lacy Boles, how many photographs of him were up in the house?

Speaker 3 (01:22:30):

I never responded to the scene, sir, so I can't answer that.

Speaker 2 (01:22:33):

Yeah. And we have no photographs of them, do we?

Speaker 3 (01:22:36):

No.

Speaker 2 (01:22:38):

Why does it matter that you see photographs of Dan Akers anyway, even though you missed it? Why does it matter to what happened in that room on December 22, 2019, whether he was taking his own life?

Speaker 3 (01:22:53):

Are you asking my opinion?

Speaker 2 (01:22:54):

I'm just asking you what evidentiary value does that have to December 22, 2019 in that room?

Speaker 3 (01:23:01):

I think it's more of an opinion question, sir.

Speaker 2 (01:23:03):

Well, I don't want your opinion. I want evidence.

Speaker 3 (01:23:06):

I don't have any evidence.

Speaker 2 (01:23:14):

The clothing the prosecutor asked you about on redirect that was thrown into a corner that he made it sound like. I don't know if it was thrown, placed there. You already said you have no... You know what clothing I'm talking about? The work clothing?

Speaker 3 (01:23:27):

Yes. The safety vest, the construction vest and the jacket.

Speaker 2 (01:23:31):

You already made it clear. You have no idea who put those items there or when they even got there.

Speaker 3 (01:23:37):

Yes. I believe I answered you on that. Yes, sir.

Speaker 2 (01:23:39):

But am I correct?

Speaker 3 (01:23:40):

I've already answered that to you yesterday.

Speaker 2 (01:23:41):

Okay. I'm asking you today after redirect.

Speaker 5 (01:23:45):

It's asked and answered in the form of the question. Admits that it's asked and answered.

Speaker 2 (01:23:49):

It was asked on redirect. I'd like to go into it.

Speaker 4 (01:23:51):

I think it's been asked and answered.

Speaker 2 (01:23:59):

How is those clothing? Does it have any blood on it, those clothing?

Speaker 3 (01:24:03):

I don't see any in the photograph, sir.

Speaker 2 (01:24:05):

What evidence, not opinion, what evidence is there that that clothing was involved in any way on December 22, 2019?

Speaker 3 (01:24:15):

There is none either way.

Speaker 2 (01:24:24):

The keys the prosecutor held up, there's an Ingles card, right? You remember that?

Speaker 3 (01:24:29):

I do remember that.

Speaker 2 (01:24:30):

What's behind the Ingles card?

Speaker 3 (01:24:32):

It doesn't appear to be anything. I can't see it.

Speaker 2 (01:24:54):

This is Ms. Boles number 88. It should be in evidence. If it's not, I'll use the state's picture. Or I'll move this into evidence. Okay. I think it's in it, right?

Speaker 3 (01:25:10):

Yes, you can approach.

Speaker 5 (01:25:10):

I don't have any objections, but no one coming in just to save the time for finding it.

Speaker 4 (01:25:10):

Okay.

Speaker 5 (01:25:10):

Thank you.

Speaker 2 (01:25:10):

May I approach you?

Speaker 3 (01:25:10):

Yes, sir.

Speaker 2 (01:25:10):

Your Honor, may I approach?

Speaker 4 (01:25:36):

Yes.

Speaker 2 (01:25:36):

I just marked it Ms. Boles 88. It might be in, but it's the same-

Speaker 3 (01:25:42):

Yes, it's the same.

Speaker 2 (01:25:43):

... photograph we were talking about, right?

Speaker 3 (01:25:46):

Yes.

Speaker 2 (01:25:47):

And look, what is behind the Ingles card or is there something behind the Ingles card?

Speaker 3 (01:25:51):

Sir, I don't believe there's anything behind the Ingles card. If you notice, and I'm sure you have these key fob things or these little key tags, sometimes the edges get messed up. It looks like it's the same card and then the edge may be kind of frayed.

Speaker 2 (01:26:03):

Does it have a green and red color to it?

Speaker 3 (01:26:10):

All I see is an Ingles card, sir.

Speaker 2 (01:26:11):

Okay. All right. If we had the keys though, we wouldn't be guessing which keys were on the... Is that true?

Speaker 3 (01:26:20):

That's correct, sir.

Speaker 2 (01:26:21):

And you didn't collect the keys or your coworkers, right?

Speaker 3 (01:26:24):

I did not.

Speaker 2 (01:26:25):

Or your coworkers?

Speaker 3 (01:26:26):

I was not there.

Speaker 2 (01:26:27):

Am I correct?

Speaker 3 (01:26:28):

Yes. The keys were not collected.

Speaker 2 (01:26:29):

Also, on December 22, 2019, the keys of Mr. Akers that are laying in the room, I really don't know whose keys they are, but they're laying near his head. You remember those keys?

Speaker 3 (01:26:40):

I do.

Speaker 2 (01:26:41):

Again, not collected, right?

Speaker 3 (01:26:42):

Correct.

Speaker 2 (01:26:43):

Who put the safe key on those keys that were in Ms. Boles' purse on May five, 2020?

Speaker 3 (01:26:56):

I have no idea, sir.

Speaker 2 (01:26:58):

How many times did Ms. Boles ever touch that key to the safe?

Speaker 3 (01:27:03):

I have no clue, sir.

Speaker 2 (01:27:03):

As of March 5th, 2020?

Speaker 3 (01:27:05):

I have no idea, sir.

Speaker 2 (01:27:15):

Okay. You said with the district attorney on redirect examination that you were told by the GBI that they could not do DNA, the GBI scientists, I'm not talking about the investigative agents of law enforcement, but the GBI scientists, that they could not test the gun for DNA. Do you remember saying that?

Speaker 3 (01:27:40):

Yes.

Speaker 2 (01:27:41):

Where in your report, anywhere, in any report, does it say that the GBI contacted anyone and said they could not do that test?

Speaker 3 (01:27:50):

I believe it's in the... Not in a written report, but it's in a GBI submission report where they replied back.

Speaker 2 (01:27:58):

Stating?

Speaker 3 (01:28:00):

That they would not be testing it.

Speaker 2 (01:28:02):

Not be testing it does not mean they can't test it. Where is it that you got a call, you got... Whatever you said on...

Speaker 3 (01:28:08):

I don't recall, sir.

Speaker 2 (01:28:11):

Do you know it's not in your report?

Speaker 3 (01:28:13):

Yes, it's not in my report.

Speaker 2 (01:28:19):

Okay. You said to the prosecutor on redirect examination that you testified, pursuant to his question, that there are no other text messages written by Mr. Akers showing that things like what I introduced, like he's going to bury himself and Lacy and make the kids go to foster care. He was depressed and lonely. He had inner turmoil. He was upset that people would look at him because he can't support the family. Remember I showed you something from Halloween and then November and December of 2019? Remember those?

Speaker 3 (01:29:32):

Yes, sir. And I answered you yesterday.

Speaker 2 (01:29:34):

Well, I didn't ask it. It was the prosecutor that said, "Are there any others?" That's a prosecutor and you said there were no others. Do you remember?

Speaker 3 (01:29:40):

No, you did put it up on the screen and you asked me and I said it was right before the end of the day and I said, "I missed that text."

Speaker 2 (01:29:49):

Well, in order to miss it means you had to read all the texts. I was asking you yesterday about text messages. I was just asking you every question. I was open to you.

Speaker 3 (01:29:56):

Yes, sir.

Speaker 2 (01:29:59):

I didn't lead you. I just asked you, "What about this? What about this?" Right?

Speaker 3 (01:30:03):

Correct.

Speaker 2 (01:30:04):

I did it all day long.

Speaker 3 (01:30:05):

Yes, sir.

Speaker 2 (01:30:05):

Because I was showing the jurors however long it took, I'm naked. I'm here to answer and learn everything just like they are, right?

Speaker 3 (01:30:14):

Yes, sir.

Speaker 2 (01:30:19):

How do you know that there are not other text messages if you didn't read all of his text messages?

Speaker 3 (01:30:30):

I don't believe there's any.

Speaker 2 (01:30:32):

Just because you don't believe it?

Speaker 3 (01:30:33):

Yes.

Speaker 2 (01:30:38):

Okay. Have you ever written a text like any of the three that we just discussed, you're going to bury somebody and make the kids foster care? Have you ever written that?

Speaker 5 (01:30:47):

Objection to relevance to what this witness has written in his texts.

Speaker 4 (01:30:53):

Is that relevant?

Speaker 2 (01:30:54):

I think so.

Speaker 4 (01:30:55):

I don't think so.

Speaker 2 (01:31:03):

Okay. Well, did you read the text message that Mr. Akers sent about being concerned with being drug tested to go to the airport job?

Speaker 3 (01:31:18):

Yes. We read it in court too.

Speaker 2 (01:31:22):

Not this one. May I have one moment, Your Honor?

Speaker 4 (01:31:27):

Yes, sir.

Speaker 2 (01:31:27):

May I have just one moment, Your Honor?

Speaker 4 (01:31:36):

Yes, sir.

Speaker 2 (01:31:52):

One second, Your Honor. I will get a hard copy, Your Honor, but I'm just going to use an electronic copy just for time, if that's okay. I'm going to show you an electronic version and we'll print it out later with the court's permission. Thank you. Your Honor, I'm approaching and it will be Ms. Boles number 142. May I approach, Your Honor?

Speaker 4 (01:32:45):

Yes, sir.

Speaker 5 (01:33:47):

I don't have any objection to this. Thank you.

Speaker 4 (01:33:48):

All right, so 142 will be admitted.

Speaker 2 (01:33:48):

[inaudible 01:33:49]. Thank you so much, Mr. Investigator. Can you dim the lights, Your Honor?

Speaker 4 (01:33:58):

Sure.

Speaker 2 (01:33:59):

Thank you. This will be printed out, but just for timing, can you make it bigger, first of all? Thank you.

Speaker 4 (01:34:14):

I'm not familiar with a computer [inaudible 01:34:42].

Speaker 2 (01:34:14):

Your Honor, may I approach the screen?

Speaker 4 (01:34:14):

Yes.

Speaker 2 (01:34:45):

I'm just going to read it. Can you see it on your screen too?

Speaker 3 (01:34:48):

I can see it, sir.

Speaker 2 (01:34:51):

This is from Mr. Akers to Chris, right?

Speaker 3 (01:34:55):

Yes.

Speaker 2 (01:34:56):

And it's dated about nine days before Mr. Akers, God forbid, going to die. Is that true?

Speaker 3 (01:35:05):

That's correct.

Speaker 2 (01:35:06):

December 13th, 2019 at 6:39 in the morning. And Mr. Akers wrote to Chris, "Have you been badged for the airport before?" True?

Speaker 3 (01:35:19):

Yes.

Speaker 2 (01:35:20):

And we know it because it said Dan Akers, but it's the 5462 number from, right?

Speaker 3 (01:35:26):

Yes.

Speaker 2 (01:35:27):

Then on the response is in blue, true?

Speaker 3 (01:35:31):

That's correct.

Speaker 2 (01:35:32):

And this is now from Chris, the 1301 number, to Mr. Akers, a 5462 number. You see that?

Speaker 3 (01:35:40):

I do.

Speaker 2 (01:35:41):

And it's about a minute later, it's at 6:40 AM on the same date, and it says, "No problem. Where with the [inaudible 01:35:51] family and no, I and H never would let me come out there. Why?" True?

Speaker 3 (01:36:00):

True.

Speaker 2 (01:36:01):

All right. [inaudible 01:36:02] next. Mr. Akers responded, we know that this is the 5462 number to Chris 85, and this is about two minutes later, it's at 6:42 AM on the same date, December 13th, 2019, right?

Speaker 3 (01:36:22):

That's correct.

Speaker 2 (01:36:23):

And Mr. Akers wrote, "Just wondering about the process, because I smoked a little while ago, and if I may need to worry about a test, I should be good, but you never know..." Excuse me. "You never can tell." That's what Mr. Akers wrote, right?

Speaker 3 (01:36:42):

That's correct.

Speaker 2 (01:36:43):

And then Chris responded in blue, Chris is the 1301 to Mr. Akers, the 5462 number, fair?

Speaker 3 (01:36:50):

Yes.

Speaker 2 (01:36:51):

And it's about a minute later, it's at 6:43 AM, the same day, December 13th, 2019, right?

Speaker 3 (01:36:58):

Yes.

Speaker 2 (01:36:59):

And now Chris is writing, "Strap up IDK." You know what IDK stands for?

Speaker 3 (01:37:08):

If you would explain it, sir.

Speaker 2 (01:37:10):

You ever hear, "I don't know"?

Speaker 3 (01:37:13):

Yes, that sounds right.

Speaker 2 (01:37:14):

So it says, "Strap up. I don't know if they watch you," right?

Speaker 3 (01:37:20):

Correct.

Speaker 2 (01:37:22):

Talking about a drug test in this at the airport?

Speaker 3 (01:37:25):

That's what it sounds like.

Speaker 2 (01:37:28):

And you already testified yesterday that when you have to take drug tests, there's no faucet in the bathroom, nobody watching you though, right?

Speaker 3 (01:37:36):

Correct.

Speaker 2 (01:37:38):

And here, Chris tells Ms. Akers, "I don't know if they watch you," right?

Speaker 3 (01:37:45):

That's correct.

Speaker 2 (01:37:46):

Meaning the employer watching Mr. Akers, whether it's coming out of his body or not, right?

Speaker 3 (01:37:51):

That's what it reads.

Speaker 2 (01:37:53):

And then on the bottom, Mr. Akers responds again nine days before, God forbid, his death, and it's a minute later, 6:44 AM, December 13th, 2019, and Mr. Akers writes to Chris, this is 5462, the 1301 number, "I hear you." Fair?

Speaker 3 (01:38:16):

That's fair.

Speaker 2 (01:38:16):

And that's the entirety of this text conversation that we have, right?

Speaker 3 (01:38:21):

That's what you provided, yes.

Speaker 2 (01:38:22):

And you never came across that when you were telling Dr... I mean, Lacy Boles on March 5th, 2020, that Mr. Akers has passed all of his drug tests for work?

Speaker 3 (01:38:40):

Can you repeat that question?

Speaker 2 (01:38:41):

Yeah. March 5th, 2020, interrogation of Lacy Boles, do you remember her saying he was concerned about a drug test and you say, "Oh, no, he passed all the drug tests at work"? Do you remember that colloquy?

Speaker 3 (01:38:55):

I do. And this is from Mr. Akers' phone, which was not broken into or unlocked at that time, so no, I did not see that text message when I told her that.

Speaker 2 (01:39:05):

Okay, thank you. So this corrects your understanding of the facts of the case, fair?

Speaker 3 (01:39:12):

I'm seeing this for the first time, so I did not see that text message when I interviewed Ms. Boles on March 5th.

Speaker 2 (01:39:17):

Thank you, Your Honor.

Speaker 4 (01:39:22):

State?

Speaker 5 (01:39:23):

Thank you, Your Honor. If it please the court, this line of text messages here... Can you leave it up? I'm sorry. What's the date on that, Detective?

Speaker 3 (01:39:36):

I believe it's December 13th, 2019.

Speaker 5 (01:39:42):

So about a week or so before Mr. Akers' death, would you agree with that?

Speaker 3 (01:39:47):

I would.

Speaker 5 (01:39:48):

Does this possibly indicate to you that Mr. Akers had another job at the airport that he might have been transitioning onto?

Speaker 3 (01:39:55):

It does.

Speaker 5 (01:40:03):

This guy Chris says, "Hey, we're family." Do you know if Daniel had a brother-in-law named Chris?

Speaker 3 (01:40:09):

Yes.

Speaker 5 (01:40:10):

He worked out there in the sheet metal area, the construction crew?

Speaker 3 (01:40:12):

Yes. I can't remember his last name, but I believe I did an interview with him.

Speaker 5 (01:40:18):

Okay. Possibly Chris Berg?

Speaker 3 (01:40:20):

Yes.

Speaker 5 (01:40:20):

Okay. Do you see anything in these text messages with Chris Berg about the decedent, Mr. Akers, talking about, "I'm furloughed or I'm losing my job." Do you see anything there?

Speaker 3 (01:40:33):

No.

Speaker 5 (01:40:35):

"I'm worried I'm not going to have a job." Do you see anything in this text chain on that?

Speaker 3 (01:40:39):

No.

Speaker 5 (01:40:43):

And do you have any indication that... Did you have it on March 5th or do you have it now? Do you have any evidence that Mr. Akers failed drug tests in his work?

Speaker 3 (01:40:53):

No.

Speaker 5 (01:40:57):

I want to just go to one more quick area. If I can have the probation revocation warrant, sir. I'll let you know which exhibit it is. If you can just please put this exhibit up, please. This will be one of the pages. Let me just point it out specifically. One, two, three, four, six, seven, eight. The pages of defendant's 116A as in alpha are not marked, but this should be page 10 of 116A like alpha. Might approach opposing counsel, please.

Speaker 4 (01:41:49):

Yes, sir.

Speaker 5 (01:41:52):

Thank you. Can you just put that up here real quick, sir? So I want to put this up there. You said you recognize this as being a petition or warrant to revoke somebody's probation, right?

Speaker 3 (01:42:06):

Yes. It says warrant for arrest of probationary.

Speaker 5 (01:42:09):

Can you go to the top, Mr. Investigator Burke? Just look it up. Up, up that way so I can see the bottom. So you do see, what is the date where Douglas County Probation sought to... When did they file this order or this warrant to try to revoke his probation?

Speaker 3 (01:42:31):

There's two different dates. One, it says it's issued on January 7th, 2020. The other one was it's notarized January 6th.

Speaker 5 (01:42:38):

Okay. Go up to the top if you will, Investigator Burke. All right. So do you have any indication that Mr. Akers knew... Could he have known that this revocation was going to be entered on January 7th when he wasn't alive? Do you have any indication he knew this?

Speaker 3 (01:42:58):

No.

Speaker 5 (01:42:59):

Do you have any indication of some other probation revocation warrant that was floating out there over his head on December 22nd, 2019?

Speaker 3 (01:43:07):

No.

Speaker 5 (01:43:08):

And if you go down to the allegations of the violation of probation, go just a little bit here. It says that it's alleged that he violated the following conditions of probation, failure to pay monies, failure to allow the probation officer to visit your home. And then it goes in to say, "I tried to reach him a letter and all this stuff. I did a field visit. He wasn't there." Right?

Speaker 3 (01:43:36):

Correct.

Speaker 5 (01:43:36):

Do you see anything about on this document where they were trying to revoke his probation starting January 7th, do you see anything about him not doing community service?

Speaker 3 (01:43:46):

No.

Speaker 5 (01:43:48):

Okay. So do you know between that email we saw yesterday, that text yesterday, "I'm worried about doing my community service. I'm worried about getting revoked." Do you know if he had done any community service between that text and when this petition was taken out?

Speaker 3 (01:44:03):

I do not.

Speaker 5 (01:44:04):

Do you know any of the other efforts he may have taken to catch up on this stuff he was supposed to do from that text to... And I'm talking about the text with Mr. Eason at R.F. Knox. Remember that?

Speaker 3 (01:44:15):

I do remember that.

Speaker 5 (01:44:16):

So that was what, 22 days or so before his death?

Speaker 3 (01:44:20):

Correct.

Speaker 5 (01:44:21):

Do you have any idea what measures he may have taken to satisfy some of these terms and conditions of his probation?

Speaker 3 (01:44:28):

I do not.

Speaker 5 (01:44:43):

Okay. I want to just cover one more thing that was asked yesterday toward the end of the day, sir, and this will be my last question to you. Do you remember me asking you if you heard on the 911 tape, I just asked you if you possibly heard the defendant say, "I took it down there now"? Do you remember that?

Speaker 3 (01:44:59):

I do remember that.

Speaker 5 (01:45:01):

And then on recross examination-

Speaker 7 (01:45:00):

I do remember that.

Speaker 6 (01:45:01):

And then on recross-examination, Mr. Steel showed you a synopsis of what you had written as far as what you heard originally when you wrote your report. Do you remember that?

Speaker 7 (01:45:12):

I do.

Speaker 6 (01:45:12):

And you wrote, "I took it down there." Is that right?

Speaker 7 (01:45:15):

Yes.

Speaker 6 (01:45:16):

And then Mr. Steel, do you remember him asking you or trying to get you to agree that that was nothing like what I asked you if you heard?

Speaker 7 (01:45:29):

I do.

Speaker 6 (01:45:29):

Nothing like what I asked you if you heard?

Speaker 7 (01:45:32):

Yes, sir.

Speaker 6 (01:45:33):

Did you write in your report when you were listening to it, "I took it down there"?

Speaker 7 (01:45:37):

Yes.

Speaker 6 (01:45:37):

Was that spoken by this defendant according to you in your report?

Speaker 7 (01:45:43):

That's what it sounded to me on the 911.

Speaker 6 (01:45:46):

Okay. I don't have anything further. Thank you.

Judge (01:45:48):

Anything else?

Mr. Steel (01:45:49):

Just briefly. May I approach?

Judge (01:45:51):

Yes, sir.

Mr. Steel (01:45:52):

Showing you your report. May I approach you?

Speaker 7 (01:45:54):

Yes, sir.

Mr. Steel (01:45:58):

Thank you. I highlighted in red. Thankfully, this evidence is memorialized and captured, the 911 recording, right?

Speaker 7 (01:46:14):

Yes.

Mr. Steel (01:46:15):

So the jurors can determine. They don't need you to interpret, right?

Speaker 7 (01:46:18):

Correct.

Mr. Steel (01:46:19):

But it doesn't say in your report the word "there," does it?

Speaker 7 (01:46:22):

No, it doesn't.

Mr. Steel (01:46:23):

So with the three questions you just asked, "I took it down there," that's just not there, is it?

Speaker 7 (01:46:30):

No.

Mr. Steel (01:46:30):

It just says, "I took it down." The next line is, "I tried to get it out of his hand," or whatever was said, right?

Speaker 7 (01:46:35):

Correct.

Mr. Steel (01:46:37):

Thank you, Your Honor.

Speaker 6 (01:46:39):

I do apologize. Thank you, Your Honor. I misspoke. Does it say, "I took it down"?

Speaker 7 (01:46:45):

Yes.

Speaker 6 (01:46:45):

And then I asked you, I'm just clarifying, did I ask you if it sounded like possibly, "I took it down there, ma'am"?

Speaker 7 (01:46:50):

Yes.

Speaker 6 (01:46:50):

Do you remember me asking that?

Speaker 7 (01:46:50):

I did, yes. Yes.

Speaker 6 (01:46:50):

So I added those two words.

Speaker 7 (01:46:54):

Yes.

Speaker 6 (01:46:54):

What you wrote, am I right, is that, "I took it down," and that's all you heard when you listened to it when you wrote the report?

Speaker 7 (01:46:59):

Yes.

Speaker 6 (01:46:59):

That the jury will be able to listen to it and form their own opinion, would you agree with that?

Speaker 7 (01:47:00):

I agree.

Speaker 6 (01:47:02):

Okay. Thank you. That's all I have, Judge. Thank you.

Judge (01:47:09):

All right, sir, you can be excused. Ladies and gentlemen, before we call another witness, would anybody like a break? Yes. All right. Take 10 minutes. Good morning, sir. Welcome.

Mark Parker (02:00:48):

How are you, sir?

Judge (02:00:48):

I'm very good. Thank you for asking. I'm going to swear you in, okay? Please raise your hand. Do you swear or affirm the testimony you're about to give in the matter before the court will be the truth, the whole truth, nothing but the truth, so help you God?

Mark Parker (02:00:59):

I do, sir.

Judge (02:00:59):

Thank you so much. Have a seat and use the microphone, please.

Speaker 6 (02:01:09):

Good morning, sir. Can you tell the jury your name, please?

Mark Parker (02:01:11):

Mark Parker.

Speaker 6 (02:01:12):

Mark with a K?

Mark Parker (02:01:14):

Yes.

Speaker 6 (02:01:15):

And Parker, regular spelling?

Mark Parker (02:01:16):

Correct.

Speaker 6 (02:01:17):

All right, sir. Tell the jury, please, how you were employed in December of 2019, please.

Mark Parker (02:01:26):

Well, I worked for the Paulding County Sheriff's Office. Been working there, I don't know, 20 years. I was in the crime scene unit, ran the crime scene unit.

Speaker 6 (02:01:36):

When did you start with Paulding County?

Mark Parker (02:01:38):

In July of 1995.

Speaker 6 (02:01:40):

1995. And did you start as a patrol officer?

Mark Parker (02:01:43):

Yes, sir. Five years in patrol. In January of 2000, I started the crime scene unit and stayed in that position for the next 20 years until I retired.

Speaker 6 (02:01:55):

Were you post-certified law enforcement officer during your time at Paulding County?

Mark Parker (02:01:59):

Yes, sir.

Speaker 6 (02:02:00):

Did you have any prior law enforcement experience before Paulding County?

Mark Parker (02:02:03):

Yes, sir. 1978 to 1989, I lived in Birmingham, Alabama and I was employed by the Birmingham Police Department as a patrolman for 11 years.

Speaker 6 (02:02:16):

Were you a sworn law enforcement officer in Birmingham having arrest powers in that county?

Mark Parker (02:02:19):

Yes, sir.

Speaker 6 (02:02:20):

If I can take you then to... You say you started the crime scene unit or the crime scene division in Paulding County. Tell the jury why you phrase it like that. What do you mean by you started?

Mark Parker (02:02:31):

Well, in patrol, the sheriff's office itself didn't have a person that handled crime scene. Obviously, over time, things were busy. I had already had experience in Birmingham, not necessarily in crime scene, but I just knew how things were. I answered a call one night with the sheriff, Bruce Harris, and after we got done with the call, I asked him, I said, "Sheriff, I would like to start a crime scene unit." He was all for it. He said, "You do what you need to do. You get the training you need to do and I'll sign off on anything."

(02:03:12)
So they eventually brought in... Well, I got the training, but about the time that everything was getting ready to start up, they brought in a trailer, which I created in my office. I did test out there in just my boat, my office. It was out back of the former sheriff's office. Not here, but...

Speaker 6 (02:03:37):

Over on [inaudible 02:03:38]?

Mark Parker (02:03:38):

Yes, sir.

Speaker 6 (02:03:39):

Okay. Did you have assistance or were you-

Mark Parker (02:03:42):

For the first seven years, I was by myself, very busy. After seven years, they let me... Well, they got someone else to help me and he eventually... Well, I don't remember how long he stayed. I would say probably seven or eight years.

Mr. Steel (02:04:02):

I'm going to object to relevance.

Speaker 6 (02:04:06):

I think his background in law enforcement is knowledge about the subject matter about which he's just [inaudible 02:04:11] going to testify is relevant-

Judge (02:04:12):

You can go a little, but let's not get-

Speaker 6 (02:04:12):

Yeah. I'll move on a little bit.

Judge (02:04:12):

Okay.

Speaker 6 (02:04:17):

So eventually got some help out there.

Mark Parker (02:04:18):

Yes, sir.

Speaker 6 (02:04:19):

Did you stay with crime scene unit until your retirement or did you-

Mark Parker (02:04:22):

Yes, sir. Yes, sir. I was promoted to lieutenant. It's just what I did.

Speaker 6 (02:04:28):

Okay. When did you leave the sheriff's office retirement, sir?

Mark Parker (02:04:31):

Retired on paper in the last, let's see, May of 2020, and I continued working for six to seven months until January of '21. The first week of January, I hung it up. I was done.

Speaker 6 (02:04:48):

Okay. Is it fair to say you're out of law enforcement now?

Mark Parker (02:04:54):

Yes, sir.

Speaker 6 (02:04:56):

Okay. Let me take you, sir, to March 5th of 2020.

Mark Parker (02:04:59):

Yes. Yes, sir.

Speaker 6 (02:05:01):

You talked about tendering your retirement or your plans to retire, but were you still employed as a crime scene analyst, crime scene technician on March 5th, 2020?

Mark Parker (02:05:12):

Yes, sir.

Speaker 6 (02:05:12):

With Paulding County?

Mark Parker (02:05:12):

Yes.

Speaker 6 (02:05:14):

Did you have an opportunity at all to accompany a detective named Nick Hardy in the execution of a search warrant in Paulding County on that day?

Mark Parker (02:05:22):

Yes, sir.

Speaker 6 (02:05:24):

Do you remember the address being 83 Braemill Court?

Mark Parker (02:05:27):

Yes, sir.

Speaker 6 (02:05:28):

Do you know how many people, if any, went out there with you to do the search warrant execution?

Mark Parker (02:05:33):

I believe there were two deputies, one or two deputies, patrol deputies. Let's see. It was me and I would say five other people.

Speaker 6 (02:05:47):

Okay. Total? Is Detective Hardy included in that?

Mark Parker (02:05:51):

Yes, yes.

Speaker 6 (02:05:51):

Is he there?

Mark Parker (02:05:51):

Yes.

Speaker 6 (02:05:53):

All right, sir. Did you get the sense, sir, that he was kind of the lead detective on the case?

Mark Parker (02:05:57):

Well, I had already been... Although I don't remember it, we had been briefed that morning. I didn't know the day before that I was going to go on a search or that I was needed on a search warrant. In my mind, sometime that morning before we went, he briefed me and/or us or the other detectives.

Speaker 6 (02:06:20):

Detective Hardy briefed you?

Mark Parker (02:06:22):

Yes.

Speaker 6 (02:06:23):

All right, sir. Can you tell the jury just, if you went out there to that residence, what was your role? He's the lead detective, and what was your role?

Mark Parker (02:06:35):

From what I gather, my role was... Again, I go back to I don't remember the conversation. In other words, "I'm needing you to do this," but based on what I did, he wanted me to look for blood.

Speaker 6 (02:06:48):

He being Detective Hardy?

Mark Parker (02:06:50):

Yes.

Speaker 6 (02:06:51):

Did you have an idea... I mean, I'm not asking you what Detective Hardy told you seven years ago, but did you remember any specific item you were actually looking for? Any items or item that you were looking for?

Mark Parker (02:07:01):

Well, I remember about a safe and a holster.

Speaker 6 (02:07:06):

Okay. May I approach the witness, please?

Judge (02:07:09):

Yes, sir.

Speaker 6 (02:07:09):

Thank you, Your Honor. May I show you, sir, what's been marked and entered into evidence as Defense 197. Do you remember this from out there at all? Do you recognize this?

Mark Parker (02:07:18):

Yes, sir.

Speaker 6 (02:07:20):

I don't want to block you from the jury, but do you remember coming across this item at that residence during your search?

Mark Parker (02:07:26):

At the time, yes.

Speaker 6 (02:07:33):

Okay. Do you remember... I'll try not to... Let's [inaudible 02:07:38] gloves there. I'll just grab it with that. Do you remember coming across State's Exhibit Number 198 around during your search, sir? Remember that?

Mark Parker (02:07:48):

Yes, sir.

Speaker 6 (02:07:50):

Okay. So 197, is that the safe that you encountered?

Mark Parker (02:07:54):

Is that the safe?

Speaker 6 (02:07:55):

Yes, sir.

Mark Parker (02:07:55):

Yes.

Speaker 6 (02:07:56):

And is that 198? What is that?

Mark Parker (02:07:58):

It's a holster.

Speaker 6 (02:08:00):

Okay. Does that look like the one that you encountered at the scene that day?

Mark Parker (02:08:01):

That I remember, yes.

Speaker 6 (02:08:02):

All right, sir. Do you remember where you encountered the safe, sir?

Mark Parker (02:08:16):

Well, it was brought down to me in a basement bedroom. That's where I was.

Speaker 6 (02:08:21):

Oh, you were setting up in the basement?

Mark Parker (02:08:23):

Yes.

Speaker 6 (02:08:23):

Okay. Was it open or closed when it was brought down to you?

Mark Parker (02:08:34):

It would've been open.

Speaker 6 (02:08:35):

Open? All right. Tell the jury, please, do you know what a substance called Bluestar is?

Mark Parker (02:08:41):

Yes.

Speaker 6 (02:08:41):

Can you tell the jury?

Mark Parker (02:08:45):

It's basically a presumptive blood test. It isn't specific to tell you whether blood is human or animal, but it... Well, with Bluestar, you spray Bluestar on something that you suspect blood to be on. I'll go back to people clean up crime scenes to hide blood, but there's always going to be blood left over no matter if they washed something that had blood on it, or if they cleaned it up, chances are there's still going to be parts of blood there or a part of blood.

Speaker 6 (02:09:26):

All right. Now I watch sometimes these crime shows, Forensic Files is the one I watch, and they talk about something called Luminol. Are you familiar with that?

Mark Parker (02:09:33):

Luminol is pre-Bluestar.

Speaker 6 (02:09:33):

Okay, so Bluestar is more modern?

Mark Parker (02:09:39):

Yes.

Speaker 6 (02:09:40):

Yeah, because I think all those Forensic Files were back in the '90s or something.

Mark Parker (02:09:42):

Yes.

Speaker 6 (02:09:42):

Did you use to use Luminol?

Mark Parker (02:09:45):

I have. I've seen it used, yes. I may have used it one or two times.

Speaker 6 (02:09:49):

Okay. When you say you spray Bluestar, is it basically the same as Luminol, but it has a few different...

Mark Parker (02:09:56):

Yes.

Speaker 6 (02:09:56):

It has a few different things?

Mark Parker (02:09:58):

It reacts different... well, when I say differently, it reacts more intense. You see a bluish glow. You spray the Bluestar on something you suspect blood to be on, and if blood's there, you will see within one to two seconds a flash of blue, and it's real intense, real bright. Then over a period of seconds or 30 seconds or so, it's starting to dissipate, and obviously the intensity of the glow eventually goes away.

Speaker 6 (02:10:35):

Totally away?

Mark Parker (02:10:36):

Yes.

Speaker 6 (02:10:36):

All right. You say you spray it, so I don't want to make an assumption. Is it in some kind of a little bottle?

Mark Parker (02:10:43):

Yes. Yes, and of course the sprayer, it's a mist. It doesn't shoot... Well, it does shoot straight out, but it's not like a stream. It's a mist.

Speaker 6 (02:11:00):

Like a triangle?

Mark Parker (02:11:02):

Yes. You don't want to saturate what you're spraying with the chemical. You just spray it. It's kind of like a spritz. Every time I see my wife spritz something on there, that's what I think of.

Speaker 6 (02:11:15):

You go back to Bluestar?

Mark Parker (02:11:18):

In a sense, yes.

Speaker 6 (02:11:19):

Had you been trained how to use Bluestar and how to recognize blood evidence on it when you're using Bluestar?

Mark Parker (02:11:24):

Yes.

Speaker 6 (02:11:27):

Had you used it before March 5th, 2020?

Mark Parker (02:11:29):

Yes.

Speaker 6 (02:11:31):

Many times?

Mark Parker (02:11:34):

I've used it some. I won't say a lot. I've been around the GBI some, not a lot. There's times that they were called out to Paulding, and whenever the GBI was called out for a crime scene or to work or a homicide or whatever, me or one of the other people would be with their technician. So I accompanied Audie Murphy who always came... That was his name. He was a GBI crime scene tech. Every time he came out and he was using Bluestar and/or Luminol, I or somebody was with him.

Speaker 6 (02:12:18):

Had you seen it applied before?

Mark Parker (02:12:19):

Yes, many times. Yes.

Speaker 6 (02:12:22):

Now just tell the jury, if you spray Bluestar on something that's had contact with blood, what exactly happens? Do you have to dim the lights or use a black light?

Mark Parker (02:12:34):

Well, with Bluestar, you don't have to dim the lights. You can use it in a room that has partial sunshine coming in. Obviously, the darker the room, the better. With Luminol, you have to have a totally dark scene. Anytime GBI came out and used Luminol, we would always have to wait until nighttime. I can remember several instances where we had to do that.

Speaker 6 (02:13:01):

With Bluestar...

Mark Parker (02:13:03):

But with Bluestar, you don't have to have a totally dark room, and that's one of its benefits why it was developed, because you didn't have to use it in total darkness.

Speaker 6 (02:13:15):

Did you apply, sir, Bluestar to this safe?

Mark Parker (02:13:20):

Yes, I did.

Speaker 6 (02:13:23):

Do you know where? From its side to-

Mark Parker (02:13:25):

All exterior sides.

Speaker 6 (02:13:27):

All sides?

Mark Parker (02:13:28):

Yes, sir.

Speaker 6 (02:13:29):

Tell the jury what your findings were or what the reaction was to the chemical when you applied BlueStar to that safe.

Mark Parker (02:13:36):

There was no reaction when I sprayed that safe.

Speaker 6 (02:13:42):

Did you spray the keypad, the little punch number area of the keypad?

Mark Parker (02:13:47):

I'm sure I would have.

Speaker 6 (02:13:49):

Okay. And what was the reaction?

Mark Parker (02:13:50):

The same.

Speaker 6 (02:13:51):

None?

Mark Parker (02:13:52):

Correct. None.

Speaker 6 (02:13:59):

Did you spray State's Exhibit 198, this holster? Did you spray this?

Mark Parker (02:14:05):

I did.

Speaker 6 (02:14:07):

In the basement there where it was brought to you?

Mark Parker (02:14:09):

Yes.

Speaker 6 (02:14:10):

Okay. Do you know where you sprayed it?

Mark Parker (02:14:14):

I sprayed it all, but it'd be like two times because I had it setting down and I spritzed it. And then I would have to turn it over and spritz it again. Of course, obviously, one time I had a reaction, but it wasn't very intense reaction. It was a dim... The color was, I will say, whitish green. It was more of a dim reaction and it flashed, and then it went away.

Speaker 6 (02:14:47):

Okay. Is that a positive blood reaction to you based on your knowledge of the product?

Mark Parker (02:14:54):

Well, I waited one or two minutes. I did it again and I got no reaction, so to me, that tells me that it wasn't blood. It was a false positive. It was reacting to something else. It was just there.

Speaker 6 (02:15:09):

Such as? What could cause it to react to something?

Mark Parker (02:15:15):

Cleaning fluid...

Speaker 6 (02:15:21):

Okay. How large was the little part that reacted on that whole...

Mark Parker (02:15:25):

Well, it was just a flash. I mean, I can't say it was a small part or the whole thing. I don't remember that. I just remember seeing it started dwelling, and of course it kind of caught me off-guard, and then it went away.

Speaker 6 (02:15:43):

You said it was white or green?

Mark Parker (02:15:45):

Well, whitish green. I mean, that was just what I remember.

Speaker 6 (02:15:50):

What is the color for presumptive positive for blood?

Mark Parker (02:15:55):

Well, with Bluestar, it turns blue. The reaction is blue. It just kind of blooms. It's a fluoresce. It fluoresces and it's just a bloom. It really catches your attention, and then over a period of 30, 45 seconds or whatever, it's dissipating and going away.

Speaker 6 (02:16:16):

Did you see that same type of reaction with this pop of white-green that it stayed and dissipated?

Mark Parker (02:16:23):

Well, it didn't stay, but it dissipated over probably five to 10 seconds, I would say.

Speaker 6 (02:16:30):

Okay. Do you have any reason to believe, based on your training, knowledge and experience, that that was any kind of blood, the blue greenish spot?

Mark Parker (02:16:39):

In my mind, it was not.

Speaker 6 (02:16:41):

Did you say you sprayed it again after the blue greenish spot came up?

Mark Parker (02:16:46):

Well, the greenish white.

Speaker 6 (02:16:48):

I'm sorry, greenish white spot.

Mark Parker (02:16:49):

Yes, sir.

Speaker 6 (02:16:51):

What did you find on your second spray?

Mark Parker (02:16:54):

Well, nothing. There was no reaction whatsoever.

Speaker 6 (02:16:59):

Okay. Was there a greenish white this time?

Mr. Steel (02:17:02):

Objection. Asked and answered.

Judge (02:17:04):

[inaudible 02:17:04] asked and answered.

Speaker 6 (02:17:07):

I'm sorry. If I did, I'm sorry. I'll move on.

Mark Parker (02:17:09):

Yes, sir.

Speaker 6 (02:17:12):

Do you have an opinion, based on your training, knowledge, and experience, about whether there was blood on the holster?

Mark Parker (02:17:20):

In my opinion, there was not blood on the holster.

Speaker 6 (02:17:23):

What about the safety?

Mark Parker (02:17:24):

No.

Speaker 6 (02:17:25):

That's all I have. Thank you. Mr. Steel may have some questions.

Judge (02:17:35):

All right. Cross-examination [inaudible 02:17:38].

Mr. Steel (02:17:40):

Good morning, sir.

Mark Parker (02:17:41):

How are you, sir?

Mr. Steel (02:17:42):

I'll let you know. I have a couple questions for you if I can.

Mark Parker (02:17:47):

Yes, sir.

Mr. Steel (02:17:49):

Now, when you concentrated yourself in the lower basement bedroom, that's what you call it, correct?

Mark Parker (02:17:55):

Yes, sir.

Mr. Steel (02:17:56):

And have you seen photographs by any chance?

Mark Parker (02:17:58):

I have.

Mr. Steel (02:17:59):

Okay. So your memory on us, and I know it's sure seven years ago almost, but-

Mark Parker (02:18:04):

Yes, sir.

Mr. Steel (02:18:04):

... you try to refresh your memory as best you could.

Mark Parker (02:18:06):

Yes, sir.

Mr. Steel (02:18:07):

Fair to say?

Mark Parker (02:18:07):

Fair to say.

Mr. Steel (02:18:08):

If you need to see anything, just let us know, okay?

Mark Parker (02:18:09):

Yes, sir.

Mr. Steel (02:18:11):

Was your work being video-recorded?

Mark Parker (02:18:18):

As far as the spraying or what?

Mr. Steel (02:18:20):

Yeah.

Mark Parker (02:18:21):

Is that what you're referring to?

Mr. Steel (02:18:22):

Yeah, your work.

Mark Parker (02:18:23):

At that time, no.

Mr. Steel (02:18:24):

Well, at any time.

Mark Parker (02:18:26):

Well, when I originally arrived on the scene, the first thing that I did was did a walkthrough video. In other words, I had a camcorder and I started on the outside and walked in, walked through the house video-recording.

Mr. Steel (02:18:41):

Perfect. Did you continue or one of your teammates continue that video recorder while you were doing the Bluestar testing-

Mark Parker (02:18:51):

No, sir.

Mr. Steel (02:18:52):

... so the jurors could actually see what you saw?

Mark Parker (02:18:54):

No, sir.

Mr. Steel (02:18:55):

You didn't do that?

Mark Parker (02:18:55):

No, sir.

Mr. Steel (02:18:56):

Photographs at the time of you spraying the mist?

Mark Parker (02:18:59):

No, sir.

Mr. Steel (02:19:00):

So we have your word.

Mark Parker (02:19:02):

Yes, sir.

Mr. Steel (02:19:02):

Seven years ago.

Mark Parker (02:19:03):

Seven years ago.

Mr. Steel (02:19:05):

But you wrote a report?

Mark Parker (02:19:06):

I did.

Mr. Steel (02:19:11):

Okay, and that report is really the only memorialization... God bless you. That report is really the only memorialization of what you did that day, fair to say?

Mark Parker (02:19:25):

That's correct, sir.

Mr. Steel (02:19:25):

And you did the report on the same day, I believe, as you were at the house, March 2020?

Mark Parker (02:19:26):

No, I believe I wrote the report... That was on a Thursday. I believe it was Monday that I wrote the report.

Mr. Steel (02:19:33):

Okay. All right, so not the same day. You waited.

Mark Parker (02:19:37):

To the best of my knowledge, yes.

Mr. Steel (02:19:39):

Okay. I want to ask you some questions. You mentioned somebody who's trying to obstruct. If I get killed and somebody unjustifiably kills me and they want to clean up my blood that's coming out of my body, they may rip up the carpeting, they may use cleaner or whatever to get out scents...

Mr. Steel (02:20:00):

May use cleaner or whatever to get out stains.

Mark Parker (02:20:02):

Yes, sir.

Mr. Steel (02:20:02):

You've seen that before, right?

Mark Parker (02:20:02):

I have.

Mr. Steel (02:20:03):

But the BLUESTAR may be used and its reagent may form the blue color or some color. There may be some reaction if you go to that area, even though people try to use Clorox or whatever to clean up.

Mark Parker (02:20:22):

I would say so.

Mr. Steel (02:20:23):

Even bleach, right?

Mark Parker (02:20:24):

I would believe so, yes.

Mr. Steel (02:20:27):

All right. And in this case, when you came onto the house in the basement, we'll call it the basement bedroom area where you were working, do you remember any windows in that area?

Mark Parker (02:20:42):

Windows in that room? Yes.

Mr. Steel (02:20:43):

Okay. And do you remember lighting?

Mark Parker (02:20:50):

Well, the lighting, it was raining outside. I know it was overcast, raining. There was light coming through the window. There was a, I want to say a sheet or a curtain or something over the window. If it had been open, if the sheet or curtain had been open, I would've closed it because obviously I wanted it to be darker in there if possible. If not, I could still continue, if that answers your question.

Mr. Steel (02:21:20):

I think so, but also electrical lighting, like this honorable courthouse in here.

‍

Mark Parker (02:21:24):

Well, I don't remember to be perfectly honest with you.

Mr. Steel (02:21:28):

We believe you're perfectly honest. You're under oath, so you don't have to say that.

Mark Parker (02:21:31):

Yes, sir.

Mr. Steel (02:21:31):

We got you. All right. So the lighting in the room, you just don't remember? It's been too long.

Mark Parker (02:21:36):

Whether I cut the light off, I don't. Yes, I don't remember.

Mr. Steel (02:21:39):

Right. It could have been on, it could have been off, you don't remember?

Mark Parker (02:21:39):

Correct.

Mr. Steel (02:21:39):

Okay. Now, did you see the photographs from the tragedy that occurred December 22, 2019? So about 60 days before this?

Mark Parker (02:21:55):

No.

Mr. Steel (02:21:55):

You weren't privy to the photos of whether there was blood or...

Mark Parker (02:22:01):

I could have if I wanted to, but I didn't.

Mr. Steel (02:22:04):

Okay.

Mark Parker (02:22:05):

I'm not saying for any specific reason I didn't. I just didn't.

Mr. Steel (02:22:11):

That's fine. But you did test other areas, not just the safe and the holster that we're talking about. We'll come back to that. But you tested other areas in that room?

Mark Parker (02:22:18):

Well, I tested one other area.

Mr. Steel (02:22:19):

Tell the jurors.

Mark Parker (02:22:20):

It was a approximately 5' wall to the left of the door that you walk in the bedroom. When I first went down into the bedroom, I noticed some stains on a wall. Not necessarily that they looked like blood, but it just kind of caught my attention. So when I started spraying with the BLUESTAR, that was the very first thing that I sprayed and there was no reaction whatsoever.

Mr. Steel (02:22:49):

I'm going to, just in the interest of time, with the Court's permission, give Mr. Lail some exhibits and then you can show the jury the wall if you remember.

Mark Parker (02:22:57):

Yes, sir. Yes.

Mr. Steel (02:22:58):

You remember the wall?

Mark Parker (02:23:00):

I do.

Mr. Steel (02:23:54):

Okay. I'll give you the exhibits. Your Honor, may I have one moment and approach?

Judge Bucci (02:23:54):

Sure.

Mr. Steel (02:23:54):

Sir, give me one moment.

Mark Parker (02:23:54):

Yes, sir.

Mr. Steel (02:23:54):

I'm going to ask Mr. Lail just to look through these for us and then of course you will look through them.

Mark Parker (02:24:01):

Yes, sir.

Mr. Steel (02:24:01):

I'm going to continue to ask you some questions. Is it okay, Mr. [inaudible 02:24:06]? Your Honor, can I just take the exhibits to Mr. Lail?

Judge Bucci (02:24:09):

Yes.

Mr. Steel (02:24:21):

Okay. Did anybody tell you, besides your observation that, "Hey, there's a stain on the wall and I'm going to spray it." Did anyone tell you where there was blood, potential blood on December 22, 2019?

Judge Bucci (02:24:37):

No. No.

Mr. Steel (02:24:38):

No one bothered to do it? Okay. And when you did spray that wall, and we'll just show it to you and then you'll, with the Court's permission, show it to the jurors just so they know where you sprayed. Obviously you said no reaction.

Mark Parker (02:24:49):

Correct.

Mr. Steel (02:24:50):

And I know that you said earlier, and I appreciate it, that even if somebody, if I got murdered and somebody tried to clean up, it may not be enough, but sometimes the blood does just go away.

Mark Parker (02:25:05):

Well, I would assume, yes, you wash something enough times, it's eventually going to be gone.

Mr. Steel (02:25:12):

Or scrub it or whatever.

Mark Parker (02:25:13):

Right. Correct.

Mr. Steel (02:25:14):

Okay. With regards to the safe, it is obvious to me you did not see that safe in the upstairs master's bedroom.

Mark Parker (02:25:28):

I did not.

Mr. Steel (02:25:29):

And somebody brought it to you in the same room you're talking about with a cloudy day, rainy day with the sheet, with the sun coming in, possibly lights, possibly no lights, that type of light?

Mark Parker (02:25:41):

Correct.

Mr. Steel (02:25:42):

And when you sprayed the safe, clearly you did not get a reaction, right?

Mark Parker (02:25:47):

That's correct.

Mr. Steel (02:25:48):

And that could mean that there was never any blood on the safe?

Mark Parker (02:25:52):

I would assume that, yes.

Mr. Steel (02:25:53):

Or it could mean that there was blood at some time, but it wore off, it got rubbed off. It's not there anymore, true?

Mark Parker (02:26:01):

True.

Mr. Steel (02:26:02):

Okay. Now I want to go to the camouflage holster, which I think you saw it. With that holster, the fact that you're spraying the BLUESTAR, now that's a presumptive test, right?

Mark Parker (02:26:21):

Correct.

Mr. Steel (02:26:21):

And presumptive means it's not something that we should rely upon in a courtroom, but it gives us a clue whether we should go further with the testing. Is that true?

Mark Parker (02:26:32):

That's correct.

Mr. Steel (02:26:33):

And I heard you say that BLUESTAR is different from Luminol, and I'm just asking you.

Mark Parker (02:26:42):

Yes, sir.

Mr. Steel (02:26:43):

I respect you and I'm not trying to challenge you.

Mark Parker (02:26:44):

Sure.

Mr. Steel (02:26:49):

But did you know that BLUESTAR is simply trademarked name of luminol, same reaction agent? Were you aware of that?

Mark Parker (02:26:58):

No, I can't say specifically that I was.

Mr. Steel (02:27:01):

They have the same exact ingredients or compounds.

Mark Parker (02:27:03):

Okay.

Mr. Steel (02:27:03):

Did you know that?

Mark Parker (02:27:05):

No.

Mr. Steel (02:27:05):

And it's fine. One's called Luminol, one's called BLUESTAR.

Mark Parker (02:27:08):

Okay.

Mr. Steel (02:27:11):

But whatever it's called.

Mark Parker (02:27:12):

Yes, sir.

Mr. Steel (02:27:14):

The bottom line is if you observe blood or suspected blood, I don't want to make a mistake, suspected blood with your eye, that's called visible blood or patent blood, right?

Mark Parker (02:27:28):

Yes.

Mr. Steel (02:27:29):

And if it's not visible to the eye, that's what the Luminol, or I'm going to use BLUESTAR, that's what it can help our eyes to see and then we can test it further potentially. And that's called invisible blood or latent blood, right?

Mark Parker (02:27:43):

Latent blood, yes.

Mr. Steel (02:27:45):

L-A-T-E-N-T?

Mark Parker (02:27:46):

Yes, sir.

Mr. Steel (02:27:47):

Versus patent, which means it's visible to the eye. P-A-T-E-N-T, right?

Mark Parker (02:27:51):

Invisible to the naked eye.

Mr. Steel (02:27:54):

That would be... But patent is visible and latent is invisible.

Mark Parker (02:27:58):

Correct.

Mr. Steel (02:27:59):

All right. Now, when you're using the BLUESTAR, did it have any requirement... There's different kits, if you're familiar and if you're not familiar, just say I'm wrong or it's not your experience. Was it the liquid BLUESTAR? I know it sprays a mist, or did you have to mix the two tablets? Do you remember?

Mark Parker (02:28:26):

I think I had to mix the two tablets.

Mr. Steel (02:28:29):

Okay. And you already discussed the lighting conditions and bottom line is you don't want to misstate. You know how important a courtroom is to get accurate information, right?

Mark Parker (02:28:42):

Can you repeat that? I don't understand.

Mr. Steel (02:28:44):

You know how important it is to try to get the accurate information in a courtroom?

Mark Parker (02:28:47):

Most certainly, yes.

Mr. Steel (02:28:48):

We don't guess. So you don't want to talk about the lighting, you're just not sure. We already covered that, right?

Mark Parker (02:28:55):

Yes, that's fair to say.

Mr. Steel (02:28:57):

All right. Now, when you said that you sprayed the item one time and it came up with the white and green color?

Mark Parker (02:29:06):

Yeah, that's what I saw. Different than the blue.

Mr. Steel (02:29:14):

I understand. And then you said you waited about a minute or two. Were you timing it? Do you have anything in your notes-

Mark Parker (02:29:20):

No, I didn't.

Mr. Steel (02:29:20):

... to say how long you really waited?

Mark Parker (02:29:22):

No. No.

Mr. Steel (02:29:22):

Okay.

Mark Parker (02:29:24):

Just best guesstimate. I remember not doing it right away again because I didn't want to saturate it with the liquid.

Mr. Steel (02:29:37):

What happens then?

Mark Parker (02:29:40):

Well, I don't specifically know what happens, but it's in the directions it's in the manual not to saturate.

Mr. Steel (02:29:49):

Okay.

Mark Parker (02:29:50):

In other words, you don't want to continue to spray it one time, let it kind of in the mist in there and let it fall down on the... Or the wall. To me, that's what I get from the directions, if that makes sense.

Mr. Steel (02:30:11):

Yeah, I think so. Can you just... Let's just focus on the... We could come to the wall if you want, but let's just go with the holster, the camouflage item. How many times... Just explain how much mist you put on. How many pumps? Was it a pump, I assume it's a pump?

Mark Parker (02:30:27):

Yes, sir. Well, with the holster, I would've held it up one time and it would've spritzed out and fallen down onto the...

Mr. Steel (02:30:37):

One time?

Mark Parker (02:30:38):

Yes, sir.

Mr. Steel (02:30:38):

Okay.

Mark Parker (02:30:38):

Well, yeah, that first time, yes. And then of course I'd do the other side. I mean, I can't tell you which side had the low intensity glow to it because I don't remember. I just know there was one side that did. It wasn't the whole thing. It was just like, let's just say this side. Or I could have spritzed this side and there was no reaction, turn it over because I want to spritz the other side, do that, and then I got the reaction. Wait one or two minutes later, best guesstimate in my head, and spritz it again and didn't get a reaction the second time.

Mr. Steel (02:31:16):

And... Go ahead.

Mark Parker (02:31:17):

No, that's... I just want to make sure I explained myself.

Mr. Steel (02:31:20):

And you spritzing this in the same area because it's a small item, you're just flipping it over with your hand?

Mark Parker (02:31:25):

Pretty much, yes. Yes.

Mr. Steel (02:31:27):

And the spritz would be whatever the hole allows the mist to come out, you're talking about one or two sprays?

Mark Parker (02:31:33):

Yeah, just because it's not like a large area that I have to do. It's just it's this small holster.

Mr. Steel (02:31:40):

How many pumps are we talking about? One or two, three? I don't know. I'm asking you. And if you don't remember, just say.

Mark Parker (02:31:47):

I don't remember.

Mr. Steel (02:31:49):

All right. All right. But clearly you got a reaction. I understand that it was not-

Mark Parker (02:31:54):

Yes. Something.

Mr. Steel (02:31:54):

... the right BLUESTAR.

Mark Parker (02:31:57):

No, it's not what you say with BLUESTAR is not what I noticed.

Mr. Steel (02:32:01):

Something reacted?

Mark Parker (02:32:02):

Yes.

Mr. Steel (02:32:03):

Did you ever have that... And when I say you, I'm not referring to you. I'm referring to the team. Did you ever have that holster then taken to, let's say, the GBI crime lab for an official blood test?

Mark Parker (02:32:14):

Well, I didn't. I don't know if it was.

Mr. Steel (02:32:18):

That was my next question. All right. Based upon that limited reaction, if there was blood there, it was not a lot of blood. Is that fair to say?

Mark Parker (02:32:28):

It was not a lot of blood. Is that what you said?

Mr. Steel (02:32:31):

Yeah. I'm asking if there was blood there.

Mark Parker (02:32:32):

Sure. That would be fair to say, yes.

Mr. Steel (02:32:35):

Because it doesn't get that huge impact of the bright blue.

Mark Parker (02:32:39):

Correct.

Mr. Steel (02:32:40):

Okay. With regards to the lighting condition on the second spraying, I'm assuming it's just the same lighting?

Mark Parker (02:32:52):

Just the same, yes.

Mr. Steel (02:32:53):

Nothing changed?

Mark Parker (02:32:54):

Nothing changed.

Mr. Steel (02:32:55):

Brighter room?

Mark Parker (02:32:55):

Yes.

Mr. Steel (02:32:56):

All right. Okay. Have you ever taught any... You said anything with Luminol or BLUESTAR?

Mark Parker (02:33:09):

No.

Mr. Steel (02:33:11):

Okay. You just learned... It sounds like you're self-motivated and you really picked this up yourself.

Mark Parker (02:33:17):

Well, sometime between, I'll say 2003 and 2005, I believe the company or someone, it could have been through the GBI for all I know, but there was a class held in Kennesaw, Marietta area. And to me, it was more of a, this is new, this is what we have, this is a new thing that you need to come see, sort of thing. And so I signed up and went to it and it was like a half day session of get to know BLUESTAR, that sort of thing.

Mr. Steel (02:34:00):

And that was in 90... When did you say?

Mark Parker (02:34:01):

I'm going to say between 2002, 2003 up to, let's just say 2005.

Mr. Steel (02:34:06):

Okay. So-

Mark Parker (02:34:09):

Because it was a new product.

Mr. Steel (02:34:12):

All right. Mr. Lail pulled out some photographs. I'm going to ask to approach. Is that okay, Your Honor. And may I give back all the exhibits?

Judge Bucci (02:34:28):

Please do.

Mr. Steel (02:34:40):

May I approach you, sir?

Mark Parker (02:34:41):

Yes, sir.

Mr. Steel (02:34:42):

I don't know if these are helpful, and that's not a comment on Mr. Lail, but just tell me if these are helpful where you sprayed the wall, if that orients you at all. And you can just pull out the ones that helpful, or if they're not helpful, just put them to the other side.

Mark Parker (02:35:05):

Okay.

Mr. Steel (02:35:08):

And all I want to show is your best memory of when you sprayed the mist on the wall, if that's something you could help us with.

Mark Parker (02:36:04):

No. None of them are what I remember.

Mr. Steel (02:36:06):

Nothing?

Mark Parker (02:36:06):

No.

Mr. Steel (02:36:08):

Okay. That's fine. All right. Let me just go back to then the BLUESTAR and just ask a few questions. Are you aware that the chemical, the BLUESTAR chemical, reacts with iron? Iron, iron?

Mark Parker (02:36:23):

Yes, sir. I've read that.

Mr. Steel (02:36:24):

Okay. And do you know what the... It's FE2, you know what I'm talking about?

Mark Parker (02:36:34):

No, not really.

Mr. Steel (02:36:35):

Okay. That's fine. That's fine. In the blood, that's fine. I'm going to move on. Anyway, when this mist hits it interacts with... Are you aware of any red blood cells that may be there? Is that true? And if it's not just that-

Mark Parker (02:36:52):

Well, I've also read that red blood cells being hemoglobin, if that's the same thing. I've read an article that says it reacted with the iron and read another article that said it reacted with the hemoglobin.

Mr. Steel (02:37:06):

Okay. And can you tell the jurors if there's very faint blood, what happens when there's retesting of the same area? Do you know?

Mark Parker (02:37:18):

Well, if you applied too much, it would dilute whatever blood specimen was there.

Mr. Steel (02:37:27):

It eats it up. The chemical eats up the blood, if there was blood there.

Mark Parker (02:37:31):

If you say eat up, I don't know that it eats it up. To me, it just saturates it.

Mr. Steel (02:37:37):

And it doesn't react.

Mark Parker (02:37:38):

Yes.

Mr. Steel (02:37:39):

Now, everything you just told the jurors, you told that to... Do you remember who Detective Hardy is?

Mark Parker (02:37:47):

Yes, sir.

Mr. Steel (02:37:48):

You told him about your work on this case for the Luminol... I mean, the BLUESTAR, right?

Mark Parker (02:37:55):

I told him about my work?

Mr. Steel (02:37:57):

Yeah, you gave him a report. You did something, somehow you communicated to him. You didn't keep this a secret.

Mark Parker (02:38:03):

I'm sure I would have. I mean, it's not... Yes. No, I didn't keep it a secret.

Mr. Steel (02:38:08):

And you would've made sure, just like you put in your report, that there was at first a... I'm just going to refer to your report. The camo cloth you would've reported to him, the gun case?

Mark Parker (02:38:28):

Yes.

Mr. Steel (02:38:29):

Initially showed a very faint reaction.

Mark Parker (02:38:31):

Correct.

Mr. Steel (02:38:32):

You would've told him that, right?

Mark Parker (02:38:33):

I did. Or I would have, yes.

Mr. Steel (02:38:35):

I mean, you're not going to hide it from anybody. You would never hide it from anybody.

Mark Parker (02:38:39):

No. It's important. Nothing to hide. That's my job.

Mr. Steel (02:38:43):

Exactly. Thank you.

Mark Parker (02:38:45):

Thank you, sir.

Mr. Steel (02:38:45):

No, thank you. Thank you, Your Honor.

Judge Bucci (02:38:45):

Yes, sir.

Mr. Treadaway (02:38:51):

Thank you, Your Honor. If there is a positive reaction for blood, is that hard to see using BLUESTAR? Is that hard to...

Mark Parker (02:39:00):

No, you get that intense bloom of fluoresce. I mean, you can't not see it.

Mr. Treadaway (02:39:07):

Did you see it here at that house for wind spray?

Mark Parker (02:39:12):

No, I did not.

Mr. Treadaway (02:39:14):

You said, I think... Did you say earlier that sometimes a cleaning agent can give a false/positive or greenish white alert or whatever you want to call it?

Mark Parker (02:39:24):

Yes.

Mr. Treadaway (02:39:26):

Do you remember, you said that you remember going through the house kind of videotaping everything?

Mark Parker (02:39:31):

Yes.

Mr. Treadaway (02:39:32):

Did you videotape a bathroom off the primary bedroom, the master bedroom?

Mark Parker (02:39:40):

I'm sure I did.

Mr. Treadaway (02:39:41):

Do you remember seeing a bottle of cleaner right there?

Mark Parker (02:39:46):

No, I don't. I can't specifically say I did. Or I don't remember. Let's put it that way.

Mr. Treadaway (02:39:52):

Nothing further. Thank you.

Mr. Steel (02:39:54):

Nothing, Your Honor.

Judge Bucci (02:39:54):

All right, sir, you can be excused.

Mark Parker (02:39:54):

Thank you, sir.

Judge Bucci (02:39:54):

Mr. [inaudible 02:39:59] your next witness, please.

State Attorney (02:39:54):

State calls Detective Dixon.

Judge Bucci (02:41:31):

Good morning, sir. I'll swear you in. Please raise your right hand. Do you swear or affirm the testimony you're about to give in the matter before the court will be the truth, the whole truth, and nothing but the truth, so help you God?

Chris Dixon (02:41:36):

I do.

Judge Bucci (02:41:36):

Please have a seat.

State Attorney (02:41:46):

Could you state your name please, sir?

Chris Dixon (02:41:48):

Officer Chris Dixon.

State Attorney (02:41:49):

And how are you employed?

Chris Dixon (02:41:51):

I'm currently employed with the Paulding County School District Police Department.

State Attorney (02:41:55):

And how long have you been employed in that position?

Chris Dixon (02:41:57):

Since July the 27th of this year.

State Attorney (02:42:01):

Prior to that, what was your job?

Chris Dixon (02:42:04):

Prior to that, I worked in the construction industry for approximately four and a half years.

State Attorney (02:42:09):

And then prior to that?

Chris Dixon (02:42:11):

I was with the Paulding County Sheriff's Office for five years, and before that, the City of Atlanta Police Department for seven.

State Attorney (02:42:17):

All right. Now, with the Paulding County Sheriff's Office in 2020, what was your job with the Paulding County Sheriff's Office in 2020? What was your job?

Chris Dixon (02:42:32):

I was a detective assigned to the Criminal Investigations Division.

State Attorney (02:42:36):

And what did you do with regard to that position?

Chris Dixon (02:42:41):

I investigated crimes ranging from property to persons and anything in between.

State Attorney (02:42:46):

Did you have occasion to participate in the execution of a search warrant at 83 Braemill Court in Dallas, Georgia?

Chris Dixon (02:42:56):

Yes, sir.

State Attorney (02:42:57):

And can you tell this court about that search warrant you participated in on March the 5th of 2020 in Dallas, Georgia at 83 Braemill Court?

Chris Dixon (02:43:11):

Absolutely. So I was a assisting detective on this case that helped with the search warrant. On arrival, I met with fellow detectives. That would be Detective Pouch, both Ashley and Greg Pouch, Lieutenant Parker. We first went in, photographs and video were taken of the entire residence. Then we proceeded to take measurements inside of the home before searching for items listed within the search warrant. As a part of the search warrant, I was able to locate a gun safe as well as a key which opens it.

State Attorney (02:43:53):

Now how did you locate the gun safe?

Chris Dixon (02:44:01):

I'm sorry?

State Attorney (02:44:02):

How did you go about finding where the gun safe was?

Chris Dixon (02:44:05):

Through just a search of the home, sir, going through the home.

State Attorney (02:44:13):

I'll show you what has previously been marked for identification as state's exhibit number 197. Is this the gun safe that you found, sir?

Chris Dixon (02:44:23):

Looks like it.

State Attorney (02:44:26):

And then you said you found the key to the gun safe. How did you go about finding the key to the gun safe?

Chris Dixon (02:44:37):

It was located on a keychain, excuse me, a keychain.

State Attorney (02:44:42):

And do you recall where that keychain had been located?

Chris Dixon (02:44:46):

I don't recall where the keychain itself was located, sir. No.

State Attorney (02:44:50):

Do you know whose keychain it was?

Chris Dixon (02:44:52):

It was identified as Ms. Lacy Boles's keychain.

State Attorney (02:45:01):

Did you attempt to open the gun safe at that point?

Chris Dixon (02:45:07):

Yes, sir. The key seemed consistent with that of a gun safe. It was tried on the safe and it did open.

State Attorney (02:45:14):

Did you watch that key open the safe?

Chris Dixon (02:45:16):

Yes, sir.

State Attorney (02:45:17):

And this was the key that was on the keychain of Ms. Boles?

Chris Dixon (02:45:22):

Yes, sir.

State Attorney (02:45:23):

Okay. Did you see Ms. Boles there that day?

Chris Dixon (02:45:27):

Yes, sir.

State Attorney (02:45:28):

And do you see her in this courtroom today?

Chris Dixon (02:45:35):

Sir, I don't recognize her if she is in here.

State Attorney (02:45:39):

All right, sir. And then when you opened the safe, what, if anything, did you observe in the safe of interest to you?

Chris Dixon (02:45:54):

In the safe was a holster that was listed in the search warrant.

State Attorney (02:45:59):

And what, if anything, did you do with that holster?

Chris Dixon (02:46:06):

It was photographed in place and then subsequently tested by the crime scene unit.

State Attorney (02:46:13):

Officer, I'll show you what's previously been marked for identification as State's Exhibit number 198A and ask you if you recognize this.

Chris Dixon (02:46:21):

Yeah, that looks like the holster.

State Attorney (02:46:24):

Is that the holster that was eventually taken into evidence, sir?

Chris Dixon (02:46:30):

I'm sorry, you trailed off, sir.

State Attorney (02:46:31):

Was that the holster that was eventually taken into evidence?

Chris Dixon (02:46:34):

Yes, sir.

State Attorney (02:46:35):

[inaudible 02:46:35] witness.

Mr. Lail (02:47:00):

Detective, good morning.

Chris Dixon (02:47:01):

Good morning, sir. How are you?

Mr. Lail (02:47:01):

I'm well, thank you. How are you doing?

Chris Dixon (02:47:01):

I'm well.

Mr. Lail (02:47:03):

Good. Detective, my name is Raymond Lail. Along with Mr. Steel, I'm representing Ms. Boles in this case. Just a few questions for you. You made a report with regard to this case, a written report, am I correct?

Chris Dixon (02:47:19):

Yes, sir.

Mr. Lail (02:47:21):

Did you just make the one report with regard to this case?

Chris Dixon (02:47:23):

I have a few supplementals in regards to this case, sir.

Mr. Lail (02:47:27):

Okay. But with regard to what you're testifying to about going to the residence and filming and everything, there's just one report with regard to that, correct?

Chris Dixon (02:47:36):

Correct.

Mr. Lail (02:47:37):

Okay. And it's a typewritten report. Are you reading from that report?

Chris Dixon (02:47:40):

Yes, sir.

Mr. Lail (02:47:41):

Just make sure we have the same report, if I can -

Chris Dixon (02:47:43):

Sure. Absolutely.

Mr. Lail (02:47:49):

Is this the report?

Chris Dixon (02:47:58):

Looks like it.

Mr. Lail (02:47:59):

Okay. Very good. Thank you.

Chris Dixon (02:48:01):

Yes, sir.

Mr. Lail (02:48:01):

I just want to make sure there's not another report. So there's no other handwritten report or anything else? This is the report, correct?

Chris Dixon (02:48:08):

That's the report, sir.

Mr. Lail (02:48:09):

Very good. Thank you. And of course, you do your report close in time to when you do an investigation because you need to have it to be accurate, correct?

Chris Dixon (02:48:16):

Correct.

Mr. Lail (02:48:17):

Because you might be testifying years later, like in this case?

Chris Dixon (02:48:20):

Correct.

Mr. Lail (02:48:20):

Okay. All right. So with regard to the key that you testified to earlier, you don't know how long that key had been on the keychain that it was found on, correct?

Chris Dixon (02:48:39):

No, sir. I wouldn't know that.

Mr. Lail (02:48:41):

Yeah. And you also don't know if that keychain was joined with another keychain at some point. You wouldn't know that, would you?

Chris Dixon (02:48:54):

I wouldn't have known that.

(02:48:55)
Okay.

Mr. Lail (02:49:00):

So did you actually video the residence when you got there or did you assist with the video of the residence?

Chris Dixon (02:49:09):

No, sir. I did not video, nor did I assist with the video. I was there during the walkthrough when the crime scene unit was doing their video and photography.

Mr. Lail (02:49:18):

Okay. And so somebody else was videoing the scene, correct?

Chris Dixon (02:49:22):

Correct.

Mr. Lail (02:49:22):

But there was a video camera there, correct?

Chris Dixon (02:49:24):

Correct.

Mr. Lail (02:49:25):

Okay. So were you present in the basement when the other detective was doing the test, the luminol test on the safe?

Chris Dixon (02:49:38):

Yes, sir.

Mr. Lail (02:49:39):

And the gun holster?

Chris Dixon (02:49:40):

Yes, sir.

Mr. Lail (02:49:40):

Okay. So that was done in the basement of the house, if you recall?

Chris Dixon (02:49:45):

I really don't. I do apologize. The location where it was tested I don't recall.

Mr. Lail (02:49:49):

Okay. And so nobody asked you to video that test, did they?

Chris Dixon (02:49:56):

Not that I recall. No, sir.

Mr. Lail (02:49:57):

Okay. If they had asked you to video the test and they had a camera, you would've done it, right?

Chris Dixon (02:50:01):

It would've been notated in my report had I made any kind of video myself. That wasn't generally my job. That's what crime scene was for.

Mr. Lail (02:50:10):

Of course. But if you're there and someone had asked you to do it, you would've done it, right?

Chris Dixon (02:50:14):

No, sir. Not generally. I can't say that I did.

Mr. Lail (02:50:18):

No, I'm not saying that you did. I'm just asking you if someone had asked you, "Hey, do you mind videoing while we do this?" You would've done that, right?

Chris Dixon (02:50:24):

Sure.

Mr. Lail (02:50:25):

Okay. Can I just have a moment, Judge? Thank you. I know it's been seven years ago. Do you remember that it was actually Ms. Boles that walked y'all upstairs and actually showed you where the safe was in the closet up there? Do you remember that?

Chris Dixon (02:50:56):

I don't. I'm sorry.

Mr. Lail (02:50:57):

Okay. She could have done that, you just don't remember?

Chris Dixon (02:51:00):

Correct.

Mr. Lail (02:51:01):

Okay. Thank you, sir.

Chris Dixon (02:51:10):

Thank you, sir.

State Attorney (02:51:16):

Officer Dixon, were you present when Lieutenant Parker actually sprayed the safe to try to determine if there was a reaction with the BLUESTAR?

Chris Dixon (02:51:27):

I was there. Yes, sir.

State Attorney (02:51:28):

Did you watch him spray the whole safe at the time?

Chris Dixon (02:51:32):

I don't remember. I do apologize.

State Attorney (02:51:35):

Okay. What about the holster? Were you present when he sprayed this holster?

Chris Dixon (02:51:41):

I was on scene. I don't know if I was in that room when he sprayed the holster.

State Attorney (02:51:45):

All right sir, that's all the questions I have. Thank you.

Mr. Lail (02:51:47):

Nothing further.

Judge Bucci (02:51:49):

Sir, you can be excused. Thank you very much.

Chris Dixon (02:51:51):

Thank you, sir.

Judge Bucci (02:51:55):

How are y'all holding up? Good? All right. Do you have another witness?

Mr. Treadaway (02:51:59):

Yes, sir. Could it please the Court, the state calls Aristide Passas.

Judge Bucci (02:52:02):

Good morning, sir.

Aristide Passas (02:53:24):

Good morning.

Judge Bucci (02:53:25):

Let me swear you in. Please raise your right hand and receive an oath. Do you swear or affirm the testimony you're about to give in the matter pending before the Court will be the truth, the whole truth, nothing but the truth, so help you God?

Aristide Passas (02:53:35):

Yes.

Judge Bucci (02:53:35):

Please have a seat.

Mr. Treadaway (02:53:39):

Good morning, sir. If you could state your name for the jury, please.

Aristide Passas (02:53:43):

Aristides Passas. A-R-I-S-T-I-D-E-S. Last name Passas, P-A-S-S-A-S.

Mr. Treadaway (02:53:52):

How are you employed now, sir?

Aristide Passas (02:53:54):

I'm an attorney.

Mr. Treadaway (02:53:55):

With?

Aristide Passas (02:53:56):

OneTrust.

Mr. Treadaway (02:53:58):

Private company?

Aristide Passas (02:53:58):

Private company.

Mr. Treadaway (02:54:00):

Okay. At some point in your career, sir, did you do work with the Georgia Bureau of Investigations?

Aristide Passas (02:54:05):

I did. I was with the GBI for about 10 years, five of those years as a forensic toxicologist, and then five of those years as an attorney.

Mr. Treadaway (02:54:15):

Sought your law degree while still employed with GBI?

Aristide Passas (02:54:18):

Yes, sir.

Mr. Treadaway (02:54:20):

Okay. Can you tell the jury, please, the nature of your education that prepared you to be a forensic toxicologist at the GBI?

Aristide Passas (02:54:29):

So I have an undergraduate degree in chemistry. That's about four years. I have a master's degree in forensic toxicology, and once I have completed all my educational training at the GBI, they give you about six month to one year training there. Which includes reviewing peer-reviewed journal articles, hands-on testing, instruction from other lead analysts there so that you can get a great foundation as you move forward towards your independent casework in forensic toxicology.

Aristides Passas (02:55:00):

... as you move forward towards your independent case work in forensic toxicology, and they kind of split it into two. The first half of the training is blood alcohol, so you're learning everything about the blood alcohol side. And the second half is the rest of the typical drugs that we see at the GBI.

Jason Treadway (02:55:18):

Have you had your work peer reviewed at the GBI?

Aristides Passas (02:55:23):

Yes.

Jason Treadway (02:55:23):

Can you just tell the jury briefly what that means?

Aristides Passas (02:55:25):

Yeah. So just to kind of explain what the peer review process is, typically as in the scientific field, peer review is when you're going to produce or publish a journal article, other scientists will review that journal article for accuracy or any issues that they might see prior to it being published. So we review those articles, but at the GBI, what we're kind of referring to when we say peer review is that any report that's put out by a toxicologist in this case or by myself will also be reviewed by another scientist. They'll review all the raw data, all the images and come to their own independent conclusion as to what they believe the results should be. Then they'll compare it back to what I've written on my report to ensure that everything lines up. So there's kind of two ways to define peer review, but at the GBI, that's how we define it.

Jason Treadway (02:56:17):

Have you prepared toxicology reports as a forensic toxicologist at the GBI before in your career?

Aristides Passas (02:56:22):

Yes.

Jason Treadway (02:56:23):

Approximately how many?

Aristides Passas (02:56:25):

Over 500.

Jason Treadway (02:56:28):

I know you did kind of a dual role at the GBI. At some point you were an attorney there, right?

Aristides Passas (02:56:33):

Yes.

Jason Treadway (02:56:34):

Okay. But while you were a scientist there, not saying you stopped being a scientist, but when you were doing the active evaluations, what period, how many years was that?

Aristides Passas (02:56:42):

That was about five years.

Jason Treadway (02:56:43):

Five years. Is that fair to say you're in a laboratory every day, basically?

Aristides Passas (02:56:48):

Yeah. So the way it works is about half the time, you'll be in the lab performing what we call extractions, which is the process of pulling the drugs out of the samples that we get. Most of the time, it's blood. So you'll be in the lab performing those extractions. Then the other half of the time, you'll be working on paperwork, producing your reports, reviewing data, those kinds of things.

Jason Treadway (02:57:09):

Did you ever publish any articles on the subject matter of forensic toxicology?

Aristides Passas (02:57:16):

Yes. I did publish one article during my undergrad. It was my thesis. I don't recall the specific title, but it had to deal with desorption electrospray ionization mass spectrometry. It's a long word, but it had to do with forensics.

Jason Treadway (02:57:37):

Is it required in your field at the time you were a scientist, sir, not that you're not a scientist anymore, but I know you're still a scientist, but when you were working in the laboratory with GBI at that time, was it required for you to continue annual education or continuing education every year?

Aristides Passas (02:57:53):

Yes. Yeah. At the GBI, you had to complete continuing education or training annually. And that was given through the GBI done by trained scientists and those kinds of things.

Jason Treadway (02:58:04):

Did you ever attend conferences in the area of forensic toxicology?

Aristides Passas (02:58:08):

I did not.

Jason Treadway (02:58:09):

Did you serve as a peer reviewer or you said your work was peer review. Did you ever peer review?

Aristides Passas (02:58:18):

I did.

Jason Treadway (02:58:18):

Many times, a few times?

Aristides Passas (02:58:20):

Yeah. I mean, over 200.

Jason Treadway (02:58:23):

200 times you were the peer reviewer, is that right?

Aristides Passas (02:58:24):

Yes.

Jason Treadway (02:58:30):

All right. Respectfully tender the witness as an expert in the area of forensic toxicology.

Judge Dean Bucci (02:58:35):

Any objection to that?

Brian Steel (02:58:36):

No, sir.

Judge Dean Bucci (02:58:39):

All right. Granted.

Jason Treadway (02:58:42):

Sir, were you involved in a case in which you had to perform or produce a forensic toxicology report for subject [inaudible 02:58:52] Daniel Lee Akers at some point with your time with the GBI?

Aristides Passas (02:58:55):

Yes.

Jason Treadway (02:58:58):

Do you know if it was around April of 2020?

Aristides Passas (02:59:02):

That sounds accurate.

Jason Treadway (02:59:05):

Okay. Was it a time when you were working as a forensic toxicologist in the setting that you just described, you're in the lab doing extractions and you were preparing to prepare reports, was it during that time?

Aristides Passas (02:59:14):

Yes.

Jason Treadway (02:59:15):

Prior to becoming an attorney for the GBI?

Aristides Passas (02:59:17):

Yes.

Jason Treadway (02:59:18):

Okay. Tell the jury, if you remember, sir, what you analyzed, what... You said you could analyze blood for alcohol content. What was your goal in a forensic examination of toxicology in that case?

Aristides Passas (02:59:34):

In that case, it was the other drugs. So we have a screening process that screens over, I believe at the time, it's 150 different drugs. And so at the time, my goal was to determine whether or not there were any of those drugs that we test for, and if we could see that, how much was there.

Jason Treadway (02:59:55):

Do you remember the source of blood that you tested?

Aristides Passas (02:59:59):

I do not.

Jason Treadway (02:59:59):

All right, sir. Please approach your opposing counsel and show what I'll mark for identification purposes only as State's Exhibit 217. May I approach the witness, please?

Judge Dean Bucci (03:00:41):

Yes, sir.

Jason Treadway (03:00:41):

Sir, let me show you what I'll mark for identification purposes only as State's Exhibit 217. I'll ask you to look at that and when you're finished, just give me a sign. Sorry. Do you recognize State's Exhibit 217?

Aristides Passas (03:01:03):

I do.

Jason Treadway (03:01:04):

Just generally, not with any detail or specifics containing the contents, but generally, what is State's Exhibit 217, please?

Aristides Passas (03:01:10):

This is a copy of my forensic toxicology report, and I can tell it's a copy of my report because it has the case number. It also has my signature and name at the end of it.

Jason Treadway (03:01:21):

Other than possibly being a facsimile, a photocopy, does it fairly and accurately depict the report as you produced it in April of 2020?

Aristides Passas (03:01:29):

Yes.

Jason Treadway (03:01:30):

Take a look at 217 and tell if there's been any changes, alterations, or deletions that make it somehow not accurate as to your report, sir.

Aristides Passas (03:01:38):

No.

Jason Treadway (03:01:42):

Respectfully, move the court to admit into evidence what's been previously marked for identification purposes only as State's Exhibit 217.

Brian Steel (03:01:48):

I don't object for the record, Your Honor, but I'd like to discuss whatever goes out with the jurors at the appropriate time.

Judge Dean Bucci (03:01:56):

Say again?

Brian Steel (03:01:56):

I do not object to the entry for the record and to be used in court.

Judge Dean Bucci (03:02:02):

I understand.

Brian Steel (03:02:02):

But I do want to reserve whether it goes out to the jurors.

Judge Dean Bucci (03:02:05):

It's admitted.

Jason Treadway (03:02:06):

Permission to publish, please.

Judge Dean Bucci (03:02:08):

Yes, sir.

Jason Treadway (03:02:09):

Thank you. I'll take it in front of me, sir. Thank you. You should have a viewpoint on your monitor, but I'm going to be referring to it up here. So for the record, if I may publish 217, if you'll look at that, sir, and specifically let's talk a little bit about this. So can you see it, sir, either on the monitor or on the giant screen?

Aristides Passas (03:02:37):

Yes.

Jason Treadway (03:02:38):

Do you see a barcode over to the top right?

Aristides Passas (03:02:41):

Yes.

Jason Treadway (03:02:41):

Why is it there?

Aristides Passas (03:02:44):

The barcode identifies the case that we're working on. These barcodes are applied to all the evidence in that case. It helps us track the case as it moves throughout the lab. For example, the blood will arrive in plastic bags. On the surface of that plastic bag, there'll be a printed barcode. We scan that to allow for tracking throughout the GBI, so that barcode is just tied to that case.

Jason Treadway (03:03:10):

Does the case number, the GBI DOFS, Department of Forensic Sciences case number remain the same throughout, as you said, travels through the GBI?

Aristides Passas (03:03:19):

Yes.

Jason Treadway (03:03:21):

And is case number 419, ending in 419, are you familiar with that being a case number for the Daniel Akers examination?

Aristides Passas (03:03:28):

Yes.

Jason Treadway (03:03:29):

In fact, do you see some information here from agency? What does it say? Is that agency?

Aristides Passas (03:03:35):

Yeah. So the agency is just telling us who requested the service in this case. So it came from the Paulding County coroner and the person who requested it was L. Eberhart.

Jason Treadway (03:03:47):

Okay. You may not know, but do you know the Paulding County coroner's name at that time, L. Eberhart?

Aristides Passas (03:03:51):

I do not know.

Jason Treadway (03:03:51):

Okay. It was requested from the coroner's office?

Aristides Passas (03:03:51):

That's correct.

Jason Treadway (03:03:58):

And what specific service or scientific testing was requested by the Paulding County Coroner's Office?

Aristides Passas (03:04:07):

Based on the testing that we did here, we can see that it was requested to have a full screen, a full analysis.

Jason Treadway (03:04:13):

Okay. Requested service, it says postmortem toxicology?

Aristides Passas (03:04:18):

Yes.

Jason Treadway (03:04:18):

So what bodily fluid or bodily evidence did you subject to your testing in this case?

Aristides Passas (03:04:25):

Yeah. So if you can aim down just a little bit.

Jason Treadway (03:04:29):

Investigator Burke, can you pull it up a little bit in the middle area?

Aristides Passas (03:04:32):

Yep. That's perfect.

Jason Treadway (03:04:33):

Yeah. So you see all of these different numbers and then you see corresponding explanations. Can you go through that?

Aristides Passas (03:04:40):

Yes. So all of the different items that you see there, 2, 2A, 2B, 2C, and 2D, and 2E are different biological specimens that were taken from the victim in this case. 2A shows that it is femoral blood. 2B is urine. And as you move down the list, you can see different types of blood. Vitreous fluid is the fluid behind the eye, urine is urine, and then subclavian blood and iliac blood are just different parts of the body where the blood is taken from. The reason that we have different parts of the body that blood is taken from has to do with something called postmortem redistribution. So what we see sometimes is that drugs may move around in different concentrations once the person has died. Femoral blood, for our purposes here, was the best specimen for us to test because it is the least likely to go through this postmortem redistribution that I was explaining. So it's going to give you the most accurate result when it comes to the testing.

Jason Treadway (03:05:52):

May I just turn down the lights a little bit, Your Honor?

Judge Dean Bucci (03:05:55):

Sure.

Jason Treadway (03:05:56):

Thank you. And Investigator Burke, can you move it up just a little bit past that section that Mr. Passas just talked about, the next section?

Investigator Burke (03:06:06):

Yeah.

Jason Treadway (03:06:07):

So if you see here, go down a little bit. So was femoral blood what you tested in this case?

Aristides Passas (03:06:17):

Yes.

Jason Treadway (03:06:17):

And is that... Did you say that's most accurate? Does that mimic most accurately the condition of the blood during life?

Aristides Passas (03:06:25):

Yes.

Jason Treadway (03:06:26):

Because it hasn't been subjected to redistribution?

Aristides Passas (03:06:29):

Right.

Jason Treadway (03:06:29):

All right. Did you test femoral blood in this case?

Aristides Passas (03:06:32):

Yes.

Jason Treadway (03:06:33):

Did you test it for common drugs of abuse right here under number one?

Aristides Passas (03:06:38):

Yes.

Jason Treadway (03:06:39):

Did you test it for cocaine?

Aristides Passas (03:06:44):

I did.

Jason Treadway (03:06:44):

Barbiturates, cannabinoids, benzodiazepines, other common opioids, was that test undertaken by you, sir?

Aristides Passas (03:06:51):

Yes.

Jason Treadway (03:06:52):

And the results were what in the femoral blood, sir?

Aristides Passas (03:06:54):

Negative.

Jason Treadway (03:06:55):

And then do you see subsection two, you have positive for amphetamine. Do you see that?

Aristides Passas (03:07:01):

Yes.

Jason Treadway (03:07:02):

So was there traces of amphetamine in the femoral blood?

Aristides Passas (03:07:09):

Yes.

Jason Treadway (03:07:10):

But then you put here, what is your finding? What are your findings immediately below the positive finding on your report, sir? What does it say?

Aristides Passas (03:07:19):

Lower than the lowest calibrator of 50 micrograms per liter.

Jason Treadway (03:07:23):

So micrograms per liter, that's a unit, I guess you work with in your field?

Aristides Passas (03:07:28):

Yes.

Jason Treadway (03:07:29):

Okay. And what do you mean lower than the lowest calibrator? What does that mean?

Aristides Passas (03:07:33):

Okay. So in order to explain what that means, I have to take you back to what a calibrator is and what a calibration is. So prior to us testing blood, what we have to do is we have to teach the instruments what response they would get, what that correlates to in terms of a concentration. So we use between 50 micrograms per liter all the way up to 800. And those numbers are based on what we've seen in prior cases, what other labs are doing, peer reviewed published articles, all of those values and ranges. That's how we decide on the 50 to 800. So that range that our instruments are able to detect and quantify of blood for, in this case, amphetamines has been established prior to.

(03:08:20)
In this case, the amount was less than our lowest amount that we can accurately detect and quantify. So what that means is we can say, "Look, it's positive because the lowest detectable amount for us is around 12.5." So between 12.5 and 50, we can say, "There's amphetamine here, we just can't give you a number." It can be as low as 12.6 and as high as 49. We don't know. But what we do know is that there is amphetamine. It's just a very small amount.

Jason Treadway (03:08:54):

The finding of the quantity of amphetamine that you noted here in your report, sir, is it consistent with someone who had recently, and I mean recently from when the blood was drawn, recently ingested or subjected the blood to a large quantity of amphetamines?

Aristides Passas (03:09:14):

No.

Jason Treadway (03:09:14):

Based on your findings as an expert and training, knowledge, experience, is it consistent with somebody who would've recently abused methamphetamine as a recreational drug of abuse?

Aristides Passas (03:09:24):

No.

Jason Treadway (03:09:49):

And did the other drugs of abuse, cocaine, marijuana, is marijuana cannabinoid?

Aristides Passas (03:09:55):

Yes.

Jason Treadway (03:09:56):

Benzodiazepines is, I guess commonly found in pills?

Aristides Passas (03:10:00):

Commonly found in pills, yes.

Jason Treadway (03:10:01):

Other common opiates you put are those commonly drugs of abuse, pills, opiates in the form of a pill?

Aristides Passas (03:10:08):

Yes.

Jason Treadway (03:10:08):

Is that common?

Aristides Passas (03:10:08):

That's common.

Jason Treadway (03:10:09):

So on those particular drugs, was it, even at the lowest possible quantifiable number as the amphetamine was, or was it non-existent?

Aristides Passas (03:10:20):

So on those, we didn't even get to the point to try to quantify it. Our screen normally picks up, "Hey, we might see this drug here." It didn't even reach that point. We didn't even get to the point of trying to quantify those because it just wasn't there. So they're all negative.

Jason Treadway (03:10:36):

Do you have an opinion, sir, as to when someone could have recreationally abused methamphetamine or amphetamine as far as compared to when the blood was harvested or taken the femoral blood, how often, in what proximity would somebody have had to abuse methamphetamine to end up then with such a almost lower than the lowest number? Do you have an opinion on that?

Aristides Passas (03:11:04):

It depends. It depends how much they took, when they took it. The thing with amphetamine and methamphetamine is it's not similar to, for example, ethyl alcohol. Alcohol, you can say it has a linear distribution to how it's going to exit your body. If you took it at this time, at this amount, around this time, this is how much you're going to have. With amphetamine and methamphetamine, it's not like that. So it's very difficult to say this person took a lot here and this is what you're looking at versus something else.

Jason Treadway (03:11:38):

Would this finding be consistent with someone who recently used it?

Aristides Passas (03:11:41):

It would not be.

Jason Treadway (03:11:43):

Thank you. That's all I have.

Judge Dean Bucci (03:11:45):

Cross examination.

Brian Steel (03:11:48):

Hello.

Aristides Passas (03:11:49):

Hello.

Brian Steel (03:11:50):

Counselor, thank you for what you do for people. What does the word recent mean?

Aristides Passas (03:11:56):

Recent to me would mean within an hour.

Brian Steel (03:11:59):

Okay. Thank you. No other questions. Thank you, Your Honor.

Jason Treadway (03:12:04):

All right. [inaudible 03:12:05].

Brian Steel (03:12:05):

And this is the courts.

Jason Treadway (03:12:07):

Okay. Very good. And an hour of when? When the femoral blood was harvested?

Aristides Passas (03:12:12):

An hour of use.

Jason Treadway (03:12:14):

So use. Within an hour of use, and then if someone used an hour before the femoral blood was harvested or a couple hours before the femoral blood was harvested, would you expect to see such a load off?

Aristides Passas (03:12:28):

So it depends. If we're saying that they're abusing it, if they are like an addict, you would typically see larger amounts, at least larger than our lowest calibrator, which would be 50. This lower than the lowest calibrator value is synonymous, I would say, or you can see it as somebody who might be using this. If they are typically using amphetamine, it would just be therapeutic level is what we would call it.

Jason Treadway (03:12:55):

Like a prescription drug?

Aristides Passas (03:12:57):

Like a prescription drug, for example, Adderall.

Jason Treadway (03:12:59):

Nothing further. Thank you.

Brian Steel (03:13:04):

‍

I don't want to get out of your field. I know you haven't done this in years. People smoke, some people smoke methamphetamine.

Aristides Passas (03:13:12):

That's correct.

Brian Steel (03:13:13):

Yeah. Some people inject methamphetamine?

Aristides Passas (03:13:16):

That's correct.

Brian Steel (03:13:18):

And some people snort methamphetamine, right?

Aristides Passas (03:13:21):

That's correct.

Brian Steel (03:13:22):

And all you're doing is, I'm not saying all, but you're just testing what's in the blood, right?

Aristides Passas (03:13:27):

That's correct.

Brian Steel (03:13:28):

Okay. Thank you. Nothing further. Thank you.

Judge Dean Bucci (03:13:28):

All right. Sir, thank you. You can be excused.

Aristides Passas (03:13:28):

Thank you.

Judge Dean Bucci (03:13:38):

Ladies and gentlemen, it's 11:30. We can keep going until noon or we can break now for 10 minutes and then resume and go 12:30 or so. Anybody want to break now?

Speaker 9 (03:13:47):

No.

Judge Dean Bucci (03:13:47):

No. Okay. Next witness.

Speaker 8 (03:13:47):

State calls Linda Wicks.

Brian Steel (03:13:54):

And Your Honor, can I just put this back to the court reporter?

Judge Dean Bucci (03:13:54):

Sure.

Brian Steel (03:13:54):

May I approach?

Judge Dean Bucci (03:13:54):

Good morning.

Linda Wicks (03:13:54):

Good morning.

Judge Dean Bucci (03:14:45):

I'll swear you in. [inaudible 03:14:41]. Do you swear or affirm the testimony you're about to give in the matter will be the truth, the whole truth, and nothing but the truth, so help you God?

Linda Wicks (03:14:46):

I do.

Judge Dean Bucci (03:14:48):

Thank you.

Speaker 8 (03:14:54):

Could you state your name please, ma'am?

Linda Wicks (03:14:56):

Linda Wicks.

Speaker 8 (03:14:58):

And how are you employed?

Linda Wicks (03:14:59):

Paulding County Sheriff's Office.

Speaker 8 (03:15:01):

And how long have you been so employed?

Linda Wicks (03:15:04):

20 years.

Speaker 8 (03:15:06):

And what is your current job assignment with the Paulding County Sheriff's Office?

Linda Wicks (03:15:10):

I'm a sergeant in criminal investigations.

Speaker 8 (03:15:13):

And how long have you been a sergeant in criminal investigations?

Linda Wicks (03:15:19):

Currently, three years.

Speaker 8 (03:15:24):

Are you a certified police officer here in the state of Georgia?

Linda Wicks (03:15:28):

Yes.

Speaker 8 (03:15:28):

Are you post certified?

Linda Wicks (03:15:30):

Yes.

Speaker 8 (03:15:31):

Did you have occasion to become involved in the case concerning Lacy Boles?

Linda Wicks (03:15:43):

Yes.

Speaker 8 (03:15:43):

How did you become involved in this case?

Linda Wicks (03:15:47):

I was notified, I believe it was December 30th, 2019 by Thomas Ogden that he was responding to a call.

Speaker 8 (03:16:03):

And did you become involved recently as the lead detective in this case?

Linda Wicks (03:16:12):

Yes.

Speaker 8 (03:16:13):

And when did that occur?

Linda Wicks (03:16:17):

I don't recall the exact date. When I became sergeant again.

Speaker 8 (03:16:28):

And are you a detective right now, officer?

Linda Wicks (03:16:31):

Sergeant. I mean sergeant?

Speaker 8 (03:16:35):

And as a sergeant, what are your duties?

Linda Wicks (03:16:40):

To oversee the detectives, assign reports to them, support.

Speaker 8 (03:16:48):

I show you what has previously been marked for identification as State's Exhibit number 180 and ask if you are familiar with that item?

Linda Wicks (03:17:05):

I am.

Speaker 8 (03:17:06):

And how are you familiar with that item?

Linda Wicks (03:17:10):

I believe this is the item that I got a search warrant for in 2025.

Speaker 8 (03:17:14):

And how did you go about getting a search warrant for that item?

Linda Wicks (03:17:25):

I filled out paperwork, affidavit and went to a judge to get a search warrant to get back in this phone.

Speaker 8 (03:17:30):

And so when you say to get back in this phone, what year was that you were trying to get back into this phone?

Linda Wicks (03:17:40):

I believe it was April 1st, 2025.

Speaker 8 (03:17:45):

And then what, if anything, did you do once you acquired this search warrant?

Linda Wicks (03:17:50):

So I came to the District Attorney's Office, took it out of evidence, and then took it to Sarah Wix. She's our technical person, and she put it on a program to download it.

Speaker 8 (03:18:06):

And once you gave this item to Sarah Wix, was that the last time you saw it until I handed it to you today?

Linda Wicks (03:18:13):

I believe so.

Speaker 8 (03:18:14):

And you said you had taken it out of evidence and you put it on some kind of system that could take information from it. Is that what you said? Or you gave it to Sarah?

Linda Wicks (03:18:41):

I gave it to Sarah.

Speaker 8 (03:18:42):

[inaudible 03:18:43].

Linda Wicks (03:18:43):

That's her job to do that.

Speaker 8 (03:18:44):

Okay. Did you watch her do anything with this phone once you gave it to her?

Linda Wicks (03:18:48):

No.

Speaker 8 (03:18:54):

She's with you.

Judge Dean Bucci (03:18:54):

Any cross examination?

Brian Steel (03:18:54):

No, sir.

Judge Dean Bucci (03:19:00):

Thank you so much, Ma'am. You can be excused.

Linda Wicks (03:19:03):

Thank you.

Judge Dean Bucci (03:19:03):

Do you have another witness?

Linda Wicks (03:19:03):

Do you want this back?

Jason Treadway (03:19:08):

You can just leave it there. [inaudible 03:19:08]. If it please the court, the state calls Sarah Wix.

Judge Dean Bucci (03:19:56):

Good morning. I'll swear you in. If you'll raise your right hand [inaudible 03:20:00] please. Do you swear or affirm the testimony you're about to give in the matter before the court will be the truth, the whole truth, and nothing but the truth, so help you God?

Sarah Wix (03:20:07):

I do.

Judge Dean Bucci (03:20:07):

Please have a seat.

Jason Treadway (03:20:11):

Good morning. If you could please introduce yourself to the jury.

Sarah Wix (03:20:14):

My name is Sarah Wix. I work with the Paulding County Sheriff's Office in the Technical Services Unit.

Jason Treadway (03:20:21):

Can you spell your first name? Is that a H on it?

Sarah Wix (03:20:24):

S-A-R-A-H.

Jason Treadway (03:20:26):

And Wix is a W-I-X?

Sarah Wix (03:20:29):

W-I-X.

Jason Treadway (03:20:30):

How long have you been employed with the Paulding County Sheriff's Office, please?

Sarah Wix (03:20:33):

I started in January of 2019.

Jason Treadway (03:20:37):

Can you tell the jury what area of law enforcement you started when you went there in 2019? What did you do?

Sarah Wix (03:20:43):

In 2019, I started as a Crimes Against Children secretary.

Jason Treadway (03:20:47):

And did you change at some point and work your way up to where you were now?

Sarah Wix (03:20:52):

I did. In October of 2021, I started in the Technical Services Unit. I got a promotion.

Jason Treadway (03:21:00):

What are your duties in the Technical Services Unit?

Sarah Wix (03:21:03):

So we receive electronics like computer scanning devices, tablets, cell phones, and we are responsible for extracting data off of those devices for evidentiary purposes.

Jason Treadway (03:21:18):

Can you give the jury an idea of your training that's allowed you to be able to do that, please?

Sarah Wix (03:21:26):

So I am a Cellebrite Certified Operator and Cellebrite Certified Physical Analyzer, and I have also been to the International Association of Computer Investigative Specialists and have my basic computer forensic examiner certification.

Jason Treadway (03:21:42):

And when you say Cellebrite, what is that? Just for people who don't know.

Sarah Wix (03:21:48):

So Cellebrite Certified Operator is basically certifying you to use Cellebrite, which is one of the tools that we use to get data off of the devices and also to view the data from the device.

Jason Treadway (03:22:02):

How many phones, just cellular phones, have you extracted in your career?

Sarah Wix (03:22:10):

We average about 75 to 150 cellular devices a year. So in 5 years, approximately 4 to 500 devices.

Jason Treadway (03:22:17):

Does anybody work with you to help you in that task or are you just the only analyst in the unit?

Sarah Wix (03:22:20):

Previously, it used to be Lieutenant Tyler Brown, and now, we have another analyst in the office.

Jason Treadway (03:22:31):

Have you ever testified in court before?

Sarah Wix (03:22:34):

I have.

Jason Treadway (03:22:34):

Have you ever been tendered as an expert in the area of cellular phone extraction in the state of Georgia?

Sarah Wix (03:22:40):

I have.

Jason Treadway (03:22:47):

I tender this witness as an expert in area of forensic cell phone extraction, data extraction.

Brian Steel (03:22:50):

I don't have an opposition, sir.

Judge Dean Bucci (03:22:51):

All right. Granted.

Jason Treadway (03:22:57):

Excuse me. I apologize. If you could pick up that exhibit that was in front of you that you asked about earlier about moving, do you see the exhibit number on it or red sticker for the record?

Sarah Wix (03:23:04):

State's Exhibit 180.

Jason Treadway (03:23:10):

180. So just for the record, if we can refer you now to State's Exhibit 180, do you recognize that device?

Sarah Wix (03:23:16):

I do.

Jason Treadway (03:23:21):

Can you tell the jury what it is and how you would recognize it?

Sarah Wix (03:23:25):

This is a iPhone that was in the... Belonging to Dan Akers. It was in the office in 2021 whenever I started in the Technical Services Unit.

Jason Treadway (03:23:40):

Do you know anything about your former colleague at one point, Tyler Brown, attempting to extract data from that device?

Sarah Wix (03:23:48):

I do.

Jason Treadway (03:23:49):

And can you tell the jury efforts that detective made, excuse me, to try to extract device from the Dan Akers cellphone?

Brian Steel (03:23:57):

I'll stipulate that you couldn't get into it, but it's hearsay [inaudible 03:24:02]. But I'll stipulate that's what the prosecution wants to do, just to move it along.

Jason Treadway (03:24:07):

If she watched him do it or participated in it, it's not hearsay. I won't get testimony elicited before the jury. SO I'm not interested in-

Judge Dean Bucci (03:24:16):

All right. You can ask her what she observed.

Jason Treadway (03:24:18):

What was done to the phone prior to your coming to take possession to try to get data off of it?

Sarah Wix (03:24:25):

So whenever the Technical Services Unit receives a device, we either plug it up to Graykey or Cellebrite Premium. Whenever this device was received, we only had Graykey in the Technical Services Unit. So the device was plugged into Graykey, and when Graykey is on a device, it does create a screen where you can see passcode attempts, things like that. So whenever I came into the Technical Services Unit in 2021, The screen was visible that there were multiple passcode attempts initiated on the device.

Jason Treadway (03:25:08):

At some point, did you become aware that there were going to be no more attempts by the Paulding County Sheriff's Office to break or brute force into the phone?

Sarah Wix (03:25:15):

I was made aware that the phone was being placed back into evidence.

Jason Treadway (03:25:20):

Is it fair to say that back into evidence, it's not being brute forced at that time, taken off the machine?

Sarah Wix (03:25:20):

Correct.

Jason Treadway (03:25:20):

And then at some point, did you try to take a fresh look at it and see if you could open the phone?

Sarah Wix (03:25:31):

Yes. Sergeant Linda Wicks did get a new search warrant for the device, and I suggested since we had already given Graykey a go, we had the capability to try Cellebrite Premium at that point and just plug it up to Cellebrite Premium and see if we could have success there.

Jason Treadway (03:25:50):

Does Cellebrite Premium use that same brute force type of technology to try to get in?

Sarah Wix (03:25:54):

It does.

Jason Treadway (03:25:56):

Did you undertake that testing or that extraction attempt in 2025? When did you do that?

Sarah Wix (03:26:05):

Can I look at my notes?

Jason Treadway (03:26:06):

If it refreshes your recollection on when you put it on the Cellebrite Premium, please do so.

Sarah Wix (03:26:10):

Yes, that was-

Jason Treadway (03:26:11):

Don't read it out loud. Just look at it and see if it refreshes your recollection.

Sarah Wix (03:26:11):

Yes. April-

Jason Treadway (03:26:11):

Don't read it out loud.

Sarah Wix (03:26:11):

Oh, sorry.

Jason Treadway (03:26:21):

Hold on a second. Has your memory or recollection been refreshed as to the date that you first tried to put it on Cellebrite Premium?

Sarah Wix (03:26:29):

Yes.

Jason Treadway (03:26:29):

Okay. Now, what date was that?

Sarah Wix (03:26:29):

It was April 2025.

Jason Treadway (03:26:30):

April '25. All right. Do you know how long it took the machine, the Cellebrite Premium, to successfully brute force into the phone?

Sarah Wix (03:26:38):

It took approximately 20 minutes.

Jason Treadway (03:26:41):

Okay. So do you know how long Graykey was trying to get in there?

Sarah Wix (03:26:44):

Graykey was attempting from 2019 to approximately 2023.

Jason Treadway (03:26:52):

So Graykey is attempting for almost four years, but were you able then to get in with Cellebrite Premium in 20 minutes?

Sarah Wix (03:27:02):

Correct.

Jason Treadway (03:27:04):

Okay. And these are two competitors, I guess? Graykey and then Cellebrite, just two software competitors?

Sarah Wix (03:27:09):

Yes, sir.

Jason Treadway (03:27:11):

Is it fair to say at all that the technology may have improved in those four years?

Sarah Wix (03:27:15):

Yes, sir.

Jason Treadway (03:27:18):

All right. So you were able to get in ultimately?

Sarah Wix (03:27:19):

Correct.

Jason Treadway (03:27:31):

Were you able to view text data on the extraction?

Sarah Wix (03:27:34):

I was.

Jason Treadway (03:27:34):

Were you able to view email data?

Sarah Wix (03:27:40):

Yes, sir.

Jason Treadway (03:27:43):

Okay. What about internet site visit data?

Sarah Wix (03:27:47):

Yes, sir.

Jason Treadway (03:27:48):

Were you able to access geolocation data?

Sarah Wix (03:27:51):

Yes, sir.

Jason Treadway (03:27:52):

What about if somebody went on the internet at Safari or something like that and tried to execute a search for a term, does the phone save those terms?

Sarah Wix (03:28:02):

It does. Yes, sir.

Jason Treadway (03:28:05):

Save some of them or all of them or how does that work with the archival of search terms?

Sarah Wix (03:28:11):

So that really depends on the device and the settings of the phone. It generally saves multiple versions of a search and browser history.

Jason Treadway (03:28:26):

When you did a... Explain to the jury please, and it seems like these phones are really kind of following us all the time. How does a phone record geolocation data?

Sarah Wix (03:28:37):

It will connect off of cell towers and if you're using MapQuest, it can connect through various different ways.

Jason Treadway (03:28:55):

Did this phone have a GPS built into it? Was it GPS capable?

Sarah Wix (03:28:58):

Yes.

Jason Treadway (03:28:59):

This phone of Dan Akers, Exhibit 180?

Sarah Wix (03:29:01):

Yes.

Jason Treadway (03:29:04):

If a user were accessing a GPS type of app, for example, a program like Waze or Google Maps, does that help you document GPS location?

Sarah Wix (03:29:15):

It does.

Jason Treadway (03:29:15):

All right. Did you have an opportunity to come into the knowledge of an address called 83 Braemill Court regarding your investigation of this case?

Sarah Wix (03:29:27):

I did.

Jason Treadway (03:29:27):

And did you have an opportunity to learn about a McDonald's near Hiram City Road in this case?

Sarah Wix (03:29:35):

I did.

Jason Treadway (03:29:35):

Did you find geolocation evidence on the phone, the device about that McDonald's?

Sarah Wix (03:29:38):

I did. The cell tower location placed him at McDonald's.

Jason Treadway (03:29:46):

Placed him, being the decedent in this case, Daniel Akers?

Sarah Wix (03:29:49):

Correct.

Jason Treadway (03:29:49):

So did you look at... I'm guessing you were made aware at some point of his date of death?

Sarah Wix (03:29:56):

Correct.

Jason Treadway (03:29:57):

Right? 12/22/19. Did you get that information?

Sarah Wix (03:29:59):

I did.

Jason Treadway (03:30:00):

And then did you seek to find out where he had been on that date?

Ms. Wix (03:30:03):

I did.

Mr. Treadaway (03:30:00):

And then did you seek to find out where he had been on that date?

Ms. Wix (03:30:04):

I did.

Mr. Treadaway (03:30:04):

Were you successful in doing that?

Ms. Wix (03:30:06):

Yes.

Mr. Treadaway (03:30:06):

Did you find multiple locations that the defendant might have been on that date or in fact was, not might have been, was?

Ms. Wix (03:30:12):

Yes, sir.

Mr. Treadaway (03:30:14):

Was McDonald's one of those locations?

Ms. Wix (03:30:16):

Yes, sir.

Mr. Treadaway (03:30:17):

And that was 83 Braemill Court, is that one of the locations?

Ms. Wix (03:30:21):

Yes, sir.

Mr. Treadaway (03:30:22):

Assuming, did you see 83 Braemill Court many times because that's where he lived?

Ms. Wix (03:30:27):

Correct.

Mr. Treadaway (03:30:28):

Was it consistent? When you see that many hits on a specific residence, would that be consistent with where somebody lives?

Ms. Wix (03:30:37):

Yes, where they spend quite a bit of time.

Mr. Treadaway (03:30:39):

Okay. I'm going to approach opposing counsel and show what I'll mark, for identification purposes only, as State's Exhibit 218, please. I'm sorry. Thank you. Did you have an opportunity to, you or your team, to map the distance between the McDonald's, a McDonald's near Hiram Sudie Road near the Chevron to 83 Braemill Court?

Ms. Wix (03:31:26):

We did.

Mr. Treadaway (03:31:26):

Do you have an idea of what the distance was between those two locations?

Ms. Wix (03:31:33):

It was approximately 1.5 miles.

Mr. Treadaway (03:31:38):

May I approach the witness, please?

Judge (03:31:40):

Yeah.

Mr. Treadaway (03:31:41):

Ma'am, let me show you please what I've marked for identification purposes only as State's Exhibit 218. See if you just recognize that. You just tell me what it is as briefly as you can without going into detail.

Ms. Wix (03:31:55):

Yes.

Mr. Treadaway (03:31:56):

Do you recognize that?

Ms. Wix (03:31:57):

I do.

Mr. Treadaway (03:31:58):

Is it a map?

Ms. Wix (03:31:59):

Yes.

Mr. Treadaway (03:32:00):

How do you recognize it?

Ms. Wix (03:32:02):

This was the route from McDonald's to 83 Braemill Court.

Mr. Treadaway (03:32:07):

Okay. Was it created as part of your investigation after taking data points or geolocation points on the [inaudible 03:32:17]?

Ms. Wix (03:32:15):

It was.

Mr. Treadaway (03:32:16):

Does it appear to be a fair and accurate depiction of the map coordinates of those two locations if you consider a McDonald's near Hiram Sudie Road and then a 83 Braemill Court location?

Ms. Wix (03:32:28):

Yes, sir. It does.

Mr. Treadaway (03:32:29):

Do you think there's elements of that map that make it somehow not accurate as far as the depiction of that area and that distance?

Ms. Wix (03:32:37):

It looks accurate.

Mr. Treadaway (03:32:39):

And please move the court respectfully to admit into evidence what's been previously marked for identification purposes only as State's Exhibit 218.

Attorney (03:32:48):

No opposition.

Mr. Treadaway (03:32:51):

Permission to publish please. [inaudible 03:32:53]. Thank you. So when you got data points or geolocation data points off the phone, were you able to create State's 218?

Ms. Wix (03:33:02):

Yes.

Mr. Treadaway (03:33:02):

Okay. I'll just show it. So can you tell the jury, obviously you have the golden arches here on... And is that Georgia 61?

Ms. Wix (03:33:19):

It is the intersection of 61 and Scoggins Road.

Mr. Treadaway (03:33:22):

Scoggins Road. And what is the horizontal blue line there? Do you know what road that is?

Ms. Wix (03:33:27):

Hiram Sudie Road.

Mr. Treadaway (03:33:30):

Hiram Sudie Road. And then come over here and you would take a right with that, what road is this, the vertical line?

Ms. Wix (03:33:36):

Davis Mill Road.

Mr. Treadaway (03:33:38):

And then the end or the beginning, either way to the end or the beginning there at 83 Braemill Court. Is that the decedent's residence?

Ms. Wix (03:33:47):

It is.

Mr. Treadaway (03:33:51):

How is it that you were able to say, if you can, how can you say to the jury, "Hey, I know somebody..." Let's just put it this way, "I know this phone was at McDonald's on a certain date." How do you know that?

Ms. Wix (03:34:06):

So the cell phone connected to a wireless network, which would have been McDonald's. Whenever we have our devices on us, we can have them scan for wireless networks and that is how it came up with the McDonald's location is because it scanned that network.

Mr. Treadaway (03:34:33):

Let me make sure I understand because I'm not really a tech guy. So if someone came within the confines of the wireless network that McDonald's was putting out, does your phone constantly seek to... Does somebody have to try to get on that network, like access it or does it happen automatically?

Ms. Wix (03:34:52):

Generally it happens automatically. You can remove that from your settings, but your device will try to seek other networks in case you need to connect to a wifi or things like that.

Mr. Treadaway (03:35:07):

Okay. Do you have any idea whether or not the user of the phone at McDonald's on 12/22/2019 made a purposeful attempt to connect to the wifi or was it automatic or can you tell?

Ms. Wix (03:35:19):

The Cellebrite report said that it was harvested, which means that it was just searching for networks.

Mr. Treadaway (03:35:26):

Automatic?

Ms. Wix (03:35:27):

Correct.

Mr. Treadaway (03:35:28):

In the background running.

Ms. Wix (03:35:29):

Mm-hmm.

Mr. Treadaway (03:35:29):

All right. Do you know what time that harvest occurred with that McDonald's wifi network?

Ms. Wix (03:35:40):

I believe it was approximately about 12:20.

Mr. Treadaway (03:35:45):

12:20 AM?

Ms. Wix (03:35:45):

Correct.

Mr. Treadaway (03:35:46):

On what day?

Ms. Wix (03:35:48):

December 22nd, if I recall correctly.

Mr. Treadaway (03:35:51):

Okay. 2019?

Ms. Wix (03:35:52):

Correct.

Mr. Treadaway (03:35:53):

All right. So you have... Is it fair then from what you found, do you have that phone accessing the McDonald's wifi, you said 12:20 on 12/22/2019?

Ms. Wix (03:36:02):

Correct.

Mr. Treadaway (03:36:07):

And then are you able to look at that harvest, I guess, or when it's trying to get on McDonald's wifi, and then find out where the phone goes from that point forward?

Ms. Wix (03:36:19):

Yes.

Mr. Treadaway (03:36:20):

Plotting those geolocation courses, is what's on the screen here State's 218, is it accurate to where the phone went at that time?

Ms. Wix (03:36:29):

The next connection was 83 Braemill Court that the phone connected to.

Mr. Treadaway (03:36:36):

So you have a connection to wifi at McDonald's and the next one was the decedent's residence?

Ms. Wix (03:36:42):

Correct.

Mr. Treadaway (03:36:43):

How do you know that?

Ms. Wix (03:36:45):

It connected to the network at the residence.

Mr. Treadaway (03:36:49):

Do you know when that was?

Ms. Wix (03:36:50):

May I look at my notes?

Mr. Treadaway (03:36:54):

If it would refresh your recollection, please do so. And then just look up when you've done that, don't say the answer. Has your record... Excuse me. Has your recollection been refreshed on when that phone or device may have attached to the 83 Braemill Court network?

Ms. Wix (03:37:29):

I don't have the specific time in my notes.

Mr. Treadaway (03:37:30):

Okay. Do you remember it being shortly after the McDonald's wifi? Do you remember? Was it a long time, later the next day? Do you remember?

Ms. Wix (03:37:36):

I believe it was approximately 12:40 when it connected to the network at 83 Braemill Court.

Mr. Treadaway (03:37:47):

12:40 AM?

Ms. Wix (03:37:48):

Correct.

Mr. Treadaway (03:37:49):

On that same day? Okay. Do you have specifics... I'm sorry. Do you have specific information as far as when the... I don't know how it works. When you get too far away from McDonald's, does it show, okay, you're no longer on this network or not?

Ms. Wix (03:38:04):

It generally just records the time that it was harvested, trying to connect.

Mr. Treadaway (03:38:10):

So we don't know when that connection was broken.

Ms. Wix (03:38:15):

Correct.

Mr. Treadaway (03:38:15):

Is that fair? But you do know approximately when the next connection was made?

Ms. Wix (03:38:19):

Correct.

Mr. Treadaway (03:38:24):

Okay. I understand. All right. I want to ask you, did you have an opportunity please to, I think I asked you, did you look at some emails that were found on the phone?

Ms. Wix (03:38:32):

I did.

Mr. Treadaway (03:38:35):

I'll show opposing counsel what I'll mark for identification purposes only as State's Exhibit 219. May I approach the witness, please?

Judge (03:39:15):

Yes, sir.

Mr. Treadaway (03:39:20):

I'm going to show you Ms. Wix, State's Exhibit 219. It's been marked for identification purposes only. See if you recognize that.

Ms. Wix (03:39:26):

Yes, sir.

Mr. Treadaway (03:39:27):

Can you just tell me what that is briefly without going into too much detail?

Ms. Wix (03:39:36):

This is an email.

Mr. Treadaway (03:39:39):

Okay. Is it an email from Mr. Akers' phone?

Ms. Wix (03:39:41):

It is, correct.

Mr. Treadaway (03:39:42):

Based on your knowledge or your understanding?

Ms. Wix (03:39:45):

Correct.

Mr. Treadaway (03:39:45):

Have you seen it before?

Ms. Wix (03:39:45):

Yes.

Mr. Treadaway (03:39:46):

How do you recognize it?

Ms. Wix (03:39:51):

Through looking, examining the emails.

Mr. Treadaway (03:39:54):

Through data extraction?

Ms. Wix (03:39:55):

Correct.

Mr. Treadaway (03:39:56):

Okay. Does it appear to be accurate to what you found as an extracted part of the email search on Mr. Akers' phone?

Ms. Wix (03:40:03):

It does.

Mr. Treadaway (03:40:04):

Do you think there's been any changes, material alterations or deletions that make State's 219 not representative and accurate to what you found on the phone?

Ms. Wix (03:40:13):

Doesn't appear so.

Mr. Treadaway (03:40:14):

Other than maybe being a copy or something?

Ms. Wix (03:40:16):

Correct. Yeah.

Mr. Treadaway (03:40:16):

And I'm guessing, I don't know, but are you looking at this extraction on your computer when you do it or is it papers?

Ms. Wix (03:40:23):

On the computer.

Mr. Treadaway (03:40:24):

Okay. So obviously 219 has been reduced to a paper, but other than that, is it accurate?

Ms. Wix (03:40:28):

Yes.

Mr. Treadaway (03:40:29):

Respectfully move the court to admit into evidence what's been previously marked for identification purposes only State's 219.

Attorney (03:40:35):

No objection, Your Honor.

Judge (03:40:37):

Admitted.

Mr. Treadaway (03:40:38):

Let me show that to you a little bit on the big screen and you can tell the jury what this is. So first of all, how would an email be preserved on a cell phone? Does it have to be like I'm using the phone to send the email or receive the email? How does that work?

Ms. Wix (03:40:56):

I mean, once the email has been sent, then it is preserved on the device.

Mr. Treadaway (03:41:02):

Okay. So any email... Are all emails saved or archived that come through or leave the device?

Ms. Wix (03:41:08):

Correct. Unless they're erased, deleted off the device.

Mr. Treadaway (03:41:12):

Okay. And even then, is it possible sometimes for you to... Somebody like you can-

Ms. Wix (03:41:15):

It is.

Mr. Treadaway (03:41:15):

... I guess recover deleted stuff?

Ms. Wix (03:41:18):

Correct.

Mr. Treadaway (03:41:20):

Let me show you this, State's 219. If I can just show you this email and ask you if you recognize it and saw it in your extraction. All right. Did you see this email as coming from Mr. Akers' phone?

Ms. Wix (03:41:53):

I did, correct.

Mr. Treadaway (03:41:55):

And over here it says timestamp 12/20/ 2019, four o'clock and 10 seconds PM Eastern. Do you see that?

Ms. Wix (03:42:05):

I do.

Mr. Treadaway (03:42:06):

What does that mean?

Ms. Wix (03:42:08):

That would be when the email was received.

Mr. Treadaway (03:42:12):

Email received.

Ms. Wix (03:42:12):

On the device.

Mr. Treadaway (03:42:14):

On the device, you said?

Ms. Wix (03:42:15):

Correct.

Mr. Treadaway (03:42:16):

And then this underneath akers.dan83, numbers 83, @gmail.com, what would that be?

Ms. Wix (03:42:22):

That would be the receiving email.

Mr. Treadaway (03:42:26):

And if you'll just read the subject line of that email you found.

Ms. Wix (03:42:32):

Vision Center eye exam confirmation for Daniel Akers, Monday, December 23rd, 2019, 5:30 PM.

Mr. Treadaway (03:42:42):

And then it goes on to say, "Thank you for booking an eye exam at the Vision Center by Walmart."

Ms. Wix (03:42:48):

Correct.

Mr. Treadaway (03:42:48):

Do you see that?

Ms. Wix (03:42:49):

Yes, sir.

Mr. Treadaway (03:42:50):

So this email seems to purport to show an eye exam appointment at 12:23 Monday.

Ms. Wix (03:42:57):

Correct.

Mr. Treadaway (03:42:58):

And you know Mr. Akers, he didn't make that. You know that?

Ms. Wix (03:43:01):

Correct.

Judge (03:43:01):

[inaudible 03:43:06] Mr. Treadaway, is now a good time?

Mr. Treadaway (03:43:06):

Yes, sir. I have a rather lengthy part on the segue.

Judge (03:43:11):

Okay. All right. So why don't we break like we did yesterday and come back at 1:15? Thank you.

Speaker 10 (03:43:17):

[inaudible 04:59:58] consent.

Judge Dean C. Bucci (04:59:59):

Yes, all right. Can we get them, please, Trovilla?

Trovilla (05:00:00):

Yes, sir. Waiting for warrant, sir.

Judge Dean C. Bucci (05:01:54):

Okay.

Speaker 11 (05:01:54):

[Inaudible 05:00:45]

Judge Dean C. Bucci (05:02:28):

Welcome back everybody. We're going to pick up where we left off.

Speaker 10 (05:02:38):

I'll continue, Your Honor.

Judge Dean C. Bucci (05:02:38):

Yes, sir.

Speaker 10 (05:02:39):

Your Honor, the record reflect, please, that I am showing opposing counsel what I'll mark for identification purposes only as State's Exhibit 220. [inaudible 05:02:42] thank you. May I approach the witness, please?

Judge Dean C. Bucci (05:03:17):

Yes, sir.

Speaker 10 (05:03:17):

Let me show you what I've marked as State's Exhibit 220, and just ask if you recognize that and talk through it if you need to.

Ms. Bertrand (05:03:25):

This is the Cellebrite extraction report.

Speaker 10 (05:03:25):

So you recognize that?

Ms. Bertrand (05:03:31):

Yes, sir.

Speaker 10 (05:03:32):

And how do you recognize it?

Ms. Bertrand (05:03:33):

This is the phone we extracted, excuse me, from Mr. Akers.

Speaker 10 (05:03:39):

Okay. So, produced from a written form?

Ms. Bertrand (05:03:39):

Correct.

Speaker 10 (05:03:43):

Does it appear to be in the same or similar condition as to when you downloaded or did the data extraction from the phone?

Ms. Bertrand (05:03:49):

Yes, sir.

Speaker 10 (05:03:51):

If you'll just look at it, do you think there's been any changes, additions, alterations that make it somehow not accurate as to what you extracted from the phone? Although I know you may have looked at it on the screen, but as far as a written form, is that accurate?

Ms. Bertrand (05:04:02):

It is. Yes, sir.

Speaker 10 (05:04:05):

The court respectfully to admit into evidence what's been previously marked for identification purposes on this State's Exhibit 220.

Mr. Steel (05:04:12):

I will not have an objection to some, but I was just told that it's not the entire report. It's certain excise. So as we go along, I'll do it quick and I'll let the court know if I have an objection to something. Right now, though, I don't have any objection to any foundation. It's just going to be the content.

Judge Dean C. Bucci (05:04:30):

All right. So what's been tendered at this point you don't have an objection to, but do you think more is coming?

Mr. Steel (05:04:35):

No, there may be some that's been tendered. I haven't seen it because it's portions of it. I don't know what's included and what's excluded.

Speaker 10 (05:04:43):

Let me try to clarify with the witness if I may, Your Honor. I tendered the entire report. Is that right what 220 is?

Ms. Bertrand (05:04:52):

Correct.

Speaker 10 (05:04:52):

Yeah. My understanding is that's the entire report. And then what I communicated to Mr. Steel, I will highlight certain portions of the entire report.

Judge Dean C. Bucci (05:04:59):

All right.

Speaker 10 (05:05:00):

My knowledge is that's the entire report, 220.

Judge Dean C. Bucci (05:05:02):

All right. Let's let Mr. Steel see it and make sure he's in a position where he can...

Speaker 10 (05:05:34):

Yes, sir.

Judge Dean C. Bucci (05:05:34):

... interpose an objection if he has one.

Mr. Steel (05:05:34):

[Inaudible 05:05:35]

Speaker 10 (05:05:34):

Right now, sir.

Mr. Steel (05:05:34):

Yes. I don't have a copy.

Speaker 10 (05:05:37):

This is the entire thing.

Mr. Steel (05:05:47):

[Inaudible 05:05:47] we ask questions, do you want this answered?

Speaker 10 (05:05:54):

Your Honor, may I just have one moment?

Judge Dean C. Bucci (05:05:55):

Sure.

Mr. Steel (05:06:42):

Okay.

Speaker 11 (05:07:19):

Yes, sir.

Mr. Steel (05:07:19):

This is the top question [inaudible 05:07:22]

Speaker 11 (05:07:19):

Yes, sir.

Speaker 10 (05:07:19):

I'll look to answer your question.

Mr. Steel (05:07:19):

Okay. Mark these as A, B, C, D [inaudible 05:07:28] thank you. So what's been... Do you still have 220?

Speaker 10 (05:07:34):

May I approach, serving 220? While you're looking at that, may I take 220?

Judge Dean C. Bucci (05:07:38):

Sure.

Speaker 10 (05:07:39):

Thank you. So 220, did you say is the entire report that you got contains everything? State's 220?

Ms. Bertrand (05:08:04):

This contains web history.

Speaker 10 (05:08:08):

Search history.

Ms. Bertrand (05:08:08):

Correct.

Speaker 10 (05:08:09):

Is that the entire search history?

Ms. Bertrand (05:08:09):

It is.

Speaker 10 (05:08:14):

What is State's 220? How many pages is it? Can you tell the jury?

Ms. Bertrand (05:08:19):

280 pages.

Speaker 10 (05:08:21):

So did you recover or identify or extract or isolate 280 some odd pages of search history from the Daniel Akers phone?

Ms. Bertrand (05:08:32):

I did, correct.

Speaker 10 (05:08:33):

All right. Let me show you what I'll mark for identification purposes only as 220A. I'll show opposing counsel that.

Speaker 12 (05:08:53):

Oh, thank you.

Speaker 10 (05:08:55):

Thank you.

Mr. Steel (05:08:55):

You Honor, I have no objection.

Judge Dean C. Bucci (05:08:57):

All right. And that's to 220?

Speaker 10 (05:09:01):

220, and then if I may show you 220A.

Judge Dean C. Bucci (05:09:05):

Okay. So 220 is admitted.

Mr. Steel (05:09:08):

And if it helps, I'm not going to object to anything. So if you want to put it all in at one time, whatever you want, there'll be no objection.

Judge Dean C. Bucci (05:09:16):

All right. So I've got 220, that's admitted.

Speaker 10 (05:09:20):

All right. Just for the record, I'll call, since this is 220A, if I may approach the witness and just show 220A, for example, that's just one paper. Let me show you that and see if you recognize that.

Ms. Bertrand (05:09:37):

I do.

Speaker 10 (05:09:38):

Is that part of what's contained in 220?

Ms. Bertrand (05:09:39):

It is.

Speaker 10 (05:09:39):

Is it just something in 220?

Ms. Bertrand (05:09:42):

It is, that's correct.

Speaker 10 (05:09:44):

220 has been admitted in evidence. So do you recognize 220A?

Ms. Bertrand (05:09:46):

I do.

Speaker 10 (05:09:49):

Is it a search term or a search, I guess, a search input that you recovered from?

Ms. Bertrand (05:09:58):

It is.

Speaker 10 (05:09:58):

We can publish that. And just read the highlighted portion, please. And these are my highlights, not yours. Is that fair?

Ms. Bertrand (05:10:12):

Correct.

Speaker 10 (05:10:12):

All right. You didn't highlight stuff?

Ms. Bertrand (05:10:14):

Correct.

Speaker 10 (05:10:14):

Okay.

Ms. Bertrand (05:10:15):

And it says it's a Safari search for Paulding County Football Registration.

Speaker 10 (05:10:21):

Okay. Do you have a date on this one?

Ms. Bertrand (05:10:33):

I do not see a date.

Speaker 10 (05:10:33):

Okay. Sometimes do you see a date on searches and sometimes do you not see a date?

Ms. Bertrand (05:10:34):

Correct.

Speaker 10 (05:10:34):

Can you tell the jury why you might not see a date?

Ms. Bertrand (05:10:37):

So, when a device does have a passcode on it, there is a lot of data that is encrypted. And sometimes, especially with the phone sitting for so long, some of that data was not able to decrypt so we could view it.

Speaker 10 (05:10:53):

Okay. So it says... Can we have a little bit less light, Deputy? Can we have a little bit less light? It says Paulding County Football Registration?

Ms. Bertrand (05:11:04):

Correct.

Speaker 10 (05:11:05):

Okay. And when it says Safari, is that the app or item that was used to access or do the web search?

Ms. Bertrand (05:11:12):

Correct.

Speaker 10 (05:11:14):

Okay. And I'll go to what I'll mark as 220B, like bravo, please. And it's in evidence, so I'll just see if you recognize it when I publish it, okay? Do you see this as a... I'm sorry. Did you need to see them every time?

Mr. Steel (05:11:31):

No, I'm okay.

Speaker 10 (05:11:33):

Do you recognize what I've highlighted? These are my highlights, but do you recognize what I've highlighted on 220B, like bravo?

Ms. Bertrand (05:11:40):

I do.

Speaker 10 (05:11:40):

Can you read that?

Ms. Bertrand (05:11:42):

How to handle your wife's mental health.

Speaker 10 (05:11:46):

This is from Mr. Akers phone?

Ms. Bertrand (05:11:48):

Correct.

Speaker 10 (05:11:48):

Again, do you see a date associated with this one specifically?

Ms. Bertrand (05:11:52):

I do not.

Speaker 10 (05:11:53):

But over here, what does this column mean? All these numbers. Is that sequential search numbers?

Mr. Steel (05:12:02):

Objection, leading.

Speaker 10 (05:12:03):

Does Cellebrite add these numbers or do you? Do you know the origin of them?

Ms. Bertrand (05:12:09):

That would be numbers associated with what Cellebrite, just sequential.

Speaker 10 (05:12:14):

So is there any... These are from Cellebrite on?

Ms. Bertrand (05:12:21):

Correct.

Speaker 10 (05:12:21):

Okay. And 220C.

Speaker 12 (05:12:24):

C [Inaudible 05:12:28]

Speaker 10 (05:12:28):

Let me show you this, please. This is two pages. I'll ask you to just take a look at page one of 220C. Do you recognize this search that was conducted?

Ms. Bertrand (05:12:40):

I do.

Speaker 10 (05:12:42):

Does it have a date associated with it?

Ms. Bertrand (05:12:44):

It does.

Speaker 10 (05:12:45):

Okay. So on this one, I know you said something about encryption or something, but were you able to isolate or was the program able to actually tell you as the examiner when this search was conducted?

Ms. Bertrand (05:12:58):

It was.

Speaker 10 (05:13:00):

When was that conducted, this first search here?

Ms. Bertrand (05:13:02):

November 24th, 2019.

Speaker 10 (05:13:07):

So, is it accurate that a user may have conducted a search on Hiram Wrestling Association on that date or on about that date?

Ms. Bertrand (05:13:16):

It is.

Speaker 10 (05:13:16):

On that device?

Ms. Bertrand (05:13:18):

Correct.

Speaker 10 (05:13:19):

Let me show you 220D, like delta. There's two highlights here. And again, did you highlight any of this?

Ms. Bertrand (05:13:43):

I did not.

Speaker 10 (05:13:43):

These are my highlights.

Ms. Bertrand (05:13:44):

Correct.

Speaker 10 (05:13:44):

So the first one in yellow, what date was that?

Ms. Bertrand (05:13:48):

December 6th, 2019.

Speaker 10 (05:13:51):

And you can read that.

Ms. Bertrand (05:13:53):

"Why is my wife tricking me to look bad?"

Speaker 10 (05:13:57):

And December 5th, you said 26. I can't read six.

Investigator Burke (05:14:00):

Okay.

Speaker 10 (05:14:01):

And go up, please, Investigator Burke, to the green. This is a different topic. What date do you see here?

Ms. Bertrand (05:14:08):

December 5th, 2019.

Speaker 10 (05:14:09):

Can you please read that to the jury?

Ms. Bertrand (05:14:11):

"When to leave a marriage with kids."

Speaker 10 (05:14:15):

And then there's several that go on from there. Message 10:56, 10:57, et cetera, all the way down to the end of the page. Are those independent, different searches? Do you know?

Ms. Bertrand (05:14:26):

So there's hundreds of thousands of different databases in a device and a lot of those like the knowledgeC that is the browser saving to a database. So it's not necessarily multiple searches on the device.

Speaker 10 (05:14:48):

Okay. But was that search inputted though at least once on 12/5/2019?

Ms. Bertrand (05:14:54):

It was. Okay.

Speaker 10 (05:14:55):

All right, thank you. Let me move on to 220E, like echo [inaudible 05:15:04]

Speaker 13 (05:15:00):

220E like echo. I'll show you this, please. So on the yellow here, the first one, what date is that? Do you see the date there?

Ms. Wiggs (05:15:30):

December 7th, 2019.

Speaker 13 (05:15:33):

And what was searched there on that device?

Ms. Wiggs (05:15:36):

Dear God, I need your help. I need strength.

Speaker 13 (05:15:40):

Okay. We see that some more times, but did you say that's not necessarily multiple searches?

Ms. Wiggs (05:15:45):

Correct.

Speaker 13 (05:15:46):

Okay. If you can go onto the lower part, sir. You see some green there-

Ms. Wiggs (05:15:50):

Yes.

Speaker 13 (05:15:50):

... 2/7/2019. What does that say?

Ms. Wiggs (05:15:57):

What's a cypress tree look like?

Speaker 13 (05:16:00):

Okay. And let me see if I can... What was that on 12/7 also?

Ms. Wiggs (05:16:07):

Correct.

Speaker 13 (05:16:08):

Is there number page two? If I can go to page three of 220E like echo, please, and continue and ask you about a search here. See if it came from your extraction. Do you see a search here, 12/7 of 2019?

Ms. Wiggs (05:16:35):

I do.

Speaker 13 (05:16:36):

What does that say?

Ms. Wiggs (05:16:38):

What should I do if my wife keeps lying to me?

Speaker 13 (05:16:41):

All right. And I'll go to State's 220F, like foxtrot. Do you see some searches there you discovered from your extraction?

Ms. Wiggs (05:17:07):

I do.

Speaker 13 (05:17:08):

Do you see a lot of searches here? If you can go up a little bit, Investigator. You see a lot of searches here about a Cadillac?

Ms. Wiggs (05:17:16):

Yes.

Speaker 13 (05:17:17):

Error code on a Cadillac and a Dallas tag on 12/7/2019?

Ms. Wiggs (05:17:24):

Yes.

Speaker 13 (05:17:25):

Were you made aware at any time in the investigation that this decedent had just bought a car?

Ms. Wiggs (05:17:30):

I did not.

Speaker 13 (05:17:56):

Okay. And if I could show you what's been marked for the identification purposes only and already admitted into evidence 220G, like George. You see a search there 12/8 of '19, 2019. You see that?

Ms. Wiggs (05:18:13):

Yes, sir.

Speaker 13 (05:18:14):

What's that say there? 12/8 of '19, what's that say?

Ms. Wiggs (05:18:18):

Gift ideas for wife.

Speaker 13 (05:18:20):

‍

And on down 12/8/2019, a little bit lower there, or subsequent search, what's that say, that line there?

Ms. Wiggs (05:18:27):

Christmas trees for sale near me.

Speaker 13 (05:18:32):

And excuse me, December 8th of 2019, what does that say there?

Ms. Wiggs (05:18:35):

Blue nailer Christmas tree.

Speaker 13 (05:18:41):

And are you confident these searches were done from that device at that time, those dates?

Ms. Wiggs (05:18:45):

Yes, sir.

Speaker 13 (05:19:00):

You see here on this one, a little bit lower on the search list, Christmas tree farm-

Ms. Wiggs (05:19:07):

Yes.

Speaker 13 (05:19:07):

... on 12/8/19 and local Christmas tree sales. Do you see that?

Ms. Wiggs (05:19:12):

Yes, sir.

Speaker 13 (05:19:14):

Is it accurate that these types of searches were being done around those times on this device?

Ms. Wiggs (05:19:19):

Yes, sir.

Speaker 13 (05:19:22):

Were you ever advised of the date of death of the decedent in this investigation being 12/22/19?

Ms. Wiggs (05:19:28):

Yes.

Speaker 13 (05:19:29):

Okay. Right around Christmas?

Ms. Wiggs (05:19:30):

Correct.

Speaker 13 (05:19:30):

Okay. If I could go to page three of 220G like George, see if I can ask you about another search here. And this date is also still on 12/8 of 2019, user searching local Christmas tree farms and stands. Do you see that or sales?

Ms. Wiggs (05:19:58):

Yes, sir.

Speaker 13 (05:20:12):

All right. I can show you, if I can draw your attention please to 220H, like hotel. These are some searches that you may be familiar with from December 12th of 2019, December 12th. A few days later, "Can your car pass admissions?" You see that? December 12th?

Ms. Wiggs (05:20:34):

Yes, sir.

Speaker 13 (05:20:34):

Is there anything else on there toward the bottom, Investigator?

Investigator Burke (05:20:38):

Yeah.

Speaker 13 (05:20:39):

So can your car pass admissions with a trouble code, but no check engine light, things like that. Do you see that?

Ms. Wiggs (05:20:45):

Yes, sir.

Speaker 13 (05:20:46):

Is that accurate to what you found on December 12th?

Ms. Wiggs (05:20:49):

It is.

Speaker 13 (05:20:50):

As far as a user search using Safari? Yes. I'm sorry, go ahead.

Ms. Wiggs (05:20:54):

Yes, sir.

Speaker 13 (05:20:55):

And then here's another little device that may have been used, Knowledge C. What is that? Do you know?

Ms. Wiggs (05:21:02):

That is one of the databases inside the phone where data is stored, and it stores things like web history and when you lock or unlock your device, things like that.

Speaker 13 (05:21:23):

Okay. And 220I, like India, a search of 12/12 of '19. If you'll take a look at that, 12/12 of '19, do you see those searches here?

Ms. Wiggs (05:21:47):

Yes, sir.

Speaker 13 (05:21:49):

Do you see where it says, "If you are a construction worker and have to work for the airport, do you get badged?" Do you see that?

Ms. Wiggs (05:21:57):

Yes, sir.

Speaker 13 (05:21:58):

12/12/19, working at the airport?

Ms. Wiggs (05:22:02):

Yes.

Speaker 13 (05:22:03):

Did it ever get brought to your attention as part of your investigation or your involvement in the case that this decedent may have been transitioning to a new job at the airport-

Ms. Wiggs (05:22:13):

No, sir.

Speaker 13 (05:22:13):

... beyond your involvement?

Ms. Wiggs (05:22:13):

Correct.

Speaker 13 (05:22:21):

And 220J like Juliet, also on 12/12. If you'll look at those, do you believe these are accurate searches to what you found on the device toward the end here, 12/12 of '19. In Georgia, how many days do you have to register a car? You see that?

Ms. Wiggs (05:22:48):

Yes, sir.

Speaker 13 (05:22:49):

How many days... I'm sorry, Paulding County Tax Office, you remember some other searches I asked you about that might be consistent with buying a new car, having just bought a new car?

Ms. Wiggs (05:22:58):

Yes, sir.

Speaker 13 (05:23:00):

Is that accurate to what was found on the device?

Ms. Wiggs (05:23:02):

It is.

Speaker 13 (05:23:15):

220K like kilo, I can draw your attention to these and see if you remember these searches being discovered as part of your extraction on or about... Searches being made on or about December 13th, 2019. See some messages, "Can I get a social security card in the same day?" And then if you can show Investigator Burke kind of goes along those lines all through that time period. Do you see that?

Ms. Wiggs (05:23:46):

Yes, sir.

Speaker 13 (05:23:47):

Does that accurately depict what the user was searching on that day?

Ms. Wiggs (05:23:51):

It does.

Speaker 13 (05:23:52):

And the next page, sir, continue on to page two of 220 kilo, you see things like another search, 12/13/19, baby woke up with swollen eye. Do you see that?

Ms. Wiggs (05:24:07):

Yes, sir.

Speaker 13 (05:24:08):

That was again with that knowledge C base, not knowledge C database?

Ms. Wiggs (05:24:13):

Correct.

Speaker 13 (05:24:14):

And is there anything on page three, Investigator?

Investigator Burke (05:24:20):

No page three.

Speaker 13 (05:24:20):

No page three? So I'll move on to 220L like Lima. Show you this. This is a one-page exhibit to 220L like Lima from 12/14/2019. Do you see that?

Ms. Wiggs (05:24:48):

Yes, sir.

Speaker 13 (05:24:49):

Do you think that's accurate for what you discovered from your extraction?

Ms. Wiggs (05:24:52):

Yes, sir.

Speaker 13 (05:24:53):

And what was the user searching here, 12/14/2019?

Ms. Wiggs (05:24:57):

Lights of life.

Speaker 13 (05:25:01):

Were you provided any information that this was a person who had children, young kids?

Ms. Wiggs (05:25:06):

Yes, sir.

Speaker 13 (05:25:08):

Okay. Lights of life, like a Christmas thing or some extraction?

Ms. Wiggs (05:25:11):

I believe so.

Speaker 13 (05:25:16):

And 220M like Mary, is it fair while I prepare this, when I ask you this, is it important to you or... So I'll ask it like this. Is it possible to kind of get a glimpse into a person's life habits or lifestyle, what they're doing on specific days? Is it helpful to you to look at these searches?

Ms. Wiggs (05:25:42):

It can be.

Speaker 13 (05:25:44):

Is it helpful to you to see people's state of mind using searches? Is that sometimes helpful to you or investigators?

Ms. Wiggs (05:25:52):

It can give indication of their habits and things like that.

Speaker 13 (05:26:15):

Okay. And I'll show you 220. Finally, I'll show you 220 [inaudible 05:26:23] Mary. 12/20 of 2019, you can show me... You can tell the jury if you think this is representative and accurate of what you found on the data extraction. 12/20/2019, looks like about 5:00 PM or so.

Ms. Wiggs (05:26:47):

It is.

Speaker 13 (05:26:49):

4:59 PM. And what was the user search in there? either maybe several searches or maybe several returns on the search. What was that search?

Ms. Wiggs (05:26:57):

Walmart Eye Center, Hiram, Georgia.

Speaker 13 (05:27:02):

On 12/20?

Ms. Wiggs (05:27:03):

Correct.

Speaker 13 (05:27:03):

Okay. I want to go back to Exhibit 220 itself. First of all, do you agree that 220A alpha through M Mary is all from 220?

Ms. Wiggs (05:27:24):

Correct.

Speaker 13 (05:27:24):

And you said 220 is how many pages of search terms?

Ms. Wiggs (05:27:31):

280.

Speaker 13 (05:27:34):

Okay, 280 pages?

Ms. Wiggs (05:27:36):

Correct.

Speaker 13 (05:27:37):

Do you remember that before the trial began, I asked you to isolate certain search terms that may have been conducted?

Ms. Wiggs (05:27:46):

I do.

Speaker 13 (05:27:46):

Did you do that?

Ms. Wiggs (05:27:48):

I did.

Speaker 13 (05:27:49):

With your software, your training, your knowledge, your experience, do you have the ability to take something like 280 and pinpoint in on certain phrases or terms that were searched?

Ms. Wiggs (05:27:59):

Yes, there is a search bar within each location that we're looking where we can search specific terms.

Speaker 13 (05:28:11):

Did you search for the term suicide?

Ms. Wiggs (05:28:13):

I did.

Speaker 13 (05:28:14):

How many times did you find it?

Ms. Wiggs (05:28:16):

Zero.

Speaker 13 (05:28:19):

Did you search for the term life insurance?

Ms. Wiggs (05:28:22):

I did.

Speaker 13 (05:28:24):

Did you find that term in all those searches?

Ms. Wiggs (05:28:26):

I did not.

Speaker 13 (05:28:28):

Did you search for the term gunshot?

Ms. Wiggs (05:28:30):

I did.

Speaker 13 (05:28:32):

Did you find search terms for that?

Ms. Wiggs (05:28:35):

No.

Speaker 13 (05:28:40):

And then I think you told me prior to trial that you had even gone a little bit far outside of those core terms and tried to find anything kind of similar to that. Can you explain to the jury what you did there?

Ms. Wiggs (05:28:51):

Correct. So just any terms that would indicate suicidal thoughts or methods were searched with certain terms.

Speaker 13 (05:29:03):

And what were the results?

Ms. Wiggs (05:29:03):

Zero.

Speaker 13 (05:29:07):

All right. Did you have an opportunity... We've gone through email. We've gone through now some search terms. We've gone through GPS data points. Did you have an opportunity to search for any type of audio recordings?

Ms. Wiggs (05:29:22):

Yes.

Speaker 13 (05:29:22):

Were you able to find any kind of audio recordings from the voice memo recorder or the device that would be on that phone you looked at?

Ms. Wiggs (05:29:32):

There was a voice memo on the phone.

Speaker 13 (05:29:38):

Okay. I can show opposing counsel what's been previously marked for identification purposes only as State's Exhibit 221. May I approach opposing counsel, please?

Judge (05:30:15):

I'm sorry. The witness, that'd be fine.

Speaker 13 (05:30:19):

May I please show you what's been marked for identification purposes only as State's Exhibit 221?

Ms. Wiggs (05:30:24):

Yes.

Speaker 13 (05:30:24):

Do you recognize that?

Ms. Wiggs (05:30:26):

I do.

Speaker 13 (05:30:27):

Can you tell just briefly, obviously, it's a little USB, you know what's on it?

Ms. Wiggs (05:30:32):

Correct.

Speaker 13 (05:30:32):

Briefly, what is that?

Ms. Wiggs (05:30:34):

It is a voice memo from Mr. Akers' device.

Speaker 13 (05:30:39):

Did you have an opportunity to listen to it prior to today as you sit there on the witness stand?

Ms. Wiggs (05:30:43):

I did.

Speaker 13 (05:30:46):

Having heard the recording on the little device, the thumb drive, do you believe it's fair and accurate to what you extracted and removed from the Daniel Akers' device?

Ms. Wiggs (05:30:55):

Yes.

Speaker 13 (05:30:55):

State's 180, I think it is?

Ms. Wiggs (05:30:55):

Yes.

Speaker 13 (05:30:59):

Do you believe there's been any changes, alterations, duplications, modifications, anything to make that State's 221 not accurate to what you actually extracted as a voice memo?

Ms. Wiggs (05:31:10):

Yeah, it should be accurate.

Speaker 13 (05:31:12):

Move the Court respectfully to admit into evidence what's been previously marked for identification purposes only as State's exhibit 221.

Speaker 14 (05:31:19):

Same objection, 403.

Judge (05:31:26):

Let me ask. This was a pretrial ruling?

Speaker 13 (05:31:28):

Yes, Your Honor. And the state followed Your Honor's pretrial ruling to make appropriate redactions.

Judge (05:31:36):

All right. It's admitted.

Speaker 13 (05:31:38):

Thank you. Permission to publish?

Judge (05:31:40):

Yes.

Speaker 13 (05:31:41):

And let me just ask you, Ms. Wiggs, so I just know of the little thing that says voice memo. I'm not too tech-savvy. Where did you find this from the phone? Where was this recording on there?

Ms. Wiggs (05:31:54):

It was in the audio portion of Cellebrite labeled as a voice memo. Voice memo is an app on your phone that you can click and record voice memos.

Speaker 13 (05:32:07):

Do you know if this is something that was saved by the user?

Ms. Wiggs (05:32:12):

I'm sorry?

Speaker 13 (05:32:13):

I'm sorry. Do you know if this is something that was saved by the user, somebody saved this memo, this little voice recording?

Ms. Wiggs (05:32:20):

It was recorded on the device.

Speaker 13 (05:32:22):

Okay. Did you have any indication that it had been deleted, but you were able to find it through deletion or was it still just there?

Ms. Wiggs (05:32:29):

It was just there.

Speaker 13 (05:32:32):

Okay. Do you have a date when the recording would've been created, please?

Ms. Wiggs (05:32:37):

May I refer to my notes?

Speaker 13 (05:32:39):

If it would help you refresh your recollection, please. And I'm asking specifically, did you get information from the software when the recording on State's 221 was created?

Ms. Wiggs (05:32:47):

Yes. Cellebrite had-

Speaker 13 (05:32:47):

Hold on a second.

Ms. Wiggs (05:32:47):

Okay.

Speaker 13 (05:32:51):

Has your recollection been refreshed on when it was created?

Ms. Wiggs (05:32:54):

Yes.

Speaker 13 (05:32:54):

And when was that, please?

Ms. Wiggs (05:32:56):

December 14th, 2019.

Speaker 13 (05:32:59):

Permission to publish, please?

Judge (05:33:01):

Yes, sir.

Speaker 13 (05:33:02):

Thank you. Thank you. Give me one second. Just have the record reflect. It looks like State's 221. The audio stopped at about maybe 12 seconds or something. I have to stop. Are you good over there? No?

Judge (05:34:01):

Worst case scenario, just move it to the podium, and put it underneath that.

Speaker 15 (05:34:01):

It should be good.

Judge (05:34:01):

You're good now?

Speaker 15 (05:34:01):

[inaudible 05:36:06].

Audio: Lacy (05:36:32):

Are you recording on your phone, monster? You should be sure you [inaudible 05:36:36] monster. Monster.

Audio: Speaker 6 (05:36:39):

I'm a monster.

Audio: Lacy (05:36:40):

Yeah. I don't think is going to take everything in court. I don't care about your recording. I should take everything.

Audio: Speaker 6 (05:36:46):

I probably don't.

Audio: Lacy (05:36:51):

No, it's not possible. It is. Watch me.

Audio: Speaker 6 (05:37:29):

[inaudible 05:37:30] How am I monster, Lacy?

Audio: Gage (05:37:30):

[inaudible 05:37:30].

Audio: Speaker 6 (05:37:30):

No? [inaudible 05:37:30].

Audio: Gage (05:37:30):

[inaudible 05:37:30].

Audio: Speaker 6 (05:37:30):

You got it. You got it.

Audio: Gage (05:37:30):

Daddy.

Audio: Speaker 6 (05:37:30):

You got it.

Audio: Gage (05:37:30):

Daddy.

Audio: Speaker 6 (05:37:30):

You got it. Lacy, you got it. You got it.

Audio: Gage (05:37:30):

Dad, I did it. Dad, I'm going to save it. Daddy.

Audio: Speaker 6 (05:38:05):

[inaudible 05:37:58] Who the hell's been up all night? Who's been up all night? Who stayed up all night, liar? Gage, was I up when you got up?

Audio: Gage (05:38:13):

Yeah.

Audio: Speaker 6 (05:38:16):

Oh, you didn't wake me up?

Audio: Lacy (05:38:23):

Monster.

Audio: Gage (05:38:23):

Yes, I didn't wake you. I didn't wake you up.

Audio: Speaker 6 (05:38:24):

You're the monster. You're a liar.

Audio: Gage (05:38:24):

[inaudible 05:38:26] break the window. This will save it.

Audio: Speaker 6 (05:38:24):

I'm not acting like a nut job. Yeah, you are.

Audio: Lacy (05:38:24):

[inaudible 05:38:48].

Audio: Speaker 6 (05:38:24):

Oh, you're lying. I didn't do enough to you. I thought you were playing with my kids, and you're interrupting it. Bye, Felicia.

Audio: Gage (05:38:24):

No. No. [inaudible 05:39:04].

Audio: Speaker 6 (05:38:24):

[inaudible 05:39:18].

Audio: Gage (05:38:24):

[inaudible 05:39:20] Dad, [inaudible 05:40:28].

Speaker 13 (05:38:24):

[inaudible 05:40:34].

Speaker 14 (05:38:24):

[inaudible 05:40:51].

Speaker 13 (05:38:24):

I'm sorry.

Audio: Gage (05:38:24):

[inaudible 05:41:16].

Speaker 13 (05:46:09):

I'm going to go ahead and stop it there. It's really hard to hear on that audio. Did you have an opportunity to listen to it in more controlled environment-

Ms. Wiggs (05:46:24):

I did.

Speaker 13 (05:46:24):

... with headphones maybe and your tech. You can go ahead and stop it, Investigator. Thank you. Do you remember listening to it in your office, your tech office with the headphones from the source?

Ms. Wiggs (05:46:45):

I've listened to it from my laptop, yes.

Speaker 13 (05:46:47):

Did you hear the name Gage which was mentioned [inaudible 05:46:52] maybe the child was...

Speaker 14 (05:46:54):

Objection. Leading.

Speaker 13 (05:46:56):

Did you hear the name Gage mentioned on there?

Judge (05:46:58):

Overruled.

Speaker 13 (05:46:58):

I'm sorry. I'm sorry, Your Honor. We didn't wait for your ruling, we're just going to rephrase it.

Judge (05:47:00):

Okay.

Speaker 13 (05:47:05):

Did you hear the name Gage mentioned on there? Do you remember?

Ms. Wiggs (05:47:05):

I don't recall the name Gage.

Speaker 13 (05:47:05):

Okay. Did you hear a child's voice?

Ms. Wiggs (05:47:05):

Yes.

Speaker 13 (05:47:05):

Okay. Did you hear the defendant say he's never going to even know-

Ms. Wiggs (05:47:05):

Yes.

Speaker 13 (05:47:05):

He'll never know himself.

Ms. Wiggs (05:47:05):

Along those lines, yes.

Speaker 13 (05:47:05):

I don't have any further questions of this witness. Thank you.

Judge (05:47:05):

All right, cross examination.

Speaker 14 (05:47:05):

Sure. [inaudible 05:47:50] Yours won't work, the voice messages.

Speaker 16 (05:47:05):

I can try it again.

Speaker 14 (05:47:05):

No, no, no. Whatever you think is better.

Speaker 16 (05:47:05):

Yeah, it's fine. We can play it here, whatever you want.

Speaker 14 (05:47:05):

All right. Let me just ask a couple questions. Thank you.

Speaker 16 (05:47:05):

Okay.

Speaker 14 (05:47:05):

[Inaudible 05:48:15]

Judge (05:47:05):

Yes, [inaudible 05:48:29].

Speaker 14 (05:48:37):

Thank you, Your Honor. Do you remember seeing at 11:11 at night on Saturday, December 21, 2019, the cache file for this extraction of Ms. Akers's phone?

Ms. Wiggs (05:49:00):

Not specifically.

Speaker 14 (05:49:01):

Let me show you something, okay? And you have the... I'm assuming.

Judge (05:49:50):

[inaudible 05:49:36] show you that. [inaudible 05:49:39] You want to show the prosecution of that? All right. Sorry to interrupt. You may proceed.

Speaker 14 (05:50:02):

Thank you.

Speaker 18 (05:50:01):

All right, sorry to interrupt. You can proceed.

Mr. Steele (05:50:02):

Thank you, Your Honor.

Speaker 17 (05:50:31):

No. Your Honor, can we take a brief break just to discuss the note that was sent to her [inaudible 05:50:36]-

Speaker 18 (05:50:32):

Sure. Let's take a break.

Mr. Steele (05:50:32):

[inaudible 05:53:30].

Speaker 18 (05:54:33):

Okay, whenever you're ready.

Mr. Steele (05:54:36):

Good afternoon again. You said that it connected to the McDonald's, and when I say it, the device, talking about the cell phone of Mr. Akers.

Speaker 19 (05:54:50):

So the cell phone was scanning networks, trying to find networks to connect to.

Mr. Steele (05:54:56):

Right. And just for basic background, if I have a cell phone, it's pinging off of a tower in the area, and pinging just means connected to that tower. So if somebody's trying to reach me, or if I'm searching something, I could go out into the internet, and it comes back to my phone because there's a connection. The actual cell phone is a device, and that's speaking to towers; it's speaking to internet connections and the like, fair?

Speaker 19 (05:55:36):

Correct.

Mr. Steele (05:55:37):

And when you explain that you can tell where the phone is and you gave that diagram, the diagram, it's really not GPS, which is global positioning. Like if I'm jogging, let's say, and I could show my route afterwards, that's really tracking me from a satellite, right?

Speaker 19 (05:55:56):

If you're jogging?

Mr. Steele (05:55:57):

Yeah, and if I have my watch on or my cell phone and it's connected.

Speaker 19 (05:56:01):

Yeah. Health data can be tracked, and it would be from GPS.

Mr. Steele (05:56:07):

But what we have here are points. We have data points. That's what you were explaining to the ladies and gentlemen of the jury, fair?

Speaker 19 (05:56:14):

There were data points and a connection where it was harvested from trying to connect to a wifi.

Mr. Steele (05:56:23):

So if the device and a device, let's assume is with a person because devices don't travel by themselves, fair to say?

Speaker 19 (05:56:30):

Correct.

Mr. Steele (05:56:30):

But they could be thrown in the back of a truck or something. But the device, when it comes up to a location, it may touch something, a network, let's say wifi network, and then it will record the latitude and longitude of that connection. Is that true?

Speaker 19 (05:56:47):

Correct.

Mr. Steele (05:56:47):

And then if any of us could put into Google Earth longitude or latitude, or another search platform, then it would tell exactly what it is, and then you can see that there's a McDonald's nearby or a Checkers or a lake, whatever. True?

Speaker 19 (05:57:02):

Correct.

Mr. Steele (05:57:02):

And that's what you did. And you said that there was a McDonald's, and you said it's about 12:20 AM. Does it sound more like 12... I don't know if it matters to the jurors, but 12:28 AM it was connected, that device was connected at the location where it comes back near a McDonald's?

Speaker 19 (05:57:21):

It could be. I could look at my notes-

Mr. Steele (05:57:24):

Yeah, go ahead.

Speaker 19 (05:57:24):

Okay.

Mr. Steele (05:57:32):

And also, a connection can stay, fair to say?

Speaker 19 (05:57:36):

Correct.

Mr. Steele (05:57:37):

And that could be connected here. I've been here all day, let's say, in the courthouse. It showed my phone potentially in the courthouse multiple times.

Speaker 19 (05:57:43):

Correct.

Mr. Steele (05:57:44):

Okay. Did you check it?

Speaker 19 (05:57:45):

I did.

Mr. Steele (05:57:46):

All right.

Speaker 19 (05:57:47):

It was 12:28.

Mr. Steele (05:57:49):

Okay. And if you said 12:28, it doesn't matter 12:28, but that's when we have a data point that that device is near a McDonald's. Fair to say?

Speaker 19 (05:58:00):

It was trying to connect to the network, yes.

Mr. Steele (05:58:03):

And you were kind enough to show us a rudimentary but map and you put the symbol for McDonald's just showing near location. This is approximately where the device is connecting, right?

Speaker 19 (05:58:17):

Correct.

Mr. Steele (05:58:18):

And then you said it goes to what I'll just call the house of Ms. Boles and Mr. Akers, but the jurors have the address, and they also have a wifi connection, and you were kind enough to look at that and determine, okay, the device is at that wifi connection. Remember that?

Speaker 19 (05:58:36):

Yes.

Mr. Steele (05:58:37):

And you said approximately; you were very clear, you said approximately 12:40, but would it be more at 12:42 AM?

Speaker 19 (05:58:44):

It could be.

Mr. Steele (05:58:46):

Okay. And that device just means that it connects to the wifi. So to be fair, if I pulled into my house and if there's wifi or even the courthouse, I guess, or a McDonald's, it doesn't mean that I get into the house where the McDonald's or the courthouse. It just means that, for whatever reason, that signal's strong enough to make the connection, my phone recognizes it, or my device recognizes it, right?

Speaker 19 (05:59:13):

Correct.

Mr. Steele (05:59:13):

So if the phone pulled up, left the McDonald's, went to the house that we're talking about, then at some point it recorded that at 12:42 AM that device was connected to that wifi in that house?

Speaker 19 (05:59:33):

Correct.

Mr. Steele (05:59:33):

Under longitude/latitude, right?

Speaker 19 (05:59:35):

Correct.

Mr. Steele (05:59:37):

But the device could still be outside for another minute if the person is collecting their belongings, taking out of a car, and then walk until they enter the house, or even two minutes, true?

Speaker 19 (05:59:47):

It could, depending on the strength of the connection.

Mr. Steele (05:59:50):

I mean, I could sit in my car for an hour if I wanted to, right?

Speaker 19 (05:59:52):

Right. Correct.

Mr. Steele (05:59:53):

All right. But what we have is, so, not to guess, we have 12:42; that device is at the longitude latitude of the address that you previously gave, fair?

Speaker 19 (06:00:04):

Yes, sir.

Mr. Steele (06:00:05):

And the way that route for the McDonald's to that address, it doesn't really mean we took that route. All you're saying is these two points, and this is a route. If people know back roads, they can go back roads, whatever. You're just saying this is one way to get from A to B; it's 1.5 miles, right?

Speaker 19 (06:00:23):

Correct.

Mr. Steele (06:00:24):

But we have the time, so it doesn't really matter the miles. We know at some point, McDonald's at the time, you said 12: 28, at some point at the house at 12:42, and all this is in the early morning hours of December 22, 2019, right?

Speaker 19 (06:00:38):

Correct. Yes, sir.

Mr. Steele (06:00:39):

I want to go back about an hour and a half. So I'm now at 11:11, the make-a-wish time at night of Saturday, December 21 of 2019. Okay? And if you need to see anything or check it later and come back, it's no problem, at least with me. We have to ask the honorable court. But do you remember checking the cache file?

Speaker 19 (06:01:06):

I checked it. I don't recall any specifics.

Mr. Steele (06:01:11):

That's fine. And a cache file... Well, why don't you tell the jurors, if you don't mind, what the cache file is?

Speaker 19 (06:01:15):

The cache file is basically in reference to locations?

Mr. Steele (06:01:21):

No.

Speaker 19 (06:01:22):

Or just-

Mr. Steele (06:01:22):

Anything.

Speaker 19 (06:01:23):

Anything? Okay. So the cache file is basically your phone is... It's a quick reference for your phone. So if it is a website or something that you may visit frequently, it'll save to your cache file. That way, your phone will remember it and populate it a little more quickly.

Mr. Steele (06:01:47):

I mean, these devices are really intelligent, right?

Speaker 19 (06:01:49):

Correct.

Mr. Steele (06:01:50):

I want to show you, and then you can check it if... I'm not here to take three hours now if you have to go back to your office, but I'm going to show you what I've already shown to the prosecutor and, with the court's permission to approach you, Ms. Boles, number 82. May I approach?

Speaker 18 (06:02:03):

Yes.

Mr. Steele (06:02:04):

May I approach you?

Speaker 19 (06:02:04):

Yes, sir.

Mr. Steele (06:02:04):

I tried to give you all the metadata that it would allow. But this is something, if it is, and you'll tell us if it's not, that was on the device at 11:11 PM, approximately an hour and a half before 12:44 AM 9-1-1 call. Can you verify that?

Speaker 19 (06:02:42):

I don't see a timestamp.

Mr. Steele (06:02:46):

It got cut off at the bottom. Do you see everything else to verify it, if you need to go back and look at the device, the extraction?

Speaker 19 (06:02:53):

Yes, sir.

Mr. Steele (06:02:54):

All right. Can you do that really fast?

Speaker 19 (06:02:57):

You need me to go back and review the device?

Mr. Steele (06:02:59):

Do you mind if you could do that really fast for the jurors?

Speaker 19 (06:03:01):

Sure. I would have to go back to the sheriff's office.

Mr. Steele (06:03:06):

Okay. No, no, no. All right. With the court's permission, I'm going to hold this, but I'm going to ask you, unless the judge tells you don't do it, to please do that.

Speaker 19 (06:03:16):

Okay.

Mr. Steele (06:03:17):

Okay? And it's marked as Ms. Boles number 82, true?

Speaker 19 (06:03:22):

Yes, sir.

Mr. Steele (06:03:23):

I'm going to move to tentatively, conditionally admit it, but if I'm wrong, you're going to tell the jurors I totally misrepresented, and it is wrong. Your Honor, if I can move it in the interest of time, I'm moving to enter it.

Speaker 17 (06:03:38):

To be honest, I've never dealt with a tentative tendering of evidence. I'll tentatively object.

Speaker 18 (06:03:55):

All right. Is it a tentative tendering?

Mr. Steele (06:03:56):

Yes.

Speaker 18 (06:03:56):

Okay. He said-

Speaker 17 (06:03:57):

Okay. It's tendering without qualification or condition [inaudible 06:04:00]. No objection.

Speaker 18 (06:04:02):

All right. [inaudible 06:04:03].

Mr. Steele (06:04:03):

I'm going to show on the screen, but I think you have the original copy. Your Honor, may I use a duplicate?

Speaker 18 (06:04:09):

Sure.

Mr. Steele (06:04:09):

May I approach? May I approach the investigation?

Speaker 18 (06:04:11):

Sure.

Mr. Steele (06:04:12):

May I approach? And you will remember; you'll take a note or something, you will remember to check this?

Speaker 19 (06:04:28):

Yes, sir.

Mr. Steele (06:04:30):

Okay. Because if I'm wrong, I want you to tell everybody I was wrong.

Speaker 19 (06:04:33):

Yes, sir.

Mr. Steele (06:04:33):

All right. It's cut off at the very top the way it's printed, but can you read that? "Tell someone you love them today because tomorrow is not promised to my family and friends. I love you," and then there's hearts and a smiley face. You see that?

Speaker 19 (06:04:48):

Yes, sir.

Mr. Steele (06:04:49):

All right. And then what we were talking about earlier, before it was displayed, you can use all that information to pretty easily find it, and it's the day before. So we're talking about Saturday evening, December 21st, 2019, at 11:11 at night, okay?

Speaker 19 (06:05:08):

Okay.

Mr. Steele (06:05:09):

All right. Thank you very much. I want to go back to some of the searches that we just saw that you printed out and you showed with the district attorney's office. Do you mind using that? I think it's state number 220, but I may be wrong. Thank you.

Speaker 17 (06:05:36):

228.

Mr. Steele (06:05:36):

You may need actually the entire... Do you have the entire printout of two...

Speaker 17 (06:05:39):

Yes.

Mr. Steele (06:05:40):

Okay. Thank you. Do you have... Can you look, if you don't mind, Officer? Otherwise, I'm coming to you. December 12th, 2019. So this is Friday, December 12th, I mean December 20, 2019, 3:02:07 AM. Do you see that in your stack? And if not...

Speaker 17 (06:06:08):

Three what?

Mr. Steele (06:06:09):

02:07 AM.

Speaker 17 (06:06:09):

2:07?

Mr. Steele (06:06:14):

3:02:07, yes. You don't see it?

Speaker 17 (06:06:52):

It's on the 12th, we have...

Mr. Steele (06:06:54):

No, December 20th, I'm looking at.

Speaker 17 (06:06:55):

20th. Okay.

Mr. Steele (06:06:59):

Your Honor, can we just approach for a minute while the investigator look at, because I may just want to speed this up.

Speaker 18 (06:07:04):

Okay.

Speaker 17 (06:07:08):

I'm going to have to object to an approach based on the defense's position prior to trial.

Speaker 18 (06:07:13):

Well, just a quick reference, and then in the next break we put it on the record. Would that be okay?

Speaker 17 (06:07:17):

Yes. Thank you.

Mr. Steele (06:08:21):

The investigator just handed me, Your Honor, and thank you. State's number 220, page two, 302. It's a bunch of... But 07. This is already in evidence. May we display, Your Honor?

Speaker 18 (06:08:41):

Yes.

Mr. Steele (06:08:42):

Okay. And you notice here... Did you not... That's December 20th, 2019, in line 84. Is that fair to say? Do you see that?

Speaker 19 (06:09:03):

Yes, sir.

Mr. Steele (06:09:05):

And it's in the morning hours... Oh, excuse me. I am sorry. It looks like a PM. 3:02:08. Here's 3:02:07. You see that?

Speaker 19 (06:09:14):

Yes, sir.

Mr. Steele (06:09:15):

So it's the afternoon.

Speaker 19 (06:09:16):

Yes, sir.

Mr. Steele (06:09:17):

And that would be Friday. If you don't know the date, just say I don't know the day of the week, but it's December 20th, 2019.

Speaker 19 (06:09:23):

Yes, sir.

Mr. Steele (06:09:24):

And the search was on Safari. That's a known site, right? That's a known search engine?

Speaker 19 (06:09:30):

Yes, sir.

Mr. Steele (06:09:31):

And it says California Meth Cities, right?

Speaker 19 (06:09:34):

Correct.

Mr. Steele (06:09:35):

All right. And then, in addition to that, you could remove that if you want. Number 1602. If you could just look at the number on the side, it'll be a different one. And it should be the reference number, how they're sequential. You know what I'm referring to, sir? It should be 1602. If you could look at this one, if you don't mind, and just announce what you put on the screen, if you don't mind, Mr. Investigator. It's on the back. You just announce which exhibit.

Speaker 22 (06:10:09):

It is 220B, as in boy.

Mr. Steele (06:10:14):

220B, as in Barry. And it's line 1602. The prosecutor showed you this one, I believe, how to handle your wife's mental health. You remember that?

Speaker 19 (06:10:28):

Yes, sir.

Mr. Steele (06:10:29):

I think that's health. If I'm wrong, I'm not trying to be wrong. And then I'm going to 1602. Do you see this? And it says, "Crackhead Dan".

Speaker 19 (06:10:38):

Yes, sir.

Mr. Steele (06:10:39):

Okay. And that's just two searches down from what you were asked to read with the prosecutor, right?

Speaker 19 (06:10:50):

Correct.

Mr. Steele (06:10:50):

All right. And then we have number... It's sequential number 425. The prosecutor showed you number 424. If you can help us, Mr. Investigator, and with the exhibit number as well.

Speaker 22 (06:11:20):

220I.

Mr. Steele (06:11:22):

Thank you. And remember, reading with the prosecutor, if you go up 424, I believe. If you are a construction worker and have to work for the airport, do you get badged? Do you see that?

Speaker 19 (06:11:40):

Yes, sir.

Mr. Steele (06:11:41):

You remember talking with us about that and explaining that was on December 12th, 2019 at 9:09 PM?

Speaker 19 (06:11:47):

Yes, sir.

Mr. Steele (06:11:48):

Okay. I'd like you to look at the next one right after it, 425. You see that?

Speaker 19 (06:11:56):

Yes, sir.

Mr. Steele (06:11:57):

And the search here is also on December 12th, 2019 at 9:09:22 seconds. So it's a second... It's basically a similar search, but this went to a different search engine, right?

Speaker 19 (06:12:14):

It wasn't through a different search engine. It just saved to a different database, the Knowledge C database.

Mr. Steele (06:12:21):

Thank you.

Speaker 19 (06:12:21):

Yes, sir.

Mr. Steele (06:12:22):

And this one reads, "When getting badged at the airport, do you get..." And it's together, but "drug tested." You see that?

Speaker 19 (06:12:31):

Yes, sir.

Mr. Steele (06:12:32):

Okay. You announced, and it's number 967 with the prosecutor. And if you remember it, we don't need to see it, but if we need to see it's fine, if it's okay with the court and the investigator. Remember something, and I may not be quoting, so maybe you better show it, but "Dear God, I need your help." Remember that one?

Speaker 19 (06:13:00):

Yes, sir.

Mr. Steele (06:13:01):

And do you know if I said it wrong, or I may not be quoting it perfectly?

Speaker 19 (06:13:07):

I don't remember it verbatim.

Mr. Steele (06:13:09):

Okay. Okay. Do you have the number 967? And while that's being looked for, do you remember listening to audio message recordings? So if I were to call you and I left you a voice message, do you remember listening to those on the same device?

Speaker 19 (06:13:34):

I don't recall any voicemails.

Mr. Steele (06:13:39):

Okay. I'm going to... I have some to play.

Speaker 19 (06:13:43):

Okay.

Mr. Steele (06:13:44):

How do we verify that this came from this device? Same thing? You can go back and check?

Speaker 19 (06:13:50):

Yeah.

Mr. Steele (06:13:53):

Okay. What number is it?

Speaker 22 (06:13:57):

220E, as in Edward.

Mr. Steele (06:13:58):

220E, as in Erin. And we're talking about number 967, just so my memory's not good, or it's better now. It's 12/7, that's December 7th, 2019. It looks like 8:03 in the morning. Does that look like it to you?

Speaker 19 (06:14:16):

Yes, sir.

Mr. Steele (06:14:17):

And it's saved to database knowledge C, as in Colette?

Speaker 19 (06:14:20):

Yes, sir.

Mr. Steele (06:14:21):

And it said, "Dear God, I need your help. I need your strength."

Speaker 19 (06:14:24):

Yes, sir.

Mr. Steele (06:14:25):

Okay. All right. Your Honor, may I have one second?

Speaker 18 (06:14:31):

Yes, sir.

Mr. Steele (06:14:42):

This is going to be 93 to 108. You don't remember listening to voice messages from this device?

Speaker 19 (06:14:53):

The only audio was the voice memo that I review.

Mr. Steele (06:15:00):

Okay. So how do we determine that this came off this device? So it's the same thing as the cache. I'm just asking you, do you go back to your office and...

Speaker 17 (06:15:10):

I'm not... I'm sure Mr. Steele's not trying to mislead the jury. I'll stipulate it came from this device, even though she may not have listened to it herself.

Speaker 18 (06:15:17):

Okay. All right.

Mr. Steele (06:15:18):

That's fine.

Speaker 18 (06:15:18):

All right.

Mr. Steele (06:15:19):

I move for the admission of 93 to 108. There's multiple exhibits on here, Your Honor, but 93 to 108. Don't-

Speaker 18 (06:15:28):

Do you object?

Speaker 17 (06:15:29):

No, Your Honor.

Speaker 18 (06:15:30):

All right. Submitted. Don't play anything else.

Mr. Steele (06:15:34):

These are very short [inaudible 06:15:35], Your Honor.

Speaker 18 (06:15:35):

That's fine.

Mr. Steele (06:15:35):

Thank you. And can you announce [inaudible 06:15:40]? Thank you.

Speaker 22 (06:15:59):

This will be 93.

Rodney (06:16:14):

Mr. Akers, this is Rodney at Titleman. You need to get in contact with me according to this account. Your account is in serious delinquent status and going into collections.

Speaker 22 (06:16:30):

94.

Brandon (06:16:34):

This is a message for Daniel Akers. This is Brandon here [inaudible 06:16:36] give me a call back at 678-567-521.

Speaker 22 (06:16:35):

Calls 95.

Speaker 20 (06:16:35):

Good evening. This is messages for Daniel Akers. This is Titleman giving you a call about your account. Give us the call back as soon as possible. It's 678-567-5231. Thank you.

Speaker 22 (06:16:35):

Calls 96.

Brandon (06:16:35):

This message for Mr. Daniel Akers. This is Brandon, giving you a call, sir. Please give me a call back at 678-567-5231.

Speaker 22 (06:16:37):

Calls 97.

Brandon (06:16:52):

Mr. Akers... Mr. Danny Akers. It's Brandon giving you a call, sir. Please get back in touch with us at 678-567-5231.

Speaker 22 (06:16:53):

Calls 98.

Speaker 20 (06:16:53):

Good evening, Mr. Akers. Titleman, giving you a call about your account. Give us a call back as soon as possible at 678-567-5231. Thank you.

Speaker 22 (06:16:54):

Calls 99.

Speaker 20 (06:17:47):

Good evening, Mr. Akers. This is Titleman giving you call about your account. Give us a call back as soon as possible at 678-567-5231. Thank you.

Speaker 22 (06:17:47):

Calls 100.

Speaker 21 (06:17:47):

Hi, Daniel Akers [inaudible 06:18:22], just call me back as soon as you hear my message at 678-567-5231. Thank you.

Speaker 22 (06:18:27):

Calls 101.

Speaker 20 (06:18:35):

Good evening, Mr. Akers. This is Titleman giving you a call about your account. Give us a call back at 678-567-5231. Thank you so much.

Speaker 22 (06:18:55):

Calls 102.

Rodney (06:18:56):

Mr. Daniel, this is Rodney at Titleman. You need to give me a call, man, because your card now is out for collection. You need to give me a call.

Speaker 22 (06:19:03):

Calls 103.

Brandon (06:19:07):

Mr. Daniel Akers, sir, it is very important we speak with you about your account. Please call back at 678-567-5231.

Speaker 22 (06:19:10):

[inaudible 06:19:11].

Mr. Steele (06:19:10):

It goes up to 108.

Speaker 22 (06:19:22):

108? Calls 104.

Brandon (06:19:30):

Hey, this message is for Mr. Daniel Akers. This is Brandon, giving you a call, sir. Sir, [inaudible 06:19:34] with you about your account. Please call back at 678-567-5231.

Speaker 22 (06:19:35):

Calls 105.

Brandon (06:19:35):

This message is for Mr. Danny Akers it is Brandon over at Titleman, sir. Please give me a contact at 678-567-5231.

Speaker 22 (06:19:50):

Calls 106.

Speaker 20 (06:19:50):

This message is for Mr. Akers. This is Titleman giving you a call about your account, sir. Give us a call back at 678-567-5231. Thank you.

Speaker 22 (06:20:18):

Calls 107.

Brandon (06:20:20):

Mr. Danny Akers, this is Brandon over at Titleman sir, looking forward to seeing you around 6:00 PM. It's a quarter after six. Please give us a call back at 678-567-5231.

Speaker 22 (06:20:27):

Calls 108.

Brandon (06:20:39):

Hey, this is for Daniel Akers. This is Brandon [inaudible 06:20:41]. Friendly reminder: you have a payment due today. Have any questions about your payment, you may contact me at 678-567-5231.

Speaker 22 (06:20:52):

That's it.

Mr. Steele (06:20:52):

Your Honor, these are from; you could check it, September 30th, 2019 to December 5th, 2019 in consecutive order. And that just sounds to you like people inquiring about a loan, maybe, bills?

Speaker 19 (06:21:10):

Yes, sir.

Mr. Steele (06:21:11):

Okay. I also was handed this. If I may approach, going back to that exhibit, it may save you some time. Your Honor, may I approach?

Speaker 18 (06:21:19):

Yes, sir.

Mr. Steele (06:21:27):

For me. May I approach you?

Speaker 19 (06:21:27):

Yes, sir.

Mr. Steele (06:21:28):

Can you tell me what the exhibit number is right in front of you?

Speaker 19 (06:21:32):

82.

Mr. Steele (06:21:35):

And I'm going to mark this with the court's permission, Ms. Boles, number 82A [inaudible 06:21:43]. And just tell me if this helps orient better. May I approach, Your Honor?

Speaker 18 (06:21:47):

Yes.

Mr. Steele (06:21:47):

May I approach you again?

Speaker 19 (06:21:49):

Yes, sir.

Mr. Steele (06:21:52):

Okay. I know you said it was cut off. Does that look similar? I know it's not a color copy, but that looks similar to what was in Ms. Boles number 82?

Speaker 19 (06:22:01):

Yes, sir.

Mr. Steele (06:22:03):

And 82A, is that fair to say it's not cut off? You have now the data? It's called metadata, right?

Speaker 19 (06:22:08):

Yes, sir.

Mr. Steele (06:22:09):

Can you just explain what metadata means to the jurors?

Speaker 19 (06:22:12):

That just metadata would be the information collected from the phone and the image and that such thing.

Mr. Steele (06:22:27):

And so we know it comes from the phone; nobody changed it. That's an imprint on the phone. Is that fair to say?

Speaker 19 (06:22:32):

Yes, sir.

Mr. Steele (06:22:33):

It just means that if I wanted to change it would say it was changed or altered in some way. And that's what Cellebrite does, right?

Speaker 19 (06:22:41):

Yes, sir.

Mr. Steele (06:22:41):

I mean, Cellebrite does the forensic extraction, meaning you can't go in afterwards and say, "Well, I'm going to delete this message."

Speaker 19 (06:22:49):

Yeah, we can't make any changes in a Cellebrite extraction.

Mr. Steele (06:22:51):

Right. And that's what you did here. You preserved the device.

Speaker 19 (06:22:55):

Yes, sir.

Mr. Steele (06:22:56):

Do you see the date? Can you tell the... Your Honor, I'll move for Ms. Boles, number 82A.

Speaker 17 (06:23:02):

No objection.

Speaker 18 (06:23:03):

Admitted.

Mr. Steele (06:23:04):

Can you just tell the ladies and gentlemen of the jury when that was on the phone?

Speaker 19 (06:23:09):

December 21st. I'm sorry.

Mr. Steele (06:23:12):

In the cache.

Speaker 19 (06:23:14):

December 21st, 2019.

Mr. Steele (06:23:18):

At time?

Speaker 19 (06:23:20):

11:11 PM.

Mr. Steele (06:23:22):

Okay. All right. Let's see. Did you look at photographs by any chance on this phone?

Speaker 19 (06:23:48):

No, sir.

Mr. Steele (06:23:57):

Okay. Your Honor, may I have one moment?

Speaker 18 (06:24:04):

Of course.

Mr. Steele (06:24:45):

[inaudible 06:24:24]. Your Honor, I've marked Ms. Boles number 80 and Ms. Boles number 81, and I believe there is going to be a stipulation of the parties, if that's agreeable with the court to embrace.

Speaker 17 (06:24:58):

I don't think we need a written formal stipulation, but I will agree to the admissibility standard-

Speaker 18 (06:25:00):

All right. Those are admitted.

Speaker 17 (06:25:01):

Thank you.

Mr. Steele (06:25:01):

And Your Honor, just for clarity-

Judge Dean C. Bucci (06:25:01):

All right, begin. Thank you.

Brian Steel (06:25:00):

And Your Honor, just for clarity, these are in the photo section of the phone that was extracted of Mr. Dan Akers.

Judge Dean C. Bucci (06:25:08):

Agreed.

Brian Steel (06:25:09):

If I'm wrong, you can come back, okay?

Sarah Wix (06:25:11):

Okay.

Brian Steel (06:25:12):

May I approach, Your Honor?

Judge Dean C. Bucci (06:25:13):

Yes.

Brian Steel (06:25:13):

I'm just showing it to you just to see it. And then I'm going to ask them to put it up on the screen.

‍

Sarah Wix (06:25:17):

Thank you, sir.

Brian Steel (06:25:28):

Thank you. Your Honor, may I ask the investigator?

Judge Dean C. Bucci (06:25:30):

Of course.

Brian Steel (06:25:31):

Do you mind displaying these? Can you do me a favor?

Investigator Burke (06:25:39):

It's going to be Boles 82A, as in apple.

Brian Steel (06:25:47):

And I know we did this, I'm not trying to make time, but the only addition is down here, it gives the date December 21, 2019 at 11:11:43 PM, right?

Sarah Wix (06:26:03):

Yes, sir.

Brian Steel (06:26:03):

Okay. If you could do the next one.

Investigator Burke (06:26:08):

Boles 80.

Brian Steel (06:26:12):

Okay. Now, I'm going to try to orient you, I know it's in evidence. You don't know what Dan Akers looks like, do you?

Sarah Wix (06:26:22):

I'm not real familiar seeing.

Brian Steel (06:26:24):

Do you recognize this gentleman as Mr. Dan Akers?

Sarah Wix (06:26:27):

It appears that it could be.

Brian Steel (06:26:29):

Okay. Okay. And this is taken, if you can tell, in a mirror. Is that true?

Sarah Wix (06:26:35):

It appears to be. Yes, sir.

Brian Steel (06:26:36):

And when you take a photograph in a mirror, is it fair to say everything's reversed?

Sarah Wix (06:26:42):

Yes, sir.

Brian Steel (06:26:42):

So if I were to hold this point or whatever, the light, the blue light in my hand, and I took a picture, it would appear, I'm not saying it's true, but it would appear everything's inverse. That if someone didn't know it's in a mirror, it would look like it's in my left hand. Is that true?

Sarah Wix (06:27:01):

Yes, sir.

Brian Steel (06:27:02):

So this photograph... You've taken a selfie before?

Sarah Wix (06:27:09):

Yes, sir.

Brian Steel (06:27:12):

This is actually a Mr. Akers, he's using his left hand, even though it appears to be his right hand, to take that selfie. Is that true?

Sarah Wix (06:27:20):

It would appear so. Yes, sir.

Brian Steel (06:27:20):

And then to be fair, if you don't mind showing the next one, Ms. Boles Number 81, I think it is.

Investigator Burke (06:27:24):

Boles 81.

Brian Steel (06:27:33):

And this is also, do you recognize potentially Mr. Akers in the photograph?

Sarah Wix (06:27:38):

Yes, sir.

Brian Steel (06:27:39):

And this is a different day it appears, because different outfit. I know he's not wearing a shirt in either one, but different outfit?

Sarah Wix (06:27:46):

Yes, sir.

Brian Steel (06:27:47):

And this is also in a mirror and a selfie, correct?

Sarah Wix (06:27:52):

It appears so. Yes, sir.

Brian Steel (06:27:52):

So this looks like it's a left hand holding the camera to take a selfie. But the truth is, it would be right, everything's inverse. It's the same as the other picture, true?

Sarah Wix (06:28:02):

It is. Yes, sir.

Brian Steel (06:28:02):

So we have one photograph, Ms. Boles Number 80, and one photograph, Ms. Boles Number 81. It's just using either hand to take a selfie, that's all, the differences, right?

Sarah Wix (06:28:12):

Yes, sir.

Brian Steel (06:28:12):

Okay. Thank you, sir.

(06:28:26)
Your Honor, may I just have one second?

Judge Dean C. Bucci (06:28:28):

Sure.

Brian Steel (06:28:55):

Would you do me a favor, sir? Would you go, if you can find December 19th, 2019? It would be State's Exhibit Number... Yes, sir.

Investigator Burke (06:29:06):

This one?

Brian Steel (06:29:06):

Yeah. But it would be December. You should have December 19th, 2019, I believe.

(06:29:09)
Were you able to find it?

Investigator Burke (06:30:24):

We don't have the 19th.

Brian Steel (06:30:57):

All right. I'll do it a different way. Thank you. May I approach, Your Honor?

Judge Dean C. Bucci (06:31:22):

Yes.

Brian Steel (06:31:23):

May I approach you?

Sarah Wix (06:31:23):

Yes.

Brian Steel (06:31:24):

I'm going to show you Ms. Boles Exhibit Number 146. Let's take a peek at that. Tell me if that has the metadata from this device, understanding that you could go back to your office, and if I'm wrong, say that that doesn't exist.

Sarah Wix (06:31:45):

Yes, sir.

Brian Steel (06:31:46):

All right. Does it look like you have all the metadata there that would come off this device?

Sarah Wix (06:31:50):

Yes, sir.

Brian Steel (06:31:51):

Your Honor, I move for Ms. Boles' Number 146.

DA Jason Treadaway (06:31:55):

No objection.

Judge Dean C. Bucci (06:31:56):

Admitted.

Brian Steel (06:31:57):

May I publish?

Judge Dean C. Bucci (06:31:58):

Yes.

Brian Steel (06:31:59):

May I approach you?

Sarah Wix (06:32:00):

Yes, sir.

Brian Steel (06:32:07):

Earlier, if you remember, on or around December 20th, 2019, there was a search on 'California meth cities.' Do you remember that?

Sarah Wix (06:32:18):

Yes, sir.

Brian Steel (06:32:18):

And this one is the day before, December 19th, 2019, 4:27 in the afternoon. And it's a Safari, and it's searching 'meth city.' True?

Sarah Wix (06:32:36):

Yes, sir.

Brian Steel (06:32:37):

Okay. With regards to... Do you have it?

(06:33:29)
Do you know how to do Control-F search?

Sarah Wix (06:33:33):

Yes, sir.

Brian Steel (06:33:33):

Okay. Your Honor, may I approach with the computer?

Judge Dean C. Bucci (06:33:35):

Yes.

Brian Steel (06:33:36):

Do you mind using it? Are you comfortable using a computer?

Sarah Wix (06:33:38):

Sure.

Brian Steel (06:33:39):

Okay. This is... Just look at it. You can move it around. It should be the Cellebrite extraction that was given to us in discovery.

Sarah Wix (06:33:56):

Yes, sir.

Brian Steel (06:33:57):

And can you search the term 'reasons why Dan a fail'? And tell us if you find anything.

Sarah Wix (06:34:09):

Dan's a fail?

Brian Steel (06:34:11):

Yeah. 'Reasons why Dan a fail,' F-A-I-L. Do you get a hit on it? If you just look at 'fail,' it should come up. It may come up. Okay. Did you find it?

Sarah Wix (06:35:14):

Yes, sir.

Brian Steel (06:35:14):

Can you see it in the light that you're under?

Sarah Wix (06:35:17):

Yes, sir.

Brian Steel (06:35:18):

Can you just read it to the jury with as much information as it gives you from your extraction? Explain what you're looking at. It's not on a screen, is my point.

Sarah Wix (06:35:28):

Yes, sir. So this pulled up a Safari Google search, or a Safari search, I'm sorry, "Reasons why Dan a fail."

Brian Steel (06:35:44):

Okay. And can you also look and do Control-F, if you don't mind? 'Why are you so mad, Dan.' Or maybe mad, M-A-D? And tell us if you find that.

Sarah Wix (06:37:14):

I'm unable to pull up mad.

Brian Steel (06:37:17):

You don't see mad, M-A-D?

Sarah Wix (06:37:19):

No, sir.

Brian Steel (06:37:22):

Okay. That's fine. That's fine. How about, 'high on ice'? Does that come up?

Sarah Wix (06:38:49):

I'm so sorry, it's not wanting to...

Brian Steel (06:38:53):

It's just searching.

Sarah Wix (06:38:55):

It's not doing anything.

Brian Steel (06:39:01):

That's all right. That's all right. I want to thank you. But if those recordings, the audio recordings that we heard, if the 11:11-

Sarah Wix (06:39:12):

The voicemails.

Brian Steel (06:39:12):

... December 21, if any of that's wrong, just please get the court's attention, the prosecutor's attention with the court's permission.

Sarah Wix (06:39:20):

Yes, sir.

Brian Steel (06:39:21):

Or my attention. And I would like you to correct it.

Sarah Wix (06:39:26):

Yes, sir.

Brian Steel (06:39:27):

All right. I have no other questions, Your Honor.

Judge Dean C. Bucci (06:39:36):

State?

DA Jason Treadaway (06:39:37):

Thank you, Your Honor. Can you please explain... I've said this for people that don't know these terms very well, what is a cache?

Sarah Wix (06:39:39):

A cache. So anytime you are ever online, your device is... Or on your device. Your device wants to be able to pop things back up quickly onto your device. So the cache is a recording of places that you have been on your device, so it can populate quickly so it doesn't have to re-download everything.

DA Jason Treadaway (06:40:08):

Okay. It's a convenience.

Sarah Wix (06:40:09):

Correct. Yes.

DA Jason Treadaway (06:40:11):

And this Defendant's Exhibit 82 that you were asked about on the screen, was that found in the cache?

Sarah Wix (06:40:25):

It is in a cache folder. Yes, sir.

DA Jason Treadaway (06:40:27):

Excuse me. Do you have any indication based on your training, knowledge, and experience and your personal data extraction that this was saved in any way by a user?

Sarah Wix (06:40:36):

I would have to go back and look to be a hundred percent accurate on that. But the file path does state it's in a cache folder.

DA Jason Treadaway (06:40:50):

Okay. And is that right here? See where it says caches, library caches?

Sarah Wix (06:40:57):

Yes.

DA Jason Treadaway (06:40:58):

So if this were saved for use later or access later, is it possible that it would be under some type of other folder than where it would say cache?

Sarah Wix (06:41:08):

It could be.

DA Jason Treadaway (06:41:09):

Do you have any indication that this, based on your data extraction, that this, what's been marked and admitted now as Defense Exhibit 82, that that was sent out to anybody?

Sarah Wix (06:41:20):

Just looking at this, no. But I would have to go back into the database and review further.

DA Jason Treadaway (06:41:26):

Okay. Is this... When something gets saved into a cache, is it possible that that was sent from someone else to the device?

Sarah Wix (06:41:37):

It could be, yes.

DA Jason Treadaway (06:41:39):

And then if I get a meme or a joke or somebody gets a meme or a joke, you look at it and then you just swipe away, could it go to a cache?

Sarah Wix (06:41:48):

It could, yes.

DA Jason Treadaway (06:41:48):

Okay. All right. Okay.

Brian Steel (06:41:56):

Your Honor, can I just get that computer while-

Judge Dean C. Bucci (06:41:59):

Sure.

Brian Steel (06:42:00):

... this transition. Thank you. May I get the computer?

Sarah Wix (06:42:04):

Yes, sir.

Brian Steel (06:42:05):

Thank you.

DA Jason Treadaway (06:42:15):

You were asked some questions about Defense Exhibit 81. I'm going to continue up on that a little bit, follow up on that. So if you look at Defense Exhibit 81, you were asked about reverse imagery in a mirror. Do you remember that?

Sarah Wix (06:42:33):

Yes, sir.

DA Jason Treadaway (06:42:35):

So if I understand it, on the computer image, it looks... While it may look like Mr. Akers was holding his phone in his left hand, that's really his right hand. Is that right? The reverse image.

Sarah Wix (06:42:51):

If it's in a mirror, then it would be inverted, yes.

DA Jason Treadaway (06:42:54):

You see where he's got this New York Giants tattoo here. And you can't read it because it's backwards, right?

Sarah Wix (06:43:00):

Yes.

DA Jason Treadaway (06:43:01):

So you would agree then that everything's backwards?

Sarah Wix (06:43:04):

Yes.

DA Jason Treadaway (06:43:04):

On Defense Exhibit 81?

Sarah Wix (06:43:04):

Yes.

DA Jason Treadaway (06:43:07):

So the phone, is it fair that the phone would really be in his right hand in this photo?

Sarah Wix (06:43:14):

Yes.

DA Jason Treadaway (06:43:15):

Do you see where he has his clip, where he would go and access his phone there?

Sarah Wix (06:43:20):

His phone clip?

DA Jason Treadaway (06:43:21):

Yeah.

Sarah Wix (06:43:21):

Yes, sir.

DA Jason Treadaway (06:43:23):

And that's on his... What side is that on his body?

Sarah Wix (06:43:24):

Right.

DA Jason Treadaway (06:43:25):

Right in reality, right?

Sarah Wix (06:43:27):

Yes.

DA Jason Treadaway (06:43:28):

Even though it may look like left on this photo. So he has this little clip on his right side?

Sarah Wix (06:43:33):

Yes, sir.

DA Jason Treadaway (06:43:49):

All right. Do you remember, defense asked you about some specific searches, there was a search called "crackhead?" Do you remember that?

Sarah Wix (06:43:55):

Yes, sir.

DA Jason Treadaway (06:43:56):

Do you remember it saying "crackhead meme" was one of the searches?

Sarah Wix (06:44:02):

Yes, sir. I believe so.

DA Jason Treadaway (06:44:03):

You know what a meme is?

Sarah Wix (06:44:03):

Yes.

DA Jason Treadaway (06:44:03):

Okay. Tell the jury if they don't know.

Sarah Wix (06:44:08):

It's just, a meme would be like a funny little picture online that is shared.

DA Jason Treadaway (06:44:14):

Okay.

Sarah Wix (06:44:14):

Usually with some type of joke.

DA Jason Treadaway (06:44:21):

All right. And then you were asked about a search that said "meth city." Do you remember that?

Sarah Wix (06:44:30):

Yes, sir.

DA Jason Treadaway (06:44:31):

Do you know of a podcast called Meth and the City? Popular podcast about meth and the way it affects, negative effects on people and families? Do you know that podcast?

Sarah Wix (06:44:41):

I'm not familiar with it. No, sir.

DA Jason Treadaway (06:44:45):

Okay. Do you know anything about... Other than the fact that it said meth city, do you know anything in the mind of the user what was being searched for there other than those two words?

Sarah Wix (06:44:52):

No, sir.

DA Jason Treadaway (06:45:04):

All the phone calls, is it fair to say that, and I know you're not super familiar with the voicemail messages that were left from TitleMax, but did you hear the date range given by the defense as ending on 12/5? Did you hear that?

Sarah Wix (06:45:21):

Yes, sir.

DA Jason Treadaway (06:45:21):

So do you have any reason to believe that the date range on the stipulated voicemails did not end on 12/5, the collections notices or the calls from TitleMax?

Sarah Wix (06:45:31):

No, sir.

DA Jason Treadaway (06:45:33):

Based on your extraction, do you have any reason to believe that that's not accurate, that the last one was 12/5?

Sarah Wix (06:45:39):

I could go back and review, but I don't know if they go beyond 12/5 or not.

DA Jason Treadaway (06:45:45):

Well, did you find anything that sticks in your mind, 'Oh, I remember there was one on 12/7 or 12/80'?

Sarah Wix (06:45:48):

No, sir.

DA Jason Treadaway (06:45:51):

You have no reason to believe Mr. Steel's inaccurate when he says 12/5 is the last date range?

Sarah Wix (06:45:55):

No, sir.

DA Jason Treadaway (06:46:02):

Okay. I'm going to ask about one more thing. If you could... Investigator Burke, if you could please go to Message 967. Message 967, please. Can you look up 967 right there? Can you put that on the screen? The defense asked you about Message 967. Can you blow that up please, sir? I appreciate it. So that's good, that's good. And let's wait for it to focus in. So do you see this, "Dear God, I need your help. I need strength."

Sarah Wix (06:47:10):

Yes, sir.

DA Jason Treadaway (06:47:11):

Do you see what date that was? 12/7/19?

Sarah Wix (06:47:12):

Yes, sir.

DA Jason Treadaway (06:47:17):

Would you... Do you know that... And what time was that? 9:35.

Sarah Wix (06:47:33):

The line item 967 would be 8:03 AM.

DA Jason Treadaway (06:47:37):

I'm sorry, I couldn't read it. 8:00 AM on 9/7. Do you know what day of the week 9/7 was?

Sarah Wix (06:47:44):

12/7? No, sir.

DA Jason Treadaway (06:47:51):

I'm sorry, 12/7. So if 12... Did you know... Were you advised that Mr. Akers lost his life on 12/22, morning hours?

Sarah Wix (06:47:57):

Yes, sir.

DA Jason Treadaway (06:47:58):

So Saturday would've been 12/21, you think?

Sarah Wix (06:48:04):

Yes, sir.

DA Jason Treadaway (06:48:05):

4/21/19. So would you agree that 12/7 would've been exactly two weeks prior to that Saturday, right?

Sarah Wix (06:48:13):

Yes, sir.

DA Jason Treadaway (06:48:14):

Okay. So this would've been on a Saturday before the following day, Sunday, 12/8?

Sarah Wix (06:48:22):

Yes, sir.

DA Jason Treadaway (06:48:27):

Okay. Do you remember seeing or listening to... I think his name was Brandon from TitleMax. Do you remember hearing those messages from Brandon at TitleMax?

Sarah Wix (06:48:38):

Yes, sir.

DA Jason Treadaway (06:48:39):

Do you remember one... Did you hear it say, "Hey, I look forward to meeting you at 6:00 PM tonight"? Did you hear that?

Sarah Wix (06:48:46):

I don't recall. I'm sorry.

DA Jason Treadaway (06:49:05):

Okay. That's all I have. Thank you.

Judge Dean C. Bucci (06:49:06):

Anything else? All right, ma'am, you're excused.

Sarah Wix (06:49:06):

Thank you.

Judge Dean C. Bucci (06:49:11):

Why don't we take a break? Before you leave, I want to let you know. That if there's something that's presented in the courtroom, like a video or an audio or any kind of evidence, once you start deliberating, if you want to come back out here again, all you have to do is let us know, okay? If you missed anything and that's your request, we'll bring you back out and let you hear it again. Okay? Just wanted to make sure you know that. Let's take 10 minutes.

Your Honor (07:07:09):

[inaudible 07:04:45]. Yes. Thank you. Welcome back. Does the state have another witness?

Speaker 23 (07:07:10):

State calls Duriel McKenzie.

Your Honor (07:07:57):

Good afternoon, sir. Let me swear you in please before you have a seat. Do you mind raising your right hand to receive an oath? Do you swear or affirm the testimony you're about to give in the matter before the court will be the truth, the whole truth, nothing but the truth, so help you God?

Duriel McKenzie (07:08:09):

I do.

Your Honor (07:08:10):

Please have a seat.

Speaker 23 (07:08:15):

Could you state your name please, sir?

Duriel McKenzie (07:08:19):

My name is Duriel McKenzie.

Speaker 23 (07:08:22):

And how are you employed?

Duriel McKenzie (07:08:24):

I'm currently employed at the Georgia Bureau of Investigation with the Division of Forensic Sciences in the toxicology department.

Speaker 23 (07:08:31):

And how long have you been so employed?

Duriel McKenzie (07:08:34):

Almost 13 years.

Speaker 23 (07:08:36):

What is your educational background?

Duriel McKenzie (07:08:40):

I have a bachelor of science degree from the University of Mississippi in forensic chemistry. I have a master of science degree with a concentration in forensic toxicology from the University of Florida.

Speaker 23 (07:08:55):

And what has been your job assignment? So during your time with the GBI, what has been your job assignment?

Duriel McKenzie (07:09:03):

I analyze biological specimens for the presence or absence of alcohol, drugs of abuse, and I also perform carbon monoxide testing.

Speaker 23 (07:09:15):

Okay. What is forensic toxicology?

Duriel McKenzie (07:09:19):

Forensic toxicology is the study of poisons and impairing substance applied to the legal field.

Speaker 23 (07:09:29):

And how long have you been involved in that type of endeavor in studies?

Duriel McKenzie (07:09:36):

19 years. I used to work at the Mississippi Crime Laboratory before I came employed at the Georgia Bureau of Investigation for a little over six years.

Speaker 23 (07:09:45):

Your Honor, at this time I would tender Duriel McKenzie as an expert in the area of forensic toxicology.

Your Honor (07:09:53):

Any objection?

Raymond Lale (07:10:12):

No objection.

Your Honor (07:10:12):

[inaudible 07:10:13].

Speaker 23 (07:10:12):

Mr. McKenzie, I show you what has previously been marked for identification as state's exhibit number 222 and ask if you are familiar with that document?

Duriel McKenzie (07:10:20):

Yes, I am.

Speaker 23 (07:10:25):

And what is that document?

Duriel McKenzie (07:10:27):

It is a copy of the report for the blood alcohol postmortem analysis that I generated.

Speaker 23 (07:10:35):

And was that for a particular individual you had done that for?

Duriel McKenzie (07:10:42):

Yes. The victim is Daniel Akers.

Speaker 23 (07:10:46):

Have there been any additions or deletions or anything to make you think that's not an exact copy of the document you produced in the evaluation of the item evaluated in this case?

Duriel McKenzie (07:11:01):

No.

Speaker 23 (07:11:03):

Your Honor, at this time, the state would tender into evidence state's exhibit number 222.

Raymond Lale (07:11:10):

No objection, Judge, with regard to whether it goes back with the jury or not.

Your Honor (07:11:14):

[inaudible 07:11:17]

Speaker 23 (07:11:22):

Mr. McKenzie, I believe this will appear on your monitor in front of you. And I would ask you to look at the state's exhibit number 222. And can you explain to the jury what this in fact is?

Duriel McKenzie (07:11:44):

So this is, as I mentioned before, a copy of the report that I generated for the blood alcohol postmortem request that was asked. In the top right-hand corner, the 2019-1035419 is the case number that was generated at the Georgia Bureau of Investigation when the evidence was submitted by the Georgia Bureau of Investigation Medical Examiner's Office.

(07:12:12)
And what was submitted was a sealed package containing the following items identified as collected from Daniel Akers. There were two tubes containing femoral blood, two tubes containing urine, two tubes containing vitreous fluid, that's a fluid taken from the eye, two tubes containing subclavian blood, and one tube containing iliac blood.

Speaker 23 (07:12:37):

And did you have occasion to analyze any particular item from those you just described?

Duriel McKenzie (07:12:45):

Yes. I analyzed 2A, one of the tubes of femoral blood that was submitted.

Speaker 23 (07:12:51):

And why did you pick the femoral blood?

Duriel McKenzie (07:12:54):

I picked the femoral blood because that is the best specimen to test in postmortem death cases. It has less chances of being contaminated or giving results that aren't valid.

Speaker 23 (07:13:10):

What exactly do you do to analyze the blood to come up with a finding?

Duriel McKenzie (07:13:17):

So I take some of the blood from the tube and I place it into a vial and it also contains another chemical called an internal standard that helps find the concentration of the alcohol. I also sample several other controls. These are known concentrations of alcohol along with the cases. They go in their own individual vials. And then I place them onto an instrument called a headspace gas chromatograph with flame ionization detector. I also sample the cases twice and report the average of the two.

(07:13:54)
So I sample the cases twice, sample the series of controls twice, place them on the instrument. The instrument has the ability to detect alcohol such as methanol, which is wood grain or blood alcohol, ethanol which is drinking alcohol, isopropanol, which is found in rubbing alcohol, and acetone, which is found in fingernail polish remover. So it can detect those and tell the difference between them. And then we can also see the amount of alcohol that is present.

Speaker 23 (07:14:26):

And what did your analysis of the substance collected from Mr. Akers' body reveal when you analyzed it?

Duriel McKenzie (07:14:36):

Submission 2A, ethyl alcohol result by gas chromatography is 0.068 grams of ethyl alcohol per 100 milliliters of blood with an uncertainty of 0.003 grams of ethyl alcohol per 100 milliliters of blood. And there's a statement saying these results may be affected by the clotted nature of the specimen.

Speaker 23 (07:15:02):

All right, sir. He's with you.

Raymond Lale (07:15:13):

Good afternoon, Mr. McKenzie.

Duriel McKenzie (07:15:14):

Good afternoon.

Raymond Lale (07:15:16):

My name is Raymond Lale. I along with Brian Steele represent Ms. Boles. Just have a couple of questions.

Duriel McKenzie (07:15:21):

Okay.

Raymond Lale (07:15:22):

Mr. Cole covered most of the things I would've asked you. So of course you have to follow protocol in order for the results to be correct, right?

Duriel McKenzie (07:15:34):

That is correct.

Raymond Lale (07:15:35):

And that's how you're trained, right?

Duriel McKenzie (07:15:38):

That is correct.

Raymond Lale (07:15:38):

Okay. And you did follow protocol in this case?

Duriel McKenzie (07:15:41):

Yes.

Raymond Lale (07:15:42):

There was nothing remarkable about this case, otherwise it would've been denoted in your report, correct?

Duriel McKenzie (07:15:47):

That is correct.

Raymond Lale (07:15:48):

Okay. Very good. Just going back to what you testified to earlier at number one, the results are 0.068 plus or minus 0.003, correct?

Duriel McKenzie (07:16:04):

Correct.

Raymond Lale (07:16:05):

So what you're saying is in your report, the result could be a 0.071 or it could be a 0.065.

Duriel McKenzie (07:16:16):

So the result that I reported is what we found, 0.068 grams of alcohol per 100 milliliters of blood, but the true value of the ethanol that may be in the two could be between what you said, between 0.065 to 0.071 grams of ethyl alcohol per 100 milliliters of blood.

Raymond Lale (07:16:42):

Very good. Okay. Okay. That's all I have.

Your Honor (07:16:45):

All right. Anything else from the state?

Speaker 23 (07:16:47):

No, Your Honor. I ask that this witness be released.

Your Honor (07:16:50):

All right. Thank you very much, sir. [inaudible 07:16:52]

Speaker 23 (07:16:54):

State calls Sarah Van Holm.

Your Honor (07:17:58):

Good afternoon. Welcome. I'm going to swear you in. [inaudible 07:17:55]. Do you swear or affirm the testimony you're about to give in the matter before the court will be the truth, the whole truth, nothing but the truth, so help you God?

Sarah Van Holm (07:18:01):

I do.

Your Honor (07:18:01):

Please, have a seat.

Speaker 23 (07:18:06):

Could you state your name please?

Sarah Van Holm (07:18:08):

Yes. My name is Sarah Van Holm. That's Sarah with an H. Last name is Van Holm, that's two words, V-A-N-H-O-L-M.

Speaker 23 (07:18:19):

And how are you employed?

Sarah Van Holm (07:18:21):

I am currently employed with the Georgia Bureau of Investigation in the Division of Forensic Science as a senior firearms' examiner.

Speaker 23 (07:18:29):

And how long have you been so employed?

Sarah Van Holm (07:18:32):

Since July of 2017, so about nine and a half years.

Speaker 23 (07:18:41):

Now, what type of education have you had to be able to be hired by the GBI as a forensic firearms' examiner?

Sarah Van Holm (07:18:50):

So I have a bachelor's degree in biology from the University of North Georgia. Prior to being employed with the GBI, I was an operations manager for a small firearms manufacturing company. I was a certified firearms instructor and I was also a sponsored competitive shooter. Upon being employed with the GBI, I completed a two-year training program to become a firearms' examiner, and that was followed by seven months of supervised case work.

(07:19:19)
I've been certified as an armorer for multiple firearms manufacturers. I have attended multiple conferences and conventions that are firearms and firearms examiner related. I'm also a member of the Association of Firearm and Tool Mark Examiners, and I'm also independently certified through that association as well.

Speaker 23 (07:19:40):

Have you ever been declared an expert in the area of firearms examination?

Sarah Van Holm (07:19:47):

Yes.

Speaker 23 (07:19:48):

Approximately how many times?

Sarah Van Holm (07:19:50):

It's around 95 times.

Speaker 23 (07:19:55):

And have you testified as an expert in court before?

Sarah Van Holm (07:19:59):

Yes.

Speaker 23 (07:20:00):

About how many times?

Sarah Van Holm (07:20:03):

Again, about 95 times.

Speaker 23 (07:20:06):

Now, well, at this time I would tender Ms. Van Holm as an expert in the area of firearms examinations and analysis.

Your Honor (07:20:17):

Any objection?

Raymond Lale (07:20:19):

No objection, Judge.

Your Honor (07:20:19):

[inaudible 07:20:22].

Speaker 23 (07:20:25):

Madam, can you tell us what exactly is a firearms' examiner? What does that person do?

Sarah Van Holm (07:20:32):

Yes. So I have a demonstrative as well if I can use it.

Speaker 23 (07:20:36):

That would be excellent.

Sarah Van Holm (07:20:36):

Perfect. Okay. So as a firearm examiner, primarily what we do is we determine if a bullet or a cartridge case was fired from a particular firearm or not. Now, what we're looking at are the repeating patterns of markings that are imparted from a firearm onto those different ammunition components, so cartridge cases and projectiles. That together is called a cartridge, so that's going to be a single unit of unfired ammunition.

(07:21:07)
So for example, this is a cartridge. It's made up of four main parts, your main housing being your cartridge case, your projectile sitting in the mouth of that cartridge case, also known as your bullet. Inside of that cartridge case is going to be your gunpowder or your smokeless powder, and then on the base of that cartridge case is going to be your primer, kind of looks like a button. When a trigger is pulled on a firearm, it releases what's called a firing pin.

(07:21:39)
That firing pin actually dimples that button or that primer on the back of that cartridge, and it creates a spark inside of this cartridge case. That spark ignites that gunpowder and creates a combustion or a rapid gas expansion. And what that does is it actually dislodges this bullet from the mouth of the cartridge case and sends it traveling down the barrel of the firearm. That's where that projectile is actually going to pick up the rifling from the barrel of that firearm.

(07:22:11)
Well, because of equal and opposite reactions as this is being pushed down the barrel of the firearm, this cartridge case is actually being slammed into the breach face of the firearm. It's also expanding slightly inside the chamber of the firearm. So those interactions with the firearm are creating markings that we as firearms examiners are actually able to look at and look at the repetition of those markings and be able to compare them.

Speaker 23 (07:22:56):

Ms. Van Holm, I'll show you what's previously been marked for identification as state's exhibit number 223 and ask you if you can identify that document.

Sarah Van Holm (07:23:11):

Yes, I do.

Speaker 23 (07:23:12):

And what is that document?

Sarah Van Holm (07:23:14):

This is the report created from this examination.

Speaker 23 (07:23:19):

Now you say the report. Who prepared that report?

Sarah Van Holm (07:23:23):

So I prepared this report.

Speaker 23 (07:23:26):

And what type of examination did you do?

Sarah Van Holm (07:23:32):

So for this case, I received a firearm, so a .22 revolver. I also received several cartridges and a cartridge case. And then I also received a 22 bullet from autopsy. So because the 22 bullet from autopsy was the same caliber as the revolver that I received, I will test fire that revolver and compare it to the projectile that I received. I'm not comparing the cartridge case that I received because it was recovered from the actual cylinder of the firearm. So then I performed an examination on that projectile compared to test fires from that firearm and then came to my conclusions.

Speaker 23 (07:24:25):

Ms. Van Horn, I show you what's previously been marked for identification as state's exhibit number 173 and ask you if you are familiar with that.

Sarah Van Holm (07:24:56):

Yes, I am.

Speaker 23 (07:24:58):

And how are you familiar with that? And first of all, what is that?

Sarah Van Holm (07:25:03):

This is the high standard 22 revolver that I received.

Speaker 23 (07:25:07):

Okay. And I think there's a sticker on the other side of that. It should be 173A, I believe. Is that correct?

Sarah Van Holm (07:25:15):

Yes, that's correct.

Speaker 23 (07:25:16):

Okay. So you were holding 173A, which is in fact the .22 caliber pistol?

Sarah Van Holm (07:25:21):

Correct.

Speaker 23 (07:25:22):

And what kind of pistol is that?

Sarah Van Holm (07:25:24):

It's a .22 revolver.

Speaker 23 (07:25:28):

Now, what's the difference between a revolver and an automatic?

Sarah Van Holm (07:25:35):

So a revolver is a type of handgun typically you see in an old Western movie. They still make revolvers today, but they were a little bit more popular back in the day, if you will. But essentially the difference between a revolver and a semi-automatic is that a revolver typically has a cylinder that swings out from the frame of the firearm, and it contains multiple areas to put cartridges, multiple cylinders, or if you will, chambers to put cartridges.

(07:26:07)
So those cartridges, the unfired ammunition, are loaded in one by one into that cylinder. That cylinder then swings into the frame of the firearm and those cartridges are lined up with the barrel ready to be fired. So on a revolver, you can either... especially this type of revolver, you can either pull the trigger and it will rotate that cylinder so it brings a cartridge in line and then it will fire that cartridge, or you can pull the hammer back and then pull the trigger and it will fire a cartridge as well.

(07:26:40)
The important thing to remember about revolvers is that those cartridge cases are retained inside of that cylinder until they are actually manually ejected from the firearm.

Speaker 23 (07:26:52):

Now, did you make any kind of comparison with this state's exhibit 173A with any type of test fire bullets?

Sarah Van Holm (07:27:05):

So I created test fire bullets with this firearm and then I compared it to a projectile I received from the medical examiner.

Speaker 23 (07:28:27):

Ms. Van Holm, I show you what has previously been marked for identification as state's exhibit number 225 and ask if you can identify that.

Sarah Van Holm (07:28:45):

Yes, I can.

Speaker 23 (07:28:45):

And what is state's exhibit number 225?

Sarah Van Holm (07:28:49):

These are the test fires that I created with the revolver.

Speaker 23 (07:28:53):

And you say cast fires, what is a cast fire? What is that?

Sarah Van Holm (07:28:59):

So when we receive evidence... I'm going to go on a spiel here. When we receive evidence, we sort it based on class characteristics initially. It's kind of like kids sorting sorting blocks. Those class characteristics are going to tell us how that firearm was designed. So whether we receive cartridge cases or in this case a bullet, we're going to look at that bullet and if the class characteristics agree with the firearm that we have received, then we will test fire that firearm to look a little further at the next category of markings that we're looking at to make our determinations.

(07:29:39)
So our broadest category of markings we're looking at are those class characteristics. Then we will test fire the firearm and then we're looking at a little bit closer at what we call subclass characteristics. So we're going to compare those bullets from the firearm that we test fired to our evidence, and we're going to be looking at this on what we call comparison microscope. So essentially that's two compound microscopes that are joined together by an optical bridge so that we can look at two objects, two cartridge cases or two bullets at the same time and be able to compare those patterns.

(07:30:14)
So once we've established that the class characteristics are agreeing, we've test fired the firearm, we're then going to look a little closer. So those subclass characteristics are microscopic characteristics that are incidental to the manufacturer of that firearm, so how that barrel was made. And those characteristics can carry over from one firearm to another that were manufactured around the same time period, but it still lets us narrow down on those markings.

(07:30:45)
So broadest class, if subclass is agreeing, then we'll move on to what we call individual characteristics. And that's the bread and butter of what we do as firearms examiners. Those are the characteristics that are incidental to the manufacturer of the firearm, but also the wear and tear of that firearm. So they are unique to that particular firearm. So those are the markings that we are looking at to make our determinations.

Speaker 23 (07:31:12):

And do you have your report in front of you there?

Sarah Van Holm (07:31:13):

I do.

Speaker 23 (07:31:14):

May I see that just a moment? And this is going to be published and you will have a copy on the screen there that should be able to come up. I'm also going to show you a paper bag that's got 233 on it. And I'm going to ask you to pull out an item in that bag and tell me if you've ever seen that. And it's got a mark, I think it's already been marked as state's exhibit number 224. Can you tell me if you recognize state's exhibit 224?

Sarah Van Holm (07:31:55):

Yes, I do recognize it.

Speaker 23 (07:31:58):

And how do you recognize that?

Sarah Van Holm (07:32:01):

I recognize it by the GBI case number and the items numbers on the packaging and my initials on the seal.

Speaker 23 (07:32:09):

Now I want you to look at your report. If you would, the first page of your report. State's exhibit 223. Correct. If you can make just a little bit bigger please, sir. Can you read that all right, Ms. Van Holm? Can you see it on the big screen here better?

Sarah Van Holm (07:32:30):

No, that's fine.

Speaker 23 (07:32:40):

Now, looking at your report, you've got a number here. What is this number right there for?

Sarah Van Holm (07:32:51):

That's going to be the agency reference number. So that's going to be Paulding County Sheriff's Office reference number.

Speaker 23 (07:32:57):

Okay. And then you have a request and you're looking at the victim right here. Is that correct?

Sarah Van Holm (07:33:04):

Yes, that's correct.

Speaker 23 (07:33:05):

Okay. Now moving down to evidence. And this is a sealed package that you had received for a firearms analysis. Is that correct?

Sarah Van Holm (07:33:17):

Yes. So that is the evidence I received.

Speaker 23 (07:33:19):

Okay. Now the item 11A is... What is that that you received?

Sarah Van Holm (07:33:27):

So when we receive a large package, we will itemize what's inside of the package. So that's going to be itemized into 11A, 11B, and 11C. 11A is the firearm itself, the 22 revolver.

Speaker 23 (07:33:42):

Okay. And then you have 122. What is that right there? What is that from?

Sarah Van Holm (07:33:50):

So that's the one 22 long/long rifle cartridge case. So 22 long and 22 long rifle have the same size cartridge case. So without a projectile, I cannot tell if it's a long or a long rifle. So I'll put both on there.

Speaker 23 (07:34:06):

And then after that on 11C, you have, what is that right there? What does that refer to?

Sarah Van Holm (07:34:15):

So 11C were seven 22 long rifle cartridges that were recovered from the cylinder of the firearm.

Speaker 23 (07:34:23):

And then you were able to have test fires. Where did you get the ammunition for the test fires that you used for the pistol that you were evaluating?

Sarah Van Holm (07:34:37):

So I actually used three of item 11C for those test fires.

Speaker 23 (07:34:45):

Okay. And how do you conduct a test fire? What do you do?

Sarah Van Holm (07:34:49):

So the reason I use the ammunition that came in as evidence is because we want to get the closest to the ammunition that we've received from ME's office or as evidence because it can...

Sarah Van Holm (07:35:00):

... as evidence because it can mark a little differently. Different metals mark a little differently, so we want to get the closest representation of what we have. So in order to create test fires, we're going to select three of those cartridges that I received. I will actually take the firearm and we will fire it into what we call a bullet retention system.

(07:35:25)
So this was fired into a water tank. And what that does is it reduces the amount of damage that the bullets have when fired, so that I'm able to actually examine them, and then I recover them from the water tank.

Thomas Cole (07:35:43):

And to what did you compare these test fire bullets?

Sarah Van Holm (07:35:49):

So I looked at the test fires to each other because I'm trying to determine those individual characteristics that they share. And then I will compare those test fires to the evidence that I have received. So to the medical examiner's bullet in this case.

Thomas Cole (07:36:03):

And did you receive the medical examiner's bullet?

Sarah Van Holm (07:36:08):

I did.

Thomas Cole (07:36:08):

And do you recognize that in front of you there?

Sarah Van Holm (07:36:13):

Yes. It is part of State's Exhibit 224 and it is GBI item number four.

Thomas Cole (07:36:21):

Okay. So what exactly did you do with the bullet that you examined for comparison with the test fire bullets? How did you go about that?

Sarah Van Holm (07:36:31):

So we will document the class characteristics of that bullet that we've received, again, to ensure that it has the same class characteristics as the firearm. It did. So I test fired the firearm and then I compared those test fires to look at those individual characteristics. And then I looked at those test fires compared to the projectile that I received on our comparison microscope. So I'm looking for those repeating patterns from the rifling of the barrel.

Thomas Cole (07:37:00):

And did you do that in this case?

Sarah Van Holm (07:37:02):

I did.

Thomas Cole (07:37:03):

And what were you able to determine by using the bullet recovered from the medical examiner's office along with the test fires? What was your analysis?

Sarah Van Holm (07:37:13):

So the result of comparing the projectile from the medical examiner's office to the test fires was an inconclusive result. And the reason for that is that there was a lot of damage to that projectile from the medical examiner's office. So there was not enough information for me to be able to make a determination whether it was fired from this firearm or not.

Thomas Cole (07:37:37):

Well, you've fired this actual firearm, is that correct?

Sarah Van Holm (07:37:41):

Yes, I have.

Thomas Cole (07:37:43):

And did you determine in your evaluation if this firearm operated as it was designed to operate?

Sarah Van Holm (07:37:52):

Yes. I did a check function on the firearm and it operates as it's designed.

Thomas Cole (07:37:56):

A check function. What is a check function?

Sarah Van Holm (07:37:59):

So when we receive a firearm and it has, again, the same class characteristics and we're going to test fire it, we perform a check function of that firearm. So we're basically determining if that firearm's safeties are working, if the firearm itself is operational, if any changes have been made to the firearm, and then we're also going to denote all the information about that firearm as well.

Thomas Cole (07:38:24):

Were there any indications that this weapon would malfunction at all?

Sarah Van Holm (07:38:29):

No.

Thomas Cole (07:38:31):

Did you determine the trigger pull on that weapon?

Sarah Van Holm (07:38:35):

I did.

Thomas Cole (07:38:36):

And what is it... Well, first of all, what is a trigger pull?

Sarah Van Holm (07:38:39):

So trigger pull is the amount of force it takes to pull the trigger and for it to release the firing pin. I did perform trigger pulls on this firearm. This firearm is a single action and double action. So essentially that means single action is it performs one action when you pull the trigger. So you have to cock the hammer first, and then when you pull the trigger, it just releases the hammer. And then it also has a double action feature to it where you don't actually have to cock the hammer every time, you can just pull the trigger. And pulling the trigger actually causes the hammer to fly back and then to fall. So I took trigger pulls of both the single action and double action for this pistol.

Thomas Cole (07:39:27):

And the pistol functioned as it was designed to function, is that correct?

Sarah Van Holm (07:39:31):

Yes, it did.

Thomas Cole (07:39:53):

Ms. Van Holm, is there any way that by looking at the discharged bullet that you recovered from the medical examiner's office, is there any way to tell whether it was single action or double action that caused that bullet to be fired?

Sarah Van Holm (07:40:12):

No, I can't tell that from a projectile.

Thomas Cole (07:40:16):

That's my last question, Your Honor. She's with defense counsel.

Judge Dean Bucci (07:40:20):

All right. Cross examination.

Raymond Lale (07:40:32):

Ms. Van Holm, good afternoon.

Sarah Van Holm (07:40:33):

Good afternoon.

Raymond Lale (07:40:34):

My name is Raymond Lale. I, along with Brian Steel, represent Lacey Boles. Just a couple of questions. Mr. Cole asked you most of the questions I was going to ask anyway. And of course, you don't receive any outside information with regard to the test that you did? When I say outside information, you didn't receive any photographs from the crime scene or anything like that, you're just looking at the gun and whether or not the bullet that you received, you could conclusively say that that was fired from that gun?

Sarah Van Holm (07:41:06):

Yes. I just have the physical evidence of the firearm and the evidence I received from the medical examiner's office.

Raymond Lale (07:41:12):

Fair enough. And there's a few dates on your report here. And just to clarify, you did this report, nobody else. This is your report, correct?

Sarah Van Holm (07:41:23):

I was the primary examiner on this report, yes.

Raymond Lale (07:41:25):

Okay. And so when you received it, the date that you did the firing was when?

Sarah Van Holm (07:41:31):

That I test fired the firearm?

Raymond Lale (07:41:32):

Yes. Uh-huh.

Sarah Van Holm (07:41:34):

The date I test fired the firearm was on October 5th, 2022.

Raymond Lale (07:41:37):

Okay. And by the time you receive a firearm, any other testing on that firearm by the GBI has already been done because you're fixing to fire a firearm, you're going to touch it, you're going to pull the trigger. So when you receive a firearm, all the other tests have been done to that firearm if there's going to be other tests done, correct?

Sarah Van Holm (07:42:01):

Yes. Typically, we are at the last stop.

Raymond Lale (07:42:03):

Very good. Okay. Thank you.

Judge Dean Bucci (07:42:04):

Anything else you want to say?

Thomas Cole (07:42:08):

No, Your Honor. I'd ask that Ms. Van Holm be excused from her subpoena.

Judge Dean Bucci (07:42:08):

Okay. You're free to go, thank you very much.

(07:42:20)
All right, we have another witness.

Thomas Cole (07:42:20):

May we have just a second?

Judge Dean Bucci (07:42:20):

Sure.

Thomas Cole (07:42:20):

Thank you.

Jason Treadaway (07:42:39):

State calls, Your Honor, if it pleases the court, Alexander Covin.

Judge Dean Bucci (07:43:35):

Good afternoon, sir. I'm going to swear you in, if you don't mind. Please raise your right hand to receive an oath. Do you swear or affirm the testimony you're about to give in the matter before the court will be the truth, the whole truth, and nothing but the truth, so help you God?

Alexander Covin (07:43:44):

Yes, I do.

Judge Dean Bucci (07:43:44):

Please have a seat.

Jason Treadaway (07:43:52):

Can I approach the witness, Your Honor?

Judge Dean Bucci (07:43:53):

Yes, sir.

Jason Treadaway (07:43:53):

Thank you. Can you please introduce yourself to the jury, sir?

Alexander Covin (07:44:05):

My name is Alexander Covin, A-L-E-X-A-N-D-E-R C-O-V as in Victor, I-N.

Jason Treadaway (07:44:16):

Thank you, sir. How are you employed?

Alexander Covin (07:44:18):

I am the assistant manager of the trace evidence section at the Georgia Bureau of Investigation, Division of Forensic Sciences, commonly known as the state crime lab.

Jason Treadaway (07:44:28):

Were you employed in the trace evidence section on or about March of 2020, sir?

Alexander Covin (07:44:35):

Yes. In March of 2020, I was a scientist in the trace evidence section.

Jason Treadaway (07:44:40):

And when did you become assistant manager of that entire section, sir?

Alexander Covin (07:44:44):

November of 2025.

Jason Treadaway (07:44:47):

Congratulations on that, sir. Can you tell the jury a little bit about your education experience level, what allows you to hold a job as... First, let's talk about just your assignment as a scientist in the laboratory in the trace evidence.

Alexander Covin (07:45:01):

Okay. I received a bachelor of science in chemistry from Albany State University, and upon being hired at the GBI in the crime laboratory, I started off as a lab technician for nine to 10 months or so, and was then promoted to the scientist position. And at that time, I began a training program in the first area of analysis that I was trained in, which was gunshot primer residue, or GSR for short.

(07:45:31)
And that was similar to going back to school again, about six to eight months of lots of readings, tests, oral examinations, written exams, a competency exam that I had to get the correct answer to, a mock trial phase, and then about a three month supervised casework phase where I was performing real casework, but my trainer was going through the technical processes with me. And for every area of analysis that I'm trained in, it was a similar process.

Jason Treadaway (07:46:07):

Have you had your work subjected to peer review, sir?

Alexander Covin (07:46:11):

Yes, they are. Every case that I release a report for is peer reviewed by another scientist that is trained in that same area of analysis.

Jason Treadaway (07:46:21):

And then sir, in contrast, have you also served as peer reviewer to some of your colleagues at the laboratory?

Alexander Covin (07:46:30):

Yes, I have.

Jason Treadaway (07:46:30):

Do you attend continuing education programs and conferences in your field of study annually to stay on top of developments, new discoveries in the area of new scientific expertise?

Alexander Covin (07:46:42):

Yes, we do.

Jason Treadaway (07:46:44):

Have you ever led any of those conferences yourself?

Alexander Covin (07:46:48):

Leading conferences myself, no. I have presented at some discipline meetings, some of the new findings in trace evidence, but lengthy conferences or anything of that matter, not necessarily.

Jason Treadaway (07:47:02):

You're a presenter in colleague meetings-

Alexander Covin (07:47:06):

Correct.

Jason Treadaway (07:47:06):

... in your field?

Alexander Covin (07:47:06):

Yes.

Jason Treadaway (07:47:07):

All right, sir. Can you tell the jury just briefly, what is trace evidence as far as the trace evidence section?

Alexander Covin (07:47:16):

Trace evidence refers to evidence that is either microscopic in nature, invisible to the naked eye, or evidence that has characteristics that we're looking at that are invisible to the naked eye or require microscopy in order to characterize them or do comparisons of them. So for us, we handle GSR, paints and coatings, plastics and polymers, glass, hair, fiber, fractured materials, general unknowns, et cetera.

Jason Treadaway (07:47:52):

And has your expertise been generally in the area of gunshot residue while you were at the GBI, sir?

Alexander Covin (07:48:02):

For the last 10 or 11 years or so, it has been GSR in addition to other areas of analysis.

Jason Treadaway (07:48:09):

Your Honor, at this time, we respectfully tender this witness, Mr. Coven, as an expert in the area of trace evidence analysis and detection, specifically gunshot residue analysis.

Thomas Cole (07:48:20):

Any objection?

Brian Steel (07:48:21):

No opposition.

Thomas Cole (07:48:23):

Granted.

Jason Treadaway (07:48:24):

Thank you, Your Honor. I should have asked you, I forgot, sir. Have you been tendered in as an expert before in the court in Georgia?

Alexander Covin (07:48:28):

Yes, I have.

Jason Treadaway (07:48:30):

Do you know how many times?

Alexander Covin (07:48:32):

Approximately 120 times.

Jason Treadaway (07:48:34):

And does that roughly correspond with the number of times you've testified in Georgia?

Alexander Covin (07:48:38):

Yes, it does.

Jason Treadaway (07:48:42):

Okay, sir. I want you to please, sir, if you will explain to the jury, just kind of in a lay person type of discussion, what is gunshot residue, sir?

Alexander Covin (07:48:51):

Gunshot residue, gunshot primer residue, specifically in this instance, is a collection of microscopic particles that are formed when a firearm is discharged. These particles are invisible to the naked eye, form a cloud or a plume of gaseous vapors around that discharging firearm, and also traveling some with the bullet as well. They contain all three of the elements, lead, barium, and antimony within singular discrete molten particles and have the ability to then settle or rain down on any surfaces that are in close proximity to that firearm when it's discharged.

Jason Treadaway (07:49:36):

Do you frequently have an opportunity to be called on to test for GSR in the modern era in modern times as far as in conjunction with the crime scene investigation?

Alexander Covin (07:49:45):

Yes, I do.

Jason Treadaway (07:49:49):

Okay. May I please show you, sir, what's been marked... I'll show opposing counsel first what's been marked for identification purposes only as State's Exhibit 226. Thank you. 226, sir. Thank you, sir. May I approach the witness, please?

Judge Dean Bucci (07:50:06):

You may.

Jason Treadaway (07:50:07):

Sir, let me show you what's been marked for identification purposes only as State's Exhibit 226 and just have you look at that and see if you recognize that, sir.

Alexander Covin (07:50:19):

Yes, I do.

Jason Treadaway (07:50:20):

How do you recognize what's been marked as State's 226?

Alexander Covin (07:50:25):

This is the report that I released for this particular case. I recognize it by the GBI DOFS specific seal at the top, our case number, as well as my signature on the last page of the report.

Jason Treadaway (07:50:41):

And you said GBI DOFS, so is that D-O-F-S, the Division of Forensic Sciences?

Alexander Covin (07:50:47):

That's correct.

Jason Treadaway (07:50:48):

Okay. Just your abbreviation of DOFS or D-O-F-S.

Alexander Covin (07:50:52):

Correct.

Jason Treadaway (07:50:52):

Does it appear, sir, State's Exhibit 226, to be a fair and accurate representation of a report that you generated in conjunction with this case, Daniel Akers, Lacey Boles case?

Alexander Covin (07:51:03):

Yes, it does.

Jason Treadaway (07:51:05):

Sir, do there appear to be any changes or material alterations or deletions that have been made to 226 that make it somehow not accurate to the report you generated, sir?

Alexander Covin (07:51:12):

No, there do not.

Jason Treadaway (07:51:13):

Respectfully move the court to admit into evidence what's been marked previously for identification purposes only as State's Exhibit 226.

Brian Steel (07:51:21):

I don't object to it being used in the courtroom, but I do object at the proper time to going out with the jury.

Judge Dean Bucci (07:51:27):

Admitted.

Jason Treadaway (07:51:28):

Thank you, Your Honor. So what were you called on to do in this case with respect to your specific specialties?

Alexander Covin (07:51:37):

In this particular case, I was asked to examine a GSR collection kit for the presence or absence of GSR.

Jason Treadaway (07:51:46):

Okay. And when you receive a kit at the laboratory, sir, in what form is that kit?

Alexander Covin (07:51:56):

Typically, the kits that we're using are envelopes, if you will, with three vials inside. These vials typically contain labels on them that say left hand, right hand, and then control. The left hand and right hand vials contain adhesive samplers that will then be used to apply to the left and right hands of whoever you are sampling for GSR. And that control vial also has an adhesive sampler, but it is just exposed to the collection environment, showing that there is no extraneous GSR in that environment that is also carried along with the entire examination process with the other two vials, the other two adhesive samplers, showing that I'm not introducing GSR to these samples at the laboratory, that there is no extraneous GSR inside of our instrument that we use, et cetera.

Jason Treadaway (07:53:00):

All right, sir, I'm going to show you part of what's been already admitted into evidence as State's Exhibit 181 and ask you if you recognize the contents of the 181. Is that similar to those little vials you were talking about?

Alexander Covin (07:53:18):

Yes, they are.

Jason Treadaway (07:53:22):

Let me give you the 181 itself in case you need that, sir. Does that look like the vials?

Alexander Covin (07:53:28):

Yes, they are.

Jason Treadaway (07:53:30):

All right, sir. Anything about the state in which the vials were received by you that caused you concern about the accuracy of your testing?

Alexander Covin (07:53:41):

No, I did not have any concerns.

Jason Treadaway (07:53:45):

All right, sir. So I can show you then what's been marked and now admitted into evidence as State's 226, sir. Thank you. You just look at the screen or the monitor in front, sir. So is this the report you generated then?

Alexander Covin (07:54:05):

Yes, it is.

Jason Treadaway (07:54:05):

And what agency or who requested that you perform the testing?

Alexander Covin (07:54:12):

The Paulding County Sheriff's Office.

‍

Jason Treadaway (07:54:15):

And do you see the DOFS case ending in 419?

Alexander Covin (07:54:20):

Yes, I do.

Jason Treadaway (07:54:20):

Is that the case number that would track this particular case throughout this evidence journey through the Division of Forensic Sciences?

Alexander Covin (07:54:29):

That's correct.

Jason Treadaway (07:54:29):

You have a barcode here to be able to quickly also track evidence, is that right?

Alexander Covin (07:54:39):

For that specific barcode, I'm not sure what that one's for, but there are barcodes on all the items of evidence that are received and then could be tracked throughout the laboratory.

Jason Treadaway (07:54:50):

And there's a barcode on 181, I believe, right?

Alexander Covin (07:54:53):

Yes, sir.

Jason Treadaway (07:54:53):

Yeah, just show it to the jury if you want, sir. And you sometimes barcode this evidence- and we can put these away. Barcode the evidence as it travels along through the laboratory?

Alexander Covin (07:55:03):

That's correct.

Jason Treadaway (07:55:08):

Did you see in 181 the control bottle?

Alexander Covin (07:55:12):

Yes, sir.

Jason Treadaway (07:55:13):

Tell me... I'm sorry, I really was trying to do a lot at once. Did I hear you say the control bottle, is that bottle opened and tested at the scene of the GSR collection or alleged GSR collection, or do you open it and test your environment?

Alexander Covin (07:55:30):

The collection environment at the scene is sampled. The air is sampled for GSR using that vial.

Jason Treadaway (07:55:39):

And what's sampled? I'm sorry, sir. What did I hear you say about taking steps to make sure that your environment doesn't have GSR just floating around from maybe the test before lunch or something like that?

Alexander Covin (07:55:50):

Correct. The laboratory environment that we're using to test these samples for GSR, we do make sure that we're wiping down the surfaces that we're placing the evidence on. I am going to wear gloves when I am handling the samplers and inputting them into the instrument. So exposing all of these samplers to our laboratory environment, to the inside of the instrument that we're using. Having that control along with that, along with this process, shows that we're not introducing any extraneous GSR to these samples.

Jason Treadaway (07:56:36):

Are you familiar with the term cross-contamination?

Alexander Covin (07:56:39):

Yes, sir.

Jason Treadaway (07:56:39):

So is that what that is? Kind of, you don't want cross-contaminating your subject sample with environmental factors from where you are?

Alexander Covin (07:56:48):

Correct. We do not want any extraneous GSR contamination to come into contact with these samplers. In our laboratory, we don't necessarily have individuals who are regularly exposed to GSR particles that will have GSR particles on them in the first place, but we do take additional measures to make sure that we're not contaminating these samples.

Jason Treadaway (07:57:15):

Anything about your testing in this case that causes you concern about cross-contamination or something may have attacked the integrity of your findings based on environmental factors in your lab?

Alexander Covin (07:57:25):

I did not have any concerns about contamination.

Jason Treadaway (07:57:29):

All right, sir. Can I have the lights down just a little, Deputy? Thank you, sir. So you receive a kit that was, I guess, performed or the kit was put into use before you got it. And what do you do when you get the kit, those vials, for example?

Alexander Covin (07:57:50):

Once I retrieve the kit from our evidence locker and begin my examination?

Jason Treadaway (07:57:58):

Yes, sir.

Alexander Covin (07:57:59):

At that point, I will inventory everything that is inside of the kit, take down any notations on my worksheet, and then input these samplers into our scanning electron microscope equipped with an energy dispersive x-ray spectrometer or SEM-EDS for short. And all that is is just a very high-powered microscope that uses a strong beam of electrons instead of light, like you usually see in a high school biology class laboratory microscope.

(07:58:37)
This instrument is what allows me to see what got picked up on those adhesive samplers, any microscopic particulate matter that is there, and then also get an elemental profile of what all that particulate matter is made of. But again, I am specifically looking for particles that have all three of the elements, lead, barium, and antimony in them in order to characterize them as gunshot primer residue particles.

Jason Treadaway (07:59:07):

Let's say you find a sampling or adhesive strip and it just has lead. What would your findings be then? Is that enough?

Alexander Covin (07:59:16):

As far as a GSR examination, I would report out that no GSR was found.

Jason Treadaway (07:59:22):

All right. And what kinds of surfaces can GSR... That's a bad question. From which kinds of surfaces can GSR be detected? Can it be detected on skin, for example?

Alexander Covin (07:59:36):

Yes, it can.

Jason Treadaway (07:59:38):

Can it be detected on clothing, sir?

Alexander Covin (07:59:40):

Yes, it can.

Jason Treadaway (07:59:41):

Can it be detected on hard surface like this table, sir?

Alexander Covin (07:59:44):

Yes, it can.

Jason Treadaway (07:59:47):

And sir, is there any relation to the time period that GSR might be on a surface until you test it? Does it degrade over time?

Alexander Covin (07:59:56):

GSR particles can persist indefinitely unless they are forcibly removed, so either wiped away, washed away, rinsed, et cetera.

Jason Treadaway (08:00:12):

Can you please tell me, did you undertake this testing for the same date as the report date, March 9th, 2020?

Alexander Covin (08:00:29):

My examination was actually performed on March 3rd, 2020.

Jason Treadaway (08:00:34):

Okay. And did you make a report on March 9th, 2020?

Alexander Covin (08:00:37):

Yes. Yes, I did.

Jason Treadaway (08:00:38):

Can you tell the jury what you found regarding, if any, conclusions about the presence of GSR from the kit that was provided to you, sir?

Alexander Covin (08:00:47):

The GSR collection kit from Mr. Daniel Akers revealed more than five particles characteristic of GSR.

Jason Treadaway (08:00:58):

So you'll see up here, is it... Where were the GSR adhesives taken in this case from the body of Daniel Akers?

Alexander Covin (08:01:09):

From the hands of Mr. Akers.

Jason Treadaway (08:01:11):

You saw more than five particles, did you say?

Alexander Covin (08:01:15):

That's correct.

Jason Treadaway (08:01:16):

Okay. What does that mean for the jury?

Alexander Covin (08:01:18):

The more than five category or level of GSR that we report out is the highest amount that we report out. Typically for us, zero particles is no GSR was found, obviously. One in two particles are a small category. Three, four, five, you're getting a little bit more significant. This is a medium category for us. And then more than five, once I get to six particles of GSR, I can stop counting because finding any more particles of GSR beyond that point will not change my conclusions that this individual either discharged a firearm, was in close proximity to a firearm when it was discharged, or they touched a surface that had a lot of GSR on it to transfer to their hands.

Jason Treadaway (08:02:15):

When you found the five particles, sir, and you noted the five particles of GSR for hands, is that consistent with someone who may have been shot?

Alexander Covin (08:02:25):

Yes. For a person that is the victim of a gunshot wound, we do expect to find GSR on their person as well because GSR can travel with the bullet as well, in addition to the simple fact that that person could have been within range of that initial plume or cloud of GSR particles to begin with. So it is reasonable for us to expect that we'll find GSR on the victim of a gunshot wound.

Jason Treadaway (08:02:56):

Do you frequently find GSR on the body, clothing, skin, et cetera, of people who are in any kind of close proximity to the discharge of the firearm?

Alexander Covin (08:03:09):

Yes, that is correct.

Jason Treadaway (08:03:10):

In a room where a firearm was discharged, like a residential bedroom where a firearm was discharged, would you be surprised to find GSR on anybody that was in that room when it was discharged?

Alexander Covin (08:03:24):

No, I would not.

Jason Treadaway (08:03:36):

Can you tell from the presence of GSR on a hand whether a firearm was purposely discharged by the person holding up the firearm, say a victim who was a suicide victim, or can you differentiate that the victim was shot just from the GSR being positive?

Alexander Covin (08:03:54):

Unfortunately, one of the limitations with a GSR examination is that we cannot tell the difference between the shooter or simply being a victim.

Jason Treadaway (08:04:13):

If a person's skin comes into contact with another person's skin that has GSR on it, so you have two people, one is a person with no GSR on them, but then there's a discharge of a firearm, the person who discharged it, assuming they would have GSR on their hands, if that person touches the skin of that first person, would you be surprised to see a positive finding of GSR on that first person?

Alexander Covin (08:04:40):

No, I would not. GSR is easy to transfer.

Jason Treadaway (08:04:43):

That's the word I was about to use, Mr. Covin. Thank you. So is there sometimes such a thing as GSR transfer?

Alexander Covin (08:04:51):

Yes, there is.

Jason Treadaway (08:04:52):

And what does that mean, sir?

Alexander Covin (08:04:54):

That just means that if you have GSR on your hands and you touch your hand to any surface, be it a person or just an inanimate object, some of those GSR particles will then transfer to that surface.

Jason Treadaway (08:05:24):

All right. Thank you, sir. That's all I have. Thank you. All right.

Judge Dean Bucci (08:05:27):

Cross examination.

Brian Steel (08:05:35):

Good to see you, sir.

Alexander Covin (08:05:36):

Good afternoon.

Brian Steel (08:05:52):

Your Honor, may I use a replica weapon, a replica toy revolver?

Judge Dean Bucci (08:05:58):

Don't mind at all.

Brian Steel (08:06:11):

May I approach?

Judge Dean Bucci (08:06:12):

Yes, sir.

Brian Steel (08:06:16):

This has the, you see the tip, the orange tip?

Alexander Covin (08:06:20):

Yes, sir.

Brian Steel (08:06:20):

Okay. And do you want to look at it? It's a replica. Do you want to look at it or-

Alexander Covin (08:06:23):

I-

Brian Steel (08:06:23):

... you're okay?

Alexander Covin (08:06:23):

... don't mind. I'm fine. Yes.

Brian Steel (08:06:29):

So just to make sure that we are explaining this properly, not only does the projectile come from the muzzle of the gun, but gases come out of the gun as well. Fair to say?

Alexander Covin (08:06:48):

That is correct.

Brian Steel (08:06:50):

And three of the elements are the elements you've been talking about to the jury, true?

Alexander Covin (08:06:55):

That is correct.

Brian Steel (08:06:57):

And I know it's barium and iron and ion and...

Alexander Covin (08:07:03):

Lead, barium and antimony.

Brian Steel (08:07:07):

Okay. And they're invisible to the human eye, typically?

Alexander Covin (08:07:10):

That is correct.

Brian Steel (08:07:11):

But they could get embedded and last forever, really, in a location unless somehow they are jarred away, washed away, cleaned with something like that, right?

Alexander Covin (08:07:20):

That is correct.

Brian Steel (08:07:22):

So when the gun is fired, these elements typically are found on the person who fires the weapon. Is that fair to say?

Alexander Covin (08:07:36):

That is correct. That is fair to say.

Brian Steel (08:07:38):

And if I- I'm pointing at myself with a toy. If I'm holding a gun, a revolver, finger's not on the trigger, but like this, and somebody comes at me and tries to stop me from hurting myself if it was a real gun and grabs me and I pull back and goes right here and fires, my hands could be in a distance to get in close proximity to get the gunshot residue on them. Is that fair to say?

Alexander Covin (08:08:09):

Absolutely. Anything that's within several feet of that discharging firearm can get GSR deposited on it.

Brian Steel (08:08:19):

And when you say several feet, is it different for the gun? Is it different for the environment? I mean, how do we range? Several feet sounds subjective.

Alexander Covin (08:08:30):

Yes. And when it comes to the plume or cloud of GSR particles that is formed when a gun is fired, that plume is never going to be the same shape or same size every time. The environment that you're in is going to make a difference as to where that plume moves and deposits. Is it static? Is it staying in the same area? Are we outdoors? Is it windy? Is it raining? Are you indoors? Is the AC blowing too hard?

(08:09:07)
So it's really difficult to pinpoint and pin down just how far these particles are going to get in every single scenario. But we do know that up to 10 feet, even further than that, depending on your conditions, those GSR particles can be deposited at that distance away from the discharging firearm.

Brian Steel (08:09:30):

Now, in this case, Mr. Akers had the maximum, you just stopped counting, the maximum amount of gunshot residue on his hands. That's all that was checked, true?

Alexander Covin (08:09:49):

That is correct. The highest amount that we report out.

Brian Steel (08:09:57):

And that's consistent, I think your report states...

Brian Steel (08:10:00):

... the report states, it supports the possibility that the individual, in this case Mr. Akers, discharged the firearm, meaning he was holding the gun and pulled the trigger.

Alex Covin (08:10:16):

That is one possibility or was in close proximity to a firearm when it was discharged or touched something that had a lot of GSR on it already to transfer to both of his hands.

Brian Steel (08:10:30):

But one possibility in your report is that Mr. Akers fired the weapon?

Alex Covin (08:10:35):

That is one possibility, yes.

Jason Treadaway (08:10:37):

Asked and answered, [inaudible 08:10:39]. Three possibilities on cross. Next time he's asking it.

Dean Bucci (08:10:44):

Okay.

Brian Steel (08:10:46):

Do you remember being part of an email on February 28th, 2020 at 3:13 in the afternoon?

Alex Covin (08:10:57):

No, I do not. I do have emails, correspondences with me though.

Brian Steel (08:11:04):

That you reviewed to prepare for testimony today?

Alex Covin (08:11:09):

Yes.

Brian Steel (08:11:11):

I'd like to, with the court's permission, exchange emails and I'd like you to look at this one. Tell me if this looks familiar and I'd like to see yours if that's with the court's permission.

(08:11:25)
I'm going to mark this Ms. Boles number... Do you know the next one, 243?

Speaker 24 (08:11:48):

No, 143.

Brian Steel (08:11:48):

I meant 143.

Speaker 24 (08:11:48):

[inaudible 08:11:51].

Brian Steel (08:11:52):

Thank you.

(08:11:52)
Thank you.

(08:11:52)
Your Honor, may I approach?

Dean Bucci (08:12:19):

Yes, sir.

Brian Steel (08:12:22):

Sir, may I approach you?

Alex Covin (08:12:23):

Yes.

Brian Steel (08:12:23):

Do you mind looking at Ms. Boles 143, just tell me if you refresh your memory and I'd like to see yours with the court's permission, the emails that you sent? Thank you, sir. I'm going to show it to the prosecutor as well.

(08:12:41)
Tell me when you are ready.

Alex Covin (08:12:42):

I'm ready.

Brian Steel (08:12:46):

Do you remember that email at all?

Alex Covin (08:12:49):

Yes, I do.

Brian Steel (08:12:50):

All right. And you were a participant, a recipient of that email, true?

Alex Covin (08:12:54):

Yes, I was.

Brian Steel (08:12:55):

All right. And who wrote that email that we're talking about?

Alex Covin (08:13:01):

At the time, it was my manager, Michael Mccarriagher.

Brian Steel (08:13:04):

And who is that person today?

Alex Covin (08:13:09):

Today, he is now an assistant deputy director of the laboratory.

Brian Steel (08:13:15):

All right. Okay. And actually, you have the same email here. Did you not realize that?

Alex Covin (08:13:30):

Yes, I did. I just was unsure of what date.

Brian Steel (08:13:33):

Okay. That's fine. All right. I want to ask something though. You're a scientist, true?

Alex Covin (08:13:40):

Yes, I am.

Brian Steel (08:13:40):

You didn't go to school in order to be a rubber stamp for the prosecution, did you?

Alex Covin (08:13:52):

No, I did not.

Brian Steel (08:13:53):

And even though you work for the GBI crime lab, which is a prosecutorial agency, it's a law enforcement agency, right?

Alex Covin (08:14:00):

It's a law enforcement agency, although we release reports and give out opinions and conclusions regardless of who is asking for it.

Brian Steel (08:14:12):

But the only people who can ask for the GBI crime lab to assist is law enforcement, right?

Alex Covin (08:14:17):

That is correct. Yes.

Brian Steel (08:14:18):

I mean, if I asked you about a case for Ms. Boles, you would say you have to get permission from the prosecutor or some sheriff or something, right?

Alex Covin (08:14:26):

That's correct. It has to go through the proper channels for that.

Brian Steel (08:14:28):

I mean, you're on the team of the prosecution, but you yourself and the other scientists should be independent and neutral, right?

Alex Covin (08:14:36):

We are independent and neutral when it comes to our findings and our reports.

Brian Steel (08:14:41):

Have you ever told someone that, "Give me the evidence because it could be beneficial to our side," or anything like that? Do you do that?

Alex Covin (08:14:52):

No. Beneficial to whose side?

Brian Steel (08:14:56):

The prosecutor's side, we'll say law enforcement.

Alex Covin (08:14:58):

Do we...

Brian Steel (08:14:59):

Yeah. Do you ever think like that? Like, "Oh, let me test it because this could be great for the case."

Alex Covin (08:15:04):

No, that's not how we go about doing our examinations. We are impartial in our examinations.

Brian Steel (08:15:11):

You're just looking for truth, right?

Alex Covin (08:15:14):

That's correct.

Brian Steel (08:15:15):

And that's really your charge, right?

Alex Covin (08:15:19):

That's correct.

Brian Steel (08:15:19):

Because this is people's lives, no matter which side you're on, your work affects people, true?

Alex Covin (08:15:26):

Very true.

Brian Steel (08:15:28):

And when you got that email and you saw what was written, did you say to your then boss, "Why would you write such a thing?"

Alex Covin (08:15:41):

No. At the time, by that point, I had been doing GSR examinations going on for years, and I understood exactly why my manager said what he said in the email pertaining to assigning this examination to me. So, that's why it wasn't a question for me.

Brian Steel (08:16:04):

Did you see that it could be a good thing if there's no gunshot residue on Mr. Akers? I'm not quoting it, but did you see something? That's what you understood, right?

Alex Covin (08:16:18):

Right. So, for us, when it comes to examining victim's kits for GSR, that is not something that we routinely do at the GBI. In 2008, we released an operations bulletin saying that we're not going to routinely examine kits from victims of gunshot wounds, just due to the fact that we would expect them to have GSR on them and our examination will not add any information of value to the case. And so, every victim's kit that comes through the GBI, either we will send them back, we will release a report saying, "We're not going to examine this kit and here's why." Or if we're asked to still do the kit, we will go ahead and examine the kit with the caveat that, "Hey, this is a victim, and if we find GSR, it's not really going to give us any additional information in this case because we know this individual was already in close proximity to a firearm when it was discharged."

Brian Steel (08:17:28):

But if there was no GSR on the hands that you tested or the swipes that you tested, swabs that you tested for Mr. Akers, then that would've been almost conclusive he didn't pull that trigger.

Alex Covin (08:17:43):

If there was no GSR on his hands, that would have been a much better indicator that he was potentially not the shooter in this particular incident.

Brian Steel (08:17:55):

But we went the other side. He has the most amount of GSR in his hands that you calculate.

Alex Covin (08:18:01):

That is correct.

Brian Steel (08:18:02):

Which is consistent with what you said earlier, right?

Alex Covin (08:18:05):

That is correct.

Brian Steel (08:18:06):

That he's possibly the shooter?

Alex Covin (08:18:07):

Possibly a shooter or possibly just in close proximity when it went off or he touched something that had a lot of GSR on it.

Brian Steel (08:18:17):

If the shooter is in a doorway and the gun is discharged, and that's what law enforcement... I'm just asking you hypothetically, you're an expert, right? And that's what law enforcement believe. If the shooting comes from a doorway, could that doorway, the frame, that area be patted down, there's a word for it, but when the tabs, the stickers, can it be captured for potential GSR?

Alex Covin (08:18:48):

The doorway could be sampled for GSR. That's not something we normally see, but that is a surface that could be sampled for GSR.

Brian Steel (08:18:59):

It's wherever the supposed gun was fired from. We can look for evidence of GSR, right?

Alex Covin (08:19:06):

Correct.

Brian Steel (08:19:06):

And GSR simply is gunshot residue?

Alex Covin (08:19:09):

Correct.

Brian Steel (08:19:09):

And it's really not perfect because, like you said, if I get shot, I may have some gunshot residue on me depending upon the environment, the conditions, how close I was to the plume. But if I fired myself, if I committed suicide, you would expect to find more than five elements on my hand if I committed suicide.

Alex Covin (08:19:34):

Finding more than five particles of GSR is a reasonable expectation if you indeed committed suicide, yes.

Brian Steel (08:19:45):

Thank you, sir. Can I approach?

Dean Bucci (08:19:47):

Yes.

Brian Steel (08:19:49):

Do you want this one back or you don't care?

Alex Covin (08:19:51):

Yes, please.

Brian Steel (08:19:51):

May I exchange? I'm going to exchange.

Alex Covin (08:19:58):

Thank you.

Brian Steel (08:20:09):

You're welcome.

(08:20:09)
I don't have any other questions, Your Honor.

Jason Treadaway (08:20:12):

Is it also a reasonable expectation when you find these five particles on somebody's hand that they may have been shot as close distance by another?

Alex Covin (08:20:17):

That is also reasonable to expect.

Jason Treadaway (08:20:20):

Did I hear you right on cross-examination? Did you say that... I'm just going to use this pen. If I shot somebody from a distance of 10 feet, would you say that there still could be particles on their body?

Alex Covin (08:20:35):

Yes, there could. Yes.

Jason Treadaway (08:20:36):

Up to 10 feet out?

Alex Covin (08:20:37):

Up to 10 feet, maybe even more, depending on what conditions we're in, what kind of firearm was used, your positioning in relation to that firearm. Sometimes a bystander, somebody who had nothing to do with the shooting incident, can actually have more GSR on them than even the shooter.

Jason Treadaway (08:21:03):

Okay. You said one thing I wanted to touch on again, not asking you the same question, but I just want to go back to something you said on cross-examination. You said that GSR particles, barium, antimony, and lead can remain on the surface or skin even indefinitely until it's acted upon by some other force. Do you remember saying that?

Alex Covin (08:21:23):

Yes, that's correct.

Jason Treadaway (08:21:24):

Can it be washed off?

Alex Covin (08:21:26):

Yes. If you have GSR particles on your hands, washing your hands will cause you to lose most, if not all, of those particles right at that moment.

Jason Treadaway (08:21:37):

So, in a scenario where someone discharged a firearm, for example, and then immediately went upstairs and maybe washed their hands in an upstairs sink, could that get rid of most or all of the GSR, possibly?

Alex Covin (08:21:52):

Yes, that would.

Jason Treadaway (08:21:54):

All right. Thank you, sir.

Dean Bucci (08:21:54):

Any [inaudible 08:21:56] defense?

Brian Steel (08:21:54):

No, sir.

Dean Bucci (08:21:59):

All right, sir. Thank you very much.

Alex Covin (08:22:02):

Thank you.

Dean Bucci (08:22:03):

Ladies and gentlemen, we're going to have dinner for you. It's going to get here shortly after five o'clock, so you can plan on a break about that time. In the meantime, do you have another witness?

Jason Treadaway (08:22:12):

Yes, Your Honor. May I please call Audey Murphy?

Dean Bucci (08:22:37):

Yes, sir. Good afternoon, sir. I'll swear you in. If you could please raise your right hand to receive an oath. Do you swear or affirm the testimony you're about to give in the matter pending before the court will be the truth, the whole truth, and nothing but the truth, so help you God?

Audey Murphy (08:23:15):

I do.

Dean Bucci (08:23:16):

Please have a seat.

(08:23:22)
Yes, sir. Go ahead.

Jason Treadaway (08:23:25):

Good afternoon, sir. Can you tell the jury your name, sir?

Audey Murphy (08:23:27):

It's Audey Murphy.

Jason Treadaway (08:23:28):

Can you spell it just for the record?

Audey Murphy (08:23:29):

A-U-D-E-Y M-U-R-P-H-Y.

Jason Treadaway (08:23:34):

All right, sir. Can you please tell the jury members how you were employed? Basically just track your employment and your experience through law enforcement, if you will.

Audey Murphy (08:23:50):

Well, I joined Alabama Department of Forensic Science, working part-time. I would really pick up the bodies at the crime scene and take them to autopsy where I'd help with the autopsies. And then I became a police officer in Gadsden, Alabama for almost five years, and I worked as a GBI agent for about 25 years. The last 21 of those years, I was a crime scene specialist.

Jason Treadaway (08:24:05):

Can you tell the jury, please, your training, your experience in the area of firearms examination, ballistics, and crime scene reconstruction?

Audey Murphy (08:24:17):

Well, my bachelor's degree is in forensic investigations. I'm also a graduate of the National Forensic Academy, which is in Knoxville, Tennessee. It's basically a 10-week academy just for crime scene investigators. It goes into blood pattern analysis, shooting reconstructions, clandestine bodies, pretty much every aspect of crime scene investigation. Over 30 years of experience in the process of crime scenes, been doing on the job training from fingerprints, photography, crime scene sketches, again, the shooting reconstructions, death investigation, just various aspects of it.

Jason Treadaway (08:24:55):

For the crime scene processing area, is it 21 years?

Audey Murphy (08:25:03):

I did 21 years as a crime scene specialist, but I've been doing crime scene work for almost 30 years.

Jason Treadaway (08:25:08):

Was the majority of your crime scene specialty work done with the GBI?

Audey Murphy (08:25:11):

Yes.

Jason Treadaway (08:25:13):

Did you ever work for Paulding County Sheriff's Office?

Audey Murphy (08:25:15):

No.

Jason Treadaway (08:25:18):

All right. Have you processed scenes first as a law enforcement officer before your work as a crime scene specialist with GBI?

Audey Murphy (08:25:25):

Yes. When I was a patrol officer with the Gadsden Police Department, I started doing crime scene work with them for about my last two years with them.

Jason Treadaway (08:25:31):

And then transitioning to GBI 21 years as crime scene specialist, have you had an opportunity to go into various crime scenes, process the scene, and do everything related to the processing or the investigation of the scene itself?

Audey Murphy (08:25:45):

Yes. Over the course of my career, I've probably worked between 400 to 500 death investigation cases.

Jason Treadaway (08:25:52):

All right. Was your experience limited, sir, to death investigations or would you go and say shootings where people did not... They were not mortal shootings, but did you go to shootings and other violent crimes, armed robberies, violent kidnappings, burglaries that did not involve death?

Audey Murphy (08:26:11):

Most of my cases were death investigations. However, occasionally I would get called to an armed robbery, an aggravated assault, an officer involved shooting, things like that as well. But the vast majority of them were death investigations.

Jason Treadaway (08:26:25):

Have you testified as an expert in the State of Georgia previously before today?

Audey Murphy (08:26:30):

Yes, I have.

Jason Treadaway (08:26:30):

Do you know how many times?

Audey Murphy (08:26:33):

No, but I know it's been at least 12 different judicial circuits, including the two federal circuits.

Jason Treadaway (08:26:40):

In what area of expertise were you tendered in those circuits, sir?

Audey Murphy (08:26:45):

Crime scene reconstruction, blood pattern analysis, firearms, and shoot reconstructions.

Jason Treadaway (08:26:54):

Did you have to attend and did you in fact attend annual training or annual recertifications, continuing education in your field when you were working with the GBI?

Audey Murphy (08:27:06):

Yes, we had yearly training as crime scene investigators, as long as with the GBI. We also had our regular agent trainings every year with the GBI. I've also been certified by the National Forensics Association as a crime scene analyst.

Jason Treadaway (08:27:19):

I tender the witness, Your Honor, respectfully as an expert in the area of crime scene analysis, forensic examination, blood pattern analysis, ballistics, and firearms examination.

Brian Steel (08:27:31):

I will object. I have zero CV notice. I'm objecting. Report.

Dean Bucci (08:27:41):

Any response, Mr. Tredaway?

Jason Treadaway (08:27:42):

No, Your Honor.

Dean Bucci (08:27:44):

No?

Jason Treadaway (08:27:45):

I'd like to take it up outside the presence of the jury.

Dean Bucci (08:27:50):

All right, let's step out.

(08:28:34)
All right. Go ahead, sir.

Jason Treadaway (08:28:34):

If it pleases the court, Your Honor, [inaudible 08:28:35] have a CV for given witness-

Dean Bucci (08:28:36):

Sir, can you step out while we have a discussion and then we'll let you back in? Okay.

(08:28:54)
All right, sir, whenever you're ready.

Jason Treadaway (08:28:56):

Your Honor, respectfully, I've put the defense on notice for well over a year now that this witness is going to be called, including all his contact information. I don't have a CV for him. I've never seen it, but the defense has been properly placed on notice of this witness with his prior experiences having worked with the GBI. They're free to contact him if they wanted to. And I don't have a CV for him. I don't have a report. He's never generated any written report involved in this case, to my knowledge, and he's certainly passed the standards for being qualified and tendered as an expert in the areas for which he was offered. Thank you.

Dean Bucci (08:29:36):

All right. Anything else, Mr. Steel?

Brian Steel (08:29:41):

Yes. I have a witness list served upon us in the State of Georgia. I have number 17 on the witness list that is dated 7th day of May 2025. It says the gentleman's name, Audey Murphy, A-U-D-E-Y M-U-R-P-H-Y. It has nothing else except this phone number that ends in 6474. I have nothing to suggest that he is going to be a crime scene reconstructionist at all. I have one, a three paragraph, maybe 17- line report that is a combination report of his and Nick, Detective Hardy, and it says he just inspected the gun. That's all it says. I have had no notice that he was coming in to do anything except say I inspected that gun for impact spatter. That's it.

(08:31:01)
So, I would have, because knowing me, I just know me, I would have interviewed him. I would have checked his CV. I would have checked the cases he would have done. I would have called experts to determine what he is. I would have asked this honorable court to hold a Daubert hearing so I could get a report and an understanding of exactly what he's going to testify to. So, if Ms. Boles needed an expert on that topic, I would get a crime scene investigator expert.

Dean Bucci (08:31:29):

All right. Anything else from the state?

Jason Treadaway (08:31:32):

I can [inaudible 08:31:32]. I don't expect to foray off into crime scene reconstruction or blood spatter analysis other than blood spatter that's possibly on the firearm itself. His testimony would be limited to what he saw on the firearm itself. I have coincidentally also received a witness list from the defense that had a Dr. Eric Warren on it. I did receive a CV, but no written report. I have no idea what he's going to testify to. I tried to call him actually, and he wouldn't return my call, wouldn't answer my call. So, I've been provided the bare minimum by the defense and I've provided what I have to the defense. I provided the man's name, his contact information, and there is a report obviously showing what he did. And I think the defense has probably been placed on notice as to the nature of his testimony because they read a report that he made.

(08:32:21)
And I'm not going to go away from that report, but he certainly qualifies as an expert, certainly can be subject to cross-examination, thorough and sitting cross-examination by the defense. And if the defense chooses based on whatever he testifies to refute his testimony or rebut it to their own expert, they do have firearm... They do have... By the way, I think it's notable to point out that they have at least served... I'm not saying, Your Honor under any obligation to present any evidence or call any witnesses, but they have served us with an abundant notice of, and/or a written report of somebody named Ross Gardner, who is a ballistics expert, who is a spatter expert, who is a reconstruction expert. So, let's not act like there's going to have to be a search for someone to rebut this evidence. They've already found someone to rebut this evidence and retain them.

(08:33:09)
So, that certainly can be done through their own witness and rebuttal if they choose to do it. So, it's not like we're springing a witness at the last minute in the area of the outer moons of Saturn. I mean, this is expected testimony. There's a report they're going to say to what he's going to say that was provided years ago, years. So, I think we've met the minimal requirements of putting the defense on notice. Thank you.

Dean Bucci (08:33:35):

Mr. Steel says that the report is something different than crime scene analyst.

Jason Treadaway (08:33:41):

It's about a firearm examination and analysis in this case, specifically the state's evidence of the firearm. This defendant, I expect, anticipate that what he would say is he didn't look at the firearm, did not see this or did see that regarding back spatter or blood spatter on the firearm itself. Again, possibly, admittedly, Your Honor, I admit I may have tendered him for things that he's certainly qualified in. I do believe he's qualified in everything he's been tendered, and he's already been tendered in the state courts and federal courts in all of those aspects. But my testimony that I'll try to elicit from him and my reason for tendering would probably be limited only to firearms analysis and blood spatter analysis as it pertains to that firearm.

Dean Bucci (08:34:23):

All right. It sounds like the objection is the notice was limited.

Brian Steel (08:34:30):

I haven't even been told he's an expert. I have a phone number. It doesn't even say GBI, but I do have a report. I'm just going to read it with the court's permission. It will not take long, if that's okay.

Dean Bucci (08:34:40):

Okay.

Brian Steel (08:34:41):

This is the sum and substance. There's more to the report, but after you introduced the parties, it's in paragraph two. "Upon opening the box, Agent Murphy found a High Standard Sentinel, S-E-N-T-I-N-E-L, 22-caliber revolver bearing serial number that ends in 661. Agent Murphy noted transfer stains near the grip of the weapon. No impact spatter, S-P-A-T-T-E-R was found on any part of the weapon, including the barrel opening. Photographs taken of the weapon by Agent Murphy are attached to the summary. That's it. If he testifies to that, I got no problem. But if he starts going into what should have been found, what does cause, what is impact spatter, what happens when a bullet enters the nostril, the head has a lot of blood in it, I'm objecting. I had no notice of that. I had nothing. I mean, this is... And what I did, by the way, if the state wants to somehow, I don't know why it even matters, I had a report for everyone but a firearms expert because there really isn't that much to say for him.

(08:35:53)
But on Ross Gardner, who he just spoke about, I had him write a report. It wasn't needed for Dr. Terry she didn't have time to write a report. I took the oral statements she made to me and I put that in writing and I gave it to the state. Dr. Downs, I have a report from Dr. Downs with photographs. This is the new Daubert life and we're supposed to all allow the gatekeeper to determine what comes in or not comes in. I have zero notice. So, yes, I'm objecting to the expertise. He could say, "I examined the weapon." I have no problem with him saying that. I could examine a weapon and he didn't see any blood on it that he considers to be impact spatter. And that I would expect to be no more expertise. That's my... I am blindsided.

Jason Treadaway (08:36:43):

I think it begs the question, how would he know that there was no impact spatter if he doesn't know what it is? So, I think to limit it by not being able to say what impact spatter or blow back spatter is, I mean, that's not going to be reasonable because he's going to say, "I did not note any back spatter or impact spatter of the weapon." And I'm supposed to be limited to not even be able to ask him what that is. Clearly he knows what that is. He wouldn't have put that in his report. But with Dr. Eric Warren, again, like I say, I don't have a report on that expert either. I just have to come in and listen to what he has to say. The defense has every report ever made by Audey Murphy in this case. So, they have plenty of notice as to what's to be said. I have no idea what Dr. Eric Warren is going to say because I wasn't given a report at all.

(08:37:29)
And I did reach out to that expert to try to contact him. He won't talk to me. So, had the defense contacted Mr. Murphy, I'm sure he would have been, or I hope he would have been, I hope he would have been readily agreed to talk to the defense, unlike the witness I reached speak to. So, I think the notice element has been satisfied, Your Honor, whatever weight the jury gives to this witness, that's up to the jury. I'm not going to be getting into is the head full of blood or the nose full of blood? I'm not going to be getting into that type of evidence. This is very limited witness. What is back spatter, impact spatter? Did you see any on the weapon? That's it. This is what's limited and confined to his report. And I apologize. I probably was misleading perhaps in trying to tender him in all these different areas.

(08:38:25)
He said he's an expert in all these different areas, but my focus and what I'm seeking to tender him as is really just an expert in blood spatter at least to the degree that it would be on the weapon or not. And then obviously he has a vast knowledge of firearms, so he knows what to look for with the firearm. He looked at it. He knows what he's looking at. He did not see any spatter or back spatter. So, it's really it.

Dean Bucci (08:38:50):

All right. But to be clear, you're not just going to say, "Did you see any spatter or what it is?" You're going to ask for expert opinions.

Jason Treadaway (08:38:57):

No, I'm going to ask him what is back spatter? What is impact spatter? Did you see any on this weapon? What is that? Did you see? How did you look for it? How did you look for it? Did you use naked eye? Did you use a microscope? Did you do a swab with some kind of blue star or anything? How did you seek to find this back spatter or blood spatter on the weapon itself? How did you seek to find it? Naked eye? I don't remember what he said in his report, but the point is he didn't note any as being present.

Dean Bucci (08:39:30):

And if he stays away from opinions, you still have an objection?

Brian Steel (08:39:35):

I'll object along the way, but I have no objection to the gentleman saying, "I did not see impact spatter on the weapon that I looked at."

Dean Bucci (08:39:45):

And what that is.

Brian Steel (08:39:47):

And if that's what we're here for in three minutes, I have no questions.

Dean Bucci (08:39:51):

Is it that simple?

Jason Treadaway (08:39:52):

Yes, sir. But I didn't hear... I misunderstood what Mr. Steel said. I do plan to ask him what is back spatter or blood spatter?

Dean Bucci (08:40:00):

Okay.

Jason Treadaway (08:40:01):

And did you see any here on this weapon? That's it.

Dean Bucci (08:40:04):

If it's that simple, then we don't have an issue.

Jason Treadaway (08:40:06):

Okay.

Dean Bucci (08:40:07):

So, why don't we get them back in here? That eliminates the need for me to take a break and reread 17-16-4, and we'll have a short witness, it sounds like, and then we'll have dinner.

Brian Steel (08:40:22):

And I'll tell you 17-16-4, also it's Dewey Green, D-E-W-E-Y G-R-E-E-N. I don't believe there's an E at the end. And it comes from the Georgia Supreme Court. And I didn't have to give any report, but you have to give notice and the CV and the expertise and the fields. I did that with Dr. Warren and everyone else. I have a report. The state gave nothing. I'm not going to rehash it.

Dean Bucci (08:40:50):

But it sounds like at this point it's kind of moot because they're not going to get beyond that.

Brian Steel (08:40:55):

I understand.

Dean Bucci (08:40:56):

Okay. All right. Let's get them back and let's get the jury back.

Brian Steel (08:41:02):

I will be objecting if he's saying I expected to find something. That would be expertise, but I didn't hear that question, so I assume that won't come.

Jason Treadaway (08:41:12):

I'd like to take a moment, Your Honor, respectfully, if you'll permit me to go out and explain to the witness-

Brian Steel (08:41:14):

Sure. That'd be great.

Jason Treadaway (08:41:15):

Don't just blurt something out.

Dean Bucci (08:41:20):

I think that'd be smart.

Jason Treadaway (08:41:20):

Thank you.

Dean Bucci (08:41:20):

Just hold on one second. We're going to have him back in a minute.

(08:41:21)
All right, let's have him back, [inaudible 08:43:53].

(08:43:52)
Okay, let's resume.

Jason Treadaway (08:43:53):

Your Honor, last thing I remember is tendering the witness as an expert. I'll limit those areas to firearms analysis and [inaudible 08:44:03]-

Brian Steel (08:44:04):

I object.

Dean Bucci (08:44:06):

All right. I though that it was going to be more limited than that based on what we just discussed.

Jason Treadaway (08:44:10):

That's fine. I won't tender him as an expert then, I'm just asking. So, did you have an opportunity to review a firearm in this case, in this investigation of Daniel Akers' death?

Audey Murphy (08:44:22):

Yes, I did.

Jason Treadaway (08:44:23):

Okay. Let me show you this firearm that's included in State's Exhibit 173.

Dean Bucci (08:44:35):

There's gloves right here if you prefer. It's up to you, sir.

Jason Treadaway (08:44:42):

Okay. Okay. Did you have an opportunity to look at that firearm and examine it in connection with your work on this case?

Audey Murphy (08:44:50):

Yes, I did.

Jason Treadaway (08:44:59):

Do you know when you did that?

Audey Murphy (08:44:59):

May 20th, 2020.

Jason Treadaway (08:44:59):

All right, sir. Do you know where you completed your analysis of it in May of 2020?

Speaker 25 (08:45:00):

Where had you completed your analysis of it in May of 2020, sir?

Speaker 26 (08:45:04):

Yes, I went to Paulding County Sheriff's Office in evidence room processing area and I did the work there.

Speaker 25 (08:45:12):

Okay. Can you tell the jury, do you know what backspatter is?

Speaker 26 (08:45:18):

Yes. Backspatter is the blood that is projected back towards the weapon. As the bullet travels into the body, it strikes the body and it carries a lot of energy with it. That energy projects the blood back towards the weapon and that's called backspatter.

Speaker 25 (08:45:31):

Okay. Did you conduct as part of your analysis in this case an examination looking for that type of backspatter?

Speaker 26 (08:45:40):

Yes, I did.

(08:45:40)
Can you tell

Speaker 25 (08:45:41):

The jury please how you undertook that analysis?

Speaker 26 (08:45:45):

So you're looking for small drops of blood and we're using a magnifying glass, a bright flashlight, and that's really all you need.

Speaker 25 (08:45:53):

Okay. Is that the way you've done it before and after... Well, I don't know if this is your last case. Have you done it like that before?

Speaker 26 (08:46:00):

Yes.

Speaker 25 (08:46:00):

Is that a method that's common to you?

Speaker 26 (08:46:03):

Yes, it is.

Speaker 25 (08:46:04):

Did you find the presence of backspatter on this firearm anywhere?

Speaker 26 (08:46:07):

No, I did not.

Speaker 25 (08:46:09):

Okay. Is it also called impact spatter? Is that different?

Speaker 26 (08:46:16):

No, impact spatter is just a general term that has several different things under it. It could be impact from a gun, impact from a blunt object. There's different types of impact spatter. Backspatter is a type of impact spatter.

Speaker 25 (08:46:32):

Okay. I understand, sir. I believe that's all the questions I have. Thank you. I'm sorry, just a moment. Just one second.

Judge (08:46:47):

Yes, sir.

Speaker 25 (08:46:50):

Did you look... Can you tell the jury just... I'm sorry. Can you tell the jury the areas of the weapon where you passed the magnifying glass and the bright light and looked for it? What areas, if any, did you look at?

Speaker 26 (08:47:02):

We're checking the entire gun, the barrel, inside the barrel as best you can, the tip of the barrel towards the revolver, the actual wheel of the revolver, all areas of it.

Speaker 25 (08:47:14):

Okay. Did you look for it inside the cylinder, the cylinder bores?

Speaker 26 (08:47:25):

Yes. As best I can, I'm checking the entire weapon and I did not find any.

Speaker 25 (08:47:29):

Did you look for it on the ejection rod here?

Speaker 26 (08:47:33):

Yes.

Speaker 25 (08:47:34):

Okay. Did you see any there either?

Speaker 26 (08:47:35):

No.

Speaker 25 (08:47:36):

What about the muzzle tip? Did you see any, I'm sorry, backspatter on that part of the weapon?

Speaker 26 (08:47:42):

There was no backspatter on any part of the weapon.

Speaker 25 (08:47:44):

All right, thank you. That's all I have.

Judge (08:47:46):

Any cross?

Speaker 27 (08:47:47):

No, sir.

Judge (08:47:48):

Okay. Can he be excused?

Speaker 25 (08:47:50):

No objection. Thank you.

Judge (08:47:52):

All right. Thank you so much, sir. All right. We will take a break. Why don't we say about half an hour and Diana, you'll take them down to the break room? They can get whatever they want and bring it back. I just don't think there's a lot of seating in there and then obviously [inaudible 08:48:10].

Speaker 28 (08:48:03):

[inaudible 08:48:12].

Judge (08:48:14):

On the first floor. Okay And I'll check in about a half an hour and see if y'all need more time, okay? All right, gentlemen, do we need to discuss anything before the break?

Speaker 27 (08:48:45):

Not at this time.

Judge (08:48:45):

No?

Speaker 27 (08:48:46):

The only issue I may have, Your Honor, depending upon... I'll talk with the state about their progress on the case. There's Dr. Warren, who we're just speaking of, he cannot testify next week and he can only testify tomorrow. So I'll speak with the state first, but that may be an issue.

Judge (08:49:09):

Okay. Y'all have food? Have dinner?

Speaker 25 (08:49:13):

Get any machine out here, Judge.

Judge (08:49:16):

Well, we may have pizza if you need it.

Speaker 25 (08:49:18):

Thank you.

Judge (08:49:19):

Shout if you do. All right. See you in half an hour.

Speaker 27 (08:49:25):

Can you guys tell us where you're looking?

Speaker 25 (08:49:25):

Yes, sir [inaudible 08:49:31]

The Court (09:21:48):

30 minutes, I think it's been about 40, so-

Speaker 30 (09:22:11):

You want me to round them up?

The Court (09:22:12):

... you want to round them up?

Speaker 29 (09:22:12):

I think we actually left about five after.

The Court (09:22:12):

Oh, is that right? So 35 and not 40?

Speaker 29 (09:22:25):

The jury was walking out at 5:00, but we didn't leave until 5 and 10 after so I'll come and [inaudible 09:22:34].

The Court (09:22:46):

You want to check in with them and see if they're ready to come in? They are ready? Okay. Y'all ready?

Mr. Steel (09:22:51):

Can I just make something brief? So the next witness was announced. I don't know who the witnesses are thereafter, but according to what we have on an interview, he talks about smoking marijuana with Lacy Boles. He talks about that he doesn't believe that Mr. Akers would kill himself or commit harm himself.

The Court (09:23:16):

Who's this? This is the next witness going to say this?

Mr. Steel (09:23:22):

James Poag.

The Court (09:23:24):

Well, he said it in the interview.

Mr. Steel (09:23:24):

He said it in the interview, but my objection, our objection is it's going to be a colossal waste of time because we're going to object to character. We're going to object to he can't talk about someone else's state of mind. And he talks about that Lacy Boles struck... I'm not saying it's true, but struck Mr. Akers' mother with her hands, fists or open hand. None of that has any relevance in our case. We have not put Lacy Boles' character in issue at all. The court has already excluded any drug use of Ms. Boles. So I really don't know if there's any more import to this person, but I'm objecting. And I figured we should do it here rather than-

The Court (09:24:11):

And this was not something we discussed in any pretrial motion.

Mr. Steel (09:24:15):

I think you did. You ruled Ms. Boles' drug use cannot come in. You ruled nothing of violence on her except what you admitted over objection that she... I'm not so sure it's violent. You said it's not violent that she got a gun.

The Court (09:24:34):

I remember with respect to a recording ordering that some of that kind of thing came out. I just don't recall. And that's why I'm asking you that with respect to a particular witness's testimony that-

Mr. Steel (09:24:45):

It's a series of witnesses. There's a lot of people, a lot of the family members and then victim impact I'm objecting to that, oh, I missed Mr. Akers. He was great. He's a great father and a great member of the community. None of that under Walker, W-A-L-K-E-R, Waller, W-A-L-L-E-R rather, versus state. I'll give you Sanchez Waller, but you can't get in victim impact either that I'm so hurt, I miss him so much. I'm just objecting now. I hope it doesn't come out, but if it does, it shouldn't come out. None of that should come out.

The Court (09:25:22):

All right. So y'all are about to call a witness and you hear the concern and you care to address that?

Mr. Treadaway (09:25:28):

Yes, Sir.

The Court (09:25:28):

Okay.

Mr. Treadaway (09:25:28):

I'm aware of the court's pretrial ruling.

The Court (09:25:31):

You don't expect that to come out? No victim impact or anything like that?

Mr. Treadaway (09:25:34):

I expect it to say what kind of person was he? I don't think that goes to any kind of improper question. And this guy has known him for 20 years, so I don't think that's improper. I think this witness was a witness. He was witness to a lot of the marital difficulties, the arguments, the fights, and he's told me that he heard those types of arguments on the phone. Statements made by this defendant on the phone, his coworker, Mr. Akers, who put the speaker on speakerphone while they were at lunch at the construction site. And it just is a very tumultuous relationship that he heard. And I think that's already been brought before the jury on both sides, obviously.

(09:26:23)
Let me just go over some of my other questions that might possibly draw an objection. I hope they don't, but how did he hear about Dan's death? I do have, what was your reaction when it was alleged that he killed himself? I think that's admissible evidence. How did you find out about the memorial service? I think that's important. What was your impression of that event? Did you interact with this defendant at that event? What's her demeanor that you witnessed? I think those are all the admissible questions and a few others that I think are admissible. So that's kind of the general nature of a lot of these witnesses.

(09:27:09)
I think that Mr. Steel is right. We will be transitioning to a lot of lay people now and that's I think the kind of gist of a lot of these lay witnesses would be mostly like that and those types of questions. I'm not planning on playing this recording that Mr. Steel mentioned playing that. Certainly go out and counsel the gentleman not to talk about drug use or extramarital affairs or anything like that that was ruled inadmissible. I do think those areas that I just brought to the court's attention are admissible.

The Court (09:27:37):

Let's try to deal with as much as we can before we get that in. Are you going to object to any of those?

Mr. Steel (09:27:38):

Yes.

The Court (09:27:42):

Do you want to take a moment home?

Mr. Steel (09:27:43):

Sure. What his reaction was when he heard his death, why does that matter?

The Court (09:27:54):

What's the relevance of that?

Mr. Treadaway (09:27:58):

The idea of suicide is contrary to what he personally observed with this defendant. And I expect the witness to say that he never had a concern about Dan's mental health to the point where he ever had to seek health or help or treatment for the gentleman. He never reported to anybody else he was concerned about this gentleman's mental health or his state of mind at all. And therefore I expect to say he was surprised when he heard that. That's what I anticipate he would said. I think it's very relevant because it goes to the... We talked a lot about state of mind. Those text messages came in to say state of mind of the victim at the time and a state of mind of the victim at the time based on those who knew him well and knew him for over 20 years is relevant and missing.

Mr. Steel (09:28:42):

I object to all of it. All of that. I can't even grasp why it matters what his thought process was on Mr. Akers' state of mind. He can't comment on his state of mind. No one can. And his reaction, meaning Mr. P-O-A-G reaction is irrelevant. He might have been surprised or he may have said, oh yeah, that's sure he killed himself. I couldn't put that up either. You have to prove it by evidence, not by somebody else's opinion of what a person would do. A lot of people commit suicide, God forbid. It's surprising to people and that's not for cross. Also, the district attorney said they've known each other for 20 years. The way I understand their relationship is they were co-conspirators and co-indictees and co-defendants and pled guilty to a burglary in 2002 and they were both sentenced. Then Mr. Poag stayed away from Mr. Akers because Mr. Akers was abusing drugs. Methamphetamine, they had smoked together. I mean, this is not what the trial's about.

The Court (09:29:55):

He said he's not getting into that.

Mr. Steel (09:29:57):

It was Mr. Akers and Mr. Poag smoking the methamphetamine together. I mean, we are so far afield. So yes, I'm objecting to it. The memorial service, his reaction to it. Okay, he loved it or hated it. What difference does it make? Now, if Ms. Boles is at the memorial service and she's handing out her numbers saying, "I'm single now," I think that that may be something that the court thinks is interesting, but I don't think that that's what happened.

The Court (09:30:24):

Okay. Well, so no argument about her demeanor at the service. But the witness's impression of the event, how's that relevant?

Mr. Treadaway (09:30:36):

I think Mr. Steel sounds like, respectfully, it sounds like he just conceded that bizarre behavior and memorial service would be relevant. He just conceded that and said that if she were there handing out her number and says, "I'm single now." That's not the only bizarre activity or bizarre behavior that one could exhibit at a funeral. And I think the jury has a right to form whatever opinion they will to this defendant's bizarre behavior at-

The Court (09:31:04):

I tend to agree with you that the defendant's behavior may be relevant at the service, but I think one of the questions you said you were planning on asking is what was the witness's impression of the service? What did he think about it?

Mr. Treadaway (09:31:18):

I can change it to-

The Court (09:31:19):

Okay.

Mr. Treadaway (09:31:19):

... did you have on here after that? Did you interact with this defendant at the memorial service? What was her behavior at the memorial service?

The Court (09:31:29):

Okay. How this person found out about the service, I don't really see any relevance to that.

Mr. Treadaway (09:31:35):

This is a gentleman who knew Mr. Akers for over 20 years. He found out about this service by seeing it on the internet, pointing that this defendant, anybody else in the defendant's family widely broadcast the fact that this guy had died and there's a funeral. This is a 20 year acquaintance of the decedent and saw it on the internet by chance to come to the funeral. I mean, this is bizarre postmortem behavior. I think the jury can put whatever weight that they choose to give it. I think they should be allowed to hear odd behavior on the part of this defendant after this man has supposedly committed suicide. Thank you.

Mr. Steel (09:32:17):

I'm objecting to that too. I didn't realize that that's the demeanor under 401, 402 and 24-403, there's no place in here. The fact that the person wasn't notified of the memorial service, that now is going to fall in a murder trial of Lacy Boles. I don't see any relevance and if it is at all relevant, I think it's too prejudicial.

The Court (09:32:43):

The only relevance that I've seen so far, respectfully, is possibly her demeanor at the service. One of the things we talked about, sorry I keep clearing my throat like that, was we want to stay away from if the decedent was the type of person who would do this, would kill himself. And so when you're asking were you surprised, then I wonder if we're getting close to that because why would he be surprised? Because he's not the type of person that would kill himself.

Mr. Treadaway (09:33:23):

Respectfully, just that having known him up until right at that point, having interacted with him repeatedly, he never showed any signs of being overly depressed.

The Court (09:33:31):

I see no problem with that.

Mr. Treadaway (09:33:34):

Okay. Well then I won't ask what was your reaction, but I did plan on asking those types of questions. Was he depressed in the time when he went to his death that you saw him? Did you have concerns to the point where you contacted mental health professionals, anything like that?

The Court (09:33:50):

I think that's fair again. You may disagree with me, Mr. Steel. You want to argue?

Mr. Steel (09:33:53):

It's over objection, Your Honor. It'd be over objection, but if we could just make our objection now and it's continuous.

The Court (09:34:01):

All right. So you're permitted to ask questions such as did you see any signs, overt signs, or however you want to phrase that, of depression or like you put it Mr. Treadaway, to the point where you felt like you had to do something. I'm going to admit that and then the defendant's demeanor. And you've already said you're staying away from drug use at your marital affairs. And then I gave you a couple rulings to stay away from how did you find out and were you surprised? Is there anything else we can take up now?

Mr. Treadaway (09:34:35):

Yes, sir. There was a bulk of the direct examination. I don't believe the court really touched on it, was about the nature of the relationship between the parties. I think this witness had direct knowledge and exposure to the relationship between the parties. I think he would testify that it was extremely volatile. I don't think that's a surprise. I think that's out there in front of the jury already, but I do think he would testify to that.

The Court (09:35:00):

Any objections to that?

Mr. Steel (09:35:03):

Volatile in what? Did Lacy Boles pick up a hammer and strike Mr. Akers? I should have had 404B evidence on this. So I don't know what it is. That they didn't get along at times, I'll concede that.

The Court (09:35:16):

All right. I'm kind of inclined to allow that. What else?

Mr. Treadaway (09:35:30):

I had... I'm just going to be... I hate to tip my hand on my entire examination, but I am going to be asking him about did this witness ever see this decedent carrying a gun?

The Court (09:35:42):

Okay.

Mr. Treadaway (09:35:43):

Was he frequently a gun person, go shooting, carry a gun on a holster, in his pocket, on his person? Did you see that? And I believe this witness has the ability firsthand and personal knowledge to testify to that.

The Court (09:35:54):

I see some relevance. All right. What else?

Mr. Treadaway (09:36:03):

Okay. I believe that this witness would be able to testify based on his having worked with the decedent on a construction type of job. Was he right-handed or left-handed? What hand dominant?

The Court (09:36:14):

I have no problem with that. If Mr. Steel does he can tell me.

Mr. Steel (09:36:17):

No objection to that.

Mr. Treadaway (09:36:20):

Those are really the only areas and it'll be similar to with all of these witnesses.

The Court (09:36:26):

All right. Let's have the jury out.

Mr. Treadaway (09:36:26):

I guess we can take a more-

Mr. Steel (09:36:30):

Can the witness be told so that... I don't know what-

Mr. Treadaway (09:36:32):

I would like some time to [inaudible 09:36:33].

The Court (09:36:33):

Sure. Why don't you do that?

Mr. Treadaway (09:36:33):

All right. So just a couple more minutes.

Mr. Steel (09:36:36):

Can they possibly huddle with all the witnesses since we don't have to do this every single time?

The Court (09:36:40):

Do what you can, Mr. Treadaway.

Mr. Treadaway (09:36:42):

I'm obviously going to tell these people, "Hey, this is not in. Don't blurt it out."

The Court (09:36:46):

That'd be great.

Mr. Treadaway (09:36:47):

Thank you.

(09:36:47)
Yes, Your Honor. The witness is aware of Your Honor's ruling.

The Court (09:38:57):

Okay. Thank you for that. And we'll have the jury. I don't know if Diane is still there. Welcome back, ladies and gentlemen. I hope dinner was satisfactory, and I can't tell you how much we appreciate y'all going the extra mile and staying late today and tomorrow. Let's continue.

Mr. Treadaway (09:40:14):

Please the court. The state calls James Poag. James Poag.

The Court (09:40:16):

Mr. Poag, welcome. Let me swear you in, please. Will you raise your right hand to receive an oath? Excuse me. Do you swear or affirm that the testimony you're about to give in the matter before the court will be the truth, the whole truth, and nothing but the truth, so help you God?

James Poag (09:41:04):

Yes.

The Court (09:41:04):

All right. Please have a seat. Please use the microphone.

Mr. Treadaway (09:41:09):

Mr. Poag, if you would kind of just make sure that mic is pointed to you, sir, and tell the jury members your name, please.

James Poag (09:41:14):

James Poag.

Mr. Treadaway (09:41:15):

How do you spell your last name, sir?

James Poag (09:41:19):

P-O-A-G.

Mr. Treadaway (09:41:22):

How are you employed today, sir?

James Poag (09:41:24):

I'm sorry?

Mr. Treadaway (09:41:25):

How are you employed nowadays?

James Poag (09:41:28):

How am I employed?

Mr. Treadaway (09:41:29):

Where do you work?

James Poag (09:41:31):

Peterson Aluminum.

Mr. Treadaway (09:41:32):

Okay. Construction?

James Poag (09:41:34):

Make metal roofing panels.

Mr. Treadaway (09:41:37):

Okay. More of a fabrication type job?

James Poag (09:41:39):

Correct.

Mr. Treadaway (09:41:39):

And what's your age, please?

James Poag (09:41:41):

I'm sorry?

Mr. Treadaway (09:41:42):

How old are you, sir? I know Mr. Poag, I should say to the court and explain to the jury, Mr. Poag has a little bit of a hearing disorder or an audible disorder. May I prove, may I move just closer to him?

The Court (09:41:52):

Of course.

Mr. Treadaway (09:41:52):

I'm sorry, Mr. Poag. I remember now you have a little bit of a hearing disability. I'm sorry. Do you live in this area?

James Poag (09:42:00):

I do.

Mr. Treadaway (09:42:00):

Okay. Paulding County?

James Poag (09:42:02):

‍

Yes, sir.

Mr. Treadaway (09:42:03):

All right. How long have you worked in construction or fabrication?

James Poag (09:42:05):

I've been at my current job since 2009.

Mr. Treadaway (09:42:09):

Did you know... How old are you?

James Poag (09:42:11):

43.

Mr. Treadaway (09:42:12):

Did you know Dan Akers, the decedent or deceased in this case?

James Poag (09:42:16):

I did.

Mr. Treadaway (09:42:17):

How did you know him?

James Poag (09:42:20):

We met at old neighborhood. My parents lived in the same neighborhood as his sister. We met probably '95, '96.

Mr. Treadaway (09:42:30):

Okay. So you would've been, I guess, were you in high school around that time?

James Poag (09:42:35):

No, I would've been 12, 11 or 12.

Mr. Treadaway (09:42:37):

Okay. Elementary school times?

James Poag (09:42:40):

Middle school, but yeah.

Mr. Treadaway (09:42:41):

All right. Did you go to the same school with Dan growing up?

James Poag (09:42:45):

I did.

Mr. Treadaway (09:42:46):

Did you guys consider yourselves friends together?

James Poag (09:42:49):

Yes.

Mr. Treadaway (09:42:50):

All right. Go off and do things together?

James Poag (09:42:53):

Yes.

Mr. Treadaway (09:42:54):

I mean, there's friends and there's friends. So were you close friends?

James Poag (09:42:58):

Yes.

Mr. Treadaway (09:42:59):

Okay. All right, sir. And did you ever work with him?

James Poag (09:43:04):

No, not professionally, no.

Mr. Treadaway (09:43:07):

Okay. But you worked in construction. Did you know what kind of work he did?

James Poag (09:43:09):

I did.

Mr. Treadaway (09:43:10):

What kind of work was he in?

James Poag (09:43:13):

Sheet metal.

Mr. Treadaway (09:43:14):

Okay. All right, sir. Did you maintain a relationship or friendship with him right until the time he died, sir?

James Poag (09:43:20):

I did.

Mr. Treadaway (09:43:24):

Do you know... Can you give the jury an idea of how frequently you guys would've talked every now and then right up until he died?

James Poag (09:43:31):

Well, obviously when we were younger, we spent a lot more time together than towards the end. So he had his family, I had mine. We weren't hanging out every day or anything like that, but we kept in frequent contact, like via messaging, Instagram, stuff like that.

Mr. Treadaway (09:43:51):

Okay. And you would message back with text messages?

James Poag (09:43:56):

Yes.

Mr. Treadaway (09:43:56):

Okay. Did you ever call him or go over and visit with him or anything?

James Poag (09:44:00):

From time to time, yes.

Mr. Treadaway (09:44:04):

Yes, sir. Can you describe right up until say 2019-ish, what kind of person was Dan?

Mr. Steel (09:44:11):

Objection. Victim impact. I though we talked about this in the pretrial and if that's an admissible question. I specifically mentioned that question.

Mr. Treadaway (09:44:23):

Yes.

The Court (09:44:25):

You can ask that question. I guess it depends on how far you go. Just-

Mr. Treadaway (09:44:29):

Not far. Can you just describe what kind of person he was?

James Poag (09:44:34):

A very caring person, always looking out for his friends, definitely care about his family, his kids.

The Court (09:44:52):

[inaudible 09:44:44]. That's fine with me. Let's do this and you say we're going to disrupt the jury to disregard that last question and answer, okay? That's not relevant.

Mr. Treadaway (09:44:56):

All right. Was Dan somebody that you felt like you could count on?

James Poag (09:45:02):

I'm sorry, could you repeat that?

Mr. Treadaway (09:45:04):

Did you feel like you could count on him?

James Poag (09:45:06):

Absolutely.

Mr. Treadaway (09:45:08):

Were you there for him to support him also?

James Poag (09:45:10):

Yes.

Mr. Treadaway (09:45:18):

All right. Did you see Dan active in the lives of his kids?

James Poag (09:45:22):

Yes.

Mr. Treadaway (09:45:24):

How so?

James Poag (09:45:29):

I'm sorry. I'm sorry. Could you repeat the question?

Mr. Treadaway (09:45:32):

Did you ever see him coaching his kids and being involved in sports with his kids?

James Poag (09:45:36):

I never went to actually-

Mr. Treadaway (09:45:38):

Hold on one second. I think there's an objection.

Mr. Steel (09:45:40):

Same objection. Relevance, victim impact.

The Court (09:45:43):

Sustained.

Mr. Treadaway (09:45:52):

Did you have an opportunity to personally observe the defendant? Do you know this person, the defendant Lacy Boles, in the courtroom?

James Poag (09:45:59):

I do.

Mr. Treadaway (09:46:00):

Did you know Lacy Boles for the totality of your friendship with Dan ever since they met Dan and the defendant?

James Poag (09:46:10):

I met her once he was involved with her.

Mr. Treadaway (09:46:13):

Okay. And did you maintain a relationship with both of them up until his death?

James Poag (09:46:20):

Yes.

Mr. Treadaway (09:46:20):

Did you have an opportunity to see them interact together?

James Poag (09:46:23):

I have.

Mr. Treadaway (09:46:24):

How would you describe that?

James Poag (09:46:32):

Not good.

Mr. Treadaway (09:46:35):

Okay. All right. At some point, did you become aware of Mr. Akers had died?

James Poag (09:46:43):

Yes.

Mr. Treadaway (09:46:44):

Okay. Did you attend any kind of memorial for him after you found that out?

James Poag (09:46:48):

I did.

Mr. Treadaway (09:46:49):

Was this defendant present?

James Poag (09:46:51):

She was.

Mr. Treadaway (09:46:52):

Did you have an opportunity to speak to her, interact with her in any way?

James Poag (09:46:55):

I did not.

Mr. Treadaway (09:46:57):

Okay. Did you have an opportunity to observe her behavior at the memorial service?

James Poag (09:47:02):

Very briefly, yes.

Mr. Treadaway (09:47:04):

Okay. Anything notable or that stands out to you about her behavior at all?

James Poag (09:47:10):

It was odd, but I mean, she was unavailable for anyone to talk to or interact with. We only saw her when the actual memorial was taking place, and then she was gone before it was over.

Mr. Treadaway (09:47:36):

Was there ever a point when you knew Dan that you became concerned about his mental health or his mental state to the point where you felt like you needed to reach out to somebody to get help for him?

James Poag (09:47:50):

No, sir.

Mr. Treadaway (09:47:54):

Is there any time that you saw him in a state that you felt like he was so depressed that you wanted to call mental health services or social services or anything like that?

James Poag (09:48:03):

No, sir.

Mr. Treadaway (09:48:07):

In the years that you knew Dan, I guess 20 some odd years, right?

James Poag (09:48:14):

Correct.

Mr. Treadaway (09:48:14):

Did you ever see him carrying a gun around?

James Poag (09:48:19):

No.

Mr. Treadaway (09:48:19):

Did you ever see him carrying a holster on his hip or anything like that with a gun?

James Poag (09:48:24):

No.

Mr. Treadaway (09:48:25):

Did you ever see him carrying a pistol in his pocket?

James Poag (09:48:29):

No.

Mr. Treadaway (09:48:31):

Did you ever see him carrying a gun in his hoodie? Hoodie, you know what a hoodie is? The little part where you put your hands, hoodie pocket?

James Poag (09:48:38):

No.

Mr. Treadaway (09:48:39):

A knife, anything?

James Poag (09:48:41):

No, sir.

Mr. Treadaway (09:48:45):

Did you ever go with Dan to go to a shooting range?

James Poag (09:48:48):

I have not.

Mr. Treadaway (09:48:49):

Did he ever ask you to go to a shooting range or anything like that?

James Poag (09:48:49):

Not that I can recall.

Mr. Treadaway (09:48:59):

Do you remember if he was right-handed or left-handed?

James Poag (09:49:05):

If my memory serves me correct, I'm pretty sure he was right-handed.

Mr. Treadaway (09:49:25):

May I approach the witness, please?

The Court (09:49:26):

Of course.

Mr. Treadaway (09:49:27):

Thank you, sir. Let me just get a glove here, sir. I'm going to show you something that's been admitted into evidence and see if you've ever seen it before.

(09:49:34)
This is State's 173A as an [inaudible 09:49:53]. Can you see what I'm holding that up?

James Poag (09:49:55):

I can.

Mr. Treadaway (09:49:56):

Have you ever seen that before?

James Poag (09:49:56):

I have not.

Mr. Treadaway (09:49:59):

Have you ever seen Dan shooting that?

James Poag (09:50:00):

No, sir.

Mr. Treadaway (09:50:02):

Carrying it around?

James Poag (09:50:03):

No, sir.

Mr. Treadaway (09:50:05):

All right. You ever go to McDonald's with Dan?

James Poag (09:50:26):

Have I ever gone to McDonald's? I'm sure a few times over the years.

Mr. Treadaway (09:50:33):

Seemed like you liked McDonald's?

James Poag (09:50:36):

I mean, not any more or less than anybody else.

Mr. Treadaway (09:50:39):

All right, sir. That's all I had, sir. Thank you.

The Court (09:50:40):

Cross?

Mr. Steel (09:51:05):

Sir, did you just testify you never saw and interacted with Mr. Akers with a gun?

James Poag (09:51:15):

He asked if I had ever seen him out... carrying a gun, I'm assuming while out and about.

Mr. Steel (09:51:27):

What's the answer?

James Poag (09:51:29):

No, I never saw him carrying a gun while out doing other stuff.

Mr. Steel (09:51:38):

Do you remember being with Mr. Akers and pleading guilty to crimes with him?

James Poag (09:51:49):

Yes.

Mr. Steel (09:51:50):

Do you remember some of those crimes included stolen firearms?

James Poag (09:51:58):

Yes, but he didn't ask-

Mr. Treadaway (09:52:00):

I object to this line of questioning. I ask to take a step outside the presence of the jury, Your Honor.

The Court (09:52:34):

Okay. We'll have a break.

(09:52:34)
Overruled. We discussed this. Can you wait outside and not very far?

James Poag (09:53:00):

Yes, sir.

The Court (09:53:01):

All right. Your objection.

Mr. Treadaway (09:53:02):

Your Honor, we had a retracted legal argument earlier in this trial about the defense admitting and introducing evidence and testimony ad nauseum about all those documents, prior convictions, being on probation, facing probation revocation, probation revocation orders by Judge Emerson, new allegations in Cobb County before Judge Kelly Hill. We have protracted legal argument about that. The court allowed that evidence ultimately because I admittedly opened the door to that and I accept that. But also I think the court, unless I'm missing the court's understanding, unless I'm misinterpreting the court's ruling, the court ruled that was relevant because of the state of mind of the decedent, which is always relevant, regarding some text messages that said he was afraid he was going to be revoked on probation. He was fearing that. And that's part of the defense theory [inaudible 09:53:53].

(09:53:52)
So the court, it seemed to me, assigned some relevance to that. And based on my opening the door, the court reversed its pretrial ruling and let some of that in. What relevance on earth would a 2002 conviction for some kind of firearms offense have by asking this witness? That has no relevance. That doesn't involve the state of mind of the defendant at the time of his death, the decedent at the time of his death at all whatsoever. That is merely a low hanging opportunity to drag the guy through the mud, again, who can't, he's not here, he can't defend himself, can't explain it.

(09:54:29)
I asked him, was he ever the type of person to carry a gun around. Then I said on a holster in his pocket, in a hoodie pocket, on his hip. The guy said no. And then when asked to clarify that question with Mr. Steel, the guy said, I assumed he meant out and about in the community. Then we go into this, wasn't he convicted and you with him of some crime, felon in possession of firearm or transporting illegal firearms or whatever it was the defense asked, that's just improper. You can't tie that to any rational purpose like you could that state of mind argument. This stands alone...

Jason Treadaway (09:55:00):

... just like you could that state of mind argument. This stands alone as completely improper, merely to impugn the character of this victim.

Judge Dean Bucci (09:55:11):

All right. Any response?

Brian Steel (09:55:12):

Yes, sir. The way I understand the testimony, I'm impeaching his testimony. On or about June 11th, 2002, both of these gentlemen, and that would be Mr. Poag, P-O-A-G, testifying, and Mr. Akers pled guilty and here are certified copies to the following two counts. And this is from Cobb County Superior Court, case number 021480.

(09:55:51)
"The grand jurors enforce it and in behalf of the citizens of Georgia charge and accuse James Harper Poag and Daniel Lee Akers with the offense of criminal damage to property in the second degree. For that said accused, in the county of Cobb, state of Georgia, 26th day of February 2002 did intentionally damage the property of Mr. Davis, to wit, a window, wall, door, and furniture without the owner's consent by breaking said window and firing a gun. Said damage exceeding $500. Count three. Grand jurors also charge the same two people with theft by receiving stolen property in the same county and the same date did receive and dispose of stolen property to wit, two 9-millimeter handguns and four 40-caliber handguns, the property of Thomas Davis. The accused knew, and should have known, said property was stolen, property having not been received and disposed of with intent to restore."

(09:56:51)
And I don't know why, but the prosecutor asked this witness, "Do you ever know him to carry a gun, be involved with a gun?" Whatever the transcript says. I'm sitting here shocked at this testimony. I have guilty pleas. They're first offenders, I'm not using for impeachment except for his testimony of what he saw. He was clearly with him and that's what they both pled guilty to. So this has nothing to do with state of mind. This has to do with straight impeachment. I don't know why the prosecutor would ask that type of question.

(09:57:23)
Also on the phone of Mr. Akers, I didn't go into it, but I guess I could now. There's machine guns. There's assault rifles on his searches that he's selling. So all of this really is shocking to me, but I'm going to impeach his sworn testimony because I believe he just either forgot to mention the truth, or intentionally did not mention the truth.

Judge Dean Bucci (09:57:48):

Well, if the question was, has the victim, Mr. Akers, ever had a gun, or possessed a gun, or been around a gun, or damaged property with a gun, and he said no, then I could see how that contradicts under rule 621. You could impeach it, but unless I missed it, I think the questions were, have you seen him carrying a gun or wearing a holster or seen that gun, so I'm not sure how that would impeach that.

Brian Steel (09:58:26):

Well, my memory is it was not just that gun. It was-

Judge Dean Bucci (09:58:31):

Well, we can fix that. Let's take a look.

(09:58:39)
I need your help, Jenny. I don't know if you want to bring it up or, you want to do that?

Jenny (09:58:53):

I'll bring it up like this.

Judge Dean Bucci (09:58:53):

Yeah, thank you.

Jenny (09:58:53):

I just can't... Because I can't type anything now.

Judge Dean Bucci (09:58:53):

Is it tight?

Jenny (09:58:53):

Right.

Judge Dean Bucci (09:58:53):

That's okay.

Jenny (09:58:53):

But yeah, you can read here, we need to read [inaudible 09:59:32].

Judge Dean Bucci (09:58:53):

Okay. When he's asking the questions, that would be before that. Is that right?

Jenny (09:58:53):

I think so. [inaudible 09:59:41].

Judge Dean Bucci (09:58:53):

Let's go back to the beginning of the gun questions.

Jenny (09:58:53):

Okay.

Judge Dean Bucci (09:58:53):

At the beginning?

Jenny (09:58:53):

[inaudible 10:00:03]

Judge Dean Bucci (10:00:08):

[inaudible 10:00:06]

(10:00:08)
All right. So there's a question.

(10:00:08)
"Did you ever see him carrying a gun around?"

(10:00:10)
"No."

(10:00:10)
"Did you ever see him carrying a holster on his hips or anything like that with a gun?"

(10:00:18)
"No."

(10:00:18)
"Did you ever see him carrying a pistol in his pocket?"

(10:00:23)
"No."

(10:00:23)
"Did you ever see him carrying a gun in his hoodie? You know what a hoodie is? A hoodie pocket?"

(10:00:36)
"No."

(10:00:36)
"Did you ever go with him to the shooting range?"

(10:00:41)
"I have not."

(10:00:42)
"Did he ever ask you to go to a shooting range or anything like that?"

(10:00:47)
"Not that I can recall."

(10:00:51)
And that's the end of the gun questions. Go back to that.

Brian Steel (10:00:57):

Your Honor, I focused on the very first question.

Jenny (10:00:59):

Let me get this on record because I'm unplugged.

Judge Dean Bucci (10:01:02):

Okay. One second. Let me look before you go back because you're not on record if she's not seated. The first question?

Jenny (10:01:10):

Of the gun?

Judge Dean Bucci (10:01:11):

Yeah.

(10:01:11)
"Did you ever see him carrying a gun around?" That's the first question. Can you get hooked back up there and we can get the lawyers on the record. Tell us when you're ready, Jenny.

Jenny (10:01:57):

I'm ready.

Judge Dean Bucci (10:01:57):

All right. Yes, sir.

Brian Steel (10:02:01):

The first question is as broad as it can be. Have you ever, whatever it was, have you ever seen him with a gun or carry a gun? I don't know how, I want to ask some questions about pleading guilty along with Mr. Akers to possession, theft by receiving stolen property and criminal... Which is multiple guns. There were six guns listed there. And then by firing a gun, they are co-defendants. I don't know how that's not relevant. I don't know who asked the question ever. If it would've been, have you ever seen this gun that's in evidence on Mr. Akers? I would probably object to relevance, but I wouldn't... Probably... Knowing me, I wouldn't have objected because it really doesn't matter to me. But how about, ever a gun?

Judge Dean Bucci (10:02:55):

But that wasn't the question. The question was, "Did you ever see him carrying a gun around?"

Brian Steel (10:03:00):

Yeah.

Judge Dean Bucci (10:03:03):

To your point, if the question was, "Have you ever seen him with a gun?" And he said no, then that's a slam dunk. But the question was, "Did you ever see him carrying a gun around?" And I'm not sure if what you told me you have contradicts that.

Brian Steel (10:03:18):

I still think it's a [inaudible 10:03:22] because I don't know who asked that type of question knowing that they have been together and been prosecuted successfully by Cobb County for possessing stolen weapons. And I just, I can't imagine.

Judge Dean Bucci (10:03:36):

Is possessing stolen weapons carrying a gun around?

Brian Steel (10:03:41):

Did you receive and dispose of stolen property, two 9-millimeter handguns and four 40-caliber handguns? How do you dispose and receive? You have to receive it to possess it. If you didn't receive it, then it's not yours. And then the other one, they're firing, they're co-defendants. They're firing a weapon into a gentleman's home. Somebody's possessing that firearm and they both plead guilty. He made it sound like he never saw him with a gun. That's really how it comes out. I think it's being cut too [inaudible 10:04:36].

Judge Dean Bucci (10:04:37):

Anything from the State?

Jason Treadaway (10:04:39):

I believe in the accusation which I haven't looked at here recently, Mr. Steel's reading from an accusation. I would imagine this, were it an indictment, I would imagine it says individually and is parties to the crime. So he's a party to the crime with Mr. Poag. How do we know that Mr. Akers was the one who fired the gun or carried it in, or possessed it in any way, shape, or form pursuant to that case? He may have pled guilty because he was a party to the crime of what Mr. Poag did singularly and solely. So see, this is going to open up this huge area of questioning being a party to the crime, what happened in that case. How many times have we seen someone charged with theft or receiving stolen property? It's just something in their car. All the time.

Judge Dean Bucci (10:05:24):

Right.

Jason Treadaway (10:05:25):

It doesn't mean they brandished a gun, possessed a gun, held a gun. I was just asking, have you ever seen him carrying a gun around and then I followed up, on a holster, in a pocket, in a hoodie? Have you ever seen this gun? Clearly I'm focusing only on this guy being the type of guy that would frequently be armed in the community or armed about in concealed carry or open carry. This is something from 17 years before he died. And I think that the temporal remoteness of it is very relevant too in this discussion. 17 years ago.

Brian Steel (10:05:59):

I wasn't even going to raise it. I'm not using it for-

Jason Treadaway (10:06:01):

It raises itself. It's a conviction from 17 years ago. It's inherent to the nature of the conviction, it's 17 years old.

Brian Steel (10:06:12):

I'm not using it for impeachment.

Judge Dean Bucci (10:06:14):

I understand that. You're using it for impeachment by contradiction.

Brian Steel (10:06:17):

Exactly.

Judge Dean Bucci (10:06:20):

I think, you say it's a layup, which I respect and I'm cutting it too thin, but I do see a distinction between the question, "Did you ever see him carrying a gun around?" And what you're telling me you have, which if you tell me you have it, I believe you have it, a guilty plea with a charging instrument that says jointly and separately or however it's worded and it includes an accusation of possessing and firing a gun. I don't even know which defendant did it. So I'll overrule your objection or I guess it wasn't really your objection. It was the State's objection. So I'll sustain the State's objection. I don't think that contradicts under rule 621.

Brian Steel (10:07:07):

Okay. Can I just enter this into the record then?

Judge Dean Bucci (10:07:09):

Of course you can.

Brian Steel (10:07:10):

These are certified copies. I'll mark it the next number.

Jason Treadaway (10:07:18):

I would respectfully ask for curative instructions striking the last answer please.

Judge Dean Bucci (10:07:23):

Did he answer?

Jason Treadaway (10:07:24):

Yes, he did.

Judge Dean Bucci (10:07:24):

Okay.

Brian Steel (10:07:28):

Well-

Jason Treadaway (10:07:32):

I'm striking the question. The question's not evidence, but the question has now been disallowed.

Judge Dean Bucci (10:07:40):

Okay.

Brian Steel (10:07:40):

Well, it brings me to a different issue then. It's going to get to the same point anyway. The prosecutor went through, you're very close, you met in middle school, you're good friends with each other, you're close to each other. I get to now talk about their relationship. They commit crimes together. I mean, at some point we can't have all this... Dan Akers is this great guy that nobody expected suicide and not expect the truth to come out. The truth is these two people commit crime together. They smoke methamphetamine together, and then they separate, like he said, and they only text with each other. It was an intentional separation according to this witness. It wasn't just they got busy with family members. This witness stayed away from Dan Akers because Dan Akers' methamphetamine use. That's in his statement, which I'm going to get into next because he said he got busy with family.

(10:08:34)
So I'm going to say that really wasn't the reason you told the authorities, was it? You never mentioned your family. What you mentioned was it's Dan Akers' abuse of methamphetamine. I don't know why the prosecutor's eliciting this testimony, but he is.

Judge Dean Bucci (10:08:47):

What did he elicit about family?

Brian Steel (10:08:49):

Said that the answer was we didn't see each other as much because we both got busy with family.

Judge Dean Bucci (10:09:00):

Okay.

Brian Steel (10:09:01):

But what he says to the authorities in discovery that we have, and this is February 28th, 2020, Detective Hardy's notation of speaking with this witness. Mr. Poag stated, it's in the third paragraph, second line, "Mr. Poag stated that a few years ago, they," being Mr. Akers and him, "had a falling out over drugs and that they mainly talk through text messages." The responding detective, which is Detective Hardy, asked if he was friends with Lacy and it goes on from there.

Judge Dean Bucci (10:09:44):

Okay. I understand.

Brian Steel (10:09:47):

And then it says, "Mr. Poag admitted that he and Mr. Akers would use methamphetamine together and he smoked marijuana with Lacy and Mr. Akers in the past." I mean, I don't know why this is coming up, but it is.

Judge Dean Bucci (10:10:00):

Okay. Any response?

Jason Treadaway (10:10:05):

Yes, Your Honor. It seems to be that the honorable Mr. Steel is equating truth with admissibility. Those aren't necessarily the same thing. This defendant, we have a reason to believe, was a frequent drug user. It doesn't make it admissible. So it may be true, but it's not admissible. I didn't ask this man why he separated, why he ended his relationship with Dan Akers. I didn't ask this witness why he moved on. It's not going to be in the record. I didn't ask him anything like that. At some point he said, "We were close and growing up, we were really close, but then at some point I just got busy with family and moved on." How does that open the door to, "Oh no, you moved on because Dan was using too much meth." I didn't ask him anything that would specifically open the door to that at all.

(10:11:01)
And it's not just a free-for-all to bring in irrelevant information about the victim's drug use. You are the gatekeeper with evidence of this nature, Your Honor. This is not relevant evidence.

Judge Dean Bucci (10:11:17):

All right. Well, I think there is a direct contradiction here if the testimony was we didn't see each other as much because we got busy with family, but then the recorded statement is, "I stopped seeing him," words to this effect, "because of drug use." Then I think that comes in under rule 621 as impeachment by contradiction.

Jason Treadaway (10:11:41):

I would ask respectfully to see the record of what he specifically said regarding that, unless Your Honor's reading it off the transcript.

Judge Dean Bucci (10:11:49):

I'm not. I'm relying on what Mr. Steel just told me.

Jason Treadaway (10:11:53):

Okay. I'd ask to see it in the record, what he said.

Judge Dean Bucci (10:11:56):

All right.

Jason Treadaway (10:11:56):

I don't really remember what he said about he got busy with family, but if he said, "Well, we just got busy with family," or, "I got busy with family," that's not contradictory to... That could be true. He may characterize it as we got busy with family. At some point, he may have characterized it as, there was a methamphetamine problem.

Judge Dean Bucci (10:12:15):

Well, we can check the record, but... We'll check the record, Jenny.

Jenny (10:12:19):

Do you want me to read it, Judge or you want me to-

Judge Dean Bucci (10:12:19):

No, just pull it up. You think you found it?

Jenny (10:12:19):

I think I found it.

Judge Dean Bucci (10:12:19):

Well, you can read it so everybody hears it.

Jenny (10:12:19):

The question [inaudible 10:14:06]?

Judge Dean Bucci (10:12:19):

Yes.

Jenny (10:14:07):

"Can you give the jury an idea of how frequently you would've talked right up until he died?"

(10:14:11)
"Well, obviously when we were younger, we spent a lot more time together than towards the end. He had his family and I had mine. We weren't hanging out like every day or anything like that, but he kept in touch with messages, Instagram, stuff like that."

Jason Treadaway (10:14:26):

That's it?

Jenny (10:14:26):

Yeah.

Judge Dean Bucci (10:14:31):

All right. I don't think I see the contradiction now, Mr. Steel. He didn't say, and I know your memory's just like mine. You don't remember every word, but when I made that ruling, it's because I was relying on your statement that your recollection was we didn't see each other... I can't even speak. Didn't see each other as much because he got busy with family. That's not what was in the record.

Brian Steel (10:15:00):

I thought that was exactly what I just said.

Judge Dean Bucci (10:15:02):

You want her to read it again?

Jenny (10:15:02):

"Well, obviously when we were younger, we spent a lot more time together than towards, you know, the end. He had his family, I had mine. We weren't hanging out like every day or anything like that, but he kept in touch with messages, Instagram, stuff like that."

Brian Steel (10:15:45):

And previously, I'm reading right from the report, James stated, that's the witness, that a few years ago they had a falling out over drugs and that they mainly talk through text messages. I think that his prior inconsistent statement totally contradicts what he just said on the witness stand. It says nothing about family. He said this was an intentional falling out over drugs relationship change. So I still think it's going to be an impeachment.

Judge Dean Bucci (10:16:19):

Anything else?

Jason Treadaway (10:16:20):

He said, "Toward the end, he had his family and I had mine." That seems to suggest toward the end of the life. Mr. Steel's reading from a statement that says several years ago or a few years ago, whatever it said, this is years ago. What he said on the witness stand is, "Towards the end he had his family and I had mine." That's not a contradiction. That's just two different statements at two different times.

Brian Steel (10:16:41):

Yeah. That's a prior inconsistent statement. He said nothing about family.

Jason Treadaway (10:16:45):

It's not inconsistent. It's different. It's not inconsistent. It's two different topics. He's referencing this drug usage and separation, the decrease in the time they saw each other, and then he's referencing it toward the end, he had his family, I had mine, we didn't see each other much.

Judge Dean Bucci (10:17:05):

All right. After hearing the Statement, I don't see the contradiction, so I'm going to sustain the objection.

Brian Steel (10:17:10):

Okay. I will not cross on it. I would've crossed on it though, so the record would show what I would've said. And I do believe that the State's questioning allows me to now confront their real relationship, which separated through drugs. So I would like to do that, but I will not do it based upon the honorable court's ruling. And then I'd like to just give to the court reporter Ms. Boles number 143, but I understand it's not going in, but if you want to see it, I know you haven't seen it. It does not say parties to a crime. It's indicted as co-indictees.

Judge Dean Bucci (10:17:43):

I'd like to see it.

Brian Steel (10:17:46):

May I approach?

Judge Dean Bucci (10:17:46):

Yes, sir. All right. Let's take five minutes.

Brian Steel (10:23:58):

I thought of something, but of course I'd like the record. I think that the witness testified that Mr. Akers is a great guy. And if he did that, I don't know how many great guys commit crimes together. So now if they didn't say that, then I will not raise any other issue. But that's my last issue.

Judge Dean Bucci (10:24:16):

We'll let Jenny check again. My recollection is initially I overruled the objection, then he started getting into that and I thought this is... Then I agreed with you and then I instructed the jury disregard that.

Brian Steel (10:24:28):

Okay.

Judge Dean Bucci (10:24:29):

I think. You want her to check?

Brian Steel (10:24:31):

Sure.

Judge Dean Bucci (10:24:32):

Yeah. Can we check?

Jenny (10:24:32):

[inaudible 10:25:17]

Judge Dean Bucci (10:25:16):

Yes, ma'am.

Jenny (10:25:19):

Okay.

(10:25:19)
Mr. Treadaway. "Can you describe what kind of person he was?"

(10:25:22)
"Very caring person, always looking out for his friends, definitely cared about his family."

(10:25:27)
And then you interrupted and said, " Let's do this. To be safe, I'm going to instruct you to disregard the last question and answer."

Judge Dean Bucci (10:25:36):

Okay. So that's out.

Brian Steel (10:25:38):

Understood.

Judge Dean Bucci (10:25:39):

All right. All right, let's have them back please.

(10:25:40)
All right. Welcome back. I sustain the State's objection. Ladies and gentlemen, the last question and answer that you heard, I'm ruling out, so you have to disregard that entirely. Let's get the witness back.

Brian Steel (10:26:43):

Mr. Poag.

Judge Dean Bucci (10:27:22):

All right, sir. Welcome back. Feel free to proceed, sir.

Brian Steel (10:27:26):

I don't have any additional questions.

Judge Dean Bucci (10:27:28):

All right. Anything else from the State?

Jason Treadaway (10:27:28):

No, Your Honor. Thank you.

Judge Dean Bucci (10:27:28):

Thank you, Mr. Poag. You're free to go.

(10:27:28)
Do you have another witness?

Jason Treadaway (10:27:38):

State calls Amanda Berg

Judge Dean Bucci (10:28:37):

Hey, good evening, ma'am.

Amanda Berg (10:28:38):

Hi.

Judge Dean Bucci (10:28:38):

Let me swear you in, please. Please raise your right hand to receive an oath. Do you swear or affirm the testimony you're about to give in this matter before the court will be the truth, the whole truth, and nothing but the truth, so help you God?

Amanda Berg (10:28:46):

Yes.

Judge Dean Bucci (10:28:48):

Please have a seat. Thank you.

Jason Treadaway (10:28:52):

Good evening, ma'am. Can you please tell the jury your name?

Amanda Berg (10:28:54):

Amanda Berg.

Jason Treadaway (10:28:56):

Berg, did you say?

Amanda Berg (10:28:57):

Yes.

Jason Treadaway (10:28:58):

B-E-R-G?

Amanda Berg (10:28:58):

B-E-R-G.

Jason Treadaway (10:28:59):

You're kind of soft-spoken, so if you can make sure to speak into the microphone.

Amanda Berg (10:29:00):

Okay.

Jason Treadaway (10:29:00):

You look a little nervous. Don't be nervous, okay?

Amanda Berg (10:29:00):

Okay.

Jason Treadaway (10:29:00):

Mr. Steel and I might only ask you some questions, just don't be nervous, okay? Did you know the decedent in this case? His name is Dan Akers?

Amanda Berg (10:29:16):

Yes, I did.

Jason Treadaway (10:29:17):

How did you know that person, please?

Amanda Berg (10:29:22):

He was my uncle, but I looked at him more like he was my brother because we were so close in age.

Jason Treadaway (10:29:27):

Okay. So is it fair to say you've known him pretty much your whole life?

Amanda Berg (10:29:31):

My whole life.

Jason Treadaway (10:29:32):

Were you close to him?

Amanda Berg (10:29:34):

Yes.

Jason Treadaway (10:29:36):

Okay. All right. Did you have an opportunity to maintain a relationship with him up until his death?

Amanda Berg (10:29:45):

Yes.

Jason Treadaway (10:29:48):

Was there any time that you lost contact with him or anything like that?

Amanda Berg (10:29:57):

We didn't talk much. The last time I seen him was Thanksgiving 2019, and we didn't talk-

Ms. Berg (10:30:00):

Thanksgiving 2019, and we didn't talk much after that.

Speaker 31 (10:30:06):

But up until 2019 Thanksgiving, had you maintained pretty close contact?

Ms. Berg (10:30:10):

Yes.

Speaker 31 (10:30:11):

To the decedent? Do you know this defendant in the courtroom, Lacey Bowles?

Ms. Berg (10:30:21):

Yes, I do.

Speaker 31 (10:30:23):

Did you have an opportunity to interact with this defendant on multiple occasions with Dan?

Ms. Berg (10:30:29):

Yes, I did.

Speaker 31 (10:30:32):

You said that you saw Dan last on Thanksgiving of 2019. Is that fair to say that you saw the defendant around that time too?

Ms. Berg (10:30:41):

Yes, she was at my house. I hosted Thanksgiving that year and she was there with Dan and their kids.

Speaker 31 (10:30:49):

Did you have an opportunity to see how they got along, Dan and Lisa?

Ms. Berg (10:30:53):

Yes, I did.

Speaker 31 (10:30:53):

Toward the end of Dan's life.

Ms. Berg (10:30:58):

Yes, I did.

Speaker 31 (10:30:58):

Can you tell the jury what that relationship was like as you saw it?

Ms. Berg (10:31:06):

Well, I know that they weren't really getting along towards the end, and even on Thanksgiving, I'd asked that they would stay back to hang out with myself and my other brothers and my husband, and Dan said that they couldn't because him and Lacey weren't getting along.

Speaker 31 (10:31:24):

All right. Do you remember if Dan was left-handed or right-handed?

Ms. Berg (10:31:32):

Dan was right-handed.

Speaker 31 (10:31:34):

How do you know that?

Ms. Berg (10:31:34):

Because my father is left-handed, so if Dan was left-handed, I for sure would've known that he was left-handed.

Speaker 31 (10:31:39):

Did you ever see Dan using his left hand to throw a baseball?

Ms. Berg (10:31:43):

No, I did not.

Speaker 31 (10:31:48):

Did you see him playing sports like baseball and football with his kids?

Ms. Berg (10:31:48):

Yes.

Speaker 31 (10:31:54):

Did you have an opportunity to see him throw football, for example?

Ms. Berg (10:31:56):

I've thrown a football with Dan before.

Speaker 31 (10:31:58):

Did you ever see him use his left hand and do that?

Ms. Berg (10:32:00):

Never.

Speaker 31 (10:32:01):

Did you ever see what wrist he wore a watch on, for example?

Ms. Berg (10:32:10):

Yes, he wore a watch on his left wrist.

Speaker 31 (10:32:18):

Having known Dan all this time, did you ever consider or have any reason to consider him to be ambidextrous? Do you know what that word means?

Ms. Berg (10:32:25):

Yes, I do know what that word means, and no, that's never come up. I've never seen that before.

Speaker 31 (10:32:31):

All right.

(10:32:44)
Did you ever know Dan to be in such a state of despair that you, as a family member, felt the need to contact somebody in mental health services?

Ms. Berg (10:32:56):

No.

Speaker 31 (10:32:56):

Did you ever see him so depressed or down that you felt like it was probably necessary to go ahead and inform some other family members?

Ms. Berg (10:33:04):

No.

Speaker 31 (10:33:16):

Did you attend a memorial service that was put on by this defendant after Dan's death?

Ms. Berg (10:33:21):

I did.

Speaker 31 (10:33:22):

Did you have an opportunity to personally observe this defendant's behavior at that service?

Ms. Berg (10:33:27):

Yes, I did. She came up to me.

Speaker 31 (10:33:30):

Did you have contact with her?

Ms. Berg (10:33:31):

Yes.

Speaker 31 (10:33:32):

What was the nature of that contact?

Ms. Berg (10:33:35):

Horrible. It was very bizarre. She was rocking around and scratching her head, all in my face. The whole thing was bizarre because I didn't even know that she had Dan cremated up until the day of the memorial. I didn't have any information about the memorial. I wasn't asked anything for the memorial or anything.

Speaker 32 (10:34:09):

Objection, Judge. Irrelevant.

Speaker 31 (10:34:11):

We'll move on from that.

Speaker 33 (10:34:12):

All right. Sustained.

Speaker 31 (10:34:15):

I want to know if you ever remember Dan carrying a gun on his person.

Ms. Berg (10:34:21):

No.

Speaker 31 (10:34:21):

Did you see that?

Ms. Berg (10:34:23):

Not that I know of.

Speaker 31 (10:34:28):

Did you ever go to a shooting range, or shooting out in the woods with Dan or anything like that?

Ms. Berg (10:34:33):

No.

Speaker 31 (10:34:36):

Did you ever see Dan, at the time you knew him, he had a tendency to hold a holster on his person to hold a gun?

Ms. Berg (10:34:47):

I don't recall that.

Speaker 31 (10:34:48):

Did you ever see this gun before, State's Exhibit 173? May I approach the witness?

Speaker 33 (10:35:00):

Yes.

Speaker 31 (10:35:00):

Did you ever have an opportunity to see this gun before? Did Dan ever carry this gun?

Ms. Berg (10:35:06):

No, I've never seen that gun before.

Speaker 31 (10:35:29):

Okay. I understand that your husband, is his name Chris?

Ms. Berg (10:35:34):

Yes.

Speaker 31 (10:35:35):

Did Dan buy a car from Chris in 2019?

Ms. Berg (10:35:38):

Yes, in 2019.

Speaker 31 (10:35:41):

Sorry. What month, do you remember, around? You used-

Ms. Berg (10:35:44):

I believe it was in November, December. It was shortly before he passed.

Speaker 31 (10:35:55):

Would he pay it with cash or was he making payments? How did that work?

Ms. Berg (10:35:59):

He was making payments.

Speaker 31 (10:36:01):

To Chris?

Ms. Berg (10:36:02):

Yes.

Speaker 31 (10:36:04):

And he bought it in, you said November or December?

Ms. Berg (10:36:09):

Yes, that's when Dan got it from Chris and then he was going to make payments.

Speaker 31 (10:36:21):

Did your husband, Chris, work with Dan at any time?

Ms. Berg (10:36:24):

Yes.

Speaker 31 (10:36:25):

What type of work was that?

Ms. Berg (10:36:26):

Union sheet metal work for Local 85.

Speaker 31 (10:36:30):

Is your husband a member of Local 85?

Ms. Berg (10:36:32):

Yes, he is.

Speaker 31 (10:36:49):

I'd like to talk to you about an incident that may have occurred with you and Lacey. Do you know who Sklar Bowles is?

Ms. Berg (10:36:57):

Yes, I do.

Speaker 31 (10:36:58):

Who's that?

Ms. Berg (10:36:59):

That's Lacey's daughter.

Speaker 31 (10:37:02):

I'm going to ask you, did you ever have an opportunity to hang out with the family where Lacey Bowles and Sklar Bowles were there and family get together?

Ms. Berg (10:37:09):

Yes, often.

Speaker 31 (10:37:15):

Specifically, I want to ask you, did you remember an occasion where y'all were hanging out at a family get together after dark and somebody kind of tried to pull a prank on you on the back deck?

Ms. Berg (10:37:28):

Yes. Skylar's boyfriend, Wes.

Speaker 31 (10:37:31):

Skylar's boyfriend Wes was there?

Ms. Berg (10:37:32):

Yes. He's the one that pulled the prank.

Speaker 31 (10:37:35):

Can you tell the jury about that prank, please?

Ms. Berg (10:37:38):

We were sitting on Lacey's back porch, me, Lacey and Skylar, and we're sitting around on the back porch and Skylar's boyfriend, Wes, went out back around and it was dark outside and it was a raised porch, so it didn't have any stairs coming down it. And Wes started shaking the porch really hard to scare all of us.

Speaker 31 (10:38:05):

Was it dark out?

Ms. Berg (10:38:05):

Yes, it was nighttime. It was dark.

Speaker 31 (10:38:09):

Did this defendant do anything that you witnessed that you found notable after Wes did that?

Ms. Berg (10:38:14):

Yes. We all went running inside and kind of dispersed and Lacey came back out with a gun.

Speaker 31 (10:38:24):

How much time elapsed between Wes pulling this prank and this defendant coming out with a gun?

Ms. Berg (10:38:31):

It all happened really fast. We all ran inside, kind of shoving each other, trying to get through the door at the same time. And I ran into the living room, Skylar ran and just kind of stayed in the kitchen area, and then when I looked back around, Lacey was coming back down her hallway with the gun out.

Speaker 31 (10:38:51):

Did she fire?

Ms. Berg (10:38:55):

No.

Speaker 31 (10:38:55):

I don't have anything else. Thank you.

Speaker 33 (10:39:12):

All right. Any cross examination?

Raymond Lyall (10:39:19):

Thank you. Hello, Ms. Berg.

Ms. Berg (10:39:20):

Hi.

Raymond Lyall (10:39:21):

My name is Raymond Lyall and I represent Ms. Lacey Bowles along with Brian Steele. Just have a couple of questions. With regard to the incident that you just shared with the jurors on the back porch, I believe you said it was dark outside. Do you remember what time it was?

Ms. Berg (10:39:42):

I don't.

Raymond Lyall (10:39:43):

But suffice it to say it was dark outside.

Ms. Berg (10:39:44):

It was dark outside.

Raymond Lyall (10:39:47):

Okay. Was anybody else in on the prank besides Wes? Did y'all know he was going down there or?

Ms. Berg (10:39:53):

No, nobody else was in on the prank and Wes was actually really scared to even come up and tell us that it was him because it was such a commotion.

Raymond Lyall (10:40:03):

Yeah. Okay. So basically you're there hanging out with friends and y'all got scared to the extent I believe you say y'all ran inside.

Ms. Berg (10:40:21):

Yes.

Raymond Lyall (10:40:21):

So I guess Wes's intent was to scare everybody.

Ms. Berg (10:40:24):

Yes.

Raymond Lyall (10:40:25):

And that's what happened, right? Y'all got scared?

Ms. Berg (10:40:27):

Yes.

Raymond Lyall (10:40:27):

And then Lacey went and got a gun to protect people, right?

Ms. Berg (10:40:30):

Yes.

Raymond Lyall (10:40:33):

Okay. Nothing further.

Speaker 33 (10:40:33):

Anything else from the state?

Speaker 31 (10:40:33):

No, Your Honor. Thank you.

Speaker 33 (10:40:45):

All right. Ma'am, thank you very much.

Ms. Berg (10:40:47):

Thank you.

Speaker 33 (10:40:47):

You're free to go, okay? Next witness.

Speaker 31 (10:40:52):

State calls Chris Berg.

Speaker 33 (10:41:37):

Sir, welcome. I'll swear you in. Please raise your right hand to receive an oath. Do you swear or affirm the testimony you're about to give in the matter before the court will be the truth, the whole truth, and nothing but the truth, so help you God?

Christopher Berg (10:41:44):

I do.

Speaker 33 (10:41:44):

Thank you, sir. You can have a seat.

Speaker 31 (10:41:51):

Your Honor, can we take just two minutes to make sure that this witness understands the court's pretrial?

Speaker 33 (10:41:57):

All right, sir, if you'll step down, you might get some instructions here about one of my rulings.

Speaker 31 (10:43:10):

Could you state your name please, sir?

Christopher Berg (10:43:11):

Christopher Berg.

Speaker 31 (10:43:14):

And how are you employed, Mr. Berg?

Christopher Berg (10:43:16):

I'm employed by Local 85 Sheet Metal Workers.

Speaker 31 (10:43:21):

How long have you been so employed?

Christopher Berg (10:43:23):

Since 2013.

Speaker 31 (10:43:26):

What do you do as a sheet metal worker?

Christopher Berg (10:43:30):

We install HVA systems in hospitals, government facilities, small facilities, schools, anything that has to do with metal.

Speaker 31 (10:43:45):

And you say Local 85 sheet metal workers. What kind of organization is that?

Christopher Berg (10:43:51):

It's a state organization and it's also a international.

Speaker 31 (10:43:58):

Okay. Is it a union?

Christopher Berg (10:43:59):

Yes.

Speaker 31 (10:44:02):

And you've been working there since what year?

Christopher Berg (10:44:07):

2013.

Speaker 31 (10:44:09):

2013. And did you ever work with an individual named Daniel Akers?

Christopher Berg (10:44:18):

Yes.

Speaker 31 (10:44:19):

When did you work with Mr. Akers?

Christopher Berg (10:44:22):

It would've been in 2019, summertime or late spring.

Speaker 31 (10:44:33):

Now, how do you know Mr. Akers?

Christopher Berg (10:44:37):

He is related to my wife.

Speaker 31 (10:44:40):

And how is he related to your wife?

Christopher Berg (10:44:43):

They were raised as brothers and sisters.

Speaker 31 (10:44:51):

And when did you first meet Mr. Akers?

Christopher Berg (10:44:54):

It would've been around 2016, late 2016, early '17, somewhere in that timeframe.

Speaker 31 (10:45:03):

Now, what's your wife's name?

Christopher Berg (10:45:04):

Amanda Berg.

Speaker 31 (10:45:08):

And now, when you worked with Mr. Akers, what kind of work were you doing at that time?

Christopher Berg (10:45:16):

I was still doing union sheet metal.

Speaker 31 (10:45:22):

And did Mr. Akers work with you?

Christopher Berg (10:45:25):

Yes. Not directly, but we were for the same company at the same hospital.

Speaker 31 (10:45:31):

And when you say at the same hospital, what kind of hospital was this that you were located?

Christopher Berg (10:45:36):

It was Piedmont Hospital, over off 400.

Speaker 31 (10:45:39):

Were you having construction there?

Christopher Berg (10:45:43):

Yes, it was a new construction building.

Speaker 31 (10:45:49):

And so you were using ... Mr. Akers, you'd see him on the job site?

Christopher Berg (10:45:56):

Yes.

Speaker 31 (10:45:57):

And were you able to observe what kind of workers Mr. Akers was?

Christopher Berg (10:46:02):

Yes.

Speaker 31 (10:46:03):

And what were you able to observe about the way Mr. Akers worked?

Christopher Berg (10:46:09):

That he was going to have a very good career in it. He was a hard worker.

Speaker 31 (10:46:18):

What about, did he have any complaints on his job site?

Christopher Berg (10:46:21):

Of him? No.

Raymond Lyall (10:46:22):

Objection, relevance.

Speaker 33 (10:46:25):

I think I'll sustain that.

‍

Speaker 31 (10:46:30):

Okay. When you saw Mr. Akers, did you see him personally as well?

Christopher Berg (10:46:39):

Yes.

Speaker 31 (10:46:40):

Okay. Where would you come across Mr. Akers in a personal environment rather than a work environment?

Christopher Berg (10:46:47):

His home, his family's home, my home.

Speaker 31 (10:46:50):

Okay. Were you able to see him with his children?

Christopher Berg (10:46:55):

Yes.

Speaker 31 (10:46:57):

And how often would you see Mr. Akers?

Christopher Berg (10:47:01):

Relatively often. We used to have cookouts. He's had Thanksgiving at my house in 2019.

Speaker 31 (10:47:12):

How often would you see him average a week in 2019? How often would you encounter him?

Christopher Berg (10:47:20):

It would almost be either weekly or every other week, depending on if someone had to work.

Speaker 31 (10:47:28):

Did you ever see Mr. Akers exhibit any type of conduct that made you think he needed to have some kind of mental health intervention where you were concerned for his safety?

Christopher Berg (10:47:43):

No.

Speaker 31 (10:47:45):

Did you ever see any type of conduct like that where you felt like you needed to alert other family members that Mr. Akers' safety may be in jeopardy because of his mental health?

Christopher Berg (10:47:59):

No.

Speaker 31 (10:48:00):

Now, did you see Mr. Akers along with the defendant, Lacey Bowles, did you ever see them together?

Christopher Berg (10:48:10):

Yes.

Speaker 31 (10:48:11):

How often would you see them together?

Christopher Berg (10:48:15):

About every time we had a cookout or we were at Thanksgiving.

Speaker 31 (10:48:19):

Were you able to observe the conduct between this defendant and Mr. Akers?

Christopher Berg (10:48:28):

Yes.

Speaker 31 (10:48:30):

And what did you note about the conduct that you observed between these two people?

Christopher Berg (10:48:36):

That it was very different in the sense that one would be argumentative towards the other.

Speaker 31 (10:48:46):

And who was argumentative toward whom?

Christopher Berg (10:48:50):

The defendant was argumentative always, usually either in some type of way of complaining or nagging to Dan.

Speaker 31 (10:49:01):

Now, did you ever have occasion to eat lunch with Mr. Akers while you all were working?

Christopher Berg (10:49:08):

Almost every day.

Speaker 31 (10:49:10):

Was there ever an occasion when you were eating lunch that you were able to overhear this defendant on a phone talking to Mr. Akers?

Christopher Berg (10:49:24):

Yes.

Speaker 31 (10:49:25):

And what was that conversation content with regard to attitude? What kind of voice inflection were you hearing?

Christopher Berg (10:49:35):

Her screaming at him.

Speaker 31 (10:49:36):

When you're saying her screaming, are you talking about this defendant, Lacey Bowles?

Christopher Berg (10:49:40):

Yes.

Speaker 31 (10:49:41):

And she was screaming at whom?

Christopher Berg (10:49:43):

Dan.

Speaker 31 (10:49:45):

Well, you worked with this defendant ... Well, you didn't work with the defendant at all though, did you?

Christopher Berg (10:49:52):

No, I didn't.

Speaker 31 (10:49:53):

No, you worked with the victim, Mr. Akers, is that right?

Christopher Berg (10:49:55):

Oh, I'm sorry. Yeah, I worked with victim.

Speaker 31 (10:49:59):

And now, approximately how many hours would this victim work a week?

Christopher Berg (10:50:06):

As far as I know, 40 plus.

Speaker 31 (10:50:09):

So minimum 40 plus. And then what about overtime? Was there a time when he worked overtime?

Raymond Lyall (10:50:19):

Objection, relevance.

Speaker 33 (10:50:22):

Overturned [inaudible 10:50:24].

Speaker 31 (10:50:25):

Your Honor, there's been an issue presented by defense counsel with regard to financial status, and I want to explore that with this witness.

Speaker 33 (10:50:37):

All right. Overruled.

Speaker 31 (10:50:39):

And when this victim would work overtime, do you have any idea approximately how many hours he would've worked overtime?

Christopher Berg (10:50:48):

Not off the top of my head, no. But I know that overtime was offered on that job.

Speaker 31 (10:50:55):

Well, you had described this phone issue with this defendant and Mr. Akers. Approximately how many times would that type of phone conversation or phone encounter between Mr. Akers and this defendant occur that you were aware of?

Christopher Berg (10:51:16):

That I'm aware of?

Speaker 31 (10:51:18):

Yes, sir.

Christopher Berg (10:51:20):

Almost weekly for three months. It was not uncommon to be heard or hear Dan complaining about her yelling on the property-

Raymond Lyall (10:51:34):

Objection, hearsay.

Speaker 33 (10:51:37):

All right. Sounds like hearsay. Sustained.

Speaker 31 (10:51:39):

Okay. Mr. Berg, let's move on to a different area. Did you have occasion to attend an event on Thanksgiving with Mr. Akers?

Christopher Berg (10:51:59):

Yes.

Speaker 31 (10:52:00):

And where did that occur?

Christopher Berg (10:52:03):

My home.

Speaker 31 (10:52:06):

And was that at your home with Ms. Berg, Amanda Berg?

Christopher Berg (10:52:09):

Yes.

Speaker 31 (10:52:11):

Okay. And what were the circumstances of that Thanksgiving? Who was there that day?

Christopher Berg (10:52:19):

Most of my wife's family. I want to say almost everyone in my wife's family, including Dan, Lacey, her grandparents, their kids, her brother.

Speaker 31 (10:52:36):

And when you were at Thanksgiving, what was the general atmosphere during that Thanksgiving celebration?

Christopher Berg (10:52:47):

It was good.

Speaker 31 (10:52:50):

And did you happen to see this defendant there at that celebration?

Christopher Berg (10:52:57):

Yes.

Speaker 31 (10:52:59):

And what was her demeanor toward Mr. Akers at that celebration?

Christopher Berg (10:53:04):

At the end?

Speaker 31 (10:53:05):

Yes, sir.

Christopher Berg (10:53:06):

Complaining and confrontational.

Speaker 31 (10:53:12):

And she was confrontational with whom?

Christopher Berg (10:53:14):

Dan.

Speaker 31 (10:53:18):

Now, you worked with Mr. Akers at your job at the Local 85. Did you become aware, at some point, what the ambition of Mr. Akers was with regard to his job at Local 85?

Raymond Lyall (10:53:45):

Objection, relevance.

Speaker 33 (10:53:45):

Mr. [inaudible 10:53:52], respond?

Speaker 31 (10:53:52):

Yes, Your Honor. The defense has tried to propound that this defendant was morose, that he was-

Speaker 33 (10:54:05):

All right. I'll overrule the objection.

Speaker 31 (10:54:07):

All right. Would you answer that with regard to what this victim's long range plans were with regard to his job and his ambitions at the job?

Raymond Lyall (10:54:20):

That's hearsay.

Speaker 33 (10:54:23):

Okay. Sounds like hearsay.

Speaker 31 (10:54:25):

I'm not asking what anybody said. I'm asking if he knows what this victim's long range plans were, not what anybody told him, not what the victim told him. I'm asking if he knows. I didn't ask from whom or what or how.

Raymond Lyall (10:54:41):

You have to establish that the witness has personal knowledge of that.

Speaker 31 (10:54:46):

All right. Do you have personal knowledge of that, Mr. Berg, of his long range ambitions?

Christopher Berg (10:54:53):

Yes.

Speaker 31 (10:54:53):

Okay. And based on your personal knowledge, were you able to-

Raymond Lyall (10:55:05):

That's hearsay, Judge. If Mr. Akers said something to him, he's fixed to respond to it, that's going to be hearsay.

Speaker 33 (10:55:13):

All right. Well, let me ask, is the basis of your knowledge what someone told you?

Christopher Berg (10:55:19):

The basis of my knowledge is what someone told me and also something of the fact that when you sign up for an apprentice program, you're striving for more.

Speaker 33 (10:55:29):

Okay. Well, don't tell us what anyone told you, so I'll sustain the objection.

Speaker 31 (10:55:37):

Other than what somebody told you, were you aware of this victim in any type of a program to improve his status in the future with this company?

Christopher Berg (10:55:48):

Yes.

Speaker 31 (10:55:48):

And what were you aware of with regard to his status with this company that he was trying to improve himself for?

Christopher Berg (10:55:55):

I was aware that he signed up for a local apprenticeship that takes a minimum of four years to complete and he wanted to complete. Not by what he said, but by his actions. You don't become a good worker not trying to complete something.

Speaker 31 (10:56:17):

Now, you were talking about a trade school. Does the term journeyman mean anything to you in your job?

Christopher Berg (10:56:26):

Yes.

Speaker 31 (10:56:26):

What is a journeyman?

Christopher Berg (10:56:28):

A journeyman is someone that completes the trade school training.

Speaker 31 (10:56:32):

Okay. What was Mr. Akers' level at the job shortly before his death? How was he classified?

Christopher Berg (10:56:43):

I think he was a second year apprentice.

Speaker 31 (10:56:46):

So what happens after apprentice? What do you do next for the company?

Christopher Berg (10:56:50):

You become a journeyman.

Speaker 31 (10:56:52):

And then eventually, what do you become if you stay with it and excel?

Christopher Berg (10:56:56):

You become a foreman.

Speaker 31 (10:57:03):

What hours would Mr. Akers work when he was at this job?

Christopher Berg (10:57:10):

I want to say it was either 6:00 to 2:30 or 7:00 to 3:30 at the time.

Speaker 31 (10:57:15):

Okay. When you say 6:00, what time of the day are you talking about?

Christopher Berg (10:57:18):

6:00 AM.

Speaker 31 (10:57:19):

6:00 AM until?

Christopher Berg (10:57:21):

2:30 PM.

Speaker 31 (10:57:23):

2:30 PM. And is there a pay increase if you go from apprentice to a journeyman?

Christopher Berg (10:57:39):

Yes.

Speaker 31 (10:57:40):

Is there a pay increase? What is the difference in the pay increase?

Christopher Berg (10:57:44):

Significant from a second year to a journeyman, you're talking almost 50%.

Speaker 31 (10:57:52):

Now, when is the last time you saw Mr. Akers?

Christopher Berg (10:58:00):

I want to say it was right before his death. It was in December.

Speaker 31 (10:58:07):

And what was the circumstance of that encounter?

Christopher Berg (10:58:12):

I honestly do not recall. I can't remember. I just know it was right around December. It was after Thanksgiving.

Speaker 31 (10:58:30):

Now, you've known this victim, Mr. Akers, for quite some time. Were you ever around him during the Christmas season?

Christopher Berg (10:58:40):

Yes.

Speaker 31 (10:58:41):

What was his attitude around Christmas time?

Christopher Berg (10:58:45):

He was happy.

Speaker 31 (10:58:48):

Was that an important event for him, Christmas?

Christopher Berg (10:58:51):

Yeah. He got to see his kids and be around his family.

Speaker 31 (10:58:56):

Now, when you learned about Mr. Akers' death, did you have any occasion to try to recover any of his items from work?

Christopher Berg (10:59:20):

I did recover his items from work along with his dad.

Speaker 31 (10:59:28):

Along with Mr. Akers' dad?

Christopher Berg (10:59:31):

Yes.

Speaker 31 (10:59:31):

You and his dad. What did you do?

Christopher Berg (10:59:33):

We went to Piedmont Hospital. I got in touch with the foreman and said that we needed to get Dan's tools because he had died.

Speaker 31 (10:59:45):

Well, you had been working with Mr. Akers for quite a while. Did you ever know of his job to be in jeopardy?

Christopher Berg (10:59:58):

No.

Speaker 31 (10:59:58):

And you said that pretty emphatically. How can you be so sure?

Christopher Berg (11:00:01):

Because I think if anyone's job would've been in jeopardy at that point, it would've been a journeyman's before an apprentice's because of-

Raymond Lyall (11:00:12):

Objection, speculation.

Speaker 33 (11:00:16):

Any response to that, Mr [inaudible 11:00:20]?

Speaker 31 (11:00:17):

No, Your Honor. I'll move on.

Speaker 33 (11:00:17):

I'll sustain.

Speaker 31 (11:00:34):

Did you ever see Mr. Akers with a gun?

Christopher Berg (11:00:42):

Once.

Speaker 31 (11:00:43):

And when was that?

Christopher Berg (11:00:44):

That would've been seven years ... I couldn't tell you exactly when.

Speaker 31 (11:00:53):

About seven years ago?

Christopher Berg (11:00:54):

Yes. It might've been around the same time we were having cookouts.

Speaker 31 (11:01:03):

Now let me show you what has been marked for identification as State's Exhibit number 173A and ask if you've ever seen this gun before.

Christopher Berg (11:01:17):

Yes.

Speaker 31 (11:01:18):

Where did you see it?

Christopher Berg (11:01:19):

In their bedroom.

Speaker 31 (11:01:21):

Whose bedroom?

Christopher Berg (11:01:22):

Lacey and Dan's.

Speaker 31 (11:01:23):

And how did you happen to see it?

Christopher Berg (11:01:25):

I can't remember how the conversation started, but Dan had showed me it before.

Speaker 31 (11:01:32):

And that was seven years ago?

Christopher Berg (11:01:34):

Yep.

Speaker 31 (11:01:36):

Now, did you ever see Mr. Akers carry around a camo holster with a gun in it?

Christopher Berg (11:01:47):

No, but I would only say that it was a dark holster that when he showed me that gun, that was a dark holster that looked close to camo.

Speaker 31 (11:02:06):

Okay. And that was the only time, the seven years ago?

Christopher Berg (11:02:10):

Yes.

Speaker 31 (11:02:11):

Okay. Now, did you know whether Mr. Akers was right-handed or left-handed?

Christopher Berg (11:02:21):

I know he was right-handed.

Speaker 31 (11:02:28):

Now you say you saw Mr. Akers with a gun seven years ago. Did you ever see him carrying that gun around?

Christopher Berg (11:02:37):

No.

Speaker 31 (11:02:37):

Did you ever see him carrying that gun around in a holster?

Christopher Berg (11:02:41):

I've never seen him carry a gun.

Speaker 31 (11:02:44):

Other than that one time seven years ago, did you ever see Mr. Akers with a gun or with a camo holster?

Christopher Berg (11:02:54):

No.

Speaker 31 (11:03:33):

Mr. Berg, I showed you what's previously been marked for identification as state's exhibit number 227 and ask if you can identify that exhibit.

Christopher Berg (11:03:44):

I can.

Speaker 31 (11:03:46):

And how can you identify it?

Christopher Berg (11:03:47):

Because I'm the person on the left and Dan is on the right.

Speaker 31 (11:03:52):

State tenders into evidence state's exhibit number 227. And also, Your Honor, I wanted to tender exhibits number 223, 224, and 225 from earlier in the day. Is there any objection to that?

Speaker 33 (11:04:20):

No objection to that exhibit. What other exhibits are you talking about?

Speaker 31 (11:04:23):

I think that was the medical examiner bullet in the test fires or ... Do you recall what those were? I think it was the firearms report from miss-

Speaker 33 (11:04:42):

Ms. Wicks?

Speaker 31 (11:04:43):

No. Von Holm.

Speaker 33 (11:04:45):

Oh

Speaker 31 (11:04:45):

Yeah.

Speaker 33 (11:04:47):

Okay.

Speaker 31 (11:04:48):

They were all identified, foundation laid. I just neglected to tender them.

Speaker 33 (11:04:52):

No objection.

Speaker 31 (11:04:53):

Okay.

Speaker 33 (11:04:54):

All right. So that's 223, 224, 225 are in from earlier and 227 now. Any objection to that?

Speaker 31 (11:05:01):

Yes, your honor.

Speaker 33 (11:05:01):

No objection to 227-

Judge (11:05:00):

... now and you just-

Mr. Cole (11:05:00):

Yes, Your Honor.

Judge (11:05:01):

Any objection to 227? Okay.

Speaker 35 (11:05:01):

No, sir.

Judge (11:05:04):

That's it.

Mr. Cole (11:05:11):

Now, Mr. Burke, with regard to State's 227, do you recognize that photo?

Burke (11:05:23):

The one on this screen? Yes.

Mr. Cole (11:05:29):

And who is on the left side of that picture as you're looking at it?

Burke (11:05:38):

That would be me.

Mr. Cole (11:05:40):

And who is on the right side of that picture?

Burke (11:05:43):

That would be Dan.

Mr. Cole (11:05:45):

And do you recall when that picture was made?

Burke (11:05:49):

I do.

Mr. Cole (11:05:50):

And when was that roughly?

Burke (11:05:53):

That was 2018, early 2018, if I'm correct.

Mr. Cole (11:06:01):

And you obviously are there working with him. Do you know where that's taken?

Burke (11:06:08):

Yes, that is at his mother's house.

Mr. Cole (11:06:10):

That's at Mr. Akers' mother's house?

Burke (11:06:12):

Yes.

Mr. Cole (11:06:15):

Okay. And did you pay attention to what hand Mr. Akers was using while he was working on his mother's house?

Burke (11:06:22):

Yes.

Mr. Cole (11:06:23):

And what hand was that?

Burke (11:06:25):

His right.

Mr. Cole (11:06:26):

And have you ever seen him use his left hand to throw a ball or anything like that?

Burke (11:06:34):

No.

Mr. Cole (11:06:34):

Are you familiar with the term ambidextrous?

Burke (11:06:40):

Yes.

Mr. Cole (11:06:41):

All your knowledge of Mr. Akers, did you say he was ambidextrous or not?

Burke (11:06:47):

Not to my knowledge, no.

Mr. Cole (11:06:52):

Now, did you have occasion to sell Mr. Akers a car at some point?

Burke (11:07:00):

I did.

Mr. Cole (11:07:01):

And what were the arrangements on the purchase of that car and when was it bought?

Burke (11:07:07):

I can't remember when it was bought. The arrangement was I knew that he could not pay it in full and I think we asked $900-

Judge (11:07:18):

Let me interrupt. Is everybody okay?

Speaker 36 (11:07:20):

Yeah, we're fine.

Judge (11:07:24):

All right. If anybody need a break or anything, it'd be okay. Y'all okay?

Speaker 36 (11:07:25):

Yes, Your Honor.

Judge (11:07:28):

You okay? You okay?

Speaker 36 (11:07:28):

Will stay a little longer.

Judge (11:07:28):

All right. All right. Sorry about that.

Mr. Cole (11:07:38):

Okay. Do you recall how close to before Mr. Akers died that this car was purchased approximately?

Burke (11:07:46):

I could not tell you exactly. A couple months, maybe close to a year.

Mr. Cole (11:07:53):

Now, the type of work that you do with the sheet metal, with Local 85, is that the kind of job where you can just be laid off pretty quickly or what's the circumstances on that?

Raymond Lale (11:08:17):

Judge, relevance.

Judge (11:08:21):

Overruled.

Mr. Cole (11:08:26):

You can go ahead and answer that question.

Burke (11:08:28):

So yes, you can be laid off.

Mr. Cole (11:08:30):

You can be laid off, but is it something that happens overnight or is it something that takes a while to do?

Burke (11:08:37):

It could happen overnight, but normally you would know that a layoff is coming.

Mr. Cole (11:08:47):

Okay. Well, let's talk about Mr. Akers' situation since you worked with him. A worker such as Mr. Akers, what would be the chances of him being laid off just overnight?

Raymond Lale (11:09:01):

That's speculation, Judge. What are the chances of somebody getting laid off?

Mr. Cole (11:09:05):

Well, I'll just ask you straight out. Was Mr. Akers about to be laid off?

Burke (11:09:09):

Not to my knowledge.

Mr. Cole (11:09:10):

Okay.

(11:09:26)
Who encouraged Mr. Akers to join the union?

Burke (11:09:29):

I did.

Mr. Cole (11:09:36):

When you were with Mr. Akers in a personal setting, did you ever see him with his children coaching football or anything like that?

Burke (11:09:48):

I seen him practicing football, yes.

Mr. Cole (11:09:55):

Did you notice how much time he spent with his family and his children?

Burke (11:10:01):

If he wasn't at work, he was spending time with his children.

Judge (11:10:03):

He's waiting.

Mr. Cole (11:10:03):

Can we approach?

Judge (11:10:03):

Well, wait your client's presence. Yes? What's that?

(11:10:03)
All right, Mr. Cole, did you have some more questions?

Mr. Cole (11:10:03):

No, Your Honor.

Judge (11:10:03):

All right.

Raymond Lale (11:10:03):

Mr. Burke, good afternoon.

Burke (11:14:38):

Good afternoon.

Raymond Lale (11:14:39):

My name is Raymond Lale. I along with Brian Steel represent Lacy Boles. Just a few questions for you.

(11:14:53)
What's that? Okay.

(11:14:58)
I believe you testified that back at Thanksgiving 2019, that Dan and Lacy were at your home for a Thanksgiving gathering, correct?

Burke (11:15:12):

Correct.

Raymond Lale (11:15:13):

Okay. And you said the children were there, families were there, you know?

Burke (11:15:18):

Yes.

Raymond Lale (11:15:18):

So it's Thanksgiving, it's a celebration,

Burke (11:15:19):

Right?

Raymond Lale (11:15:20):

Okay. And I believe you testified that you were asked a question about her demeanor, and I think you said at the end she was argumentative. I'm assuming you meant at the end of the evening, is that correct?

Burke (11:15:42):

Not at the end of the evening because the Thanksgiving kept going on. We had the party to where people can still hang out, play cards, drink, whatever.

Raymond Lale (11:15:53):

Okay.

Burke (11:15:55):

I guess after food was served is what I meant.

Raymond Lale (11:15:58):

I thought you had said earlier at the end she was getting argued. I'm assuming that meant at the end of the evening or the end of the celebration. When you said at the end, I just wrote it down.

Burke (11:16:06):

Okay.

Raymond Lale (11:16:06):

Okay. So, I mean, Dan and Lacy are married. The kids are there. They got three kids at the time. They were ages two, three, and six, correct? Did you know they were two, three, and six at the time?

Burke (11:16:24):

You're missing children out of that statement.

Raymond Lale (11:16:26):

I'm sorry?

Burke (11:16:27):

You're missing children out of that statement.

Raymond Lale (11:16:29):

No, no. I mean, the three children they have together. They're three biological children.

Burke (11:16:33):

Yes.

Raymond Lale (11:16:33):

Okay. And so all the children were there, then seven total, correct?

Burke (11:16:39):

Yes.

Raymond Lale (11:16:39):

Okay. So they were all at your house at Thanksgiving?

Burke (11:16:42):

Except for Skylar and Phoenix.

Raymond Lale (11:16:44):

Okay. Okay. So you would agree with me, wouldn't you, that it's not necessarily uncommon for husbands and wives to maybe argue if the wife's saying, "Hey, it's time to go," and the husband doesn't want to go. So they're arguing with each other. I mean, they're-

Burke (11:17:02):

Sometimes they do.

Raymond Lale (11:17:03):

Right. Would you agree?

Burke (11:17:06):

Yeah.

Raymond Lale (11:17:07):

Okay. Husbands and wives argue sometimes.

Burke (11:17:09):

Yeah, that's what I'm agreeing.

Raymond Lale (11:17:09):

Okay. Now, you've known him for about four years at the time and you guys worked together, correct?

Burke (11:17:28):

Correct.

Raymond Lale (11:17:31):

Okay. And I believe when you were interviewed by the police or law enforcement about this case back in February of 2020, your wife was interviewed, correct?

Burke (11:17:45):

I would assume so, yes. I don't remember her interview.

Raymond Lale (11:17:47):

Okay. And you were interviewed, correct?

Burke (11:17:50):

I would assume so, yes.

Raymond Lale (11:17:51):

And you went to the police station and they interviewed you?

Burke (11:17:54):

Went to the police station?

Raymond Lale (11:17:56):

Did they interview you?

Burke (11:17:57):

I do not think that they did. You're asking me something that happened a long time ago. I don't remember.

Raymond Lale (11:18:02):

Okay. Okay. At the interview, did you indicate to law enforcement that Dan was worried about losing his job because he had smoked some marijuana?

Burke (11:18:14):

Not to my knowledge, no.

Raymond Lale (11:18:15):

Okay. And you certainly wouldn't have indicated to Dan that he needed to get around the drug test by bringing some fake urine, right?

Burke (11:18:26):

I mean, I don't understand the question. I'm sorry.

Raymond Lale (11:18:30):

You never told Dan Akers to get around a drug test to bring some fake urine with you to the drug test. You never told him that, right?

Burke (11:18:38):

I'm not saying that, no, because I would tell anyone that's in the local, if you're afraid of a drug test, that use fake urine because-

Raymond Lale (11:18:49):

Yeah. So you never told him that, right? That's what your testimony is.

Burke (11:18:53):

No.

Raymond Lale (11:18:55):

Okay.

Burke (11:18:55):

I don't believe so.

Raymond Lale (11:18:56):

Okay. Well, can we put up 142? 142A? This is already in evidence and these are some Instagram messages. And if you'll direct your attention to either the screen or on your... Can you see it there?

Burke (11:19:21):

Yes.

Raymond Lale (11:19:21):

Okay. Yeah. So Daniel Akers' phone number ends in 5462, and this is a message to, it says Chris 85. Is that you?

Burke (11:19:41):

Yes.

Raymond Lale (11:19:41):

Okay. And that's your phone number, correct?

Burke (11:19:43):

Correct.

Raymond Lale (11:19:44):

Okay. And it says, "Have you been badged for the airport before?" Do you remember that exchange with him? Do you remember that? That looks like it's 12/13 of 2019, so between Thanksgiving and Christmas.

Burke (11:20:00):

I do not remember that exchange, no.

Raymond Lale (11:20:02):

Okay. Let's go to the next one. Then in response to that, according to this exhibit, it's already in the evidence, it shows it's from you, Chris 85, and that's you, correct?

Burke (11:20:16):

Correct.

Raymond Lale (11:20:17):

Okay. To Daniel Akers, right?

Burke (11:20:20):

Yep.

Raymond Lale (11:20:21):

Okay. And you say on that date, 12/13/2019 at 6:40, " No problem. We're family and no, and H never would let me come out there. Why?" Do you recall sending him that? I mean, do you dispute that you sent him that? You say this is not true?

Burke (11:20:51):

I'm not disputing that, but I do not remember the text message from seven years ago.

Raymond Lale (11:20:56):

Okay. But you see that it's a text message from your phone to his phone, correct?

Burke (11:21:03):

Correct.

Raymond Lale (11:21:03):

Okay. Next one. Going down a little bit. Okay. And this is from Daniel to you, again, the same date at 6:42 where he asked you, "Just wondering about the process, because I smoked a little while ago, and if I may need to worry about a test, I should be good, but you never can tell." Do you recall getting that message from him?

Burke (11:21:39):

I do not recall getting the text messages from him. I don't remember this conversation from seven years ago.

Raymond Lale (11:21:45):

Okay.

Burke (11:21:45):

But if this is a text thread.

Raymond Lale (11:21:48):

Okay. I mean, are you saying none of this is true, you just don't remember?

Burke (11:21:52):

I just don't remember.

Raymond Lale (11:21:53):

Okay. Fair enough.

Mr. Cole (11:21:54):

I'm going to object, Judge. I ask that Mr. Burke be allowed to complete his response before Mr. Lale asks the next question.

Judge (11:22:03):

All right. You're welcome to. Were you done?

Burke (11:22:06):

No.

Judge (11:22:06):

All right, go ahead.

Burke (11:22:07):

I do not remember a text thread from seven years ago. That's kind of hard to remember. I don't have that same number. I don't even have that same phone. Otherwise, I would've probably looked back at it in memory trying to remember Dan, because I'm almost positive I have pictures of them in between our text threads. So no, I don't remember this conversation. But if you were saying that this is my phone and that this is his phone, yes, then I clearly had the conversation. But if you're asking me if I remember the totality of a text thread from seven years ago, no.

Raymond Lale (11:22:46):

Okay. So you don't remember it because it's been seven years ago, but you admit that that's your phone to his phone and you admit that those are the text messages between you guys?

Burke (11:22:54):

Correct.

Raymond Lale (11:22:54):

Okay. All right. So now, again, from you to Dan at 6:43:41, you say to him, "Strap up IDK," meaning I don't know, "if they watch you." Right?

Burke (11:23:16):

Yeah.

Raymond Lale (11:23:16):

Well, strap up means gets a fake urine, right?

Burke (11:23:20):

Yes.

Raymond Lale (11:23:20):

Okay. Next one. And finally from Dan back to you, just maybe a minute later, 6:44, he says, "I hear you." Yeah. So that speaks for itself. So Mr. Cole asked you a question about seeing Dan Akers with a gun.

Burke (11:24:04):

Yes.

Raymond Lale (11:24:04):

Correct? And I believe you pointed out it's the gun that's here in evidence, correct?

Burke (11:24:09):

Correct.

Raymond Lale (11:24:09):

Okay. And you testified that the gun was in a holster, a darker holster, correct?

Burke (11:24:18):

Correct.

Raymond Lale (11:24:19):

Not the camo holster that's here, right, but in a darker holster?

Burke (11:24:23):

In a dark holster.

Raymond Lale (11:24:24):

Okay.

Burke (11:24:25):

Yes.

Raymond Lale (11:24:25):

Okay. Fair enough. So if you recall, when Dan showed you the gun... I mean, it's seven years ago. Did you go up to his room and he say, "Hey man, here's my gun," and pull it out of the holster and then show it to you? Or do you remember how that happened?

Burke (11:24:42):

I don't remember the context, no, but I remember him showing me.

Raymond Lale (11:24:45):

Okay. But you remember it was in a holster and then he showed it to you?

Burke (11:24:48):

Yes. And then I briefly remember him putting it back into a safe.

Raymond Lale (11:24:56):

Okay. And that was 2019, correct?

Burke (11:24:57):

Correct.

Raymond Lale (11:24:58):

And you said seven years ago, so it was 2019?

Burke (11:24:59):

Yeah.

Raymond Lale (11:25:01):

Okay. Do you know how many holsters that Dan Akers owned in 2019?

Burke (11:25:12):

No.

Raymond Lale (11:25:13):

Yeah. You have no idea if he owned just that one holster or he had a dozen holsters. You don't know, do you?

Burke (11:25:19):

No.

Raymond Lale (11:25:20):

Yeah. So you don't know if he had that camo holster, he just didn't have the gun in there that day, do you?

Burke (11:25:26):

I know that he was showing me a silver revolver in a dark holster.

Raymond Lale (11:25:32):

Yeah. But you don't know if he had another camo holster that he didn't show you, right? You don't know that.

Burke (11:25:38):

Correct.

Raymond Lale (11:25:38):

Okay.

(11:25:53)
Thank you, sir.

Judge (11:25:54):

Any redirect?

Mr. Cole (11:25:56):

No, Your Honor.

Judge (11:26:00):

All right, sir, you're free to go. All right. I think that's going to round out our day, unless you have a five-minute witness or something like that. Say you have a moment or.

Mr. Cole (11:26:09):

I don't have a five-minute witness.

Judge (11:26:13):

All right. All right.

Raymond Lale (11:26:16):

I'm sorry. I'm sorry.

Judge (11:26:17):

That's okay.

Raymond Lale (11:26:18):

Can I have the witness back? I'm sorry.

Judge (11:26:19):

All right, sir. Call him back for just one minute.

Raymond Lale (11:26:52):

Sorry about that, sir. I apologize, Judge. It just slipped my mind.

(11:26:52)
May I approach, Judge? It's been marked as Ms. Boles number 144 and ask you if you recognize that person there.

Burke (11:27:01):

Yes. That would be Dan holding a marker for the football.

Raymond Lale (11:27:08):

Okay. Very good. Thank you. Judge, I'll tender.

Judge (11:27:08):

Any objection?

Mr. Cole (11:27:08):

No objection.

Judge (11:27:08):

Admitted.

Raymond Lale (11:27:17):

And just so you know, he's... Well, he's holding this as his left hand, correct?

Burke (11:27:24):

Yes.

Raymond Lale (11:27:25):

Okay. That's all I have. Thank you.

Judge (11:27:30):

You're dismissed. Thank you.

Burke (11:27:33):

Thank you.

Mr. Cole (11:27:35):

Judge, I didn't have another question since you called him back.

Burke (11:27:36):

It's all good.

Mr. Cole (11:27:45):

Mr. Burke, do you know whose gun that was that you were shown in 2019? Do you know whose gun that was?

Burke (11:27:51):

Yes.

Mr. Cole (11:27:51):

Whose was it?

Burke (11:27:52):

Dan told me it was Lacy's.

Mr. Cole (11:28:00):

All right. Thank you.

Judge (11:28:00):

Anything else?

Mr. Cole (11:28:00):

Nothing further, Sir.

Judge (11:28:00):

All right. At this time, we're sure, right?

Mr. Cole (11:28:00):

Yes.

Raymond Lale (11:28:00):

Yes, sir.

Judge (11:28:00):

All right, better run. Can I ask him one more time?

Speaker 34 (11:28:01):

The witness has asked if he could remain in the courtroom from this point.

Judge (11:28:16):

That's fine.

Speaker 34 (11:28:17):

I would inquire if the defense has any objection to that.

Speaker 35 (11:28:26):

No objection. Thank you.

Judge (11:28:27):

Okay.

(11:28:27)
All right, ladies and gentlemen, this has been a long day. We're going to do it one more time tomorrow, and then you're going to get a long weekend. One of the things I want you to think about and talk to your family with tonight and then talk amongst yourselves when you're in the jury room tomorrow is what next week looks like. I'm available next week, Monday, Tuesday, and Wednesday. You may not be. If you can't do Monday, Tuesday, and Wednesday, then the next question is, can you do Monday, Tuesday, and half a day Wednesday? If you can't do that, tell us. We just want to hear from you so we can plan. So be thinking about that, okay? Thank you very much.

(11:29:06)
[inaudible 11:29:24]. Before we wrap up, just out of an abundance of caution, we had a brief bench conference and the defense waived Ms. Boles' presence. And what came up was that one of the defense attorneys said that the question had been asked by the state about the decedent spending time with the children, and then there was a suggestion that perhaps that was character evidence and opened the door to bad character evidence. And then I think it was the court that brought up that it sounded to me like victim impact, potentially not quite there yet, but if questions continued along those lines, then that might be victim impact. And the state indicated that it understood, and I don't think any further questions were asked. And then I think Mr. Steel asked, "Well, can I cross with the bad character evidence?" And I said, "I don't think we've reached that point yet." So is there anything else that was said during that bench conference of substance that y'all want to put on the record?

Speaker 35 (11:30:51):

No, we just wanted to show the impeachment for bad character of Mr. Akers, since I believe good character has been introduced by the state with these questions. And I would've shown the prior conviction from Douglas County, the conviction or the admission on his probation revocation that he possessed methamphetamine in Cobb County, and I was going to go down that whole path. The court ruled it inadmissible and I respect that decision. Ms. Boles was not present. She's aware of everything that occurred at the bench.

Judge (11:31:22):

All right. Can we all agree that was the substance of the bench conference?

Mr. Cole (11:31:25):

Yes, Your Honor.

Speaker 35 (11:31:26):

Yes, sir.

Judge (11:31:26):

Yes. Thank you very much, gentlemen. So we'll have another long day tomorrow. We'll go 8:30 till about 8:00 again, and then we'll have a long weekend.

Speaker 35 (11:31:35):

And then, Your Honor, we will talk amongst ourselves, but otherwise, there may be a witness, and the state said that we can break their case if the court will allow.

Judge (11:31:47):

All right, so we'll plan on taking the defense witness out of order tomorrow. Is that right?

Mr. Cole (11:31:51):

What time would that be?

Speaker 35 (11:31:53):

What time could you write after lunch, I guess?

Mr. Cole (11:31:56):

I guess we can do it after lunch. All right.

Judge (11:32:03):

Okay. And that witness... Well, we'll have a long after lunch tomorrow, so you'll finish the witness then.

Speaker 35 (11:32:10):

Thank you.

Judge (11:32:11):

All right. See y'all in the morning. Thank you.

Speaker 35 (11:32:13):

Thank you, Your Honor.

Judge (11:32:13):

I'm giving you these. Do they go to jury tomorrow?

(11:32:13)
[inaudible 11:32:22].

(11:32:13)
Okay. Right.

‍

Topics:
No items found.
Hungry For More?

Luckily for you, we deliver. Subscribe to our blog today.

Thank You for Subscribing!

A confirmation email is on it’s way to your inbox.

Share this post

Copyright Disclaimer

Under Title 17 U.S.C. Section 107, allowance is made for "fair use" for purposes such as criticism, comment, news reporting, teaching, scholarship, and research. Fair use is permitted by copyright statute that might otherwise be infringing.

Subscribe to The Rev Blog

Sign up to get Rev content delivered straight to your inbox.