Live Weekly Demo | Led by a Rev Workflow Specialist
Save Your Spot
FL v. Dwain Hall Day 1

FL v. Dwain Hall Day 1

Dwain Hall stands trial for the alleged murder of Sonia Exelby, day one. Read the transcript here.

Dwain Hall stands trial for the alleged murder of Sonia Exelby, day one.
Hungry For More?

Luckily for you, we deliver. Subscribe to our blog today.

Thank You for Subscribing!

A confirmation email is on it’s way to your inbox.

Share this post

Copyright Disclaimer

Under Title 17 U.S.C. Section 107, allowance is made for "fair use" for purposes such as criticism, comment, news reporting, teaching, scholarship, and research. Fair use is permitted by copyright statute that might otherwise be infringing.

Speaker 1 (11:41):

All rise. Circuit court in the Fort Mary County is not in session. The Honorable Timothy T. McCourt presiding.

Judge McCourt (11:44):

Good morning, y'all can be seated.

Speaker 1 (11:48):

We are here in 2025 CF4516, State of Florida versus Dwain C. Hall. Will counsel for the parties identify for the record?

Amy Berndt (11:55):

Amy Berndt for the State.

Rich Buxman (11:56):

Rich Buxman for the State.

Junior Barrett (11:57):

Junior Barrett representing Mr. Hall.

Jacques Ward (12:00):

Jacques Ward, also representing Mr. Hall.

Judge McCourt (12:02):

Good morning, counsel. All right. Mr. Hall is present, seated at the [inaudible 00:12:05]. Mr. Hall, raise your right hand for me. Do you swear to tell the truth, the whole truth, nothing but the truth, so help you God?

Dwain Hall (12:09):

Yes.

Judge McCourt (12:09):

Okay. Mr. Hall, you can put your hand down. Are you shackled?

Dwain Hall (12:12):

No.

Judge McCourt (12:12):

Are you handcuffed?

Dwain Hall (12:14):

No.

Judge McCourt (12:14):

Okay. I'm going to have you stand up, take a couple steps back, so I can describe your clothing from head to toe. All right, Mr. Hall is in custody, though he does not look it. He's wearing a light purple colored dress shirt, buttoned down and pair of charcoal colored slacks, a belt and a pair of dress shoes, appropriate dress for court. And neither handcuffed nor shackled. Be seated, Mr. Hall. Thank you.

(12:38)
State defense, anything else before we bring in the jury from you all?

Amy Berndt (12:44):

Nothing from the state, Your Honor.

Junior Barrett (12:44):

Nothing from the defense, Your Honor.

Judge McCourt (12:45):

All right. State, my understanding is that the first witness you all are intending to call today is Stevie Hunt via Zoom.

Amy Berndt (12:52):

That is correct, Your Honor.

Judge McCourt (12:52):

All right. I'm going to take a few minutes to get the Zoom platform queued up.

Zoom (13:05):

Welcome to Zoom. Please press pound, then enter your meeting ID followed by the pound sign again. You are in the meeting now. Recording in progress.

Judge McCourt (14:21):

Ms. Berndt, I have nobody in my Zoom waiting room. Is anybody from your office in contact with the witness?

Amy Berndt (14:27):

Yes, Judge. I told him not to be there until 8:30 because we were going to have opening statements.

Judge McCourt (14:38):

Okay. Are we ready to bring in the jury?

Amy Berndt (14:40):

State's ready, Your Honor.

Junior Barrett (14:41):

Yes, Your Honor.

Judge McCourt (14:43):

Okay. All right. Everybody's here, correct?

Speaker 1 (14:45):

All [inaudible 00:14:46].

Judge McCourt (14:45):

Let's bring them in.

(14:46)
Everyone can be seated. Thank you. Ladies and gentlemen, welcome back. Everybody have a good night? All right. So a couple of things I want to go over with you here this morning. First, I needed to talk with you. When we separated yesterday, I instructed all of you to not learn about the case or attempt to learn about the case or not to speak about the case or do any research about the case. Has everybody here been able to follow that instruction if you have nod your head in the affirmative up and down? Have you been able to follow that instruction?

Jurior (17:02):

Pardon me?

Judge McCourt (17:03):

Has everybody here been able to follow that instruction?

Juriors (17:05):

Yes. Yes, sir.

Judge McCourt (17:07):

I need to see all the heads nodding, yes or no?

Juriors (17:09):

Yes. Yes.

Judge McCourt (17:09):

Okay. Everybody has nodded in the affirmative for the record. Now, you'll notice in the courtroom today, we do have a lot of cameras here. I told you that this case has attracted some amount of media attention. I do want to let you all know that as jurors, you are not filmed, you are not televised. Your images are not put on the television. Okay? So it is for all intents and purposes of black void over there, and the camera will not turn toward you or film you if you were wondering that. Okay? So at this point in time, ladies and gentlemen, the attorneys will now have the opportunity, if they wish, to make an opening statement. The opening statement gives the attorneys the opportunity to tell you what evidence they believe will be presented during the trial. What the attorneys say is not evidence, you are not to consider it as such.

(17:53)
State, you may proceed.

Amy Berndt (17:54):

May it please the Court, Counsel. Good morning, members of the jurors. Good morning. On Friday, October 10th of 2025, 32-year-old Sonia Exelby flew from England to the United States. By Sunday, October 12th, she was dead. She was brutally murdered by a predator, a man who called himself Alpha Sadist. A man who was sexually aroused by the rape and torture of women. That man is the defendant, Dwain Hall. Sonia Exelby was a beautiful, kind woman who was deeply loved by everyone who knew her, but sadly, she suffered from mental illness for most of her life. She met the defendant online and he manipulated her for years. He targeted her because of her mental illness and he exploited her for his own sadistic pleasure. And when he finally got her alone, thousands of miles away from home, completely incapable of making any rational decisions, he stabbed her to death and buried her body.

(19:20)
Now, before you can understand why this happened and how this happened, you have to understand a little bit of the history of Sonia Exelby. Sonia was born in England and she was the youngest of six siblings. She had two sisters and three brothers. Unfortunately, their household was one of which no child should ever have to grow up in. Both of Sonia's parents were mentally ill and her father also suffered from a drug addiction. Child Social Services intervened early on and removed all six siblings from the house. All of the siblings were very close. They were split up and sent different places. Sonia was two years old when this happened, and she and her sister Sarah, who was five years old, were placed in a foster home together. And that foster home wasn't much better than what they had at home. They were in that foster home for three years, and then Sarah and Sonia were adopted together.

(20:26)
Now, even though during that three-year period, Sonia and her siblings would periodically see each other and spend time together. When Sarah and Sonia were adopted, their adoptive parents thought it would be best if Sonia and Sara had no more contact with their siblings. Now, Sonia was unable to escape the trauma of her childhood. And when she was a teenager, around 13 or 14 years old, she began struggling with mental illness. She started cutting herself and she developed bulimia, which was an eating disorder. And even though she did go to counseling and therapy, her mental health would decline and she would struggle with her mental illness for her whole life and be diagnosed with many other disorders.

(21:17)
However, when Sonia was 17, there was a bright spot that came into her life. She was working at a movie theater and she met a man named Steven Hunt. She was 17 and Steven Hunt was two years older than her and everybody called him Stevie, and he also worked at the movie theater. They were friends at first, and then when Sonia turned 18, they started dating. Within months of when they began dating, Sonia told him about her mental health struggles. She was very open about the bulimia, being bipolar, having depression.

(21:57)
Stevie had a choice to make. He could stay or he could go. And Stevie will tell you that he believed with his whole heart that Sonia was the woman for him and was the love of his life. He told her, "We can make this work and we can have a great life together." And from that moment on, he never left her. In the meantime, when Sonia was 18, she and Sarah were able to find their older siblings and reunite with them. The older siblings were thrilled to be reunited with Sonia and Sarah. They hadn't seen them since they were adopted. They had thought of them often and wondered where they were, and there was an ache in their heart all those years for Sonia and Sarah. So that was a great time in her life.

(22:50)
And over the years, the siblings tried to understand Sonia's mental health and what she'd been going through. They talked about it, but often they would try to spend time with Sonia. They would plan meetings, gatherings, but due to her mental health, she would not show up many times and she would cancel. And while they would be disappointed, they still loved her and tried to plan things with her. But over the years, as it happens with mental health, Sonia's mental health was up and down. There were good times and there were bad times. And those bad times included two suicide attempts by overdose. And you'll learn that most of the time, Sonia was always trying to find some substitute for the cutting, some outlet that would make her feel alive and feel something again.

(23:51)
Unfortunately, she found another outlet for the cutting, about two years before her death, and ultimately that outlet would lead to her murder. And that began when she got on a website called Motherless. Motherless was a website that allowed users to upload pornographic videos and photographs. It also allowed the members on Motherless to communicate with each other. But the users of Motherless over the years started uploading videos of women actually being raped, women being tortured, women being murdered, as well as child sexual adult material, abuse material. The website was shut down this year because of those things. The servers were seized and there's an ongoing criminal investigation. But before it was shut down, Sonia was communicating on Motherless with many different men. She was trying to find somebody that would kill her. Her mental health was declining. She wanted to die, and she knew that she couldn't do it herself.

(25:10)
And unfortunately, there was no shortage of depraved men willing to kill Sonia in the most torturous and vile ways possible. And they would send her messages and describe to her how they would kill her. Sadly, due to her mental health issues, this was something that Sonia used as a substitute for the cutting. These things made her feel alive when she would read them. Now, even though there were many men competing for this job, one man went out, one man would manipulate and groom Sonia until he won the job of being her executioner. And that person was the defendant, Dwain Hall. Dwain Hall's username on Motherless, the name he chose, the name he wanted to be called was Alpha Sadist.

(26:14)
And part of his bio on Motherless read, "Would love to find a domestic pain for complete control." That's what he was looking for. Sonia and the defendant would communicate over Motherless for quite some time, and then they moved to another platform called Sessions, which is a phone app. It's more private, it's encrypted, and the messages would delete automatically. And you'll learn that the defendant lived in Marion County and he was married to a woman named Ginger Stein, and he owned his own business called Solver Wolf Roadside Assistance. And what he would do is people would call him, they would say they had a flat tire, something minor wrong with their car. He would respond to where they were and fix their car. Even though he lived in Marion County, he basically serviced Alachua County and the Gainesville area.

(27:17)
Now, the first attempt that Sonia and the defendant made for him to kill her happened in March of 2025. She planned to come here, but then that fell through. After that fell through, the defendant realized, "Hey, not only can I kill her, but I might as well get some money from it as well." And he told her that she had to bring $4,000 cash with her when she actually came here for him to kill her. So after the March of 2025 trip fell through, they planned another one. And that trip was planned for Friday, October 10th, 2025, she would come here to the United States. And in September of 2025, Sonia booked that plane ticket. She also booked an Airbnb in Reddick, which is just north of Ocala, from Friday, October 10th to Sunday, October 12th.

(28:16)
This was the plan. Everything was booked. But now Sonia couldn't tell Stevie and her family that she was coming here. It happened to be on that same weekend her sister Sarah, who lived in Australia, was planning to visit their other sister named Gemma, who also lived in England about 45 minutes away from Sonia. So Sonia, her sister Sarah and Gemma all spoke and Sonia said, "Hey, let's make it a sister's weekend. I'll come visit you guys and we'll spend the weekend together." Of course, her sister Sara and Gemma thought, that would be fantastic. They would love to see her and spend that weekend together. Sonia told Stevie, "Hey, I'm going to have the sister's weekend with Gemma and Sarah." He was also thrilled. Due to her mental health, Sonia did not get out of the house much and she didn't go many places.

(29:15)
So the plan was she would go Friday to Gemma's and come back on Sunday. Well, she messaged Gemma and said, "Well, I'm not going to come on Friday, but I'll come on Saturday," and then messaged her later and said, "Oh, I'm going to come on Sunday at two o'clock." So when Friday, October 10th rolled around, Stevie set his alarm early in the morning because he wanted to make sure that he could tell Sonia goodbye before she left on the trip. He got up, she was dressed, he'll tell you, in the dress with flowers, cardigan, sandals, and a black backpack with pink glitter writing on it. She told him she was going to take a taxi to her sister Gemma's house. He kissed her goodbye and watched her walk out the door. And that would be the last time he ever saw her alive again.

(30:16)
So on Sunday, when Sonia didn't show up to Gemma's as planned at two o'clock, Gemma and Sarah were disappointed. But again, they weren't worried because this was something that was typical of Sonia, for her not to show up once plans were made. So they communicated and texted her and said, "Hey, are you coming?" But she never responded. And she was supposed to be back to her house that she shared with Stevie that Sunday evening, October 12th. And when it got later and she didn't come home, Stevie called Gemma and said, "Hey, did Sonia leave yet? Because she's not home." And Gemma told Stevie she was never here. She never showed up.

(31:09)
Well, obviously panic sets in now because nobody has seen Sonia since Friday, October 10th, and they don't know where she is. And they know how fragile her mental health is. Stevie immediately calls the police that Sunday night to report Sonia missing. And while the police are on their way over to Stevie's, he gets on Sonia's computer and he checks and he looks at it. And he sees that Sonia emailed herself a letter from what appeared to be a plane. She said she was on a plane. And he read this letter and it was full of sorrow, depression, regret, and death. And it talked about suicide. Of course, Steve was panicked. When the officer got to his apartment, he gave them Sonia's computer. He told them about her mental health and he showed them that letter. They took all of that information and then Monday morning they gave it to a special unit they had in England for missing people.

(32:20)
And you're going to hear from the head of that unit, Sergeant Detective Darren Thomas. Monday morning, he was involved in it trying to find Sonia. He had a letter, he had a computer. And early on, he's able to find out that Sonia was on a plane from Heathrow in London, went to Atlanta and then landed in Gainesville. He confirmed she was on that flight. So now he contacts Interpol, which helps with international missing person cases like this. And Interpol contacts the Florida Department of Law Enforcement in Gainesville.

Amy Berndt (33:00):

And Interpol contacts the Florida Department of Law Enforcement in Gainesville since that's where she landed. And they assigned the case agent, and her name is Special Agent Rebecca McKenzie. So now you have Florida Department of Law Enforcement in Gainesville, and they are communicating with Detective Sergeant Darren Thomas in England. They're sharing information. They're trying to find out where could Sonia be. Well, they get Sonia's bank records in England. Of course, they want to see where has she spent money? Where could she possibly be? And they see that transaction for that Airbnb in Reddick. So they send out two deputies from the Marion County Sheriff's Office. Agent McKenzie says, "Can you go out to this Airbnb?" Maybe Sonia's there. Crisis averted. This is on Monday. The deputies go out to the Airbnb, knock on the door, look in the windows. No one's there. Sonia's not there.

(33:56)
They can't find her. They keep trying to look around and see where she could be. And Agent McKenzie starts doing search warrants for Facebook and other things to try to find out where she is. And then you'll learn that also when they get her bank records on Monday, they see that there was a charge attempted on one of her credit cards that was declined for $1,200. And this charge was attempted on Saturday, October 11th. And they're like, "What is this about?" And that charge was attempted by a company called Solver Wolf Roadside Assistance. And so they say, "Well, who owns this company? Dwain Hall owns it." So that Monday, agents from FDLE say, "Well, we need to talk to this guy and see what he knows about Sonia." So they call him on the phone and they say, "Hey, we're looking for this missing person. You ran her credit card on Saturday, October 11th for $1,200 and it was declined."

(35:02)
He completely lies to them. He says, "Some lady called me Friday or Saturday, said her car broke down and she needed a ride." I said, "Give me your credit card number." She gave me the credit card number. I ran it. It didn't go through. I told her I couldn't help her. And that was the end of our conversation. I don't know where she was. I never met her. I don't know where she was going." And so they say, "Okay, thank you." And they continue to investigate and try to find her. Again, they're doing search warrants, subpoenas, trying to get records. Well, as they're doing this, Tuesday, October 14th, they say, "You know what? We need to talk to that guy that owns that roadside assistance again, try to get some more information because we still can't find her."

(35:53)
They talked to him again. Same thing, lies. "Never met her, never saw her, don't know where she's going. I don't know anything." They're like, "Okay, this is strange." But they searched that Airbnb on Wednesday the 15th. They get permission from the owner and they go in there and they search that and they process it. And they say, "Let's look at the receipts in the trash." They always check the trash. And in the trash, they find a receipt for a Walmart in Gainesville. And the time on the receipt is right before Sonia's plane lands in Gainesville. And they're concerned by what's on this receipt.

(36:39)
On the receipts, a person bought a shovel, two different kinds of rope, deodorant and gun oil. This is concerning that this receipt is in the Airbnb where Sonia booked. They're able to run that credit card to see who bought that. Guess who bought those things? Dwain Hall. But they want to confirm, is he the one that actually bought them even though his credit card was used? So they go to that Walmart in Gainesville and look for video footage from that time.

(37:25)
And you'll see it plain as day. There he is buying the shovel, buying the rope right before she lands in Gainesville, getting all of his supplies. Now based on this, the fact that he ran her credit card, he's obviously becoming their main suspect that probably knows where she is. So on Thursday, October 16th, Agent McKenzie calls the FBI and asks them for some help. She asks for the cell phone tower records from the defendant's phone on an exigent basis, which means "It's an emergency, I need these right away."

(38:09)
So she can see where the defendant has been and maybe find Sonia alive. They get those records on the 16th and they see that he was at the Gainesville airport when Sonia's plane landed on October 10th of 2025, but then they find something more concerning on those records. On the morning of October 12th, which was Sunday, the defendant's phone was at a wooded location in Marion Oaks for an hour and 20 minutes.

(38:49)
That evening on Thursday the 16th, some deputies from the Marion County Sheriff's Office go out and they search that area. They don't find anything that night and they make a plan to come back the next day, which is Friday, October 17th. And they're going to bring out a cadaver dog and a field force unit so they can really search that area. Also, at the same time they're searching that area with cadaver dog and field force deputies, Agent McKenzie decides she is going to bring the defendant down to the sheriff's office and interview him, a face-to-face interview and find out what's going on.

(39:27)
So the defendant does come down. And Agent McKenzie and Detective Joe Miller from the Sheriff's office interview him for four hours, 40 minutes. The first four hours of that interview, the defendant lies for four hours and you'll see it. He makes up a wild, nonsensical story about why he was at the Airbnb and why he was with Sonia. After he does that for four hours, he changes his mind. They take a break and he says, "Hey, come back in here. I want to recant everything I said for the past four hours." He takes it all back and he admits it was a made up story for four hours.

(40:20)
And he admits, "I know Sonia. I've been communicating with her for years on Motherless. She came here to die." He admits that he had sex with her in that Airbnb. He admits he hit her in the face during the sex. He hit her in the breasts. He hit her on the back and there was light choking. Ultimately he says he helped Sonia get what she wanted. Agent McKenzie, after this interview, gets a search warrant for the defendant's house. In his house, in the garage, they find that shovel that he bought at Walmart. That shovel is sent to Florida Department of Law Enforcement to be analyzed for DNA.

(41:23)
On that shovel, they find Sonia's blood. They also get a search warrant for the defendant's car. And in his car they find a UPS label that shows that on October 14th, which was Tuesday, the defendant mailed a package to someone named Rick Snider in Ohio. And Asia McKenzie says, "We got to know what's in this package that he mailed on October 14th, Tuesday." She goes to Ohio. Detectives from the county in Ohio, Washington County get a search warrant for Rick Snider's house. And they go there and say, "Hey, Dwain Hall mailed you a package. Where is it?" Rick Snider's uncooperative at first, but eventually he gives them what was in the package. Guess what was in the package?

(42:21)
A knife in a sheath and a bracelet. Because at the same time, Rebecca McKenzie, the agent, was interviewing the defendant, they found Sonia's body. They found her body in that wooded area exactly where the defendant's phone was for an hour and 20 minutes. She was naked in the grave except for a bra, sandals, and her flower dress was laid over her. She had been stabbed four times on the left side with a knife. Her body was sent to the medical examiner's office for an autopsy. And the medical examiner determined that those four stab wounds were all between four and seven inches deep and they all hit vital structures and that she died of sharp force injuries and it was a homicide. And that knife was also sent to the Florida Department of Law Enforcement to be tested for DNA. And guess what was also on that knife? Sonia's blood.

(43:40)
And finally they did a search warrant for the defendant's cell phone and they get a forensic cell phone examiner to search it. And you'll learn that the defendant tried to erase every trace of Sonia on his phone. He had numerous nude photographs of her and the video he had all tried to delete, but the forensic cell phone examiner was able to recover them and you'll be able to see those. On his phone, they also found something else. They found numerous images of women being raped, tortured and murdered. Horrific photographs of women with knives being shoved in their vaginas, images of women with nails piercing their breasts and other vile, horrific things. Evidence that the reason the defendant beat, stabbed and murdered Sonia was for his own sadistic pleasure. After you hear from all the witnesses and you see all the evidence, we are going to ask that you find the defendant, Dwain Hall, guilty. Thank you.

Judge Timothy McCourt (45:08):

And counsel, Mr. Barrett, do you care to make an opening statement?

Junior Barrett (45:16):

I'm going to be brief. And the reason I'm going to be brief is because if you recall jury selection, the judge told you a set of facts that we all agreed on. And again, if you recall, also said to you that you are the tribe of facts. You will need to listen to all the witnesses and determine what actually happened, what were the circumstances of that day. Judge will give you instructions and will tell you what the attorneys say is not evidence. We believe that when you listen to all the facts and evidence in this case, you will arrive at a decision that Dwain Hall did not murder this woman. And so the evidence starts now and that is what you will need to use to determine what happened to this young lady. Thank you.

Judge Timothy McCourt (46:25):

Thank you, counsel. State, you can call your first witness.

Amy Berndt (46:28):

State calls Steven Hunt.

Judge Timothy McCourt (46:29):

Okay. Members of the jury, our first witness is going to be appearing via Zoom. So I'm going to get everything queued up here. Give me just one moment.

Amy Berndt (46:50):

Your Honor, there should be someone there to swear him in as well.

Judge Timothy McCourt (46:53):

Yes. All right. Members of the jury, we got the Zoom queued up before we began court. It's been on pause. I'm not able to get it off the pause screen. So here's what we're going to do. We're going to take our first recess. Okay? So we're going to do this every recess. All your notepads and pens that you have, fold them up, close them up. You're going to leave them on your chairs when you go back to the jury room. When you're back in the jury room, if you need to use the restroom, go ahead and use it. You'll take that opportunity. Get a drink of water. We'll get you back out here as soon as we're able. I'm going to get some of our IT folks here to help me get off this screen. There is a chance I have to disconnect my Zoom and re-log back in.

(47:45)
If I do that, it'll take a couple more minutes, but we'll get you back in as soon as we're able. Okay? All right. Thank you. And again, don't discuss the case with one another. The jury's exited the courtroom. You all can be seated. Thank you. Ms. Zee, if you're listening, can you have somebody from IT come here and see if they can help me with the Zoom screen? Okay. Well, this may be it. I think I've got it. When it switched back over, it blocked out the top two screens with blue and the video feed wasn't working on my screen. So that would be what the witness would be able to see?

Rob (49:36):

Yes, sir.

Judge Timothy McCourt (49:57):

Mr. Hunt, can you hear me okay? This is Judge McCourt. Okay, sir, it does appear to me that your microphone is... I'll need you to unmute once more. Okay. Can you hear me?

Speaker 2 (50:17):

Oh, there we go, sir.

Steven Hunt (50:17):

Yeah, I can hear you.

Judge Timothy McCourt (50:19):

Okay. How is the image being captured? Is it on a camera, a cell phone, something else?

Steven Hunt (50:25):

It's a webcam set up at a police station in the UK.

Judge Timothy McCourt (50:29):

Okay. Is it possible for them to zoom in a little closer to you so that we can perhaps have the screen be maybe a couple inches to each side? A little more, a little more, a little more. Down. Okay, that will work. All right. Now, Mr. Hunt, I understand that there's a person there who's going to administer an oath for you. Is that correct?

Steven Hunt (50:54):

That's correct.

Judge Timothy McCourt (50:55):

Okay. Let's go ahead and... Is that person there? Can they get on camera?

Steven Hunt (50:59):

Yeah.

Judge Timothy McCourt (51:05):

Okay. All right. I'm going to have that person duck down so I can see them a little bit, if they don't mind. All right. Thank you. All right. What is your name, sir? Well, first, let me place you under oath. Can you raise your right hand? Do you swear to tell the truth, the whole truth, nothing but the truth, so help you God?

Jake Steele (51:18):

Yeah. I affirm to tell the truth, the whole truth, and nothing but the truth.

Judge Timothy McCourt (51:22):

Okay. You put your hand down, sir. What is your name?

Jake Steele (51:24):

PC Steele.

Judge Timothy McCourt (51:26):

One more time.

Jake Steele (51:27):

PC Steele.

Judge Timothy McCourt (51:29):

PC Steele?

Jake Steele (51:32):

Yeah. S-T-E-E-L-E.

Judge Timothy McCourt (51:34):

Okay. And PC, are those initials or is that rank?

Jake Steele (51:42):

That is rank, sorry. Yeah.

Judge Timothy McCourt (51:43):

Okay. What's your first name?

Jake Steele (51:45):

Jake.

Judge Timothy McCourt (51:49):

And you're a police officer in the United Kingdom?

Jake Steele (51:52):

[inaudible 00:51:53].

Judge Timothy McCourt (51:53):

Okay. Are you authorized by the law of the United Kingdom to administer oaths? Do you place people under oath in your work?

Jake Steele (52:10):

It's not something I've done before, no.

Judge Timothy McCourt (52:10):

Okay.

Amy Berndt (52:10):

Can do it though.

Judge Timothy McCourt (52:10):

Yeah.

Amy Berndt (52:10):

He's an officer.

Judge Timothy McCourt (52:10):

Okay. All right. Very well. I will have you in a moment, sir, place Mr. Hunt under oath by asking him if he swears or affirms the testimony he will give will be the truth, the whole truth, nothing but the truth, so help him God. Okay?

Amy Berndt (52:25):

I think, Judge, I don't know if it matters to the court, but did they have a separate oath that they do there that I believe they have with them if...

Judge Timothy McCourt (52:33):

Do you have a form of oath that you administer?

Jake Steele (52:37):

Yes. We've got an affirmation here for Stevie to read out.

Judge Timothy McCourt (52:40):

Can you read it to me so I can hear what it is?

Jake Steele (52:44):

Yeah. Shall be, "I do solemnly, sincerely, and truly declare and affirm that the evidence I shall give shall be the truth, the whole truth, and nothing but the truth."

Judge Timothy McCourt (52:52):

Okay. All right. Very good. Okay. Are we ready to bring in the jury?

Amy Berndt (52:57):

Yes, Your Honor.

Junior Barrett (52:57):

Yes, Your Honor.

Judge Timothy McCourt (52:57):

Go ahead and bring them in. Thank you, Rob.

Rob (52:57):

Yes, sir.

Judge Timothy McCourt (55:19):

Ladies and gentlemen, welcome back. You all can be seated. Thank you. All right. Members of the jury, we have via Zoom a witness who's going to be placed under oath. Officer Steele, can you provide the affirmation for Mr. Hunt to read aloud?

Jake Steele (55:37):

Yeah.

Steven Hunt (55:37):

Sorry. I do solemnly, sincerely, and truly declare and affirm that the evidence I shall give will be the truth, the whole truth, and nothing but the truth.

Judge Timothy McCourt (55:52):

Okay. Thank you, sir. Ms. Berndt, you may inquire.

Amy Berndt (55:53):

Thank you, Your Honor. Good morning.

Steven Hunt (55:56):

Morning.

Amy Berndt (55:57):

Officer Steele. Thank you. You're done. Thank you, sir. Can you please tell the jury your name?

Steven Hunt (56:06):

Steven Robert Hunt.

Amy Berndt (56:09):

All right. And do you go by Stevie?

Steven Hunt (56:11):

I do go by Stevie, yes.

Amy Berndt (56:12):

Okay. And where do you live?

Steven Hunt (56:15):

I live in Portsmouth, England.

Amy Berndt (56:18):

How long have you lived in Portsmouth, England?

Steven Hunt (56:22):

All of my life, 36 years.

Amy Berndt (56:27):

36 years? All right.

Steven Hunt (56:27):

Yeah.

Amy Berndt (56:30):

And what kind of work do you do for a living?

Steven Hunt (56:33):

I'm a visual merchandiser and stockroom assistant for Adidas.

Amy Berndt (56:42):

All right. What does a visual merchandiser do?

Steven Hunt (56:42):

I make the shop look pretty. I'll get the new stock out, keep the stockroom as best it can be to support the shop floor.

Amy Berndt (56:53):

Did you know Sonia Exelby?

Steven Hunt (56:55):

Yes.

Amy Berndt (56:56):

How did you know her?

Steven Hunt (56:59):

I met her at work when I worked in the cinema 15, 16 years ago.

Amy Berndt (57:05):

Okay. What was your relationship with Sonia?

Steven Hunt (57:09):

She later went on to be my fiance.

Amy Berndt (57:13):

Your fiance?

Steven Hunt (57:14):

Yes.

Amy Berndt (57:15):

All right.

Judge Timothy McCourt (57:15):

Ms. Berndt, hold on.

Amy Berndt (57:16):

Yes.

Judge Timothy McCourt (57:16):

One second. Mr. Hunt, is there anybody there who could perhaps move the microphone or whatever device is capturing the sound a little bit closer to you? Some of your testimony is coming through a little bit garbled on our end. Is Officer Steele still nearby?

Speaker 2 (57:31):

[Inaudible 00:57:41].

Steven Hunt (57:43):

Is that better? Sorry.

Judge Timothy McCourt (57:45):

Yes. Do try to talk a little bit slowly though and enunciate your words to make sure we can hear everything though in the event that we do get anything else garbled. But go ahead. Sorry to interrupt.

Steven Hunt (57:55):

That's no problem.

Amy Berndt (57:57):

How long were you and Sonia together?

Steven Hunt (58:00):

16 years this November.

Amy Berndt (58:04):

And how old was Sonia when she was murdered?

Steven Hunt (58:06):

33.

Amy Berndt (58:13):

So did you meet Sonia when she was 17 years old?

Steven Hunt (58:17):

Yes.

Amy Berndt (58:17):

And I think you said this earlier, it was a little bit mumbled. You met her at the cinema?

Steven Hunt (58:24):

Yes. We both worked at the cinema.

Amy Berndt (58:29):

Are you older than Sonia?

Steven Hunt (58:31):

Yes.

Amy Berndt (58:33):

And how old was she when you started dating?

Steven Hunt (58:37):

She was 17 and I was 20.

Amy Berndt (58:45):

And did you and Sonia eventually live together in Portsmouth, England?

Steven Hunt (58:46):

Yes. We eventually lived together. As soon as I saw her at work the first time, I knew that this was the girl I wanted to spend the rest of the life with.

Amy Berndt (59:00):

How long did you live together?

Steven Hunt (59:01):

So we moved in together a couple of years after us going out together. So we've lived together for just over 10 years.

Amy Berndt (59:15):

Was Sonia right-handed?

Steven Hunt (59:18):

She was right-handed.

Amy Berndt (59:20):

Did Sonia have any brothers and sisters?

Steven Hunt (59:23):

Yes.

Amy Berndt (59:24):

Okay. How many sisters did she have?

Steven Hunt (59:28):

She has two sisters and three brothers.

Amy Berndt (59:31):

All right. And what are her sisters' names?

Steven Hunt (59:34):

Gemma and Sara.

Amy Berndt (59:36):

And Sara?

Steven Hunt (59:38):

Yes.

Amy Berndt (59:38):

All right. Sorry, it's just at the end of your answer, it kind of is cutting out a little bit. And where-

Steven Hunt (59:45):

Oh, sorry.

Amy Berndt (59:45):

Okay. Where does Sonia's sister, Gemma, live?

Steven Hunt (59:49):

She lives in the UK near Portsmouth.

Amy Berndt (59:54):

Near Portsmouth?

Steven Hunt (59:54):

Yes.

Amy Berndt (59:55):

Okay. And how far away did she live from Portsmouth?

Steven Hunt (01:00:01):

I think she lived just on the outskirts.

Amy Berndt (01:00:05):

About how many minutes away would that be from Portsmouth?

Steven Hunt (01:00:07):

I think about half an hour.

Amy Berndt (01:00:13):

Okay. And where did Sonia's sister Sara live?

Steven Hunt (01:00:17):

She currently lives in Australia.

Amy Berndt (01:00:19):

All right. Did Sonia's brothers live in England?

Steven Hunt (01:00:26):

Yes.

Amy Berndt (01:00:26):

All right. Were you close with Sonia's family?

Steven Hunt (01:00:30):

Yes.

Amy Berndt (01:00:33):

Now, you first met Sonia when she was 17. At some point, did you become aware that she was struggling with some serious mental health issues?

Steven Hunt (01:00:42):

Yes. Very, very early in our relationship. She almost tried to warn me that she had several mental health issues that she was working through. At no point did that ever stop me loving her. She was the most incredible woman I've ever met, and I knew that we could get through anything together.

Amy Berndt (01:01:04):

What kind of mental health issues were you aware that she struggled with?

Steven Hunt (01:01:17):

She opened up about various eating disorders. She got diagnosed with that at a young age.

Amy Berndt (01:01:22):

Okay. Were you aware that when she was younger, she was cutting herself?

Steven Hunt (01:01:27):

Yes, it was quite visible.

Amy Berndt (01:01:32):

It was quite what?

Steven Hunt (01:01:32):

Quite visible on her arms and legs.

Amy Berndt (01:01:37):

So you could see the scars from the cutting?

Steven Hunt (01:01:39):

Yes.

Amy Berndt (01:01:40):

All right. Was Sonia your first love?

Steven Hunt (01:01:46):

Yes.

Amy Berndt (01:01:48):

And over the years, did you ever go to therapy with her or counseling?

Steven Hunt (01:01:53):

Yes. For most of our relationship, I went to and from therapy with her.

Amy Berndt (01:02:02):

And what was Sonia's personality like?

Steven Hunt (01:02:07):

Anyone that met her, just fell in love with her. She was the nicest, kindest person I've ever met in my life. And her drive to overcome eating disorders, her mental disorder just still inspire me to this day. She had so much love and talent for music. She was an incredible musician, simply blew me away when she sung and played piano.

Amy Berndt (01:02:37):

How was her self-esteem?

Steven Hunt (01:02:42):

Her self-esteem wasn't good. So what I learned quite early on is she just has such a low opinion of herself no matter what, that I think most of her mental problems came from this absolute rock bottom self-esteem she always had.

Amy Berndt (01:03:01):

During your relationship with Sonia, did you learn about her upbringing?

Steven Hunt (01:03:08):

Yes. Not in great detail, but I know she had a very hard life being adopted.

Amy Berndt (01:03:18):

All right. Would it be fair to say that it was a traumatic upbringing?

Steven Hunt (01:03:22):

Yes. Yes.

Amy Berndt (01:03:24):

Was Sonia able to work a job outside of the house?

Steven Hunt (01:03:30):

In the early years, the last six to 10 years, no. She was very unwell to do [inaudible 01:03:42]

Amy Berndt (01:03:41):

Was it rare that she would actually even leave the house during those last six years or so?

Steven Hunt (01:03:48):

Yes, incredibly.

Amy Berndt (01:03:50):

Did she receive money from the government because of her mental health struggles?

Steven Hunt (01:03:55):

Yes, she did. She got support.

Amy Berndt (01:03:58):

Had Sonia attempted suicide before?

Steven Hunt (01:04:02):

Yes.

Amy Berndt (01:04:03):

How many times?

Steven Hunt (01:04:07):

Two attempts.

Amy Berndt (01:04:08):

Two attempts. How long ago was that before she was murdered?

Steven Hunt (01:04:17):

Six to eight years ago.

Amy Berndt (01:04:20):

I'm sorry, can you repeat that?

Steven Hunt (01:04:22):

Six to eight years ago.

Amy Berndt (01:04:24):

Six to eight years ago? All right. And how did she attempt both of those suicides?

Steven Hunt (01:04:30):

Overdose, prescribed medication.

Amy Berndt (01:04:35):

An overdose with prescribed medication?

Steven Hunt (01:04:38):

Yeah.

Amy Berndt (01:04:38):

Okay. Would it be fair to say that over the past 15 years or so, there were good periods and then bad periods with Sonia's mental health?

Steven Hunt (01:04:47):

100%. 100%. There was good times and bad times. We knew that she would never [inaudible 01:04:58]... So there were good days more than bad days. The good days really meant the world to us.

Amy Berndt (01:05:10):

About two years before she was murdered, were you aware that Sonia had joined some forums online that had some violent and sadistic themes?

Steven Hunt (01:05:22):

Yes.

Amy Berndt (01:05:23):

All right. And what did you do when you learned that Sonia was on these forums?

Steven Hunt (01:05:29):

Straight away, I contacted over in England, we call it the mental health crisis team. We also went to the police and we got Sonia into a really good therapist.

Amy Berndt (01:05:52):

Did you say you got her with a really good therapist?

Steven Hunt (01:05:52):

Yes.

Amy Berndt (01:05:52):

All right. And you went to a crisis team right away as well?

Steven Hunt (01:05:55):

Yes.

Amy Berndt (01:05:56):

Okay. And then I think you had mentioned you also actually went to the police?

Steven Hunt (01:05:59):

Yes.

Amy Berndt (01:06:00):

All right. Now, did you feel that these people...

Amy Berndt (01:06:00):

Yes. All right. Now, did you feel that these people online were taking advantage of Sonia's mental health?

Steven Hunt (01:06:07):

100%. I could see a complete change. She went from having good days and bad days, just bad days, bad day after the next. She almost became [inaudible 01:06:21] person when she started going... website.

Amy Berndt (01:06:27):

And during this time period, was Sonia sent some very violent videos that depicted women being tortured and murdered?

Steven Hunt (01:06:34):

Yes.

Amy Berndt (01:06:35):

All right. Were some of these sexually based?

Steven Hunt (01:06:40):

Yes, I believe so. Yes.

Amy Berndt (01:06:43):

All right. And was that sort of sex a part of your relationship with Sonia?

Steven Hunt (01:06:46):

No.

Amy Berndt (01:06:50):

And I think you had said it was mostly bad days after she started going on these forums, but how would you describe her demeanor during this time?

Steven Hunt (01:07:01):

She was very [inaudible 01:07:06] wouldn't say more than one or two words for me. She was almost in a state of shock. Just night and day. It was hard to get her to look after herself, and it was a challenging time.

Amy Berndt (01:07:21):

All right. Did you and the therapist come up with some sort of plan basically to have two different phones to help her get through this?

Steven Hunt (01:07:29):

Yes, that's correct. So-

Amy Berndt (01:07:30):

All right. If you can just talk very slowly, please, and describe to us what that was about.

Steven Hunt (01:07:37):

Yes. So first off, if I had it my way, she wouldn't be on these websites at all. But to Sonia, this was a type of self-harm because of her low self-esteem to go on these websites and be spoken to in the manner she did. Her therapist said have a good phone and a bad phone. The bad phone is the phone that you can go on these websites with. The good phone is for nice, normal things.

Amy Berndt (01:08:13):

All right. Why didn't you and the therapist just tell her, "Stop, you can't go on those anymore"?

Steven Hunt (01:08:19):

Because over the years I learned that with the self-harm that she used to do, you can't just tell someone stop it. It doesn't work. So we needed to kind of try and tackle the real issues with self-esteem. If I took all [inaudible 01:08:38] of her phones in the place off her it wouldn't have stopped her accessing these sites.

Amy Berndt (01:08:45):

Now, at some point after Sonia started talking to these people on these violent websites, did you actually take her passport so she couldn't leave the country?

Steven Hunt (01:08:54):

Yes. Yes.

Amy Berndt (01:08:55):

And when was this, just approximately?

Steven Hunt (01:08:59):

Two, three years ago.

Amy Berndt (01:09:01):

All right. And at some point did you give her back her passport?

Steven Hunt (01:09:06):

Yes.

Amy Berndt (01:09:07):

All right. And why did you do that?

Steven Hunt (01:09:13):

It seemed to me and the people round us at the time that Sonia had stopped going on these sites now and things just slowly started to get better. And Sonia had the desire to go and visit Australia to go and see her sister. So I brought [inaudible 01:09:37] that she has her passport back because she needed it detailed, things like that. And I thought talking to these people on these websites was coming up to be a thing of the past.

Amy Berndt (01:09:54):

Now in October of 2025, did Sonia make plans to travel to her sister Gemma's house to meet her and have a sister's weekend there?

Steven Hunt (01:10:02):

Yes.

Amy Berndt (01:10:03):

Okay. And you said that Gemma's house wasn't far from where you and Sonia lived in Portsmouth?

Steven Hunt (01:10:09):

That's correct.

Amy Berndt (01:10:10):

All right. And was her sister Sara supposed to fly in from Australia at some point as well and join in on the sister's weekend?

Steven Hunt (01:10:17):

Yes.

Amy Berndt (01:10:18):

All right. When did Sonia start making these plans?

Steven Hunt (01:10:25):

Probably a couple of weeks before the weekend that she was meant to meet up with them.

Amy Berndt (01:10:32):

All right. And when she told you about this, how was her demeanor?

Steven Hunt (01:10:37):

She was really happy. She never stops talking about her sisters. They're close. It's really like upped the heat, and she started doing her hair nice, her nails nice. And I know that sounds patronizing, but that was difficult for her to do. And the fact that she was going to get counseling [inaudible 01:11:00] with her family, she was so happy about that and so was I.

Amy Berndt (01:11:04):

So you were also happy about Sonia going to her sister's house for a sisters reunion?

Steven Hunt (01:11:10):

100%, great.

Amy Berndt (01:11:12):

And did Sonia make all of her own travel arrangements?

Steven Hunt (01:11:17):

Yes.

Amy Berndt (01:11:18):

Okay. How was Sonia supposed to get to Gemma's house?

Steven Hunt (01:11:22):

A pre-ordered taxi that could take her in the morning on the Friday.

Amy Berndt (01:11:28):

Okay. You said a taxi?

Steven Hunt (01:11:30):

Yes.

Amy Berndt (01:11:30):

All right. And so you said Friday was... That Friday, was that October 10th of 2025 that she was supposed to leave to go to Gemma's house?

Steven Hunt (01:11:38):

That's correct.

Amy Berndt (01:11:40):

All right. And when was she supposed to return?

Steven Hunt (01:11:44):

Sunday.

Amy Berndt (01:11:45):

Okay. That would be October 12th then?

Steven Hunt (01:11:48):

That's right, yes.

Amy Berndt (01:11:50):

All right. Was she supposed to be back at any certain time that day on Sunday to you?

Steven Hunt (01:11:52):

No, she just said [inaudible 01:11:55] Sunday.

Amy Berndt (01:11:55):

Okay. Now what happened the morning of Friday, October 10th before Sonia left to go to Gemma's house? Did you see her?

Steven Hunt (01:12:06):

Yes. So I wanted to give her a big kiss goodbye. I woke up with her very early. I even watched her leave the front door when her taxi pulled up. And then when I closed the front door, I just went and waved to her at the window.

Amy Berndt (01:12:26):

What was she wearing that morning?

Steven Hunt (01:12:29):

She was wearing her brown cardigan, a flowery dress and a Superdry backpack.

Amy Berndt (01:12:37):

Okay. You said a flowery dress, a cardigan?

Steven Hunt (01:12:39):

Yes.

Amy Berndt (01:12:39):

Okay. And what kind of shoes did she have on?

Steven Hunt (01:12:46):

Like open toe strap sandals.

Amy Berndt (01:12:51):

All right. And did you say she had a black backpack on?

Steven Hunt (01:12:56):

Yes.

Amy Berndt (01:12:56):

All right. Were you familiar with the backpack she had on?

Steven Hunt (01:13:00):

Yes.

Amy Berndt (01:13:01):

Why were you familiar with that?

Steven Hunt (01:13:04):

I brought that as [inaudible 01:13:06] few years ago.

Amy Berndt (01:13:06):

You bought it for her as present?

Steven Hunt (01:13:08):

Yeah.

Amy Berndt (01:13:09):

Okay. Did it have any other coloring on it or glitter on it?

Steven Hunt (01:13:18):

Yes, I had a pink glitter and the Superdry logo.

Amy Berndt (01:13:20):

Okay. Superdry logo, you said?

Steven Hunt (01:13:21):

Yes.

Amy Berndt (01:13:22):

All right. Now, were you sent a black binder containing images of a black backpack?

Steven Hunt (01:13:30):

Yes.

Amy Berndt (01:13:30):

Okay. And did that binder that you were sent have a blue evidence tag stapled to the back?

Steven Hunt (01:13:36):

Yes.

Amy Berndt (01:13:36):

[inaudible 01:13:37] read out this one, though.

(01:13:48)
Did you recognize the black backpack that Sonia left with that morning in any of those photographs that you were sent?

Steven Hunt (01:13:55):

Yes.

Amy Berndt (01:13:56):

All right. And did you do anything to the photographs in which you recognized the black backpack?

Steven Hunt (01:14:02):

Yes. I signed, initialed and dated.

Amy Berndt (01:14:07):

Signed, initialed, and dated photographs you recognized?

Steven Hunt (01:14:09):

That's right, yes. Bottom right corner.

Amy Berndt (01:14:12):

Is September 10th of 2026 the date that you signed those photographs?

Steven Hunt (01:14:17):

Yes.

Amy Berndt (01:14:18):

All right. And did you mail that binder with the photographs you signed, initialed and dated back to the state attorney's office?

Steven Hunt (01:14:24):

I did, yes.

Amy Berndt (01:14:26):

All right. Were you also sent a black binder containing four photographs from an airport?

‍

Steven Hunt (01:05:59):

Yes.

Amy Berndt (01:06:00):

All right. Now, did you feel that these people...

Amy Berndt (01:06:00):

Yes. All right. Now, did you feel that these people online were taking advantage of Sonia's mental health?

Steven Hunt (01:06:07):

100%. I could see a complete change. She went from having good days and bad days, just bad days, bad day after the next. She almost became [inaudible 01:06:21] person when she started going... website.

Amy Berndt (01:06:27):

And during this time period, was Sonia sent some very violent videos that depicted women being tortured and murdered?

Steven Hunt (01:06:34):

Yes.

Amy Berndt (01:06:35):

All right. Were some of these sexually based?

Steven Hunt (01:06:40):

Yes, I believe so. Yes.

Amy Berndt (01:06:43):

All right. And was that sort of sex a part of your relationship with Sonia?

Steven Hunt (01:06:46):

No.

Amy Berndt (01:06:50):

And I think you had said it was mostly bad days after she started going on these forums, but how would you describe her demeanor during this time?

Steven Hunt (01:07:01):

She was very [inaudible 01:07:06] wouldn't say more than one or two words for me. She was almost in a state of shock. Just night and day. It was hard to get her to look after herself, and it was a challenging time.

Amy Berndt (01:07:21):

All right. Did you and the therapist come up with some sort of plan basically to have two different phones to help her get through this?

Steven Hunt (01:07:29):

Yes, that's correct. So-

Amy Berndt (01:07:30):

All right. If you can just talk very slowly, please, and describe to us what that was about.

Steven Hunt (01:07:37):

Yes. So first off, if I had it my way, she wouldn't be on these websites at all. But to Sonia, this was a type of self-harm because of her low self-esteem to go on these websites and be spoken to in the manner she did. Her therapist said have a good phone and a bad phone. The bad phone is the phone that you can go on these websites with. The good phone is for nice, normal things.

Amy Berndt (01:08:13):

All right. Why didn't you and the therapist just tell her, "Stop, you can't go on those anymore"?

Steven Hunt (01:08:19):

Because over the years I learned that with the self-harm that she used to do, you can't just tell someone stop it. It doesn't work. So we needed to kind of try and tackle the real issues with self-esteem. If I took all [inaudible 01:08:38] of her phones in the place off her it wouldn't have stopped her accessing these sites.

Amy Berndt (01:08:45):

Now, at some point after Sonia started talking to these people on these violent websites, did you actually take her passport so she couldn't leave the country?

Steven Hunt (01:08:54):

Yes. Yes.

Amy Berndt (01:08:55):

And when was this, just approximately?

Steven Hunt (01:08:59):

Two, three years ago.

Amy Berndt (01:09:01):

All right. And at some point did you give her back her passport?

Steven Hunt (01:09:06):

Yes.

Amy Berndt (01:09:07):

All right. And why did you do that?

Steven Hunt (01:09:13):

It seemed to me and the people round us at the time that Sonia had stopped going on these sites now and things just slowly started to get better. And Sonia had the desire to go and visit Australia to go and see her sister. So I brought [inaudible 01:09:37] that she has her passport back because she needed it detailed, things like that. And I thought talking to these people on these websites was coming up to be a thing of the past.

Amy Berndt (01:09:54):

Now in October of 2025, did Sonia make plans to travel to her sister Gemma's house to meet her and have a sister's weekend there?

Steven Hunt (01:10:02):

Yes.

Amy Berndt (01:10:03):

Okay. And you said that Gemma's house wasn't far from where you and Sonia lived in Portsmouth?

Steven Hunt (01:10:09):

That's correct.

Amy Berndt (01:10:10):

All right. And was her sister Sara supposed to fly in from Australia at some point as well and join in on the sister's weekend?

Steven Hunt (01:10:17):

Yes.

Amy Berndt (01:10:18):

All right. When did Sonia start making these plans?

Steven Hunt (01:10:25):

Probably a couple of weeks before the weekend that she was meant to meet up with them.

Amy Berndt (01:10:32):

All right. And when she told you about this, how was her demeanor?

Steven Hunt (01:10:37):

She was really happy. She never stops talking about her sisters. They're close. It's really like upped the heat, and she started doing her hair nice, her nails nice. And I know that sounds patronizing, but that was difficult for her to do. And the fact that she was going to get counseling [inaudible 01:11:00] with her family, she was so happy about that and so was I.

Amy Berndt (01:11:04):

So you were also happy about Sonia going to her sister's house for a sisters reunion?

Steven Hunt (01:11:10):

100%, great.

Amy Berndt (01:11:12):

And did Sonia make all of her own travel arrangements?

Steven Hunt (01:11:17):

Yes.

Amy Berndt (01:11:18):

Okay. How was Sonia supposed to get to Gemma's house?

Steven Hunt (01:11:22):

A pre-ordered taxi that could take her in the morning on the Friday.

Amy Berndt (01:11:28):

Okay. You said a taxi?

Steven Hunt (01:11:30):

Yes.

Amy Berndt (01:11:30):

All right. And so you said Friday was... That Friday, was that October 10th of 2025 that she was supposed to leave to go to Gemma's house?

Steven Hunt (01:11:38):

That's correct.

Amy Berndt (01:11:40):

All right. And when was she supposed to return?

Steven Hunt (01:11:44):

Sunday.

Amy Berndt (01:11:45):

Okay. That would be October 12th then?

Steven Hunt (01:11:48):

That's right, yes.

Amy Berndt (01:11:50):

All right. Was she supposed to be back at any certain time that day on Sunday to you?

Steven Hunt (01:11:52):

No, she just said [inaudible 01:11:55] Sunday.

Amy Berndt (01:11:55):

Okay. Now what happened the morning of Friday, October 10th before Sonia left to go to Gemma's house? Did you see her?

Steven Hunt (01:12:06):

Yes. So I wanted to give her a big kiss goodbye. I woke up with her very early. I even watched her leave the front door when her taxi pulled up. And then when I closed the front door, I just went and waved to her at the window.

Amy Berndt (01:12:26):

What was she wearing that morning?

Steven Hunt (01:12:29):

She was wearing her brown cardigan, a flowery dress and a Superdry backpack.

Amy Berndt (01:12:37):

Okay. You said a flowery dress, a cardigan?

Steven Hunt (01:12:39):

Yes.

Amy Berndt (01:12:39):

Okay. And what kind of shoes did she have on?

Steven Hunt (01:12:46):

Like open toe strap sandals.

Amy Berndt (01:12:51):

All right. And did you say she had a black backpack on?

Steven Hunt (01:12:56):

Yes.

Amy Berndt (01:12:56):

All right. Were you familiar with the backpack she had on?

Steven Hunt (01:13:00):

Yes.

Amy Berndt (01:13:01):

Why were you familiar with that?

Steven Hunt (01:13:04):

I brought that as [inaudible 01:13:06] few years ago.

Amy Berndt (01:13:06):

You bought it for her as present?

Steven Hunt (01:13:08):

Yeah.

Amy Berndt (01:13:09):

Okay. Did it have any other coloring on it or glitter on it?

Steven Hunt (01:13:18):

Yes, I had a pink glitter and the Superdry logo.

Amy Berndt (01:13:20):

Okay. Superdry logo, you said?

Steven Hunt (01:13:21):

Yes.

Amy Berndt (01:13:22):

All right. Now, were you sent a black binder containing images of a black backpack?

Steven Hunt (01:13:30):

Yes.

Amy Berndt (01:13:30):

Okay. And did that binder that you were sent have a blue evidence tag stapled to the back?

Steven Hunt (01:13:36):

Yes.

Amy Berndt (01:13:36):

[inaudible 01:13:37] read out this one, though.

(01:13:48)
Did you recognize the black backpack that Sonia left with that morning in any of those photographs that you were sent?

Steven Hunt (01:13:55):

Yes.

Amy Berndt (01:13:56):

All right. And did you do anything to the photographs in which you recognized the black backpack?

Steven Hunt (01:14:02):

Yes. I signed, initialed and dated.

Amy Berndt (01:14:07):

Signed, initialed, and dated photographs you recognized?

Steven Hunt (01:14:09):

That's right, yes. Bottom right corner.

Amy Berndt (01:14:12):

Is September 10th of 2026 the date that you signed those photographs?

Steven Hunt (01:14:17):

Yes.

Amy Berndt (01:14:18):

All right. And did you mail that binder with the photographs you signed, initialed and dated back to the state attorney's office?

Steven Hunt (01:14:24):

I did, yes.

Amy Berndt (01:14:26):

All right. Were you also sent a black binder containing four photographs from an airport?

Steven Hunt (01:14:34):

Yes.

Amy Berndt (01:14:35):

All right. And did that binder also have a blue evidence tag stapled to the back?

Steven Hunt (01:14:39):

It did, yes.

Amy Berndt (01:14:41):

All right. And did you recognize anyone in those photographs?

Steven Hunt (01:14:44):

Yes.

Amy Berndt (01:14:45):

Who did you recognize in those photographs?

Steven Hunt (01:14:47):

My fiance, Sonia Exelby.

Amy Berndt (01:14:54):

All right. And was she wearing the same outfit that she had on when she left the house that morning that you described to us with the flowery dress and the cardigan?

Steven Hunt (01:15:02):

Yeah, exactly the same.

Amy Berndt (01:15:03):

All right. And what sort of things was she doing in the photographs that you saw her at in the airport?

Steven Hunt (01:15:10):

Typical airport things like going through security and boarding the plane.

Amy Berndt (01:15:17):

All right. And were those photographs a fair and accurate depiction of the way she looked the morning of October 10th of 2025?

Steven Hunt (01:15:21):

Yes.

Amy Berndt (01:15:22):

Okay. And did you do anything to the photographs in which you recognized Sonia at the airport?

Steven Hunt (01:15:30):

Yes, I signed, initialed and dated the bottom corner.

Amy Berndt (01:15:34):

Okay. Signed, initialed and dated?

Steven Hunt (01:15:35):

Yes.

Amy Berndt (01:15:36):

Again, was September 10th of 2026 the date that you signed those?

Steven Hunt (01:15:41):

It was, yes.

Amy Berndt (01:15:43):

All right. And did you mail that binder with those signed photographs back to the state attorney's office?

Steven Hunt (01:15:47):

I did, yes.

Amy Berndt (01:15:49):

Your Honor, at this time we will move State's Exhibit B into evidence as State's 1.

Junior Barrett (01:15:54):

No objection, Judge.

Timothy McCourt (01:15:55):

Without objection, what's been marked for identification as State's Exhibit B will be admitted into evidence as State's Exhibit 1.

Amy Berndt (01:16:00):

And, Judge, may I publish those? I put them on a board since we obviously can't use the PowerPoint.

Timothy McCourt (01:16:06):

Ladies and gentlemen of the jury, the State's going to publish some photographs right now, which means show you the evidence, okay? During the course of the trial, things that are admitted into evidence will be kept by the clerk. When you go back to deliberate your verdict, all the exhibits admitted into evidence will be sent with you when you deliberate. This will not be the only time you have to view the exhibits. So you can publish.

Amy Berndt (01:16:23):

Thank you. And Mr. Hunt, you said in these photographs you recognized Sonia by wearing the flowery dress?

Steven Hunt (01:16:31):

Yes. And I could see her face and it was clearly her.

Amy Berndt (01:16:51):

And did she also have the black backpack on in these photographs as well?

Steven Hunt (01:16:55):

Yes.

Amy Berndt (01:17:17):

Now, after Sonia left that morning, did you ever speak with her again on the phone?

Steven Hunt (01:17:24):

Yes. Later that Friday she messaged me saying she was switching phones because she [inaudible 01:17:31] signal.

Amy Berndt (01:17:31):

Okay. So it wasn't actually... You didn't hear her voice, it was some other kind of communication?

Steven Hunt (01:17:37):

Yes. WhatsApp.

Amy Berndt (01:17:37):

Okay. WhatsApp? All right. And you said that was Friday afternoon?

Steven Hunt (01:17:46):

Yes.

Amy Berndt (01:17:47):

All right. Was there anything concerning about the communication you had with her on WhatsApp that Friday afternoon?

Steven Hunt (01:17:52):

No, I had no concerns.

Amy Berndt (01:17:55):

All right. Now you said that Sonia was supposed to return on Sunday, October 12th of 2025. Did she ever come home that Sunday?

Steven Hunt (01:18:05):

No, she didn't come home.

Amy Berndt (01:18:08):

All right. At some point that Sunday evening, did you become worried?

Steven Hunt (01:18:12):

Yes. When it got quite late, about 7:00 PM UK time, I messaged her sister to see whether she had left yet, and she informed me that Sonia never went there that weekend.

Amy Berndt (01:18:29):

All right. And what did you do when you realized that Sonia had never went to Gemma's and you hadn't seen her since Friday?

Steven Hunt (01:18:35):

I straight away after called the police.

Amy Berndt (01:18:38):

All right. And this was the evening of Sunday, October 12th?

Steven Hunt (01:18:41):

That's right, yes.

Amy Berndt (01:18:42):

All right. And while you were waiting for the police to come to your house that Sunday evening, did you look at Sonia's computer?

Steven Hunt (01:18:51):

Yes. It was switched on on the side and I checked her email to see whether or not I could work out where she was, and I found a written note that Sonia had written for herself on the airport.

Amy Berndt (01:19:10):

So you checked her email and you found a note that Sonia had written to herself, she had emailed to herself?

Steven Hunt (01:19:13):

Yes.

Amy Berndt (01:19:14):

All right. Now, when the officer arrived at your house, did you show him that letter on the computer?

Steven Hunt (01:19:20):

Yeah. Yeah, straight away.

Amy Berndt (01:19:22):

All right. And did you tell the officer about Sonia's mental health problems?

Steven Hunt (01:19:26):

Yes. Yes.

Amy Berndt (01:19:28):

And were you sent a black binder containing a photograph of a computer?

Steven Hunt (01:19:33):

Yes.

Amy Berndt (01:19:34):

And did that binder have a blue evidence tag stapled to the back?

Steven Hunt (01:19:38):

It did, yes.

Amy Berndt (01:19:40):

Okay. And did you recognize the photograph of the computer in that binder that was sent to you?

Steven Hunt (01:19:46):

Yes.

Amy Berndt (01:19:46):

How did you recognize it?

Steven Hunt (01:19:50):

It was her laptop with her stickers. It was ASUS's laptop with the white lights on it. It was her laptop.

Amy Berndt (01:20:01):

Okay. It was Sonia's laptop?

Steven Hunt (01:20:02):

Yes.

Amy Berndt (01:20:04):

Okay. You said it was an ASUS laptop?

Steven Hunt (01:20:06):

Yes.

Amy Berndt (01:20:06):

Okay. And it had stickers on it, that's how you recognized it?

Steven Hunt (01:20:12):

Yeah.

Amy Berndt (01:20:12):

All right. And did you do anything to the photograph in which you recognized the computer as Sonia's?

Steven Hunt (01:20:17):

Yes, I signed initialed and dated, bottom right corner.

Amy Berndt (01:20:20):

Okay. Same thing you did with the other photographs, signed and dated them?

Steven Hunt (01:20:25):

Exactly, yes.

Amy Berndt (01:20:27):

All right. And did you mail that photograph back to the state attorney's office?

Steven Hunt (01:20:31):

I did, yes.

Amy Berndt (01:20:32):

Your Honor, at this time we would move State's Exhibit C into evidence as State's 2.

Junior Barrett (01:20:36):

No objection, Judge.

Timothy McCourt (01:20:37):

Without objection, what's been marked for identification as State's Exhibit C will be admitted into evidence as State's Exhibit 2.

Amy Berndt (01:20:43):

Did the police officer collect Sonia's computer?

Steven Hunt (01:20:47):

Yes.

Amy Berndt (01:20:48):

Okay. And now you said that you found that letter on Sonia's computer that she sent to herself. In that letter, does it reference her being on a plane?

Steven Hunt (01:20:57):

Yes.

Amy Berndt (01:20:58):

Okay. And was the date it was written the day she was actually on the plane, October 10th of 2025?

Steven Hunt (01:21:05):

Yes.

Amy Berndt (01:21:06):

All right. And was the letter consistent with the way Sonia sounded and consistent with her writing style?

Steven Hunt (01:21:12):

Yes.

Amy Berndt (01:21:13):

Okay. Are you sure that that letter was written by Sonia?

Steven Hunt (01:21:17):

100%.

Amy Berndt (01:21:19):

And were you sent a black binder containing a copy of that letter from Sonia's computer that you found?

Steven Hunt (01:21:24):

I was, yes.

Amy Berndt (01:21:26):

And did you recognize that to be the letter that Sonia wrote and sent to herself on October 10th of 2025 as being from a plane?

Steven Hunt (01:21:34):

Yes.

Amy Berndt (01:21:34):

And what did you do to that when you recognized that letter?

Steven Hunt (01:21:40):

Signed, initial, dated bottom right corner.

Amy Berndt (01:21:44):

And you sent it back to the state attorney's office as well?

Steven Hunt (01:21:47):

Yes.

Amy Berndt (01:21:48):

Your Honor, at this time we would move State's Exhibit D into evidence.

Junior Barrett (01:21:51):

No objection, Judge.

Timothy McCourt (01:21:52):

Without objection, what's been marked for identification as State's Exhibit D will be admitted in evidence as State's Exhibit 3.

Amy Berndt (01:22:02):

And do you have a copy of that letter with you today?

Steven Hunt (01:22:07):

Yes, I do.

Amy Berndt (01:22:08):

All right. Can you please... Judge, we'd ask to publish that letter at this time.

Timothy McCourt (01:22:12):

Yes, ma'am.

Amy Berndt (01:22:12):

All right. And if you can slowly read that letter to the jury, please, that you found on Sonia's computer from October 10th of 2025.

Steven Hunt (01:22:22):

Yes.

(01:22:22)
"I've never hurt so much. I'm trying so hard not to have a panic attack. I'm scared enough to leave [inaudible 01:22:40] and Don't You Forget About Me playing. It's such cruel irony. This was the song I almost died to in an attempted suicide. I haven't really heard it since. As soon as the wheels leave the ground, I wished I was home, but I can't get off the plane and it's moving and I have no wifi. I'm screaming like I've been [inaudible 01:23:06]. I want to beg for help so badly, but there's such a [inaudible 01:23:14]. The Virgin intro saying, "The end." Oh God, I feel so sick. I can hear it powering up. Why am I here? Why? The guy in front of... looks like Barry. If I wasn't numb, I would never have gotten out of..." Sorry, one sec.

(01:23:38)
"If I wasn't numb, I'd never have gotten out of the house. This would be impossible. Although I'm hurting more than I ever have done, and that's exactly why. Any worse [inaudible 01:23:58] bloody number. I thought I was... I know they want to help me and I could just tell them, but I can't. The crushing realization that my scene yesterday [inaudible 01:24:21], I offended my [inaudible 01:24:24]. It was everything. I left nothing. Fuck [inaudible 01:24:32]. And there we go, to fuck, fuck it. It's too late. Oh, I thought [inaudible 01:24:40]. I never felt panic like this. Everyone can give [foreign language 01:24:49], I just take. It almost looks like a perfect day [inaudible 01:24:55]. Why do I still [inaudible 01:25:02] going to die? I fucked up so bad [inaudible 01:25:07] to the end. I got too [inaudible 01:25:11] things. Even if I managed to get them, it would be so easy to find me and be mutilated and disabled for the rest of my life.

Amy Berndt (01:25:24):

Thank you. I don't have any other questions, Judge.

Timothy McCourt (01:25:25):

Any cross examination, counsel?

Junior Barrett (01:25:26):

Yes, Your Honor. Good morning, sir. Can you hear me?

Steven Hunt (01:25:38):

I can hear you.

Junior Barrett (01:25:40):

Okay. I just have some questions I need to ask you. All right. Now, during the time you knew Sonia when she was still alive, did she have mood swings?

Steven Hunt (01:25:54):

Yes.

Junior Barrett (01:25:55):

So there were times when she would be happy and other times she would be sad?

Steven Hunt (01:26:01):

Correct.

Junior Barrett (01:26:03):

And would those mood swings last for a while?

Steven Hunt (01:26:08):

Yes.

Junior Barrett (01:26:10):

Days, maybe?

Steven Hunt (01:26:12):

Yes.

Junior Barrett (01:26:13):

Sometime even more than that?

Steven Hunt (01:26:19):

I would say a mood swing would last no longer than a full week.

Junior Barrett (01:26:27):

Okay. Now, you mentioned that you've known her and you've been together somewhere around 16 years?

Steven Hunt (01:26:36):

Correct.

Junior Barrett (01:26:36):

And again, those mood swings you would see during those 16 years, correct?

Steven Hunt (01:26:42):

Correct.

Junior Barrett (01:26:42):

And at one point you, I guess, took her to see a psychologist, psychiatrist, someone in the mental health field, correct?

Steven Hunt (01:26:55):

Yes.

Junior Barrett (01:26:56):

Okay. Was it something that she would go to on a daily basis, weekly basis, monthly? Do you recall?

Steven Hunt (01:27:05):

Weekly.

Junior Barrett (01:27:06):

Weekly? Okay. How long was she doing that for?

Steven Hunt (01:27:11):

She was in and out of therapy for probably around about the 15 years we were together.

Junior Barrett (01:27:21):

Okay. And would it be the same therapist?

Steven Hunt (01:27:25):

No, they would change [inaudible 01:27:28] over time.

Junior Barrett (01:27:30):

Okay. And would you always go with her?

Steven Hunt (01:27:34):

Most of the time, yes.

Junior Barrett (01:27:36):

And during those times when she was seeing a therapist, was she given medication?

Steven Hunt (01:27:42):

Yes.

Junior Barrett (01:27:44):

And would you see her take her medication?

Steven Hunt (01:27:49):

Yes.

Junior Barrett (01:27:50):

When was the last time you saw her take medication?

Steven Hunt (01:28:00):

The day before I last saw her.

Junior Barrett (01:28:03):

Okay. Just to make sure I understand, it's a little fuzzy. You said the day before she left?

Steven Hunt (01:28:09):

That's correct, yes.

Junior Barrett (01:28:09):

Okay.

Steven Hunt (01:28:09):

Thursday.

Junior Barrett (01:28:10):

Are we talking about pills?

Steven Hunt (01:28:20):

Yes.

Junior Barrett (01:28:21):

Are we talking about more than one pills?

Steven Hunt (01:28:24):

Yes.

Junior Barrett (01:28:24):

Did you actually see her take the medication? If you don't recall, that's fine.

Steven Hunt (01:28:35):

I don't recall.

Junior Barrett (01:28:39):

Say again?

Steven Hunt (01:28:39):

I don't recall.

Junior Barrett (01:28:42):

Okay, that's fine. That's fine. But during the time she was with you, she was on medication and at least you would see her take medication at times, correct?

Steven Hunt (01:28:52):

Yes.

Junior Barrett (01:28:52):

Okay.

Steven Hunt (01:28:52):

Yeah.

Junior Barrett (01:28:56):

And again, there were some times that she seems, for lack of a better term, normal and other times when she wasn't, correct?

Steven Hunt (01:29:04):

Can you repeat that, sorry?

Junior Barrett (01:29:06):

There were some times when she seemed normal and other times when she wasn't, correct?

Steven Hunt (01:29:13):

Yes, correct.

Junior Barrett (01:29:14):

Okay. During the time you were with her, did she attempt suicide?

Steven Hunt (01:29:21):

Yes.

Junior Barrett (01:29:22):

And that was the two times you talked about?

Steven Hunt (01:29:25):

Yes.

Junior Barrett (01:29:25):

Was she taken to a hospital?

Steven Hunt (01:29:29):

Yes.

Junior Barrett (01:29:37):

Now, at some point, she decided that she was going to stay with her sister.

Steven Hunt (01:29:45):

Mm-hmm.

Junior Barrett (01:29:46):

Is that a yes?

Steven Hunt (01:29:46):

Yes.

Junior Barrett (01:29:48):

And the only reason I'm asking you that is because even though you're somewhere else, it's kind of being recorded here. So was this decision made, I think you said, something like weeks before?

Steven Hunt (01:30:01):

Yes.

Junior Barrett (01:30:02):

Okay. And during the time she told you she was going to stay with her sister, did she seem normal?

Steven Hunt (01:30:10):

No, she seemed the opposite, full of...

Junior Barrett (01:30:16):

All right. Around the time she told you she was going to stay with her sister, do you know whether or not she had gone to see a therapist?

Steven Hunt (01:30:22):

I don't recall.

Junior Barrett (01:30:22):

Okay. But up until the point she left the UK, she was seeing the therapist on a weekly basis?

Steven Hunt (01:30:45):

Yes. Either seeing a therapist or had online therapists.

Junior Barrett (01:30:53):

Do you recall the last time you went with her to her therapist? Do you recall? And again, using the day she left as point, do you remember the last time she went to see a therapist?

Steven Hunt (01:31:07):

I don't recall.

Junior Barrett (01:31:10):

Okay. Do you even recall if it was within the same month or months before?

Steven Hunt (01:31:20):

I want to say about a month, but I don't really [inaudible 01:31:30].

Junior Barrett (01:31:32):

Okay. Now, did you ever have contact with the therapist where they would call you if there was something they felt you needed to know?

Steven Hunt (01:31:42):

Yes.

Junior Barrett (01:31:42):

Did they ever call you and tell you that she wasn't showing up for her appointments?

Steven Hunt (01:31:51):

No, they never told me.

Junior Barrett (01:31:59):

Okay.

Steven Hunt (01:31:59):

Because most of the time I went with her to her appointments.

Junior Barrett (01:32:00):

Okay. You went with her most of the time?

Steven Hunt (01:32:00):

Yes.

Junior Barrett (01:32:08):

Okay. Now, when she told you she was going to stay with her sister, was there anything about the way she was telling you this that seemed like she was making it up?

Steven Hunt (01:32:20):

No, nothing.

Junior Barrett (01:32:21):

Did she do or say anything that gave you any reason to doubt what she was saying?

Steven Hunt (01:32:29):

No. No, I fully trusted and believed that that was what she was going to do, going and see her sister.

Junior Barrett (01:32:36):

Did you see or hear anything that suggested to you that she wasn't acting normal around that time?

Steven Hunt (01:32:41):

Can you repeat that, sorry?

Junior Barrett (01:32:45):

Sure. Did you see or hear anything that suggested to you that she wasn't acting normal around the time she told you that she was going to stay with her sister?

Steven Hunt (01:32:58):

No. She was acting very upbeat and normal.

Junior Barrett (01:33:12):

Okay. Were you aware... Well, I'm assuming you weren't aware that she had bought a plane ticket, correct?

Steven Hunt (01:33:18):

That's correct. I didn't know she had a plane ticket.

Junior Barrett (01:33:27):

You said at one point you took her passport from her?

Steven Hunt (01:33:32):

Yes.

Junior Barrett (01:33:33):

Okay. So it wasn't done by the government or anything like that? You took it?

Steven Hunt (01:33:39):

The police offered to take it.

Junior Barrett (01:33:41):

Oh, okay.

Steven Hunt (01:33:44):

But I knew it was Sonia's only form ID and we had her belief and faith we would overcome this and then I'd be able to give her passport back to her. I didn't want it to get lost at the police station through paperwork and things like that.

Junior Barrett (01:34:02):

Okay. And again, I know it's because of the connection, so I just want to make sure I'm understanding what you're saying. At one point, are you saying at one point the police took the passport or just you took it?

Steven Hunt (01:34:14):

They wanted to take it. The option was that I take it and hold it or the police take it.

Junior Barrett (01:34:21):

Okay. So it may have been the police or it may have been you?

Steven Hunt (01:34:27):

Yeah. Yes.

Junior Barrett (01:34:29):

Okay. So at this point, you're not sure which one of you took her passport?

Steven Hunt (01:34:32):

I took the passport.

Junior Barrett (01:34:34):

Okay. All right. How long did you keep the passport before you gave it back to her?

Steven Hunt (01:34:40):

A fair few months. I'd say probably about five to six months.

Junior Barrett (01:34:52):

Okay. And when you gave it back to her, it was because she was planning to go see her sister in Australia?

Steven Hunt (01:35:00):

Yes. And I thought that the threat of her wanting to leave or anything like that was behind us.

Junior Barrett (01:35:15):

Okay. Now you said she had two phones, correct?

Steven Hunt (01:35:18):

Yes.

Junior Barrett (01:35:19):

Did you give her the phones or these are two phones she bought?

Steven Hunt (01:35:26):

One she brought, one I think a friend gave her.

Junior Barrett (01:35:29):

Okay. If I may have a minute.

Timothy McCourt (01:35:48):

Yeah, sure.

Junior Barrett (01:36:16):

[inaudible 01:35:52]. All right. Thank you, sir. I don't have any other questions.

Timothy McCourt (01:36:18):

Any redirect, [inaudible 01:36:19] State?

Amy Berndt (01:36:24):

I just have two follow up questions. Mr. Hunt, you said that when Sonia left that morning, she seemed very happy and was in a good mood?

Steven Hunt (01:36:31):

Yes.

Amy Berndt (01:36:31):

Okay. And you had no concerns that morning when she left about her mental health?

Steven Hunt (01:36:35):

No.

Amy Berndt (01:36:37):

Later on, you found the letter that she wrote to herself from the plane, which would've just been a couple of hours after you last saw her, right?

Steven Hunt (01:36:45):

That's correct.

Amy Berndt (01:36:45):

Okay. And did it seem when you read that letter that Sonia was in a good state of mind, from that letter?

Steven Hunt (01:36:54):

No, she was crying out for help.

Amy Berndt (01:36:57):

Thank you. I don't have any other questions.

Timothy McCourt (01:36:58):

Any recross examination?

Amy Berndt (01:36:59):

No, Your Honor.

Timothy McCourt (01:37:00):

Members of the jury, do any of you all have questions of this witness? If you do, please raise your hand. All right. Seeing no hands, State, is this witness released?

Amy Berndt (01:37:08):

Yes, your honor. We thank you and ask that he be released.

Timothy McCourt (01:37:10):

Defense?

Junior Barrett (01:37:11):

No objection, Judge.

Timothy McCourt (01:37:13):

Okay. Mr. Hunt, we're going to go ahead and end the Zoom call. Thank you for your time, sir.

Steven Hunt (01:37:17):

Thank you.

Timothy McCourt (01:37:25):

State, you can call your next witness.

Amy Berndt (01:37:26):

State calls Gemma Isaj.

Speaker 3 (01:37:31):

And would the court give us presentation mode, please?

Timothy McCourt (01:37:33):

Yes, sir. Would you like me to engage prosecution last?

Speaker 3 (01:37:44):

Please, your Honor.

Timothy McCourt (01:37:47):

Come on up, ma'am. Raise your right hand, face the clerk to be sworn.

Court Clerk (01:37:51):

Do you swear or affirm the testimony you're about to give will be the truth, the whole truth, and nothing but the truth, so help you God?

Gemma Isaj (01:38:01):

I swear to tell the truth, the whole truth, and nothing but the truth, so help me God.

Timothy McCourt (01:38:01):

You can go ahead be seated, ma'am. Thank you.

Amy Berndt (01:38:01):

Good morning.

Gemma Isaj (01:38:10):

Morning.

Amy Berndt (01:38:12):

Can you scoot up and make sure you talk into that microphone? You can pull that down so everybody can hear you a little bit.

Gemma Isaj (01:38:18):

Is that better?

Amy Berndt (01:38:20):

I don't know, can everybody hear her?

Timothy McCourt (01:38:21):

Members of the jury, can you all hear her okay?

Members of the Jury (01:38:22):

Yes.

Timothy McCourt (01:38:23):

Okay. All right.

Gemma Isaj (01:38:23):

Thank you.

Amy Berndt (01:38:26):

Can you tell the jury your name?

Gemma Isaj (01:38:28):

Gemma Isaj. Gemma Theresa Isaj.

Amy Berndt (01:38:30):

How do you spell your last name?

Gemma Isaj (01:38:32):

I-S-A-J.

Amy Berndt (01:38:34):

And where do you live?

Gemma Isaj (01:38:36):

In Fareham, on the outskirts of Portsmouth.

Amy Berndt (01:38:39):

And that's in England?

Gemma Isaj (01:38:41):

Yes.

Amy Berndt (01:38:42):

All right. Are you married?

Gemma Isaj (01:38:44):

Yes.

Amy Berndt (01:38:45):

Are you employed?

Gemma Isaj (01:38:47):

I was. Recently took a break.

Amy Berndt (01:38:51):

Okay. What kind of work did you do before you took a break?

Gemma Isaj (01:38:54):

I supported the mental health of students with neurodivergent needs in education.

Amy Berndt (01:39:03):

All right.

Speaker 4 (01:39:02):

In education.

Amy Berndt (01:39:03):

All right. Do you have any siblings?

Speaker 4 (01:39:06):

Yes, five siblings.

Amy Berndt (01:39:09):

Five. All right. Can you tell the jury their names and the birth order and the ages, if you know?

Speaker 4 (01:39:17):

I know them as whether I remember them in this moment. Our oldest brother is Mark. He has severe learning disabilities. He's 49. And then I have my other older brother, Luke. He is 47. And then it's myself, I'm 42. And then it's Barry. He's 39. And then Sara is 36.

Amy Berndt (01:39:56):

And how old would Sonya be today?

Speaker 4 (01:39:58):

She would be 33 today.

Amy Berndt (01:40:02):

Would it be fair to say that you and your siblings had a difficult start in life?

Speaker 4 (01:40:06):

Yes.

Amy Berndt (01:40:07):

And why was that?

Speaker 4 (01:40:12):

Our mom, she had quite severe mental health challenges and our dad suffered with quite a few different addictions.

Amy Berndt (01:40:24):

Did that involve drug addictions with your father?

Speaker 4 (01:40:27):

Yes.

Amy Berndt (01:40:27):

Okay. When you and your siblings were very young, were you taken away from your parents?

Speaker 4 (01:40:33):

Yes. Myself and my brother, Luke, we cared a lot for our younger siblings. We were the older ones and yeah, we were taken into the care of the state.

Amy Berndt (01:40:51):

How old was Sonya when that happened?

Speaker 4 (01:40:53):

It was just before Sonya's second birthday.

Amy Berndt (01:40:58):

All right. When you and your siblings were taken away from your parents by the state, where did you all go?

Speaker 4 (01:41:04):

Myself and Barry, we went to one foster home. Luke was in another, and Sarah and Sonya went to another.

Amy Berndt (01:41:16):

And Sarah was three years older than Sonya?

Speaker 4 (01:41:18):

Yes.

Amy Berndt (01:41:21):

Now, were Sarah and Sonya eventually adopted?

Speaker 4 (01:41:25):

Yes.

Amy Berndt (01:41:25):

Were they adopted together?

Speaker 4 (01:41:27):

They were, yeah.

Amy Berndt (01:41:28):

How old was Sonya when she was adopted?

Speaker 4 (01:41:31):

I think she was about five years old when the adoption went through.

Amy Berndt (01:41:36):

So that would've made Sarah eight?

Speaker 4 (01:41:38):

Yes.

Amy Berndt (01:41:40):

Now, during the three years that you were all living in separate foster homes before Sonya and Sarah were adopted, did you have contact with Sonya and Sarah?

Speaker 4 (01:41:50):

Yes, we did. Regular contact through family centers. It was a very treasured time for us. As siblings, we helped each other a lot.

Amy Berndt (01:42:04):

You were very close?

Speaker 4 (01:42:06):

Yes. Yeah, we were.

Amy Berndt (01:42:08):

Now, after Sonya and Sara were adopted, did you and your siblings have any contact with them?

Speaker 4 (01:42:15):

No.

Amy Berndt (01:42:16):

Why not?

Speaker 4 (01:42:16):

Once the adoption happened, Mr. and Mrs. Ikler, we felt it was all the best for Sarah and Sonya to not have contact during that time.

Amy Berndt (01:42:33):

Did you and your siblings miss and talk about Sonya and Sarah while they were gone?

Speaker 4 (01:42:39):

All the time. Every gathering, we would always talk about the times which we reunited.

Amy Berndt (01:42:49):

At some point, did you and your siblings reconnect with Sonya and Sarah?

Speaker 4 (01:42:53):

Yes. When Sonya turned 18, we reconnected.

Amy Berndt (01:43:00):

And after you guys all reconnected, did you all become close again?

Speaker 4 (01:43:05):

Yes. It was like we'd never been apart. Yeah.

Amy Berndt (01:43:11):

During that time when you were reconnecting with Sonya, did you become aware of her mental health issues?

Speaker 4 (01:43:17):

Yes. Very early on, Sonya would open up and would talk about her struggles. Yeah.

Amy Berndt (01:43:28):

How far away did Sonya live from you as an adult?

Speaker 4 (01:43:34):

There was a time when I was living in Portsmouth. So it was very close by, maybe 15, 20 minutes by car. And then, once I moved to Farnham, it was still very similar because of the traffic, so although slightly-

Amy Berndt (01:43:50):

So not that far away?

Speaker 4 (01:43:51):

No.

Amy Berndt (01:43:52):

How often would you get to see Sonya?

Speaker 4 (01:43:55):

It would vary. When she was in a better place, she would engage with us more and interact. But when she was really struggling, she felt like she didn't deserve to be seen and would keep us at distance. It was really hard because we just wanted to see her no matter where she was at.

Amy Berndt (01:44:21):

Did she often cancel plans you had with her or just not show up?

Speaker 4 (01:44:24):

Yes. Yeah, very frequently.

Amy Berndt (01:44:27):

Were you mad at her? Did you hold it against her?

Speaker 4 (01:44:30):

No. No, because we knew that she wanted to be there with us. We knew that she wanted to spend that time, but sometimes it was just too much.

Amy Berndt (01:44:41):

Now, were you aware in the year preceding her murder that Sonya had gotten involved with some people online that were offering to kill her?

Speaker 4 (01:44:48):

Yes.

Amy Berndt (01:44:49):

All right. In November of 2023, did you and your siblings have a family get together because Sarah was moving back to Australia?

Speaker 4 (01:44:56):

Yes, we did. Yeah.

Amy Berndt (01:44:58):

And was Sonya at that gathering?

Speaker 4 (01:45:00):

Yes.

Amy Berndt (01:45:02):

Is that when you became aware that she had gotten involved with some violent, dangerous people on the dark web?

Speaker 4 (01:45:10):

She said to me that she needed to talk about something, so we went and sat in another room. Sorry.

Amy Berndt (01:45:30):

It's okay. You want to take a break?

Judge Timothy McCourt (01:45:32):

Take a moment, ma'am. Great question.

Speaker 4 (01:45:33):

Yes, please.

(01:45:50)
We went and sat in another room and she told me that she had got into something and that she was really terrified and that people had been making some horrible threats to her and threats even against the family, that they knew where she was and they could locate her. Sonya said that she had gone on to some suicide forums for support and that on these forums there were people that were preying on Sonya and her friends that she had made online. And Sonya said that she was trying to gather evidence because she couldn't bear that people were being hurt. She said that she needed to do this to gather the evidence so that she could stop these things from happening to other people.

Amy Berndt (01:46:58):

Were you concerned enough after Sonya talked to you and brought this to your attention that did you actually contact the police about what Sonya had told you?

Speaker 4 (01:47:05):

Yes. I phoned the police in that moment because, and especially with the work that I was doing, I know a lot of my job is to try and protect and support vulnerable people, and I could see how scared Sonya was.

Amy Berndt (01:47:24):

So you and Sonya actually went to the police and they maybe started some investigation?

Speaker 4 (01:47:29):

Oh, yeah, I contacted the police and I contacted the mental health crisis team and got her support.

Amy Berndt (01:47:38):

For Sonya?

Speaker 4 (01:47:38):

Yes.

Amy Berndt (01:47:39):

All right.

Speaker 4 (01:47:39):

And we spoke, made sure that our siblings were aware so we could try and wrap around that support for her.

Amy Berndt (01:47:50):

Now, did you, Sarah, and Sonya have plans to meet up and spend some time together the weekend of October 10th of 2025?

Speaker 4 (01:47:57):

Yes.

Amy Berndt (01:47:57):

Okay. Can you tell the jury about what your plans were initially?

Speaker 4 (01:48:03):

Sarah was due to arrive on Saturday the 11th of October, and Sonya messaged and said that she was going to come and stay on the Friday and that we would travel up to the airport together and that we would have that weekend together to enjoy. When we missed so many times that when we had those opportunities to get together, it was something that we really treasured. So I was very excited at the fort.

Amy Berndt (01:48:42):

So all of you, Sarah and Sonya were all excited about this?

Speaker 4 (01:48:45):

Yes. Yeah.

Amy Berndt (01:48:49):

How was Sonya going to get to your house?

Speaker 4 (01:48:50):

I offered to pick her up, but she was quite adamant about getting a taxi over.

Amy Berndt (01:48:56):

All right. Now, I know she initially had told you that she would be there on Friday, October 10th. Did that change of when she was going to come to meet you and Sarah?

Speaker 4 (01:49:07):

Yeah. Initially, it was a Friday and then as the time got closer, she said, "Oh, I'll come to the airport with you on the Saturday." And then when it came to the Saturday, as we got closer, she said, "Oh, no, I'm not coming to the airport. I'll meet you at the Sunday." And she said, "I'll see you Sunday at two o'clock." And she was very specific about the time. And again, I offered to pick her up, but she said, "I'll get a taxi." In hindsight, that was a bit different, but she was familiar with taxis and I thought maybe she was coming from her friends or something.

Amy Berndt (01:49:48):

So she left in with you, "I'll be there Sunday, October 12th at two o'clock"?

Speaker 4 (01:49:53):

Yes.

Amy Berndt (01:49:54):

And when Sunday, October 12th came around at two o'clock, did she come to your house?

Speaker 4 (01:49:59):

No.

Amy Berndt (01:49:59):

All right.Wat did you and Sarah think when sh didn't show up as she [inaudible 01:50:04]?

Speaker 4 (01:50:06):

I didn't think a lot of it because it was quite usual for Sonya to not arrive. Sometimes the plans became too much, so I just sent her a message and said, "We'd love to see her if she is able to," and again, offered to come and pick her up.

Amy Berndt (01:50:24):

Did she ever respond to your message?

Speaker 4 (01:50:26):

No.

Amy Berndt (01:50:28):

Now, on Sunday evening of October 12th of 2025, did you learn that Sonya was actually missing?

Speaker 4 (01:50:34):

Yes. Stevie contacted me to see how Sonya was. Sonia had sent a message over the weekend to say that her phone was broken so she could only communicate through Messenger. And when Stevie said, "Where was she?" I only thought that it was for that day because we were expecting to see her on the Sunday. And when I phoned and spoke with Stevie and learned that she'd been missing since Friday morning, it was very concerning.

Amy Berndt (01:51:12):

Did you agree with the decision to call the police right away that Sunday?

Speaker 4 (01:51:13):

Yes. As soon as I spoke to Stevie, I said to contact the police because she had already been missing two days at this point.

Amy Berndt (01:51:24):

When you learned that she had actually flown to the United States without telling anyone, what did you do to try to help find her?

Speaker 4 (01:51:32):

Then I did a post. I wrote a post and we looked at it together as a family and we put it over all of the Florida missing sites, as many as that we could identify. We wanted to make sure that we spread the word far and wide because we knew how vulnerable she was and we wanted to try and make sure that we found her safe and well.

Amy Berndt (01:52:00):

Your Honor, may I approach the witness?

Judge Timothy McCourt (01:52:01):

Yes, ma'am.

Amy Berndt (01:52:07):

I'm going to show you what's been marked for identification as State's Exhibit E and ask you, do you recognize that photograph?

Speaker 4 (01:52:13):

Yes.

Amy Berndt (01:52:14):

Who's that picture of?

Speaker 4 (01:52:14):

Sonya [inaudible 01:52:16].

Amy Berndt (01:52:17):

Is that a fair and accurate depiction of the way Sonya looked on October 10th of 2025?

Speaker 4 (01:52:21):

Yes.

Amy Berndt (01:52:21):

Your Honor, at this time we move State's Exhibit E into evidence.

Junior Barrett (01:52:25):

No objection, Judge.

Judge Timothy McCourt (01:52:26):

Without objection, what's been marked for identification as State's Exhibit E will be admitted into evidence as State's Exhibit four.

Amy Berndt (01:52:31):

And may we publish, Your Honor?

Judge Timothy McCourt (01:52:32):

Yes, ma'am.

Amy Berndt (01:52:36):

Is that your sister's Sonya?

Speaker 4 (01:52:36):

Yes.

Amy Berndt (01:52:36):

I don't have any other questions, Judge.

Judge Timothy McCourt (01:52:44):

Okay. Any cross examination?

Junior Barrett (01:52:46):

Yes, Judge. As soon as the stage... Thank you.

(01:52:48)
Good Morning.

Speaker 4 (01:52:58):

Good morning.

Junior Barrett (01:53:02):

If at some point I ask a question and you don't understand it, just let me know.

Speaker 4 (01:53:11):

Thank you.

Junior Barrett (01:53:11):

I know I have an accent, so again, if you don't understand it, just let me know. All right?

Speaker 4 (01:53:12):

Okay. Thank you.

Junior Barrett (01:53:13):

If you don't recall something, just let me know you don't remember. That's fine.

Speaker 4 (01:53:20):

Okay. Thank you very much.

Junior Barrett (01:53:23):

No problem. Okay. You said at one point when you spoke to your sister, she mentioned to you that there was a website she was going on and she was being threatened. Is that correct?

Speaker 4 (01:53:32):

Yes.

Junior Barrett (01:53:32):

And you said you went to the police?

Speaker 4 (01:53:33):

We did, yeah.

Junior Barrett (01:53:33):

Do you know whether or not the police had investigated?

Speaker 4 (01:53:41):

When I spoke to the police we contacted, it's called 111 in the UK. It's not an emergency number. They said that they were looking into it when we spoke on the phone. They said about getting her mental health support, which we did. When I spoke to Sonya the week after, she mentioned that there hadn't been much contact, and so I suggested that she sent the evidence because she had shown me some screenshots of some of the threats, and she had said that she had lost friends and that they'd confessed to some very violent crimes to her and sent videos. And so I suggested that she sent that information to the... There's an online forum where we can send the information to the police.

Junior Barrett (01:54:50):

Okay. Did you actually speak to any police officer?

Speaker 4 (01:54:57):

I didn't, no. They didn't come back to me at that time.

Junior Barrett (01:54:59):

Now, when you spoke to your sister about these threats, do you recall whether or not it was one person or several different individuals?

Speaker 4 (01:55:11):

She said that there were several individuals that she was talking to.

Junior Barrett (01:55:20):

And you essentially told her to send it to the police, or do you recall if you were involved with getting that information to the police?

Speaker 4 (01:55:27):

I was involved with the initial call and calling the police, but the sending of the information, I wasn't, no.

Junior Barrett (01:55:38):

‍

Do you know whether or not any of those individuals was from the UK?

Speaker 4 (01:55:43):

Not to my understanding, no. It was one person in particular that she spoke with more as far as I remember the conversations, but they all had different usernames, so I don't remember whose was who.

Junior Barrett (01:56:05):

Okay. But you actually saw the messages itself?

Speaker 4 (01:56:05):

I did see the messages.

Junior Barrett (01:56:08):

Okay. So when you said you went to the police, you're talking about really just calling the number or physically going?

Speaker 4 (01:56:19):

No, I called the police.

Junior Barrett (01:56:19):

Okay. Okay. Now, the plans to meet up with your sister, was that made weeks before or just days before she disappeared?

Speaker 4 (01:56:30):

Initially, it was weeks before, and as we got closer, that changed.

Junior Barrett (01:56:37):

All right. Now, at that point, was there an actual date you all were supposed to meet up?

Speaker 4 (01:56:44):

Well, Sarah was arriving on Saturday the 11th, and I was driving to the airport to pick her up. And initially, Sonya was going to stay the night before and travel with me to the airport to pick up Sarah.

Junior Barrett (01:57:00):

So your sister, meaning Sonya, was supposed to be with you the Friday, the day before the other sister was flying?

Speaker 4 (01:57:07):

Yes, initially. Yeah.

Junior Barrett (01:57:07):

Initially. And then, did she call you and change it?

Speaker 4 (01:57:12):

She sent messages as we got closer to the day, and then she said that she'll come to the airport, but not stay over the night before. And then, when it come to pick Sarah up, she said that she was just going to come on the Sunday at two o'clock. She was very specific about that time.

Junior Barrett (01:57:33):

Okay. Through the messages, was there anything in the messages that gave you any concern that maybe she wasn't her normal self? I hate to use the word normal, but just that she wasn't her normal self?

Speaker 4 (01:57:52):

At that time, there wasn't anything that worried me. She said her phone was broken. Yeah, there wasn't anything that I was particularly worried about with the messages. It was quite common for it to become too much for Sonya to carry through with plans.

Junior Barrett (01:58:12):

Okay. Did you ever actually speak to her on the phone?

Speaker 4 (01:58:18):

I think maybe a couple of weeks before, I had a conversation with her on the phone. I can't remember the exact date though.

Junior Barrett (01:58:28):

But when you offered she definitely didn't want you to come and pick her up, she said she would basically find her way to you?

Speaker 4 (01:58:33):

Yes.

Junior Barrett (01:58:34):

Okay. You also mentioned that there were times that, the phrase I think you used was a better place. I'm assuming you mean that she seemed steady in terms of her interaction with you, she seems okay. Is that correct?

Speaker 4 (01:59:07):

Yeah. When she was feeling better, she would engage with conversation and interact with us more than when she was struggling with her mental health. As I said before, she would push us away and make it very difficult because she didn't feel like she deserved to have us contact and have us be around her. She didn't want to put anything extra on us, but it's completely opposite to what we wanted. We just wanted to be there and be with her.

Junior Barrett (01:59:48):

Understood. And if I get you corrected, the last time you spoke to her as opposed to messages would've been, what, weeks before, correct?

Judge Timothy McCourt (01:59:58):

Yes.

Junior Barrett (02:00:00):

All right.

(02:00:04)
No other questions, Judge. Thank you.

Judge Timothy McCourt (02:00:05):

Any redirect examination?

Amy Berndt (02:00:07):

No, Your Honor. I have no further questions.

Judge Timothy McCourt (02:00:07):

Members of the jury, do any of you all have questions of this witness? If you do, please raise your hand. Seeing no hands, State, is this witness released?

Amy Berndt (02:00:14):

Yes. We'd ask that she be released.

Judge Timothy McCourt (02:00:16):

Okay. Defense, is she released?

Junior Barrett (02:00:17):

No objection, Your Honor.

Judge Timothy McCourt (02:00:17):

Ma'am, you're free to go about your day. Thank you for your time.

Speaker 4 (02:00:19):

Thank you.

Judge Timothy McCourt (02:00:23):

State, on your lineup for how long you expect witnesses to take for their arrival time? The next witness looks like they may be a little while. Would now be a good time for a short recess?

Speaker 5 (02:00:32):

Probably, Your Honor.

Judge Timothy McCourt (02:00:33):

Okay. Members of the jury, we're going to take about a 10 minute recess to be long enough for y'all to go to the back, use the restroom, get a drink, and come back out. Okay? Leave your notepads here on your chairs closed up and get them to get back. Again, on break, do not discuss the case with one another or any other person. Should you happen to use your phones or electronic devices, do not use them to learn about the case, the people or places involved in the case or anything to do with the case. And again, my directive to not access social media or any news site continues to apply. Okay? We'll see you back in about 10 minutes. The jury's exited the courtroom. We're going to be in recess for 10 minutes. I know we have a lot of folks here in the audience. So that you all know, we have restrooms here on the fourth floor. If you go out these double doors to the left, there's restrooms over there. There are restrooms in front of courtroom 4A on the other side of the floor. We also have some single stall restrooms out to the left. Okay? Everybody who is here, if you want to be here for the continuation of the trial, please make sure to be back within 10 minutes. I don't want to have witnesses coming and going when anybody's on the witness stand. We need to make sure that the jury hears everything that they need to hear. So just be quick with the break. We'll be back in 10 minutes, okay?

Speaker 6 (02:11:25):

We're ready to proceed, Your Honor.

Judge Timothy McCourt (02:11:27):

Is anybody from the audience we expect to be filtering back in?

Speaker 7 (02:11:30):

[inaudible 02:11:33]

Judge Timothy McCourt (02:11:34):

Let's go and bring in the jury.

Judge Timothy McCourt (02:12:51):

Everyone can be seated. Thank you. Ladies and gentlemen, welcome back. State, you can call your next witness.

Lawyer (02:12:56):

State calls Darren Thomas. Presentation mode, Your Honor.

Judge Timothy McCourt (02:13:12):

Yes, sir.

(02:13:12)
If you can raise your right hand, face the court to be sworn.

Clerk (02:13:47):

Do you swear or affirm the testimony you're about to give will be the truth, the whole truth, and nothing but the truth, so help you God?

Darren Thomas (02:13:47):

I do.

Judge Timothy McCourt (02:13:47):

You can go ahead be seated.

Lawyer (02:13:47):

Would you please introduce yourself to the jury?

Darren Thomas (02:13:49):

I'm Detective Sergeant Darren Thomas of the Hampshire and on the White Constabulary based in the UK.

Lawyer (02:13:55):

You said Hampshire?

Darren Thomas (02:13:56):

Hampshire.

Lawyer (02:13:57):

Okay. What do you do as a detective sergeant over there?

Darren Thomas (02:14:00):

So I've been a police officer for 29 years, detective sergeant since 2012. For the last three years, I'm the supervisor on the missing team, one of three missing teams in Hampshire that covers the Portsmouth area.

Lawyer (02:14:15):

And what does the missing team do?

Darren Thomas (02:14:17):

Yeah, so our role is primarily to conduct investigations into locating missing individuals.

Lawyer (02:14:25):

Okay. Let me direct your attention to Monday morning, October 13th, 2025. Did you receive a report regarding a missing person named Sonia Exelby taken by Constable Alex Brown the previous evening?

Darren Thomas (02:14:38):

Yes.

Lawyer (02:14:38):

And who is Constable Alex Brown?

Darren Thomas (02:14:41):

Constable Alex Brown is a response officer who did attend the initial missing person report, take the details off of the reporting person and make an initial risk assessment. I believe he would've undertaken inquiries at the address, searched the address and seized some items as well.

Lawyer (02:15:05):

Would Constable Alex Brown been the one to actually go out and make contact with Steven Hunt who called?

Darren Thomas (02:15:10):

Yes, that would be correct.

Lawyer (02:15:12):

So in the UK, if someone calls in to report a missing person, can you describe for the jury the process that you undergo?

Darren Thomas (02:15:20):

Yeah. So someone would be reported missing. An officer would be dispatched to attend that location and speak to the reporting person. They would obtain details as to the circumstances of that missing person's disappearance, like I say, search the address, and then based on all the information that the reporting person is given, make an assessment as to the level of risk and potentially seize any items that could be considered evidence or may give an idea as to the whereabouts of the missing individual.

Lawyer (02:15:56):

Okay. And again, who made the report, the missing person report in this case?

Darren Thomas (02:16:00):

Stevie Hunt.

Lawyer (02:16:03):

How would you have gotten involved personally?

Darren Thomas (02:16:06):

So I'm the supervisor on the missing person team. When I came on duty, the morning after the report had been taken, we agreed to take ownership of the investigation and I directed my staff to conduct a number of inquiries.

Lawyer (02:16:20):

Did Constable Alex Brown's report contain some personal information about Sonia Exelby, such as her social media accounts, passwords, banking information, potential flight information, things like that?

Darren Thomas (02:16:33):

Yes, it did.

Lawyer (02:16:34):

Okay. And had a laptop computer also been collected as evidence by Constable Alex Brown the night before you got involved?

Darren Thomas (02:16:43):

Yes, it had.

Lawyer (02:16:44):

And was that laptop brought to the police station?

Darren Thomas (02:16:47):

Yes. As in all property in the UK, the seizing officer brings that into the police station to be booked into our secure property store, is allocated a specific unique reference number and then put into an evidence bag and booked into property.

Lawyer (02:17:05):

When somebody collects a piece of evidence such as the laptop you described, does the collecting officer write information on the packaging as well?

Darren Thomas (02:17:12):

Yes.

Lawyer (02:17:12):

Like what?

Darren Thomas (02:17:14):

They would just write their name, date, and time that they took possession of that item and obviously provide a description as to what the item is.

Lawyer (02:17:22):

And you said a label is generated to put on the piece of evidence?

Darren Thomas (02:17:25):

Yes, that's correct.

Lawyer (02:17:26):

What information is on that label?

Darren Thomas (02:17:28):

So it's again, just the description of the item and a unique property reference number.

Lawyer (02:17:34):

And at some point, did you take possession of the laptop that Constable Alex Brown collected from Steven Hunt?

Darren Thomas (02:17:39):

Yes, I did.

Lawyer (02:17:48):

Can I approach, Your Honor?

Judge Timothy McCourt (02:17:48):

Yes, sir.

Lawyer (02:17:48):

I'm showing you what's been marked as State's Exhibit F, as in Frank. Can you take a look at that and tell me if you recognize that item?

Darren Thomas (02:17:56):

Yes, that is the laptop that was initially seized by Constable Alex Brown that I took possession of.

Lawyer (02:18:02):

Do you recognize Constable Alex Brown's ID number on that and his information?

Darren Thomas (02:18:12):

Yes.

Lawyer (02:18:12):

Okay. And does that laptop also contain the identifying information of where it was collected, what it is, and the case number and things like that?

Darren Thomas (02:18:21):

Yes, it does.

Lawyer (02:18:23):

At this time, Your Honor, State would move... Is that laptop the same or substantially the same condition as when it was provided to you and you collected it?

Darren Thomas (02:18:31):

Yes, it appears to be.

Lawyer (02:18:32):

Okay. At this time, State would move F into evidence as State's 5, Your Honor.

Junior Barrett (02:18:35):

No objection, Judge.

Judge Timothy McCourt (02:18:36):

That objection was marked for identification as State's Exhibit F will be admitted into evidence as State's Exhibit 5.

Lawyer (02:18:55):

Did you eventually transfer custody of that laptop to a special agent from the Florida Department of Law Enforcement named Rebecca McKenzie?

Darren Thomas (02:19:03):

Yes, I did.

Lawyer (02:19:04):

How'd that happen?

Darren Thomas (02:19:05):

So in November last year, Special Agent McKenzie came over to the UK and she was provided with a number of pieces of evidence and information, and that laptop was one of them that I handed directly to her.

Lawyer (02:19:20):

Okay. Once you received the missing persons report generated by Constable Alex Brown, what steps did you first take?

Darren Thomas (02:19:28):

So initially I directed my team to conduct some inquiries in relation... the initial information on the report suggested there was a chance that Ms. Exelby had left the UK. So we made inquiries with the Virgin Airline. We conducted some financial inquiries through our financial investigation unit to identify if there was any relevant financial transactions and identify accounts belonging to Ms. Exelby. And we also conducted some inquiries in relation to phone data for devices that phones we believe to be in Ms. Exelby's possession.

Lawyer (02:20:09):

Is this all being done on an expedited basis?

Darren Thomas (02:20:12):

Yes.

Lawyer (02:20:13):

Okay. So logistically, how do you and your team reach out to these, the airlines, the financial institutions you described?

Darren Thomas (02:20:21):

So email and phone calls initially, and then with regards to the communications data, that's done through a specialist team. We make an application and they go direct to the phone companies. And then as I said with the financial records, we go to our financial investigation unit and they make contact with the police liaison departments at the relevant banks and obtain the information.

Lawyer (02:20:44):

And because it involves a missing persons and the exigent basis, do these institutions send you their records pretty much immediately?

Darren Thomas (02:20:51):

Yes, although they don't send the formal records at that stage because it's effectively done on an intelligence only basis because it's expedited at that point. So they provide you the information, but not maybe the full record.

Lawyer (02:21:08):

Is it common then later on for you to follow up with formal legal requests to these companies and have them send you the actual records?

Darren Thomas (02:21:15):

Yes.

Lawyer (02:21:24):

Okay. As your team is getting this information from these various companies, the airlines, the banking institutions, things like that, are you being updated as far as what the information shows?

Darren Thomas (02:21:33):

Yes.

Lawyer (02:21:34):

Did you and your intelligence team investigate whether Sonia Exelby did in fact board any flights?

Darren Thomas (02:21:43):

So the information we received from Virgin Airline indicated that Ms. Exelby had boarded a flight at London Heathrow and had flown into Atlanta and then had subsequently boarded another flight at Atlanta and flown to Gainesville.

Lawyer (02:22:00):

Your Honor, at this time the State would introduce State's Exhibit G into evidence as State's Exhibit 6. The Virgin Atlantic flight records are self-authenticating a business record certification has been attached as well as notice being provided to the defense.

Judge Timothy McCourt (02:22:13):

Any objection?

Junior Barrett (02:22:13):

No objection, Judge.

Judge Timothy McCourt (02:22:14):

Without objection, then State's Exhibit G will be admitted into evidence as State's Exhibit 6.

Lawyer (02:22:18):

May I approach the witness?

Judge Timothy McCourt (02:22:19):

Yes, sir.

Lawyer (02:22:22):

Can you take a look at that exhibit and tell me if you recognize that?

Darren Thomas (02:22:38):

Yes, that's information from Virgin Atlantic Airlines in relation to that travel booking.

Lawyer (02:22:44):

Your Honor, may I publish?

Judge Timothy McCourt (02:22:45):

Yes, sir.

Lawyer (02:22:47):

Showing you State's Exhibit 6. What do we see here?

Darren Thomas (02:22:51):

So again, that's the custom record relating to that booking and the method that that booking was made, the payment method, and obviously the cost of that ticket as well, and the flight itinerary.

Lawyer (02:23:05):

Okay. And the left side, is that the full document and the right side, just a portion blown up to make it easier to read?

Darren Thomas (02:23:08):

Yes, that's correct.

Lawyer (02:23:09):

Okay. So what was determined as far as whether Ms. Exelby actually boarded a flight?

Darren Thomas (02:23:17):

So on the itinerary, the information received from Virgin Atlantic, it shows that she'd physically checked in and checked in at the gate and boarded the aircraft on the flight from Heathrow to Atlanta and then Atlanta to Georgia. However, she had failed to check in for her pre-booked return flight at Gainesville to Atlanta.

Lawyer (02:23:40):

And according to the records from Virgin Airlines, on what date did she fly from Heathrow in England to the US?

Darren Thomas (02:23:48):

That was on the 10th of October 2025, and she was due to return back on the 13th of October 2025.

Lawyer (02:23:55):

And in the upper right box of the right-hand side of the screen, what were the last four digits of the credit card number that was used to book this flight?

Darren Thomas (02:24:03):

8331.

Lawyer (02:24:05):

And in the middle box on the right, how much did this flight cost?

Darren Thomas (02:24:09):

It's £593.92.

Lawyer (02:24:17):

You mentioned earlier that you and part of your team also investigated Ms. Exelby's financial records-

Darren Thomas (02:24:23):

Yes, that's correct.

Lawyer (02:24:24):

... from the banking institutions? At this time, Your Honor, State would move State's Exhibit H into evidence as State's 7. They are bank records from Lloyd Bank for the victim. A business record certification is included and notice has been provided to the defense.

Junior Barrett (02:24:45):

No objection, Judge.

Judge Timothy McCourt (02:24:46):

Without objection, then State's Exhibit H will be admitted into evidence as State's Exhibit 7.

Lawyer (02:24:50):

Do you recognize the document I just handed you?

Darren Thomas (02:24:59):

Yes. That is banking records relating to Ms. Exelby's Lloyd's bank account.

Lawyer (02:25:06):

May I publish, Your Honor?

Judge Timothy McCourt (02:25:07):

Yes, sir.

Lawyer (02:25:09):

Showing you State's Exhibit 7, you said they're in the victim's name. What do we see in the box up in the top left-hand corner?

Darren Thomas (02:25:16):

The victim's first full name and surname and her home address.

Lawyer (02:25:22):

And we see a column called date. In the UK, how do you express date?

Darren Thomas (02:25:27):

So in the UK, date is written down expressed as day, month, year, as opposed to month, day, year as you do in the US.

Lawyer (02:25:36):

Okay. So what month or what period of time do these records cover that we see in the screen?

Darren Thomas (02:25:41):

So the first date in column nine on the first column there is the 1st of September 2025.

Lawyer (02:25:47):

So that's December 1st, not January 9th. Understood. Showing you next page of those records. Was a charge located on Ms. Exelby's financial data from the Lloyd's bank records for £593.92?

Darren Thomas (02:26:07):

Yes.

Lawyer (02:26:08):

And what was that charge for according to the records?

Darren Thomas (02:26:11):

According to the records, that was for the booking of the Virgin Atlantic flights.

Lawyer (02:26:14):

And does that charge correspond with the amount that was paid for the flight from Virgin Airlines that we saw in the previous exhibit?

Darren Thomas (02:26:21):

Yes, it does. It's the same amount.

Lawyer (02:26:22):

Does their entry also include the last four digits of the credit card used to pay for that flight?

Darren Thomas (02:26:28):

Yes, it does. It's card 8331, which is the same account.

Lawyer (02:26:34):

And showing you the next page, what month are we looking at now?

Darren Thomas (02:26:39):

That this is the month of October 2025.

Lawyer (02:26:41):

Okay. And showing you the next page, there's a box showing some entries. What did the records show as far as any recent transactions or attempted transactions involving Sonia Exelby's bank or credit card after she landed in the US?

Darren Thomas (02:26:58):

So the financial inquiries identified that on the 11th of October 2025, there were four attempted transactions. They didn't actually go through, but four attempted transactions from Ms. Exelby's account to Silver Wolf's Roadside Assistance.

Lawyer (02:27:15):

And for the record, how much were each of those transactions attempted?

Darren Thomas (02:27:20):

So the first two transactions were for the same amount, for £226.28. There was a transaction for £150.85 and a transaction for £75.43, so they were decreasing.

Lawyer (02:27:33):

Do Ms. Exelby's financial records from Lloyd's Bank indicate the credit card that was being used for these attempted transactions?

Darren Thomas (02:27:43):

Yes, they do. It's card 8331, the same as previously.

Lawyer (02:27:47):

Does that correspond with the same last four digits that was used to book the Virgin Atlantic flights?

Darren Thomas (02:27:54):

Yes.

Lawyer (02:27:57):

Okay. Did you learn that there was another bank account associated with Sonia Exelby?

Darren Thomas (02:28:02):

Yes, I did. Financial inquiries also identified that there was a Tesco Bank account.

Lawyer (02:28:07):

At this time, Your Honor, the State would move State's I into evidence as State's 8. It is Sonia Exelby's records from Tesco Bank. A business record certification is attached and proper notice was provided to the defense.

Junior Barrett (02:28:21):

No objection, Judge.

Judge Timothy McCourt (02:28:22):

Without objection, State's Exhibit I will be admitted into evidence as State's Exhibit 8.

Lawyer (02:28:26):

Can you take a look at those items and tell me about that?

Darren Thomas (02:28:36):

Yes, that is the banking record from Ms. Exelby's Tesco bank account.

Lawyer (02:28:40):

May I publish, Your Honor?

Judge Timothy McCourt (02:28:41):

Yes, sir.

Lawyer (02:28:43):

Showing you the first page of State's Exhibit 8, the Tesco Bank records. Again, does the left side show the full page and the right side just show a blow up of that section?

Darren Thomas (02:28:51):

Yes.

Lawyer (02:28:52):

And in whose name are these records?

Darren Thomas (02:28:54):

Again, in the name of Ms. Sonia Exelby with her home address as well.

Lawyer (02:29:04):

Did her bank records from Tesco Bank reflect usage of her credit card around the same period as the attempted transactions we just talked about involving Lloyd's Bank?

Darren Thomas (02:29:14):

Yes, they did.

Lawyer (02:29:14):

What did they show?

Darren Thomas (02:29:15):

They showed one confirmed transaction that had gone through and cleared with the transaction, the clearing date being the 12th of October 25, and that was a payment made to Silver Wolf's Roadside Assistance.

Lawyer (02:29:31):

Is that Silver Wolf's Roadside Assistance the same company that tried to access her credit card with the other bank records we just looked at?

Darren Thomas (02:29:38):

Yes, that's correct.

Lawyer (02:29:39):

And when did the actual transaction take place, according to the records?

Darren Thomas (02:29:43):

So the transaction card payment was made on the 11th of October.

Lawyer (02:29:47):

And it cleared the bank the next day on the 12th?

Darren Thomas (02:29:49):

That's correct.

Lawyer (02:29:49):

How much was that transaction for in pounds?

Darren Thomas (02:29:52):

That transaction was for £905.11.

Lawyer (02:29:55):

Okay. Do the records indicate how much that would equate to in US dollars?

Darren Thomas (02:30:01):

The records show that they, based on that currency transaction rate, that would've been $1,200 US.

Lawyer (02:30:12):

So at this point, did you know that Ms. Exelby's bank accounts were involved in transactions with Silver Wolf Roadside Assistance in the US after she apparently landed in Gainesville?

Darren Thomas (02:30:22):

Yes.

Lawyer (02:30:23):

At this point, did you know who was associated with Silver Wolf's Roadside Assistance?

Darren Thomas (02:30:28):

So based on that information, just from a basic Google search, I identified that Silver Wolf's Roadside Assistance was a roadside recovery business and open source research just on Google identified that that was owned and run by Dwayne Hall.

Lawyer (02:30:50):

Did Sonia Exelby's bank records give you any information about where Sonia Exelby may have been staying once she landed in the US?

Darren Thomas (02:30:59):

So the banking records indicated that she may have booked an Airbnb.

Lawyer (02:31:04):

Okay. I'm showing you State's Exhibit 7. What do we see here in the red box?

Darren Thomas (02:31:11):

So again, that's a transaction from the 22nd of September 2025 showing a booking for Airbnb.

Lawyer (02:31:21):

And how much was that booking for, according to the records?

Darren Thomas (02:31:25):

For £218.95.

Lawyer (02:31:28):

Was there a confirmation associated with the booking of that Airbnb, a confirmation number?

Darren Thomas (02:31:34):

Yes. The confirmation number is the HMSYBX5JN reference number on there.

Lawyer (02:31:40):

Is it possible to track that confirmation number to figure out where that Airbnb is located?

Darren Thomas (02:31:45):

Yes, via an application to Airbnb.

Lawyer (02:31:47):

And was that done?

Darren Thomas (02:31:49):

Yes.

Lawyer (02:31:50):

Your Honor, at this time, State would move State's Exhibit J into evidence as State's Exhibit 9. These are the Airbnb reservation records. A business record certification is attached and proper notice has been given to the defense.

Junior Barrett (02:32:06):

No objection, Judge.

Judge Timothy McCourt (02:32:07):

Without objection, State's Exhibit J will be admitted into evidence as State's Exhibit 9.

Lawyer (02:32:11):

May I approach?

Judge Timothy McCourt (02:32:12):

Yes, sir.

Lawyer (02:32:14):

I'm showing you State's Exhibit 9. Can you take a look at that and tell me if that looks familiar?

Darren Thomas (02:32:26):

Yes, that is the application requesting the guest reservation details from Airbnb.

Lawyer (02:32:34):

May I publish, Your Honor?

Judge Timothy McCourt (02:32:34):

Yes, sir.

Lawyer (02:32:36):

Showing you State's Exhibit 9. Can you explain to the jury what we see here?

Darren Thomas (02:32:41):

So that is the confirmation code, the booking reference number HMSYBX5JN4.

Lawyer (02:32:50):

And does that confirmation code correspond to the confirmation code we just looked at from her Lloyd's bank records?

Darren Thomas (02:32:56):

Yes, it's the same reference number.

Lawyer (02:33:00):

Is that what we see here?

Darren Thomas (02:33:01):

Yes, that's correct.

Lawyer (02:33:08):

According to the Airbnb guest reservation details, what date was the reservation to begin?

Darren Thomas (02:33:16):

The reservation was booked to commence from the 10th of October 2025.

Lawyer (02:33:23):

Is that date consistent with the flight information showing that was when she was coming to the US?

Darren Thomas (02:33:27):

Yes.

Lawyer (02:33:28):

How long was the reservation for, according to the records?

Darren Thomas (02:33:30):

For two nights.

Lawyer (02:33:33):

Did the reservation details also give you the address of the Airbnb?

Darren Thomas (02:33:37):

It provided the location as 1623 Northwest 122nd Terrace.

Lawyer (02:33:45):

Did the Airbnb records also show you the name of the person who booked that Airbnb?

Darren Thomas (02:33:50):

Yes. It shows that that reservation was made by Sonia Exelby.

Lawyer (02:33:56):

And was there a phone number associated with the reservation?

Darren Thomas (02:33:58):

There was a contact phone number and an email address provided.

Lawyer (02:34:01):

So I'm showing you State's 6 and 9. Does that phone number correspond with the phone number used according to the Virgin Atlantic records to book that flight?

Darren Thomas (02:34:10):

Yes, it's the same phone number.

Lawyer (02:34:20):

Was this information that we just talked about and was obtained by you and your team provided to the Florida Department of Law Enforcement officers in Gainesville?

Darren Thomas (02:34:30):

Yes, it was. Although it is quite a complicated and bureaucratic process to transfer information, provide information across borders. You can't just pick up the phone and call a colleague in another country. So yes, I completed a report detailing the information that we'd ascertained to that date, requesting that the US authorities start commence making investigations into trying to locate Ms. Exelby, and then that was transmitted via our international liaison officer in our force via the National Crime Agency based in Manchester in the UK to the NCB, which is the INTERPOL office in Washington DC. And then it was obviously passed to local state law enforcement and ultimately to Special Agent McKenzie at the FDLE.

Lawyer (02:35:28):

So this is a complicated, long process to exchange information between the US and the UK?

Darren Thomas (02:35:34):

It can be, yes.

Lawyer (02:35:35):

Okay. Did you and your intelligence team also request surveillance footage from Heathrow Airport around the times Sonia Exelby would have arrived and boarded the plane to travel to the US?

Darren Thomas (02:35:46):

Yes, we did.

Lawyer (02:35:47):

And where is Heathrow?

Darren Thomas (02:35:48):

Heathrow Airport is in London. It's in West London.

Lawyer (02:35:52):

Were you provided such surveillance footage?

Darren Thomas (02:35:54):

Yes. We were provided footage from the security area at Heathrow that passengers have to transit through before they get to a departure gate.

Lawyer (02:36:06):

So at this point, your information has gone through the process to get to Florida Department of Law Enforcement here in Gainesville, right?

Darren Thomas (02:36:13):

Yes.

Lawyer (02:36:14):

Okay. Moving ahead a few months later, you mentioned earlier, did Special Agent Rebecca McKenzie come to the UK?

Darren Thomas (02:36:20):

Yes, she did, in November 2025.

Lawyer (02:36:25):

Did you assist her in her doing some additional investigation and some interviews and things like that?

Darren Thomas (02:36:30):

I did, yes.

Lawyer (02:36:30):

Did you also transfer the laptop that was introduced earlier over to her custody?

Darren Thomas (02:36:35):

At that time I did, yes.

Lawyer (02:36:39):

Okay. Thank you, sir. No other questions, Your Honor.

Judge Timothy McCourt (02:36:41):

Any cross-examination?

Junior Barrett (02:36:51):

Good morning, sir.

Darren Thomas (02:36:52):

Good morning.

Junior Barrett (02:36:53):

Just to make clear, the flight as well as the Airbnb were booked on Ms. Exelby's account, correct?

Darren Thomas (02:37:07):

That's correct, yes.

Junior Barrett (02:37:08):

Her credit card?

Darren Thomas (02:37:09):

Her credit card number.

Junior Barrett (02:37:10):

Did your investigation indicate or suggested that someone else may have used that credit card to do the booking?

Darren Thomas (02:37:16):

We found no evidence that that was the case.

Junior Barrett (02:37:18):

Okay. And again, both the hotel and the Airbnb as well as the flight itself, do you recall whether or not that was booked the day before or the month before? Do you recall that?

Darren Thomas (02:37:36):

The banking records will show, but I believe it was booked. They were both booked prior to Ms. Exelby traveling to the US in October 2025. I believe they were booked in September.

Junior Barrett (02:37:49):

In September, okay. I don't have any other questions, Judge.

Judge Timothy McCourt (02:38:04):

Any redirect examination?

Lawyer (02:38:05):

No, Your Honor.

Judge Timothy McCourt (02:38:05):

Members of the jury, do any of you all have questions of this witness? If you do, please raise your hand. Okay. Seeing no hands, state is he released?

Lawyer (02:38:12):

He is, Your Honor.

Judge Timothy McCourt (02:38:13):

Defense?

Junior Barrett (02:38:13):

No objection, Judge.

Judge Timothy McCourt (02:38:14):

Sir, you're free to go about your day. Thank you for your time.

Darren Thomas (02:38:16):

Thank you, Your Honor.

Judge Timothy McCourt (02:38:16):

State, call your next witness.

Amy Berndt (02:38:18):

The State calls Riley Artman.

Judge Timothy McCourt (02:38:31):

Ms. Burke, can you hand me the exhibits? Thank you, ma'am.

(02:38:39)
Raise your right hand, face the clerk to be sworn in.

Clerk (02:39:19):

Do you swear or affirm the testimony you're about to give will be the truth, the whole truth, and nothing but the truth, so help you God?

Riley Artman (02:39:23):

I do swear.

Clerk (02:39:23):

All right.

Judge Timothy McCourt (02:39:24):

You can go ahead and be seated, sir.

Amy Berndt (02:39:27):

Good morning.

Riley Artman (02:39:27):

Good morning.

Amy Berndt (02:39:28):

Can you please tell the jury your name?

Riley Artman (02:39:30):

My name is Riley Artman.

Amy Berndt (02:39:31):

And where do you work?

Riley Artman (02:39:32):

The Marion County Sheriff's Office.

Amy Berndt (02:39:34):

How long have you worked for the Marion County Sheriff's Office?

Riley Artman (02:39:36):

I've worked there for 10 years.

Amy Berndt (02:39:38):

And what is your position with the Marion County Sheriff's Office?

Riley Artman (02:39:41):

Currently, I am a patrol deputy.

Amy Berndt (02:39:43):

Okay. How long have you been a patrol deputy?

Riley Artman (02:39:45):

For 10 years.

Amy Berndt (02:39:47):

I want to direct your attention to Monday, October 13th of 2025. On that date, did you respond to 16293 Northwest 122nd Terrace in Reddick, Florida?

Riley Artman (02:40:00):

I did.

Amy Berndt (02:40:00):

Approximately what time did you arrive there?

Riley Artman (02:40:03):

Sometime in the morning. I don't remember the specific time.

Amy Berndt (02:40:05):

Okay. Would the incident detail report help you recollect what time you arrived?

Riley Artman (02:40:08):

Yes, ma'am.

Amy Berndt (02:40:09):

Your Honor, may I approach the witness?

Judge Timothy McCourt (02:40:09):

Yes, ma'am.

Riley Artman (02:40:29):

Thank you.

(02:40:29)
It was around 8:26 in the morning.

Amy Berndt (02:40:31):

Okay. So 8:26 Monday morning?

Riley Artman (02:40:32):

Yes, ma'am.

Amy Berndt (02:40:33):

All right. And did any other deputies arrive on the scene shortly after you?

Riley Artman (02:40:36):

Deputy Linnell.

Amy Berndt (02:40:37):

All right. And why did you and Deputy Linnell go to this address?

Riley Artman (02:40:40):

We were dispatched there to conduct a wellbeing check at the location. There's a small Airbnb on the front part of the property.

Amy Berndt (02:40:47):

All right. And who were you looking for?

Riley Artman (02:40:49):

Sonia Exelby.

Amy Berndt (02:40:50):

All right. Was she a missing and endangered person from England?

Riley Artman (02:40:56):

Yes, ma'am.

Amy Berndt (02:40:57):

And you said there was an Airbnb at this address?

Riley Artman (02:40:59):

Yes, ma'am.

Amy Berndt (02:41:00):

All right. And what did you do once you arrived at the address?

Riley Artman (02:41:02):

We walked up, conducted a security check of the property. I looked in the windows, knocked on the door, tried to see if there was possibly anybody inside, which there was not at that time.

Amy Berndt (02:41:13):

All right. So nobody answered the door?

Riley Artman (02:41:15):

No, ma'am.

Amy Berndt (02:41:16):

And you were able to look inside?

Riley Artman (02:41:17):

Yes, ma'am.

Amy Berndt (02:41:18):

Did you actually go inside?

Riley Artman (02:41:20):

No, ma'am.

Amy Berndt (02:41:21):

Did the Airbnb appear to be vacant?

Riley Artman (02:41:23):

It did.

Amy Berndt (02:41:25):

Did you or Deputy Linnell speak with some neighbors next to the Airbnb to see if they had any information about Sonia Exelby?

Riley Artman (02:41:31):

We did talk to a neighbor directly next door to where the Airbnb was located.

Amy Berndt (02:41:36):

All right. Were you able to get any relevant information from the neighbor about the whereabouts of Sonia Exelby?

Riley Artman (02:41:41):

No, ma'am.

Amy Berndt (02:41:43):

Okay. And did you locate Sonia Exelby anywhere near the property that morning?

Riley Artman (02:41:47):

No, ma'am.

Amy Berndt (02:41:48):

Did you or Deputy Linnell let an agent from the Florida Department of Law Enforcement know that you could not locate her?

Riley Artman (02:41:53):

Deputy Linnell was the one who made contact with them.

Amy Berndt (02:41:56):

All right. And were you wearing body camera that morning?

Riley Artman (02:41:58):

Yes, ma'am.

Amy Berndt (02:41:59):

Your Honor, may May I approach the witness?

Judge Timothy McCourt (02:42:00):

Yes, ma'am.

Amy Berndt (02:42:04):

I'm showing you what's been marked for identification as State's Exhibit K. If you can look at that and tell me, do you recognize that?

Riley Artman (02:42:10):

I do.

Amy Berndt (02:42:11):

Okay. How do you recognize it?

Riley Artman (02:42:14):

It has the date and my initials on it.

Amy Berndt (02:42:16):

All right. What is that?

Riley Artman (02:42:16):

It is a copy of the wellbeing check camera footage from that night or that morning.

Amy Berndt (02:42:21):

And is that a fair and accurate depiction of the relevant portions of your body camera from October 13th of 2025?

Riley Artman (02:42:26):

Yes, ma'am.

Amy Berndt (02:42:27):

Your Honor, at this time we have move State's Exhibit K into evidence.

Junior Barrett (02:42:29):

No objection, Judge.

Judge Timothy McCourt (02:42:30):

Without objection, State's Exhibit K will be admitted into evidence as State's Exhibit 10.

Amy Berndt (02:42:35):

And this is just a small portion of your body camera that shows you going up to the Airbnb?

Riley Artman (02:42:38):

That's correct. Yes, ma'am.

Amy Berndt (02:42:40):

Your Honor, at this time, may I publish?

Judge Timothy McCourt (02:42:41):

Yes, ma'am. Would you like me to read instruction 2.2?

Amy Berndt (02:42:44):

Yes, Your Honor, please.

Judge Timothy McCourt (02:42:46):

Members of the jury, you're about to view and listen to an audio video recording. The court instructs you that the recording has been edited to eliminate irrelevant portions that would not add to your understanding of the case. The fact that the recording has been edited should not concern you in any way and must not impact the way you view, listen to, and consider this evidence.

Speaker 8 (02:43:03):

[inaudible 02:44:19].

Amy Berndt (02:45:00):

And that's all the questions I have, Judge.

Speaker 11 (02:45:08):

No questions, Your Honor.

Timothy McCourt (02:45:09):

Members of the jury, any of y'all have questions of this witness? If you do, please raise your hand. Okay. Is this witness released?

Amy Berndt (02:45:14):

No, your Honor. He will be recalled at a later time.

Timothy McCourt (02:45:16):

Okay, sir. Just remain in contact with the state, okay?

Speaker 9 (02:45:18):

Okay.

Amy Berndt (02:45:19):

Thank you.

Timothy McCourt (02:45:21):

All right. State, you can call your next witness.

Amy Berndt (02:45:22):

State calls Calvin Lee.

Timothy McCourt (02:45:23):

Face the clerk. Raise your right hand to be sworn in.

Speaker 10 (02:46:33):

Do you swear or affirm the testimony you're about to give be the truth, the whole truth, and nothing but the truth, so help you God?

Calvin Lee (02:46:33):

I do.

Timothy McCourt (02:46:33):

All right. You can go ahead and be seated, sir.

Calvin Lee (02:46:33):

Thank you.

Amy Berndt (02:46:33):

Good morning.

Calvin Lee (02:46:34):

Good morning.

Amy Berndt (02:46:34):

Can you please tell the jury your name?

Calvin Lee (02:46:36):

Calvin Lee.

Amy Berndt (02:46:38):

Where do you work?

Calvin Lee (02:46:39):

With the Florida Department of Law Enforcement, also known as FDLE.

Amy Berndt (02:46:43):

How long have you worked for FDLE?

Calvin Lee (02:46:44):

Since October 2019.

Amy Berndt (02:46:46):

All right. And where did you work prior to FDLE?

Calvin Lee (02:46:49):

I was with the Columbia County Sheriff's Office from March of 2013 until October 2019.

Amy Berndt (02:46:56):

All right. And what is your position with the Florida Department of Law Enforcement?

Calvin Lee (02:46:59):

I'm a special agent.

Amy Berndt (02:47:00):

And what are your duties as a special agent with FDLE?

Calvin Lee (02:47:03):

We conduct violent crimes, crimes against persons, property, such as fraud, crimes against children. I'm in a field office, so we work generally everything.

Amy Berndt (02:47:15):

Where is the field office located that you're in?

Calvin Lee (02:47:18):

It's called the Gainesville Field Office, but it's actually in the city of Alachua.

Amy Berndt (02:47:22):

All right. I want to direct your attention to Monday, October 13th of 2025. On that date, did you become involved in assisting the United Kingdom in locating a missing and endangered woman named Sonia Exelby?

Calvin Lee (02:47:34):

Yes, I did.

Amy Berndt (02:47:36):

And did you learn that a business in Marion County called Solver Wolfs Roadside Assistance had attempted to run one of Sonia's credit cards?

Calvin Lee (02:47:43):

Yes, I did.

Amy Berndt (02:47:44):

All right. And through what processing company was Sonia's card ran?

Calvin Lee (02:47:48):

It was Talech Processing, which is ultimately maintained in records housed by Elavon Bank.

Amy Berndt (02:47:55):

Elavon Bank? Your Honor, may I approach the witness?

Timothy McCourt (02:47:58):

Yes, ma'am.

Amy Berndt (02:48:01):

Your Honor, we move into evidence State's Exhibit L. It's the Elavon Bank records. We have provided notice to the defendant and there is a business record certification.

Speaker 11 (02:48:09):

No objection, Judge.

Timothy McCourt (02:48:10):

Without objection, State's Exhibit L will be admitted into evidence as State's Exhibit 10, or I'm sorry, 11.

Amy Berndt (02:48:17):

If you could look at State's 11 and tell me, do you recognize those?

Calvin Lee (02:48:27):

Yes, I do.

Amy Berndt (02:48:28):

Are those the bank records associated with Solver Wolf's Roadside Assistance that attempted to run one of Sonia Exelby's credit cards?

Calvin Lee (02:48:36):

Yes, through Elavon.

Amy Berndt (02:48:37):

Your Honor, may I publish the records?

Timothy McCourt (02:48:39):

Yes, ma'am. Oh, I'm sorry.

Amy Berndt (02:48:49):

Thank you. Hopefully that top goes away. Is this the merchant profile?

Calvin Lee (02:48:59):

Yes, it is.

Amy Berndt (02:48:59):

All right. Which it states right here at the top. And does this tell you who the owner of Solver Wolfs Roadside Assistance is?

Calvin Lee (02:49:07):

Yes, it is. Dwain Hall.

Amy Berndt (02:49:09):

And that would be right here where it says the owner?

Calvin Lee (02:49:13):

Yes.

Amy Berndt (02:49:14):

All right. And do these records also give you the phone number of Dwain Hall?

Calvin Lee (02:49:17):

Yes, they do.

Amy Berndt (02:49:18):

All right. Can you tell us what the phone number of Dwain Hall is?

Calvin Lee (02:49:22):

That would be 330-575-4894.

Amy Berndt (02:49:29):

And does this also give you an email address that's associated with this company?

Calvin Lee (02:49:34):

Yes, it does.

Amy Berndt (02:49:34):

Okay. And what's the email address?

Calvin Lee (02:49:36):

It is darkwolf44646@gmail.com.

Amy Berndt (02:49:43):

So this comes with those bank records from Elavon and tells you who owns the company and information about the person that owns the company?

Calvin Lee (02:49:50):

Correct.

Amy Berndt (02:49:51):

Which is Dwain Hall. And now are these the actual records pertaining to Solver Wolfs Roadside Assistance?

Calvin Lee (02:49:57):

Yes.

Amy Berndt (02:49:57):

Okay. And we have here, these all seem to be from October 11th of 2025. What are these records showing you?

Calvin Lee (02:50:04):

They're showing transactions that were processed through Talech, which is the processing company used by Dwain Hall's business, and those are declined and an approved credit card from two out of country credit cards.

Amy Berndt (02:50:23):

Okay. So we have a credit card ending in 8331 and one ending in 0804. Were both of those credit cards associated with Sonia Exelby?

Calvin Lee (02:50:33):

Yes, they were determined later on to be.

Amy Berndt (02:50:34):

And did one of these transactional actions for a card ending in 084 actually go through?

Calvin Lee (02:50:40):

Yes. And that would be the $1,200 charge that was highlighted there.

Amy Berndt (02:50:43):

Okay. And then what was the date of that transaction?

Calvin Lee (02:50:48):

October 11th, 2025 at 1:10:30 PM.

Amy Berndt (02:50:54):

And these are different from some attempts that were made on another credit card of Sonia Exelby's?

Calvin Lee (02:50:59):

Correct.

Amy Berndt (02:51:00):

And those attempts did not go through?

Calvin Lee (02:51:02):

They did not.

Amy Berndt (02:51:04):

And are these in standard Eastern Standard Time?

Calvin Lee (02:51:07):

Yes, they are.

Amy Berndt (02:51:07):

These records?

Calvin Lee (02:51:08):

They are.

Amy Berndt (02:51:11):

Now, even though you knew that the Solver Wolf's business attempted to run one of Sonia Exelby's credit cards, at the time you spoke with him, did you actually have these records and did you know that one of these transactions had actually gone through?

Calvin Lee (02:51:26):

I did not.

Amy Berndt (02:51:27):

All right. So when you first spoke with Dwain Hall, you only knew that he had attempted to run one of her cards four times?

Calvin Lee (02:51:33):

Correct.

Amy Berndt (02:51:34):

All right. Now, once you knew that he owned the business, Solver Wolf's Roadside Assistance, did you attempt to make contact with Dwain Hall to ask him about that attempted charge?

Calvin Lee (02:51:45):

Yes, I did.

Amy Berndt (02:51:48):

All right. And did you actually speak with him?

Calvin Lee (02:51:49):

Yes, I did.

Amy Berndt (02:51:50):

All right. When is the first time, the date of the first time you spoke with him?

Calvin Lee (02:51:53):

It would've been October 13th, 2025 at 11:03 AM. I contacted him by telephone.

Amy Berndt (02:52:00):

All right. What number did you call him on?

Calvin Lee (02:52:01):

That would be the 330-575-4894.

Amy Berndt (02:52:09):

The number that was associated with his Solver Wolf's Roadside Assistance business that we just saw?

Calvin Lee (02:52:13):

Yes.

Amy Berndt (02:52:15):

And when you called him, did he identify himself as Dwain Hall?

Calvin Lee (02:52:18):

Yes.

Amy Berndt (02:52:19):

All right. And generally, what did he tell you?

Calvin Lee (02:52:21):

I explained to him that we were helping out Interpol or the United Kingdom with a missing person who was reported missing to them and possibly suicidal. And that information passed to me was that he attempted to use her card or her credit card was declined by his business at some point after she had landed in Gainesville, Florida. And so I was trying to establish a timeline. So the purpose of that call was to figure out what was surrounding the circumstances surrounding that while the payment was declined.

Amy Berndt (02:53:01):

Okay. Did he admit that he had ever met Sonia Exelby when you spoke with him?

Calvin Lee (02:53:04):

No, he said he couldn't remember the exact day or date, but either on that Friday or Saturday night, he received a call from a female that he believed to be Exelby who said she had a flat tire. He never went out there because he was taking payment first before he responded out there. And when the card declined, he never went out there and that ended the contact.

Amy Berndt (02:53:36):

Okay. Your Honor, may I approach the witness?

Calvin Lee (02:53:37):

Yes, ma'am.

Amy Berndt (02:53:38):

I'm going to show you what's been marked identification as State's Exhibit M. Can you look at that and tell me you recognize that?

Calvin Lee (02:53:43):

Yes, I do.

Amy Berndt (02:53:43):

How do you recognize that?

Calvin Lee (02:53:45):

This is the interview recording of my phone call with Dwain Hall from October 13th, 2025.

Amy Berndt (02:53:52):

Of 2025. How do you recognize it?

Calvin Lee (02:53:54):

It has my initials here, CL, and the date of 10/27/26 from when I reviewed this specific disk that has a copy of that recording on it.

Amy Berndt (02:54:01):

Is that a fair and accurate depiction of the interview you did with Dwain Hall on October 13th of 2025?

Calvin Lee (02:54:06):

Yes, it is.

Amy Berndt (02:54:07):

Your Honor, at this time we would move State's Exhibit M into evidence.

Speaker 11 (02:54:10):

No objection, Judge.

Timothy McCourt (02:54:12):

Without objection, State's Exhibit M will be admitted into evidence as State's Exhibit 12.

Amy Berndt (02:54:17):

And Your Honor, may I publish?

Timothy McCourt (02:54:18):

Yes, ma'am.

Audio: Dwain Hall (02:54:43):

Hello. You have reached Silver Wolf Roadside Assistance. This is Dwain, the owner. If you've reached this message between our regular business hours, please hang up and call back again. If you've reached this message otherwise, we're closed. I thank you and have a nice day.

Audio: Speaker 9 (02:55:17):

At the tone, please record your message. When you've finished recording, you may hang up.

Audio: Calvin Lee (02:55:22):

Hello?

Audio: Dwain Hall (02:55:24):

Hello, this is Dwain with Solver Wolfs Roadside. How can I help you?

Audio: Calvin Lee (02:55:27):

Hey, my name is Calvin Lee. I'm a special agent with the Florida Department of Law Enforcement out of the Gainesville area. And we got a weird request. So we are helping out the United Kingdom Police with a missing person, and looking through her banking records, it looked like she called your business for assistance probably two or three days ago, and the payment was declined. Her name would've been Sonia Exelby. Is that ringing a bell?

Audio: Dwain Hall (02:56:08):

Yes and no.

Audio: Calvin Lee (02:56:13):

Okay. So I guess the easiest... Does the declined payment, is that...

Audio: Dwain Hall (02:56:20):

Yeah.

Audio: Calvin Lee (02:56:20):

Okay. What was the deal with that, if you don't mind me asking? Because basically she's reported missing and suicidal, so we're trying to track her down, and we know that three days ago she landed at Gainesville Airport and got in a rental car and was heading south. So like I said, through the banking records, it shows that there was a decline charge from your company. So we're assuming that I guess she needed assistance?

Audio: Dwain Hall (02:56:55):

Yeah, she broke down, needed a tire change.

Audio: Calvin Lee (02:56:58):

Okay.

Audio: Dwain Hall (02:56:58):

And was requesting to be transported the rest of the way to her location, but declined payments. We ain't going to touch that.

Audio: Calvin Lee (02:57:05):

Okay.

‍

Audio: Dwain Hall (02:57:07):

We have to pay for our services.

Audio: Calvin Lee (02:57:08):

Right. So you did change the tire and the payment got declined or that payment went through and she-

Audio: Dwain Hall (02:57:16):

We never showed up.

Audio: Calvin Lee (02:57:17):

Oh, okay. Okay. So she said she had a flat tire.

Audio: Dwain Hall (02:57:21):

Yeah.

Audio: Calvin Lee (02:57:22):

And so before y'all show up there, they have to pay over the phone?

Audio: Dwain Hall (02:57:28):

Yeah.

Audio: Calvin Lee (02:57:28):

Okay. And that declined, so y'all never actually showed up?

Audio: Dwain Hall (02:57:33):

Right.

Audio: Calvin Lee (02:57:34):

Did she say where she was wanting to go to, her final destination?

Audio: Dwain Hall (02:57:38):

Did not say.

Audio: Calvin Lee (02:57:39):

Okay.

Audio: Dwain Hall (02:57:40):

She was very, very, very secretive about everything. I don't know.

Audio: Calvin Lee (02:57:46):

Okay. Did she ever provide her name? Does that name Sonia or Sonia Exelby, was that the name she provided?

Audio: Dwain Hall (02:57:56):

Yeah.

Audio: Calvin Lee (02:57:57):

Okay.

Audio: Dwain Hall (02:57:57):

Yeah. Yeah.

Audio: Calvin Lee (02:57:58):

What day was this? Do you remember?

Audio: Dwain Hall (02:58:06):

Not off the top of my head. Maybe Friday evening.

Audio: Calvin Lee (02:58:10):

Friday evening. So it was evening time?

Audio: Dwain Hall (02:58:13):

I think so.

Audio: Calvin Lee (02:58:13):

Okay.

Audio: Dwain Hall (02:58:15):

It was either Friday or Saturday.

Audio: Calvin Lee (02:58:17):

Okay.

Audio: Dwain Hall (02:58:18):

I'm pretty busy. Days tend to blur together.

Audio: Calvin Lee (02:58:21):

Right. And I understand this is a weird phone call you weren't expecting, but we're just trying to track her down.

Audio: Dwain Hall (02:58:27):

Yeah, I don't have any idea.

Audio: Calvin Lee (02:58:30):

Okay. So you never went out there or anything. Do you remember where she said exactly she was, like where her vehicles burnt down at?

Audio: Dwain Hall (02:58:45):

Not exactly.

Audio: Calvin Lee (02:58:47):

Okay.

Audio: Dwain Hall (02:58:47):

Somewhere out around Reddick. It was out of our service area anyway.

Audio: Calvin Lee (02:58:51):

Reddick. So out of your service area?

Audio: Dwain Hall (02:58:53):

Yeah.

Audio: Calvin Lee (02:58:53):

Okay. All right. Well, I appreciate it. You said you're Dwain, right? The owner?

Audio: Dwain Hall (02:59:02):

Yeah.

Audio: Calvin Lee (02:59:03):

Okay. What's your last name, just for my record, so I say I spoke with you?

Audio: Dwain Hall (02:59:08):

Hall, H-A-L-L.

Audio: Calvin Lee (02:59:10):

H-A-L-L. All right. Well, I appreciate it. If you come across or remember anything, this is my cell phone number. If you could just, like I said, if something jogs your memory or anything, if you could give me a call back or shoot me a text, I'd appreciate it.

Audio: Dwain Hall (02:59:26):

All right.

Audio: Calvin Lee (02:59:27):

All right. Have a good one.

Audio: Dwain Hall (02:59:28):

Thanks.

Audio: Calvin Lee (02:59:28):

Bye-bye.

Amy Berndt (02:59:33):

Now I want to direct your attention to the following day, which would be October 14th of 2025, which would be Tuesday. On that date, did Special Agent Rebecca McKenzie attempt to contact Dwain Hall at his residence?

Calvin Lee (02:59:46):

She did, yes.

Amy Berndt (02:59:47):

Okay. Was she successful in contacting him at his residence?

Calvin Lee (02:59:51):

No, she was not.

Amy Berndt (02:59:52):

All right. Did she leave a message for him at his home to contact her?

Calvin Lee (02:59:55):

Yes.

Amy Berndt (02:59:57):

And later that same day, did you speak with Dwain Hall again?

Calvin Lee (03:00:00):

I did.

Amy Berndt (03:00:01):

How did that happen?

Calvin Lee (03:00:03):

Special Agent McKenzie contacted me and said she had spoken with Dwain, that he was, I guess, in the area of the Gainesville field office where I was located at, and that he was willing to stop by and speak with me further about our investigation, so that he was on his way.

Amy Berndt (03:00:23):

All right. So he came to the FDLE Gainesville field office?

Calvin Lee (03:00:24):

Correct.

Amy Berndt (03:00:25):

Do you see the person you know to be Dwain Hall in the courtroom today?

Calvin Lee (03:00:28):

I do.

Amy Berndt (03:00:29):

Can you please point to him and describe something he's wearing?

Calvin Lee (03:00:31):

He's wearing the purple shirt right here with his hands folded.

Amy Berndt (03:00:34):

Your Honor, may the record reflect the witness has identified the defendant?

Timothy McCourt (03:00:39):

Without objection, the record will so reflect the witness identified the defendant.

Amy Berndt (03:00:42):

And so did you interview the defendant again once he came to the Gainesville field office?

Calvin Lee (03:00:46):

I did.

Amy Berndt (03:00:46):

Was it recorded?

Calvin Lee (03:00:48):

It was audio recorded.

Amy Berndt (03:00:49):

So there was no video, it was just audio?

Calvin Lee (03:00:51):

Just audio.

Amy Berndt (03:00:52):

Did you attempt to get more information about his interactions with Sonia Exelby during this interview?

Calvin Lee (03:00:56):

Yes, I was. I was trying to determine a better timeline of her movements that we knew of.

Amy Berndt (03:01:03):

Was anyone else present with you during this interview?

Calvin Lee (03:01:06):

Yes.

Amy Berndt (03:01:06):

Who was that?

Calvin Lee (03:01:08):

It was crime intelligence analyst, Kendall Osteen, that's assigned to the Gainesville field office.

Amy Berndt (03:01:13):

Your Honor, may I approach the witness?

Timothy McCourt (03:01:15):

Yes, ma'am.

Amy Berndt (03:01:19):

I'm going to show you what's been marked for identification as State's Exhibit N, as in Nancy. You can tell me, do you recognize that?

Calvin Lee (03:01:26):

Yes. How

Amy Berndt (03:01:26):

Do you recognize it?

Calvin Lee (03:01:28):

This is the disk with the recording of my interview with Dwain Hall on October 14th, 2025, and it has my initial CL and the date 10/27/2026 showing that I've reviewed this disk.

Amy Berndt (03:01:43):

Is that a fair and accurate depiction of the relevant portions of your interview with the defendant on October 14th, 2025?

Calvin Lee (03:01:48):

Yes, it is.

Amy Berndt (03:01:49):

Your Honor, at this time we move State's Exhibit N into evidence.

Speaker 11 (03:01:51):

No objection, Judge.

Timothy McCourt (03:01:53):

Without objection, what's been marked for identification as State's Exhibit N will be admitted into evidence as State's Exhibit 13.

Amy Berndt (03:02:00):

Now, the beginning of this recording kind of starts mid-sentence. Why is that?

Calvin Lee (03:02:04):

When I made contact with Mr. Hall outside of our office secure facility and I was showing him in, he was immediately started talking about why he was there and our investigation. So instead of interrupting him, I just started recording as soon as we got into the interview room.

Amy Berndt (03:02:22):

And, Your Honor, I would ask to publish, but if you could read the edited recording instruction before we publish.

Timothy McCourt (03:02:25):

Yes. Members of the jury, you're about to listen to an audio recording. The court instructs you that the recording has been edited to eliminate irrelevant portions that would not add to your understanding of this case. The fact that the recording has been edited should not concern you in any way and must not impact the way you listen to and consider this evidence.

Amy Berndt (03:02:44):

Thank you.

Audio: Dwain Hall (03:02:54):

They're gone.

Audio: Calvin Lee (03:02:55):

They're gone.

Audio: Dwain Hall (03:02:56):

The call logs are fucking gone.

Audio: Calvin Lee (03:02:58):

Okay.

Audio: Dwain Hall (03:02:59):

There's a whole bunch of stuff from this weekend that's just missing out of my call logs.

Audio: Calvin Lee (03:03:04):

All right. So let's just, from the start-

Audio: Dwain Hall (03:03:08):

From the start. Tell me what you need. Ask your questions. Okay. Pause and then we can continue. Okay? All I'm going to say is be direct with your questions.

Audio: Calvin Lee (03:03:17):

Yes.

Audio: Dwain Hall (03:03:17):

You're going to get a direct answer.

Audio: Calvin Lee (03:03:19):

Yeah.

Audio: Dwain Hall (03:03:19):

I don't appreciate sneaky shit and I'll just show it.

Audio: Calvin Lee (03:03:22):

Yeah.

Audio: Dwain Hall (03:03:23):

I don't appreciate that shit.

Audio: Calvin Lee (03:03:24):

I'm not here to try to trick you for anything. We are not looking at you like it's a suspect, if that's what you're thinking.

Audio: Dwain Hall (03:03:30):

Yeah, that's exactly what I'm thinking.

Audio: Calvin Lee (03:03:32):

Okay. We would probably do things a little bit differently if that was the case.

Audio: Dwain Hall (03:03:35):

All right.

Audio: Calvin Lee (03:03:35):

Okay.

Audio: Dwain Hall (03:03:37):

Then let's keep this.

Audio: Calvin Lee (03:03:38):

I'll let you know what-

Audio: Dwain Hall (03:03:39):

From one businessman to law enforcement, from a businessman who works with law enforcement.

Audio: Calvin Lee (03:03:44):

Right.

Audio: Dwain Hall (03:03:44):

That's why I'm telling you this. Just be direct, you will get direct.

Audio: Calvin Lee (03:03:48):

Right. And with this, it's very frustrating for us working this because we're having to deal with the UK.

Audio: Dwain Hall (03:03:55):

Yeah, it's happening in the UK.

Audio: Calvin Lee (03:03:57):

So what we have that started yesterday was an email request from Interpol.

Audio: Dwain Hall (03:04:03):

Sorry, sorry. It's from old school days.

Audio: Calvin Lee (03:04:06):

Right. Saying that this girl was missing. She was reported missing in the UK, supposedly from her boyfriend. She's suicidal and that they last found where she landed in Gainesville last week and then-

Audio: Dwain Hall (03:04:25):

That's what you were saying.

Audio: Calvin Lee (03:04:26):

Right. Through banking records, that's how you came up. They said through her banking records, there was a declined payment.

Audio: Dwain Hall (03:04:33):

Yeah, there was a declined payment.

Audio: Calvin Lee (03:04:36):

Okay.

Audio: Dwain Hall (03:04:36):

She sounded absolutely fucking panicked. I couldn't hear what was actually going on in the background, but she kept saying, "I swear there's money on the card. I swear. I swear."

Audio: Calvin Lee (03:04:47):

Okay.

Audio: Dwain Hall (03:04:48):

It was really stupid suspicious, and it was at night and I wasn't trying to...

Audio: Calvin Lee (03:04:53):

Okay. What we are doing and the whole point of this is building a better timeline because we're about a day behind on everything that we-

Audio: Dwain Hall (03:05:00):

A day ahead on everything.

Audio: Calvin Lee (03:05:04):

Right. And that's why we're trying to get the specifics with this. So help me understand. You have the roadside assistance.

Audio: Dwain Hall (03:05:13):

I'm the owner of Solver Wolf's Roadside Assistance.

Audio: Calvin Lee (03:05:16):

Okay. Right.

Audio: Dwain Hall (03:05:16):

Yes.

Audio: Calvin Lee (03:05:16):

So how does it work? Walk me through the process for this process. How does it work normally for somebody to call you?

Audio: Dwain Hall (03:05:25):

Just like you would think. Just like you would think. In her case, she's a foreigner. She could have found my number. I am on Yelp. She could have found my number on Yelp. Even though the area that she said she was in is out of our service area, we still were probably pinged and it was pretty late at night.

Audio: Calvin Lee (03:05:47):

Okay.

Audio: Dwain Hall (03:05:47):

So I mean, late at night for me, I'm 53 years old and I work my ass off all day.

Audio: Calvin Lee (03:05:49):

Sun was down at least, right?

Audio: Dwain Hall (03:05:51):

The sun was fucking down, man. And I typically don't drive at night if I can at all help it.

Audio: Calvin Lee (03:05:56):

Okay.

Audio: Dwain Hall (03:05:58):

Just because I'm getting old and I can't see shit no more.

Audio: Calvin Lee (03:06:02):

So do you remember specifically what she said her issue was?

Audio: Dwain Hall (03:06:07):

I don't remember. I'll be honest with you, I don't remember. I just remember she called and she wanted help with her vehicle.

Audio: Calvin Lee (03:06:13):

Did she ever describe what kind of vehicle? Do you remember?

Audio: Dwain Hall (03:06:16):

There was no description of a vehicle. It's so brief with me. I won't give you a good example. Hey, I need help with my vehicle. I answered the phone. "Hey, this is Dwain Solver Wolf's roadside." "Oh, good, good. I need help with my vehicle. I'm over here..." Most cases is how they do it. "I'm over here by Lowe's." "Okay. What do you need help with? All right. How do you intend to pay? All right, let me get that card number." I'll run the card number and it's going to tell me right then and there whether or not it's declined. She tried to pay an exorbitant amount for what I was trying to help her with.

Audio: Calvin Lee (03:06:53):

Yeah, because it was around $700.

Audio: Dwain Hall (03:06:55):

Yeah, it was around $700.

Audio: Calvin Lee (03:06:55):

Okay.

Audio: Dwain Hall (03:06:57):

And I ran it and I was like, "You know what? I don't give a shit. It's the middle of the night. It's out of my service area. I don't really want to do it. If you want to give me $700, that's a week's pay to come change your tire, look at your car." Because we do all kinds of stuff. We change tires, we do batteries, we do part spark repair, we do repairs, onsite repairs.

Audio: Calvin Lee (03:07:15):

But you don't remember specifically what she said was wrong?

Audio: Dwain Hall (03:07:18):

No, not specifically. Not specifically.

Audio: Calvin Lee (03:07:21):

And then is there a call-out fee for you after hours or is it just one lump sum?

Audio: Dwain Hall (03:07:27):

It's usually one lump sum. What we normally charge during regular business hours when it's me with the sign-up and I'm not going out after night, typically in service area calls are only $25.

Audio: Calvin Lee (03:07:37):

Just to get there?

Audio: Dwain Hall (03:07:41):

No, 25 period. Now, if you tell me you need repairs done, we're going to jump that up. Depending on the repair that needs done, it could be a hundred with the $25 rolled in because we don't do anything that takes longer than 45 minutes. If it takes longer than 45 minutes, one, we're probably not going to do it. Two, we're going to double our rate. So I've never charged anybody over $150.

Audio: Calvin Lee (03:08:07):

So how did the $700 come? How did they get that number?

Audio: Dwain Hall (03:08:10):

She said that she'd give me X number of dollars because I tried to refuse. It's after hours, she's out of my service area. "Please, I can give you $700 to come out here and help me."

Audio: Calvin Lee (03:08:20):

Okay.

Audio: Dwain Hall (03:08:20):

All right, whatever. Like I said, that's over a week's pay for me.

Audio: Calvin Lee (03:08:24):

All right.

Audio: Dwain Hall (03:08:26):

And then she kept swearing, they kept declining and she kept swearing, "There's money. There's money. I have money. There's money. I'll pay you. Come get me," or something along those lines.

Audio: Calvin Lee (03:08:35):

So when they pay you, you say you run it, how do you run it?

Audio: Dwain Hall (03:08:40):

I have a business banking app.

Audio: Calvin Lee (03:08:43):

Okay. So is it on your phone?

Audio: Dwain Hall (03:08:45):

Yeah, something like Square.

Audio: Calvin Lee (03:08:46):

Okay. Are you able to access that and tell me the credit card number she gave you that declined?

Audio: Dwain Hall (03:08:52):

I cannot tell you the declines numbers. I can't even tell you a good example. Okay? I mean, I'll kind of show you, but mind you, this is business and confidential.

Audio: Calvin Lee (03:09:03):

That's what this is. I don't care about anything.

Audio: Dwain Hall (03:09:04):

This is voluntary. This is something you'd normally need a warrant for because it being tied to a business.

Audio: Calvin Lee (03:09:11):

So what is your business account then?

Audio: Dwain Hall (03:09:14):

I will pull this up.

Audio: Calvin Lee (03:09:16):

Because I'll just go do is I'll do a subpoena.

Audio: Dwain Hall (03:09:17):

I'll pull this up. It's like this, and I'm cooperating with you, so you ain't accurate.

Audio: Calvin Lee (03:09:22):

I understand that, but I'm just-

Audio: Dwain Hall (03:09:23):

But if this will actually load, because you have absolutely zero service here.

Audio: Calvin Lee (03:09:27):

Talech? Is that the name of the brand?

Audio: Dwain Hall (03:09:30):

That's just the name of the processing company.

Audio: Calvin Lee (03:09:32):

Okay.

Audio: Dwain Hall (03:09:33):

Okay. And yeah, if it'll pull up, you got Wi-Fi or can we step somewhere where I can get service?

Audio: Calvin Lee (03:09:40):

Do you have public Wi-Fi?

Speaker 12 (03:09:42):

No.

Audio: Calvin Lee (03:09:43):

We'd have to step outside.

Audio: Dwain Hall (03:09:44):

Do you mind?

Audio: Calvin Lee (03:09:45):

No.

Audio: Dwain Hall (03:09:45):

Because like I said, I'll happily show you and I'll show you how it comes up. Once we run the card, this is one of them secure things where once we run a card, it deletes all that information. Still with me?

Audio: Calvin Lee (03:10:02):

Yeah. It's these metal roofs.

Audio: Dwain Hall (03:10:08):

Yeah. Yeah, exactly. Okay. So we're going to shut it off and we'll try to reload it here.

Audio: Calvin Lee (03:10:15):

Are you able to at least tell me the date and time that... Will it show me the date and time it was ran?

Audio: Dwain Hall (03:10:21):

Decline calls typically don't show up, but if you let me work with the system a minute, I might be able to-

Audio: Calvin Lee (03:10:26):

I'm asking because I don't know. So what I'm looking for is-

Audio: Dwain Hall (03:10:28):

No, no, no. Absolutely.

Audio: Calvin Lee (03:10:28):

We're timelining here.

Audio: Dwain Hall (03:10:31):

And I'm trying to help you out as much as I can.

Audio: Calvin Lee (03:10:33):

Yeah, I understand.

Audio: Dwain Hall (03:10:33):

If there's a missing person that called my company and I run a respectable God damn company, I worked my off to get to this position.

Audio: Calvin Lee (03:10:40):

Yeah.

Audio: Dwain Hall (03:10:41):

It's not one. [inaudible 03:10:42]

Audio: Calvin Lee (03:10:41):

Well, I mean, they're calling for a reason. I mean, they obviously needed help and you got a business to run. We get that, but I'm not wanting to know insides and outs. It's just specifically to her. If it helps me do the timeline-

Audio: Dwain Hall (03:10:54):

Yeah, that's what I'm saying. I don't know why this isn't loading.

Audio: Calvin Lee (03:10:59):

We might need to get out of the metal building.

Audio: Dwain Hall (03:11:02):

You guys are already tagging up on my phone, man.

Audio: Calvin Lee (03:11:05):

I wish it was that easy.

Audio: Dwain Hall (03:11:06):

Man, I'm going to tell you right now, I'm going to tell you though, last night... No, it's even worse over here. I need public Wi-Fi. You got a hotspot on your phone? If you got service on your phone and you got a hotspot, I can do it that way too. Because like I said, I'm trying to help you guys out as much as possible.

Audio: Calvin Lee (03:11:24):

Yeah, yeah, yeah.

Audio: Dwain Hall (03:11:25):

But yeah, something real wonky happened last night too after I got done talking to you guys. The GPS, it started spinning like mad and then it pinged me up here on Archer Road and I was in Alachua. Yeah, I was down by my house in Alachua. God-damn it. No, it's not. I have no service. I don't know what the hell is up with this. It's hotspot.

Audio: Calvin Lee (03:11:48):

I have hotspot on.

Audio: Dwain Hall (03:11:50):

Okay. Let's see if I can find you here.

Audio: Calvin Lee (03:11:52):

Should say like Galaxy S22.

Audio: Dwain Hall (03:11:54):

Galaxy S22. It's scanning for next words. S2266 something something. You got a password?

Audio: Calvin Lee (03:12:01):

Y-A-Z-M 8480.

Audio: Dwain Hall (03:12:06):

8480.

Audio: Calvin Lee (03:12:11):

Yep. There's you. Shows your connection.

Audio: Dwain Hall (03:12:12):

Yep.

Audio: Calvin Lee (03:12:19):

And so we're not sitting outside. We could probably go back in there since you're just hotspotting off of this because I have service.

Audio: Dwain Hall (03:12:26):

No, if it'll actually freaking load, like I said, I'll go through it and see if I can find it, but typically it's not loading whatsoever today. Normally we program these things in and once we program them in, even if they pay, they actually drop the card number and everything else. It's just gone and it's replaced with a four or five digit code.

Audio: Calvin Lee (03:12:48):

Okay. So how does that work with your business keeping your records keeping and stuff?

Audio: Dwain Hall (03:12:54):

It just shows stuff coming in. It's on us to keep up with it as to where it came from and whatnot. I also use another thing called Towbook. I don't have a laptop here. I could log into it or whatnot because it couldn't log in. There's a problem. All right. So it took me back here. Try this again. Sit down here and let her go. What the hell? Okay. Set it down and let it go. God dammit it. Something went wrong. Close every damn thing. So yeah, basically we use this company and they are the processing company for everything. And when that happened, if something went wrong, it's not letting me log in whatsoever. I'm going to drop your hotspot if that's all right with you.

Audio: Calvin Lee (03:13:49):

Yep.

Audio: Dwain Hall (03:13:56):

Okay. We're going to try it again here. We'll just let it sit here and spin until it loads up or something.

Audio: Calvin Lee (03:14:00):

Who's your service provider for...

Audio: Dwain Hall (03:14:00):

Verizon.

Audio: Calvin Lee (03:14:06):

Okay. Do you have Verizon?

Speaker 12 (03:14:08):

Yes.

Audio: Calvin Lee (03:14:08):

Okay.

Audio: Dwain Hall (03:14:11):

It says something went wrong and it's absolutely just not letting me in. Like I said, these weird coincidences with my phone started happening this past weekend around Sunday. Because some of the business stuff that I'd had on Sunday that should have left a digital record are erased. They're gone. I didn't erase them.

Audio: Calvin Lee (03:14:32):

And so your call logs, you said those are gone?

Audio: Dwain Hall (03:14:36):

Not all of them.

Audio: Calvin Lee (03:14:36):

Okay.

Audio: Dwain Hall (03:14:39):

But if I go here to recents and there are certain numbers that should pop up from... See, I'm on the phone with all kinds of people all day, every day, and that was Monday or whatever. And then I get all... Look how many calls I get. Okay? Sunday. Okay. There are calls missing. There are calls missing. There are calls that happened before noon from about eight o'clock on that are gone. Same thing for, well, I guess-

Audio: Calvin Lee (03:15:12):

And that' Saturday.

Audio: Dwain Hall (03:15:12):

Saturday.

Audio: Calvin Lee (03:15:13):

At night.

Audio: Dwain Hall (03:15:14):

Yeah. I had calls all day. They're gone.

Audio: Calvin Lee (03:15:18):

I'm going to grab that number there real quick just because-

Audio: Dwain Hall (03:15:20):

Whoa, whoa, whoa. Which Number?

Audio: Calvin Lee (03:15:20):

The four two six four.

Audio: Dwain Hall (03:15:20):

That's my mom.

Audio: Calvin Lee (03:15:23):

Oh, that's your mom?

Audio: Dwain Hall (03:15:23):

Yeah, that's why I was like, "Whoa, whoa, whoa [inaudible 03:15:25].

Audio: Calvin Lee (03:15:25):

Yeah, I wasn't just grabbing that.

Audio: Dwain Hall (03:15:26):

No, that's my mom.

Audio: Calvin Lee (03:15:28):

Can you go to Friday for me because I'm just trying to see if there's a weird number that popped up that she called.

Audio: Dwain Hall (03:15:33):

They're gone.

Audio: Calvin Lee (03:15:35):

So you know who this LA number is?

Audio: Dwain Hall (03:15:38):

That was a client. That was a client, that's a student. If I'm not mistaken, that was a student. But yeah, pretty much everything on there is all students except for the weird telemarketers that are the 330s. And on Sunday, I should have had a slew of the 330s. They're just gone. I can show you in here almost every day where I'm getting 330 numbers. Well, maybe not every day, but regularly getting, see, that's like today or whatever, coming out of Akron. Calls all day from 330. It's all telemarketers or scammers. And I get down here to Sunday and I have three calls. The rest of them is gone.

Audio: Calvin Lee (03:16:20):

So you didn't complete an invoice or anything like that for this call?

Audio: Dwain Hall (03:16:26):

No, no, nope. Nope. First thing we do in a situation like that, like I said, primarily A, you're out of our service area. B, sketchy as shit. C, card declined. I'm not even going to start an invoice. As a matter of fact, when we do call, those are called cash calls.

Audio: Calvin Lee (03:16:45):

This is how you run your... I'm not the business police.

Audio: Dwain Hall (03:16:49):

Well, like I said, I don't keep invoices for cash calls anyway because I feel like we'll turn that in at the end of the year as undisclosed income and my CPA will go get my... I'll print him out 12 pages of my income for that month and he'll figure out my taxes.

Audio: Calvin Lee (03:17:04):

So she offered around $700. That's what she offered.

Audio: Dwain Hall (03:17:08):

She offered 700. Yeah. No, I'd never say that because like I said, it was weird because she tried to get that and she had me run it for lower and lower amounts. I think it was seven, six and then a hundred and it all declined and I'm like, "I'm sorry, ma'am. It declined. I can't help you."

Audio: Calvin Lee (03:17:26):

Card declined. Okay. Yesterday on the phone you told me that she said something about trying to get to her final destination.

Audio: Dwain Hall (03:17:39):

Okay. The conversation never got-

Audio: Calvin Lee (03:17:42):

Explain that to me.

Audio: Dwain Hall (03:17:44):

She never explained that either. She just said, "I have somewhere, I need to be there."

Audio: Calvin Lee (03:17:49):

Okay. So it wasn't like, "Hey, can you get me to Miami?" Or something like as direct as that?

Audio: Dwain Hall (03:17:54):

Now, if I'd have showed up or something, that might've been something more along those lines.

Audio: Calvin Lee (03:17:58):

Okay.

Audio: Dwain Hall (03:18:00):

But the GPS where I had her at was-

Audio: Dwain Hall (03:18:00):

... but the GPS where I had her at was-

Audio: Calvin Lee (03:18:05):

Where did she say?

Audio: Dwain Hall (03:18:07):

I don't have an exact... She didn't have an exact location. If I remember right... What is that? You're going down the interstate here, exit 368. What is that road right there?

Audio: Calvin Lee (03:18:19):

368. I don't realize, not off the top of my head.

Audio: Dwain Hall (03:18:21):

That exit 368, whatever exit that is, there's a road that's right there. She was on that road about a mile or two from the interstate.

Audio: Calvin Lee (03:18:31):

So either in Micanopy or around that area, does that sound about right?

Audio: Dwain Hall (03:18:36):

Micanopy is 374.

Audio: Calvin Lee (03:18:36):

Okay. So it's south of that.

Audio: Dwain Hall (03:18:40):

Like I said, it was closer to Reddick.

Audio: Calvin Lee (03:18:42):

Okay.

Audio: Dwain Hall (03:18:42):

It was down in there around the Reddick area. Our service quits at exit 358 and don't pick up again until about 374. It's a little further north technically but... And I don't even have anybody down there running Ocala right now. I closed it the fuck down because it went so bad down there business-wise that I couldn't afford to pay anybody to keep it open down there.

Audio: Calvin Lee (03:19:08):

Okay. So y'all determined she was around the 368 area?

Audio: Dwain Hall (03:19:12):

Exit 368 was within about a mile or two of the interstate is where I had her at based on what she was trying to describe to me. Because that's the first thing I asked basically under normal circumstance is, "Okay, what kind of vehicle you got and where are you?"

Audio: Calvin Lee (03:19:30):

Okay. Do you remember what she said about as far as the vehicle?

Audio: Dwain Hall (03:19:35):

You know, I can't really remember off the top of my head. Like I said, I had a lot going on that I was tired already, tired of shit already. I didn't want to be on the phone, so I wasn't even taking it too serious, especially after the card declined.

Audio: Calvin Lee (03:19:50):

Are you sole owner or owner operator?

Audio: Dwain Hall (03:19:52):

Sole owner, operator. I do have one employee though, and he doesn't work that late at night neither. And he definitely does not work on the weekends because it's the only time he has his kids.

Audio: Calvin Lee (03:20:01):

Okay. So try to think. I know when we talked about yesterday, you said nighttime, it might've been Friday or it might've been Saturday, so having to think about -

Audio: Dwain Hall (03:20:15):

I'm thinking Friday was not the day. I'm thinking it was Saturday.

Audio: Calvin Lee (03:20:17):

Okay.

Audio: Dwain Hall (03:20:18):

I'm thinking it was Saturday.

Audio: Calvin Lee (03:20:23):

Okay. But we know at least timeframe the sun was down, so was in the evening time.

Audio: Dwain Hall (03:20:27):

It was later than I work and it was out of my service area on a Saturday night. And nothing good happens after night and when the sun goes down on the weekend. They're either drunk or aggressive and I don't like dealing with either one of them at my age. And plus I just had a car accident not too long ago up here in Gainesville and my back is all kind of switched up. I want to be on my muscle relaxers and I want to be asleep at that time of night.

Audio: Calvin Lee (03:20:54):

Right.

Audio: Dwain Hall (03:20:54):

That's another reason why things are a little bit hazy and a little bit foggy and I don't know. I'm drugged up and ready to go, done for the day, lay on the heat pad or the ice block or whatever the heck it's going to be that's going to make me feel better.

Audio: Calvin Lee (03:21:12):

All right.

Audio: Dwain Hall (03:21:12):

I'm pretty sure that was in fact Saturday night.

Audio: Calvin Lee (03:21:20):

Kendall, is there anything-

Audio: Dwain Hall (03:21:25):

Just ask away. It's the only way we're going to get to the bottom of this shit.

Audio: Calvin Lee (03:21:29):

Right. Yeah. I'm just trying to... I don't want to keep bothering you any more than I have to. So I'm just trying to make sure that we're covering everything that we need because like I said, the biggest thing we're trying to figure out is A, because we don't know what vehicle she's in, and we don't-

Audio: Dwain Hall (03:21:45):

I got the sense that it was a smaller vehicle, like maybe a small sedan of some kind.

Audio: Calvin Lee (03:21:51):

Okay. What makes you think that?

Audio: Dwain Hall (03:21:54):

Because it's a woman and it's a rental.

Audio: Calvin Lee (03:21:58):

She told you it was a rental?

Audio: Dwain Hall (03:22:00):

No, but if she came here from somewhere else, that's just making an educated guess based on what you've told me, that she flew in. She's from the UK. She's not going to have her own vehicle here. She had to have picked up a rental somewhere and that rental more than likely would be a small sedan.

Audio: Calvin Lee (03:22:20):

Other than normal big name rental companies, do you know of any other rental company because they do not have her in her system unless she's using a fake name or something, but there's nothing in her banking account of-

Audio: Dwain Hall (03:22:34):

Maybe she brought-

Audio: Calvin Lee (03:22:35):

... getting rentals.

Audio: Dwain Hall (03:22:37):

Maybe she brought cash.

Audio: Calvin Lee (03:22:38):

I've traveled all over-

Audio: Dwain Hall (03:22:39):

No, you know what? You can't rent a car without having a credit card of some kind.

Audio: Calvin Lee (03:22:43):

Right.

Audio: Dwain Hall (03:22:45):

You know what? I don't know.

Audio: Calvin Lee (03:22:46):

We've already been to the airport and everything and done all that.

Audio: Dwain Hall (03:22:48):

You have?. Trying to figure it out, huh? No, man. It keeps just putting me back on this screen. Basically, if I could get into this, what it does is I have my charge history. I have open accounts and I have closed accounts. Now I've done already tried to do some homework for you so I could try to get back with you, but there's nothing there. My open accounts, obviously because it's declined, it's not going to be there. My closed accounts are only things that's been paid, so it's not there neither.

Audio: Calvin Lee (03:23:15):

Okay.

Audio: Dwain Hall (03:23:16):

And then I tried to check and see if I had any history of things that have run, and because of the way security runs with this company, it's deleted immediately. Like soon as I close out the invoice or whatever, it's gone.

Audio: Calvin Lee (03:23:28):

And there might be something on the back end with the company.

Audio: Dwain Hall (03:23:31):

There might be.

Audio: Calvin Lee (03:23:33):

Do you mind giving me your email? Because it's associated to your email, so I'm going to have to subpoena those records through this company and subpoena this through the company, and it's going to be based off of your name or email or phone number.

Audio: Dwain Hall (03:23:48):

Okay. I mean I-

Audio: Calvin Lee (03:23:50):

I have your name in your phone-

Audio: Dwain Hall (03:23:51):

I kind of don't really fucking like you poking around in my business, but at the same time, if it closes this shit up and gets it closed-

Audio: Calvin Lee (03:23:57):

Well, I'm not poking around. I mean, all I care about is trying to get this timeframe, so if there is something that shows me through the company that shows me like, "Hey, on this date and time," that way I can sit here and say, "On this date and time, she was speaking to him based off of the records when he tried to run this at the client." That's all I'm trying to look for.

Audio: Dwain Hall (03:24:15):

Okay.

Audio: Calvin Lee (03:24:16):

That's all I want is because I'm building my timeframe.

Audio: Dwain Hall (03:24:18):

Yeah, you just understand though-

Audio: Calvin Lee (03:24:20):

Right. I get it. Nobody trusts the government. Personally, I don't give a shit about that right now. I care about a missing girl. This is our first time ever meeting.

Audio: Dwain Hall (03:24:29):

This is fucking awesome, so don't mention that-

Audio: Calvin Lee (03:24:32):

I understand that. It helps me make it easier.

Audio: Dwain Hall (03:24:33):

Darkwolf.

Audio: Calvin Lee (03:24:36):

Darkwolf?

Audio: Dwain Hall (03:24:36):

Mm-hmm. D-A-R-K.

Audio: Calvin Lee (03:24:38):

I can't spell here.

Audio: Dwain Hall (03:24:40):

Wolf, W-O-L-F, 44646@gmail.

Audio: Calvin Lee (03:24:45):

446-

Audio: Dwain Hall (03:24:45):

44646@gmail.

Audio: Calvin Lee (03:24:45):

@gmail. Okay.

Audio: Dwain Hall (03:24:47):

All right. I gave you my disclaimer.

Audio: Calvin Lee (03:24:52):

Yeah.

Audio: Dwain Hall (03:24:53):

All right?

Audio: Calvin Lee (03:24:53):

I understand.

Audio: Dwain Hall (03:24:54):

You have my full cooperation in trying to figure this shit out, but at the same fucking time, I don't have a great issue with this.

Audio: Calvin Lee (03:25:02):

But what's going to happen to do is I'm going to reach out to this company. I'm going to say, "Hey."

Audio: Dwain Hall (03:25:06):

Hang on. Let me see if it'll pull something else up here. It's just terms and service, blah, blah, blah, blah, blah. Share third party. Attention. Yeah. Okay. T-A-L-E-C-H.com at support@...

Audio: Calvin Lee (03:25:38):

Yeah.

Audio: Dwain Hall (03:25:38):

If you want to, that way you know who you're trying to deal with. Here is any information regarding them right there.

Audio: Calvin Lee (03:25:46):

Okay. Yeah, we can get all that because we have the database.

Audio: Dwain Hall (03:25:49):

Like I said, whatever helps you guys out.

Audio: Calvin Lee (03:25:52):

Sir, what I'm going to be doing is I'm going to be subpoenaing the records of like, "Hey," and specifically asking for declined payments on this date or this date. I know it's either got to be Friday-

Audio: Dwain Hall (03:26:05):

It's either got to be Friday-

Audio: Calvin Lee (03:26:05):

... or Saturday.

Audio: Dwain Hall (03:26:07):

.. or Saturday.

Audio: Calvin Lee (03:26:07):

I'm looking specifically for one thing.

Audio: Dwain Hall (03:26:10):

I'm thinking Saturday. I'm honestly thinking Saturday because I wasn't doing any dispatching that evening, so I was already hip deep in some muscle relaxers because Fridays I'm open until 9:00 PM in Gainesville and I have to dispatch the calls because you know how it is, a small business you wear all the hats. I wouldn't have been on anything-

Audio: Calvin Lee (03:26:37):

I mean, we already know the amount because we have part of her banking agreement.

Audio: Dwain Hall (03:26:42):

Like I said, I think we went to... I think there was seven, six and maybe 100, 700, 600, maybe 100. And she kept offering these different amounts. Try it again, try it again. I will tell you, she seemed super fucking desperate and my impression was she wasn't alone because she kept swearing up and down that there was money there and she seemed way too nervous to just be broke down. I deal with a lot of college age kids that don't know the first thing about the first thing of nothing and they break down and they break down in an unfamiliar area. There's a different nervousness. I've heard people on the phone, that's what I do, that's what I've been doing for a living for a decade now.

Audio: Calvin Lee (03:27:32):

Recalling back to those phone calls, could you hear anybody? Did it sound like anybody was there?

Audio: Dwain Hall (03:27:37):

I couldn't hear nothing. There was nobody there. It was too damn quiet to-

Audio: Calvin Lee (03:27:38):

But just how she was acting.

Audio: Dwain Hall (03:27:39):

It was too quiet for being broke down, literally broke down on the side of the road. Okay? Way too quiet. I didn't hear crickets, man. There was no sound. There was no motor noise. That's the other thing. There was no motor noise. There was no crickets or nothing like that. Natural ambient sound that you would hear from somebody sitting in a dead car.

Audio: Calvin Lee (03:27:57):

Like you sitting on the side of the interstate and hearing semis blow by or anything like that.

Audio: Dwain Hall (03:28:01):

Yeah. There was none of that because you're going to hear them semis at 10 o'clock at night. It's about all you're going to hear is the commercial vehicles. It was just too damn quiet.

Audio: Calvin Lee (03:28:11):

Okay.

Audio: Dwain Hall (03:28:11):

And that keyed in my immediately, that's some fuckery. I need to steer clear of it.

Audio: Calvin Lee (03:28:17):

Okay. Now what would've happened if the money went through? Would you have-

Audio: Dwain Hall (03:28:21):

I showed up. I showed up. You're paying me. I've showed up and I'd have been... I'd have been armed. I'd have been armed. We have an open carry law here. I don't fuck around with shit like that, especially at night anyway. Yeah, that had all my danger sense tingling there.

Audio: Calvin Lee (03:28:39):

Do you still have my phone number in there?

Audio: Dwain Hall (03:28:41):

You know what? I would not be able to find that.

Audio: Calvin Lee (03:28:44):

I'll get you my card before I leave.

Audio: Dwain Hall (03:28:46):

Yeah, absolutely.

Audio: Calvin Lee (03:28:48):

If you can get that back up or if something comes up and you find something-

Audio: Dwain Hall (03:28:50):

I'm just going to show you how that normally runs and how that normally works because there's nothing there. If a card doesn't decline, for some reason, it doesn't keep a record of it here. Okay? So it's card decline. It's gone. It's like it never happened.

Audio: Calvin Lee (03:29:07):

Well, if you get to messing around with it and come across that, you'll at least have my number.

Audio: Dwain Hall (03:29:10):

I'll screenshot it and happily send it to you.

Audio: Calvin Lee (03:29:11):

Yeah, you can text my number.

Audio: Dwain Hall (03:29:12):

I mean, you're going to subpoena it anyway, so you're probably going to find it before I am.

Audio: Calvin Lee (03:29:16):

If I can get away from it, because I'm dealing with major businesses here, sometimes they take longer than we would like for them to take.

Audio: Dwain Hall (03:29:22):

Well, they got to protect their clients too.

Audio: Calvin Lee (03:29:25):

Yeah, I understand.

Audio: Dwain Hall (03:29:26):

They got to make sure everything's on the up and up.

Audio: Calvin Lee (03:29:28):

And it's nothing for me to-

Audio: Dwain Hall (03:29:29):

Especially in my line of work. I don't even tell shops half the time who I've serviced and who I haven't serviced unless I'm already there. Like if you came to me and said, "Hey, I need you to service my car. I broke down on the side of the road." I get there and I have to make a repair to make it so you can safely get to the garage and you're talking to the garage while I'm there. I'll say, "Hey, let me talk to them for you." And then I'll tell them everything I did. And that's the end of it. And that's only because you were right there with me because I kind of take y'all's privacy kind of serious because I'm going to get sued for violation of privacy in some fucked up way.

Audio: Calvin Lee (03:30:07):

Right.

Audio: Dwain Hall (03:30:07):

I'm a small business. I can't afford that shit.

Audio: Calvin Lee (03:30:09):

I understand. I understand. Well, you got anything else, Kendall, that you-

Audio: Dwain Hall (03:30:14):

Do you need anything else from me today?

Audio: Calvin Lee (03:30:16):

No. Nope. I think that's it. Hopefully this will be the end of it, of having to bother you with it.

Audio: Dwain Hall (03:30:23):

Look here. I know damn good and well that ain't going to be the end of it.

Audio: Calvin Lee (03:30:26):

Well, I hope... Hopefully it is, but yeah. Hopefully we find her down the road somewhere and she's fine. And this is just the whole... Because unfortunately we have it all the time where-

Audio: Dwain Hall (03:30:36):

If they're suicidal though, you never know where the fuck they might have ended up, with who?

Audio: Calvin Lee (03:30:42):

You never know.

Audio: Dwain Hall (03:30:43):

We are in Florida.

Audio: Calvin Lee (03:30:44):

We can't get a... The bad thing is, we're having to deal with a whole nother country, not another state, a whole nother country. Their law enforcement over there is different than how we do business here.

Audio: Dwain Hall (03:30:54):

Their law enforcement over there is shit.

Audio: Calvin Lee (03:30:56):

Right.

Audio: Dwain Hall (03:30:56):

I'll take you guys over them any day.

Audio: Calvin Lee (03:30:57):

Yeah, so we're having to manage that. I mean, and a lot of this stuff is, like I said, it's coming through them through Interpol, through an email on a... So it's not like I can -

Audio: Dwain Hall (03:31:08):

Telephone. You know, the child game telephone?

Audio: Calvin Lee (03:31:11):

Well, I wish I had a... They would pick up the phone and I could ask them direct questions and get direct answers. They don't do that.

Audio: Dwain Hall (03:31:17):

You have to catch him at like 2:00 in the morning to talk to them directly.

Audio: Calvin Lee (03:31:20):

Let me get you my card real quick, just so you have that and we'll get you out of here.

Audio: Dwain Hall (03:31:26):

Yeah, but you guys need anything. I'm kind of finicky about you just going through my records.

Audio: Calvin Lee (03:31:34):

And I know that they were down there because we're kind of working this jointly, and I think they just stopped by there because they were down there.

Audio: Dwain Hall (03:31:41):

Okay.

Speaker 13 (03:31:46):

When the defendant left your field office in Gainesville, were you able to see what kind of car he was driving?

Speaker 14 (03:31:51):

Yes, I was.

Speaker 13 (03:31:52):

Can you tell the jury what kind of car it was?

Speaker 14 (03:31:54):

It was a black Jeep Cherokee and it was missing the rear bumper and had in big letters on the back window emergency roadside. And then I was able to get the tag number as well.

Speaker 13 (03:32:07):

Your Honor, may I approach?

Judge Timothy McCourt (03:32:08):

Yes, ma'am.

Speaker 13 (03:32:08):

I'm showing you what's been marked for identification as State's Exhibit O. If you can look at those two photographs and tell me if you recognize those.

Speaker 14 (03:32:14):

I do.

Speaker 13 (03:32:14):

What are those?

Speaker 14 (03:32:15):

Those are Dwayne Hall's vehicle that was registered to him, but also that he was driving on the 14th when I interviewed him at my field office.

Speaker 13 (03:32:27):

Those are a fair and accurate depiction of the way's vehicle on October 14th of 2025?

Speaker 14 (03:32:31):

Yes, it is.

Speaker 13 (03:32:32):

Your Honor, at this time we move State's Exhibit O into evidence.

Audio: Calvin Lee (03:32:35):

No objection, Judge.

Judge Timothy McCourt (03:32:36):

Without objection, what's been marked for identification as State's Exhibit O will be admitted into evidence as State's Exhibit 14.

Speaker 13 (03:32:41):

May I publish, Your Honor?

Judge Timothy McCourt (03:32:42):

Yes, ma'am.

Speaker 13 (03:32:45):

And what are we looking at in photograph number one?

Audio: Calvin Lee (03:32:48):

Dwayne Hall's Jeep Cherokee.

Speaker 13 (03:32:50):

Okay. And then photograph number two?

Audio: Calvin Lee (03:32:53):

The same vehicle, his Jeep Cherokee.

Speaker 13 (03:32:55):

And he had this sticker on the back, emergency roadside assistance?

Audio: Calvin Lee (03:32:58):

Yes.

Speaker 13 (03:32:59):

And you had mentioned of something wrong right back here?

Audio: Calvin Lee (03:33:02):

Yeah, their rear bumper was missing.

Speaker 13 (03:33:05):

I don't have any further questions, Your Honor.

Audio: Calvin Lee (03:33:06):

No questions, Judge.

Judge Timothy McCourt (03:33:08):

Okay. Counsel, will you all approach. All right. Is this witness... Oh, real quick. Members of the jury, any of y'all have questions of this witness? Seeing no hands, is he released?

Speaker 13 (03:33:19):

He'll be recalled-

Judge Timothy McCourt (03:33:21):

Okay.

Speaker 13 (03:33:21):

... later this afternoon, so he can-

Judge Timothy McCourt (03:33:23):

You can step down. Just remain in contact with the state for your recall later.

Speaker 14 (03:33:25):

Thank you.

Speaker 13 (03:33:26):

Thank you.

Judge Timothy McCourt (03:33:26):

You have this?

Speaker 13 (03:33:27):

Yes.

Judge Timothy McCourt (03:33:47):

I'm sure that will get lost. All right. Deputy Cabrera, have lunches arrived?

Deputy Cabrera (03:33:48):

[inaudible 03:33:51].

Judge Timothy McCourt (03:33:51):

Okay. All right. Ladies and gentlemen, we are done with the morning. This is what we had scheduled for the morning. We planned to break around noon, so we're a little ahead of schedule, so we're going to take a break for lunch. Your lunches are set to arrive at 12:00 noon. They're typically here within five minutes of that. Now, over the lunch break, your notepads will remain here in the courtroom. On the lunch break you cannot speak with one another about the case or anything having to do with the case or any of the testimony that you've heard. If you use your phones or electronic devices, you can use them. But again, do not access social media or anything where you may encounter news on your phone and do not use your phone or electronic device to communicate about the case or with any other person about the case. I think what we're going to do... Do we have any smokers on the jury?

Deputy Cabrera (03:34:34):

We got one.

Judge Timothy McCourt (03:34:34):

Okay. That's good because it's an excuse to get everybody outside. I don't know how the weather is. We're in a room without windows, so. Do we know how the weather is outside?

Deputy Cabrera (03:34:43):

[inaudible 03:34:44].

Judge Timothy McCourt (03:34:44):

I'm getting a thumbs up from one of our bailiffs. What we're going to plan to do, everybody, we're going to plan to reconvene at 12:45 to resume the trial. This will give you all time to either go down and get a breath of fresh air before y'all eat or afterward. We'll come back around. Okay? Any questions for me? Enjoy your lunch.

Speaker 15 (03:35:15):

[inaudible 03:35:50]

Judge Timothy McCourt (03:36:02):

Hold on one second. Lloyd, who's out in the audience speaking? Ms. Rockwood?

Speaker 13 (03:36:08):

Yes, Your Honor.

Judge Timothy McCourt (03:36:10):

Okay. You're talking loud enough that I can hear you up here. Court is in session still. Okay? I'm still doing things here for the benefit of the record. I'd appreciate the volume in the audience, especially for members of the bar to be counted down. Now, for the benefit of the record, the jury has now left the courtroom. Y'all can be seated. Is there anything, lawyers, that we need to take up before we recess for lunch?

Speaker 13 (03:36:35):

Thank you, Judge.

Audio: Calvin Lee (03:36:36):

No, Your Honor.

Speaker 16 (03:36:37):

No, Your Honor.

Judge Timothy McCourt (03:36:38):

Okay. All right. We will come back at 12:45. Corporal or Deputy Cabrera, can you make sure that if they go down for an outside break after lunch, that we just make sure we have them up here ready to go and begin receiving evidence at 12:45?

Deputy Cabrera (03:36:55):

Will do.

Judge Timothy McCourt (03:36:57):

Okay. And make sure to keep all 12 together, or 14 together. Okay. Thank you, counsel.

Audio: Calvin Lee (03:37:02):

Thank you, Your Honor.

Speaker 13 (03:37:02):

Thank you, Your Honor.

Judge McCourt (03:54:07):

All right, the VCR stuff is on. Testing one, two, three. Andy, do you hear me?

Speaker 17 (03:54:11):

Nope.

Judge McCourt (03:54:13):

Hey, Andy.

Andy (03:54:13):

Rob, I may not be able to hear you in Teams. Okay, okay [inaudible 03:54:14] of my ear, so I probably just [inaudible 03:54:28].

Judge McCourt (03:54:30):

Well, I hear you in Teams.

Andy (03:54:37):

Yes.

Judge McCourt (03:54:37):

Okay. Okay.

Andy (03:54:37):

Yeah. So what I did is I routed the audio right from the overflow output, and the mixer from 4C into the overflow for 3A, like it would have been in the right way for overflow. I just don't know, but it seemed like the bailiff said he could hear people in 4C. So I think the audio [inaudible 03:55:08], but I just want to make sure that it persists-

Judge McCourt (03:55:09):

Yes.

Andy (03:55:09):

... if the [inaudible 03:55:13].

Judge McCourt (03:55:14):

Yes.

Andy (03:55:14):

I've also repeated the [inaudible 03:55:17]. I don't know, hopefully, I've secured it for now because it might not [inaudible 03:55:23], but just try it.

Judge McCourt (03:55:24):

Should I get Steven to go down there?

Andy (03:55:27):

If he's available, that would be great. I [inaudible 03:55:33]-

Judge McCourt (03:55:30):

I think he's-

Andy (03:55:30):

[inaudible 03:55:33].

Judge McCourt (03:55:33):

He is, I think.

Andy (03:55:54):

[inaudible 03:55:38] standby for [inaudible 03:55:55].

Judge McCourt (03:55:54):

Right.

Andy (03:55:54):

[inaudible 03:55:55] see if he's [inaudible 03:55:55].

Judge McCourt (03:55:54):

Yeah, well, let me see if he's available. I'm not sure if he's doing lunch quite yet. Yep. [inaudible 03:56:09]. Is there somebody in 3A currently, like a bailiff?

Andy (03:56:16):

Oh, the bailiff was in there, but-

Judge McCourt (03:56:18):

He told me he was going to leave for lunch. Yeah.

Andy (03:56:20):

Yeah. But if you're in 4C and if you want to go ahead and talk into the mic, let me just see if I can hear you [inaudible 03:56:28].

Judge McCourt (03:56:28):

Oh, yeah. I'm sorry. I've been talking this whole time. So testing, test ... Yeah, audio's on and everything. Testing, testing, one, two, three, four, five. I'm talking directly into the microphone.

Andy (03:56:38):

Yeah. [inaudible 03:56:44].

Judge McCourt (03:56:38):

Oh.

Andy (03:56:38):

I think it's ... That's what I think it [inaudible 03:56:50]. I think it's [inaudible 03:56:57] on 3A [inaudible 03:57:02].

Judge McCourt (03:57:04):

Yeah. I think the ECR has just turned on recording. What does Steven say? Yeah, he's at lunch right now. Yes, please. He says he's done eating. He's gone into 3A.

Andy (03:57:33):

[inaudible 03:57:41].

Judge McCourt (03:57:40):

Well, we got to jump on these opportunities.

Andy (03:58:01):

Yeah. [inaudible 03:58:02].

Judge McCourt (03:58:01):

Yes, that's perfect.

Andy (03:58:02):

[inaudible 03:58:08].

Judge McCourt (03:58:11):

Yeah.

Andy (03:58:11):

[inaudible 03:58:15].

Judge McCourt (03:58:14):

I'm just hoping this isn't ... I don't know. Have I said this? Well, correct me if I'm wrong, if I haven't said this, and I'm sorry, but I was not promised the same courtroom for overflow for each day.

Speaker 18 (03:58:31):

Yeah.

Andy (03:58:31):

[inaudible 03:58:34].

Speaker 17 (03:58:36):

Did you hear it?

Andy (03:58:36):

[inaudible 03:58:36].

Judge McCourt (03:58:36):

Hmm?

Speaker 17 (03:58:40):

No. [inaudible 03:58:42]?

Andy (03:58:40):

‍

[inaudible 03:58:45].

Judge McCourt (03:58:55):

Fourth or third floor. Yeah. I'll let Christina know that.

Andy (03:58:59):

And then [inaudible 03:59:06]-

Judge McCourt (03:59:17):

Hmm.

Andy (03:59:17):

... [inaudible 03:59:26].

Judge McCourt (03:59:26):

Yeah.

Andy (03:59:26):

But...

Judge McCourt (03:59:28):

And then we'll get to get it all working and then the next time we'll need it is like ... Oh, you know what? With parole probably, get it for the investiture for the new judge. How about that? I'll plan on ... We got to get it ready before then, so we at least have an action plan. That'd be cool at least. Because what I see is the trend of, this all gets swept under the rug after the need is gone.

Andy (03:59:52):

Well, I think you should [inaudible 03:59:59]-

Judge McCourt (04:00:02):

Yeah.

Andy (04:00:02):

... [inaudible 04:00:06].

Judge McCourt (04:00:06):

The last two investitures, they didn't have an overflow room. They just had enough for the courtroom.

Speaker 17 (04:00:09):

He's got a death penalty case in December. Another one, so ...

Judge McCourt (04:00:15):

Well, hopefully that one will be in courtroom 2A or 2B, so we wouldn't need an overflow room.

(04:00:19)
Sorry I was talking to the bailiff.

(04:00:25)
Yeah.

(04:00:25)
Oh, is Steven ...

Andy (04:00:26):

[inaudible 04:00:29].

Judge McCourt (04:00:29):

Great. Steven, hopefully you can hear me. If you can hear me, Steven, in the overhead speakers in 3A, I want you to wave your hands around like crazy so we know that the overflow room is working.

Andy (04:00:42):

It doesn't have to be crazy but-

Judge McCourt (04:00:43):

Well, I'm just interested to see what his idea of crazy is. I can't even see it, so I'm relying on you to...

Andy (04:00:48):

Well, that's amazing. He's done it perfectly.

Judge McCourt (04:00:51):

Oh, great.

Andy (04:00:52):

Very crazy.

Judge McCourt (04:00:53):

Very crazy. Okay, great.

Andy (04:00:55):

All right. Let's jump back over to [inaudible 04:00:58] because they both want to be added.

Judge McCourt (04:01:00):

Yes.

Andy (04:01:01):

So I'm [inaudible 04:01:04].

Judge McCourt (04:01:03):

Okay.

Speaker 17 (04:01:08):

As soon as Blue Man turned off, the sound came on over there. I was like, "That was one or two prizes." The hell [inaudible 04:01:20] going to get out of here, but [inaudible 04:01:22].

(04:01:19)
Did you get lunch?

Judge McCourt (04:01:19):

What's that?

Speaker 17 (04:01:19):

Did you get some lunch?

Judge McCourt (04:01:19):

Yeah, I've just got to eat it [inaudible 04:01:28].

Speaker 17 (04:01:19):

[inaudible 04:01:31] have to get through the [inaudible 04:01:31].

Andy (04:01:19):

[inaudible 04:01:31].

Speaker 17 (04:01:19):

All right, I'm going to eat right now, but I'm going to go take lunch, so-

Judge McCourt (04:01:33):

Yes. [inaudible 04:01:34].

Speaker 17 (04:01:33):

You'll probably [inaudible 04:01:34].

Judge McCourt (04:01:34):

I just got to eat it up there.

Speaker 17 (04:01:46):

Yeah. Got to go eat my lunch too.

Andy (04:01:46):

[inaudible 04:01:47].

Speaker 17 (04:01:46):

All right. Back [inaudible 04:01:47].

Andy (04:01:46):

[inaudible 04:01:47].

Judge McCourt (04:01:48):

Yes, yes.

Speaker 17 (04:01:49):

[inaudible 04:02:12].

Judge McCourt (04:02:13):

How you doing?

Speaker 17 (04:02:13):

Did you get my text?

Judge McCourt (04:02:14):

I did.

Speaker 17 (04:02:17):

I mean, because all of a sudden the TV just popped on with sound and I was like, "What?"

Judge McCourt (04:02:32):

That should be... Okay. So currently it is a set to presentation mode. That's how it was when I arrived. It is presenting from-

Andy (04:02:44):

[inaudible 04:02:48].

Judge McCourt (04:02:49):

Huh?

Andy (04:02:49):

[inaudible 04:02:51].

Judge McCourt (04:02:50):

Oh my gosh. Yes, you're right. Yeah. So it's currently connected to prosecution laptop presentation mode. So I can switch it to standard mode. Is that what you want?

Andy (04:02:59):

Yeah.

Judge McCourt (04:03:01):

All right. Switching to standard mode.

Speaker 18 (04:03:09):

[inaudible 04:03:08].

(04:03:09)
Okay. I'm sneaking out for lunch, so I won't be listening if he says-

Judge McCourt (04:03:15):

And you can hear me? Testing one, two, three.

Speaker 17 (04:03:18):

Hey, we got plenty of people [inaudible 04:03:20] that's going on.

Judge McCourt (04:03:23):

All right. So we've all approached. I better take this...

Andy (04:03:27):

[inaudible 04:03:29].

Judge McCourt (04:03:29):

Oh yeah, here's the whole thing. All right, so I'm going to go to sidebar now. I've ended sidebar. Testing one, two, three.

Andy (04:03:45):

[inaudible 04:03:51].

Judge McCourt (04:03:54):

Fair enough. Fair enough. I realize that now I'm going to mute my phone now and go into sidebar. All right. I'm going to go into sidebar starting now. All right. I've ended sidebar and I'm going to unmute my phone. How's that?

Andy (04:04:17):

[inaudible 04:04:20].

Judge McCourt (04:04:20):

Dang it. You heard the intimate details.

Speaker 18 (04:04:31):

[inaudible 04:04:26]. Are they out smoking?

Speaker 17 (04:04:31):

No, not yet.

Speaker 18 (04:04:31):

Oh.

Speaker 17 (04:04:31):

[inaudible 04:04:36].

Speaker 18 (04:04:40):

Oh, okay. We can take him out. We can take him out of it.

Speaker 17 (04:04:46):

I was just waiting until he got back from his-

Speaker 18 (04:04:46):

Oh, okay.

Speaker 17 (04:04:46):

He told me 12:20, I'm going to eat my lunch-

Speaker 18 (04:04:46):

What was that-

Speaker 17 (04:04:46):

He told me 12:20

Speaker 18 (04:04:46):

Oh, okay.

Speaker 17 (04:04:52):

Just so they would have time to eat.

Speaker 18 (04:04:53):

Okay. You guys taking him out or-

Speaker 17 (04:04:55):

I think so, yeah.

Speaker 18 (04:05:00):

Okay.

Judge McCourt (04:05:00):

[inaudible 04:05:00].

Speaker 17 (04:05:00):

They're sitting down there doing nothing.

Speaker 18 (04:05:00):

Oh.

Speaker 17 (04:05:00):

[inaudible 04:05:05].

Speaker 18 (04:05:05):

So what do you get to see? You just see him?

Speaker 17 (04:05:08):

All I've seen is I've seen the guy on the video and the start of the First Lady.

Speaker 18 (04:05:19):

Okay. So it's not locked.

Speaker 17 (04:05:19):

It's about two hours-

Judge McCourt (04:05:20):

We're getting this feed working down there as an overflow room. We have failed to do so properly so far because in order for it to be an overflow room, we do not want the sidebar audio to go through, which has been our biggest hangup. So we're trying to work out-

Speaker 18 (04:05:34):

So nobody's down there?

Judge McCourt (04:05:34):

No one's down there.

Speaker 18 (04:05:34):

Just you.

Speaker 17 (04:05:39):

Just me and the buddy.

Speaker 18 (04:05:41):

Aww.

Speaker 17 (04:05:41):

And whoever else they have-

Speaker 18 (04:05:42):

Look, you've seen so many of these big trials. This is nothing for you.

Speaker 17 (04:05:44):

I've never seen a trial like this.

Speaker 18 (04:05:44):

Really?

Speaker 17 (04:05:44):

Not this big.

Speaker 18 (04:05:44):

Well, did you see Bargo? You were here for Bargo?

Speaker 17 (04:05:55):

I was here for his jury selection, but then I didn't get to be part of the trial.

Speaker 18 (04:06:01):

He was [inaudible 04:06:01] it's still here.

Judge McCourt (04:06:03):

Brandon, weren't you in Bargo?

Speaker 18 (04:06:05):

Were you in Bargo?

Judge McCourt (04:06:08):

Michael Bargo, the one who killed the kids?

Speaker 18 (04:06:10):

The Seth Jackson?

Brandon (04:06:12):

Oh no, no, I wasn't here yet.

Speaker 18 (04:06:13):

So who would've been in it? Who was the judge?

Brandon (04:06:21):

Hope maybe.

Speaker 18 (04:06:34):

I don't even know that Judge.

Speaker 17 (04:06:34):

Yeah, he'd been retired for a minute. No, Bargo would've been...

Speaker 18 (04:06:34):

Gosh, that was a while ago.

Speaker 17 (04:06:35):

Almost over 15 years ago.

Speaker 18 (04:06:47):

I think it's been at least 10.

Speaker 17 (04:06:47):

Yeah.

Speaker 18 (04:06:47):

Might've been 2011.

Speaker 17 (04:06:47):

With [inaudible 04:06:47] Singbush?

Judge McCourt (04:06:47):

I think it was 2012. Either '11 or '12.

Speaker 17 (04:06:49):

Yeah.

Speaker 18 (04:06:49):

But you were here then? You were the SRO then.

Speaker 17 (04:07:00):

I was SRO. I was the SRO at Bellevue when he came to [inaudible 04:07:02].

Speaker 18 (04:07:01):

Oh.

Speaker 17 (04:07:04):

And we had him there for two weeks. I told him you need to get rid of this kid because he's going to hurt somebody.

(04:07:11)
Took me two weeks. They got rid of him. Picked up a chair in the cafeteria trying to hit a kid with the chair.

Speaker 18 (04:07:16):

Yeah, he was psycho.

Speaker 17 (04:07:23):

Yep. And then a year later, killed Seth.

Speaker 18 (04:07:25):

Wow.

Andy (04:07:25):

[inaudible 04:07:31].

Judge McCourt (04:07:32):

The judge's mic? Maybe the witness mic?

Andy (04:07:37):

[inaudible 04:07:38].

Judge McCourt (04:07:37):

Sidebar's off. Before we turn off presentation.

Andy (04:08:32):

[inaudible 04:08:33] sidebar.

Judge McCourt (04:08:36):

All right. I mean, or I could mute the judge and witness mic and then try and doing that now.

Speaker 18 (04:08:46):

Tomorrow it's just you guys in DRT. Just you, Brandon, DRT, and...

Andy (04:08:46):

[inaudible 04:08:46].

Speaker 18 (04:08:46):

Oh, and Max.

Speaker 17 (04:08:46):

I was going to say they got to have the third person.

Speaker 18 (04:09:03):

Yeah, they got Max.

Speaker 17 (04:09:11):

[inaudible 04:09:20].

Speaker 18 (04:09:20):

Yeah [inaudible 04:09:22].

Andy (04:09:20):

[inaudible 04:09:24].

Speaker 18 (04:09:24):

Well, Cabrera got his day off.

Speaker 17 (04:09:26):

Yep.

Speaker 18 (04:09:27):

Baby.

Speaker 17 (04:09:27):

So Max was running the ship?

Speaker 18 (04:09:35):

Yep.

Brandon (04:09:35):

Max is leading?

Speaker 18 (04:09:36):

Yep.

Brandon (04:09:36):

Oh. They got a problem with me.

Speaker 18 (04:09:40):

Oh, you think so?

Brandon (04:09:41):

Yeah.

Speaker 18 (04:09:41):

No way.

Brandon (04:09:42):

Because I was lead all last week in here.

Speaker 18 (04:09:47):

What do you think happened?

Brandon (04:09:52):

[inaudible 04:09:52]. I mean, it's the first name, so I would assume that, but that's what that's supposed to mean.

Speaker 18 (04:09:55):

That's corny.

Speaker 17 (04:09:57):

And we got a motion hearing at 8:00-

Speaker 18 (04:09:59):

But it wouldn't be his problem.

Brandon (04:09:59):

No, it's not his... No.

Speaker 18 (04:09:59):

Yeah, because Zach's hair was getting loud.

Brandon (04:10:05):

Yeah. No, it's-

Speaker 17 (04:10:06):

Flawless.

Speaker 18 (04:10:07):

Have they told you to cut it?

Brandon (04:10:10):

No. Every time Tori sees it-

Speaker 17 (04:10:11):

Oh my God, I love it.

Speaker 18 (04:10:12):

Yeah, because you just got to cut hair on the side.

Brandon (04:10:17):

Yeah, this is a mess. I had to go to a different guy. I walked in and his legs are open so the pants don't fall down. And I think he had cerebral palsy or something too. And then he had a shoulder bag, like a Louis Vuitton shoulder... It definitely had a gun in it. It was a sketchy situation.

Speaker 18 (04:10:38):

Yeah.

Brandon (04:10:41):

And I was going to have him trim the back, but he took so long. He took forever on the sides.

Speaker 18 (04:10:56):

It looks good.

Brandon (04:10:56):

I mean, the fade is good.

Speaker 18 (04:10:56):

The fade is good.

Brandon (04:10:56):

Yeah. It just is not what it should be.

Speaker 18 (04:10:56):

Oh, okay.

Brandon (04:10:56):

So I had a funeral event due Saturday night, so I went beforehand. So then he sprays the back down to go trim it. I was like, "You know what? We'll just leave the back. I got to get out of here."

Speaker 18 (04:11:10):

What'd your girlfriend say?

Brandon (04:11:13):

Well, I told her, I said... When I finished, I was like, "I look like Lord Farquaad." And she's like, "Oh, it couldn't be that bad." So I get to the house and I take my hat off and she's like, "Oh." I'm like, "Yeah."

(04:11:21)
"I don't like it." I'm like, "Neither do I." This will be grown in a week or two anyway.

Speaker 18 (04:11:35):

Yeah. You just wear the hat for a while.

Brandon (04:11:36):

Yeah.

Speaker 17 (04:11:37):

Whatever.

Brandon (04:11:38):

Yeah. But of course, the day that I'm going to be on TV-

Speaker 17 (04:11:43):

Oh, you've been on TV all day?

Brandon (04:11:43):

The week that I'll be on TV I get a horrible haircut.

Judge McCourt (04:11:49):

I did all that for nothing, I'm going to have to [inaudible 04:11:51].

Speaker 17 (04:11:50):

You ready?

Brandon (04:11:50):

Yeah, I'm ready.

Speaker 17 (04:11:58):

You look flustered.

Brandon (04:12:02):

What's that?

Speaker 17 (04:12:03):

You look flustered.

Brandon (04:12:06):

Yeah, because by the time I got in the elevator, I went down [inaudible 04:12:09] I told [inaudible 04:12:10] this, "Please submit me with your favorite joke." "It's going to happen anywhere." [inaudible 04:12:17] I'm just glad I'm off [inaudible 04:12:21].

Speaker 17 (04:12:29):

All right. We got to take the jurors down?

Speaker 18 (04:12:30):

Okay.

Speaker 17 (04:12:30):

Stay here because he hasn't eaten.

Speaker 18 (04:12:31):

Okay. I can stay here. I just want to go pee pee before we start.

Speaker 17 (04:12:35):

No. Oh, before we start, okay.

Speaker 18 (04:12:45):

[inaudible 04:12:45] munchkins?

Speaker 17 (04:12:49):

Nah, I got the [inaudible 04:12:50].

Brandon (04:12:49):

I know. I know what it is. I better start talking on the phone.

Speaker 17 (04:12:54):

[inaudible 04:12:55] crock pot [inaudible 04:12:55].

Speaker 18 (04:12:55):

So what'd you do, get a spiral ham?

Speaker 17 (04:13:05):

It was a... Shriner had given me a bunch of meat, so it was a ham that he had butchered and everything. Kind of a flat hand bone.

Speaker 18 (04:13:15):

So it had a little bone in the middle of it kind of thing? Yeah.

Speaker 17 (04:13:24):

[inaudible 04:13:24] she put it in the crock pot a little, about an hour-

Speaker 18 (04:13:26):

Yeah. So it wasn't cooked when you got it? Just cured.

Speaker 17 (04:13:32):

No, she just had it butchered and wrapped it.

Speaker 18 (04:13:33):

So that's not ham, is it?

Speaker 17 (04:13:38):

It's pork ham.

Speaker 18 (04:13:42):

Doesn't ham have to be cured or something to make it salty?

Speaker 17 (04:13:45):

I mean, it wasn't salty. It was just [inaudible 04:13:50].

Speaker 18 (04:13:51):

That portion of it.

Speaker 17 (04:13:51):

It's called ham.

Speaker 18 (04:13:54):

Yeah.

Speaker 17 (04:13:54):

I mean, it's not ham, but it's the ham.

Speaker 18 (04:13:54):

Yeah.

Speaker 17 (04:13:59):

So it's kind of like cooking a portion of it, but same time [inaudible 04:14:01].

Speaker 18 (04:14:00):

With the ham.

Speaker 17 (04:14:00):

But it's the ham.

Speaker 18 (04:14:04):

How did it taste?

Speaker 17 (04:14:05):

Good. Yeah, she seasoned it and then put honey on top.

Speaker 18 (04:14:09):

Oh wow. That's delicious.

Speaker 17 (04:14:09):

Crock pot-

Speaker 18 (04:14:10):

That's awesome.

Speaker 17 (04:14:12):

We'll see what it tastes like the next day.

Speaker 18 (04:14:12):

Yeah.

Speaker 17 (04:14:17):

[inaudible 04:14:16]. And I put some of the juice from the honey [inaudible 04:14:20] put some of that in it [inaudible 04:14:25].

Speaker 18 (04:14:36):

Yeah, would make a good sandwich though.

Speaker 17 (04:14:44):

[inaudible 04:14:45].

Speaker 18 (04:14:44):

There you go.

Speaker 17 (04:14:53):

[inaudible 04:14:45] they were [inaudible 04:14:45] trying to wait around and get extra people [inaudible 04:15:01].

Brandon (04:14:54):

[inaudible 04:15:11].

Speaker 17 (04:14:54):

[inaudible 04:15:16].

Speaker 18 (04:15:19):

Let me go to the bathroom real quick before you leave.

Speaker 17 (04:15:21):

Yep, no need to be there, down there-

Speaker 18 (04:15:24):

Yep.

Judge McCourt (04:15:25):

Testing one, two, three. Testing.

Andy (04:15:26):

[inaudible 04:15:33].

Judge McCourt (04:15:34):

Okay. Testing sidebar. Great. You didn't hear me talking about you.

Andy (04:15:59):

[inaudible 04:15:59].

Judge McCourt (04:15:59):

Yes, it is.

Andy (04:15:59):

[inaudible 04:16:12].

Judge McCourt (04:16:12):

Okay. Well, I can try reporting enabled/disabled. So it's enabled right now. I'm going to disable it. There we go. Now you should be able to hear me again now that I've re-enabled the audio.

Andy (04:17:07):

[inaudible 04:17:11].

Judge McCourt (04:17:10):

Okay, great. Are you talking about changing actual ECR recording? Andy?

Andy (04:17:17):

Yeah, that should be-

Judge McCourt (04:17:20):

Yeah, I think so.

Andy (04:17:20):

[inaudible 04:17:25].

Judge McCourt (04:17:28):

Oh, right.

Andy (04:17:47):

[inaudible 04:17:36] audio and [inaudible 04:17:48].

Automated (04:17:47):

Welcome to Zoom. Please press pound. Then enter your meeting ID, followed by the pound sign again.

Judge McCourt (04:17:54):

Did you all that?

Andy (04:17:54):

[inaudible 04:17:59].

Judge McCourt (04:18:03):

Crazy loud. Yeah, it was crazy loud in here too. Looks like he turned it up because the guy from England or whatever that was zooming in, he was really quiet.

(04:18:16)
Yeah. I'm turning it down to a reasonable volume. How about we try that again? Why not?

Andy (04:18:19):

[inaudible 04:18:26].

Judge McCourt (04:18:27):

Yep.

Automated (04:18:33):

Welcome to Zoom. Please press pound, then enter your meeting ID followed by the pound sign again.

Judge McCourt (04:18:39):

[inaudible 04:18:40] hear that [inaudible 04:18:44]. Steven.

Andy (04:18:43):

[inaudible 04:18:50].

Judge McCourt (04:18:49):

Still incredibly loud? Well, I don't want to adjust it too much beyond what the judge already set it to. So if you can hear it [inaudible 04:19:00].

Speaker 18 (04:19:07):

Thanks for taking one for the team, for me.

Judge McCourt (04:19:08):

[inaudible 04:19:13].

Speaker 18 (04:19:08):

I know, right?

Judge McCourt (04:19:15):

Great.

Andy (04:19:15):

[inaudible 04:19:20].

Judge McCourt (04:19:28):

Okay. I'm talking into the podium mic right now. Testing one, two, three. Testing one, two, three.

Andy (04:19:36):

That's clear. Good volume.

Judge McCourt (04:19:38):

Thank you.

Andy (04:19:41):

And you sound amazing. [inaudible 04:19:46].

Judge McCourt (04:20:26):

Yeah.

Andy (04:20:26):

[inaudible 04:20:45].

Judge McCourt (04:20:58):

I remember state, I talked to them yesterday. They had me turn up the video send... Or I turned up the video sent audio output, the touch panel, because the victim on the video that they were trying to play was very, very soft-spoken. And we had to find an agreement. So that could be something to do with it too. I'm realizing, yeah, it's up almost all the way.

Andy (04:21:30):

[inaudible 04:21:34].

Judge McCourt (04:21:34):

Yeah, the audio's up.

Speaker 18 (04:21:34):

There's an audience back there.

Andy (04:21:34):

[inaudible 04:21:39].

Speaker 18 (04:21:34):

[inaudible 04:21:43].

Judge McCourt (04:21:46):

Oh yeah, this is the speaker. Well [inaudible 04:21:54].

Speaker 17 (04:22:00):

I love a case with my big papa. That was funny.

Speaker 18 (04:22:01):

[inaudible 04:22:05].

Speaker 17 (04:22:26):

Yes.

Judge McCourt (04:22:43):

Okay. All right. I'm going to make a Zoom call now. All right, try to make a call.

Speaker 18 (04:22:54):

When I get to the five million drinks on the table point.

Speaker 17 (04:22:56):

[inaudible 04:23:00].

Speaker 18 (04:22:59):

I wanted to call here, no, I'm not going to have [inaudible 04:23:02].

Speaker 17 (04:23:01):

[inaudible 04:23:06].

Automated (04:23:14):

Welcome to Zoom. Please press pound, then enter your meeting ID followed by the pound sign again.

Andy (04:23:20):

[inaudible 04:23:24].

Judge McCourt (04:23:25):

Perfect. I'll do that again. A little loud and perfect.

Andy (04:23:29):

[inaudible 04:23:32].

Judge McCourt (04:23:33):

Right. Okay. All right. I'm going to exit this call and I'm going to put it back in the state that was in when I arrived, presentation, prosecution laptop, and home screen.

Andy (04:23:48):

[inaudible 04:23:50].

Judge McCourt (04:23:50):

Okay. Awesome. I'm going to come down and take a look at it myself, just out of curiosity.

Andy (04:23:56):

[inaudible 04:24:00].

Judge McCourt (04:34:09):

We're back from lunch. It's 12:42 in the afternoon. The record should reflect counsel for the state defense are present as well as the defendant. Is there anything else we have to bring up, members or lawyers, before we bring in the jury?

Lawyer (04:34:22):

Briefly, Your Honor. This afternoon, the last thing we're going to do is start to play the defendant's interview. It's lengthy.

Judge McCourt (04:34:28):

How long?

Lawyer (04:34:29):

It's about four hours and 40 minutes, so we're going to probably split it up a little bit this afternoon into more tomorrow morning. Well, we tested the audio yesterday using the court system. The audio wasn't great. We tried to mess with the sound a little bit and it's still a little muffled. So our plan was we have our large smart board with a sound bar, which provides much better quality of sound.

Judge McCourt (04:34:50):

Yes, sir.

Lawyer (04:34:51):

We were going to bring that in here and play it over the smart board, if that's okay.

Judge McCourt (04:34:56):

Yes.

Lawyer (04:34:56):

Was just a matter of trying to figure out how to situate it so everybody can see. But our hope was that we would be able to take a break, like a 10, 15 minute break. We could bring it in here and hook it up.

Judge McCourt (04:35:07):

All right. If your timeline holds for the afternoon, that would be shortly before or around three o'clock?

Lawyer (04:35:13):

Yes, sir.

Speaker 19 (04:35:14):

That's going to be after. It's a little after 3:00.

Lawyer (04:35:19):

It'd probably be a little after 3:00.

Judge McCourt (04:35:20):

Okay. I know y'all have had the smart board in here. I don't know if it's a smart board, but y'all have had a laptop and screen that don't connect to the internet in here before for other trials. I remember it being a pretty large setup in here.

Lawyer (04:35:34):

It's large.

Speaker 19 (04:35:36):

That's why we need a few minutes to just move it around to make sure obviously everybody can see.

Judge McCourt (04:35:42):

Yeah. All right. Have we given the jurors a two-minute warning?

Clerk (04:35:44):

Not yet.

Judge McCourt (04:35:44):

Let's give them the two-minute warning while we're hashing this out a little bit. All right. We'll need to move the podium, obviously. And then Mr. Hall, if later when we play the video, you want to watch it, you'll be permitted to change your location in the courtroom. Okay? And sit somewhere that you can view the video if you wish to view it.

Lawyer (04:36:05):

What we have done in the past, the smart board would face the jury, but the laptop is also would be facing the defendant and it'll play on the backside as well so the defense counsel can see just a smaller screen.

Judge McCourt (04:36:15):

Yeah, that would work. Okay.

Lawyer (04:36:15):

Thank you, Your Honor.

Judge McCourt (04:36:18):

Okay. Anything else from the defense before we bring in the jury?

Dwain Hall (04:36:20):

No, Your Honor.

Judge McCourt (04:36:21):

All right. Mr. Hall, you were given lunch, yes?

Dwain Hall (04:36:23):

Yes.

Judge McCourt (04:36:24):

What do they have for you today?

Dwain Hall (04:36:25):

Same old, same old.

Judge McCourt (04:36:27):

Bologna and apple slices?

Dwain Hall (04:36:28):

Yep.

Judge McCourt (04:36:29):

Fair enough. Okay. Are we ready for the jury now?

Clerk (04:36:31):

Yes, sir.

Lawyer (04:36:31):

Yes, Your Honor.

Judge McCourt (04:37:53):

Bring them in.

(04:37:53)
Ladies and gentlemen, welcome back, Counsel. Everybody can be seated. How was lunch?

Speaker 20 (04:37:56):

Very good. Very good.

Judge McCourt (04:37:58):

Looking forward to having you again tomorrow, right?

Speaker 20 (04:38:00):

Yes, yes.

Judge McCourt (04:38:02):

We may have something different on Thursday. I'll talk to you all a little bit about that toward the end of the day today and give you all some options for Thursday that may be a little different than Jimmy John's. All right. State, you can call your next witness.

Lawyer (04:38:13):

State calls Maria Andreoli.

Judge McCourt (04:38:54):

Come on in, ma'am. If you could raise your right hand, face the clerk to be sworn.

Clerk (04:38:59):

Do you swear or affirm the testimony you're about to give be the truth, the whole truth, and nothing but the truth, so help you God?

Maria Andreoli (04:39:01):

Yes, I do.

Judge McCourt (04:39:01):

You can go ahead and be seated, ma'am.

Lawyer (04:39:12):

Good afternoon.

Maria Andreoli (04:39:13):

Good afternoon.

Lawyer (04:39:14):

Will you please introduce yourself to the jury?

Maria Andreoli (04:39:16):

My name is Maria Andreoli.

Lawyer (04:39:18):

Can you spell your last name for us?

Maria Andreoli (04:39:19):

Yes. A-N-D-R-E-O-L-I.

Lawyer (04:39:20):

Where do you work?

Maria Andreoli (04:39:25):

I am employed with the Florida Department of Law Enforcement, also known as FDLE.

Lawyer (04:39:30):

What do you do for them?

Maria Andreoli (04:39:31):

I am a crime laboratory analyst supervisor over the crime scene investigation section and the evidence intake section.

Lawyer (04:39:39):

How long have you been with FDLE?

Maria Andreoli (04:39:41):

A little over seven and a half years now.

Lawyer (04:39:43):

What do you do on a day-to-day basis?

Maria Andreoli (04:39:46):

On the day-to-day, I supervise both the crime scene investigation and evidence intake sections and the members within them. I am also a proficient analyst, which means I process crime scenes.

Lawyer (04:39:57):

And how long have you been processing crime scenes?

Maria Andreoli (04:40:01):

Since 2020.

Lawyer (04:40:03):

What is meant by the phrase processing a crime scene?

Maria Andreoli (04:40:06):

That is the act of responding to the scene, documenting it through notes, photographs, sketches, or three-dimensional laser scans. I will then search the scene for items of evidence and collect those items for future processing by the laboratory.

Lawyer (04:40:24):

Can you describe for the jury your educational background and training that allows you to do that?

Maria Andreoli (04:40:25):

Yes. I have a bachelor's of science in biology from the University of Central Florida and a certificate in crime scene technology from Miami-Dade College.

Lawyer (04:40:36):

Now, often when you respond to a scene and begin to process that scene, do you always have the benefit of a full and complete investigation at that point?

Maria Andreoli (04:40:45):

No. Oftentimes when I am responding to a crime scene, it's at the beginning stages of an investigation.

Lawyer (04:40:52):

Because of that, do you often, as a crime scene analyst, document things and collect things that end up having no relevance to anything whatsoever involving the case?

Maria Andreoli (04:41:01):

That is possible.

Lawyer (04:41:04):

Okay. Are you trained in the different ways to collect evidence?

Maria Andreoli (04:41:06):

Yes, I am.

Lawyer (04:41:07):

And what precautions do you and other crime scene technicians from FDLE take when entering a crime scene?

Maria Andreoli (04:41:13):

Depending on the scene, we will use different types of personal protective equipment or PPE. Every scene, without a doubt, there is going to be gloves involved. And then for this particular scene, I also used crime scene booties, which are covers that go over my crime scene boots, and other individuals who were at the scene also used gloves and crime scene booties.

Lawyer (04:41:39):

Let me direct your attention to October 15th and October 16th of 2025. Did you respond to a residence located at 16293 Northwest, 122nd Terrace in Reddick, Florida?

Maria Andreoli (04:41:52):

Yes, I did.

Lawyer (04:41:53):

Generally, where is that located?

Maria Andreoli (04:41:55):

It was in a more rural area. On the way there, I noticed a few houses, but it was mostly farm-ish land.

Lawyer (04:42:06):

Okay. And can you describe for the jury that residence, that house, generally what it looked like?

Maria Andreoli (04:42:10):

It was a two bedroom, two bathroom manufactured home. So it was located east of Northwest 122nd Terrace, and the front door was on the north end of the manufactured home. In the back were the bedrooms and the bathroom.

Lawyer (04:42:29):

Was it your understanding that this residence was basically being used as an Airbnb?

Maria Andreoli (04:42:32):

Yes.

Lawyer (04:42:32):

Okay. So why'd you go there?

Maria Andreoli (04:42:36):

I was requested to process the crime scene for a missing person's report that our special agents had received.

Lawyer (04:42:44):

And had the owner of the Airbnb given you and other law enforcement officers permission to go inside and look around and do what you had to do?

Maria Andreoli (04:42:53):

Yes.

Lawyer (04:42:56):

While you were there, did you take photographs of both the inside and outside of the residence?

Maria Andreoli (04:43:01):

Yes, I did.

Lawyer (04:43:05):

May I approach, Your Honor?

Judge McCourt (04:43:05):

Yes, sir.

Lawyer (04:43:06):

Showing you what's been marked as State's Exhibit P as in Paul for identification. Can you take a look at those photos and tell me if you recognize them?

Maria Andreoli (04:43:31):

Yes, I do.

Lawyer (04:43:32):

And how do you recognize them?

Maria Andreoli (04:43:34):

I took these photos during the documentation of the crime scene.

Lawyer (04:43:38):

Do they fairly and accurately depict the residence and the items of interest that you located within that residence or around that residence?

Maria Andreoli (04:43:44):

Yes.

Lawyer (04:43:45):

At this time, state would move state's P as in Paul into evidence as 15.

Dwain Hall (04:43:49):

No objection, Judge.

Judge McCourt (04:43:50):

Without objection, State's Exhibit P will be introduced or admitted into evidence as Exhibit 15.

Lawyer (04:43:55):

May I publish?

Judge McCourt (04:43:56):

Yes, sir.

Lawyer (04:43:58):

Showing you photograph one from State's 15. Explain to the jury what we see here.

Maria Andreoli (04:44:02):

This is the north side of the two bedroom, two bathroom manufactured home. There was a patio on the north end of that, and towards the back of the patio was the door to the residence.

Lawyer (04:44:17):

Showing you photo two from State's 15. Did you document the numerical address of the location?

Maria Andreoli (04:44:22):

Yes, I did.

Lawyer (04:44:23):

And what was it?

Maria Andreoli (04:44:24):

It was 16293.

Lawyer (04:44:27):

Photograph three of State's 15. Did you locate a garbage can on the outside beneath the porch area?

Maria Andreoli (04:44:38):

Yes.

Lawyer (04:44:38):

Did you search that garbage can?

Maria Andreoli (04:44:39):

Yes, I did.

Lawyer (04:44:40):

Showing you photograph four of State's 15. What does this show?

Maria Andreoli (04:45:16):

This is an overall photograph of the garbage can that I searched.

Lawyer (04:45:16):

Photo five of State's 15. What'd you find when you looked inside?

Maria Andreoli (04:45:16):

Inside the garbage can... Well, the garbage can was lined with a black garbage trash bag, and then within that trash bag was a white trash bag.

Lawyer (04:45:16):

What'd you do with the white trash bag?

Maria Andreoli (04:45:16):

I took the white trash bag out and then I laid a tarp out and photographed the trash bag and its contents.

Lawyer (04:45:16):

Showing you photograph six of State's 15. What does this show?

Maria Andreoli (04:45:16):

This is the tarp that I laid out and an overall photograph of the white trash bag.

Lawyer (04:45:21):

And photograph seven of State's 15. What about this?

Maria Andreoli (04:45:24):

This is an overall photograph of the white trash bag and all of the contents within the white trash bag.

Lawyer (04:45:30):

And the blue tarp that everything is laying on top of, that was something you provided?

Maria Andreoli (04:45:34):

Yes.

Lawyer (04:45:34):

Okay. Generally, what types of things did you find in the trash?

Maria Andreoli (04:45:38):

I found food containers, wrappers, and some receipts, some wipes, toiletries, and suspected hairs.

Lawyer (04:45:49):

Showing you photograph eight of State's 15, you mentioned receipts that were found.

Maria Andreoli (04:45:53):

Yes.

Lawyer (04:45:53):

Specifically, what kind of receipts did you find?

Maria Andreoli (04:45:55):

I found two Walmart receipts.

Lawyer (04:45:58):

And on photograph eight of 15, what types of items were purchased according to the Walmart receipt?

Maria Andreoli (04:46:07):

There was a paracord that was purchased, an aerosol spray, a Lume spray, and a U-line utility rope.

Lawyer (04:46:21):

And can you tell from the receipt what date and time that purchase occurred?

Maria Andreoli (04:46:25):

Yes. It's dated October 10th, 2025 at 17:47.

Lawyer (04:46:31):

That's 5:47 PM?

Maria Andreoli (04:46:33):

Yes.

Lawyer (04:46:34):

All right. I'm showing you photograph nine of State's 15. Did you locate a second receipt from Walmart?

Maria Andreoli (04:46:39):

Yes, I did.

Lawyer (04:46:40):

And what was purchased based on that receipt?

Maria Andreoli (04:46:42):

A shovel.

Lawyer (04:46:43):

How much was the shovel according to the receipt?

Maria Andreoli (04:46:46):

It was $20.39 with tax.

Lawyer (04:46:49):

And was there a date and time for that purchase for the shovel?

Maria Andreoli (04:46:53):

Yes. What time? It was dated October 10th, 2025 at 17:54, so 5:54 and 30 seconds.

Lawyer (04:47:02):

So just a few minutes after the items in the previous receipt were purchased?

Maria Andreoli (04:47:06):

Yes.

Lawyer (04:47:08):

Okay. Did you collect those receipts?

Maria Andreoli (04:47:10):

Yes, I did.

Lawyer (04:47:11):

May I approach?

Judge McCourt (04:47:16):

Yes, sir.

Lawyer (04:47:17):

Showing you what's been marked State's Exhibit Q for identification. Can you take a look at that and tell me if you recognize that?

Maria Andreoli (04:47:25):

Yes, I do.

Lawyer (04:47:26):

And how do you recognize it?

Maria Andreoli (04:47:27):

It has my initials and our FDLE laboratory case label on it.

Lawyer (04:47:32):

Can you open it up, look inside and tell me if you recognize the documents? Is that item currently sealed?

Maria Andreoli (04:47:43):

It is, yes.

Lawyer (04:48:19):

What's inside?

Maria Andreoli (04:48:21):

So in one of the envelopes is the Walmart receipt dated October 10th, 2025 at 17:47. And the other envelope is the Walmart receipt dated October 10th, 2025.

Lawyer (04:48:55):

And are those the same receipts that we saw in the photographs that we just looked at?

Maria Andreoli (04:48:59):

Yes.

Lawyer (04:49:00):

Are they in the same or substantially the same condition as when you collected them that day?

Maria Andreoli (04:49:03):

Yes.

Lawyer (04:49:04):

This time, State would move Q into evidence as State's 16.

Dwain Hall (04:49:07):

No objection, Judge.

Judge McCourt (04:49:08):

Without objection, State's Exhibit Q will be admitted into evidence as State's Exhibit 16.

Lawyer (04:49:12):

And on those receipts, is there a store number such that an officer could go back and track down what store those receipts came from?

Maria Andreoli (04:49:19):

Yes.

Lawyer (04:49:20):

Okay. Thank you. And you mentioned on one of the... I'm showing you photograph 10 of State's 15. You mentioned on one of the receipts there were purchases of a paracord and the utility type rope or line, right?

Maria Andreoli (04:49:38):

Yes.

Lawyer (04:49:40):

What do we see in photograph 10?

Maria Andreoli (04:49:43):

This is an overall photograph of the wrappers that I found within the trash can.

Lawyer (04:49:54):

Did you collect that wrapping?

Maria Andreoli (04:49:56):

Yes, I did.

Lawyer (04:49:57):

May I approach, Your Honor?

Judge McCourt (04:49:58):

Yes, sir.

Lawyer (04:49:59):

Showing you what's been marked as State's Exhibit R as well as State's S. Can you take a look at those items and tell me if you recognize them?

Maria Andreoli (04:50:12):

Yes, I do.

Lawyer (04:50:13):

And what are they?

Maria Andreoli (04:50:14):

They are the Ozark Trail 100... Well, 1100 paracord 50-foot wrapper and the Ozark Trail twisted utility line wrapper that I collected.

Lawyer (04:50:28):

Can you please open those up, look inside and tell me if you recognize the contents of each?

Maria Andreoli (04:50:30):

Yes.

Lawyer (04:51:35):

And what's in that first package you looked at?

Maria Andreoli (04:51:38):

This first one is the wrapper for 1100 paracord from Ozark Trail.

Lawyer (04:51:46):

Okay. Thank you.

Maria Andreoli (04:52:44):

Within this envelope is the wrapper for the twisted utility line from Ozark Trail.

Lawyer (04:52:51):

And in both of those exhibits I just showed you, State's R and State's S, are those the wrappers that we see in the photograph here?

Maria Andreoli (04:52:56):

Yes.

Lawyer (04:52:58):

And are both of those wrappers in the same or substantially the same condition as when you collected them?

Maria Andreoli (04:53:02):

Yes.

Lawyer (04:53:02):

This time, state would move R into evidence as 17.

Dwain Hall (04:53:06):

No objection. Judge, just only can I ask which one is which so I can know just for my notes.

Judge McCourt (04:53:12):

Ma'am, you can answer.

Maria Andreoli (04:53:16):

Okay. 16A is the Ozark Trail twisted utility line.

Judge McCourt (04:53:23):

Okay. There should be a blue tag on the back that has a letter.

Maria Andreoli (04:53:27):

Oh, I'm sorry. So S is the Ozark Trail twisted utility line, and R is the Ozark Trail 1100 paracord.

Dwain Hall (04:53:39):

All right. Thank you.

Judge McCourt (04:53:42):

Without objection, then State's Exhibit R will be admitted into evidence as State's Exhibit 17.

Lawyer (04:53:46):

The State will move S into evidence as State's 18.

Dwain Hall (04:53:49):

No objection, Judge.

Judge McCourt (04:53:50):

And without objection, State's Exhibit S will be admitted into evidence as State's Exhibit 18.

Lawyer (04:54:07):

Are the pieces of the paracord label and the utility label that we just looked at and were in the pictures, are those consistent with the purchases that you saw on the Walmart receipt we talked about earlier?

Maria Andreoli (04:54:18):

Yes.

Lawyer (04:54:22):

Okay. Did you find the actual utility rope or cord anywhere during the search?

Maria Andreoli (04:54:26):

I did not.

Lawyer (04:54:30):

Okay. Showing you photograph 11 of State's 15. Did you locate some plastic food containers during your search of that garbage can?

Maria Andreoli (04:54:39):

Yes, I did.

Lawyer (04:54:39):

What'd you find and what does this photograph show?

Maria Andreoli (04:54:42):

This is a photograph of a PB&J white grape sandwich container that I found and collected from the trash can.

Lawyer (04:54:51):

Photograph 12 of State's 15, what does this show?

Maria Andreoli (04:54:54):

This is a photograph of a food container that was labeled as strawberries that I collected from the trash can.

Lawyer (04:55:02):

And did you collect these food containers along with other items that you found in the garbage can?

Maria Andreoli (04:55:06):

Yes, I did.

Lawyer (04:55:07):

May I approach?

Judge McCourt (04:55:08):

Yes, sir.

Lawyer (04:55:08):

Showing you what's been marked as State's Exhibit T as in Tom. Take a look at that item. Tell me if you recognize that.

Maria Andreoli (04:55:14):

I do.

Lawyer (04:55:15):

What is it?

Maria Andreoli (04:55:16):

It is several items that I collected from the trash can.

Lawyer (04:55:22):

Okay. Can you please open that up, look inside and tell me if you recognize the contents?

Maria Andreoli (04:55:24):

Yes.

Lawyer (04:57:14):

Are there multiple packages inside the box?

Maria Andreoli (04:57:17):

Yes.

Lawyer (04:57:18):

Specifically, can you pull out the two food containers that we talked about?

Maria Andreoli (04:57:24):

Yes.

Lawyer (04:57:24):

[inaudible 04:57:25].

Maria Andreoli (04:57:24):

Yep.

‍

Lawyer (04:57:24):

Okay. [inaudible 04:57:36] take a look inside and tell me if you recognize the contents.

Maria Andreoli (04:58:08):

Yes, I do.

Lawyer (04:58:09):

What is that?

Maria Andreoli (04:58:11):

This is the strawberry plastic container and the PB&J white grape container that I collected.

Lawyer (04:58:18):

And the rest of the items in the box, are those just the remaining items we saw in the photographs, like the drink cans and things like that?

Maria Andreoli (04:58:23):

Yes.

Lawyer (04:58:24):

Okay. Is that in the same or substantially the same condition as when you collected?

Maria Andreoli (04:58:26):

Yes.

Lawyer (04:58:28):

At this time, State would move T, as in Tom, into evidence as 19.

Junior Barrett (04:58:32):

No objection, Judge.

Judge (04:58:33):

Without objection, State's Exhibit T will be admitted into evidence as State's Exhibit 19.

Lawyer (04:58:48):

Did you also search the inside of the residence?

Maria Andreoli (04:58:51):

I did.

Lawyer (04:58:51):

Describe the inside. Was it clean? Was it cluttered?

Maria Andreoli (04:58:54):

It was sparsely furnished and relatively clean, but there was quite a bit of bedding that appeared that it had been used.

Lawyer (04:59:03):

Okay. Did you find anything in the residence of obvious evidentiary value?

Maria Andreoli (04:59:09):

Yes.

Lawyer (04:59:10):

Like what?

Maria Andreoli (04:59:11):

I collected several items of bedding. The scene was also processed for friction ridge detail, and multiple swabs were also collected from the scene.

Lawyer (04:59:23):

Okay. Showing you photograph 13 of State's 15. What does this show?

Maria Andreoli (04:59:27):

This is an overall photograph of the living room and kitchen area. So this photograph was taken right as I walked in through that north front door of the manufactured home, and towards the back of the photograph is where the bedrooms and bathrooms were located.

Lawyer (04:59:47):

Showing you photograph 14 of State's 15. Did you locate an internet router in the bedroom?

Maria Andreoli (04:59:54):

Yes. It was labeled as a modem router hybrid.

Lawyer (04:59:57):

Okay. And photograph 15 of State's 15, what does this show?

Maria Andreoli (05:00:02):

This is the backside of the router labeled "Kinetic Wi-fi 6 Modem".

Lawyer (05:00:06):

So this picture is the back of the previous picture of the router modem?

Maria Andreoli (05:00:06):

Yes.

Lawyer (05:00:06):

Okay.

(05:00:06)
Thank you.

(05:00:06)
May I approach, Your Honor?

Judge (05:00:06):

Yes, sir.

Lawyer (05:01:59):

Showing what's been marked as State's Exhibit II. Do you recognize the area that that map depicts?

Maria Andreoli (05:02:06):

Yes, I do.

Lawyer (05:02:08):

And does that map fairly and accurately depict the location of the Airbnb that you processed those days?

Maria Andreoli (05:02:13):

Yes.

Lawyer (05:02:14):

Thank you, ma'am. And what I handed you is State's II for the record.

(05:02:29)
No further questions, Your Honor. Thank you.

Junior Barrett (05:02:29):

No questions.

Judge (05:02:31):

Any cross examination?

Junior Barrett (05:02:32):

No questions.

Judge (05:02:33):

Members of the jury, any of y'all have questions of this witness? If you do, please raise your hands.

(05:02:38)
Seeing no hands, State, is she released?

Lawyer (05:02:41):

She will be recalled, Your Honor.

Judge (05:02:42):

Okay, ma'am, you're free to step down.

Maria Andreoli (05:02:44):

Thank you.

Judge (05:02:44):

Thank you.

(05:02:44)
State, you can call your next witness.

Lawyer (05:02:46):

State calls Christopher Perryman.

Judge (05:03:33):

Come on in, sir. Raise your right hand. Face the clerk to be sworn.

Court Clerk (05:03:36):

Do you swear or affirm the testimony you're about to give will be the truth, the whole truth, and nothing but the truth, so help you God?

Christopher Perryman (05:03:40):

I do.

Judge (05:03:42):

You can go ahead and be seated.

Lawyer (05:03:49):

Good afternoon, sir.

Christopher Perryman (05:03:50):

Good afternoon.

Lawyer (05:03:51):

Can you please introduce yourself to the jury?

Christopher Perryman (05:03:53):

I'm Christopher Perryman. I work for the Florida Department of Law Enforcement. I'm a special agent at the Gainesville Field Office.

Lawyer (05:04:00):

How long have you worked for FDLE?

Christopher Perryman (05:04:02):

A little over two years.

Lawyer (05:04:03):

Where'd you work before that?

Christopher Perryman (05:04:04):

I worked for Levy County Sheriff's Office.

Lawyer (05:04:07):

Before that, anywhere?

Christopher Perryman (05:04:08):

No, sir.

Lawyer (05:04:08):

Okay. How long were you at Levy County?

Christopher Perryman (05:04:10):

From 2014 to 2024.

Lawyer (05:04:14):

What type of work did you do for Levy County Sheriff's Office?

Christopher Perryman (05:04:17):

So for Levy County, I was a patrol deputy for several years, promoted into Criminal Investigations Division, later promoted back out to a corporal position, which is a line supervisor for patrol. I went back in as a line supervisor for Criminal Investigations Division.

Lawyer (05:04:36):

While you were in Levy County, did you do any work involving crimes against children and kind of internet-type-related crimes?

Christopher Perryman (05:04:42):

I did.

Lawyer (05:04:42):

Okay. What type of things did you do?

Christopher Perryman (05:04:44):

Worked many different crimes, specifically crimes against persons, so shootings, homicides, property crimes, and then also internet crimes against children, so cyber type of crimes.

Lawyer (05:05:00):

Let me direct your attention to October 15th of 2025. Did you respond to an Airbnb located at 16293 Northwest 122nd Terrace in Reddick, Florida?

Christopher Perryman (05:05:12):

Yes, I did.

Lawyer (05:05:13):

Showing you photograph 1 from State's 15. Do you recognize that location?

Christopher Perryman (05:05:17):

Yes, sir. I do.

Lawyer (05:05:18):

And why did you go here?

Christopher Perryman (05:05:20):

We were working an investigation with a missing person identified as Sonia Exelby. We knew that she had rented this Airbnb, so we went there for further investigation.

Lawyer (05:05:32):

Was there a crime scene technician from Florida Department of Law Enforcement named Maria Andreoli also there processing the scene?

Christopher Perryman (05:05:38):

Yes, sir, there was.

Lawyer (05:05:39):

While there, did you perform something called a router interrogation?

Christopher Perryman (05:05:43):

Yes, sir, I did.

Lawyer (05:05:44):

First of all, what is a router?

Christopher Perryman (05:05:46):

So a router essentially is kind of what it says it is. It routes information. So it's something connected to your home network that sends and receives information from other devices.

Lawyer (05:05:57):

And we've also heard the term "modem". What's a modem?

Christopher Perryman (05:06:00):

A modem basically is what connects to your ISP, or your internet service provider. So if you had AT&T or something like that, it would connect externally, bring internet into your house, and connect into a router to help create a wireless internet.

Lawyer (05:06:14):

Okay. So the modem brings the internet signal into your house and the router disperses it amongst the devices that need it?

Christopher Perryman (05:06:20):

That's correct. It disperses it and also sends messages back out.

Lawyer (05:06:24):

Okay. So if I go to your house and I pull out my cell phone and connect to your internet system, will the router store the information from my phone somehow?

Christopher Perryman (05:06:34):

Yes, sir, it will.

Lawyer (05:06:35):

Okay. Briefly and generally, can you explain kind of how that works?

Christopher Perryman (05:06:40):

Yes, sir. So when you connect to a router, typically, there's different ways it can store it. Some routers store information internally through a memory system, like a memory card, and secondarily, it can store it through a cloud-based system. So store things like a MAC address, IP addresses, names, devices, connected devices, things like that.

Lawyer (05:07:04):

What's a MAC address?

Christopher Perryman (05:07:06):

So a MAC address essentially is a 12-bit hexadecimal number that identifies a specific electronic device. So for example, a cell phone, when it's manufactured, a manufacturer will put a special serial number, which is basically your MAC address, into it that is unique to it, kind of like a fingerprint, and never changes.

Lawyer (05:07:29):

And what is an IP address?

Christopher Perryman (05:07:31):

So an IP address is, basically, it's an... internet protocol address is what it's called, but basically, what it does is it kind of acts like a home address. So when you get your mail delivered from a postmaster, it goes to your home. An IP address is where the internet would provide the data packages, basically, to.

Lawyer (05:07:51):

And you said you performed what's called a router interrogation. What is that, and what does it involve?

Christopher Perryman (05:07:55):

So router interrogation basically means that I'm looking at the administrative side, or the admin side, of a router. So earlier when I mentioned that there was some stored information on the router, that's what I'm looking for, is plugging in externally from my computer through an ethernet cable into the router, and then accessing logged information. So MAC addresses, connected devices, prior connected devices, things like that.

Lawyer (05:08:25):

Specifically in this case, at this Airbnb, what were you looking for when you did this router interrogation?

Christopher Perryman (05:08:31):

So specifically for this one, I'm really looking for everything, anything. There's so much information there, but the most important thing was trying to see what connected devices were on the system or had been on the system previously.

Lawyer (05:08:47):

Okay. Showing you photograph 14 of State's 15. What does this show?

Christopher Perryman (05:08:50):

That's showing the router.

Lawyer (05:08:51):

Okay. And photograph 15 of State's 15, what does this show?

Christopher Perryman (05:08:55):

It's showing the, I guess the side or the back of the router.

Lawyer (05:08:58):

And on the back of the router, we see a whole bunch of information.

Christopher Perryman (05:09:01):

Yes, sir.

Lawyer (05:09:02):

Is that the information that you used in part to perform this router interrogation?

Christopher Perryman (05:09:07):

Yes, it is.

Lawyer (05:09:08):

What internet service was being used to provide internet to this Airbnb?

Christopher Perryman (05:09:12):

It was a Windstream.

Lawyer (05:09:13):

And how do you know that?

Christopher Perryman (05:09:14):

Well, a few different ways. A, the router itself is a Kinetic router. I believe on the other side, if you look, it actually says, "Kinetic by Windstream." And secondarily, through the router interrogation, I was able to observe that it was a Kinetic Windstream router, and then there was a subsequent subpoena that was sent to Windstream, which later confirmed that it was a Windstream router.

Lawyer (05:09:35):

And what information do we see in the back of the router here that was important to you?

Christopher Perryman (05:09:39):

So there's a few things there that are important. First, if you look up top, it says the make, model, below that is network name, network password, and then the bottom right shows the serial number to the router and then the MAC address, which is its unique identifier. To the left are the admin settings, username and password. So the admin settings side is what I was really focusing on.

Lawyer (05:10:03):

Is that admin setting the information that allows you to actually get inside the inner workings of the router?

Christopher Perryman (05:10:08):

Yes, it is.

Lawyer (05:10:09):

All right. So can you explain to the jury what you did and what you, logistically, from a practical standpoint, did to get into the router?

Christopher Perryman (05:10:15):

Yeah. So basically, what I did was, after determining where the router was, I use a work laptop and I take an ethernet cable and plug from my work laptop into the router using the admin private IP address. You can see on the top of the bottom left side, it says, "admin setting". There's a URL there. I used that to access an admin page, which I then used the admin username and password to access the information I was looking for.

Lawyer (05:10:47):

And did you download the relevant information from the router during that process?

Christopher Perryman (05:10:51):

Yes, I did.

Lawyer (05:10:52):

May I approach, Your Honor?

Judge (05:10:53):

Yes, sir.

Lawyer (05:10:54):

Showing you what's been marked as State's Exhibit U for identification. Take a look at that item and tell me if you recognize it.

Christopher Perryman (05:10:59):

Yes, sir, I do.

Lawyer (05:11:00):

What is it?

Christopher Perryman (05:11:00):

This is information from the router interrogation.

Lawyer (05:11:03):

Is that the information you downloaded from the router?

Christopher Perryman (05:11:06):

Yes, sir, it is.

Lawyer (05:11:07):

Is it the same or substantially the same condition as when you downloaded it, and is that just a printout of it?

Christopher Perryman (05:11:12):

Yes, sir, it's just a printout.

Lawyer (05:11:13):

At this time the State, would move U into evidence as 20.

Junior Barrett (05:11:16):

No objection, Judge.

Judge (05:11:17):

Without objection, State's Exhibit U will be admitted into evidence as State's Exhibit 20.

Lawyer (05:11:21):

Okay. May I publish?

Judge (05:11:23):

Yes, sir.

Lawyer (05:11:23):

Showing you the first page of that document called Connection Status. Kind of what information do we see here?

Christopher Perryman (05:11:30):

Looks like the IP address, just kind of basic information to the router itself.

Lawyer (05:11:38):

And we see some information like a serial number and a MAC address. Do those numbers reflect the same numbers that were on the back of the actual modem you looked at?

Christopher Perryman (05:11:50):

Yes, sir, it does.

Lawyer (05:11:51):

Okay. Showing you State's 20, along with photograph 15 of 15. Is that what this shows?

Christopher Perryman (05:12:00):

Yes, sir.

Lawyer (05:12:03):

Okay. Showing you the next page of State's 20. What does this show?

Christopher Perryman (05:12:08):

This shows a log of connected devices.

Lawyer (05:12:10):

Okay. And the part in the bottom, this is the bottom half of this, are those the actual devices that have connected to the router?

Christopher Perryman (05:12:19):

Yes, sir.

Lawyer (05:12:20):

Showing you the next page of that printout. Referring to the last two entries, what do we see there?

Christopher Perryman (05:12:27):

The last two entries are myself connecting via an ethernet cable with my computer, and then a device named Sonia-S-S22.

Lawyer (05:12:40):

Okay. So the 93753JROC, is that you?

Christopher Perryman (05:12:42):

That's me. Yes, sir.

Lawyer (05:12:43):

What is JROC?

Christopher Perryman (05:12:45):

JROC stands for the Jacksonville Regional Operation Center. So we have several different operation centers. That's one I'm out of.

Lawyer (05:12:51):

So when you logged into the router using your computer, the router recognized your computer as JROC?

Christopher Perryman (05:12:57):

That's correct.

Lawyer (05:12:58):

Okay. What's the previous entry in the log before you?

Christopher Perryman (05:13:02):

Just prior to me was Sonia-S-S22.

Lawyer (05:13:06):

And is that the name of the device that would've entered the router before you did?

Christopher Perryman (05:13:10):

Correct.

Lawyer (05:13:11):

How can you name a device?

Christopher Perryman (05:13:13):

So it's pretty simple through your settings. So a lot of people who have phones, not everyone names their devices, but it's pretty common in initial setup to name your device, but you can do it at any time. So for example, if you get into your car and you connect to Bluetooth, it typically will say, "iPhone," or whatever device. If you want to change that to Christopher's device, you could change it to "Christopher S22" and it would connect and show you.

Lawyer (05:13:42):

And the device referenced Sonia-S-S22, that was the device that connected the router before you did?

Christopher Perryman (05:13:49):

That's correct.

Lawyer (05:13:50):

Does "S22" have any significance?

Christopher Perryman (05:13:52):

Yes, sir, it does.

Lawyer (05:13:53):

What is it?

Christopher Perryman (05:13:56):

There was Google information from Sonia that showed that she had an S22 device.

Lawyer (05:14:04):

Okay. So I'm showing you the network device report from State's 20. What do we see here?

Christopher Perryman (05:14:14):

Looks like connected devices again.

Lawyer (05:14:16):

Okay. And same information, the bottom two entries, are those consistent with the last two logins to the router at the Airbnb?

Christopher Perryman (05:14:26):

Yes, sir, they are.

Lawyer (05:14:27):

You mentioned earlier, did you later send a subpoena to Windstream Internet Service for their official records related to this router?

Christopher Perryman (05:14:34):

Yes, sir, I did.

Lawyer (05:14:34):

At this time, Your Honor, the State would move State's U into evidence as State's 21. It's the records from Windstream regarding the router at the Airbnb.

Junior Barrett (05:14:42):

State U, I thought we did that.

Amy Berndt (05:14:43):

It's V. It's V. It's V.

Judge (05:14:47):

It may be V.

Lawyer (05:14:49):

V as in Victor. I apologize. Thank you. It's the records from Windstream. A business record certification is attached and proper notice has been given.

Junior Barrett (05:14:58):

No objection, Judge.

Judge (05:14:59):

Without objection, State's Exhibit V will be admitted into evidence as State's Exhibit 21.

Lawyer (05:15:09):

May I approach?

Judge (05:15:16):

Yes, sir.

Lawyer (05:15:16):

Showing you State's [inaudible 05:15:18] 21 now. Yes, 21. Do you recognize those records?

Christopher Perryman (05:15:18):

Yes, sir. I do.

Lawyer (05:15:21):

May I publish?

Judge (05:15:22):

Yes, sir.

Lawyer (05:15:24):

Showing you Page 2 of the actual Windstream records. Does the information on the Windstream records reflect the same information that you downloaded from the router itself?

Christopher Perryman (05:15:33):

Yes, sir, it does.

Lawyer (05:15:39):

Is the MAC address the same as on the router?

Christopher Perryman (05:15:41):

Yes, sir, it is.

Lawyer (05:15:44):

Okay. And according to the information from Windstream... Well, first of all, what time zone are these records in?

Christopher Perryman (05:15:57):

I believe they're in Central Time.

Lawyer (05:15:59):

Okay. So they're an hour behind Eastern?

Christopher Perryman (05:16:01):

Yes, sir.

Lawyer (05:16:09):

Did the records indicate that the authorized user of the router was Dane Miller?

Christopher Perryman (05:16:16):

Yes, sir, they did.

Lawyer (05:16:17):

Who did you determine that to be?

Christopher Perryman (05:16:18):

The owner of the Airbnb.

Lawyer (05:16:20):

Okay. Showing you photograph... or image 3 from State's 21. What do we see here?

Christopher Perryman (05:16:29):

Connected devices.

Lawyer (05:16:31):

And what is Cottage 500 and RokuTV?

Christopher Perryman (05:16:35):

Based on the name, I know that "Cottage" was a name used for the Airbnb. "RokuTV", likely what that is there was a smart TV there at the house, which would show connection to the internet, so I believe that's what it's going to be.

Lawyer (05:16:48):

Okay. And then, do we see the entries reflecting Sonia-S-S22?

Christopher Perryman (05:16:53):

Yes, sir.

Lawyer (05:16:56):

And towards the end of those records, what does this show in the red box, again, State 21?

Christopher Perryman (05:17:02):

It shows the JROC computer that I was using.

Lawyer (05:17:06):

Okay. Does this subpoenaed information from Windstream correspond and confirm the information you did from your router interrogation process?

Christopher Perryman (05:17:15):

Yes, sir, it does.

Lawyer (05:17:15):

Okay. And when was the last connection made by Sonia-S-S22? What period of time?

Christopher Perryman (05:17:28):

The last connection was October 12th of 2025.

Lawyer (05:17:31):

Okay. Thank you, sir. No other questions.

Judge (05:17:40):

Any cross-examination?

Junior Barrett (05:17:48):

Good afternoon, sir. Just a few questions.

Christopher Perryman (05:17:51):

Yes, sir.

Junior Barrett (05:17:51):

For those of us not as sophisticated [inaudible 05:17:54] as you are, can you tell from the device itself, the information you get from the router, what type of device was actually connected?

Christopher Perryman (05:18:06):

No, sir.

Junior Barrett (05:18:06):

Okay. What about how long it was connected?

Christopher Perryman (05:18:10):

You can see timeframes. So specifically, the Sonia-S-S22 device was connected from October 10th of 2025 to October 12th, 2025. So you can see some time indications there.

Junior Barrett (05:18:26):

Okay. I don't have any other questions.

Judge (05:18:43):

Okay.

(05:18:43)
Any redirect examination, State?

Lawyer (05:18:44):

No, Your Honor.

Judge (05:18:45):

Members of the jury, do any of y'all have questions of this witness? If you do, please raise your hand.

(05:18:50)
Okay, seeing no hands, State, is he released?

Lawyer (05:18:52):

He is not. He'll be recalled.

Judge (05:18:53):

Okay. All right, sir, you can step down.

Christopher Perryman (05:18:55):

Thank you.

Judge (05:18:58):

Oh, exhibits? Yes, sir. Thank you.

(05:18:59)
All right, State, you can call your next witness.

Amy Berndt (05:19:04):

State calls Vincent Moore.

Judge (05:19:41):

Come on in, sir. Raise your right hand. Face the clerk to be sworn.

Court Clerk (05:19:45):

Do you swear or affirm the testimony you're about to give will be the truth, the whole truth, and nothing but the truth, so help you God?

Vincent Moore (05:19:49):

I do.

Judge (05:19:49):

All right. You go ahead and be seated, sir.

Amy Berndt (05:19:53):

Good afternoon.

Vincent Moore (05:19:54):

Good afternoon.

Amy Berndt (05:19:54):

Can you please tell the jury your name?

Vincent Moore (05:19:57):

My name is Vincent Moore.

Amy Berndt (05:19:58):

Where do you work, Mr. Moore?

Vincent Moore (05:20:00):

I work at Walmart as an asset protection investigator.

Amy Berndt (05:20:04):

Which Walmart do you work at?

Vincent Moore (05:20:05):

The Walmart in Gainesville, Florida. It's 5700 Northwest 23rd Street.

Amy Berndt (05:20:11):

All right. How long have you worked for Walmart?

Vincent Moore (05:20:13):

I've been working for Walmart going on 10 years.

Amy Berndt (05:20:17):

And I think you said your position was an asset protection officer?

Vincent Moore (05:20:20):

Yes, ma'am.

Amy Berndt (05:20:21):

All right. And how long have you been an asset protection officer?

Vincent Moore (05:20:23):

Going on four years.

Amy Berndt (05:20:26):

What are your duties as an asset protection officer?

Vincent Moore (05:20:29):

Pretty much just focused on the safety of the store, as well as catching shoplifters.

Amy Berndt (05:20:34):

All right. Do your duties also include assisting law enforcement that may be investigating a crime?

Vincent Moore (05:20:40):

Yes, ma'am.

Amy Berndt (05:20:40):

Okay. Does the Walmart you work at in Gainesville have a surveillance system?

Vincent Moore (05:20:44):

Yes, ma'am.

Amy Berndt (05:20:45):

Does it continuously record?

Vincent Moore (05:20:47):

Yes, ma'am.

Amy Berndt (05:20:48):

Approximately how many cameras are there throughout the entire store?

Vincent Moore (05:20:52):

I can't make a number, but hundreds.

Amy Berndt (05:20:54):

Okay. Are they located inside and outside of the Walmart?

Vincent Moore (05:20:57):

Yes, ma'am.

Amy Berndt (05:20:58):

Does it basically cover the whole store?

Vincent Moore (05:21:00):

Yes, ma'am.

Amy Berndt (05:21:01):

Where is the recording system for the cameras kept?

Vincent Moore (05:21:04):

It's kept in the asset protection office.

Amy Berndt (05:21:09):

Is the asset protection office kept locked?

Vincent Moore (05:21:11):

Yes, ma'am.

Amy Berndt (05:21:12):

All right. Who has keys?

Vincent Moore (05:21:14):

Upper management in the store.

Amy Berndt (05:21:18):

So a regular cashier does not have keys to get into this office?

Vincent Moore (05:21:21):

No.

Amy Berndt (05:21:22):

All right. I want to direct your attention to October of 2025. During that timeframe, did you meet with an agent from the Florida Department of Law Enforcement who requested to view some video from October 10th of 2025?

Vincent Moore (05:21:35):

Yes.

Amy Berndt (05:21:36):

And how did the agent gain access to the system, the surveillance system?

Vincent Moore (05:21:40):

He gained it through me.

Amy Berndt (05:21:42):

Okay. You let him in?

Vincent Moore (05:21:43):

Yes.

Amy Berndt (05:21:45):

All right. Is anyone able to delete or tamper with the video footage on the surveillance system?

Vincent Moore (05:21:49):

Not at all.

Amy Berndt (05:21:51):

And was everything with the surveillance system working fine at that time?

Vincent Moore (05:21:54):

Yes.

Amy Berndt (05:21:55):

Was the date and timestamp on the system working correctly?

Vincent Moore (05:21:58):

Yes.

Amy Berndt (05:21:59):

And did you locate the video that the agent was requesting?

Vincent Moore (05:22:02):

Yes.

Amy Berndt (05:22:03):

Now, did you let the agent pull up the video on his own, or did you do it for him?

Vincent Moore (05:22:07):

I did it for him.

Amy Berndt (05:22:09):

Okay. And did you make a copy of the video and provide it to the agent?

Vincent Moore (05:22:12):

Yes.

Amy Berndt (05:22:12):

So you gave him an actual physical copy?

Vincent Moore (05:22:14):

Correct.

Amy Berndt (05:22:15):

Your Honor, may I approach the witness?

Judge (05:22:16):

Yes, ma'am.

Amy Berndt (05:22:17):

Showing you what's been marked for identification as State's Exhibit W. If you can look at that and tell me, do you recognize that?

Vincent Moore (05:22:24):

Yes.

Amy Berndt (05:22:25):

What is that?

Vincent Moore (05:22:26):

This is the surveillance video that I watched on November 2nd.

Amy Berndt (05:22:33):

This is the video that you pulled up for the agent when you came in?

Vincent Moore (05:22:37):

Oh, yes, yes, correct.

Amy Berndt (05:22:38):

And you did watch it on November 2nd?

Vincent Moore (05:22:41):

Yes.

Amy Berndt (05:22:41):

Of 2026?

Vincent Moore (05:22:41):

Yes.

Amy Berndt (05:22:42):

How do you know that that's the video that you watched?

Vincent Moore (05:22:43):

Because I see that I initialed it and dated it.

Amy Berndt (05:22:46):

And is this a fair and accurate depiction of the video from Walmart that you gave the officer from October 10th of 2025?

Vincent Moore (05:22:52):

Yes, ma'am.

Amy Berndt (05:22:58):

All right.

(05:22:58)
I don't have any other questions, Your Honor.

Junior Barrett (05:22:59):

No questions.

Judge (05:23:00):

Any cross-examination?

(05:23:01)
Members of the jury, do any of you all have questions of this witness? If you do, please raise your hand.

(05:23:06)
Seeing no hands, is he released, State?

Amy Berndt (05:23:07):

We'd ask that he be released. Thank you.

Judge (05:23:09):

Defense, is he released?

Junior Barrett (05:23:09):

No objection, Your Honor.

Judge (05:23:10):

All right, sir, you're free to go about your day. Thank you for your time.

Vincent Moore (05:23:12):

Thank you.

Judge (05:23:14):

State, you can call your next witness.

Amy Berndt (05:23:15):

State recalls Calvin Lee.

Judge (05:24:20):

All right. Come on in, sir. You can have a seat. You remain under oath.

Calvin Lee (05:24:24):

All right.

Amy Berndt (05:24:25):

Welcome back.

Calvin Lee (05:24:26):

Thank you.

Amy Berndt (05:24:26):

Can you please state your name again for the record?

Calvin Lee (05:24:28):

I'm Special Agent Calvin Lee with the Florida Department of Law Enforcement.

Amy Berndt (05:24:31):

When we last left you, it was October 14th of 2025, and you had just interviewed the defendant for a second time. I want to move on now to the next day, Wednesday, October 15th of 2025. On that date, did you respond to a Walmart to obtain some video surveillance?

Calvin Lee (05:24:46):

Yes, I did.

Amy Berndt (05:24:47):

Where was the Walmart located?

Calvin Lee (05:24:49):

It's 5700 Northwest 23rd Street in Gainesville, Florida.

Amy Berndt (05:24:54):

And what were you looking for at that Walmart?

Calvin Lee (05:24:56):

Video surveillance pertaining to two receipts that were recovered at an Airbnb in Reddick, Florida.

Amy Berndt (05:25:06):

Okay. What was the date of the video surveillance that you were looking for?

Calvin Lee (05:25:08):

October 10th, 2025.

Amy Berndt (05:25:10):

All right. And was the date and time of the video you were looking for based on those two receipts that were found at that Airbnb?

Calvin Lee (05:25:17):

Yes, they were.

Amy Berndt (05:25:18):

Who did you meet with at Walmart about obtaining the video?

Calvin Lee (05:25:20):

Vincent Moore.

Amy Berndt (05:25:20):

And who was Vincent Moore?

Calvin Lee (05:25:24):

He's the loss prevention specialist that was on duty at that time.

Amy Berndt (05:25:28):

All right. And where did you go with Mr. Moore once you arrived at the Walmart?

Calvin Lee (05:25:32):

Just inside one of the entrances of the store, there's a little room that you have to go through through a locked door. That's where their loss prevention office is.

Amy Berndt (05:25:41):

So the door was locked?

Calvin Lee (05:25:43):

Yes, it was locked.

Amy Berndt (05:25:43):

And did Mr. Moore let you in?

Calvin Lee (05:25:45):

He did.

Amy Berndt (05:25:46):

And did Mr. Moore actually work the camera to obtain the video that you were looking for?

Calvin Lee (05:25:49):

Yes, he did.

Amy Berndt (05:25:50):

Was the date and timestamp accurate on the system?

Calvin Lee (05:25:53):

Yes, it was.

Amy Berndt (05:25:54):

Did the Walmart have multiple camera views?

Calvin Lee (05:25:56):

Yes, they did.

Amy Berndt (05:25:58):

Were you able to find video from that date and time from those receipts that were found?

Calvin Lee (05:26:03):

Yes, we were.

Amy Berndt (05:26:03):

All right. And who was on the video that you found?

Calvin Lee (05:26:07):

Dwain Hall.

Amy Berndt (05:26:09):

All right. Can you briefly describe for the jury what video footage you located?

Calvin Lee (05:26:15):

So it was from several different angles throughout, but the loss prevention specialist was able to take from the point of sale on the receipt and track it backwards. So we were able to track it backwards, and then from there moving, it was Dwain Hall entering into the store. He goes into the bathroom, comes out, he's maneuvering around, he purchases some items from the sporting good register from-

Amy Berndt (05:26:42):

Let me just stop you right there. Would that be deodorant, two different kinds of rope, and a gun cleaner?

Calvin Lee (05:26:47):

Yes.

Amy Berndt (05:26:48):

Okay. That was an initial purchase?

Calvin Lee (05:26:49):

Yes.

Amy Berndt (05:26:50):

Where did he buy those things?

Calvin Lee (05:26:51):

From Walmart, but the purchase was, instead of coming back out through the self-checkouts and the normal checkouts in Walmart, he went to the point of sale register at the sporting goods store, or sporting good area of the store. So then, from there, he leaves and exits out the garden center towards that exit, but then diverts from there before actually exiting the store and goes into the secure area where the garden... the plants and shovels and things of that nature are, he's there for a few moments, comes back out with a shovel, pays for the shovel, so a second transaction there at the garden center, and then exits the store. Able to follow him back to where his vehicle is and see his vehicle leaving Walmart facility parking lot.

Amy Berndt (05:27:45):

Were these two transactions back-to-back?

Calvin Lee (05:27:48):

Within a few moments. One was at 5:47 PM, and the other one was at 5:54 PM.

Amy Berndt (05:27:56):

All right. So he doesn't leave the store and then come back in. He purchases the first items, and then goes to the garden center, gets the shovel and purchases that?

Calvin Lee (05:28:05):

Correct.

Amy Berndt (05:28:07):

Now, the area where the defendant goes and purchases the shovel in the garden center, is there an exit in there to leave the store if you actually wanted to leave the store?

Calvin Lee (05:28:16):

No, there's not. You have to exit... or enter back into the indoor garden area where the cash register is and the main exit doors, entry doors are.

Amy Berndt (05:28:27):

All right. Now, were you able to obtain the video footage that you were looking for?

Calvin Lee (05:28:30):

Yes, I was.

Amy Berndt (05:28:31):

All right. And did Mr. Moore give you an actual physical copy of that?

Calvin Lee (05:28:34):

Yes, he did.

Amy Berndt (05:28:35):

Your Honor, may I approach the witness?

Judge (05:28:36):

Yes, ma'am.

Amy Berndt (05:28:36):

I'm going to show you what's been marked for identification as State's Exhibit W and ask you if you recognize that.

Calvin Lee (05:28:40):

Yes, I do.

Amy Berndt (05:28:40):

What is that?

Calvin Lee (05:28:42):

It's a disc that's labeled Walmart Video, has my initials, CL, and the date, 10-27-2026, from when I viewed this.

Amy Berndt (05:28:51):

All right. And does that have five clips from all the videos that you looked at from the Walmart on October 10th of 2025?

Calvin Lee (05:28:57):

Yes, it does.

Amy Berndt (05:28:58):

And does it cover the areas that you know are in the Walmart since you have been there?

Calvin Lee (05:29:02):

Yes, it does.

Amy Berndt (05:29:03):

Your Honor, at this time we move State's Exhibit W into evidence.

Junior Barrett (05:29:06):

No objection, Your Honor.

Judge (05:29:07):

Without objection, State's Exhibit W will be admitted into evidence as State's Exhibit 22.

Amy Berndt (05:29:13):

And Judge, I would ask to publish, please.

Judge (05:29:14):

Yes, ma'am.

Amy Berndt (05:29:22):

And are these all running together, all five clips?

Calvin Lee (05:29:24):

They are.

Amy Berndt (05:29:45):

And who is that that we see in the video?

Calvin Lee (05:29:47):

That is Dwain Hall.

Speaker 21 (05:31:10):

And is this the garden center that we talked about earlier?

Speaker 23 (05:31:12):

Yes, that's the outdoor area.

Speaker 21 (05:34:30):

Okay. Thank you. I don't have any further questions, Your Honor.

Speaker 24 (05:35:06):

No questions, Judge.

Judge Timothy McCourt (05:35:08):

Members of the jury, any of y'all have questions of this witness? If you do, please raise your hands. Seeing no hands, State, is he released?

Speaker 21 (05:35:14):

We would ask that he be excused finally.

Judge Timothy McCourt (05:35:16):

Okay. Defense?

Speaker 24 (05:35:17):

No objection, Judge.

Judge Timothy McCourt (05:35:18):

All right. Sir, you're free to go about your day. Thank you for your time.

Speaker 23 (05:35:21):

Thank you.

Judge Timothy McCourt (05:35:21):

Members of the jury, we've been back now for about an hour. Does anybody need a bathroom break or are you good with going to another witness? Next witness it is, State.

Lawyer (05:35:29):

State calls Daniel Buser.

Judge Timothy McCourt (05:36:04):

Come in, sir. Raise your right hand if you could. Face the clerk and be placed under oath.

Speaker 22 (05:36:07):

Do you swear or affirm the testimony you're about to give will be the truth, the whole truth, and nothing but the truth, so help you God?

Daniel Buser (05:36:11):

I do swear.

Judge Timothy McCourt (05:36:13):

All right. You go ahead and be seated, sir.

Lawyer (05:36:18):

Good afternoon, sir.

Daniel Buser (05:36:18):

Good afternoon.

Lawyer (05:36:19):

Can you please introduce yourself to the jury and spell your last name?

Daniel Buser (05:36:22):

Hi, my name is Daniel Buser. Last name B-U-S-E-R.

Lawyer (05:36:26):

Where do you work?

Daniel Buser (05:36:27):

I work at BP TravelCenters of America Petro.

Lawyer (05:36:31):

And what is that?

Daniel Buser (05:36:31):

That is a truck stop chain.

Lawyer (05:36:34):

How long have you worked there?

Daniel Buser (05:36:36):

15 years.

Lawyer (05:36:37):

What's the address of the business that you work at now?

Daniel Buser (05:36:41):

7401 West Highway 318, Reddick, Florida.

Lawyer (05:36:45):

And generally, where is that located in relation to I-75?

Daniel Buser (05:36:49):

I-75, right off the exit. As soon as you get off, it's on the right-hand side.

Lawyer (05:36:53):

Is there a Wendy's also in that same area?

Daniel Buser (05:36:55):

Yeah, there's a Wendy's as well.

Lawyer (05:36:56):

Let me direct your attention to October 16th, 2025. Did a Florida Department of Law Enforcement agent come to your store and show you several photographs of some items?

Daniel Buser (05:37:07):

Yes.

Lawyer (05:37:07):

Okay. Showing you photograph 11 of State's 15. Do you recognize the container?

Daniel Buser (05:37:16):

I do.

Lawyer (05:37:17):

And what would normally be in this container?

Daniel Buser (05:37:20):

To the right, the PB&J white grape would be actually a peanut butter and jelly sandwich on white bread.

Lawyer (05:37:25):

Okay. And showing you photograph 12 of State's 15. What does this show?

Daniel Buser (05:37:29):

That is a container that we usually chop our strawberries up and put in that.

Lawyer (05:37:33):

Did your store sell those two items in these containers?

Daniel Buser (05:37:38):

Yes.

Lawyer (05:37:40):

When the Florida Department of Law Enforcement agent came to your store and met with you, did he ask you to search recent transactions for purchases of these two items?

Daniel Buser (05:37:49):

Yes.

Lawyer (05:37:49):

And were you able to do that?

Daniel Buser (05:37:50):

I was able to find the receipt, yes.

Lawyer (05:37:52):

How do you go about doing that kind of a search?

Daniel Buser (05:37:54):

We go into the back office system to search any past electronic logs that are usually older than a few hours, and we search through that. We go through the logins and all that and get that electronic statements from those back office systems.

Lawyer (05:38:09):

Who has access to that system that you use to search?

Daniel Buser (05:38:12):

Anybody that has a username and password, usually management or leadership, like a lead or something of that nature will usually have access.

Lawyer (05:38:19):

And you indicated you need a username and password to even access the system?

Daniel Buser (05:38:22):

Correct.

Lawyer (05:38:24):

When you did that search, were you able to find a transaction of those two items at the same time?

Daniel Buser (05:38:30):

Yes.

Lawyer (05:38:31):

Were you able to pull up a transaction history or a receipt showing the date and time and purchase of those items?

Daniel Buser (05:38:37):

Yes, I printed a receipt for those items.

Lawyer (05:38:39):

Does your system create those records, those transaction records in the normal course of your business?

Daniel Buser (05:38:45):

Yeah, as they occur when they ring up, it creates a receipt.

Lawyer (05:38:48):

Okay. So right when the item is scanned and the purchase is made, it generates a record in the system?

Daniel Buser (05:38:52):

Yeah. Even if you voided it still would show as a voided thing in the system, but it would show as a receipt when it's complete sale.

Lawyer (05:38:59):

Okay. Does the system maintain those records for a period of time as the normal course of your business?

Daniel Buser (05:39:04):

For a period of time. I don't know for exactly how long, but definitely.

Lawyer (05:39:08):

Okay. Do you have the ability to go into your system and alter those records in any way?

Daniel Buser (05:39:12):

No, there is no way I can do that.

Lawyer (05:39:18):

May I approach?

Judge Timothy McCourt (05:39:19):

Yes, sir.

Lawyer (05:39:20):

Showing you what's been marked as State's Exhibit X for identification. Do you recognize that document?

Daniel Buser (05:39:25):

Yes.

Lawyer (05:39:25):

What is it?

Daniel Buser (05:39:26):

It's a clarification on the receipts used with a debit card and to purchase PB&J wheat and strawberries.

Lawyer (05:39:34):

Is that the receipt you pulled up and provided to the Florida Department of Law Enforcement?

Daniel Buser (05:39:38):

Yeah, it is.

Lawyer (05:39:39):

Does it fairly and accurately depict the transaction that you found in your system?

Daniel Buser (05:39:43):

Yes.

Lawyer (05:39:43):

This time, state would move X into evidence as State's 23.

Speaker 24 (05:39:47):

No objection, Judge.

Judge Timothy McCourt (05:39:48):

Without objection, State's Exhibit X will be admitted into evidence as State's Exhibit 23.

Lawyer (05:39:52):

May I publish?

Judge Timothy McCourt (05:39:53):

Yes, sir.

Lawyer (05:39:54):

Showing you State's 23. Can you explain to the jury what we see here?

Daniel Buser (05:39:58):

Well, you see a transaction receipt. You got the date on the top with the time of the transaction, the register number it was done on, the transaction number it is, which store number, the employee ID who rang up that transaction, as well as all the information of all the things purchased with the total and the debit card information showing the last four and the first six.

Lawyer (05:40:19):

Okay. And does this purchase receipt for PB&J wheat and strawberries, is that consistent with the two photos of the containers that the FDLE agent provided to you?

Daniel Buser (05:40:27):

That is correct, yes.

Lawyer (05:40:28):

And what were the last four digits of the debit card used to make the purchase according to the receipt?

Daniel Buser (05:40:32):

8343.

Lawyer (05:40:34):

Does the travel center also have a surveillance system within and around the business?

Daniel Buser (05:40:41):

That's correct, yes.

Lawyer (05:40:42):

And are part of your duties to check and monitor that surveillance system and pull footage if need be?

Daniel Buser (05:40:47):

If need be. To provide footage, anything like that, it requires our loss prevention team, but other than that, I am able to, yes, review it and look at it.

Lawyer (05:40:57):

Okay. So you would review it and if it needed to be burned, you'd have to get permission from the loss prevention team?

Daniel Buser (05:41:02):

Correct. Yes. Mm-hmm.

Lawyer (05:41:05):

Okay. What kind of surveillance system is it? Is it a DVR-based system or a cloud-based?

Daniel Buser (05:41:09):

A DVR.

Lawyer (05:41:12):

And is that system motion-activated or is it record continuously?

Daniel Buser (05:41:16):

It has the ability to do both.

Lawyer (05:41:18):

Okay. Where is the hub of that surveillance system located in the TA patrol?

Daniel Buser (05:41:23):

A manager's office.

Lawyer (05:41:24):

Is it kept in a locked room?

Daniel Buser (05:41:26):

Yes. And in a locked box as well in that room. Yeah.

Lawyer (05:41:31):

Who has access to that surveillance system?

Daniel Buser (05:41:34):

Usually anything from a system manager to above. They have a login ID that they can utilize.

Lawyer (05:41:39):

Okay. Generally, what areas of the store does the surveillance system cover?

Daniel Buser (05:41:46):

Most inside, some outside. Yeah, that's about best [inaudible 05:41:54].

Lawyer (05:41:55):

Were you also asked by that same Florida Department of Law Enforcement agent to review surveillance footage to capture the purchase of the PB&J and the strawberries reflected in the receipt?

Daniel Buser (05:42:07):

Yes.

Lawyer (05:42:09):

Were you able to pull surveillance footage reflecting that purchase?

Daniel Buser (05:42:13):

Yeah, we were able to find the transaction time and the camera system as well.

Lawyer (05:42:23):

Okay. At some point, were you given permission to provide that footage to the agent?

Daniel Buser (05:42:28):

Yeah. I had to contact loss prevention in order to get something like that and they would burn it for us, send it either to us in the zip file or even to the officer or whoever requested it to their email as well. I can't recall exactly what transpired during that, but we provided it to them. I know that.

Lawyer (05:42:45):

And would you have reviewed the footage prior to sending it out?

Daniel Buser (05:42:48):

Yes. Yeah. Mm-hmm.

Lawyer (05:42:48):

Okay. Was the timestamp on the footage accurate?

Daniel Buser (05:42:51):

Yes.

Lawyer (05:42:52):

Any problems with the DVR system?

Daniel Buser (05:42:53):

No.

Lawyer (05:42:53):

Okay. Was there any indication that the footage had been altered or tampered with in any way?

Daniel Buser (05:43:01):

No.

Lawyer (05:43:01):

Do you have the ability to go into the system and alter or tamper with the footage?

Daniel Buser (05:43:05):

No.

Lawyer (05:43:05):

May I approach, your honor?

Judge Timothy McCourt (05:43:08):

Yes, sir.

Lawyer (05:43:08):

Showing you what's been marked as State's Exhibit Y for identification. Do you recognize that disc?

‍

Daniel Buser (05:43:13):

Yes, I do.

Lawyer (05:43:14):

How do you recognize it?

Daniel Buser (05:43:16):

I reviewed it with you, and we initialed and dated on the top there the date it was 11/4/26.

Lawyer (05:43:23):

Okay. And that was the date you watched it?

Daniel Buser (05:43:25):

Yes, sir.

Lawyer (05:43:25):

And did you initial it?

Daniel Buser (05:43:26):

Yes.

Lawyer (05:43:27):

Okay. Does that fairly and accurately depict the surveillance footage from inside the store that you've discussed and that you provided to the Florida Department of Law Enforcement agent?

Daniel Buser (05:43:35):

That is correct, yes.

Lawyer (05:43:35):

At this time, State would move Y into evidence as 24.

Speaker 24 (05:43:38):

No objection, Judge.

Judge Timothy McCourt (05:43:39):

Without objection, State's Exhibit Y will be admitted into evidence as State's Exhibit 24.

Lawyer (05:43:44):

Thank you, sir. No other questions.

Daniel Buser (05:43:45):

No problem.

Judge Timothy McCourt (05:43:45):

Any question [inaudible 05:43:47]-

Speaker 24 (05:43:46):

No questions, Judge.

Judge Timothy McCourt (05:43:47):

Members of the jury, any of y'all have questions of this witness? If you do, please raise your hand. Seeing no hands, is he released? State?

Lawyer (05:43:54):

He is, You're Honor.

Judge Timothy McCourt (05:43:54):

Defense?

Speaker 24 (05:43:55):

Yes, Judge. No objection. May we approach after the court's release him?

Judge Timothy McCourt (05:43:58):

Yes. All right, sir, you're free to go about your day. Thank you for your time.

Daniel Buser (05:44:01):

Thank you. Appreciate it.

Judge Timothy McCourt (05:44:01):

Yes, lawyers, y'all can approach.

(05:44:02)
We're going to take a little bathroom break here. It's about 1:52. This will be about a 10-minute break, so use the restroom, get a drink of water. We'll give you the two-minute warning as we've been doing. Again, leave your notepads here. Keep your binders closed up and leave them on your chair. On the break, don't discuss the case with one another. And again, if you use your phones or electronic devices over the break, don't use them to research the case or look up anything about the case or communicate with anybody about the case. See you all back shortly.

Speaker X (05:44:46):

[inaudible 05:44:46].

(05:44:46)
Yep, the [inaudible 05:45:02].

(05:44:46)
[inaudible 05:45:09].

(05:44:46)
Sure. [inaudible 05:45:11].

(05:44:46)
[inaudible 05:45:16].

Judge Timothy McCourt (05:45:27):

The record should reflect the jury has left the courtroom. This is a quick word to the folks in the audience. I want everybody here to remember that court is in session even when the jury is filing out, okay? And if the judge is on the bench, court is in session. That's usually a good indicator. It got a little noisy right before the lunch break, so just make sure that as you all are filing in and out at recesses, just remember there may be other things we have to take up before we recess, so we need to make sure the volume of the audience is down. Be back in about 10 minutes. See what we [inaudible 05:46:08].

(05:45:58)
All right. Good, yes.

Speaker X (05:45:58):

[inaudible 05:54:12].

(05:45:58)
Oh, yeah. [inaudible 05:54:12].

Lawyer (05:54:17):

I'm afraid of it, so yeah.

Speaker X (05:54:17):

[inaudible 05:54:23].

(05:54:17)
[inaudible 05:54:30].

Judge Timothy McCourt (05:54:17):

Okay. Let's bring him in.

Lawyer (05:54:17):

[inaudible 05:54:56]. Show them we understand. [inaudible 05:55:19].

Speaker X (05:54:17):

[inaudible 05:55:23].

Judge Timothy McCourt (05:55:45):

Y'all can be seated. Thank you. Welcome back. State, you can call your next witness.

Lawyer (05:55:50):

State calls Patrick Vitellaro.

Judge Timothy McCourt (05:56:29):

Come on in. Raise your right hand, face the clerk to be sworn.

Speaker 22 (05:56:32):

Do you swear or affirm the testimony you're about to give will be the truth, the whole truth, and nothing but the truth, so help you God?

Patrick Vitellaro (05:56:35):

I swear.

Judge Timothy McCourt (05:56:35):

Okay. You go ahead and be seated.

Patrick Vitellaro (05:56:35):

Thank you, Your Honor.

Lawyer (05:56:44):

Thank you, Your Honor.

(05:56:44)
Morning. Good afternoon, sir.

Patrick Vitellaro (05:56:45):

Good afternoon, sir.

Lawyer (05:56:45):

Can you please introduce yourself to the jury?

Patrick Vitellaro (05:56:47):

Yeah. My name is Special Agent Patrick Vitellaro with the Florida Department of Law Enforcement.

Lawyer (05:56:52):

How long have you been with FDLE?

Patrick Vitellaro (05:56:54):

About four years.

Lawyer (05:56:56):

Where did you work prior to that?

Patrick Vitellaro (05:56:57):

Prior to that, I was with the Clay County Sheriff's Office.

Lawyer (05:56:59):

And what did you do for Clay County?

Patrick Vitellaro (05:57:01):

My last assignment for the last eight years I was there was a robbery homicide detective.

Lawyer (05:57:06):

What do you do for FDLE now?

Patrick Vitellaro (05:57:09):

I'm part of the major case squad, investigate officer-involved shootings, in-custody deaths, and assist other agencies with cold cases and homicides.

Lawyer (05:57:20):

Did you become involved in the investigation into the murder of Sonia Exelby?

Patrick Vitellaro (05:57:24):

I did.

Lawyer (05:57:25):

Were you asked to try to track down the location of the purchase of some items found in the garbage located at an Airbnb in Reddick?

Patrick Vitellaro (05:57:34):

Yes.

Lawyer (05:57:36):

Were you also tasked with trying to recover any surveillance footage that reflected that purchase?

Patrick Vitellaro (05:57:42):

Yes.

Lawyer (05:57:43):

Showing you photograph 11 of State's 15. Do you recognize the container in this photo?

Patrick Vitellaro (05:57:48):

I do.

Lawyer (05:57:49):

And how do you recognize it?

Patrick Vitellaro (05:57:52):

Well, the one on the far left is the Dunkin' Donuts cup, but the two that I was tasked with tracking down is the cylindrical container, which was strawberries, and the other one is like a triangle shaped container for PB&J or peanut butter and jelly sandwich.

Lawyer (05:58:13):

Okay. And photograph 12 of state's 15, it's just a close up of the strawberry container? Okay. So what did you do to try to find out where these items were purchased from?

Patrick Vitellaro (05:58:24):

So the items looked like they came from convenience store. We knew that there was a truck stop approximately 7 miles away from the Airbnb, so I went there.

Lawyer (05:58:36):

Did you bring the photos with you that we looked at?

Patrick Vitellaro (05:58:37):

I did.

Lawyer (05:58:38):

What did you do when you got there?

Patrick Vitellaro (05:58:39):

I looked around the store to find these items to start with, and these are right by the front, by the counters.

Lawyer (05:58:45):

Okay. At some point, did you ask the loss prevention officer there to look for purchases recently for these two items?

Patrick Vitellaro (05:58:56):

Yeah. So we identified those items the night we were out there. The loss prevention was not at the business, so I left my business card and spoke to him the next day.

Lawyer (05:59:11):

Okay. And did you eventually go back to the travel center and collect the information that you asked them to provide?

Patrick Vitellaro (05:59:17):

Yes.

Lawyer (05:59:18):

What happened when you got there the next day?

Patrick Vitellaro (05:59:20):

So I actually sent a formal request to their loss prevention headquarters on our letterhead. And then they looked for these items in recent sales, and they found one specific with only the strawberries and the peanut butter and jelly sandwich.

Lawyer (05:59:41):

Did you ask loss prevention to provide you a copy of the transaction for those purchases?

Patrick Vitellaro (05:59:46):

Yes.

Lawyer (05:59:46):

Okay. I'm showing you what's been introduced into evidence as State's 23. Does that look familiar?

Patrick Vitellaro (05:59:51):

Yes.

Lawyer (05:59:51):

All right. Were you also provided surveillance footage from the travel center deflecting this purchase?

Patrick Vitellaro (06:00:01):

I was.

Lawyer (06:00:02):

May I publish at this time State's 24, Your Honor?

Judge Timothy McCourt (06:00:05):

Yes, sir.

Lawyer (06:00:31):

And according to the surveillance, what's the timestamp footage?

Patrick Vitellaro (06:00:35):

October 11th, 2025 at 12:06 PM.

Lawyer (06:00:39):

Okay. Were still shots also generated of this surveillance footage, kind of zoomed in a little bit.

Patrick Vitellaro (06:00:47):

Yes.

Lawyer (06:00:47):

May I approach, Your Honor?

Judge Timothy McCourt (06:00:49):

Yes, sir.

Lawyer (06:00:50):

Showing you State's Exhibit Z for identification. Can you take a look at those two photos and tell me if you recognize them?

Patrick Vitellaro (06:00:58):

Yeah, I recognize them.

Lawyer (06:00:59):

And what are they?

Patrick Vitellaro (06:01:02):

That is the transaction where Dwain Hall purchased the peanut butter and jelly sandwich and the strawberries.

Lawyer (06:01:13):

Are those still shots from the video that we just looked at?

Patrick Vitellaro (06:01:14):

Yes.

Lawyer (06:01:15):

At this time, State would move Z into evidence as 25.

Speaker 24 (06:01:19):

No objection, Judge.

Judge Timothy McCourt (06:01:20):

Without objection, what's been marked for identification as State's Exhibit Z will be admitted into evidence as State's Exhibit 25.

Lawyer (06:01:26):

May I publish?

Judge Timothy McCourt (06:01:27):

Yes, sir.

Lawyer (06:01:28):

Showing you Image 1 from that surveillance footage and Image 2. Thank you, sir. No other questions at this time, Your Honor.

Speaker 24 (06:01:40):

No questions, Judge.

Judge Timothy McCourt (06:01:42):

Members of the jury, [inaudible 06:01:44]. Agent, have a seat.

Lawyer (06:01:45):

Yes, sir.

Judge Timothy McCourt (06:01:46):

This court allows its jurors to ask questions.

Patrick Vitellaro (06:01:48):

I apologize.

Judge Timothy McCourt (06:01:49):

Members of the jury, do any of y'all have questions of this witness? With that being said, now may he be released?

Lawyer (06:01:54):

Yes, Your Honor.

Speaker 24 (06:01:55):

No objection, Judge.

Lawyer (06:01:56):

He'll be recalled, but yes for now, Your Honor.

Judge Timothy McCourt (06:01:57):

Okay. You're free to step down, sir.

Patrick Vitellaro (06:01:59):

Thank you.

Judge Timothy McCourt (06:01:59):

State, next witness.

Lawyer (06:02:00):

State calls Riley Artman.

Judge Timothy McCourt (06:03:00):

Come on in, sir. You can go ahead and be seated. You remain under oath.

Judge McCourt (06:03:00):

Come on in, sir. You can go ahead and be seated. You remain under oath.

Lawyer (06:03:03):

Hello again.

Riley Artman (06:03:06):

Hello.

Lawyer (06:03:07):

Can you please tell us your name again?

Riley Artman (06:03:09):

Riley Artman.

Lawyer (06:03:09):

All right. Remind us again where you work.

Riley Artman (06:03:14):

I work for the Marion County Sheriff's Office as a patrol deputy.

Lawyer (06:03:16):

All right. Let me direct your attention to October 17th of 2025. Did you conduct a traffic stop on a black 2019 Jeep Cherokee with tag JMIQ49?

Riley Artman (06:03:28):

Yes, sir.

Lawyer (06:03:28):

I'm showing you photograph one of State's 14. Does that vehicle look familiar?

Riley Artman (06:03:33):

Yes, sir.

Lawyer (06:03:33):

Is that the Jeep you stopped?

Riley Artman (06:03:35):

Yes, sir.

Lawyer (06:03:35):

Was anyone with you when you performed this traffic stop?

Riley Artman (06:03:39):

Special Agent Esquivel was in the passenger seat.

Lawyer (06:03:42):

All right. Of your car?

Riley Artman (06:03:43):

Yes, sir.

Lawyer (06:03:44):

Were you driving?

Riley Artman (06:03:44):

I was driving. Yes, sir.

Lawyer (06:03:45):

About what time of day did this traffic stop happen?

Riley Artman (06:03:47):

Around 7:50 in the morning.

Lawyer (06:03:50):

Okay. And where was the traffic stop actually done?

Riley Artman (06:03:53):

On I-75 northbound.

Lawyer (06:03:57):

Okay. Did you have information beforehand that this vehicle was traveling on I-75 northbound?

Riley Artman (06:04:02):

Yes, sir.

Lawyer (06:04:03):

All right. Had other officers been doing surveillance on this vehicle to let you know its location?

Riley Artman (06:04:09):

Yes, sir.

Lawyer (06:04:13):

All right. Were you in a marked patrol car?

Riley Artman (06:04:15):

I was in a marked patrol car. Yes, sir.

Lawyer (06:04:16):

Were you in uniform, and wearing some kind of Marion County Sheriff's Office insignia?

Riley Artman (06:04:20):

Yes, sir.

Lawyer (06:04:21):

Can you explain to the jury how the traffic stop was done?

Riley Artman (06:04:25):

We were both traveling northbound on I-75. When I was told to, I initiated a traffic stop, called out on the radio, activated my emergency lights, and we pulled over on the soft shoulder of the interstate, still going northbound.

Lawyer (06:04:38):

Okay. Did the vehicle in the photograph pull over properly?

Riley Artman (06:04:41):

Yes, sir.

Lawyer (06:04:42):

All right. Who was the driver of the vehicle?

Riley Artman (06:04:44):

Mr. Dwain. Mr. Hall.

Lawyer (06:04:48):

Okay. Remember his last name?

Riley Artman (06:04:50):

Yes.

Lawyer (06:04:50):

Hall?

Riley Artman (06:04:50):

Hall.

Lawyer (06:04:51):

Okay. Do you see Mr. Hall in court here today?

Riley Artman (06:04:54):

Yes, sir.

Lawyer (06:04:54):

Can you please point him out and tell me what he's wearing and where he's sitting?

Riley Artman (06:04:57):

He is sitting in that chair right there wearing the purple button up shirt.

Lawyer (06:05:00):

Your Honor, may the record reflect the witness has identified the defendant?

Speaker 25 (06:05:04):

No objection.

Judge McCourt (06:05:04):

Without objection, the record will reflect the witness has identified the defendant.

Lawyer (06:05:07):

Was anybody else in the vehicle with the defendant?

Riley Artman (06:05:10):

I believe his wife was in the passenger seat.

Lawyer (06:05:12):

Okay. Do you remember her name?

Riley Artman (06:05:14):

I do not.

Lawyer (06:05:14):

Okay. While at the traffic stop, were you made aware of a firearm located inside the Jeep?

Riley Artman (06:05:22):

Yes, sir.

Lawyer (06:05:23):

And what was done with the defendant's wife?

Riley Artman (06:05:27):

She was given transport up to her doctor's appointment in Gainesville, I believe.

Lawyer (06:05:32):

Did the patrol unit take her up there, or...

Riley Artman (06:05:34):

Yes, sir. Another marked unit responded, and gave her a ride to her appointment.

Lawyer (06:05:40):

Okay. You guys didn't want her to miss that medical day-

Riley Artman (06:05:41):

Of course not, no.

Lawyer (06:05:42):

... so you took her there?

Riley Artman (06:05:43):

Yes, sir.

Lawyer (06:05:43):

I understand. What was done with the defendant?

Riley Artman (06:05:48):

He volunteered to go for an interview at our interview rooms at the main office.

Lawyer (06:05:55):

Okay. And how did he get from the location of the traffic stop to Marion County Sheriff's Office?

Riley Artman (06:05:58):

I provided him with a ride to that office.

Lawyer (06:06:01):

Was his vehicle also towed to the Marion County Sheriff's Office?

Riley Artman (06:06:05):

Yes, sir.

Lawyer (06:06:05):

All right. At some point during your interaction with the defendant, did you recover a knife from his body, in his possession?

Riley Artman (06:06:15):

I was provided a knife that was recovered from his person. Yes, sir.

Lawyer (06:06:17):

Okay. And how did that come about?

Riley Artman (06:06:20):

I was inside my car, but one of the other units on scene was speaking to him. I guess they were asking if had any weapons or anything like that on him, he provided the knife to them, and the knife was then provided to me.

Lawyer (06:06:31):

Okay. So you're all around, and another officer takes it and hands it to you?

Riley Artman (06:06:34):

Yes.

Lawyer (06:06:34):

May I approach?

Judge McCourt (06:06:34):

Yes, sir.

Lawyer (06:06:36):

Showing you what's been marked as State's Exhibit AA for identification. Can you open that up, look inside, and tell me if you recognize the contents?

Riley Artman (06:06:43):

Does it matter where I cut on the back, sir?

Lawyer (06:06:45):

Not really.

Riley Artman (06:06:58):

Okay. I do recognize it.

Lawyer (06:06:59):

Okay. What is it?

Riley Artman (06:07:00):

It is a foldable pocket knife.

Lawyer (06:07:02):

Is it the same, or substantially the same condition as what was taken off the defendant and given to you?

Riley Artman (06:07:06):

Yes, sir.

Lawyer (06:07:06):

At this time, State would move AA into evidence as 26.

Speaker 25 (06:07:09):

No objection, Judge.

Judge McCourt (06:07:10):

Without objection, State's Exhibit AA will be admitted into evidence as State's Exhibit 26.

Lawyer (06:07:15):

Did all of this happen in Marion County?

Riley Artman (06:07:16):

Yes, sir.

Speaker 26 (06:07:17):

Right.

Lawyer (06:07:22):

No further questions at this time. Thank you, sir.

Speaker 25 (06:07:24):

No questions, Judge.

Judge McCourt (06:07:25):

Members of the jury, any of y'all have questions of this witness? Okay, go ahead and write it down. Wait, wait, wait. Remember how we're going to do the questions, okay? So I'll go ahead and explain-

Speaker 26 (06:07:33):

Oh.

Judge McCourt (06:07:33):

... it again to everybody. If you have any questions of the witness, you can write it down. Write it down on a clean piece of paper with nothing on the paper except the question that you wish to ask, or for the court to ask, and you need to write the question verbatim like you would like me to read it. Again, I remind you, the rules of evidence apply, regardless of whether a question is posed to a witness by the jury, by the court, or by the lawyer. So there may be a legal reason why I cannot ask your questions. Once I have it though, we'll go over it with the lawyers, and we'll see what we can do. Lawyers, if you want to peremptorily approach, you can.

Speaker 27 (06:08:19):

Your Honor, did you want to put the white noise on?

Judge McCourt (06:08:53):

Detective, I'm going to ask you the question that the jurors have written.

Riley Artman (06:08:56):

Yes, sir.

Judge McCourt (06:08:58):

What was the purpose of the traffic stop? Routine, speeding, et cetera, or was he looking for that specific vehicle?

Riley Artman (06:09:04):

I believe they were looking for that specific vehicle, and they had questions related to another matter that I was not a part of. I was just instructed by the special agents who were on scene to stop the vehicle.

Judge McCourt (06:09:15):

Okay. State, any follow up?

Lawyer (06:09:17):

No, your Honor.

Judge McCourt (06:09:18):

Defense, any follow up?

Speaker 25 (06:09:19):

No, your Honor.

Judge McCourt (06:09:19):

Members of the jury, any additional questions of this witness? If so, raise your hand, please. I see no hands. State, is he released?

Lawyer (06:09:26):

He is, Your Honor.

Judge McCourt (06:09:26):

Okay. Defense?

Speaker 25 (06:09:27):

No objection, Your Honor.

Judge McCourt (06:09:28):

Okay. Sir, you're free to go about your day. Thank you for your time.

Riley Artman (06:09:30):

Thanks, sir.

Judge McCourt (06:09:31):

All right. State, you can call your next witness.

Lawyer (06:09:34):

I'm not positive that the witness is here yet. I believe she probably is, but I don't know. Ashley Vidot? I'm being informed she's a few minutes out, Your Honor. We're about 20 minutes ahead of schedule.

Judge McCourt (06:09:46):

Yes, sir. What about the witness after her? They have the same arrival time?

Speaker 28 (06:09:52):

Yeah, [inaudible 06:09:53].

Lawyer (06:09:53):

They're coming together. They're both going to be short.

Judge McCourt (06:09:57):

Okay. Ladies and gentlemen, how about a five-minute break? Take your notepads, fold them up, leave them on your chairs faced down. Don't discuss the case with one another, use electronic devices to learn about the case, or do research about the case, okay? See you back shortly. All right. Y'all can be seated.

Lawyer (06:10:57):

We called in the last break to move everybody up, so I apologize.

Judge McCourt (06:10:59):

Yes, sir. No, it's okay. It happens. I'd rather this than be behind. Do you have somebody back to advise y'all when they get to arrive?

Lawyer (06:11:07):

Yes, we have somebody in contact with the witnesses.

Judge McCourt (06:11:12):

Okay. Is there anything we can use this couple minutes for to address that we have to later eventually anyway? Let's talk about the video, you said it's a four hour, 40 minute video. If we start playing it at roughly 3:00, are there any logical stopping points or breaks in the interview? I would not want to stop the interview for the day, mid-question obviously, but-

Lawyer (06:11:34):

There really is not a logical stopping point until about four hours into it. So I think we're going to just have to stop it whenever the court sees fit.

Judge McCourt (06:11:48):

Okay. [inaudible 06:11:46]. We can do that, and then just back it up a couple minutes tomorrow morning when we restart it.

Lawyer (06:11:52):

Yes, sir.

Speaker 28 (06:11:53):

I was thinking of [inaudible 06:11:55].

Lawyer (06:11:53):

[inaudible 06:10:00].

Speaker 28 (06:11:53):

[inaudible 06:12:08].

Judge McCourt (06:12:55):

State, for tomorrow's schedule, it looks like you start off with still playing defendant's statement, and then you have Ms. Osted arriving at 11:30. She'll be moved up accordingly?

Lawyer (06:13:06):

Yes, Your Honor.

Speaker 28 (06:13:06):

Yes, Your Honor.

Judge McCourt (06:13:07):

And the witnesses that you have coming tomorrow afternoon, if we believe that we are capable of getting to them in the morning, would you be able to move them up as well?

Lawyer (06:13:15):

Depending on how long we get through the interview today, we'll know exactly how long tomorrow morning will take, and we'll move up accordingly.

Speaker 29 (06:13:24):

Hey, [inaudible 06:13:25].

Lawyer (06:13:43):

[inaudible 06:13:26]. The second witness is here. The first one is not quite here yet.

Judge McCourt (06:13:45):

Okay.

Lawyer (06:13:47):

They're both Marion County Sheriff's Office employees coming from the Sheriff's Office.

Judge McCourt (06:13:50):

Yeah. Yeah.

Lawyer (06:13:50):

Okay. We're ready, Your Honor. Thank you for your patience.

Judge McCourt (06:19:32):

Yes, sir. Let's go and bring in the jury.

(06:19:32)
Ladies and gentlemen, welcome back. State, you can call your next witness.

Lawyer (06:21:08):

State calls Ashley Vidot.

Judge McCourt (06:21:46):

Ma'am, raise your right hand, face the clerk to be sworn.

Clerk (06:21:48):

Do you swear or affirm the testimony you're about to give will be the truth, the whole truth, and nothing but the truth, so help you God?

Ashley Vidot (06:21:51):

I do.

Judge McCourt (06:21:51):

You can go ahead and be seated.

Lawyer (06:22:00):

Good afternoon.

Ashley Vidot (06:22:01):

Good afternoon.

Lawyer (06:22:02):

Will you please introduce yourself to the jury, and spell your last name for them?

Ashley Vidot (06:22:04):

I'm Ashley Vidot. My first name's A-S-H-L-E-Y. Last name is V, as in Victor, I, D as in delta, O-T, as in tango.

Lawyer (06:22:13):

Where do you work?

Ashley Vidot (06:22:13):

I work at the Marion County Sheriff's Office.

Lawyer (06:22:15):

What do you do for them?

Ashley Vidot (06:22:16):

I'm the Assistant Forensics Director, so I oversee all the forensics, which includes the DNA lab, firearms, latents, the evidence property room. I think that's it now. Nope, crime scene as well. Sorry.

Lawyer (06:22:29):

Did you also use to process crime scenes?

Ashley Vidot (06:22:31):

Yes. I'm cross-trained. I actually came from the DNA lab, so I was a DNA technician, cross-trained in crime scene, and I'm a Certified Crime Scene Analyst.

Lawyer (06:22:40):

Trained in the proper ways of collecting evidence and things like that?

Ashley Vidot (06:22:43):

Correct.

Lawyer (06:22:44):

Okay. Let me direct your attention to October 17th of 2025. Were you made aware that a black Jeep Cherokee belonging to Dwain Hall had been brought to the Marion County Sheriff's Office [inaudible 06:22:55] to be processed?

Ashley Vidot (06:22:56):

Yes.

Lawyer (06:22:57):

All right. And how did you come to learn that?

Ashley Vidot (06:22:59):

Detective Karla Santana-Palau contacted me, advising that she needed something out of the vehicle that just came into the bay.

Lawyer (06:23:06):

And what were you asked to do?

Ashley Vidot (06:23:07):

I was asked to get a cell phone, as well as a bag that had medications for somebody that needed it.

Lawyer (06:23:14):

And had law enforcement obtained a search warrant that would allow you and other officers to go inside that vehicle to process it for evidence?

Ashley Vidot (06:23:21):

Yes.

Lawyer (06:23:22):

All right. So what did you do?

Ashley Vidot (06:23:25):

I documented the vehicle. I took photographs of the vehicle. I then noticed that there were seals on the door, I broke the seals of the front passenger and the front driver's door to obtain the cell phone, which was in the center console, as well as the bag full of medication, which was on the passenger side of the car.

Lawyer (06:23:43):

And what do you mean by seals on the door?

Ashley Vidot (06:23:45):

When we bring in a car for evidence preservation, we seal the vehicle to make sure that nobody else has entered it by using a yellow piece of tape that is easily broken once the door is open.

Lawyer (06:23:57):

Is that like the seals that we have seen on pieces of evidence, let's say?

Ashley Vidot (06:24:00):

Very similar, yes.

Lawyer (06:24:03):

Okay. And you said you took some photographs of it?

Ashley Vidot (06:24:05):

Yes.

Lawyer (06:24:06):

Now, were you the one in charge of actually doing the full-blown processing of the Jeep, or were you just asked to go in specifically and get these items?

Ashley Vidot (06:24:12):

I was asked specifically to get these items.

Lawyer (06:24:15):

May I approach?

Judge McCourt (06:24:16):

Yes, sir.

Lawyer (06:24:16):

Showing you what's been marked as State's Exhibit BB as in boy. Can you take a look at those photographs and tell me if you recognize them?

Ashley Vidot (06:24:22):

Sure. Three. Yes.

Lawyer (06:24:38):

And what are those?

Ashley Vidot (06:24:39):

These are photographs of the vehicle prior to me entering it, as well as the seal, and then the cell phone in the center console.

Lawyer (06:24:47):

Do those fairly and accurately depict the vehicle as well as the cell phone you located inside?

Ashley Vidot (06:24:51):

Yes.

Lawyer (06:24:52):

State would move BB, B as in boy into evidence as 27.

Speaker 25 (06:24:56):

No objection, Judge.

Judge McCourt (06:24:57):

Without objection, State's Exhibit BB will be admitted into evidence as State's Exhibit 27.

Lawyer (06:25:02):

May I publish?

Judge McCourt (06:25:03):

Yes, sir.

Lawyer (06:25:04):

Showing you Photograph One of State's 27. What does this show?

Ashley Vidot (06:25:08):

This shows the rear of the vehicle, which was in the bay, with the license plate.

Lawyer (06:25:14):

Okay. And Photograph Two?

Ashley Vidot (06:25:15):

This is showing the seal of the driver's side of the vehicle.

Lawyer (06:25:19):

This yellow strip here?

Ashley Vidot (06:25:20):

Yes.

Lawyer (06:25:20):

Okay. And Photograph Three of State's 27, what does this show?

Ashley Vidot (06:25:27):

That's showing the cell phone that was located in the center console.

Lawyer (06:25:34):

And Photograph Four of State's 27, what does this show?

Ashley Vidot (06:25:38):

It's a closer up image of the phone in the center console.

Lawyer (06:25:43):

This is the phone you collected?

Ashley Vidot (06:25:44):

Yes.

Lawyer (06:25:44):

What did you do with it once you removed it?

Ashley Vidot (06:25:47):

I handed it directly to the detective, Karla Santana-Palau.

Lawyer (06:25:50):

Did you put it inside of anything?

Ashley Vidot (06:25:52):

No.

Lawyer (06:25:54):

Okay. Was a Faraday bag used at some point?

Ashley Vidot (06:25:55):

Oh, yes. I think... Sorry.

Lawyer (06:25:55):

That's okay.

Ashley Vidot (06:25:57):

If I can refer back to my... I did place it into a Faraday bag, yes.

Lawyer (06:26:00):

What's a Faraday bag?

Ashley Vidot (06:26:01):

A Faraday bag is a bag that blocks out any signal, so that way nobody can tamper the phone from afar.

Lawyer (06:26:06):

Okay. May I approach again?

Judge McCourt (06:26:08):

Yes, sir.

Lawyer (06:26:08):

Showing you State's CC for identification. Do you recognize that item?

Ashley Vidot (06:26:16):

Yes.

Lawyer (06:26:16):

What is it?

Ashley Vidot (06:26:16):

This is the cell phone from the center console.

Lawyer (06:26:18):

Is it the same, or substantially the same condition as when you collected it?

Ashley Vidot (06:26:21):

Yes.

Lawyer (06:26:21):

At this time, State would move CC into evidence as 28.

Speaker 25 (06:26:25):

No objection, Judge.

Judge McCourt (06:26:26):

Without objection, State's Exhibit CC will be admitted into evidence as State's Exhibit 28.

Lawyer (06:26:32):

Did you have any involvement in looking inside the phone, and analyzing its contents?

Ashley Vidot (06:26:36):

No.

Lawyer (06:26:40):

Okay. Thank you, ma'am. No other questions, Your Honor.

Speaker 25 (06:26:41):

No questions, Judge.

Judge McCourt (06:26:42):

Members of the jury, do any of y'all have questions of this witness? If you do, please raise your hands. Seeing no hands. State, is she released?

Lawyer (06:26:48):

She is, Your Honor.

Judge McCourt (06:26:49):

Defense?

Speaker 25 (06:26:49):

No objection, Judge.

Ashley Vidot (06:26:50):

Thank you.

Judge McCourt (06:26:50):

Ma'am, you're free to go about your day. Thank you for your time. Next witness.

Lawyer (06:26:54):

State calls Karla Santana-Palau.

Judge McCourt (06:26:57):

If you raise your right hand, face the clerk to be sworn.

Clerk (06:27:32):

Do you swear or affirm the testimony you're about to give will be the truth, the whole truth, and nothing but the truth, so help you God?

Karla Santana-Palau (06:27:34):

I do.

Judge McCourt (06:27:34):

You can be seated, ma'am.

Lawyer (06:27:34):

Good afternoon.

Karla Santana-Palau (06:27:34):

Good afternoon.

Lawyer (06:27:41):

Would you please introduce yourself to the jury, and spell your last name?

Karla Santana-Palau (06:27:43):

Yes. My name is Sergeant Karla Santana-Palau. My last name is spelled S-A-N-T-A-N-A hyphen P-A-L-A-U.

Lawyer (06:27:51):

Where do you work?

Karla Santana-Palau (06:27:52):

I work with the Marion County Sheriff's Office.

Lawyer (06:27:53):

You indicated you're a sergeant, have you been recently promoted?

Karla Santana-Palau (06:27:56):

Yes.

Lawyer (06:27:56):

All right. What did you do before you were promoted to sergeant?

Karla Santana-Palau (06:27:59):

I'm still in the process of transitioning from my position as a Major Crimes Robbery Homicide Detective.

Lawyer (06:28:04):

All right. Let me direct your attention to October 17th of 2025. Did you become aware that a black Jeep Cherokee belonging to Dwain Hall had been brought to the Marion County Sheriff's Office evidence bay?

Karla Santana-Palau (06:28:15):

Yes.

Lawyer (06:28:17):

How did you become involved? What were you asked to do?

Karla Santana-Palau (06:28:20):

I was asked to respond to our evidence bay, and just assist FDLE Agent Lee in executing a search warrant of that vehicle.

Lawyer (06:28:28):

Okay. Were you specifically asked to get something out of that vehicle?

Karla Santana-Palau (06:28:33):

Yes. I was asked to retrieve a tote that was in the front passenger seat, belonging to the suspect's wife or significant other. She had just been through surgery, and needed that tote.

Lawyer (06:28:48):

Were you also asked to retrieve a bag of medication and a cell phone?

Karla Santana-Palau (06:28:52):

Yes.

Lawyer (06:28:54):

Okay. Was Crime Scene Supervisor Ashley Vidot also present-

Karla Santana-Palau (06:28:57):

Yes.

Lawyer (06:28:57):

... to helping with this process?

Karla Santana-Palau (06:28:58):

Yes, sir.

Lawyer (06:28:59):

All right. Showing you Photograph One of State's 27. Is that the vehicle we're talking about?

Karla Santana-Palau (06:29:03):

Yes.

Lawyer (06:29:04):

And Photograph Three of State's 27. Do you recognize this?

Karla Santana-Palau (06:29:08):

Yes.

Lawyer (06:29:08):

All right. Were you present when Ashley Vidot accessed the vehicle, broke the seals, and went inside?

Karla Santana-Palau (06:29:14):

Yes.

Lawyer (06:29:15):

And did Ms. Vidot retrieve a cell phone?

Karla Santana-Palau (06:29:17):

Yes.

Lawyer (06:29:18):

And you mentioned FDLE Agent Calvin Lee was present?

Karla Santana-Palau (06:29:21):

Yes.

Lawyer (06:29:22):

And if Ms. Vidot retrieved the cell phone and gave it to you, who would you have given it to?

Karla Santana-Palau (06:29:26):

I gave it to Agent Lee.

Lawyer (06:29:27):

Okay. Thank you, ma'am. No other questions.

Speaker 25 (06:29:31):

No questions, Judge.

Judge McCourt (06:29:32):

Members of the jury, any of y'all have questions of this witness? If you do, please raise your hand. Okay. Seeing no hands, is she released, State?

Lawyer (06:29:39):

She is, Your Honor.

Judge McCourt (06:29:40):

Defense?

Speaker 25 (06:29:40):

No objection, Your Honor.

Judge McCourt (06:29:42):

Ma'am, you're free to go about your day. Thank you for your time.

Karla Santana-Palau (06:29:42):

Thanks.

Judge McCourt (06:29:42):

All right. Counsel, if y'all will approach. Members of the jury, I'm going to put the white noise on the talk with the lawyers. Okay. State, you can call your next witness.

Speaker 28 (06:32:47):

State calls Rebekah McKinzie.

Judge McCourt (06:32:48):

If you raise your right hand, face the clerk to be sworn.

Clerk (06:33:47):

Do you swear or affirm the testimony you're about to give will be the truth, the whole truth, and nothing but the truth, so help you God?

Rebekah McKinzie (06:33:51):

I do.

Judge McCourt (06:33:51):

You can go ahead and be seated, ma'am.

Rebekah McKinzie (06:33:51):

Thank you.

Speaker 28 (06:33:56):

Good afternoon.

Rebekah McKinzie (06:33:56):

Good afternoon.

Speaker 28 (06:33:57):

Can you please tell the jury your name, and spell your first name and your last name for the record?

Rebekah McKinzie (06:34:01):

My name is Rebekah McKinzie, R-E-B-E-K-A-H M-C-K-I-N-Z-I-E.

Speaker 28 (06:34:08):

Thank you. What is your current occupation?

Rebekah McKinzie (06:34:11):

I'm a special agent with the Florida Department of Law Enforcement.

Speaker 28 (06:34:14):

How long have you worked for the Florida Department of Law Enforcement?

Rebekah McKinzie (06:34:16):

Just over two years.

Speaker 28 (06:34:18):

What are your duties as a special agent?

Rebekah McKinzie (06:34:21):

I investigate serious felonies to include homicide, child sexual abuse, human trafficking, things like that.

Speaker 28 (06:34:29):

And where did you work before FDLE?

Rebekah McKinzie (06:34:31):

The Gainesville Police Department in Gainesville, Florida.

Speaker 28 (06:34:34):

How long did you work for the Gainesville Police Department?

Rebekah McKinzie (06:34:36):

Approximately 21 years.

Speaker 28 (06:34:38):

And what sort of positions did you hold with the Gainesville Police Department?

Rebekah McKinzie (06:34:42):

During my career at the Gainesville Police Department, I was an officer, corporal, sergeant, and lieutenant. And in each of those ranks, I served time in operations, as well as our Criminal Investigations Division, and spent some time in logistics and training as well.

Speaker 28 (06:34:58):

I want to direct your attention to October 13th of 2025. On that date, did you become involved in the investigation into a missing and endangered female named Sonia Exelby?

Rebekah McKinzie (06:35:07):

I did.

Speaker 28 (06:35:08):

Were you assigned as the lead case agent on this case?

Rebekah McKinzie (06:35:11):

I was.

Speaker 28 (06:35:14):

And what were your duties as the lead agent?

Rebekah McKinzie (06:35:17):

As the lead agent, I was responsible for managing the case, communicating with outside agencies to include the overseas agencies that I was working with, and conducting interviews, as well as obtaining search warrants and subpoenas.

Speaker 28 (06:35:35):

And did your job as lead agent also involve assigning other agents with tasks that need to be done?

Rebekah McKinzie (06:35:41):

It did.

Speaker 28 (06:35:41):

I'm assuming you couldn't do everything?

Rebekah McKinzie (06:35:43):

Correct.

Speaker 28 (06:35:45):

You talked about writing search warrants, in addition to yourself writing search warrants, did you have other agents write search warrants as needed?

Rebekah McKinzie (06:35:51):

I did.

Speaker 28 (06:35:54):

And did it often take several weeks, if not months, to get results back from certain search warrants such as Facebook?

Rebekah McKinzie (06:36:00):

Yes.

Speaker 28 (06:36:02):

Other than those sorts...

Judge Timothy McCourt (06:36:03):

[inaudible 06:36:00].

Rebekah McKinzie (06:36:00):

Yes.

Amy Berndt (06:36:02):

Other than those sorts of things, would you characterize this as a relatively fast moving investigation from the time you became involved?

Rebekah McKinzie (06:36:09):

Yes, I would.

Amy Berndt (06:36:11):

And after FDLE became involved on October 13th of 2025, over the next few days, did your investigation narrow in on Dwain Hall?

Rebekah McKinzie (06:36:20):

It did.

Amy Berndt (06:36:21):

And why was that?

Rebekah McKinzie (06:36:23):

So we found receipts where he had purchased a shovel and rope along with some additional items in Gainesville, Florida, as well as his conversations with Special Agent Calvin Lee. And he also was recorded on a license plate reader at the Gainesville Regional Airport around the time that Sonia's plane landed in Gainesville, Florida.

Amy Berndt (06:36:50):

And on October 15th of 2025, was the FBI contacted to assist in tracking the defendant's phone on an exigent basis?

Rebekah McKinzie (06:36:57):

They were.

Amy Berndt (06:36:58):

Okay. And why was that done?

Rebekah McKinzie (06:37:00):

We had hoped that Sonia was still alive and we needed to find out where she was with the hopes of finding her.

Amy Berndt (06:37:09):

And what does it mean to get something on an exigent basis?

Rebekah McKinzie (06:37:13):

An exigent basis means there's a life-threatening situation, and so we are able to get records that normally would require a search warrant or a subpoena. But because it was a life-threatening situation, we were able to do that without the search warrant or subpoena.

Amy Berndt (06:37:28):

All right. And were those results obtained relatively quickly on the next day, October 16th of 2025?

Rebekah McKinzie (06:37:33):

They were.

Amy Berndt (06:37:35):

And did those results help you narrow down a wooded area where the defendant spent some time on Sunday, October 12th of 2025?

Rebekah McKinzie (06:37:43):

It did.

Amy Berndt (06:37:44):

And was that wooded area close to his residence?

Rebekah McKinzie (06:37:48):

It was.

Amy Berndt (06:37:50):

Okay. Is that in Marion Oaks?

Rebekah McKinzie (06:37:51):

It was. I believe it was near the intersection of Southwest 32nd Avenue and Southwest 27th Circle, which was around Marion Oaks area.

Amy Berndt (06:38:01):

And did he spend about an hour and a half in that location according to the records?

Rebekah McKinzie (06:38:05):

Somewhere around that amount of time, yes.

Amy Berndt (06:38:08):

Now on the evening of October 16th of 2025 or late afternoon after you received those records, did the Florida Department of Law Enforcement and deputies from the Marion County Sheriff's Office go to that location to search for Sonia Exelby?

Rebekah McKinzie (06:38:21):

Yes, they did conduct a preliminary search that evening.

Amy Berndt (06:38:25):

All right. And did they locate anything that evening?

Rebekah McKinzie (06:38:27):

They did not.

Amy Berndt (06:38:28):

Was the plan made to return to that location the following day, Friday, October 17th of 2025, to do a grid search?

Rebekah McKinzie (06:38:36):

Yes.

Amy Berndt (06:38:36):

What's a grid search?

Rebekah McKinzie (06:38:38):

A grid search is where you've identified a particular area that needs to be searched and you break it up into sections and you methodically search those sections to make sure all of those sections are accounted for so there's no area that is missed.

Amy Berndt (06:38:52):

And do you know if a cadaver dog was also brought out to that location on Friday, October 17th of 2025?

Rebekah McKinzie (06:38:58):

Yes.

Amy Berndt (06:38:59):

Now on that date, that Friday, while the other officers and agents were searching that area again, did you conduct a lengthy interview with Dwain Hall?

Rebekah McKinzie (06:39:08):

I did.

Amy Berndt (06:39:09):

Do you see the person you know as Dwain Hall in the courtroom today?

Rebekah McKinzie (06:39:12):

I do.

Amy Berndt (06:39:12):

Can you please point to him and describe something he's wearing?

Rebekah McKinzie (06:39:15):

He's wearing a light purple shirt.

Amy Berndt (06:39:17):

Your Honor, may the record reflect the witness has identified the defendant?

Junior Barrett (06:39:20):

No objection.

Judge Timothy McCourt (06:39:21):

Without objection, the record will reflect the witness has identified the defendant.

Amy Berndt (06:39:24):

Now, did you read the defendant his Miranda warnings before you spoke with him?

Rebekah McKinzie (06:39:28):

I did.

Amy Berndt (06:39:29):

Did you force him or coerce him in any way in order to get him to speak with you?

Rebekah McKinzie (06:39:32):

I did not.

Amy Berndt (06:39:33):

Did you promise him anything in order to get him to speak with you?

Rebekah McKinzie (06:39:36):

I did not.

Amy Berndt (06:39:37):

Did he agree to speak with you?

Rebekah McKinzie (06:39:38):

He did.

Amy Berndt (06:39:40):

And did a detective from the Marion County Sheriff's Office assist you in the interview?

Rebekah McKinzie (06:39:43):

Yes.

Amy Berndt (06:39:44):

And who was that?

Rebekah McKinzie (06:39:45):

It was Sergeant Joseph Miller.

Amy Berndt (06:39:48):

And where did you and Sergeant Miller conduct this interview with the defendant?

Rebekah McKinzie (06:39:52):

At the Marion County Sheriff's Office.

Amy Berndt (06:39:54):

Was the interview video and audio recorded?

Rebekah McKinzie (06:39:57):

It was.

Amy Berndt (06:39:58):

And was it a lengthy interview?

Rebekah McKinzie (06:39:59):

It was.

Amy Berndt (06:40:02):

Now, how did you approach the interview with the defendant?

Rebekah McKinzie (06:40:05):

So prior to going into the interview, it was important for me to be able to engage in conversation with Dwain Hall. And so I went in being non-confrontational and nonchalant in an effort to get him comfortable to speak with me. I felt like if I was able to get him to speak with me in the beginning, that ultimately I would be able to get information that would help me find out what happened to Sonia and where Sonia was.

‍

Amy Berndt (06:40:32):

Now, in the interview, you made statements that indicated to the defendant that it was okay if he killed Sonia because she wanted to be killed, that you thought that was okay. Was that true when you told him that?

Rebekah McKinzie (06:40:44):

It wasn't. It was a tactic that I used so that he would feel comfortable talking to me about what he had done with Sonia.

Amy Berndt (06:40:53):

Now for the first several hours of the interview, what did the defendant tell you just generally?

Rebekah McKinzie (06:40:58):

So he said a lot of different things, but in general, he said that he had been hired by a man named Harold to work on high-end vehicles in the Reddick area. He could not give us a specific location because it was supposed to be a secret location, that he could not discuss it in detail because he had signed a non-disclosure agreement, but that Harold had paid him $1,200 for his services.

Amy Berndt (06:41:25):

Okay. And did this story go on and on for about four hours?

Rebekah McKinzie (06:41:31):

It was quite lengthy.

Amy Berndt (06:41:33):

All right. At some point in the interview, was there a break?

Rebekah McKinzie (06:41:38):

Yes.

Amy Berndt (06:41:38):

All right. And did someone bring the defendant some food during the break?

Rebekah McKinzie (06:41:42):

Yes, he was provided food during the break.

Amy Berndt (06:41:44):

All right. And then did the defendant at some point tell you that he wanted to recant everything he had told you for the past four hours?

Rebekah McKinzie (06:41:53):

Yes.

Amy Berndt (06:41:56):

And after he said he wanted to recant everything he had previously tell you, did the defendant admit that he did know Sonia Exelby and he had been communicating with her for years?

Rebekah McKinzie (06:42:07):

Yes, he did admit to me that he knew her and that he had been communicating with her for a couple of years.

Amy Berndt (06:42:12):

And what platforms did the defendant admit that he communicated with Sonia on?

Rebekah McKinzie (06:42:16):

He told me that he was communicating with her on Motherless as well as Sessions.

Amy Berndt (06:42:22):

Did you attempt to get records of the communications between the defendant and Sonia from Sessions?

Rebekah McKinzie (06:42:27):

Sessions is an encrypted app, and so it is impossible to retrieve messages from Sessions. You would have to actually have the device to be able to recover the messages.

Amy Berndt (06:42:40):

So you were not able to get any of those communications?

Rebekah McKinzie (06:42:42):

Correct.

Amy Berndt (06:42:42):

All right. Now the other platform you said the defendant communicated with Sonia on was Motherless?

Rebekah McKinzie (06:42:48):

Correct.

Amy Berndt (06:42:49):

Can you explain to the jury what Motherless is?

Rebekah McKinzie (06:42:52):

Motherless was a pornographic website that hosted content that involved incest, BSM, torture, snuff films, child sex abuse, the rape of women, drugging women, content like that.

Amy Berndt (06:43:11):

What is BDSM?

Rebekah McKinzie (06:43:13):

It's basically violent sex.

Amy Berndt (06:43:16):

Has Motherless since been shut down?

Rebekah McKinzie (06:43:18):

It has.

Amy Berndt (06:43:19):

Did that happen sometime this year?

Rebekah McKinzie (06:43:22):

It did.

Amy Berndt (06:43:22):

And did the defendant during your interview tell you what his username on Motherless was?

Rebekah McKinzie (06:43:27):

He did.

Amy Berndt (06:43:28):

What was that?

Rebekah McKinzie (06:43:29):

He said it was Alpha Sadist.

Amy Berndt (06:43:32):

And did the defendant say that he communicated with Sonia on Motherless using the name Alpha Sadist?

Rebekah McKinzie (06:43:39):

He did, but he also said that he wasn't sure which one because he had multiple profile names and had been kicked off the Motherless website.

Amy Berndt (06:43:48):

So he did admit that he had the username Alpha Sadist, but in addition, he had other usernames on Motherless?

Rebekah McKinzie (06:43:54):

Yes.

Amy Berndt (06:43:55):

All right. And did the defendant have an account on Motherless with the username Silverwolf44646?

Rebekah McKinzie (06:44:03):

Yes.

Amy Berndt (06:44:07):

And did the defendant tell Agent Calvin Lee during their interview that his email address was darkwolf44646@gmail.com?

Rebekah McKinzie (06:44:16):

Yes, he did.

Amy Berndt (06:44:21):

Now, before Motherless was shut down this year, were you able to get some records via subpoena from Motherless concerning the defendant's account, Alpha Sadist and the defendant's account, Silverwolf44646?

Rebekah McKinzie (06:44:34):

It was actually through search warrant, but yes, I was able to get some records.

Amy Berndt (06:44:38):

All right. And did the dates that those two accounts, Silverwolf44646 and Alpha Sadist became active, did it correspond with the timeframes the defendant told you he communicated with Sonia on Motherless?

Rebekah McKinzie (06:44:52):

They were within the past two years.

Amy Berndt (06:44:56):

And at the time you said you received some records from Motherless, was the defendant's Motherless account, Alpha Sadist, still active?

Rebekah McKinzie (06:45:03):

It was not. It had been deleted.

Amy Berndt (06:45:05):

Okay. Was it deleted on July 16th of 2025?

Rebekah McKinzie (06:45:09):

It was.

Amy Berndt (06:45:10):

And what about the defendant's Motherless account, Silverwolf44646, was that still active?

Rebekah McKinzie (06:45:16):

No, it had also been deleted.

Amy Berndt (06:45:18):

And was that deleted on October 9th of 2024?

Rebekah McKinzie (06:45:21):

Yes, that's correct.

Amy Berndt (06:45:23):

All right. Were you able to recover any of the actual messages from the defendant's Alpha Sadist account on Motherless or his Silverwolf44646 account?

Rebekah McKinzie (06:45:33):

I was not able to.

Amy Berndt (06:45:34):

And why was that?

Rebekah McKinzie (06:45:36):

From what I learned was that once an account had been deleted, the message would be no longer available.

Amy Berndt (06:45:42):

Okay. So since he had deleted both of those accounts, you could not get any of the actual messages?

Rebekah McKinzie (06:45:46):

Correct.

Amy Berndt (06:45:47):

All right. Now, what were you able to get from the search warrant that you produced to Motherless?

Rebekah McKinzie (06:45:53):

There was a detail sheet that included some information, email address, as well as a site bio and some internet IP addresses.

Amy Berndt (06:46:12):

Your Honor, may I approach the witness?

Judge Timothy McCourt (06:46:13):

Yes, ma'am.

Amy Berndt (06:46:25):

I'm first going to show you what's been marked for identification as State's Exhibit MMMM and ask if you look at that.

(06:46:41)
Are those the records that you told us you were able to obtain from Motherless.com pursuant to the search warrant?

Rebekah McKinzie (06:46:45):

Yes.

Amy Berndt (06:46:46):

Your Honor, at this time we move State's MMMM into evidence.

Junior Barrett (06:46:52):

No objection, Judge.

Judge Timothy McCourt (06:46:53):

Without objection, State's Exhibit State's Exhibit MMMM will be admitted into evidence as State's Exhibit 29.

Amy Berndt (06:47:04):

And Your Honor, may I publish?

Judge Timothy McCourt (06:47:05):

Yes, ma'am.

Amy Berndt (06:47:09):

All right. If you can tell us what we're looking at here first.

Rebekah McKinzie (06:47:12):

So this just shows that Alpha Sadist... This is the information that I received back from Motherless.com regarding the Alpha Sadist profile name.

Amy Berndt (06:47:23):

All right. And now this says document created on November 4th, 2025. Is that just the date that the documents were created for you pursuant to your search warrant?

Rebekah McKinzie (06:47:32):

Yes.

Amy Berndt (06:47:33):

Okay. And then what are we looking at here on this detail sheet?

Rebekah McKinzie (06:47:37):

So this is the detail sheet that was provided to me by Motherless. It shows the date and time that the user joined, the last time they logged in.

Amy Berndt (06:47:45):

Tell us what that would be, what the date that was joined-

Rebekah McKinzie (06:47:47):

Would be February 21st, 2025.

Amy Berndt (06:47:50):

All right.

Rebekah McKinzie (06:47:51):

At 9:17.

Amy Berndt (06:47:52):

All right. And then what is this showing us here?

Rebekah McKinzie (06:47:54):

The last login, which was July 15th, 2025 at 7:43.

Amy Berndt (06:47:59):

And then we have an email address as well, alphasadist@-

Rebekah McKinzie (06:48:04):

@Mail.com. Yes.

Amy Berndt (06:48:06):

All right. Gender, male, David Korn, Roth?

Rebekah McKinzie (06:48:12):

Correct.

Amy Berndt (06:48:14):

And can you read for the jury what his site bio is?

Rebekah McKinzie (06:48:18):

The site bio that was provided to me says, "Mm, well, I am a sadist. I like 18 to 25-year-old generally. I enjoy mother-daughter sets as slaves. Would love to find a domestic pain slut for complete control. No scat or puke play. Only complete submission is acceptable."

Amy Berndt (06:48:38):

And so that's the records you were able to get for the Alpha Sadist?

Rebekah McKinzie (06:48:42):

Yes.

Amy Berndt (06:48:45):

Your Honor, may I approach?

Judge Timothy McCourt (06:48:46):

Yes, ma'am.

Amy Berndt (06:48:47):

I'm going to show you what's been marked for identification as State's Exhibit NNNN. Do you recognize those?

Rebekah McKinzie (06:48:58):

Yes.

Amy Berndt (06:48:58):

And what is that?

Rebekah McKinzie (06:48:59):

This would be the Darkwolf44646 profile detail information.

Amy Berndt (06:49:07):

The other account that the defendant had on other list that you obtained his records from the search warrant?

Rebekah McKinzie (06:49:11):

Correct.

Amy Berndt (06:49:11):

Your Honor, at this time we move state's NNNN into evidence.

Junior Barrett (06:49:14):

No objection, Judge.

Judge Timothy McCourt (06:49:16):

Without objection, State's Exhibit NNNN will be admitted into evidence as State's Exhibit 30.

Amy Berndt (06:49:22):

May I publish, your Honor?

Judge Timothy McCourt (06:49:23):

Yes, ma'am.

Amy Berndt (06:49:25):

And again, is this just kind of the cover sheet for the Silverwolf44646, which is the other account that he had on Motherless?

Rebekah McKinzie (06:49:34):

Yes.

Amy Berndt (06:49:36):

Then moving on to the detail sheet, if you can tell us again the date joined and the date last login.

Rebekah McKinzie (06:49:41):

The date joined is October 5th, 2024, and then the date last login was October 9th, 2024.

Amy Berndt (06:49:50):

And then the email address, thedarkwolf44646@gmail.com, again, that's the email address that he told Special Agent Calvin Lee was his email address?

Rebekah McKinzie (06:49:58):

Correct.

Amy Berndt (06:50:00):

And if you can read the site bio for the Motherless account, Silverwolf.

Rebekah McKinzie (06:50:06):

Live in Florida, or FL, Sadist, want to find A, my own little sex doll for all sorts of things.

Amy Berndt (06:50:20):

Now, were you able to obtain any records between the defendant and Sonia from her Motherless account?

Rebekah McKinzie (06:50:26):

I was.

Amy Berndt (06:50:27):

Okay. And what was the name of her Motherless account?

Rebekah McKinzie (06:50:29):

Already Yours.

Amy Berndt (06:50:32):

Okay. And why were you able to obtain messages, a few messages from her account?

Rebekah McKinzie (06:50:36):

Her account had not been deleted.

Amy Berndt (06:50:38):

Your Honor, may I approach the witness?

Judge Timothy McCourt (06:50:41):

Yes, ma'am.

Amy Berndt (06:50:42):

I'm going to show you what's been marked identification as State's Exhibit 0000. You can look at that and tell me you recognize those.

Rebekah McKinzie (06:50:49):

I do.

Amy Berndt (06:50:49):

What are those?

Rebekah McKinzie (06:51:02):

Those would be the same detail information that was provided for the other accounts and then the messages.

Amy Berndt (06:51:11):

From Sonia's Motherless account, Already Yours?

Rebekah McKinzie (06:51:13):

Yes.

Amy Berndt (06:51:14):

Your Honor at this time, we move State's 0000 into evidence.

Junior Barrett (06:51:17):

No objection, Judge.

Judge Timothy McCourt (06:51:19):

All right. State's Exhibit 0000 or 0000 will be admitted into evidence as State's Exhibit 31.

Amy Berndt (06:51:30):

And there's not very many messages that you were able to obtain between Alpha Sadist and Already Yours, Sonia and the defendant on Motherless. Did the defendant during his interview tell you that they had moved on to a different platform that they were talking on, which would be Sessions at some point?

Rebekah McKinzie (06:51:45):

Yes, that's what he told me.

Amy Berndt (06:51:46):

Okay. So they moved from Motherless to Sessions and you weren't able to get any records because they don't keep those and they delete?

Rebekah McKinzie (06:51:54):

Correct.

Amy Berndt (06:51:54):

All right. And then this is the detail sheet for Already Yours, which was the name of Sonia's account on Motherless?

Rebekah McKinzie (06:52:02):

Yes.

Amy Berndt (06:52:04):

And then when is the date that she joined Motherless?

Rebekah McKinzie (06:52:07):

September 4th, 2024.

Amy Berndt (06:52:10):

Okay. And the date of her last login?

Rebekah McKinzie (06:52:12):

October 4th, 2025.

Amy Berndt (06:52:12):

All right. And then what is her site bio?

Rebekah McKinzie (06:52:16):

"Life's the bitch and then you die, and now life's finally stopped being a bitch."

Amy Berndt (06:52:22):

And then what are we looking at here?

Rebekah McKinzie (06:52:24):

These are messages from Sonia's account to the Alpha Sadist account.

Amy Berndt (06:52:30):

All right. Now they look very disjointed and hard to understand. Is that because we don't have the defendant's portion of the conversation because his records were deleted?

Rebekah McKinzie (06:52:42):

Correct.

Amy Berndt (06:52:43):

All right. So all we can say is that these are three correspondence that Sonia sent from her Already Yours account to his at Alpha Sadist?

Rebekah McKinzie (06:52:56):

Correct.

Amy Berndt (06:52:57):

And we don't know what his responses were?

Rebekah McKinzie (06:52:59):

Correct.

Amy Berndt (06:52:59):

All right. Now, in your interview with the defendant, did he eventually admit that he stayed in the Airbnb in Reddick with Sonia after he recanted the previous story?

Rebekah McKinzie (06:53:16):

He did.

Amy Berndt (06:53:18):

Okay. Did the defendant say anything about having sex with Sonia while they were in the Airbnb?

Rebekah McKinzie (06:53:22):

Yes. He admitted to me that he had had sex with her at least twice.

Amy Berndt (06:53:27):

How did he describe the sex?

Rebekah McKinzie (06:53:29):

He described the sex as vanilla for him, but that it was rough with light choking.

Amy Berndt (06:53:34):

Okay. Did he admit hitting Sonia during the sex?

Rebekah McKinzie (06:53:37):

Yes. He told me that he hit her on the front and the back, which included her breasts, her face, and her ass.

Amy Berndt (06:53:45):

Did he say anything about choking?

Rebekah McKinzie (06:53:48):

He did.

Amy Berndt (06:53:49):

Okay. What did he say?

Rebekah McKinzie (06:53:51):

He said that it was light choking, but that it did happen during sex.

Amy Berndt (06:53:55):

Okay. Did the defendant tell you anything about taking a video of Sonia while they were at the Airbnb?

Rebekah McKinzie (06:54:01):

He did.

Amy Berndt (06:54:02):

What did he say about that?

Rebekah McKinzie (06:54:03):

He told me that he took a video of her on his cell phone where he was recording her and it lasted a few minutes, but after recording it, he immediately deleted it because she was not behaving right.

Amy Berndt (06:54:17):

She wasn't behaving the way he wanted on the video?

Rebekah McKinzie (06:54:19):

Yes.

Amy Berndt (06:54:20):

All right. Did the defendant ever actually admit to killing Sonia during the interview?

Rebekah McKinzie (06:54:27):

He did not come out and say that he had killed her, but he indicated to me that he was the last person to see her alive, that he had disposed of some of her items in a donation bin, which we were able to recover. He put himself at the place where we found Sonia's body, where it had been buried, and he also made a comment when we were questioning him that if you take somebody's life, that's murder.

Amy Berndt (06:54:57):

Did he ever say that he helped Sonia get what she want or imply that he helped her get what she wanted?

Rebekah McKinzie (06:55:03):

Yes, he did.

Amy Berndt (06:55:08):

Your Honor, may I approach the witness?

Judge Timothy McCourt (06:55:09):

Yes, ma'am.

Amy Berndt (06:55:10):

I'm going to show you what's been marked as State's Exhibit DD for identification. Do you recognize that?

Rebekah McKinzie (06:55:16):

I do.

Amy Berndt (06:55:17):

What is that?

Rebekah McKinzie (06:55:18):

That is the interview.

Amy Berndt (06:55:20):

The video recording that you did with the defendant?

Rebekah McKinzie (06:55:22):

Correct.

Amy Berndt (06:55:22):

On October 17th of 2025?

Rebekah McKinzie (06:55:24):

Correct.

Amy Berndt (06:55:25):

And is that a fair and accurate depiction of the relevant portions of the interview?

Rebekah McKinzie (06:55:28):

It is.

Amy Berndt (06:55:29):

And have you reviewed that?

Rebekah McKinzie (06:55:30):

I have.

Amy Berndt (06:55:31):

How do you recognize that as the DVD review?

Rebekah McKinzie (06:55:33):

I initialed and there's my ID number as well as the date.

Amy Berndt (06:55:36):

Thank you. At this time we move into evidence State's DD.

Junior Barrett (06:55:42):

Judge, I'm assuming that's one of the... May we approach, please?

Judge Timothy McCourt (06:55:45):

Yes, sir. Ladies and gentlemen, I'm going to put the white noise on real quick.

(06:56:05)
Exhibit DD will be admitted into evidence as State's Exhibit 32.

Amy Berndt (06:56:34):

Was Sonia's body eventually located on October 17th of 2025, that same day that you were interviewing the defendant?

Rebekah McKinzie (06:56:41):

It was.

Amy Berndt (06:56:43):

All right. And where was it located?

Rebekah McKinzie (06:56:45):

It was located in the same area that we discussed earlier, which was near the intersection of Southwest 27th Circle, Southwest 32nd Avenue in the Marion County's... I'm sorry, Marion Oaks near his residence.

Amy Berndt (06:57:02):

And was her body clothed when it was found?

Rebekah McKinzie (06:57:04):

Her body was partially clothed. She did have a bra on and her sandals, and then her dress was laid on top of her.

Amy Berndt (06:57:13):

And was her body taken to the medical examiner's office for an autopsy to determine her cause of death?

Rebekah McKinzie (06:57:18):

It was.

Amy Berndt (06:57:19):

And I want to jump ahead and direct your attention now to October 27th of 2025. On that date, did you execute a search warrant that had been obtained for the defendant's DNA?

Rebekah McKinzie (06:57:30):

I did.

Amy Berndt (06:57:31):

Okay. Can you please explain to the jury how you obtained a sample of his DNA?

Rebekah McKinzie (06:57:34):

So in order for me to obtain a sample of Dwain Hall's DNA, I put gloves on. We have Q-tips that are rather large and they're kept in sterile containers, and so I did two, so I removed them each from their packaging. I swabbed Dwain Hall's mouth and then replaced the cotton back into that original sterile packaging and then put it within another paper bag.

Amy Berndt (06:58:04):

Your Honor, may I approach the witness?

Judge Timothy McCourt (06:58:05):

Yes, ma'am.

Amy Berndt (06:58:07):

I'm going to show you what's been marked for identification as State's Exhibit EE and ask you if you recognize that.

Rebekah McKinzie (06:58:13):

I do.

Amy Berndt (06:58:14):

How do you recognize it?

Rebekah McKinzie (06:58:15):

Based off of my signature on the back.

Amy Berndt (06:58:20):

Okay. And what is that?

Rebekah McKinzie (06:58:22):

This would be the buccal swabs that I collected from Dwain Hall.

Amy Berndt (06:58:26):

In the manner that you just described to the jury?

Rebekah McKinzie (06:58:28):

Yes.

Amy Berndt (06:58:29):

At this time, we move State's Exhibit EE into evidence.

Junior Barrett (06:58:32):

No objection, Judge.

Judge Timothy McCourt (06:58:33):

Without objection, State's Exhibit EE will be admitted into evidence as State's Exhibit 32. I'm sorry, 33.

Amy Berndt (06:58:41):

All right. And Judge, that's all the questions I have for today. We are going to recall Special Agent McKenzie.

Judge Timothy McCourt (06:58:47):

Okay. Do you have any cross-examination?

Junior Barrett (06:58:48):

Yes, Judge.

(06:58:49)
And now you indicated that Mr. Hall was brought to an interview room and was interviewed?

Rebekah McKinzie (06:59:02):

Yes.

Junior Barrett (06:59:02):

Okay. And prior to that interview, was Mr. Hall a suspect in the disappearance of Ms. Exelby?

Rebekah McKinzie (06:59:15):

Yes.

Junior Barrett (06:59:15):

He was? Okay. Was he a strong suspect?

Rebekah McKinzie (06:59:19):

Yes.

Junior Barrett (06:59:19):

Okay. Did you tell him that?

Rebekah McKinzie (06:59:21):

No.

Junior Barrett (06:59:32):

Okay. Now, you said that he didn't come out and say that he had killed her, correct?

Rebekah McKinzie (06:59:39):

Correct.

Junior Barrett (06:59:43):

In fact, when you said he didn't come out and say, he never said anything to you that indicated that he was responsible for her death, correct?

Rebekah McKinzie (06:59:51):

No, he did say things that indicated he was responsible for his death. He just did not come out and say that he killed her.

Junior Barrett (06:59:57):

The interview you did with him is recorded, correct?

Rebekah McKinzie (07:00:00):

I'm sorry, could you repeat?

Junior Barrett (07:00:01):

The interview that you did with him was recorded, correct? Video and audio?

Rebekah McKinzie (07:00:06):

Yes.

Junior Barrett (07:00:06):

All right. So you're saying that in that interview, he did say something to the effect that he was responsible for her death, that's what you're saying?

Rebekah McKinzie (07:00:15):

There were things that he said that indicated that he was potentially responsible for her death.

Junior Barrett (07:00:19):

Okay. But everything you spoke to him about is on that video?

Rebekah McKinzie (07:00:23):

Correct.

Junior Barrett (07:00:24):

Okay. Now, I believe you indicated that his Motherless account was closed in October of 2024.

Rebekah McKinzie (07:00:42):

There were two accounts.

Junior Barrett (07:00:43):

Okay. Were they both closed in 2024 or they were still open at the time she disappeared?

Rebekah McKinzie (07:00:51):

They were both closed prior to the time that she was reported missing.

Junior Barrett (07:00:56):

Okay. Were they closed prior to the time that she left the UK to come to the US?

Rebekah McKinzie (07:01:02):

Yes.

Junior Barrett (07:01:03):

Okay. I don't have any other questions at this time.

Judge Timothy McCourt (07:01:11):

Okay. State, any redirect at this time?

Amy Berndt (07:01:12):

Nothing at this time, Your Honor.

Judge Timothy McCourt (07:01:14):

Okay. All right. Can she step down?

Amy Berndt (07:01:17):

Yes, your Honor. I should ask that she be excused for today.

Judge Timothy McCourt (07:01:19):

Okay. We'll see you back tomorrow.

Rebekah McKinzie (07:01:21):

Okay. Thank you.

Judge Timothy McCourt (07:01:21):

Talk with the prosecutors about the time though, okay?

Rebekah McKinzie (07:01:23):

Okay. Thank you.

Judge Timothy McCourt (07:01:25):

All right. Now, members of the jury, we're going to do something a little bit different. I know you all may have questions of this witness. If you do, hold those until tomorrow. Okay? What we're going to do now, my understanding is that the state wants to publish-

Amy Berndt (07:01:36):

Yes, Your Honor.

Judge Timothy McCourt (07:01:36):

... Exhibit, it would be 32. I'm told that this recording will take approximately four hours and 40 minutes to play for you. Okay? So what we're going to do, we're going to take a short break now. I'm told by the lawyers that there's some issues with the audio quality, that it doesn't come through the speakers in the courtroom as clear as it could. So they have another TV and a laptop and a cart that they're going to reel into the courtroom. We're going to get that set up and it's going to be published for you using that. Okay? So that's the first thing. Second, if you have questions of this witness, she'll come back on the witness stand tomorrow morning after the interview's been played. At that point in time, the police will have the opportunity to complete its cross-examination. If you have any questions of the witness, you can ask them at that time as you've been able to do with the other witnesses. Okay?

(07:02:25)
What we're going to do is we're going to take a recess, allow the state to set up the other TV. We'll get you all back in. It'll probably take about 10 or 15 minutes, and I expect we'll go today until about 4:45 or so, and then we'll break. If you all want, we can take about a five or 10 minute break about 45 minutes into the interview and then pick it back up or we can go straight through. Everybody here think that they'll want to just go straight through. Raise your hands for straight through. Straight through today, today. Meaning that we'll watch until about 4:45. We're not watching five hours interview starting at 3:00. All right. We'll plan to do that. All right, let's go ahead and take a break. Jurors, leave your notepads here on your chairs, face down. Don't discuss the case with one another. This will be a short break. Jury's out the courtroom. We'll take about a 10-minute break. Mr. Hall, if you need to use the restroom, now would be the time. Members of the audience, if you need to use the restroom as well, now would be the time.

Judge McCourt (07:16:41):

Defendant has returned to the courtroom. Lawyers are present and we're ready to publish Exhibit 32. I heard the person who's running the camera for the media pool indicate that they're having difficulty with audio. What I can do, sir, is I will move my microphone that's in front of me on the bench near to the television, if that will help you capture the audio for your purposes?

Speaker 30 (07:17:04):

I can leave the podium [inaudible 07:17:06].

Judge McCourt (07:17:05):

Okay.

Speaker 30 (07:17:06):

Thank you.

Judge McCourt (07:17:08):

I'll do what I can for you. Alrighty.

(07:17:14)
Now, Mr. Barrett, does Mr. Hall wish to... I'm told that the laptop the State believed was hooked up to the back of the television is not there. So, if Mr. Hall wants to come to some other location in the courtroom so he can watch the video at the same time as the jury, he can do that, or he can remain at counsel table.

Dwain Hall (07:17:33):

I lived it. I don't want to live it again.

Judge McCourt (07:17:34):

Okay.

Mr. Barrett (07:17:37):

He's indicated, Judge, that he's seen the video so he doesn't need to see it again.

Judge McCourt (07:17:40):

I understand. Okay. Very well. All right.

Mr. Barrett (07:17:41):

Thank you, Your Honor.

Judge McCourt (07:17:42):

Very good. That's correct, Mr. Hall?

Dwain Hall (07:17:44):

I'm sorry, sir?

Judge McCourt (07:17:45):

That's correct, sir?

Dwain Hall (07:17:46):

Yes, sir.

Judge McCourt (07:17:46):

Okay. Very good. All right, are we ready for the jury?

Speaker 31 (07:17:48):

Yes, Your Honor.

Judge McCourt (07:17:49):

Defense, ready for the jury?

Mr. Barrett (07:17:52):

Yes, Judge, we're ready.

Judge McCourt (07:17:53):

All right, let's go and bring them in, please.

Court Attendees (07:17:54):

[inaudible 07:17:55].

Judge McCourt (07:19:25):

Ladies and gentlemen, welcome back. State?

Speaker 31 (07:19:28):

Would the court mind reading the edited recording instruction?

Judge McCourt (07:19:31):

Yes, sir. Members of the jury, you're about to view and listen to an audio video recording. The court instructs you that the recording has been edited to eliminate irrelevant portions that would not add to your understanding of the case. The fact that the recording has been edited should not concern you in any way and must not impact the way you view, listen to, and consider this evidence. With that said, State, you may now publish Exhibit 32.

Speaker 31 (07:19:51):

Thank you, Your Honor.

VIDEO: Speaker 7 (07:19:51):

Okay. [inaudible 07:20:39]. You're on the right.

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (07:19:51):

Here?

VIDEO: Speaker 7 (07:19:51):

Yeah, right there, right there.

VIDEO: Rebecca McKinsey (07:19:51):

Hi, Mr. Hall. My name is Rebecca-

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (07:19:51):

[inaudible 07:23:19].

VIDEO: Rebecca McKinsey (07:19:51):

... McKinsey. [inaudible 07:23:20]? Okay.

VIDEO: Joe (07:19:51):

Hi, Mr. Hall.

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (07:19:51):

Hello.

VIDEO: Joe (07:19:51):

What's your first name?

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (07:23:26):

As if you don't know. I don't like playing silly.

VIDEO: Joe (07:23:28):

Okay, well-

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (07:23:29):

I like to be direct. You know my name, or else I wouldn't be here.

VIDEO: Joe (07:23:30):

I-

VIDEO: Rebecca McKinsey (07:23:30):

What would you like us to call you?

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (07:23:30):

Dwain is fine.

VIDEO: Rebecca McKinsey (07:23:30):

Dwain is fine? Okay.

VIDEO: Joe (07:23:30):

Dwain? Okay, well, I was just going to say, because I honestly forgot, that's why I [inaudible 07:23:30]-

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (07:23:30):

Okay. I will accept that.

VIDEO: Joe (07:23:30):

My name's Joe. Dwain, it's a pleasure to meet you. I appreciate you coming up here.

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (07:23:49):

No, look, I'm going to say a few things and then we can get on with your interview and whatnot. Okay?

VIDEO: Rebecca McKinsey (07:23:53):

Absolutely.

VIDEO: Joe (07:23:53):

Okay.

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (07:23:55):

Number one, you guys want to impound my vehicle and search my vehicle, search warrant, whatever. Okay? I get it. But when you guys pulled us over today, my wife was on her way up to Shands post-transplant bronchoscopy with all of her meds, rejection and all that stuff was in that vehicle.

VIDEO: Joe (07:24:13):

Okay.

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (07:24:15):

Okay? So, whatever you are looking for in my vehicle is not going to be in her bag that she needs to have that keeps records of all her breathing and everything else that they need.

VIDEO: Joe (07:24:25):

Okay.

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (07:24:27):

Okay? Not to mention you just kind of left her on the side of the highway.

VIDEO: Joe (07:24:31):

Okay.

VIDEO: Rebecca McKinsey (07:24:31):

Well, that-

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (07:24:33):

She just had this... I'm sorry to cut you off.

VIDEO: Rebecca McKinsey (07:24:35):

No, you're fine.

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (07:24:36):

She just had this at the beginning of August and they had to crack her chest open and everything else. So, I am-

VIDEO: Rebecca McKinsey (07:24:43):

I can tell that you're very concerned, and so I want to let you know-

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (07:24:45):

Yes, yes.

VIDEO: Rebecca McKinsey (07:24:46):

Yes, which absolutely, but you should be. So, I wanted to let you know that we are taking her to Shands so that she can go to the hospital.

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (07:24:55):

Just how is she going to get back home? Y'all took my vehicle.

VIDEO: Rebecca McKinsey (07:24:57):

We are going to make sure that that is arranged. So, I don't want you to worry about that, we have not left her stranded.

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (07:25:06):

I know you're not going to leave her stranded, but... And her pills too, I hope?

VIDEO: Rebecca McKinsey (07:25:06):

We'll make sure that she gets what she needs to get.

VIDEO: Joe (07:25:08):

Describe the bag to me that the pills are in.

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (07:25:12):

It says University Florida Health Shands on it. It's blue and tan or something like that.

VIDEO: Joe (07:25:16):

Oh, that one, yeah.

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (07:25:16):

Yeah, that. Please.

VIDEO: Rebecca McKinsey (07:25:16):

Yes.

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (07:25:19):

Okay.

VIDEO: Rebecca McKinsey (07:25:19):

We will-

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (07:25:21):

And then we can get on with this interview.

VIDEO: Rebecca McKinsey (07:25:22):

Okay.

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (07:25:22):

Whatever it is that you guys need. There's another gentleman that I've been talking to, which I assume that this is about, I can only assume this is about, because I only work at home, it's all I ever damn well do.

VIDEO: Rebecca McKinsey (07:25:32):

Okay.

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (07:25:33):

And I've been talking to a fellow, Corbin? Calvin?

VIDEO: Rebecca McKinsey (07:25:40):

Mm-hmm.

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (07:25:41):

From FDLE, special unit, special agent guy up there. And seeing as how that's the only thing I'm ever mixed up in, is work and sleep, and this is the only thing that's out of the ordinary, I'm going to have to assume this heck got something to do with that. And if you had any contact with him, he'll tell you that I've been nothing but cooperative.

VIDEO: Rebecca McKinsey (07:25:58):

Okay.

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (07:26:04):

So, I'm going to do the best direct questions, get direct answers.

VIDEO: Rebecca McKinsey (07:26:06):

Okay.

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (07:26:06):

[inaudible 07:26:07].

VIDEO: Rebecca McKinsey (07:26:06):

That's the way I like to do business, so I think we'll get along fine.

(07:26:11)
And you're dealing with a lot because your wife is... So, on top of all of that, you're dealing with her.

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (07:26:19):

She died, dude. I mean, I ain't even going to get into that, but they had her on something called... What is it?

VIDEO: Rebecca McKinsey (07:26:26):

ECMO?

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (07:26:28):

Yeah, yeah, ECMO. [inaudible 07:26:29].

VIDEO: Rebecca McKinsey (07:26:28):

Where basically the machine was keeping her alive.

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (07:26:31):

Keeping her organs alive, just keeping them oxygenated. She wasn't even in there, okay? She was, but she was somewhere way in the back. But at the same damn time, I've been through a lot these last couple of months, and whatever this is related to is just the cherry on top, I feel like. So, by all means, ask away, or whatever you need will outright help you, okay?

VIDEO: Rebecca McKinsey (07:26:52):

Okay. So, I work with Calvin.

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (07:26:57):

Calvin? Yeah.

VIDEO: Rebecca McKinsey (07:26:57):

And so I'm helping him with this. One of the things that he did express to me was that when he did have a conversation with you, that you were adamant that we not come to your house or do anything in your house.

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (07:27:10):

Yeah, I [inaudible 07:27:11].

VIDEO: Rebecca McKinsey (07:27:10):

I know. And I'm thinking like-

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (07:27:17):

I'm so very sorry.

VIDEO: Rebecca McKinsey (07:27:25):

That was not our intention, but we're actually trying to do this in a way that was what you were asking.

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (07:27:26):

[inaudible 07:27:26]. And I super, super appreciate that. You guys are trying to work with me. I am trying my best to cooperate with you in any way that I can.

VIDEO: Rebecca McKinsey (07:27:33):

Okay.

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (07:27:33):

So, I think I've already mentioned that, that's just a repeat for you, okay?

VIDEO: Joe (07:27:35):

Awesome. Thank you, Dwain.

VIDEO: Rebecca McKinsey (07:27:38):

So, that is kind of why it happened the way that it happened this morning, because he relayed my [inaudible 07:27:44].

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (07:27:43):

That is perfectly fine. Perfectly fine.

VIDEO: Rebecca McKinsey (07:27:46):

Now, the other thing that I just want to get into is anytime we bring somebody down to the department, that we read them their rights. And it's just so that you understand that at any time you want to talk to us or-

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (07:27:56):

Okay, so am I being officially detained?

VIDEO: Rebecca McKinsey (07:28:03):

You are here to hopefully talk with us and-

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (07:28:09):

Straight answers.

VIDEO: Rebecca McKinsey (07:28:11):

Yeah.

VIDEO: Joe (07:28:11):

You're not detained.

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (07:28:11):

Am I being detained?

VIDEO: Rebecca McKinsey (07:28:14):

You're not detained-

VIDEO: Joe (07:28:14):

So, you're here-

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (07:28:14):

I [inaudible 07:28:15].

VIDEO: Rebecca McKinsey (07:28:14):

You voluntarily came up here.

VIDEO: Joe (07:28:19):

You were brought here voluntarily, you're not under arrest, you're not detained. If at any point you don't want to talk anymore, let us know. We did drive you up here. So, at the conclusion of this, when we're all done, the intent is to give you a ride to where you want to go. Obviously, you don't want to go to the house, but if there's somewhere nearby, we can arrange everything.

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (07:28:38):

My vehicle is everything right now, okay? I run my own company. I have a batch supposed to coming to work later today. You have my phone. You have everything that is pretty much my life right now tied up because you needed to search it.

VIDEO: Rebecca McKinsey (07:28:58):

And we're going to try to do that as quickly as possible, because we understand that's your livelihood.

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (07:28:59):

It's so much more than my livelihood, right?

VIDEO: Rebecca McKinsey (07:29:01):

Yeah.

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (07:29:02):

Okay? This is her emergency medical transport. This is [inaudible 07:29:06].

VIDEO: Rebecca McKinsey (07:29:06):

So, I should say it's your lifeline.

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (07:29:09):

Yeah, exactly.

VIDEO: Rebecca McKinsey (07:29:09):

Would that be appropriate?

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (07:29:11):

It's absolutely, yeah, it's absolutely my lifeline.

VIDEO: Rebecca McKinsey (07:29:12):

Okay.

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (07:29:12):

And it hurts. It hurts.

VIDEO: Rebecca McKinsey (07:29:16):

So, you said you kind of understand because [inaudible 07:29:18].

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (07:29:17):

Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, I've been talking to Calvin about this stuff. So, what's going on? [inaudible 07:29:18].

VIDEO: Rebecca McKinsey (07:29:17):

So, you understand that I do need to just tell you your rights?

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (07:29:26):

You got to do my rights.

VIDEO: Rebecca McKinsey (07:29:26):

It's checking a box.

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (07:29:30):

Read my rights, okay? Check the box.

VIDEO: Rebecca McKinsey (07:29:33):

Yeah. It's checking a box.

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (07:29:34):

You have the right to remain silent. Anything you say can and will be used against you in a court of law.

VIDEO: Rebecca McKinsey (07:29:35):

All right! You're going to do it. You're going to do it?

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (07:29:35):

You still have to do it, though.

VIDEO: Rebecca McKinsey (07:29:35):

I know, I still have to do it, even though you said it, you understand.

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (07:29:35):

[inaudible 07:29:42].

VIDEO: Rebecca McKinsey (07:29:43):

Yeah, exactly.

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (07:29:45):

You have the right to an attorney. If you can't afford one, one will be provided.

VIDEO: Rebecca McKinsey (07:29:49):

Before you make any statements or answer any questions, you must fully understand your constitutional rights. You have the right to remain silent, which you've already rehearsed to us. Anything you say can and will be used against you in a court of law. You have the right to call or obtain an attorney at this time, have them present now or at any time while we're talking with you. If you cannot afford an attorney and you want one before, at any time during questioning, one will be provided for you. If you decide to answer questions now, at any point, you can stop answering our questions-

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (07:30:22):

Voluntarily, of course.

VIDEO: Rebecca McKinsey (07:30:22):

Yes. Yeah, like we said, you voluntarily came down, we appreciate it. That's helpful for us.

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (07:30:26):

Well, like I said, I run the business, okay?

(07:30:27)
And then this mess comes up.

VIDEO: Rebecca McKinsey (07:30:27):

Yeah. So, really-

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (07:30:27):

[inaudible 07:30:36].

VIDEO: Rebecca McKinsey (07:30:35):

... the reason why we want to talk with you is because of some business transactions. And I think Calvin talked to you about how-

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (07:30:43):

Yeah, there was a [inaudible 07:30:45] that got turned down and declined multiple times and stuff. Yeah, it was pretty [inaudible 07:30:49].

VIDEO: Rebecca McKinsey (07:30:48):

So, can you tell me about that? Because I wasn't there for that conversation.

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (07:30:56):

I'm going to give you the cliff notes of it. There was a woman that called while I was not on duty. To my recollection, the sun was down. I'm not allowed to drive at night. I can't see very well at night. They called at night and they grabbed the wrong card and my card services kept declining it, so they kept going lower and lower on the amount. And the only thing she was saying that made made me paranoid and thought it was pretty sketchy, it was too quiet in the background for somebody to break down. For somebody that broke down, it was way too quiet in the background, and she kept saying over and over again, "I swear there's money on the card. I swear, I swear, I swear." And of course I declined and I didn't go out there.

(07:31:42)
And as far as I know, there's no record keeping of declined cards or attempted, but I don't know. It may be on the back end where I don't have access to it, but there's nothing that I can have access to. When I was out there the other day trying to find out a log, coincidental bullshit, they were actually having problems with the system. The system was down, so I couldn't log in so I could just go through it and let him press buttons and take a look or anything like that.

VIDEO: Rebecca McKinsey (07:32:03):

You're talking about the system that processes?

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (07:32:03):

Yeah.

VIDEO: Rebecca McKinsey (07:32:08):

Okay. Is that something that you do on your phone? You access it-

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (07:32:12):

I have a card reader. I have a card reader. It's like this big, I can insert, I can swipe, I can tap, and it links into my phone or I can manual input.

VIDEO: Rebecca McKinsey (07:32:21):

Okay.

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (07:32:24):

And it's all on my phone.

VIDEO: Rebecca McKinsey (07:32:25):

Okay. Can you tell me about the voice of the person that you talked to?

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (07:32:29):

No.

VIDEO: Rebecca McKinsey (07:32:29):

Okay. Anything else that-

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (07:32:34):

It seemed really... I don't even know, I'm going to be honest with you. I don't know.

VIDEO: Rebecca McKinsey (07:32:39):

What about an accent?

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (07:32:45):

It's like I told him and... Not really. Not really. But we've already determined that she was from the UK, so it doesn't really matter if I determined what the hell was going on with it or not, to be honest, because like I said, in my prior conversations with Calvin, he said she's from the UK. And I was actually thinking about it after I spoke to Calvin. I was like, "If I talk to him again, I'll throw my idea out there," just simply because I don't want to throw anything, I don't want to throw him into looking or thinking any different from what he's already going to look into, his thing.

(07:33:14)
And then if more comes of this, which it just did obviously, because I'm here and you have my vehicle, I was thinking about it. And I even asked my wife about it, because I had mentioned something about it the first time I got a call from Calvin, and me and her talked about it, and I'm more convinced than ever, I don't think, I seriously don't think it was about a service call. This is something that happens in my industry, okay? Let's say either one of you are subject to the same thing, okay? You call me up, "Hey, I need a jumpstart. Hey, I need a tire change." Okay, how you going to pay for it? Let me get your card. Let me run that and I'll be out there, whatever. I'm trying to ring the card. The card goes through. You call me 10 minutes later and say, "Nevermind, I need a refund."

(07:34:10)
What that would do and what I'm thinking, why she kept saying over and over again, "I swear there's money on the card," run the card for an exorbitant amount of money, which it was. I'm not going to play, it was like a week's pay. Like I'm going to turn that down, right? I'm a small company. There's literally two of us, okay? And I'm struggling to make ends meet. But if you ran the card and you called back 15, 20 minutes later and said, "No money on the card, I need a refund." I submit a refund, three, five business days later, you get your money back. Now, if there was somebody there coercing this woman to do this, all they have to do is keep that card, wait three, five days and then scan or whatever at the local ATM. That's what I'm thinking.

VIDEO: Rebecca McKinsey (07:35:00):

What do you mean, scan? I'm just trying to understand, because I don't-

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (07:35:03):

Put it in the ATM.

VIDEO: Rebecca McKinsey (07:35:03):

Oh, to get the money?

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (07:35:11):

Yeah. "Oh, we confirmed that there's $1,000 on there now. Let's go get it in five days."

VIDEO: Rebecca McKinsey (07:35:15):

Oh, because of the refund?

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (07:35:16):

Yeah, because of the refund.

VIDEO: Rebecca McKinsey (07:35:16):

Okay. All right.

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (07:35:18):

That's confirming that there's money on there and you wouldn't want to go to an... If you were up to some shady shit, you wouldn't want to go to an ATM and do that because they have cameras.

VIDEO: Rebecca McKinsey (07:35:26):

Okay.

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (07:35:29):

And it just so happened that they seen my company, because we're one of the top companies in the area, and we [inaudible 07:35:36] searches.

VIDEO: Rebecca McKinsey (07:35:33):

Okay. So-

VIDEO: Joe (07:35:33):

You mentioned-

VIDEO: Rebecca McKinsey (07:35:33):

Oh, go ahead.

VIDEO: Joe (07:35:33):

You mentioned $1,000 and I might be out of the loop on this, but you mentioned $1,000.

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (07:35:33):

Yeah, [inaudible 07:35:44].

VIDEO: Joe (07:35:33):

Was that [inaudible 07:35:45], or was that something else?

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (07:35:54):

No, it was nine, six? I don't know. She just kept lowering the amount, lowering and lowering and lower, got all the way down to $100. It started out $900, which I kind of flinched at. It's like, "You know I don't charge that much." "Just run it, just run it, just run it."

VIDEO: Joe (07:36:08):

And what was she wanting?

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (07:36:09):

Service. She never really said. There was not that much of a conversation about my car work. "I need help." "You need it towed?" "No. I just need help." Which is not out of the ordinary. We do mechanical, too.

VIDEO: Rebecca McKinsey (07:36:27):

Well, that's what I was going to ask you. What services, if someone was looking for the roadside assistance, what services do you provide?

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (07:36:35):

Jump starts, door unlocks, tire changes, and light mechanical. We can do lines, hoses, part swaps, all kinds of stuff. And as well as diagnostic, you might have something just as simple as a loose fitting or something that we need to fix [inaudible 07:36:52]. Half the garage is... We joke that it's in the back of my vehicle.

VIDEO: Rebecca McKinsey (07:36:57):

Okay.

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (07:36:58):

So, we can do pretty much whatever. I have about 90% completion rate, so we'll send this out and not get back on the road typically.

VIDEO: Rebecca McKinsey (07:37:06):

Okay. So, she called, and did she say there was something wrong with her vehicle or not?

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (07:37:15):

She said, "I need help." She said, "Basically my car broke down and..." I said, "Do you need towing?" "No." "Okay. Well, how do you want to pay?"

VIDEO: Rebecca McKinsey (07:37:24):

Okay. And so do you typically require payment prior to coming out?

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (07:37:30):

We typically... Okay, look, she was explaining, there was a follow-up question. "Okay, you need to..." "No." "Where are you located?" And she was trying to explain to me, and if I'm not mistaken, because I've been taking medication for my back, I had a car accident on the 4th, and I'm not supposed to be lifting myself right now, okay? I'm not supposed to be getting up and going around, I don't really-

VIDEO: Rebecca McKinsey (07:37:53):

Got to make money though, right?

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (07:37:56):

Yeah, I don't really have much of a choice. I got a few things going. So, muscle relaxers play a big part in it and I don't take pills. So, by the time the sun goes down, I've done already popped a couple muscle relaxers, especially if after I ate, I'm all but not in there. So, you have to bear with me on that a little bit. From what I remember, she was up around Exit 364.

VIDEO: Rebecca McKinsey (07:38:27):

So, I'm not familiar with the area where-

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (07:38:30):

[inaudible 07:38:31].

VIDEO: Rebecca McKinsey (07:38:30):

Well, that's why I have him in, because he's familiar with the area.

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (07:38:35):

I don't even know. I don't, I don't-

VIDEO: Rebecca McKinsey (07:38:35):

Are you familiar with it or?

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (07:38:35):

Yeah.

VIDEO: Rebecca McKinsey (07:38:35):

Okay.

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (07:38:42):

Because I drive right past it every day. I'm not really sure what that is that's right there, but if I'm not mistaken, she was up off of 364, out toward Reddick.

VIDEO: Rebecca McKinsey (07:38:50):

Okay.

VIDEO: Joe (07:38:52):

Okay.

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (07:38:52):

So, she was kind of out in the middle of nowhere.

VIDEO: Joe (07:38:55):

Did she say 364-

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (07:38:56):

[inaudible 07:38:57].

VIDEO: Joe (07:38:57):

... or did she-

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (07:38:58):

No, that's just she was telling me... She was trying to explain to me where she was, and because I've been doing this for a decade-

VIDEO: Joe (07:39:04):

Oh, okay.

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (07:39:06):

... I'm so used to doing stuff like that. I open up the map program and they start describing where they're at, and I start looking. So, like I said, I think, it's not necessarily where they were. It could have been anywhere and just telling me what I want to hear, okay? So, especially if she was under duress, which I'm firm that she was. [inaudible 07:39:38].

VIDEO: Joe (07:39:37):

Tell me more about that. Why do you say that?

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (07:39:37):

Because she was very, very adamant about, "There's money on the card, there's money on the card." That didn't look like she was talking to me. I didn't get the sense that she was talking to me.

VIDEO: Joe (07:39:48):

Okay.

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (07:39:51):

So, in hindsight, I feel like she was under duress. I feel like she was talking to somebody else. It was way too quiet. You broke down in the middle of nowhere, notice there's a lot of insects this time of year, should be able to hear it over the phone.

VIDEO: Rebecca McKinsey (07:40:03):

Oh, okay.

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (07:40:06):

You get me? Okay? Even if you're inside your car with the windows up, I should still be able to hear something. Even if the car completely [inaudible 07:40:14] power, I should still be able to hear something, even more so at night. There's going to be night birds, animals and whatnot, and I'm going to hear it, especially if you're not near the interstate, which, again, was way too quiet. So, I know she wasn't out in the interstate, because big rigs make a big whoosh when they go by.

VIDEO: Rebecca McKinsey (07:40:29):

Oh, yeah.

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (07:40:32):

Okay? So, like I said, I've been going this a long time. And when I was a kid, I was a tracker.

VIDEO: Rebecca McKinsey (07:40:41):

[inaudible 07:40:40] a tracker?

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (07:40:41):

A tracker? You don't know what a tracker is? When he shoots a deer, he needs to find it.

VIDEO: Rebecca McKinsey (07:40:45):

Oh, okay.

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (07:40:47):

He rounds up the local kids and [inaudible 07:40:49] up through the woods.

VIDEO: Rebecca McKinsey (07:40:52):

Okay, they'll find that deer.

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (07:40:52):

[inaudible 07:40:52], yeah.

VIDEO: Rebecca McKinsey (07:40:52):

Okay.

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (07:41:08):

So, I have a little bit of background [inaudible 07:40:56]. And I've been doing this for a decade. I just kind of got the impression she wasn't anywhere normal, just by lack of sound and the fact that she kept saying that over and over again before I hung up with her, "I swear there's money on the card, there's money on the card, I swear."

VIDEO: Rebecca McKinsey (07:41:17):

Okay. So, none of the transactions went through?

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (07:41:29):

‍

No transactions went through.

VIDEO: Rebecca McKinsey (07:41:29):

So, do you get notified about that immediately?

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (07:41:29):

Immediately. Immediately. "Card declined. Declined. Declined." [inaudible 07:41:37].

VIDEO: Joe (07:41:29):

How many times [inaudible 07:41:41] decline?

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (07:41:29):

I can't answer.

VIDEO: Joe (07:41:29):

One, or more than one?

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (07:41:29):

More than once.

VIDEO: Joe (07:41:29):

Less than one? Okay.

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (07:41:47):

Yeah, more than once, [inaudible 07:41:48].

VIDEO: Rebecca McKinsey (07:41:47):

So, you said there were varying amounts?

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (07:41:49):

Yeah. She kept dropping the amounts by a couple hundred dollars or so each time, four or five times, because she started at $900 and dropped it all the way down to $100.

VIDEO: Rebecca McKinsey (07:42:01):

And what were you thinking about when that was happening?

VIDEO: Rebecca McKinsey (07:42:04):

Okay. And what were you thinking about when that was happening?

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (07:42:04):

What the fuck is this bitch on?

Speaker 32 (07:42:04):

Okay.

VIDEO: Rebecca McKinsey (07:42:04):

That's fair, right?

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (07:42:04):

Yeah.

VIDEO: Rebecca McKinsey (07:42:04):

Okay.

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (07:42:04):

I mean, because it's nighttime. Nothing good happens at night, right?

Speaker 32 (07:42:14):

So you described not hearing anything but you described whooshing of trucks that you talked about hearing in the past with other calls, you didn't hear any of that, didn't hear bugs or anything-

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (07:42:25):

No.

Speaker 32 (07:42:25):

... chirping or nothing in the background?

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (07:42:28):

Nothing in the background. It was quiet.

Speaker 32 (07:42:29):

Where were you when you were having this conversation?

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (07:42:34):

I was actually out in the other side of Reddick. I was out there on a different type of job.

Speaker 32 (07:42:43):

Okay.

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (07:42:44):

I've gotten hired now. I ain't telling you anything about this because I signed an NDA for the client.

VIDEO: Rebecca McKinsey (07:42:46):

Okay.

Speaker 32 (07:42:51):

Okay.

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (07:42:53):

But if it comes down to it and you need that information, if you desperately need that information, I'll break that NDA. But the reason why the NDA was there was because there's a high profile client that has cars for people like Travolta and shit like that on his property, and he doesn't want that shit all disclosed.

Speaker 32 (07:43:15):

What about her side of Reddick? Like, you're-

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (07:43:17):

Man, we're talking about over that fucking way.

Speaker 32 (07:43:22):

Okay.

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (07:43:23):

Over that way, out in the middle of a fucking I don't know what, but out that way.

Speaker 32 (07:43:30):

Like further away from the interstate?

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (07:43:33):

Oh, yeah. Yeah.

Speaker 32 (07:43:35):

Where?

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (07:43:35):

My God, yes. I drove for probably 30 minutes just to get out in the general area. And then I had to park my vehicle with my phone and everything else initially before they'd take me on out to the property.

Speaker 32 (07:43:45):

Tell me more about that. Has it-

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (07:43:47):

It's pretty important. I can't tell you more about that. Tell me why it's more important.

Speaker 32 (07:43:53):

Because it's different from what you told before.

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (07:43:55):

Yeah, because I wasn't asked these questions before.

Speaker 32 (07:43:58):

Well, now we're asking them, so that's why-

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (07:44:02):

Okay. So basically what happened was dude had a bunch of parked cars out there, old shit. My favorite one was the '33 rat rod with a big 355 sitting down in it, it all chromed out and shit. And he basically had me out there doing maintenance on them and he said he chooses a different company every year. And basically, he goes through Yelp or whatever to find a small company. And then if they know what they're doing, because he'll sabotage his car on purpose to see if they know what they're doing. And I had his car fixed when he did that to me in two minutes. So now [inaudible 07:44:42].

Speaker 32 (07:44:42):

Do you remember what he did to sabotage it?

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (07:44:43):

He just unplugged the wire.

Speaker 32 (07:44:44):

Oh, okay.

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (07:44:45):

Yeah, he unplugged the wire that's kind of hidden down in there. I said, "Oh, try it now." And I hooked my box up to it, box said everything was good and I reached down and I started looking and... It just [inaudible 07:44:57].

Speaker 32 (07:45:00):

And I'm not as familiar with cars. What wire would cause the whole car not to start like that?

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (07:45:04):

The ground wire.

Speaker 32 (07:45:05):

Oh, okay.

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (07:45:07):

If you unground the vehicle, you can't start the vehicle.

Speaker 32 (07:45:08):

Okay.

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (07:45:14):

It won't [inaudible 07:45:10]. The new cars are a little bit different. You have to have about half a dozen of them. But the old-school ones, they have one major ground in there. If you unhook it just enough or make it loose in there, it won't ground and it won't go.

Speaker 32 (07:45:18):

Okay.

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (07:45:20):

And it'll cut off while you're driving.

Speaker 32 (07:45:28):

Gotcha.

VIDEO: Rebecca McKinsey (07:45:28):

Learn something new every day.

Speaker 32 (07:45:28):

Yeah.

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (07:45:31):

I've been doing mechanics since I was five, so I'm almost 50 years of history and experience. So anyway, he had me come out there and then he had me sign the NDA and he paid me a shit-ton of money. And basically, he was getting all his cars ready for the big car shows that happen this time of the year, like the spooky Halloween drives, et cetera, et cetera. At least that's what I was told.

Speaker 32 (07:45:48):

Okay.

VIDEO: Rebecca McKinsey (07:45:52):

What time did he reach out to you? Is this something that you've been working with him for-

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (07:45:59):

Oh, yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Way before she even went in for her transplant. It actually got delayed because of her transplant.

VIDEO: Rebecca McKinsey (07:46:00):

Okay. And how did he find you?

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (07:46:05):

If I remember right, it's probably through Yelp.

VIDEO: Rebecca McKinsey (07:46:07):

Okay.

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (07:46:09):

Because I have a small add on Yelp that people can find if they really need someone to do something. Especially after hours or if you ain't got any other option, people look at Yelp.

VIDEO: Rebecca McKinsey (07:46:22):

Look at the reviews and see what the reviews are.

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (07:46:27):

We got pretty good reviews there and we're a pretty reliable company, so it is what it is. I showed up, I had him back on the road in under 30 minutes. He liked that idea. He called me up about a week later, told me he had more work for me and that was that.

Speaker 32 (07:46:44):

And then that's when the NDA came up and... Okay.

VIDEO: Rebecca McKinsey (07:46:44):

Did he give you a copy of it? Is there any paperwork?

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (07:46:53):

Okay. So now that you're asking the direct questions, I can tell you about that too. Too bad I don't have my phone here or I'd show you. For that time period, normally I have calls coming all hours of the day and night, okay?

Speaker 32 (07:47:03):

Yeah.

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (07:47:06):

Okay. So on that weekend when these transactions and interactions with this individual were taking place, they disappeared. I didn't delete them.

VIDEO: Rebecca McKinsey (07:47:18):

Okay.

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (07:47:19):

I literally have three calls listed for, I think it's Sunday. Three. It's either Saturday or Sunday. There's three calls compared to 20, 30 a day that are coming to my phone.

VIDEO: Rebecca McKinsey (07:47:33):

So did the calls come in and you were having those conversations and it wasn't logged, or you weren't getting calls at all?

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (07:47:40):

Calls were coming in. They vanished. They vanished out of the call log. Text messages, emails, everything. Everything regarding and relating to that service that I did out there, vanished, gone, like it never happened.

VIDEO: Rebecca McKinsey (07:47:55):

Okay.

Speaker 32 (07:47:58):

How'd he pay you?

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (07:47:58):

Paid [inaudible 07:48:01] card.

Speaker 32 (07:47:58):

Okay.

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (07:48:02):

Paid by card. Read card numbers off to me, I programmed them in and I got paid. I got paid 1,200 [inaudible 07:48:13] dollars for 36 hours of my time.

VIDEO: Rebecca McKinsey (07:48:16):

For the guy with the car?

Speaker 32 (07:48:24):

And you said that he read you the numbers, so did you hand type that in or did you tap or swipe or do something?

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (07:48:28):

No, no. He read the numbers off.

Speaker 32 (07:48:30):

Okay.

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (07:48:30):

Because after the NDA, I never seen him again.

Speaker 32 (07:48:30):

Okay.

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (07:48:38):

And he always sent a driver to come pick me up and take me whenever I was scheduled to go out there.

Speaker 32 (07:48:43):

What was his name?

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (07:48:46):

It was Harold and I can't remember. I'm shit with names. I just am. It was Harold and I was joking that I tried to commit it to memory, but it sounded a lot like the last name was Hydrangea, but it wasn't. It sounded like that. It was Harold something, and I think it's a fake name.

VIDEO: Rebecca McKinsey (07:49:05):

Okay. How did he originally reach out to you?

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (07:49:08):

I told you that.

VIDEO: Rebecca McKinsey (07:49:09):

Well, you said he contacted you, but did he call you?

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (07:49:12):

Yeah.

VIDEO: Rebecca McKinsey (07:49:13):

Okay. He called you and he called you on the phone number that was listed, which is the phone number that you have?

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (07:49:18):

My phone number.

VIDEO: Rebecca McKinsey (07:49:20):

Okay. And when was that again, initially?

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (07:49:41):

Months ago. Months ago. Six, seven months ago.

VIDEO: Rebecca McKinsey (07:49:47):

Okay. And I just want to make sure that I'm understanding. That was at the time that he tested you?

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (07:49:47):

Yeah.

VIDEO: Rebecca McKinsey (07:49:47):

Six months ago?

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (07:49:47):

Yeah. Yeah, six months or thereabouts.

Speaker 32 (07:49:47):

Where did you go for that six, seven months ago?

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (07:49:47):

If I'm not mistaken, it was the Cracker Barrel down off 484.

Speaker 32 (07:49:49):

Okay.

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (07:49:51):

If I'm not mistaken.

Speaker 32 (07:49:59):

Walk me through how that whole interaction went, like how-

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (07:50:00):

Normal.

Speaker 32 (07:50:00):

Okay.

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (07:50:00):

I don't know what your question is.

Speaker 32 (07:50:00):

Just walk me through how that went.

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (07:50:01):

Do you expect me to remember something six months ago? I barely remember yesterday, boss.

VIDEO: Rebecca McKinsey (07:50:07):

Oh, you sound like me now.

Speaker 32 (07:50:07):

As much as you can. I don't know, did-

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (07:50:16):

Showed up, did the job. He called me on the phone and I told him how much it would be, and then he said okay. And I showed up and paid me cash.

Speaker 32 (07:50:17):

He paid you cash?

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (07:50:17):

Paid me cash.

Speaker 32 (07:50:18):

How much did he pay you?

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (07:50:21):

Oh, our service total was $25.

Speaker 32 (07:50:24):

Oh, okay. So was it the standard 25-

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (07:50:24):

Yes.

Speaker 32 (07:50:24):

... or something more, something less?

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (07:50:24):

No.

Speaker 32 (07:50:24):

Okay.

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (07:50:24):

$25.

Speaker 32 (07:50:24):

Okay.

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (07:50:33):

And of course it's cash. There's no transaction receipts or anything like that or stuff like that, especially when I'm coming from insurance companies because that's where my main money comes from. I have contracts with just about anybody who can have roadside assistance through third-party contractors. So chances are I'd probably see you see out there, providing I'm allowed to ever leave and get out [inaudible 07:50:56]-

VIDEO: Rebecca McKinsey (07:50:55):

[inaudible 07:50:56].

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (07:50:56):

... go back to work, I might see any one of you guys.

VIDEO: Rebecca McKinsey (07:50:58):

So you're on a rotation with the insurance companies? Or you're-

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (07:51:07):

No. Right now, just because we're only in Gainesville generally right now, basically it goes off of our overall score and we're right at the top if the list so we see about 90% of everything comes that in [inaudible 07:51:21].

Speaker 32 (07:51:21):

Okay.

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (07:51:22):

If not more.

Speaker 32 (07:51:25):

And I probably missed this in the beginning, I'm sorry. What's the name of your company?

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (07:51:27):

Oh, sure, sure, sure. Solver, S-O-L-V-E-R, Wolf, W-O-L-F, R-S-A, Roadside Assistance.

Speaker 32 (07:51:35):

Okay.

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (07:51:38):

So of course we're listed with the Sunshine Business or whatever. We're a legitimate business.

Speaker 32 (07:51:43):

Okay.

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (07:51:43):

We have a tax ID. We have [inaudible 07:51:46]. We're legit. We're not fly-by-night.

Speaker 32 (07:51:50):

Okay. Before, you said you had two people, just two people working?

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (07:51:53):

Me and another guy.

Speaker 32 (07:51:56):

Okay. Do you have a couple cars? Is it just your car?

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (07:51:59):

Yeah, you got to use your own vehicle.

Speaker 32 (07:52:00):

[inaudible 07:52:02].

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (07:52:02):

I have another employee, but he's not working right now because we found out his license was expired and he got in an accident and totaled my other car, my other family vehicle.

Speaker 32 (07:52:13):

Okay.

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (07:52:13):

So it's like, yeah, no. When you get your own vehicle and you get your license sorted out, you can come back to work.

Speaker 32 (07:52:17):

Okay.

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (07:52:17):

You can come back and do nothing that is here in Ocala, okay? But yeah, so... Yeah.

VIDEO: Rebecca McKinsey (07:52:17):

Okay. So you said that you thought maybe he had given you a fake name because you couldn't really remember it?

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (07:52:36):

No, it's not because I couldn't remember. It's because of what happened to the digital footprint afterwards.

VIDEO: Rebecca McKinsey (07:52:36):

Of this most recent? Okay.

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (07:52:37):

And you're going to ask me what his name was then and I'm going to tell you I don't know.

VIDEO: Rebecca McKinsey (07:52:50):

Okay. [inaudible 07:52:53].

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (07:52:50):

I'm going to tell you '63 'Cuda, Okay?

Speaker 32 (07:52:50):

Because you don't know or because the NDA?

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (07:52:56):

Because I don't know.

Speaker 32 (07:52:57):

Oh, okay. I didn't know if it-

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (07:52:58):

Yeah, no. I'm shit with names.

Speaker 32 (07:53:00):

Okay.

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (07:53:00):

If I wasn't looking at your name as Miller, I'd probably already have forgotten your name.

Speaker 32 (07:53:04):

Okay.

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (07:53:05):

But I'll remember your car for six, eight months. I'll know that car. I'll be riding down the road and I'll see that car and it'll look like any other car out there, I'll be like, "I worked on that and it's still on the road." But yeah, I do that all the time.

Speaker 32 (07:53:18):

Okay.

VIDEO: Rebecca McKinsey (07:53:20):

Tell me about what he looked like, because you said you did meet him in person.

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (07:53:25):

He looked like a Middle Easterner, but tall.

VIDEO: Rebecca McKinsey (07:53:27):

[inaudible 07:53:28]

Speaker 32 (07:53:27):

[inaudible 07:53:28] okay.

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (07:53:27):

He looked like a Middle Easterner. In my brain, this is how I remember what he looked like, okay? He was a tall Middle Easterner, but his teeth were too big for his face and his smile was too big for his teeth.

VIDEO: Rebecca McKinsey (07:53:43):

His teeth were too big for his face. Smile was too big for his teeth?

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (07:53:50):

Uh-huh.

VIDEO: Rebecca McKinsey (07:53:50):

Okay.

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (07:53:52):

So when he smiled, you seen everything. It looked like this creepy serial killer vibe on the smile. [inaudible 07:53:59] of course his teeth were as white as your paper.

Speaker 32 (07:54:01):

Okay.

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (07:54:01):

And it made his teeth look way too big for his face. And then he smiled super fucking creepy big on top of it. And then of course he's tan and he's got the darker-colored hair. It's just like [inaudible 07:54:16] this guy. But at the same time, that's really nondescript because I don't remember faces. Like I said, I don't [inaudible 07:54:33].

VIDEO: Rebecca McKinsey (07:54:32):

Clothing?

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (07:54:32):

Standard casual dress, yeah. Casual dress, yeah.

Speaker 32 (07:54:32):

Looking at yourself, it sounded like you [inaudible 07:54:34].

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (07:54:33):

Really clean, very clean, very tidy. That's the one thing that stood out. Don't have a hair out of place. Just clean, tidy, very [inaudible 07:54:47].

VIDEO: Rebecca McKinsey (07:54:46):

So was that what he was wearing when you met-

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (07:55:04):

It was the last time I seen him.

VIDEO: Rebecca McKinsey (07:55:04):

Which was?

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (07:55:04):

[inaudible 07:55:04] It would've been a Friday. Friday evening. A week ago, I want to say. Last Friday. I want to say last Friday. I have my phone and I'll be able to tell you there.

Speaker 32 (07:55:04):

Okay.

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (07:55:21):

Oh, that's another thing. Talking about digital footprints, he paid me at 11 o'clock at night, but when I look at the thing, it says 1:09 PM. Because he said, and I quote, "My other truck was delayed and didn't come in, so I don't have the extra 20 vehicles for you. So you're done. Our contract is over." And he paid me. And then I went home that Sunday, or I tried to go home that Sunday, but I was being followed.

Speaker 32 (07:55:57):

How so?

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (07:55:57):

I was being tailed.

Speaker 32 (07:56:03):

Tell me more about that?

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (07:56:05):

I can't really tell you too much because they never got close enough, but it was either... It was along the lines because they got these stupid-ass new colors now because they can't just be silver or fucking gray. But it was on color spectrum type from a silvery tan color. You know what I'm talking about, right? When the vehicle color that gets out of that tan cream color and more into the charcoal color, the gray color. It was something like that or maybe a silver color sedan.

VIDEO: Rebecca McKinsey (07:56:38):

So it kind of depends on how the light's shining on it?

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (07:56:38):

Yeah.

VIDEO: Rebecca McKinsey (07:56:38):

Okay.

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (07:56:42):

And it was blacked out.

VIDEO: Rebecca McKinsey (07:56:43):

Okay.

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (07:56:44):

I mean, at least from my vantage point, it was blacked out. It freaked me out enough that I actually didn't go home.

VIDEO: Rebecca McKinsey (07:56:54):

Okay. Tell me more about that?

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (07:56:55):

I got off like I was going to get off to go home. I went past the entrance to where I would normally turn to go to my house and I came back. I U-turned and come back because it's like there's no way. There's coincidence. Maybe he's just getting off, maybe he's going out through here. I went and came back and then I noticed that they turned too, so I dipped into a side little spot and sat there for a few minutes until they left, until I thought they left.

(07:57:18)
And then I zipped and took some back roads and I sat there and waited and I seriously sat there. And, no, I don't know what the address is. But at the same time, I sat there and I waited for an hour and they kept making passes on the main road and now they couldn't see the back of my vehicle I didn't care about them. They kept making passes on the main road and then I left. And when I left, they pulled in and stopped right where the fuck I was because I went down, got back to the main road and left because I ain't going home to my house. And when I went back through, they were sat right where I was.

Speaker 32 (07:58:00):

What day would that have been?

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (07:58:01):

Sunday morning.

Speaker 32 (07:58:01):

Sunday morning? Okay.

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (07:58:04):

Sunday morning.

Speaker 32 (07:58:05):

Where were you parked for an hour?

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (07:58:05):

I was out in the back of Marion Oaks.

Speaker 32 (07:58:05):

Okay.

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (07:58:12):

[inaudible 07:58:11] Marion Oaks. And it was up near 484.

Speaker 32 (07:58:16):

Okay. And I'm sorry, how long were you parked there?

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (07:58:18):

About an hour.

Speaker 32 (07:58:19):

Okay.

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (07:58:20):

About an hour, maybe. Maybe a little less, maybe a little more. I know because I smoked my dabs, the legal dabs that you can get at any store. I sit there and smoked some dabs while I was waiting to calm the nerves, which is actually in my car right now.

Speaker 32 (07:58:39):

Oh, they're in there? I was going to ask if they were like-

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (07:58:39):

They're in the vehicle right now.

Speaker 32 (07:58:43):

Well, you said they pulled in after you. I didn't know. Did you leave anything behind when they pulled up?

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (07:58:47):

Never got out of the vehicle.

Speaker 32 (07:58:47):

Okay. You never even got out? Okay.

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (07:58:56):

So I don't know if [inaudible 07:58:54]. And the fact that the digital footprint disappearing from the whole interaction, and then when I leave the area and I decide I want to go home, I spent some time with my wife who I'm very grateful to have back alive and missed terribly because I've been gone pretty much Friday and Saturday.

VIDEO: Rebecca McKinsey (07:59:16):

So you provided the service to this guy that you think's name is Harold on Friday night?

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (07:59:24):

Yeah, Friday night. Well, it was Friday night and Saturday night.

VIDEO: Rebecca McKinsey (07:59:29):

So Friday and Saturday night you were with him?

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (07:59:34):

Yeah. Well, I wasn't with him, but I was on his property.

VIDEO: Rebecca McKinsey (07:59:39):

Okay.

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (07:59:40):

Okay?

VIDEO: Rebecca McKinsey (07:59:41):

And where was that property at?

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (07:59:45):

South off of 122nd somewhere.

VIDEO: Rebecca McKinsey (07:59:45):

Okay.

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (07:59:46):

I don't even know what the actual address is. It's 122nd, somewhere out that way. That's where my phone's GPS pinged from and that's where I had to leave it. But we went somewhere else, probably about 10 or 15 minutes away.

Speaker 32 (08:00:01):

Okay. Tell me more about that? It's where your phone pinged from, what do you mean by that?

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (08:00:05):

My wife tracks my GPS.

Speaker 32 (08:00:07):

Oh, okay. How does she do that?

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (08:00:08):

Life360.

Speaker 32 (08:00:09):

Oh, okay. Gotcha.

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (08:00:13):

Yeah, it's set up that way because if ever get in trouble, then the phone... My job is not exactly the safest job.

VIDEO: Rebecca McKinsey (08:00:26):

Yeah. You're out everywhere.

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (08:00:27):

Yeah, yeah. I go in all kinds of neighborhoods with no expectation of coming out of them, to be honest.

Speaker 32 (08:00:28):

Yeah.

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (08:00:32):

And it used to be a lot worse and working a lot worse neighborhoods.

Speaker 32 (08:00:34):

Describe to me, so you said that's where your phone was pinging from. Describe to me how you got there and then what happened, because you mentioned a 15-minute drive and I'm curious because this sounds really...

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (08:00:48):

It's really fucked up.

Speaker 32 (08:00:52):

Yeah. Yeah. What happened when you got there?

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (08:00:57):

We got there and basically he had a... I don't know what the hell you'd call it. It's not a full size trailer. It's like a mini house. He had a mini apartment there that wasn't attached to anything, and that's where he let me stay while I was working on his vehicles.

VIDEO: Rebecca McKinsey (08:01:19):

Okay.

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (08:01:20):

Yeah. And then my vehicle stayed basically parked there, and then he made me leave my phone behind.

VIDEO: Rebecca McKinsey (08:01:28):

Okay. Tell me more about where you stayed.

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (08:01:34):

Where I stayed?

VIDEO: Rebecca McKinsey (08:01:35):

Just what did it look like? I know you said like a mini trailer, but you stayed there for the weekend?

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (08:01:42):

I stayed there Friday night and Saturday night, right.

VIDEO: Rebecca McKinsey (08:01:42):

Okay. So what does the outside look like?

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (08:01:42):

White. Just white.

VIDEO: Rebecca McKinsey (08:01:42):

Okay.

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (08:01:50):

Nondescript, man.

VIDEO: Rebecca McKinsey (08:01:53):

Nondescript?

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (08:01:53):

Nondescript. Got nothing to tell you.

Speaker 32 (08:01:55):

What kind of structure is it?

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (08:01:58):

Just like a mini trailer.

Speaker 32 (08:01:58):

Okay. When you say trailer-

VIDEO: Rebecca McKinsey (08:01:58):

Like what [inaudible 08:01:59].

Speaker 32 (08:01:59):

... I think of a camper, so that's why I'm trying to get you to describe it to me.

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (08:01:59):

No, no, no. It's like mini house.

VIDEO: Rebecca McKinsey (08:01:59):

Mobile home?

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (08:01:59):

No. Yeah, yeah.

Speaker 32 (08:01:59):

Oh, okay.

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (08:01:59):

[inaudible 08:02:01] mini.

Speaker 32 (08:01:59):

Mini, okay.

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (08:01:59):

[inaudible 08:02:01].

Speaker 32 (08:01:59):

So like a...

VIDEO: Rebecca McKinsey (08:01:59):

A tiny house. [inaudible 08:02:01]

Speaker 32 (08:01:59):

A tiny house, mini [inaudible 08:02:01] thing.

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (08:02:00):

Yeah. I don't know if it was mobile or not, but yeah, at the same time.

Speaker 32 (08:02:22):

Okay.

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (08:02:22):

A tiny house.

Speaker 32 (08:02:22):

Okay.

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (08:02:24):

But it was a little bigger than your standard tiny house.

Speaker 32 (08:02:26):

Okay.

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (08:02:27):

The difference is [inaudible 08:02:30].

Speaker 32 (08:02:30):

And I'm trying to picture-

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (08:02:31):

A rectangle, mobile home-ish home.

Speaker 32 (08:02:31):

Yeah.

VIDEO: Rebecca McKinsey (08:02:31):

Okay.

Speaker 32 (08:02:32):

Describe, was the front of it on the long side, the short side, or something else?

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (08:02:44):

The short side.

Speaker 32 (08:02:44):

Okay.

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (08:02:44):

If it's a rectangle, it's back here.

Speaker 32 (08:02:50):

Okay. And describe to me if I'm standing in the yard or the road, I don't know where it sits, so I don't know how it sits, but if I'm sitting here looking at it, describe what the front of it looks like.

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (08:02:59):

Just looked like any other house you could imagine. A small porch on the front of it, covered. Table on the porch.

Speaker 32 (08:03:06):

Table on the porch. Covered porch.

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (08:03:07):

Sliding glass door [inaudible 08:03:07].

Speaker 32 (08:03:07):

Okay.

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (08:03:07):

[inaudible 08:03:07].

Speaker 32 (08:03:07):

No. That's perfect. [inaudible 08:03:17]

VIDEO: Rebecca McKinsey (08:03:17):

Because you said you were worried about people following you, so we're just trying to get a-

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (08:03:25):

[inaudible 08:03:25] worried about people following me. I'm not worried about people following me. I mean, I drive around enough to pretty much know when somebody's behind me. I knew you guys were behind me before you flipped your lights on. And you can ask them. I slipped over. I seen you coming and got over into the middle lane to let you guys go by well before you flipped your lights on. I'm not [inaudible 08:03:42]-

VIDEO: Rebecca McKinsey (08:03:42):

So you're pretty aware.

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (08:03:43):

I can tell when somebody's following me, I have to be aware because it's not the '90s and 2000s anymore, but I still live like it is. There used to be other private companies in my industry, not nice [inaudible 08:04:00]. So I'm still hyper aware of people tailing me even if they're a half mile back, if I can see them and I'm watching them make similar moves to what I'm going, I'm going to speed up, slow down. I'm going to do something to either draw them in so I can get a better look or something. I'm going to do something until I determine that they're actually not following me. And not in a paranoid way, but you have to actually be back there for a minute and actually obviously following me.

(08:04:32)
And like I said, even today, I seen you guys coming before I knew you were coming for me. And because the wife even asked me, "What are you doing?" I said, "I'm getting pulled over." And then you guys slid in and you [inaudible 08:04:49] your lights and then you slid in behind me with the lights on and then I just made my way right over to the side of the road.

Speaker 32 (08:04:55):

So this house, rectangular, entry on the front side, you said sliding doors, porch.

Speaker 34 (08:05:04):

It just appears, for the benefit of the record, that there are some messages popping up about the computer we need to update or restart.

Speaker 33 (08:05:09):

Yes, sir.

Speaker 34 (08:05:10):

Have you delayed that so it doesn't -

Speaker 33 (08:05:12):

I have. It won't start for another 24 hours.

Speaker 34 (08:05:15):

Okay.

Speaker 33 (08:05:16):

And I've moved it down to the bottom so you can't see it anymore.

Speaker 34 (08:05:17):

Yeah.

Speaker 33 (08:05:17):

Very good. Sorry about that, Your Honor.

Speaker 32 (08:05:18):

The inside, you said you were staying at it from the time that you were there. What did the inside look like?

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (08:05:28):

Nondescript, just like you'd expect to see in a little apartment.

Speaker 32 (08:05:35):

Okay. When you go through the sliding glass door that you just described as being the front end, what do you come into?

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (08:05:41):

Living room, kitchen, small hallway, bedroom, bathroom.

Speaker 32 (08:05:44):

Okay.

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (08:05:45):

Another bathroom, back bedroom.

Speaker 32 (08:05:47):

Okay. So living room and kitchen, describe to me how that was laid out. Do you walk into the kitchen or the living room?

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (08:05:54):

The living room.

Speaker 32 (08:05:55):

Okay.

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (08:05:57):

It was very small. It was only maybe one and a half of this room, if that.

Speaker 32 (08:06:01):

Okay.

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (08:06:02):

Very small. [inaudible 08:06:03] I'm looking at you like [inaudible 08:06:05].

VIDEO: Rebecca McKinsey (08:06:07):

We're trying to picture what you're talking about.

Speaker 32 (08:06:08):

Yeah [inaudible 08:06:11].

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (08:06:11):

I don't even know what that has to do with anything right now.

Speaker 32 (08:06:13):

What was outside and around the property where you were staying?

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (08:06:16):

Fields.

Speaker 32 (08:06:17):

Fields?

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (08:06:18):

Horses, cows.

Speaker 32 (08:06:19):

Okay.

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (08:06:20):

Trees, ponds, more houses. Little houses like that.

Speaker 32 (08:06:25):

Well, because I want to... After we talk, I'd be curious if I were trying to find it, what would I... You said 122nd?

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (08:06:35):

122nd something.

Speaker 32 (08:06:38):

Do you remember if it was a street, what it was called?

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (08:06:42):

You're asking the wrong questions. I already told you. If I have my phone, I'd be able to tell you. Might even be able to tell you the address.

VIDEO: Rebecca McKinsey (08:06:42):

So you said-

Speaker 32 (08:06:50):

How so? How could you tell from the phone?

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (08:06:51):

By GPS.

Speaker 32 (08:06:51):

Okay. Oh, you mentioned Life360.

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (08:06:51):

Mm-hmm.

VIDEO: Rebecca McKinsey (08:06:51):

So you said that Harold's the one that said you could stay there?

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (08:06:51):

Harold's the one that unlocked the damn door.

VIDEO: Rebecca McKinsey (08:06:51):

Okay. That's what I was trying to just figure out how -

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (08:07:06):

And we went in and signed the NDA right there on the center island counter.

VIDEO: Rebecca McKinsey (08:07:08):

Okay. So all that happened at this...

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (08:07:08):

Yeah.

VIDEO: Rebecca McKinsey (08:07:08):

Okay. So Harold let you in and you signed the paperwork.

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (08:07:20):

Mm-hmm. You want to hear something else really more fun? Wife told me I should definitely mention this. On the very last night there, I was on the phone with her and I was talking to her, and this is before he told me, mind you, this is before I was told [inaudible 08:07:31] before I was told on the phone that the other truck was delayed and my service, my contract was done

‍

and over. I was talking to her on the phone and I said, "Well, this is fun. Big blow up. Oh, follow along if you can. There's a big blow up. I guess a trespasser or something." Because there was a bunch of loud shit going on.

(08:07:56)
And mind you, this is after I'd already got back over there because I was pretty much done for the evening. I'd finished all the vehicles that was there to be done. [inaudible 08:08:07] oil changes, spark plug swaps on some of them, air filter swaps, cabin air filters, coils, whatever. Just small, normal maintenance for vehicles that's been sitting for a while. [inaudible 08:08:23] make sure that it's going to be firing up the first time you turn the key because you don't want your [inaudible 08:08:29] to not fire up when you want it to fire up obviously, okay?

(08:08:32)
So like I said, there was that whole big mess, okay? And then there was a bunch of loud shit going on, arguing and yelling and whatnot. And I said, "It must be a trespasser." Because I insisted on being allowed to take my phone after the first night, because I had a weird feeling. So I kept sneaking my phone, but GPS was wrong. I could barely get a phone call out.

VIDEO: Rebecca McKinsey (08:09:01):

Okay.

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (08:09:01):

It just went wrong. And he had some kind of signal damper on the buildings.

VIDEO: Rebecca McKinsey (08:09:12):

So the trespasser, that situation was the place that he took you to?

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (08:09:16):

Uh-huh.

VIDEO: Rebecca McKinsey (08:09:18):

So not where you're staying on 122nd. And he came and picked you up?

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (08:09:27):

No, I told you already, he had a driver. He had somebody he referred to as his driver come and pick me up.

VIDEO: Rebecca McKinsey (08:09:30):

Okay. That's right, you said.

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (08:09:30):

And it was never the same person. It was always somebody different.

VIDEO: Rebecca McKinsey (08:09:30):

What did that vehicle and driver look like that came and picked you up?

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (08:09:43):

A nondescript mini SUV, kind of like mine, except it was never the same vehicle. This guy had tons of fucking cars. It was never the same fucking vehicle. It was always some little trashy piece of shit that he picked me up in. I was not insulted. I did not give a fuck. And he was going to pay-

VIDEO: Rebecca McKinsey (08:09:53):

Hey, he was paying you money, right?

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (08:10:00):

He's going to pay me two weeks wages to do two nights worth of work. Well, it was supposed to be three, but at the same time.

Speaker 32 (08:10:05):

What kind of car was it the first time?

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (08:10:08):

The first time?

Speaker 32 (08:10:08):

Mm-hmm.

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (08:10:13):

Oh, yeah. I don't know what year it was, but it was a muscle car.

Speaker 32 (08:10:17):

Okay.

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (08:10:18):

I think it was a GTO Judge, but it was a later one.

Speaker 32 (08:10:18):

Yeah.

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (08:10:18):

So I don't know exactly what year it was. And of course that was fun to ride in.

Speaker 32 (08:10:27):

Oh, yeah.

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (08:10:30):

You know, I love them. [inaudible 08:10:31]

Speaker 32 (08:10:30):

I think of that being loud exhaust just [inaudible 08:10:31].

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (08:10:30):

Oh, shit yeah. It just pulled straight pipes with [inaudible 08:10:33] packs just rumbling down an old country road.

Speaker 32 (08:10:35):

Okay. Is that-

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (08:10:35):

[inaudible 08:10:38].

Speaker 32 (08:10:38):

That's how it was?

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (08:10:40):

Oh yeah, that's how it was. There is nothing better. And of course I was excited to see all that and be in the seat of a show car like that. It's a real piece of machinery. He had another one there that had, I think it was a 350 Cleveland Rocket sitting down there with the orange... What the fuck do you call it? The airflow [inaudible 08:11:04] and everything just all [inaudible 08:11:07].

Speaker 32 (08:11:06):

Wow.

VIDEO: Rebecca McKinsey (08:11:07):

I was like, "Don't look at me to figure out what to call anything on cars."

Speaker 32 (08:11:26):

Yeah. I know. I know a little bit but not a lot.

VIDEO: Rebecca McKinsey (08:11:26):

I don't know about cars.

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (08:11:27):

It was so amazing. But yes, [inaudible 08:11:27] I got in there and he had a cart in front of him, like a cart like you would take commissary around on in jail.

Speaker 32 (08:11:30):

Oh, okay.

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (08:11:32):

He had a cart and it had everything on that you needed to [inaudible 08:11:36] that car. He already had all the cars up on these lift jacks.

Speaker 32 (08:11:41):

Oh, wow.

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (08:11:41):

Yeah. It was completely level, off the ground and I could scroll right under on the little skier thing he had in there. I had to actually put my hair up again so it wouldn't get caught in the wheels.

VIDEO: Rebecca McKinsey (08:11:45):

Sounds like he had a nice setup.

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (08:11:45):

Yeah. [inaudible 08:11:56].

VIDEO: Rebecca McKinsey (08:11:45):

So he had all the stuff.

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (08:11:45):

All the [inaudible 08:12:01].

VIDEO: Rebecca McKinsey (08:11:45):

Everything lined up ready to go.

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (08:11:45):

[inaudible 08:12:04].

VIDEO: Rebecca McKinsey (08:11:45):

Did he have the tools too or did you have to bring the tools?

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (08:12:06):

I tried to bring my tools and he says, no. And he had this [inaudible 08:12:14].

VIDEO: Rebecca McKinsey (08:12:07):

So he had everything in extreme?

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (08:12:20):

Yeah, yeah, yeah. It's like, if I was to do something like that and if I was to retire and not going to do the job [inaudible 08:12:23]. And this is the other weird thing about that is he kept taking me back to the same building, but I never saw a semi or a car hauler. But he'd take me back to the same building and there'd be different cars in it.

Speaker 32 (08:12:38):

Oh, wow.

VIDEO: Rebecca McKinsey (08:12:38):

Okay.

Speaker 32 (08:12:43):

How many times did you go to the building?

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (08:12:45):

Three times.

Speaker 32 (08:12:45):

Three times?

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (08:12:47):

Friday night.

Speaker 32 (08:12:48):

Friday night? Okay.

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (08:12:49):

Saturday afternoon.

Speaker 32 (08:12:50):

Saturday afternoon.

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (08:12:55):

Came back and then went back Saturday night.

Speaker 32 (08:12:55):

Okay.

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (08:12:57):

And then right around what I assume was right around 11:00 or so, I finished the last vehicle, opened the phone with my wife, the big blow up happened.

Speaker 32 (08:13:09):

Oh, where you were at? Okay. All right. All right. So now I'm making more sense of this. Okay.

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (08:13:14):

And then I got a call from him telling me my contract was finished. And then I was free to go or what the fuck ever the next morning. He told me to stay one more night and then I was free to go the next morning, which I went out. I went out and [inaudible 08:13:30].

Speaker 32 (08:13:32):

So you had your phone on you.

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (08:13:33):

[inaudible 08:13:33].

Speaker 32 (08:13:33):

You had your phone on you Saturday night when you went over. How about Saturday morning and Friday night? Were you able to take your phone? Because you mentioned at one point you started sneaking it, so...

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (08:13:42):

Yeah, exactly. Friday night I started sneaking it with me.

Speaker 32 (08:13:43):

Okay.

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (08:13:49):

But I had zero bars, lines, [inaudible 08:13:49] thing, no signal, nothing like that. So that's how I know he had a damper on it. He basically had signal jammers on because he did not want this place [inaudible 08:13:58] at all. At all.

Speaker 32 (08:14:01):

Were you able to check your phone while you were driving there? Was there a point in the trip where it just went to the line like you called it?

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (08:14:08):

[inaudible 08:14:10] I was trying to sneak it, you know?

Speaker 32 (08:14:08):

Okay. And it-

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (08:14:13):

Because I knew I wouldn't get paid. It would directly violate the NDA that I signed and basically said I wouldn't disclose anything about anything and no outside communication, electronic devices, no blah, blah, blah, blah, blah.

Speaker 32 (08:14:29):

Okay.

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (08:14:29):

I wasn't allowed to take pictures of the cars. I wasn't allowed to do this, that or the other.

Speaker 32 (08:14:33):

Okay.

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (08:14:33):

[inaudible 08:14:38].

VIDEO: Rebecca McKinsey (08:14:33):

[inaudible 08:14:40] cars.

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (08:14:33):

I love them cars, I do. [inaudible 08:14:45].

VIDEO: Rebecca McKinsey (08:14:33):

How big was the building?

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (08:14:55):

Let's see. Big enough to double line 10 cars. So, one, two, three, four, five, six, seven [inaudible 08:15:00]-

VIDEO: Rebecca McKinsey (08:14:57):

Okay. So it's a total of 20 cars, 10 on each side?

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (08:14:57):

Yeah. And then-

VIDEO: Rebecca McKinsey (08:15:18):

Okay. So a total of 20 cars, 10 on each side?

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (08:15:18):

Yeah. And then of course you had to have enough room to pull them in and out. You know what I mean?

Speaker 32 (08:15:18):

So you're describing cars lined up down the sides with an area that they would drive in on?

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (08:15:18):

Uh-huh.

Speaker 32 (08:15:18):

Okay.

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (08:15:19):

And there was only one big double door in the front. And it looked like a barn. It just looked like a barn from the outside, never knew that shit was in there.

VIDEO: Rebecca McKinsey (08:15:27):

Okay. Tell me more about that looking like a barn. Color?

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (08:15:30):

Looked like a barn to me. It looked like a barn.

VIDEO: Rebecca McKinsey (08:15:34):

Well, when I think of a barn, I'm like, red with black doors or but...

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (08:15:37):

I don't know. It was a newer construction, kind of a cream white color.

VIDEO: Rebecca McKinsey (08:15:54):

Okay. Do you know what type of material it was made out of?

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (08:15:54):

It could have been anything.

VIDEO: Rebecca McKinsey (08:15:54):

Like a prefab building?

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (08:15:54):

It could have been prefab. It could have been prefab. I didn't look too much at the building.

VIDEO: Rebecca McKinsey (08:15:54):

Okay.

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (08:15:55):

[Inaudible 08:15:55] on the cars.

Speaker 32 (08:16:01):

What are some of the other cars you remember?

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (08:16:05):

Just your standard array of heavy, good-looking cars. There was a lot of Camaros and some Mustangs, the old school Mustangs. Wasn't nothing too outstanding except for that 33 [inaudible 08:16:19]. And then he had a '57 Chevy that was all blown, but it wasn't overdone. But I do remember it was the gas motor because it took almost a full two gallons of oil.

Speaker 32 (08:16:30):

Okay.

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (08:16:30):

I think it was a 545 with a pancake. Basically, it's the same motor they use in monster trucks.

Speaker 32 (08:16:45):

Oh, wow.

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (08:16:45):

Okay?

Speaker 32 (08:16:45):

Yeah.

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (08:16:45):

545 with pancake. It was a full on smuffler.

Speaker 32 (08:16:45):

Wow.

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (08:16:48):

But when we fired it, and I was there when he fired it up and thing.

Speaker 32 (08:16:56):

Crazy loud.

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (08:16:57):

Yeah, crazy loud, probably stood up on two wheels and walked away. Struck my boss, I'll tell you right now. Just based on what I was looking at. And that was another thing, I did that when he said change the oil out and it was chrome, everything was fucking chrome.

Speaker 32 (08:17:15):

Okay. Friday night, or I'm sorry, Friday before you got to that house or whatever, that mini house that you described going to-

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (08:17:25):

Now we get to the worst part of the story that I'm dreading talking about altogether because I have a really bad feeling about it again. Like I said, really bad. This thing went from I'm not really paying attention to it to really fucking bad, in my opinion, because everything that happened. He called me up. I was working in Gainesville. Shift ended at 6:00. He called me up and he said, "Hey, I need you to go pick somebody up from Gainesville Airport." Okay. I picked somebody up from Gainesville Airport, female, tried to make small talk with them. They told me basically, and I'm barely even paraphrasing here, "Shut up. I don't talk to the help."

Speaker 32 (08:18:03):

Okay.

VIDEO: Rebecca McKinsey (08:18:03):

This is what this person said?

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (08:18:03):

Mm-hmm.

VIDEO: Rebecca McKinsey (08:18:03):

Okay.

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (08:18:04):

"Shut up, I don't talk to the help. Just drive."

Speaker 32 (08:18:12):

Okay.

VIDEO: Rebecca McKinsey (08:18:13):

Okay.

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (08:18:13):

I drove. She got out of my vehicle, walked up to him like she knew him, gave him a hug, hopped in. What was that fucking... Maybe a '70s Cadillac El Dorado with a separate driver, all blacked out and they left.

VIDEO: Rebecca McKinsey (08:18:36):

And where was that?

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (08:18:37):

At 122nd.

VIDEO: Rebecca McKinsey (08:18:37):

Okay.

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (08:18:41):

I was told that, that was a buyer and was going to purchase one of the vehicles. That's why I had to pick her up and they didn't have her in the vehicle because they were going to be driving off in their own vehicle.

Speaker 32 (08:18:58):

Okay.

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (08:18:58):

And that was the last I heard about that until that blow up on Saturday night.

Speaker 32 (08:19:02):

Okay. Describe her to me.

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (08:19:07):

5'8", 5'9". Dark hair, pulled back, very prude. Very prudent.

Speaker 32 (08:19:17):

What do you mean by that?

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (08:19:17):

Flowery dress. Flowery dress, kind of low cut, but just like I said, when I tried to make small talk, "Shut up. I don't talk to the help."

Speaker 32 (08:19:27):

Okay.

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (08:19:27):

Prudent. And [inaudible 08:19:33].

Speaker 32 (08:19:33):

What'd she sound like?

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (08:19:37):

American?

VIDEO: Rebecca McKinsey (08:19:37):

[inaudible 08:19:39].

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (08:19:37):

Yeah, kind of.

VIDEO: Rebecca McKinsey (08:19:41):

Yeah? Okay.

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (08:19:43):

Maybe a slightly deeper voice.

Speaker 32 (08:19:45):

Okay. Did she have anything with her? You said you picked her up at the airport.

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (08:19:50):

A bag.

Speaker 32 (08:19:50):

Okay.

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (08:19:50):

She really didn't have anything.

Speaker 32 (08:19:54):

And what kind of bag?

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (08:20:01):

I wasn't paying that much attention. Short skirt. What do you want me to say? [inaudible 08:20:07]. Look at the legs. But that was, I want to say around 8:00 on Friday evening.

VIDEO: Rebecca McKinsey (08:20:05):

On Friday?

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (08:20:05):

Yeah, Friday evening around 8:00.

VIDEO: Rebecca McKinsey (08:20:06):

Now I know you said that you picked her up from the airport. Where at the airport did you pick her up at?

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (08:20:32):

On the front.

VIDEO: Rebecca McKinsey (08:20:32):

The front?

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (08:20:33):

Yeah. Apparently she had a description of my vehicle because when I pulled over to slow down at the time I seen the plane come in, I gave it about 10 minutes. And then I went up to the front and when I pulled over, they walked up to my vehicle and got in.

VIDEO: Rebecca McKinsey (08:20:51):

They said they?

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (08:20:51):

Typo.

VIDEO: Rebecca McKinsey (08:20:51):

Okay.

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (08:20:51):

Mental typo.

VIDEO: Rebecca McKinsey (08:20:51):

I just want to make sure.

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (08:20:52):

They being them. Kind of a they/them person.

VIDEO: Rebecca McKinsey (08:21:03):

One person?

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (08:21:04):

One person singular.

VIDEO: Rebecca McKinsey (08:21:07):

Okay.

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (08:21:07):

There's no room for passengers as it is. I had to make some room for a passenger because I've been taking my wife back and forth.

VIDEO: Rebecca McKinsey (08:21:15):

To Gainesville. So-

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (08:21:15):

It's full of equipment, computers or what have you.

VIDEO: Rebecca McKinsey (08:21:15):

What you need to do your job?

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (08:21:24):

Yeah. Everything I need to do my job. So I had to take a bunch of that out. Well, not a bunch of it. It was a laptop and some other towels and whatnot. I had to rearrange because you get wet from sitting on the seat [inaudible 08:21:38].

Speaker 32 (08:21:37):

What number did he call from Friday when he called you and [inaudible 08:21:48]?

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (08:21:47):

I told you. And like I said, that digital footprint is gone. I went backwards.

Speaker 32 (08:21:55):

So that one's gone too?

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (08:21:57):

Yeah. Everything from about Friday. Everything from Friday on forward up until, I want to say Sunday, there's a missing digital footprint. And we're talking about emails from him that I had, because I saved a bunch of stuff that's business related. Those emails are gone. All text messages and all phone numbers, they're gone, straight fucking gone. And that freaked me the fuck out. Until we got to this point here, I didn't even feel comfortable bringing it up with Cal.

Speaker 32 (08:22:40):

What do you remember about the phone number? Did the area code stick out to you or anything about it?

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (08:22:48):

I don't remember. I don't do numbers, man. I don't do numbers and I don't do people. I just don't. I have no memory for that stuff. But the car, like I said, the car, I can tell you exactly what I did to it four years ago. I can tell you exactly what I did to your car four years ago.

Speaker 32 (08:23:03):

So prior to the phone call, you said you were on a job or something?

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (08:23:11):

No, no, no. My shift ends at about 6:00 PM. At a certain point there, that was the first weekend I think that we were going to stay open past 6:00 PM. I was supposed to have another guy working in Gainesville, my other employee.

Speaker 32 (08:23:24):

Okay.

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (08:23:24):

I opened up evening shift just for him basically. I was getting ready to make my way out of town to where he said to meet the man. Then he called and said, "Change of plans. I need you to get out to Gainesville Airport to pick up a client." And I'm like, "what?" "I need you to go out to the airport, to Gainesville Airport and pick up a client for me."

Speaker 32 (08:23:50):

Okay.

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (08:23:54):

"Okay. What?" "Don't worry about it. They'll know you." Nothing unusual considering that you already told me I was going to have to sign an NDA, so apparently this is something I didn't even know. Above my pay grade.

VIDEO: Rebecca McKinsey (08:24:09):

Yeah.

Speaker 32 (08:24:09):

Had you been paid?

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (08:24:20):

No. No, no, no. No. Like I said, this is apparently what I assume, just the way I approach things like that, just above my pay grade. [inaudible 08:24:29].

Speaker 32 (08:24:29):

And I only asked because earlier, that girl you were talking about, that you wanted payment first. So had he paid you anything before you started helping him?

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (08:24:35):

No, not at all. Not at all. This was a prearranged thing. This isn't just like you called me out of the fucking blue. This was, "Okay, this is the area I'm going to hang out. When I'm finished, you pay me." This is just like you called me now that I know who you are.

Speaker 32 (08:24:49):

No, you're fine.

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (08:24:49):

I don't your name, I'm sorry. But at the same fucking time, now that I know who you are, you're probably going to tell me, "Hey, this is Mr. Miller. Well, I spoke to you for hours on end at the interrogation room and I broke down. Can you come help me?" And I'll be like, "Oh yeah, sure. Where you at?" And then when I get over there and you know my fee's $25 or whatever, because I've already met you. This is a phone call from somewhere that I don't recognize.

VIDEO: Rebecca McKinsey (08:25:08):

You know it's not a scam.

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (08:25:19):

And it's not even that it's not a scam. It's just that I already have a history with you. Or it doesn't matter if I've met you before and you tell me I've met you before, I do things a little different. But if you're just cold and I don't know who the hell you are, I want to make sure you pay me before I drive to you, number one, especially if you're out in the service area and it's after my service hours. I'm not going to send my other guy out because I don't want to put him in danger like that, especially if it's after he's supposed to be off work.

Speaker 32 (08:25:53):

Yeah, okay. So the...

VIDEO: Rebecca McKinsey (08:26:01):

So when you're in town and you're working-

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (08:26:03):

Calls come in from the insurance company.

VIDEO: Rebecca McKinsey (08:26:03):

Calls come in.

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (08:26:08):

I use a digital dispatch called Towbook. All my shit comes through there. Anything that comes in from outside there.

VIDEO: Rebecca McKinsey (08:26:17):

So is Gainesville your response area?

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (08:26:19):

Yep.

VIDEO: Rebecca McKinsey (08:26:20):

So do you just drive around or is there a place that you hang out when you're waiting for those calls or how does a day work?

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (08:26:30):

If you want me to walk you through a day, that's fine. When do I get up in the morning usually? I don't set an alarm, but normally I naturally wake up between 6:00 and 7:00 in the morning. We open up in Gainesville at 7:00 AM.

Speaker 32 (08:26:40):

Okay.

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (08:26:41):

So I'm trying to get out of there. I'm trying to get out of my house and get out to Gainesville before 7:00 AM, usually late because I oversleep by at least an hour. At least for now, until I fall back and then I'll be finally on time again.

VIDEO: Rebecca McKinsey (08:26:52):

Yeah.

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (08:26:56):

But okay, so I get up, do my thing, usually stop at Dunkin Donuts down 484. And it's almost the morning routine. I shoot myself up here in Gainesville and then I wait for calls to come in. I usually, because my vehicle's familiar here and they'll let me do it for now at least. I park in Shands parking garage [inaudible 08:27:20] pay. It's cooler in there. I shut my vehicle off. Turn off the AC. So I save a little money by sitting there. And then of course they got cafeteria, so if I want something to eat or drink, I just go to the cafeteria. And it's real convenient and seems how my wife has to be there two, three days a week anyway. There's a good chance I'm there with her anyhow. So I'm either waiting on her or doing things with her or waiting for phone calls to come in. Well, service calls to come in.

(08:27:49)
And once the service call comes in, I accept it. Given an ETA and I'll respond. And I'll do that. And sometimes I'm busy enough to zip, zip, zip, zip, zip all over the damn place. And sometimes I'm back to the parking lot and sit and wait. Sometimes, especially when I'm there with the wife, I'm going to her appointments with her usually on Wednesdays because those are clinic days. That's where we got to see the transplant team. So they like to see both of us at the same time. And she's probably supposed to have me there with her today because they're on bronchoscopy.

Speaker 32 (08:28:28):

Okay. So is that how your Friday went before all that stuff started happening with them?

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (08:28:32):

Friday was pretty much a routine thing on Friday.

Speaker 32 (08:28:37):

How many service calls did you have Friday?

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (08:28:39):

Well, I could find out. If I had any of my shit here, I can tell you right now because it's all old.

Speaker 32 (08:28:42):

Okay. All in your phone?

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (08:28:42):

Yeah.

Speaker 32 (08:28:42):

Okay.

VIDEO: Rebecca McKinsey (08:28:42):

[inaudible 08:28:50]-

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (08:28:50):

[inaudible 08:28:50] tells me the calls I ran on what days, but I can see more information about it in my laptop, which is always at home.

Speaker 32 (08:28:54):

That's at home? Okay.

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (08:29:00):

Ever since I brought her home from transplant a couple weeks back, two, three weeks back, that's how it stays home.

Speaker 32 (08:29:10):

So Friday, roughly, how many service calls do you have a day? I'm not going to Hold you-

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (08:29:16):

We average Friday, seven or eight calls a day.

Speaker 32 (08:29:17):

Okay. Was Friday an average day for you?

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (08:29:22):

I don't really remember that. I remember I've been so stressed out after Calvin called me initially and everything else. And then of course on the 4th, I got in a car accident and it's killing me too, by the way. But yeah, so-

VIDEO: Rebecca McKinsey (08:29:36):

The calls that come in, because you said you're on insurance lists, but you're also listed as your independent business. So you have calls come in that go directly to your phone and then calls that come in through-

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (08:29:46):

Yeah. Yeah, yeah, yeah. Towbook.

VIDEO: Rebecca McKinsey (08:29:46):

Towbook.

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (08:29:49):

Yeah.

VIDEO: Rebecca McKinsey (08:29:49):

So you could get calls from both of them?

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (08:29:52):

I could, but it's way less common to get just a straight through call unless I've dealt with you before. I give you my card or something like that. A lot of times, I see people in rapid succession and you only get so many credits a month or a year with your regular roadside systems. And I always tell people to save that for just in case and just call us if it's not towing. That way, if you get in a situation where you need towing, you at least have knowledge and security of having that credit that you don't have to pay full price for towing.

Speaker 32 (08:30:24):

Okay.

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (08:30:24):

So yeah, that's general.

VIDEO: Rebecca McKinsey (08:30:31):

So you had a normal amount of calls, nothing would stick out to you on Friday prior to you meeting with Harold and picking up the woman from the airport?

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (08:30:41):

Yeah. Prior to getting a phone call from Harold to go pick up this client from the airport. And then basically, I had calls coming in all Saturday.

VIDEO: Rebecca McKinsey (08:30:54):

Okay.

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (08:30:55):

At least I think I did. I don't know. I'd have to look carefully at my thing. But-

Speaker 32 (08:30:58):

What kind of phone do you got?

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (08:31:08):

Does it matter? You've got [inaudible 08:31:03]. I'm sorry, God. But you're asking dumb-ass questions. No, I'm just kidding. I know you got to ask all these questions. It's a Samsung Galaxy 22S or something like that. It's some Galaxy phone.

Speaker 32 (08:31:11):

Oh, okay.

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (08:31:11):

Some kind of Galaxy phone. [inaudible 08:31:13] with you guys.

Speaker 32 (08:31:20):

See, I'm an iPhone guy. What kind of passcode does that have? Is it a code or one of them pattern things?

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (08:31:26):

Whatever. Not being an asshole.

Speaker 32 (08:31:30):

No, you're fine. I'm an iPhone guy.

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (08:31:31):

I'm being literal. It's anything I want it to be.

Speaker 32 (08:31:32):

Oh, okay.

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (08:31:34):

I have those options to do. I can do patterns, I can do haptic, I can do fingerprint. I can do all any of it. I can do retina.

Speaker 32 (08:31:48):

Oh, okay.

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (08:31:49):

So mine's not set up like that. I don't have it set up like that because I don't like that. Because what if something happens and somebody wants to force me into a situation and they want me to unlock my phone?

Speaker 32 (08:32:00):

Yeah.

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (08:32:00):

If I'm not conscious, they can just hold my eye and scan the retina. With a fingerprint, have fun guessing which one.

Speaker 32 (08:32:11):

Yeah, that's true. And that's actually factual.

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (08:32:12):

It is fingerprint. Have fun guessing which one if I don't want you to know.

VIDEO: Rebecca McKinsey (08:32:20):

Yeah. Smart up. You said that sometimes when you were working, that you would take your wife to her appointments?

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (08:32:25):

Yeah. Yeah, that's been a regular thing lasts about two, three weeks now.

VIDEO: Rebecca McKinsey (08:32:28):

Okay.

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (08:32:29):

Because she got out at the... She was in there all August and she got out in September.

VIDEO: Rebecca McKinsey (08:32:34):

Okay.

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (08:32:34):

Yeah.

VIDEO: Rebecca McKinsey (08:32:38):

So do you run any errands or anything like that beyond doctor's appointments? Because you mentioned you go to Dunkin Donuts.

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (08:32:48):

I try not to, but of course family duties call, so [inaudible 08:32:50] from Walmart [inaudible 08:32:50].

Speaker 32 (08:32:50):

Okay.

VIDEO: Rebecca McKinsey (08:32:50):

Did you do that on Friday at all? Run any errands?

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (08:32:59):

No, no, no. Friday was all business.

Speaker 32 (08:32:59):

All business Friday?

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (08:33:06):

That Friday was all business. [inaudible 08:33:07], where I was going and everything and I wouldn't be home, et cetera, et cetera.

VIDEO: Rebecca McKinsey (08:33:06):

Okay. So she was aware you were going to be gone for the weekend for this?

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (08:33:22):

Exactly what I was doing and exactly what it was going to entail. I told her about the NDA. I told her about not being allowed to have my phone and the whole thing. I told her everything. Well, she's not my business partner. She's my wife.

VIDEO: Rebecca McKinsey (08:33:35):

She's your business partner, right? Whether formal or informal.

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (08:33:40):

Yeah, very informal.

VIDEO: Rebecca McKinsey (08:33:40):

No, you sound like a good husband. You got to keep her... She knows what you need to.

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (08:33:40):

I tell her everything I do and everywhere I go, I even told her about all this mess.

VIDEO: Rebecca McKinsey (08:33:40):

Yeah. Yeah.

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (08:33:55):

Especially after Calvin got ahold of me, I freaked out. I was crying because it was like-

VIDEO: Rebecca McKinsey (08:34:09):

What was going through your head then?

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (08:34:09):

I was like, "I'm not going to be out there again because this is bullshit." Sorry?

VIDEO: Rebecca McKinsey (08:34:09):

No. So he called you and you said it really upset you. So what was going through your head? What was going on?

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (08:34:10):

[inaudible 08:34:10] some bullshit again and everything I worked so hard to do was going to be ruined. My wife was going to be left stranded and I was...

Speaker 32 (08:34:26):

I had asked you before and we kind of got sidetracked.

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (08:34:26):

Yeah, sorry.

Speaker 32 (08:34:26):

No, no, you're fine. We got sidetracked with the cool car that [inaudible 08:34:33].

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (08:34:30):

[inaudible 08:34:34].

VIDEO: Rebecca McKinsey (08:34:30):

It's okay.

Speaker 32 (08:34:36):

No, you're all right. So you said Friday, he picked you up in that cool, loud muscle car we were talking about.

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (08:34:38):

[inaudible 08:34:41].

Speaker 32 (08:34:41):

Okay. And then how about Saturday morning and Saturday night? How did he pick you up those times?

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (08:34:45):

[inaudible 08:34:48].

Speaker 32 (08:34:47):

Okay.

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (08:34:48):

Little [inaudible 08:34:49] stick shift. I think he was trying to flex. I think he was trying to flex. He already had me there, so what's the point, right?

Speaker 32 (08:34:54):

Yeah.

VIDEO: Rebecca McKinsey (08:34:54):

But yeah, once you saw the other cars, you were like, "I'm in."

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (08:34:54):

Yeah, I'm in. Yeah, let's do this.

Speaker 32 (08:35:09):

What were the other cars? Just standard SUV cars that you were talking about?

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (08:35:36):

I think one of them was a [inaudible 08:35:37]. There was another one that's [inaudible 08:35:37]. It's not an Encore. Something like that.

Speaker 32 (08:35:36):

Like a Buick SUV type thing?

VIDEO: Rebecca McKinsey (08:35:36):

A mid-size.

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (08:35:42):

A mid-size, about the same size as mine. Just a nice little car. Definitely it was a work car. It was pretty on the inside. I don't fucking know. What do they give fuck? If he probably had greasy fucking clothes [inaudible 08:35:45] fancy muscle car. But you know, hey. Whatever. [inaudible 08:35:50].

Speaker 32 (08:35:53):

And I also wanted to ask you, was anyone else staying in the house with you that you were in?

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (08:35:55):

Just me.

Speaker 32 (08:35:55):

Just you? Okay.

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (08:35:55):

It was just me. [inaudible 08:36:04]. You can ask my wife the same thing because I called her from there. [inaudible 08:36:13]. And it was obvious that there was nobody there [inaudible 08:36:17] TV or whatever.

Speaker 32 (08:36:07):

Okay.

VIDEO: Rebecca McKinsey (08:36:25):

Now you said that the Saturday night, so I guess the third time that you went to the building, that there was some sort of disturbance and you thought that maybe it involved the woman that you had picked up from the airport. Can you tell me more about that?

VIDEO: Dwain Hall (08:36:40):

There's not much to tell. It was just some screaming and yelling. It was just really suspicious in hindsight after getting a phone call, but it was really, really too quiet. [inaudible 08:36:53].

Judge McCourt (08:36:56):

All right, members of the jury, it's about a quarter to five. We've had a pretty long day today. We're going to go ahead and pause the recording. We'll pick up tomorrow morning when we start the trial.

(08:37:05)
So a couple things before we break for the day. Obviously this is going to be a recess. I spoke to you yesterday when I instructed you about how you were to conduct yourself over recesses. Tonight when you're at home, do not talk to anybody about the case. Do not allow anybody to talk to you about the case. As you can see, there's been a camera in the courtroom throughout the trial. Therefore, I'm going to instruct you all again, do not access social media. Do not access any websites where you may come into contact with news. Okay?

(08:37:32)
I'm also going to instruct you all to avoid YouTube, Netflix, other things like that where streaming programs commonly are. If you really need to watch TV tonight, make sure you stay away from any platform where you can access anything about court proceedings or court cases. Okay? And again, if you use your electronic devices, do not attempt to learn anything about the case, research anything about the case or look up anything having to do with the case. Okay?

(08:37:57)
I'd like you all back here tomorrow morning at 8:10. I have two short hearings at 8:00. I should be able to get through by about 8:15 or so. We'll be done with that and hopefully ready to go right at 8:30. Okay? I'm going to have Deputy Cabrera talk to y'all about Thursday lunch options when you all get to the back there because we have an option we can give you. I'm not sure if y'all will want it or not, but we have Jimmy John's in tomorrow. State, defense, anything else you'd like to cover before the recess?

Speaker 35 (08:38:23):

No, Your Honor.

Speaker 36 (08:38:24):

No, Your Honor.

Judge McCourt (08:38:25):

Okay. Members of the jury, we'll see you back tomorrow morning. Leave your notepads here, get a good night's sleep. And if y'all have little things like pillows that are not particularly valuable that you want to leave in the back, feel free to. Okay?

Speaker 36 (08:38:42):

[Inaudible 08:38:43].

Judge McCourt (08:38:42):

Y'all can be seated. Mr. Buxman, what is the timestamp? It's about one hour, 16 minutes.

Mr. Buxman (08:39:36):

39 seconds. Probably backed up about 30 seconds.

Judge McCourt (08:39:39):

Yeah. We'll just start at 1:16.

Mr. Buxman (08:39:41):

Yes, sir.

Judge McCourt (08:39:42):

Tomorrow morning?

Mr. Buxman (08:39:43):

Yes, sir.

Judge McCourt (08:39:47):

Okay. Lawyers, do y'all have anything you need to bring up with the court before morning?

Speaker 35 (08:39:49):

Nothing, Your Honor.

Speaker 36 (08:39:50):

Nothing from the defense.

Judge McCourt (08:39:51):

One thing I want you all to think about, there's been a good amount of evidence that we've displayed on the screens here. I have a computer and a laptop. The laptop is not connected to the internet or any type of computer network. If during deliberations we want for the exhibits, we can load up all of the interviews, everything like that, that the jury can watch through a laptop, onto the laptop, and they can have it back there in the jury room while they deliberate. If y'all want to do that, I've got the TV in the back. We can do it over lunch one day, but if the jury wants to watch this interview again, it will save us from having to sit in the courtroom for four and a half hours while they watch it. Also, they can review the evidence and discuss it with each other, but it'll take some time to upload it. But if that's something y'all agree to and want to do, we can do that.

Speaker 35 (08:40:32):

Yes, sir.

Speaker 37 (08:40:32):

Thank you, Judge.

Judge McCourt (08:40:32):

Okay. Anything else?

Speaker 35 (08:40:32):

No, Your Honor.

Speaker 36 (08:40:32):

No, Your Honor.

Judge McCourt (08:40:32):

Okay. All right. We'll see you all tomorrow morning.

(08:40:32)
[inaudible 08:40:51].

‍

Topics:
No items found.
Hungry For More?

Luckily for you, we deliver. Subscribe to our blog today.

Thank You for Subscribing!

A confirmation email is on it’s way to your inbox.

Share this post

Copyright Disclaimer

Under Title 17 U.S.C. Section 107, allowance is made for "fair use" for purposes such as criticism, comment, news reporting, teaching, scholarship, and research. Fair use is permitted by copyright statute that might otherwise be infringing.

Subscribe to The Rev Blog

Sign up to get Rev content delivered straight to your inbox.