Judge Dean Bucci (00:00):
Did you reach out to Sean, or? [inaudible 00:01:03]. Why?
Ray Lale (00:00):
Judge, [inaudible 00:01:12].
Judge Dean Bucci (01:15):
We could try to track one down. Let me try to do that for you.
Ray Lale (01:19):
Thank you.
Judge Dean Bucci (03:04):
[inaudible 00:01:28]. I'll tell you another idea, which this is just me thinking out loud, it may be too much on the lawyers, and it may be too much on the jury, but I could bring in dinner for the jury and we could work late, like to eight o'clock this week. That might be too much on y'all.
Ray Lale (03:32):
That's fine.
Mr. Steel (03:33):
I'm not going to say it's not fine after Ray Lale just says-
Judge Dean Bucci (03:34):
Okay.
Mr. Steel (03:35):
... I can hang with Ray Lale.
Judge Dean Bucci (03:36):
Well, what I'll do is, consistent with my promise to the jury, is I'll float the idea to them and let them talk about it in private so that I'm not putting anybody on the spot. And if they tell me it's too much, then it's too much, and then we won't do it.
Ray Lale (03:57):
I'm looking at some of these witnesses we've got coming up. We have one more long law enforcement witness, and then we have the medical examiner. I expect those to be really long. Other than that, these witnesses should go pretty quickly.
Judge Dean Bucci (04:09):
Okay.
Ray Lale (04:09):
People from GBI, people that knew that they'd come and testify, that's it. So it might go pretty quickly. We might be able to start getting-
Judge Dean Bucci (04:17):
It normally goes longer than we expect.
Ray Lale (04:20):
But we might be able to pick up some speed here coming up in the next few days.
Judge Dean Bucci (04:30):
Then we're starting a multi-defendant case the next Monday.
Ray Lale (04:34):
And January the 4th, murder case. January 4th, multi-defendant murder case.
Judge Dean Bucci (04:43):
And December 14th maybe? I think we've got a multi-defendant.
Ray Lale (04:47):
[inaudible 00:04:49].
Judge Dean Bucci (07:09):
Are we still waiting on a juror? Are we still waiting on a juror? We are?
Speaker 3 (07:17):
Five minutes away.
Judge Dean Bucci (09:18):
Okay. [inaudible 00:07:28]. Okay, we're good, man, thank you.
Speaker 4 (09:20):
All right.
Judge Dean Bucci (09:20):
Mr. Lale, we have an easel. Do you need it now or you just want it handy for-
Ray Lale (09:24):
Just want to make sure you have one. At some point when we'll need it. Thank you.
Judge Dean Bucci (09:24):
Okay.
Speaker 1 (09:24):
May it please the court?
Judge Dean Bucci (10:29):
We don't need it today.
Speaker 1 (10:33):
Your Honor, when we recessed on Friday, the witness we brought up from-
Judge Dean Bucci (10:38):
They may still be hearing us.
Speaker 1 (10:40):
Oh.
Mr. Steel (10:40):
There could be a witness in there.
Judge Dean Bucci (10:45):
Get confirmation that's not happening.
Speaker 5 (10:46):
I think Sean said he cut off the speakers out there.
Judge Dean Bucci (10:46):
Okay. Maybe double-check.
Speaker 5 (10:46):
[inaudible 00:10:57].
Ray Lale (12:22):
I'll just run to the bathroom if we-
Judge Dean Bucci (12:23):
Sure.
Ray Lale (12:23):
Thank you. Thank you, sir.
Judge Dean Bucci (16:20):
Thank you. [inaudible 00:12:51].
(16:20)
Got him? All right. Waiting on Mr. Steel. Okay. Are y'all ready?
Mr. Steel (16:21):
Yes, sir.
Judge Dean Bucci (16:22):
Ready? Okay, jury please.
Speaker 1 (16:22):
Yeah, I wanted to make [inaudible 00:16:23].
Mr. Steel (16:22):
Oh, yes. I'm sorry.
Speaker 1 (16:22):
It's okay.
Judge Dean Bucci (16:34):
You want us to hold them?
Speaker 1 (16:35):
If you would, [inaudible 00:16:36].
Judge Dean Bucci (16:36):
Yeah. Well, we don't have Levo to hold them. There we do.
Speaker 4 (16:41):
Hold up. Hold up. Hold up. Hold up.
Judge Dean Bucci (16:52):
All right.
Speaker 1 (16:53):
Your Honor, when we recessed on Friday evening, Mr. Steel, Mr. Lale, we met in the DA's office and talked to a witness that had brought up from Florida to testify who used to be employed by Fallon County Sheriff's Office. He had a number of photographs, and we viewed all the photographs. They asked him all the questions they wanted to ask him. And what it boiled down to is we have just a very few photographs we want to introduce. It's going to be without objection. And I was going to let Mr. Treadaway do it with this witness on redirect, but I just wanted to... That's why these photographs [inaudible 00:17:35]-
Judge Dean Bucci (17:35):
Okay.
Speaker 1 (17:35):
And this leaves us, this eliminates a witness that might have been a bit lengthy.
Judge Dean Bucci (17:41):
Great.
Mr. Steel (17:41):
That's fine.
Judge Dean Bucci (17:44):
All right. Is that true, Mr. Steel?
Mr. Steel (17:46):
Yeah.
Judge Dean Bucci (17:50):
All right.
Mr. Steel (17:50):
It's all good.
Judge Dean Bucci (17:50):
Well, thank you for that. All right, that's the way we'll do it. We can have the jury know.
Mr. Steel (17:59):
Sorry?
Judge Dean Bucci (18:30):
Good morning, everybody. Welcome back. Hope y'all had a great weekend. Hope your football team won, whatever team that is. You may have heard some of our discussions in the jury assembly room. I was told that the audio was on out there, so this might not come as a surprise to you. One of the concerns that I've had in this case is scheduling, and I'm sure that's a concern for y'all as well. We got news that one of you had a unforeseen event come up and needs to go to a funeral Thursday. And so anytime I ask you about scheduling, what I try to do is give you the information here, not get an answer from you so that nobody's put on the spot and y'all can go back and talk about it, and then you can tell the bailiff.
(19:15)
So as to that person who needs to leave town, the question is, can you leave at noon or do you have to leave first thing in the morning? Whatever your answer is, that's okay, but that's just a suggestion, and we'd like to know. We know that we're putting a lot on y'all, and sometimes I have an idea or a suggestion, and it's just too much and your answer will be no, but sometimes your answer will be yes. What we're faced with is probably going the remainder of this week, but it's going to be a short week for reasons outside of our control. And that's not blaming anybody. That's just life. That will put us into next week. Well, next week is a very special week for all of us because it's Thanksgiving, and we need to finish before Thanksgiving.
(20:02)
One idea is to work late today, tomorrow and Wednesday, or if not all three days, two of those days or one of those days. What that would look like is I would have dinner brought in, and somewhere around five o'clock, y'all would go back into the jury room and you'd have dinner, and then we'd come back out and we'd work another couple hours as late as y'all wanted to go. That's an idea. If the answer is no, it's too much, you just say no. Okay? So talk about that please during a break. All right. Is the state ready to resume?
Ray Lale (20:38):
State's ready, Your Honor. We had Nicholas Hardy-
Judge Dean Bucci (20:41):
All right.
Ray Lale (20:42):
... we had passed the witness at that point.
Judge Dean Bucci (20:54):
Okay. Welcome back. You understand you're still under oath?
Nicholas Hardy (20:56):
Yes, Your Honor.
Judge Dean Bucci (20:57):
All right. Yes, sir. You ready?
Mr. Steel (21:04):
Your Honor, may I approach with state's Exhibit number 210?
Judge Dean Bucci (21:23):
Yes, sir.
Mr. Steel (21:25):
211, 212, 213, and 214?
Judge Dean Bucci (21:27):
Yes, sir.
Mr. Steel (21:29):
May I approach you, sir?
Nicholas Hardy (21:29):
Yes, sir.
Mr. Steel (21:31):
I'm going to show you a... It's marked State's Exhibit number, it's kind of a joint submission, in the interest of time. Can you take a look at those and tell me whether you recognize those items, and that they accurately depict what is contained therein of each one? If there's some that you recognize, some you don't, just tell us that as well.
Nicholas Hardy (21:52):
I recognize them all, sir.
Mr. Steel (21:56):
And they're fair and accurate photographs of what they depicted at the time, as far as you know?
Nicholas Hardy (22:02):
They are.
Mr. Steel (22:03):
Your Honor, it's really a joint submission. I'm just trying to do it for time, but if it's okay with the state, I'm moving for the admission of State's Exhibits number... And I think it's 210 through 214.
Judge Dean Bucci (22:17):
Those are all in evidence.
Mr. Steel (22:19):
Thank you. Okay. The reason why you... Well, you took an oath to be an officer, right?
Nicholas Hardy (22:33):
I did, Your Honor, sir.
Mr. Steel (22:34):
Wherever you worked, it's always required, true?
Nicholas Hardy (22:39):
Yes, sir.
Mr. Steel (22:39):
It's because law enforcement officers have a lot of power in our community. The community gives law enforcement a lot of power. Is that fair to say?
Nicholas Hardy (22:49):
That's fair.
Mr. Steel (22:50):
And part of that power is, in a scene like this, that you were tasked to be the lead detective late in the game, but the lead detective, is because you need to, as well as your teammates, everybody on the prosecution team, collect evidence. Is that fair to say?
Nicholas Hardy (23:12):
That's fair.
Mr. Steel (23:12):
And the reason why we collect evidence... I'm saying we, the reason why you and scientists look at it, prosecutors look at it, and eventually jurors look at it, is because the goal is, in front of a fair, wise court like we have, a just court, is to produce the best and highest evidence so the jurors get good information. That's really the goal, true?
Nicholas Hardy (23:39):
Yes, sir. That is the goal.
Mr. Steel (23:40):
And physical evidence is critical in an investigation because it can tell what happened. It can tell a story, right?
Nicholas Hardy (23:50):
Yes. Physical evidence is important.
Mr. Steel (23:53):
And as opposed to a human being, I'm not saying they're lying, but emotions can get involved, trauma can get involved, bias can get involved, maybe it's intentional. Sometimes human beings can be accurate with what they say, sometimes they can be inaccurate. Is that all fair?
Nicholas Hardy (24:09):
That's fair.
Mr. Steel (24:10):
But physical evidence doesn't have an agenda. It's the blood evidence, the DNA, the fingerprints, whatever, true? The photographs.
Nicholas Hardy (24:20):
Yes, sir.
Mr. Steel (24:21):
So in this case, you didn't bring to the juries a theory or guesswork. You tried to bring the best evidence you could, fair?
Nicholas Hardy (24:31):
I did.
Mr. Steel (24:32):
And you do, and the jurors know, you come in afterwards, and I'm not criticizing anybody, but you come in afterwards and there's some benefits to that and there's some downside to that. Is that fair to say?
Nicholas Hardy (24:44):
It's fair.
Mr. Steel (24:44):
Because by the time you come in, several weeks or months have passed, true?
Nicholas Hardy (24:52):
I believe, yes. It's been several weeks when I came in.
Mr. Steel (24:55):
And because of that, certain things, it's beyond your control. You can't go back and get Lacy Boles' clothing. I mean, you just can't do it, right? It wasn't done.
Nicholas Hardy (25:04):
No, I could not.
Mr. Steel (25:05):
You can't go back and photograph what Lacy looked like that night. It's just over. Those days have passed, right?
Nicholas Hardy (25:12):
That is correct.
Mr. Steel (25:13):
And that should have been done. No one's criticizing. That should have been done by the people who are on the scene responding immediately. Fair?
Nicholas Hardy (25:21):
That's fair.
Mr. Steel (25:22):
You also have the benefit though, because you get to look at what is there and get to contemplate, and nobody's rushing you, and say, "Well, what can I do with this? What can I do with this?" Et cetera, right?
Nicholas Hardy (25:34):
That's fair.
Mr. Steel (25:35):
And you could come up with the ideas and go forward with what your coworkers did, and you can add to it if you want to add to it, or subtract from it, depending upon where the investigation should lead. Fair to say?
Nicholas Hardy (25:50):
Fair to say.
Mr. Steel (25:51):
All right. Now, the whole point of that is really for the jury, or people like me or the prosecutor, we weren't there at the time. Anyone wasn't there at the time of the shooting, that we know of, except for Lacy and Mr. Akers, true?
Nicholas Hardy (26:11):
That is true.
Mr. Steel (26:12):
So we're trying to figure out as best we can, what does the evidence show, right?
Nicholas Hardy (26:18):
Yes, sir.
Mr. Steel (26:19):
And it's your job, as well as your coworkers and the prosecutors, to present such competent evidence to convince the jurors, and the judge will charge on the law, but you have the burden of proof. You realize that, right?
Nicholas Hardy (26:30):
I do.
Mr. Steel (26:31):
Okay. So in the case-
Ray Lale (26:36):
I object to that last question. The state, the prosecutors have the burden of proof. This detective's under no burden other than to produce the best evidence. He doesn't have a burden of proof in this courtroom other than to tell the truth. That's his only burden.
Judge Dean Bucci (26:51):
Okay. Do you care to respond to that, Mr. Steel?
Mr. Steel (26:52):
No.
Judge Dean Bucci (26:53):
All right.
Mr. Steel (26:56):
Well-
Ray Lale (26:56):
Is it sustained?
Judge Dean Bucci (26:59):
I'll sustain. And if Mr. Steel wants to re-ask the question, he can.
Mr. Steel (27:02):
It's fine. All right. I want to talk with you about certain evidence in the case, if I can. There's physical evidence, there's photographs. Whatever you need, if I don't show it to you, I'm not trying to hide it, just say, "There's another exhibit that's a better exhibit," or whatever. Okay?
Nicholas Hardy (27:25):
Yes, sir.
Mr. Steel (27:26):
Just tell me if I leave out something or you need something to look at. So with regards to... And let me get the exhibit. Do you mind helping me out. Thank you. I'd like to show you, and then with the court's permission, it's in evidence, State's Exhibit number 290, if you don't mind. May I approach, Your Honor?
Judge Dean Bucci (28:41):
Yes, you may.
Mr. Steel (28:42):
This is already in evidence. I just want to show it to you. May I approach you?
Nicholas Hardy (28:45):
Yes, sir.
Mr. Steel (28:48):
It's on the back, is the exhibit number.
Nicholas Hardy (28:53):
Yes, sir.
Mr. Steel (28:54):
I'm going to put it on the screen. If you need to see it just better than this technology, just let us know. Your Honor, may I display?
Judge Dean Bucci (29:04):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (29:06):
With the assistance of the DA's investigator, I think.
Speaker 2 (29:08):
State's 290.
Mr. Steel (29:12):
Do you remember testifying to this exhibit last week?
Nicholas Hardy (29:16):
I do, on Friday. Yes, sir.
Mr. Steel (29:17):
Yes. And I'm focusing on, what I believe you focused on, these are some photographs. Is that fair to say?
Nicholas Hardy (29:23):
It is.
Mr. Steel (29:24):
And it says something like, "Memories," and I can't read it, but something like that. It's a collage of photographs on a placard. Is that correct?
Nicholas Hardy (29:34):
That is correct.
Mr. Steel (29:36):
All right. And this was taken when you were in Lacy and Mr. Akers' home on March 5th of 2020. Is that fair to say?
Nicholas Hardy (29:44):
Yes, sir.
Mr. Steel (29:45):
And when you walked through the home with Lacy and you wanted to see the safe before you took Lacy back, with her permission, to the sheriff's office to be interviewed, which the jurors saw that video audio recording. You noticed, and I think you told the jurors, that it was of interest to you that there's no photographs of Mr. Akers in the home. Do you remember testifying that?
Nicholas Hardy (30:10):
I do remember, sir.
Mr. Steel (30:11):
And why was that of interest to you, if you don't mind explaining? You took note of it, so I assume it was of interest to you.
Nicholas Hardy (30:19):
I just noticed that there was no photographs of Mr. Akers in the house anymore, that I saw.
Mr. Steel (30:26):
And when you noticed that, it registered in your mind. Fair to say?
Nicholas Hardy (30:31):
It did.
Mr. Steel (30:32):
And you thought it was interesting. I'm not saying it proves anything to this case, but you just thought it was an interesting fact, I guess.
Nicholas Hardy (30:38):
Yes, sir.
Mr. Steel (30:39):
Because it really doesn't prove that Lacy came down the steps with a gun or Mr. Akers committed suicide. It's just an interesting fact, I guess. Is that-
Nicholas Hardy (30:48):
It was an interesting fact, sir.
Mr. Steel (30:51):
I'm going to ask you to look at some photographs. And just tell me if you recognize these photographs, okay?
Nicholas Hardy (31:07):
Yes, sir.
Mr. Steel (31:07):
I'm going to be right there with you. Okay. Your Honor, may I approach?
Judge Dean Bucci (31:07):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (33:52):
Okay. I am going to show you what I've marked as Ms. Boles number 134, 135, and 133. And I've given those to the prosecutors. May I approach you?
Nicholas Hardy (34:12):
Yes, sir.
Mr. Steel (34:17):
If you could take a peek at each one individually, just tell me whether you recognize those photographs and the people depicted in them.
Nicholas Hardy (34:34):
They appear to be some photographs of Dan and Lacy.
Mr. Steel (34:39):
Okay. And do you recognize the... I think it's 133, 134, 135, Ms. Boles exhibits.
Nicholas Hardy (34:47):
I mean, I recognize that they're pictures of them.
Mr. Steel (34:49):
And do they look like what they looked like during their life together?
Nicholas Hardy (35:00):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (35:01):
Your Honor, I move for the admission of Ms. Boles, 133, four.
Nicholas Hardy (35:00):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (35:01):
Your Honor, I move for the admission of Ms. Boles 1334 and 5.
Ray Lale (35:04):
Object to lack of foundation. Just because he can recognize people in pictures doesn't show that these are authentic pictures, or where they came from, the origin of the pictures. Doesn't prove that he saw those pictures in his house at that time. Showing him people that he recognizes, that's not proper foundation for admissibility.
Judge Dean Bucci (35:22):
All right. I'll overrule that objection [inaudible 00:35:26].
Mr. Steel (35:27):
I'd like you to do me a favor, if you don't mind, Investigator, can you blow up on... What number is that? Is that 290 of the states that's on the screen right now?
Investigator (35:34):
State's 290.
Mr. Steel (35:36):
Can you blow it up to the one, the photograph? And we'll come back to it if we need to, but it's right there, I believe. You could try your best. It's right there, actually. That one right there. Can you make that any better? Sheriff, with the court's permission, can the lights be adjusted?
Judge Dean Bucci (36:04):
That's fine.
Mr. Steel (36:05):
Thank you, Your Honor. Do you see this picture right here in the collage?
Nicholas Hardy (36:19):
I do.
Mr. Steel (36:20):
And I'm just focusing on that one. I'm not going to go through each one of these or other pictures in the house, but I'm just focusing on this one. I'm going to show you, or ask you to help me to review Ms. Boles number 135, if you don't mind. I'm going to hand one, just the same copy. If you want me to use the original, I will to the investigator. May I approach, Your Honor?
Judge Dean Bucci (36:47):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (36:47):
May I approach you? This is Ms. Boles 135. From State's 290, if you need to see it in person, this is just focusing on that same picture. Do you see these two people?
Nicholas Hardy (37:08):
Yes, sir. I do.
Mr. Steel (37:09):
Do you recognize that as Lacy Boles and Mr. Akers?
Nicholas Hardy (37:12):
I do.
Mr. Steel (37:13):
And then just for clarity, I'm going to also ask the court if I could display 134. Ms. Boles number, may I approach, Your Honor?
Judge Dean Bucci (37:21):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (37:29):
May I approach, sir? And this is just another closeup. You see Mr. Akers here on the... Would be my right and Ms. Boles on my left?
Nicholas Hardy (37:37):
I do.
Mr. Steel (37:38):
Okay. Now that picture is actually hanging in the home of Ms. Boles on May 5th... Well, excuse me, March 5th, 2020. Do you realize that now?
Nicholas Hardy (37:50):
I do not.
Mr. Steel (37:51):
You don't think that this-
Nicholas Hardy (37:52):
I didn't recognize that picture.
Mr. Steel (37:53):
But do you recognize it now?
Nicholas Hardy (37:56):
I mean, I see that it is Ms. Boles and Mr. Akers, but I did not see that picture.
Mr. Steel (38:00):
And when you say you didn't see it...
Nicholas Hardy (38:02):
On March 5th, I did not see it, sir.
Mr. Steel (38:03):
Well, let me show you State's Exhibit number 290 again up front. May I approach, Your Honor?
Judge Dean Bucci (38:09):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (38:16):
It's on the court's screen. Do you see it?
Nicholas Hardy (38:55):
Yes, sir. I see it.
Mr. Steel (38:56):
Is it the same picture as what was hanging in Lacy Boles' home, Ms. Akers' home on March 5th, 2020?
Nicholas Hardy (39:04):
It's extremely hard to tell on this, but I see that there is a picture there and there are two individuals in it. But I cannot accurately say that that is the picture.
Mr. Steel (39:13):
Well, I'm going to hand you with the court's permission, the actual picture so it's not on the screen, okay?
Nicholas Hardy (39:17):
Okay.
Mr. Steel (39:18):
And then you tell us whether that's the same picture or not, and the jurors will have it out with them as well.
Nicholas Hardy (39:23):
Yes, sir.
Mr. Steel (39:23):
Okay? May I approach, Your Honor?
Judge Dean Bucci (39:25):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (39:26):
May I approach you, Investigator?
Investigator (39:38):
Yes, sir.
Mr. Steel (39:38):
Can I have the 290? May I approach you?
Nicholas Hardy (39:38):
Yes, sir.
Mr. Steel (39:57):
You should have seen [inaudible 00:39:44]. Do you still feel certain on your testimony that there wasn't a photograph of Mr. Akers hanging in that house when you went through it?
Nicholas Hardy (40:05):
As I said in my testimony, I did not see any photos.
Mr. Steel (40:08):
But there may have been one that you just missed, right?
Nicholas Hardy (40:11):
There may have been one I missed. I did not see any.
Mr. Steel (40:13):
Okay. You have in front of you all these exhibits that we just put in, the ones that are on the record just a moment ago?
Nicholas Hardy (40:27):
Yes, sir.
Mr. Steel (40:27):
Are you telling the jury that that is not a closeup... Ms. Boles' exhibit number [inaudible 00:40:34] are not a closeup of State's number 290? Are you telling them that?
Nicholas Hardy (40:38):
I'm sorry, sir. Which exhibit are you referring to?
Mr. Steel (40:40):
Ms. Boles Exhibit numbers that I just handed you.
Nicholas Hardy (40:45):
This one or Ms. Boles, I'm sorry. Ms. Boles. They're zoomed in, but I did not see that picture that day.
Mr. Steel (40:56):
Thank you, sir. Let me show you another picture that was hanging in the house when you went through it and made the observation that no photographs of Mr. Akers in the house, okay? Thank you, sir. I'd like to show you what I'll remark unless the State wants to keep their exhibit number, I'll remark it Ms. Boles number 136 and 137. May I approach, Your Honor?
Judge Dean Bucci (44:09):
Yes, sir.
Mr. Steel (44:10):
I'm going to show you what I've pre-marked as Ms. Boles number 136, 137. May I approach?
Nicholas Hardy (44:16):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (44:17):
Tell me whether you recognize from March 5th, 2020, what the house looked like in that image.
Nicholas Hardy (44:29):
These are accurate.
Mr. Steel (44:30):
And those were taken at your command by your fellow coworker, fair to say?
Nicholas Hardy (44:35):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (44:36):
Your Honor, I move for the admission of Ms. Boles 136 and 137.
Ray Lale (44:39):
No objection.
Judge Dean Bucci (44:39):
Admitted.
Mr. Steel (44:41):
May I display them, Your Honor?
Judge Dean Bucci (44:42):
Yes, sir.
Mr. Steel (44:43):
May I approach you and take them? Can you just announce which one you're displaying, if you don't mind?
Investigator (44:57):
Boles 136.
Mr. Steel (45:01):
And this is just another photograph focusing on that same Making Memories, I think it says [inaudible 00:45:12]. And that's that same photograph, right?
Nicholas Hardy (45:15):
Yes, sir.
Mr. Steel (45:16):
Does that help you? And the investigator can zoom in if he can. Does that help you to show that that is the exact same photograph that I showed you and Ms. Boles?
Nicholas Hardy (45:23):
It does appear to be.
Mr. Steel (45:25):
So in fact, now, and I appreciate, you just missed it, right?
Nicholas Hardy (45:34):
Yes, sir.
Mr. Steel (45:35):
In fact, there is at least one, and I'm not saying there's not others, but there's at least one picture that we can see based upon what was taken at that search warrant on March 5, 2020, that there is a photograph or more of Mr. Akers in the home, fair?
Nicholas Hardy (45:50):
There's only one photograph that I see here.
Mr. Steel (45:53):
Okay.
Nicholas Hardy (45:55):
That I did miss.
Mr. Steel (45:56):
But you changed your testimony from last Friday.
Nicholas Hardy (46:00):
I missed.
Mr. Steel (46:01):
Yeah, that's okay. People, human beings miss things. They make mistakes, right?
Nicholas Hardy (46:07):
Yes, sir.
Mr. Steel (46:08):
Okay. Now, I'd like to go and talk to you about the nail, the white nail, the acrylic nail-
Nicholas Hardy (46:29):
Yes, sir.
Mr. Steel (46:29):
... in the safe.
Nicholas Hardy (46:31):
Yes, sir.
Mr. Steel (46:32):
Do you understand what I'm referring to?
Nicholas Hardy (46:33):
Yes, sir. I do.
Mr. Steel (46:35):
I want to just show you some photographs and they're already in evidence, but just to make sure that we're talking about the same thing. May I approach, Your Honor?
Judge Dean Bucci (46:43):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (47:03):
I'm showing you State's Exhibit number 203, 204, 205, 206. They're already in evidence.
Nicholas Hardy (47:14):
Yes, sir.
Mr. Steel (47:16):
May I approach you? If you just take a memory of that, and then we're going to display that. Thank you. Your Honor, may I approach the investigator?
Judge Dean Bucci (47:33):
Yes, sir.
Mr. Steel (47:34):
Could you display... Thank you. Just to orient the jury, if the investigator can put on the item just looking into the safe and then it gets closer up to the, what I'll call an acrylic white nail. And then announce the numbers, if you don't mind, that you're displaying.
Investigator (47:57):
State's 203.
Mr. Steel (47:59):
So this is the inside of the safe, which is in evidence already, and I don't have the evidence number in my mind, but the jurors have seen that safe, right?
Nicholas Hardy (48:09):
Yes, sir.
Mr. Steel (48:10):
And you would not call it, or would you call it a gun safe?
Nicholas Hardy (48:13):
I refer to it as a gun safe.
Mr. Steel (48:15):
That's a gun safe to you?
Nicholas Hardy (48:16):
To me.
Mr. Steel (48:17):
Is it because it held the gun or the holster of the gun? Or is it just that's typically what a gun safe looks like?
Nicholas Hardy (48:25):
In my experience, that's what a gun safe looks like.
Mr. Steel (48:27):
Okay. And what we're doing here, since I'm focusing or asking you questions about the acrylic nail, we're going to show more pictures of it, but right there is what we're talking about. Is that fair to say?
Nicholas Hardy (48:43):
Yes, sir.
Mr. Steel (48:44):
And then if the investigator can put up the next one just to orient the jurors on a closer image.
Investigator (48:51):
State's 205.
Mr. Steel (48:57):
And again, we're talking about like right there, there's another object here and...
Nicholas Hardy (49:02):
If I can move back, I can't see your pointer. I'm only looking at my screen.
Mr. Steel (49:06):
Can you see the pointer right here?
Nicholas Hardy (49:08):
Yes, sir. I can now.
Mr. Steel (49:09):
Kind of in the middle left of the safe?
Nicholas Hardy (49:13):
Yes, sir.
Mr. Steel (49:13):
Okay. And then we're going to do one more, I believe maybe two.
Investigator (49:20):
State's 206.
Mr. Steel (49:23):
And this is on top of the safe, and this is the item taken out, just to be photographed more clearly of what I'm calling an acrylic nail, white nail.
Nicholas Hardy (49:34):
Yes, sir.
Mr. Steel (49:34):
And an acrylic white nail, it's just... It's a press-on over the nail of a human being. Is that true?
Nicholas Hardy (49:44):
I would believe so, yes.
Mr. Steel (49:45):
Okay. And tell the ladies and gentlemen of the jury when that nail got into that safe.
Nicholas Hardy (49:56):
I cannot.
Mr. Steel (49:58):
Could it have been a month before December 22, 2019 that it's been in that safe?
Nicholas Hardy (50:04):
It could have been.
Mr. Steel (50:05):
And could it have been the morning of December 19, 2022?
Nicholas Hardy (50:14):
It could have been.
Mr. Steel (50:15):
And could it have been in the days after December 22, 2019, until March 5th, 2020, if it wasn't put there by Ms. Boles?
Nicholas Hardy (50:28):
You're saying after the incident, sir?
Mr. Steel (50:30):
Yeah.
Nicholas Hardy (50:31):
According to Ms. Boles, she didn't have access to the safe.
Mr. Steel (50:34):
Right. But other people may have had access.
Nicholas Hardy (50:37):
Other people, yes. According to Ms. Boles, she did not have the key to the safe.
Mr. Steel (50:43):
Sure. And we're going to talk about that too, if that's okay.
Nicholas Hardy (50:45):
Yes, sir.
Mr. Steel (50:47):
But I'm just saying in reality, you know, on oaths, the truth is we don't know when that acrylic white nail came into that safe. Is that fair to say?
Nicholas Hardy (50:58):
It's fair to say.
Mr. Steel (50:59):
And we don't know if it was before December 22, 2019. I'm using that because God forbid that's the day of the death of Mr. Akers or after that date, right?
Nicholas Hardy (51:10):
It's fair to say.
Mr. Steel (51:10):
But we do know that it's there at least on March 5th, 2020.
Nicholas Hardy (51:14):
It is.
Mr. Steel (51:18):
Tell the ladies and gentlemen of the jury what Lacy Boles' nails looked like on the morning of December 22, 2019.
Nicholas Hardy (51:30):
According to the interview with Ogden, her fingernails were white.
Mr. Steel (51:34):
Okay. That interview occurred December 30th, 2019, fair to say?
Nicholas Hardy (51:39):
Fair to say.
Mr. Steel (51:40):
That's eight days after the date I asked you about.
Nicholas Hardy (51:43):
Yes, sir.
Mr. Steel (51:43):
So let me just be more clear. What would the color or what did the nails appear to be of Lacy Boles on December 22, 2019?
Nicholas Hardy (51:55):
I don't know, sir.
Mr. Steel (51:56):
Yeah. You'd be guessing, you're not going to guess, right?
Nicholas Hardy (51:58):
No, sir.
Mr. Steel (51:59):
So you don't know?
Nicholas Hardy (52:00):
No.
Mr. Steel (52:01):
And that's because you weren't at the scene. This is not your doing, but none of your coworkers ever even took a photograph of Lacy Boles on December 22, 2019. You realize that?
Nicholas Hardy (52:12):
I do.
Mr. Steel (52:14):
And nobody put in their notes what her appearance looked like. Do you realize that?
Nicholas Hardy (52:20):
Yes, sir.
Mr. Steel (52:22):
So we really don't know, and you're not going to guess. That's not what you do, right? You're not a guess guy, right?
Nicholas Hardy (52:29):
I'm not.
Mr. Steel (52:31):
You're not going to tell the jurors that you have any idea what Lacy Boles' nails looked like on December 22, 2019, fair?
Nicholas Hardy (52:39):
Fair.
Mr. Steel (52:40):
Now, I just want to be fair to you. Eight days later, when Lacy came in to speak with Detective Ogden at the sheriff's office, that was video recorded, right?
Nicholas Hardy (52:53):
It was.
Mr. Steel (52:54):
And the jurors have seen... I'm not saying you know this, but assuming the jurors have seen that video recording, you've seen it definitely, right?
Nicholas Hardy (53:01):
I have.
Mr. Steel (53:02):
And Lacy Boles' fingernails are white and it appears to be the acrylic press-on white fingernails, true? Is that true?
Nicholas Hardy (53:09):
It does, yes.
Mr. Steel (53:10):
And it looks like all 10 of them are there, is that true?
Nicholas Hardy (53:14):
It's hard to tell in the video.
Mr. Steel (53:16):
Okay. But you don't know when those white acrylic nails could have been put on the morning of December 30th, 2019. We just don't know, right?
Nicholas Hardy (53:31):
That's fair.
Mr. Steel (53:33):
Okay. With regards to... You can take that down if you don't mind. Regard to the... Do you remember there was a conversation about lipstick, you remember something like that with you and the honorable prosecutor?
Nicholas Hardy (54:06):
Yes, sir.
Mr. Steel (54:06):
And that was during the interview with you, Ms. Boles put on what you described as lipstick, true?
Nicholas Hardy (54:17):
That's what it appeared to me.
Mr. Steel (54:51):
And you didn't bring that up at the time with her. You didn't ask her anything about, you know, can I seize that? You know what I mean? Can I take the lipstick? I mean, you didn't collect it is my point. Is that true?
Nicholas Hardy (55:11):
No, I didn't see a reason to collect her lipstick.
Mr. Steel (55:15):
Okay. And she had it... The jurors had already seen the video audio?
Nicholas Hardy (55:19):
Yes, sir.
Mr. Steel (55:20):
But she had it prominently displayed on the counter. When I say counter, the desk where you were with her, is that true?
Nicholas Hardy (55:28):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (55:30):
And she reached for it actually a couple of times when you met with her. Is that true?
Nicholas Hardy (55:37):
I remember the one time. There could have been more times.
Mr. Steel (55:39):
Okay. Well, at least one time. Did you notice that the tip, the color of the tip of the item that she touched to her lip?
Nicholas Hardy (55:53):
I did not, sir. I couldn't recall at this time what color it was.
Mr. Steel (55:57):
Could it be lip balm, like ChapStick type?
Nicholas Hardy (56:00):
I'm used to ChapStick in an actual white or whatever brand it is. I don't think there was any brand or label on that.
Mr. Steel (56:10):
Did you notice any lipstick? Remember the cup she was drinking from, you were kind enough or your teammate to give her some coffee? You commented on the odor of it, French vanilla.
Nicholas Hardy (56:22):
I think it was hazelnut actually, but no, there was no lipstick that I could see on the cup.
Mr. Steel (56:27):
Right. So you're not telling the jury that that was lipstick. It was some sort of item that she put on her, whatever it was that she put on her lips, right?
Nicholas Hardy (56:37):
It appeared to be lipstick to me, sir.
Mr. Steel (56:40):
Okay. Did it have a color?
Nicholas Hardy (56:42):
I didn't see a color.
Mr. Steel (56:44):
Could it have been lip balm?
Nicholas Hardy (56:46):
It's possible.
Ray Lale (56:47):
I believe that's asked and answered.
Mr. Steel (56:49):
I'm going to show you what's already... Oh, I'm sorry. I'm going to show you what's already in evidence. State's Exhibit number 146. May I approach, Your Honor?
Judge Dean Bucci (57:01):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (57:12):
May I approach you?
Nicholas Hardy (57:13):
Yes, sir.
Mr. Steel (57:14):
I'm going to show you what's already been entered into evidence. State's Exhibit number 146. Just orient yourself and I'll put it on the screen with the Court's permission. Okay. I'm going to take it. May I approach? Your Honor, may I display?
Judge Dean Bucci (57:23):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (57:39):
Sir, do you recognize this as being taken on what date, if you know?
Nicholas Hardy (57:47):
It's the night of the incident. I believe it would've been the 20th.
Mr. Steel (57:50):
Okay.
Nicholas Hardy (57:50):
In the early morning hours.
Mr. Steel (57:55):
I'm going to say December 22, 2019.
Nicholas Hardy (57:57):
I'm sorry. December 20... Yes.
Mr. Steel (57:59):
That's all right. And do you see the McDonald's cup?
Nicholas Hardy (58:02):
I do.
Mr. Steel (58:03):
Or what I recognize to be a McDonald's logo on it, on a cup?
Nicholas Hardy (58:06):
Yes, sir.
Mr. Steel (58:07):
Now, this is different than the McDonald's cup downstairs next to Mr. Akers, fair?
Nicholas Hardy (58:11):
I would like to see the other photograph, but yes, it is fair.
Mr. Steel (58:16):
May I have a second, Your Honor?
Judge Dean Bucci (58:17):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (58:32):
May I approach, Your Honor?
Judge Dean Bucci (58:32):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (58:32):
May I approach?
Nicholas Hardy (58:35):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (58:37):
I'm showing you what's been marked and entered into evidence, Ms. Boles number four.
Nicholas Hardy (58:43):
Yes, that is a different cup.
Mr. Steel (58:44):
May I approach and take it?
Nicholas Hardy (58:46):
Yes, sir.
Mr. Steel (58:46):
And just to show the jurors what you looked at, may I just lay this down?
Investigator (58:46):
Yes, sir.
Mr. Steel (58:56):
And this is the same night of the, God forbid, the death of Mr. Akers, and that is Ms. Boles number 4. And it's fair to say it's a different cup than the exhibit the jurors were just looking at?
Nicholas Hardy (59:11):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (59:12):
Okay. If you can go back to the State's Exhibit number, if you don't mind. And can you announce the number you're putting on again?
Investigator (59:18):
146, State's.
Mr. Steel (59:20):
And right here on State's Exhibit number 146, do you see what you call like a ChapStick?
Nicholas Hardy (59:29):
Yes. That would be more what I'd be familiar with, with ChapStick.
Mr. Steel (59:33):
Okay. Are you familiar that they come in different types of sizes or containers?
Nicholas Hardy (59:39):
I'm sure they do, but I don't use ChapStick, so.
Mr. Steel (59:43):
Right there. Okay. Well, you noticed that there were no photographs of Mr. Akers. I understand you're wrong. I understand you clarified to jurors don't pay attention that that was wrong. And you noticed that, according to you, Ms. Lacy Boles put on lipstick during your meeting with him. Those are some observations, right?
Nicholas Hardy (01:00:10):
Yes, sir.
Mr. Steel (01:00:11):
What is putting on lipstick or ChapStick or a lip balm, whatever it is, what does that have to do with what happened on December 22, 2019 at the scene for evidence, not guesswork?
Nicholas Hardy (01:00:30):
I don't want to give you my opinion.
Mr. Steel (01:00:31):
Right, because it would just be opinion, right?
Nicholas Hardy (01:00:34):
It's my observations of what I saw during my interview.
Mr. Steel (01:00:36):
Yeah. But it's not evidence pointing to any type of suicide or shooting, does it?
Ray Lale (01:00:44):
Objection.
Mr. Steel (01:00:44):
Physical evidence?
Ray Lale (01:00:45):
Objection. The jury will draw whatever value they want, if any at all, from that evidence. For asking this witness what opinion he has of that evidence or what value that evidence has is improper. That invades the ultimate province of the jury. They will take whatever value they want from it.
Judge Dean Bucci (01:01:03):
Can you respond to that?
Mr. Steel (01:01:05):
That's fine. I'll withdraw the question.
Ray Lale (01:01:06):
Okay. Is it sustained for the record?
Judge Dean Bucci (01:01:07):
Sustained. Thank you.
Mr. Steel (01:01:12):
Okay. Have you noticed... Have you ever seen any photograph of Lacy wearing a wedding ring while married to Mr. Akers?
Nicholas Hardy (01:01:36):
No, I haven't.
Mr. Steel (01:01:38):
Do you know whether Mr. Akers ever gave Lacy a wedding band, wedding ring?
Nicholas Hardy (01:01:42):
I do not.
Mr. Steel (01:01:43):
Okay. I'd like to show you what I'll mark as Ms. Boles number 138 and 139.
Investigator (01:01:48):
[Inaudible 01:02:58].
Mr. Steel (01:01:48):
Yeah.
Investigator (01:01:48):
Okay, thank you.
Mr. Steel (01:01:48):
May I approach, Your Honor?
Judge Dean Bucci (01:01:48):
Yes, sir.
Mr. Steel (01:03:08):
May I come forward, sir?
Nicholas Hardy (01:03:09):
Absolutely.
Mr. Steel (01:03:10):
I'm showing you Ms. Boles 138 and 139. Tell me if you recognize either or both of those exhibits.
Nicholas Hardy (01:03:22):
I recognize 138. I do not recognize 139. I do recognize the person in it.
Mr. Steel (01:03:28):
You recognize the person depicted in 139?
Nicholas Hardy (01:03:29):
I do.
Mr. Steel (01:03:29):
Okay. And Your Honor, I move for the admission of 138 and 139.
Ray Lale (01:03:42):
I would have a motion outside the presence of the jury, please.
Judge Dean Bucci (01:03:46):
Okay. Let's take a break then. Your Honor, may it please the court.
Ray Lale (01:04:29):
The defense opted into reciprocal discovery in this case. I've never seen Defense 139 in my life. This was not served on us prior to trial. I don't believe any of the rest of this was either. There is, for example, Defense number 133, I've never seen. I'm not sure where that comes from. Looks like it's kind of internet photo of these two. So it seems to be a snowball starting to roll downhill here of stuff I've never seen ever, pretrial and reciprocal. So I object to the tender of these exhibits. I didn't object to 133, but 139, I've never seen either.
Judge Dean Bucci (01:05:12):
Are you objecting to 139?
Ray Lale (01:05:13):
Yes, sir.
Judge Dean Bucci (01:05:15):
Okay. Any response?
Mr. Steel (01:05:18):
Yes, sir. Reciprocal discovery is for items used in the case in chief of the party. This is not my case in chief. This is on cross-examination. It's the State's case in chief. Reciprocal discovery under 17-16-1 et al does not apply. I will give the Court the case if the Court need it.
Judge Dean Bucci (01:05:46):
Well, even if it applied, I'm not sure that the remedy would be to keep it out, unless there was some kind of bad faith. So if the state is caught off guard and you need some time, we'll take a break and I'll give you whatever time you need.
Ray Lale (01:06:00):
If we can have five minutes or so.
Judge Dean Bucci (01:06:00):
Okay. All right. Let's take five minutes. Thank you.
Judge (01:10:00):
Okay. State ready.
Ray Lale (01:10:00):
I've had an opportunity to review 139 and had no objection to it. Thank you.
Judge (01:15:50):
All right. Have the jury back, please.
Diane (01:17:46):
[inaudible 01:17:40]. Are we ready for the jurors?
Judge (01:17:52):
One second. This is Court's Exhibit 5; am I right?
Diane (01:17:55):
Yes.
Judge (01:17:59):
I need to leave first thing 7:30 AM on Thursday morning. It's a 12-hour drive. Okay, ready?
Diane (01:18:07):
Get ready for [inaudible 01:18:08].
Judge (01:18:58):
All right. Let's resume.
Ray Lale (01:18:58):
No objection, Your Honor. I'll have the state on to 138 and 139.
Mr. Steel (01:19:11):
138 and 139? Thank you.
Judge (01:19:12):
All right. You want those admitted?
Mr. Steel (01:19:20):
Yes, sir.
Judge (01:19:20):
Those are admitted.
Mr. Steel (01:19:20):
May I approach, Your Honor?
Ray Lale (01:19:20):
May I approach, Your Honor?
Judge (01:19:20):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (01:19:31):
Mr. Investigator, if you can display and just announce, make sure it is 138, Ms. Boles.
Speaker 6 (01:19:37):
Boles 138.
Mr. Steel (01:19:42):
Detective, you recognize this as a screenshot of the recording, video/audio recording, where you were with Ms. Boles when you watched it, excuse me, on December 30th, 2019? So, let me... Your Honor, may I ask a different question?
Judge (01:20:01):
Sure.
Mr. Steel (01:20:02):
Okay. I think I stepped on my words. Did you recognize Ms. Boles number 138 as an accurate screenshot, I'll call it, or photograph of the video/audio recording on December 30th, 2019, when Ms. Boles was in the sheriff's department speaking with Detective Ogden?
Nicholas Hardy (01:20:23):
It is, sir.
Mr. Steel (01:20:24):
Okay. And do you notice here Ms. Boles' sweatshirt?
Nicholas Hardy (01:20:31):
I do.
Mr. Steel (01:20:32):
Okay. I'd like to now ask this humble court with permission to publish to the jury, 139, Ms. Boles exhibit number, that's into evidence. And you recognize this gentleman as Mr. Akers, is that fair to say?
Nicholas Hardy (01:20:49):
Yes, sir.
Mr. Steel (01:20:50):
And is it look like or appear to you to be either... I guess it'd be the same or similar sweatshirt?
Nicholas Hardy (01:20:57):
It has the same logo and the same color.
Mr. Steel (01:21:00):
You don't know whether it's the same or a similar sweatshirt, do you?
Nicholas Hardy (01:21:03):
I would not testify to that. No, sir.
Mr. Steel (01:21:04):
Okay. And then just going back to Ms. Boles exhibit number 138, if that's okay with the court. May we display, Your Honor?
Judge (01:21:14):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (01:21:15):
And Mr. Investigator, if you could just focus, just to tie it up. The jurors are looking at December 30th, 2019 screenshot of the video/audio recording, true?
Nicholas Hardy (01:21:33):
Yes, sir.
Mr. Steel (01:21:33):
With Detective Ogden. And right here, that would be similar to a white acrylic... I'm not saying it's acrylic. I don't know, but it's similar to the white painted finger.
Nicholas Hardy (01:21:43):
May I stand up and see where you're pointing at?
Mr. Steel (01:21:44):
Of course.
Nicholas Hardy (01:21:45):
I can't see because of the... Yes, sir. It appears to be the white acrylic nails.
Mr. Steel (01:21:50):
Whether it is or not, we're not 100% sure, but that's what it appears?
Nicholas Hardy (01:21:52):
Yes, sir.
Mr. Steel (01:21:58):
Okay. When you reviewed all the evidence, did you find multiple sweatshirts that are found in Ms. Boles number 138 and 139? Do you know?
Nicholas Hardy (01:22:09):
I'm not 100% sure. I didn't inspect their clothes.
Mr. Steel (01:22:13):
That's fine. Okay. Thank you. Thank you very much. I'd like to just go back to the lipstick. These are State's Exhibit numbers 207, 208, 209 that admitted in evidence. Your Honor, may I approach?
Judge (01:22:35):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (01:22:36):
May I approach you?
Nicholas Hardy (01:22:36):
Yes, sir.
Mr. Steel (01:22:39):
It should be state... It's on the back. State's Exhibit number 206, seven... I think it said 207, eight, nine maybe.
Nicholas Hardy (01:22:46):
209, 208, and 207.
Mr. Steel (01:22:49):
Okay. And they're already in evidence. Just acquaint yourself with them again, if you don't mind.
Nicholas Hardy (01:22:58):
Yes, sir.
Mr. Steel (01:22:59):
And may I approach, Your Honor? It should be 209 before I take it from you. Just look at the tip of the lipstick, ChapStick, whatever it is, and tell me whether you notice it to be white. And then we're going to display it to the jurors.
Nicholas Hardy (01:23:17):
Sir, to be honest, it appears to be white, but it's hard to tell the color in this photograph.
Mr. Steel (01:23:20):
May I approach, Your Honor?
Judge (01:23:20):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (01:23:24):
May I approach you?
Nicholas Hardy (01:23:25):
Yes, sir.
Mr. Steel (01:23:35):
And this is from what's going on on the court's courtroom screen. This is going to be Ms. Boles number 207, I believe.
Nicholas Hardy (01:23:47):
Should be 207, 208, and 209.
Speaker 6 (01:23:49):
State's 208.
Mr. Steel (01:23:52):
That's fine. 208. This is the same thing. It's a screenshot during the interview with you on March 5, 2020.
Nicholas Hardy (01:24:03):
Yes, sir.
Mr. Steel (01:24:04):
Okay. And that's what you were referring to on direct examination last week about Ms. Boles applying, I'm going to call it what you call the lipstick, fair?
Nicholas Hardy (01:24:14):
Yes, sir.
Mr. Steel (01:24:14):
Okay. And then if you can put the next one up.
Speaker 6 (01:24:16):
State's 207.
Mr. Steel (01:24:22):
And that's just a similar screenshot that was put in by the state, right?
Nicholas Hardy (01:24:26):
Yes, sir.
Mr. Steel (01:24:27):
And then 209, if you don't mind. And then 209 is a little different because it's not... you can actually see the tip of the item. You see that?
Nicholas Hardy (01:24:39):
Again, I can't see where you're pointing at on my screen, so... Yes, sir.
Mr. Steel (01:24:44):
And you see the black sweater, I'm going to call it a sweater, or jacket of Ms. Boles?
Nicholas Hardy (01:24:50):
Yes, sir.
Mr. Steel (01:24:51):
And as you already said, it appears to be a white color at the tip of that, whatever it is, the lip balm, ChapStick, lipstick, whatever; is that true?
Nicholas Hardy (01:25:03):
Yes, sir.
Mr. Steel (01:25:04):
And you're saying... You made it clear, I think, I really don't know what that is. That's what you're saying.
Nicholas Hardy (01:25:10):
So, I called it lipstick because I'm used to a ChapStick, like we saw in the other photograph with the McDonald's cup. That has something gold on the bottom, almost like you would twist it up like lipstick.
Mr. Steel (01:25:22):
But you don't know what it is?
Nicholas Hardy (01:25:24):
No.
Mr. Steel (01:25:25):
Am I correct?
Nicholas Hardy (01:25:26):
I did not take it, so no.
Mr. Steel (01:25:28):
Am I correct?
Nicholas Hardy (01:25:29):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (01:25:29):
Okay. Thank you, sir. All right. I want to talk with you about the blood on the holster and safe, if you don't mind.
Nicholas Hardy (01:25:52):
Yes, sir.
Mr. Steel (01:25:53):
Or lack thereof, I guess. May I approach, Your Honor?
Judge (01:26:26):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (01:26:27):
May I approach you, sir?
Nicholas Hardy (01:26:28):
Yes, sir.
Mr. Steel (01:26:28):
I'm going to show you what's been marked as state's exhibit and admitted, by the way, State's Exhibit number 187, 189. Can I come forward?
Nicholas Hardy (01:26:37):
Yes, sir.
Mr. Steel (01:26:39):
Just reorient yourself with that. And if we need other photographs, like I said, just please help us.
Nicholas Hardy (01:26:50):
I think the other ones are right here of the safe.
Mr. Steel (01:26:53):
Just add it to the stack if we need to discuss it, please. And thank you for doing that.
Nicholas Hardy (01:26:57):
I'm just going to add all these that are with the safe.
Mr. Steel (01:27:04):
And do me a favor, just announce what they are, instead of saying all of these.
Nicholas Hardy (01:27:08):
I'm sorry. State's Exhibit 213, 214, 210... Sorry, they're out of order. 211 and 212.
Mr. Steel (01:27:20):
May I approach, Your Honor?
Judge (01:27:20):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (01:27:21):
I'm going to take all of those exhibits [inaudible 01:27:24] you and the court. Thank you, sir.
Speaker 6 (01:27:52):
State's Exhibit 187.
Mr. Steel (01:27:55):
So, just to orient and give context, this is the safe that the jurors have in evidence, fair to say?
Nicholas Hardy (01:28:04):
It's fair.
Mr. Steel (01:28:05):
And Ms. Boles showed you where that safe was when you were in her home, Ms. Akers' home on March 5, 2020?
Nicholas Hardy (01:28:11):
Yes. She took me to the safe.
Mr. Steel (01:28:13):
And this is a closet that the safe is in, in the master bedroom?
Nicholas Hardy (01:28:18):
That is correct.
Mr. Steel (01:28:19):
And I'm not saying it's true. I'm not saying it's not true. Ms. Boles said that the safe had been moved since December 22, 2019.
Nicholas Hardy (01:28:30):
I believe it was in her statement or in the interview, but when she took me to it, she never said that to me.
Mr. Steel (01:28:37):
That's fine. But at some point she said the safe was moved?
Nicholas Hardy (01:28:42):
I believe it was in the interview.
Mr. Steel (01:28:43):
And do you know where the safe was located on December 22, 2019?
Nicholas Hardy (01:28:57):
I would need to go back and refresh our crime scene photos. I don't believe they took a photograph of it, but I want to make sure.
Mr. Steel (01:29:03):
If you find one, can you just-
Nicholas Hardy (01:29:05):
Yes, sir.
Mr. Steel (01:29:05):
... tell the jurors during a break or something?
Nicholas Hardy (01:29:07):
Yes, sir.
Mr. Steel (01:29:08):
Okay. But otherwise, your answer would be, I guess at this point, until your memory's changed, no, there's no photograph. I don't know where the safe was on December 22, 2019. If that's wrong, just say that's wrong.
Nicholas Hardy (01:29:23):
I believe in her statement to me, in her interview, she said she took the gun holster back up to the safe upstairs, so I would assume it was in the bedroom.
Mr. Steel (01:29:33):
I'm trying to disorient the jurors to be fair to the evidence. You don't know where the safe was on December 22, 2019?
Nicholas Hardy (01:29:40):
No, sir.
Mr. Steel (01:29:41):
Am I correct?
Nicholas Hardy (01:29:42):
Yeah.
Mr. Steel (01:29:42):
Okay. That's all.
Nicholas Hardy (01:29:43):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (01:29:44):
All right. Now, here in state's exhibit number... And I forget the number.
Speaker 6 (01:29:51):
189.
Mr. Steel (01:29:51):
Well, no. Keep that one still on me.
Speaker 6 (01:29:52):
187.
Mr. Steel (01:29:54):
187. Thank you. The keys that we've been talking about that is on Ms. Boles' keyring, keychain, when you and your coworkers had that keychain in her home on March 5, 2020 during the execution of the search warrant; is that true?
Nicholas Hardy (01:30:22):
That is true.
Mr. Steel (01:30:22):
All right. And the safe here in this picture appears to be a jar slightly opened; is that true?
Nicholas Hardy (01:30:31):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (01:30:31):
And there's different ways. It appears to open the safe, maybe you need all of them, but there's a little turn lock here; is that correct? And the jurors have the actual safe here.
Nicholas Hardy (01:30:40):
Yes. I believe there's a combination code and a key.
Mr. Steel (01:30:43):
And here's a combination code, fair to say, the items, the numbers?
Nicholas Hardy (01:30:47):
Yes, sir.
Mr. Steel (01:30:47):
And then the key obviously is hanging down with all the other keys?
Nicholas Hardy (01:30:50):
Yes, sir.
Mr. Steel (01:30:51):
All right. And that appears to be just a jar, like little opening, right? Or does it appear to be shut?
Nicholas Hardy (01:30:58):
Yes, it's opened.
Mr. Steel (01:31:00):
Can you see what's right here? Can you see that?
Nicholas Hardy (01:31:05):
Yes. It looks like part of the holster coming out of the safe.
Mr. Steel (01:31:08):
Okay. And let's take another picture and remember that. We're going to go back to that.
Speaker 6 (01:31:14):
State's Exhibit 189.
Mr. Steel (01:31:15):
And this is the holster that we're talking about, correct? The camouflage item?
Nicholas Hardy (01:31:23):
Yes, sir.
Mr. Steel (01:31:24):
And then this is the part of the holster that you just explained to the jurors appeared to be sticking out from the open safe in 187?
Nicholas Hardy (01:31:32):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (01:31:33):
Okay. Can you try another one if you don't mind?
Speaker 6 (01:31:43):
State's Exhibit 213.
Mr. Steel (01:31:47):
This is another view. The safe door is open. And again, this is an image of the holster with its apparatus or item right here hanging over the safe ledge; is that true?
Nicholas Hardy (01:32:04):
That is true.
Mr. Steel (01:32:05):
Okay. Next one, if you don't mind.
Speaker 6 (01:32:09):
State's Exhibit 214.
Mr. Steel (01:32:11):
This is the safe after it's been cleared out of all its content, just a picture showing how depth of the safe it is?
Nicholas Hardy (01:32:19):
That's correct.
Mr. Steel (01:32:19):
Okay.
Speaker 6 (01:32:20):
State's Exhibit 210.
Mr. Steel (01:32:27):
This is the safe closed before the keys are in it. Is that fair to say?
Nicholas Hardy (01:32:32):
That is accurate.
Mr. Steel (01:32:33):
So, this is what you've trained your coworkers and they've trained you, too, and they've taken their own training. First, you approach an item that's of interest, take a picture of it, and then show stages, such as that's why later we see a key in it and that's why later we see it opened, and that's why later we see the contents, that's why later we see the safe without the content.
Ray Lale (01:32:51):
Objection. Compound question.
Judge (01:32:51):
Go ahead and rephrase.
Mr. Steel (01:32:57):
Is it true that this is the initial, according to you, the way your training is, this would be the initial photograph of the safe before it's opened up?
Nicholas Hardy (01:33:05):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (01:33:06):
Okay. And then after that, law enforcement show the steps that it took. It could be on video, but if it's photographed by the key in the keyhole, right?
Nicholas Hardy (01:33:19):
Yes, sir.
Mr. Steel (01:33:19):
And we see that picture. The jurors just saw that picture, 187.
Nicholas Hardy (01:33:23):
That is correct.
Mr. Steel (01:33:25):
And then it gets opened or ajar, and then eventually we see the content of the safe, true?
Nicholas Hardy (01:33:31):
Yes, sir.
Mr. Steel (01:33:32):
But this is how law enforcement on May 5, 2020, based upon your understanding, and you saw the safe, this is what it looked like, true?
Nicholas Hardy (01:33:40):
That is true.
Mr. Steel (01:33:47):
You see this part right here that you talked about earlier, part of the holster? You see it sticking out here on the bottom of the safe?
Nicholas Hardy (01:33:56):
I do.
Mr. Steel (01:33:58):
Okay. And that's the way you saw it when you were with Ms. Boles on March 5, 2020 when she showed you the safe, fair?
Nicholas Hardy (01:34:03):
It is.
Mr. Steel (01:34:04):
Okay. The next one.
Speaker 6 (01:34:08):
State's 211.
Mr. Steel (01:34:11):
And that's just what your coworkers did. They just took a clearer picture showing that part of the holster is sticking out at the bottom of the safe?
Nicholas Hardy (01:34:21):
That's true.
Mr. Steel (01:34:22):
When the safe is closed before opened?
Nicholas Hardy (01:34:24):
Yes, sir.
Mr. Steel (01:34:25):
Okay. And you noticed this too when you saw it?
Nicholas Hardy (01:34:29):
I did.
Mr. Steel (01:34:30):
Okay.
Speaker 6 (01:34:30):
State's 212.
Mr. Steel (01:34:36):
That's what we talked about earlier. And it looks similar to me to the 187. But it's the key, again, in the actual safe hanging down and the safe has been opened, but it still leaves the part right there of the holster sticking out the way it was found.
Speaker 6 (01:34:54):
It looks like your message got cut off. Did you finish your photo?
Mr. Steel (01:34:58):
Is that right?
Nicholas Hardy (01:34:59):
It is.
Mr. Steel (01:35:01):
Okay. Next.
Speaker 6 (01:35:02):
That's it. Last one.
Mr. Steel (01:35:04):
Okay. Now, part of the interest in the holster is that law enforcement wanted to see whether there was blood on the holster and on the safe. Is that fair to say?
Nicholas Hardy (01:35:19):
That is fair.
Mr. Steel (01:35:20):
Are you a blood expert? I'm not trying to do that.
Nicholas Hardy (01:35:25):
No, I am not.
Mr. Steel (01:35:26):
Okay. No expertise. I'm just generalities, okay? You are aware that there are presumptive tests that can be used at the scene to determine whether possibly there's blood on an item; is that true?
Nicholas Hardy (01:35:42):
That is true.
Mr. Steel (01:35:42):
And it's called presumptive because it's really not confirmatory. It's like an initial possibility test; is that true?
Nicholas Hardy (01:35:50):
It is.
Mr. Steel (01:35:51):
And to confirm it, generally what we do anyway is we go to the... not me, but law enforcement goes to the Georgia Bureau of Investigation Crime Lab, and then they can really test the substance and determine whether it is blood, is it human being's blood, and potentially whose blood it is; is that true?
Nicholas Hardy (01:36:10):
That is true.
Mr. Steel (01:36:11):
But the presumptive test is something that's important because it could be done right there on the scene. And you had that done on March 5th, 2020, right?
Nicholas Hardy (01:36:21):
Yes. I had Lieutenant Parker do the test.
Mr. Steel (01:36:23):
And when Lieutenant Parker did the test, you reported to the jury that there was no indication... I know it's not a final test. I know it's not the real test, but there's no indication of blood on the holster.
Nicholas Hardy (01:36:38):
I was advised by Lieutenant Parker there was no blood on the holster.
Mr. Steel (01:36:41):
I want to show you... Do you know how the test works? Do you know what it's called, the test?
Nicholas Hardy (01:36:50):
I do not know how it works. No, sir.
Mr. Steel (01:36:52):
Okay. Were you advised by... Well, first of all, Lieutenant Parker works in your agency at that time, March 5, 2020, correct?
Nicholas Hardy (01:37:05):
Yes. He was a lieutenant over crime scene.
Mr. Steel (01:37:08):
And he's a gentleman who is supposed to... You work together, so while you are with Ms. Boles, either driving her back to the sheriff's office or maybe at the sheriff's office, he's inside the house lawfully. And he is doing a test to determine whether the holster has any potential blood on it, true?
Nicholas Hardy (01:37:28):
That is true.
Mr. Steel (01:37:29):
And do you remember, by any chance, him reporting to you that the camo cloth type gun case initially showed a very faint reaction for blood? Do you remember that?
Nicholas Hardy (01:37:45):
I don't remember him telling me that. No.
Mr. Steel (01:37:47):
Can I show you something that you may have seen that may help refresh your memory?
Nicholas Hardy (01:37:51):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (01:37:51):
And if it doesn't, just say it doesn't help me.
Nicholas Hardy (01:37:58):
May I approach, Your Honor?
Judge (01:37:59):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (01:38:00):
Just tell me if you recognize this. Do not read it to the jury or the court. Will you follow the court's rules?
Nicholas Hardy (01:38:05):
Yes, sir.
Mr. Steel (01:38:07):
Read it to yourself and then just tell me whether this refreshes your memory, okay?
Nicholas Hardy (01:38:11):
Yes, sir. This refreshes my memory. I've seen it before.
Mr. Steel (01:38:20):
Okay. I don't know what your coworker actually, Lieutenant Parker, told you, but his report indicates that actually there was faint reaction indicating potential blood on the holster.
Ray Lale (01:38:35):
Object to that. And asked to take that outside the place of said attorney, please.
Judge (01:38:36):
All right. We have to take another break.
Ray Lale (01:39:21):
May it please the court, You Honor, this is improper.
Mr. Steel (01:39:22):
Can I say some favor?
Ray Lale (01:39:22):
Your Honor, this is improper refresh-
Mr. Steel (01:39:27):
Can you just hold on one second? Your Honor, can the witness be excused?
Judge (01:39:30):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (01:39:31):
Thank you.
Ray Lale (01:39:49):
Your Honor, this is improper refreshment of recollection. And what's happening is the defense is able to read from a report through an attempted refreshment of recollection and that's improper. He showed him the report. And the witness said, "My recollection's been refreshed." Mr. Steele starts to read from the report. That's improper. The report's not in evidence. The proper process is, "Has your recollection been refreshed on the issue of whether Detective Parker found a tracing on the blood?" "Yes, it has." "What is your recollection now?" And then he testifies to it. He can't just sit there and read from Parker's report through an attempted refreshment of recollection because the report is not in evidence. And it's been going on throughout this trial. And Mr. Lale would hold up a report and read from a report and show the report to the witness. "Do you recognize this?" "Yeah, that's a report."
(01:40:39)
And many times it was the witness's own report. "Yes, I wrote that report. It's part of my investigation." "And you said in your report, didn't you?" Or whatever. If the report's not in evidence, you can't just sit there and read from it. And that's what's happening. Defense Counsel on repeated witnesses, they're just reading from reports and that's improper. And that's what's happening here when Mr. Steele said, "Now isn't it true Detective Parker wrote in his report that?" That's improper. You can't do that just through refreshing of recollection.
Judge (01:41:08):
Okay. Any response?
Mr. Steel (01:41:11):
I don't have the report in front of me. I was not reading from a report. And I asked if it refreshed his memory. He immediately said, yes, it does. And I asked him then the question, whatever I asked. I'm confident that the honorable court reporter has my exact words, but I'm just asking him and I don't have to ask him an open-ended question. He's on cross-examination. "Isn't it true that the item first had a slight indication of positive potential blood?" Something to that effect.
Ray Lale (01:41:36):
No, it's not something to that effect. It was, "Isn't it true Detective Parker wrote in his report that there was a faint amount of blood?"
Judge (01:41:43):
All right. Well, I'll sustain the objection. Just don't read from the report and you can rephrase it to make sure you're not just reading or getting him to say what's in the report.
Mr. Steel (01:41:53):
Thank you.
Judge (01:41:55):
Okay. Let's have him back.
Ray Lale (01:41:56):
I'd ask that the objection be sustained in front of the jury. Thank you.
Judge (01:42:02):
Okay. I will.
Diane (01:42:03):
[inaudible 01:42:08].
Judge (01:42:22):
What about libraries?
Speaker 6 (01:42:22):
[inaudible 01:42:22].
Judge (01:42:23):
Are they any interest in tomorrow night or Wednesday night?
Diane (01:42:36):
Yeah. And I have the [inaudible 01:42:26]. And they can stay a couple hours or so after that, whatever you say, because they know it's-
Judge (01:42:41):
After that. Like tomorrow?
Diane (01:42:43):
Yes. After they eat or something.
Judge (01:42:43):
Okay. So, tomorrow or Wednesday?
Diane (01:42:47):
Yes. [inaudible 01:42:48].
Judge (01:42:49):
All right. This is Court's Exhibit 6. "For this week, Monday 16, 17, 18, jurors can be here every morning at 8:30. Monday night can only be here until 5:00." All right. And that's because of one particular juror. And it's not on the note, but what I'm told from Diane is they can work late tomorrow and Wednesday. So, tomorrow and Wednesday, I will plan on having dinner brought in and we'll stay till say 8:00 PM. But today, we have to stop at 5:00. All right. Bring him back, please.
Diane (01:43:43):
Bear with us just a minute.
Judge (01:46:45):
Okay. Welcome back, ladies and gentlemen. I received your notes. Thank you for considering what I asked you to consider. What we'll do is we will go until 5:00 tonight and stop. We'll start 8:30 in the morning, Tuesday and Wednesday. Tuesday and Wednesday, we'll work late. We'll bring in dinner. We'll plan to go to 8:00. If anybody has any special dietary needs, just let Diane know. And then next Monday we'll resume at 8:30 in the morning. Okay? The court sustains the objection. Mr. Steele, please rephrase.
Mr. Steel (01:47:25):
Do you now remember that the initial testing of the holster for preliminary presumptive possibility of this blood was positive?
Nicholas Hardy (01:47:47):
I don't remember because he told me on the phone that it was negative.
Mr. Steel (01:47:53):
I understand. God bless you. I understand Lieutenant Parker told you that.
Nicholas Hardy (01:47:58):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (01:47:58):
But you read that report?
Nicholas Hardy (01:47:59):
I do read that report.
Mr. Steel (01:48:00):
And in the report, does it refresh your memory?
Nicholas Hardy (01:48:06):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (01:48:06):
That initially there was blood.
Ray Lale (01:48:09):
It's the same objection. Going back to the report and what the report says versus the independent recollection of this witness. He says he doesn't remember that. The fact that it's in a report doesn't make that report admissible in evidence. It's the same objection.
Mr. Steel (01:48:22):
Not asking for a report to be admissible. The gentleman said that it refreshes his memory. I'm asking that question.
Judge (01:48:28):
All right. So the question was asked, does it refresh your memory? That was answered. Next question.
Mr. Steel (01:48:34):
Did the initial presumptive test show on the holster positive for blood?
Nicholas Hardy (01:48:41):
Based on this report, yes.
Mr. Steel (01:48:43):
Okay. That's all I was asking you. And you read that report because it's your job as the lead detective to assimilate and to gather all reports by other people. Is that fair to say?
Nicholas Hardy (01:48:56):
That's fair.
Mr. Steel (01:48:57):
And then you have to read everything and you determine, you give it over to the prosecutor, you give it over to defense lawyers, and then jurors eventually have all the information, true?
Nicholas Hardy (01:49:07):
True.
Mr. Steel (01:49:08):
Okay. With regards to Lacy Boles' bloody hands, I want to talk to you about that, okay?
Nicholas Hardy (01:49:19):
Yes, sir.
Mr. Steel (01:49:20):
Because the reason you were interested if there's blood on the holster and the safe is because if Ms. Boles touched the holster and the safe with a transference of blood, then potentially, I'm not saying has to, but potentially there should be able to see or test for blood on the holster and/or the safe. That's the whole purpose of this discussion, right?
Nicholas Hardy (01:49:49):
Yes, sir.
Mr. Steel (01:49:49):
All right. And we know from the scene, and I'm going to show you some pictures that are already in evidence. I've already shown them to the prosecution, Your Honor. May I approach?
Judge (01:49:58):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (01:49:58):
I'm just going to show these to you. And if you need to see other ones, just let us know. But it's Ms. Boles Number 39, Number 17, Number 3, Number 2, Number 5, and then State's Exhibit Number 59, 31, and 55. May I approach you?
Nicholas Hardy (01:50:47):
Yes, sir.
Mr. Steel (01:50:51):
Just orient yourself again, if you don't mind, to these photos, and then we'll display them with the court's permission to the jury. And then I'd like to discuss the hands of Ms. Boles and the blood, okay?
Nicholas Hardy (01:51:39):
Yes, sir. I'm familiar with these.
Mr. Steel (01:51:40):
Okay. Your Honor, may I come forward?
Judge (01:51:54):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (01:51:55):
Thank you, sir. Your Honor, may I approach the investigator and ask you to display them?
Judge (01:51:55):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (01:52:00):
Thank you. If we could have the lights, if you don't mind, if that's okay with the court.
Speaker 7 (01:52:03):
State's 54.
Mr. Steel (01:52:15):
So just to orient the jury, they've seen these pictures potentially before. They're already in evidence, but do you remember seeing this type of photograph?
Nicholas Hardy (01:52:24):
I do.
Mr. Steel (01:52:24):
And it's remarkable because it's a McDonald's bag, and then it's apparent or potential, I don't want to overstate, but it appears to be a bloody hand print. Is that fair to say?
Nicholas Hardy (01:52:36):
It is very fair.
Mr. Steel (01:52:37):
Okay. And we're talking about one hand print, fair?
Nicholas Hardy (01:52:40):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (01:52:41):
And left hand, if you remember that?
Nicholas Hardy (01:52:46):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (01:52:47):
If you could show the next one, if you don't mind.
Speaker 7 (01:52:52):
State's 55.
Mr. Steel (01:52:55):
That's a little closer. And you've already discussed with the jurors, law enforcement's trained to take an overall kind of perspective and then you get closer to the item of interest for the photograph. Is that true?
Nicholas Hardy (01:53:05):
That is true.
Mr. Steel (01:53:06):
And this is just a little bit, it's actually a lot closer, but you can make out five fingers, and then the palm area over here at the bottom of the bag. Is that fair to say?
Nicholas Hardy (01:53:17):
It is accurate.
Mr. Steel (01:53:18):
And the way you know that it's a left hand is because it's the four fingers and then the thumb over here. That's what it appears to be anyway.
Nicholas Hardy (01:53:28):
That is correct.
Mr. Steel (01:53:28):
All right. Next one.
Speaker 7 (01:53:33):
State's 31.
Mr. Steel (01:53:36):
And this was... There's a glare from where I'm sitting, but this is just an overall and we see what we've been talking about on a McDonald's bag and then on the carpeted floor, what we believe to be a bloody hand print, left hand, correct?
Nicholas Hardy (01:53:54):
That is correct.
Speaker 7 (01:53:57):
Boles Number Five.
Mr. Steel (01:54:01):
That's again where you can see the four fingers in the thumb and the palm print. Fair to say?
Nicholas Hardy (01:54:09):
Fair.
Mr. Steel (01:54:10):
Okay.
Speaker 7 (01:54:15):
Boles Number Two.
Mr. Steel (01:54:17):
This is just a different angle, but it's of the same item and the bloody print, true?
Nicholas Hardy (01:54:23):
Fair.
Mr. Steel (01:54:28):
Okay.
Speaker 7 (01:54:28):
Boles Number Three.
Mr. Steel (01:54:30):
Same thing, a little closer. You see the fingers here, and then the thumb is over here. Does that sound right?
Nicholas Hardy (01:54:37):
That is true.
Speaker 7 (01:54:43):
Boles 39.
Mr. Steel (01:54:45):
This removed, I'm not saying it's wrong in any way, but this is just a picture of the hand print, but removed without the bag. Fair to say?
Nicholas Hardy (01:54:56):
That is accurate.
Mr. Steel (01:54:56):
And the reason law enforcement took all those pictures, the bag, just to show nobody's saying that this is a different hand print, it's the same one, but it's just of a hand print without the bag obstructing any type of photograph. Is that true?
Nicholas Hardy (01:55:09):
That is correct.
Mr. Steel (01:55:10):
And here again on the fingers, three, four and then the thumb over here, that's what it appears to be, true?
Nicholas Hardy (01:55:16):
Yes, sir.
Mr. Steel (01:55:16):
Okay.
Speaker 7 (01:55:19):
Boles 17.
Mr. Steel (01:55:22):
And that again is the distance shot to give the overall scene and context, right? That's why it was done.
Nicholas Hardy (01:55:31):
That's correct, sir.
Mr. Steel (01:55:31):
Okay. So we know through the work of, not you, but the law enforcement that arrived on December 22, 2019, we know definitively if that's blood, I'm assuming it's blood, but that the left hand was extremely bloody. Is that a fair statement?
Nicholas Hardy (01:55:57):
I wouldn't say... I can't... I wasn't there, sir, for her hand to be extremely bloody, but I would say there was definitely blood on her left hand.
Mr. Steel (01:56:05):
Okay. And that's because in order to get the blood on the bottom of the bag as well as the carpet, the hand had to have some source of blood on it, either it's bleeding itself or it touched something?
Nicholas Hardy (01:56:21):
Yes. Transfer.
Mr. Steel (01:56:23):
Yeah, transfer. And because it is almost, I'm not saying it's entire, but it's almost like the silhouette of the hand and filled in, it looks like the left hand is bloody. Fair to say?
Nicholas Hardy (01:56:36):
Fair to say.
Mr. Steel (01:56:37):
Now, I want to flip over to the right hand. Is it fair to tell the jurors that we don't know the condition of the right hand of Ms. Boles?
Nicholas Hardy (01:56:48):
We do not know the condition, but based on her statement and her interview, she said both her hands were bloody because she was wiping the blood away from his face with both her hands.
Mr. Steel (01:56:57):
But because we don't know how she did the CPR on the chest, remember that?
Nicholas Hardy (01:57:05):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (01:57:06):
We don't know what else she touched. We don't know how much blood is on the right hand as compared to the left hand, true?
Nicholas Hardy (01:57:14):
That's fair.
Mr. Steel (01:57:15):
And one of the reasons, or I'm going to say the reason that we don't know the condition of her right hand when law enforcement arrived is because we have no photographs or videos or statements of the condition of her right hand, right?
Nicholas Hardy (01:57:30):
That is correct.
Mr. Steel (01:57:31):
And we don't know which hand Ms. Boles picked up the holster, do we?
Nicholas Hardy (01:57:39):
No, she didn't specify.
Mr. Steel (01:57:40):
And we don't know how she picked up the holster, do we?
Nicholas Hardy (01:57:43):
She just said she picked it up.
Mr. Steel (01:57:45):
So is my question affirmative, correct?
Nicholas Hardy (01:57:48):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (01:57:48):
Okay. And the safe itself, so I'm kind of leaving the holster, but I'm now going to that safe we've been talking about. You called it a gun safe?
Nicholas Hardy (01:57:57):
Yes, sir.
Mr. Steel (01:57:58):
With the little holster part sticking out of the bottom. We really don't know if that safe door was open or not when Ms. Boles went upstairs and put the holster inside it like she said. Is that true?
Nicholas Hardy (01:58:11):
I do not.
Mr. Steel (01:58:12):
So we don't know if she even touched that safe other than obviously however she got the holster inside, true?
Nicholas Hardy (01:58:20):
She told me in her interview that she opened the safe and put the holster in the safe. So that would have to be manipulating the handle to open the safe to put the holster in.
Mr. Steel (01:58:33):
What if the safe was ajar, but you have to open the door?
Nicholas Hardy (01:58:36):
You would still have to touch the door.
Mr. Steel (01:58:38):
And how did she touch the door?
Nicholas Hardy (01:58:40):
I do not know.
Mr. Steel (01:58:41):
And which hand did she use to touch the door?
Nicholas Hardy (01:58:43):
I do not know.
Mr. Steel (01:58:43):
And what was her right-hand condition when she touched that door?
Nicholas Hardy (01:58:47):
I do not know.
Mr. Steel (01:59:19):
Okay. Now, you actually spoke with Ms. Boles, this is not perfect, but just over a hundred days since December 22, 2019. And the way I got that is it's March 5th of 2020. And if I did it wrong, please, it may be actually less now I think of it.
Nicholas Hardy (01:59:42):
It could be less, yes.
Mr. Steel (01:59:43):
Maybe 70 days, maybe 60 days?
Nicholas Hardy (01:59:45):
Somewhere in there. It was March 5th. I think the incident happened on the 22nd of December.
Mr. Steel (01:59:51):
So we have about eight days plus 60 days, we'll say. So I don't know, 68 days? I've been saying a hundred, so I apologize.
Nicholas Hardy (01:59:58):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (01:59:59):
All right. But that's a substantial amount of time for some things and others, it's a short amount of time, true?
Nicholas Hardy (02:00:09):
I don't understand your question, sir.
Mr. Steel (02:00:11):
So that passage of time, sometime memories get better, sometimes memories get worse. It just depends on the person, true?
Nicholas Hardy (02:00:24):
I mean, I guess it depends on the person, sir.
Mr. Steel (02:00:27):
Because sometimes people remember things over time, even inaccurately, but they start saying, "Oh, I remember this."
Nicholas Hardy (02:00:32):
Again, you're asking my opinion on people's memories, sir.
Mr. Steel (02:00:37):
Okay. Let's talk about some of the receipts in the case. These are all in evidence. May I approach, Your Honor?
Judge (02:00:54):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (02:00:55):
And I show these to the prosecutors. These numbers are on the back.
Nicholas Hardy (02:01:06):
Yes, sir.
Mr. Steel (02:01:07):
May I approach, sir?
Nicholas Hardy (02:01:08):
Absolutely.
Mr. Steel (02:01:10):
And just do me a favor, announce... They're already in evidence, but just make sure that you recognize them and can discuss these receipts, if you don't mind.
Nicholas Hardy (02:01:19):
I recognize State's Exhibit 193, State's Exhibit 196, State's Exhibit 194, and State's Exhibit 195.
Mr. Steel (02:01:32):
And the only correction I'm going to ask you to make, if you don't mind, except for the first one, can you just see whether it's the State's Exhibit or Ms. Boles' Exhibit? They'll be the same number.
Nicholas Hardy (02:01:43):
They're all marked red with State's Exhibit, sir.
Mr. Steel (02:01:46):
Oh, okay. That's fine. May I approach, Your Honor?
Judge (02:01:49):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (02:01:50):
Can I take them from you?
Nicholas Hardy (02:01:51):
Yes, sir.
Mr. Steel (02:01:54):
Thank you, sir. Appreciate it. May I approach? Your Honor, may I approach?
Judge (02:02:01):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (02:02:02):
I'd like to go through some of these exhibits, and these are receipts that you were looking for and your team during the March 5th, 2020 search warrant at Ms. Boles and Mr. Akers' home, true?
Nicholas Hardy (02:02:22):
That is true.
Speaker 7 (02:02:22):
State's 193.
Mr. Steel (02:02:24):
And this is just a collection on the steps of Mr. Akers and Ms. Boles' home, just spread out, showing what was taken by law enforcement?
Nicholas Hardy (02:02:36):
Yes, sir.
Mr. Steel (02:02:37):
Okay. Next.
Speaker 7 (02:02:42):
State's 195.
Mr. Steel (02:02:50):
Do you see, and we're going to get to it, but there should be another Exhibit in there, but I want to focus first, if that's okay with you, the Tractor Supply Company?
Nicholas Hardy (02:03:00):
Yes, sir.
Mr. Steel (02:03:00):
So what we'll do is, and we could use this one too, but if the investigator can blow it up, just focusing on the Tractor Supply Company, if that's possible. Otherwise, there's another one when it's in the center. Can you see where it says Tractor Supply Company from where you are?
Nicholas Hardy (02:03:34):
I have it on my screen. I can see it, sir.
Mr. Steel (02:03:36):
And do you see where right here... I know you can't see me pointing, but it says ticket number on the furthest left, the most top item furthest on the left, and then underneath it says the date of December 21, 2019.
Nicholas Hardy (02:03:50):
Yes, I see that, sir.
Mr. Steel (02:03:52):
And that's the day before, God forbid, Mr. Akers is no longer going to be living, true?
Nicholas Hardy (02:03:58):
True.
Mr. Steel (02:03:59):
And then underneath it, we have the store and then the cashier. You see all that?
Nicholas Hardy (02:04:03):
I do.
Mr. Steel (02:04:04):
And then it has the time at 3:59 PM?
Nicholas Hardy (02:04:09):
Yes, sir.
Mr. Steel (02:04:10):
And register number two. Is that fair to say?
Nicholas Hardy (02:04:12):
Yes, sir.
Mr. Steel (02:04:14):
And you read this earlier, but it says under the item, you see quantity and then price, you see those three items there?
Nicholas Hardy (02:04:22):
I do.
Mr. Steel (02:04:23):
And then it says M-A-Z-U-R-I Mini PG Youth 25lb like pound. Is that fair to say?
Nicholas Hardy (02:04:35):
That's fair to say.
Mr. Steel (02:04:36):
And it was $19.99, right?
Nicholas Hardy (02:04:39):
Yes, sir.
Mr. Steel (02:04:40):
And you realize that's a return. Do you see that?
Nicholas Hardy (02:04:43):
I do see that. Yes, sir.
Mr. Steel (02:04:44):
And do you realize the reason for the return, according to the receipt, is changed mind? Do you see that?
Nicholas Hardy (02:04:49):
I do see that.
Mr. Steel (02:04:50):
And then it gives the store and the date again, right?
Nicholas Hardy (02:04:54):
Yes, sir.
Mr. Steel (02:04:55):
So this was food for the pig, right?
Nicholas Hardy (02:05:01):
I believe so.
Mr. Steel (02:05:02):
I mean, you Googled it and realized that that product makes food for a pig?
Nicholas Hardy (02:05:06):
I didn't Google it, but I believe it was food for the pig.
Mr. Steel (02:05:08):
Say it again.
Nicholas Hardy (02:05:10):
I did not Google it, sir, but 25 pounds I believe would be a bag of food.
Mr. Steel (02:05:16):
Okay. And when that was returned the day before Mr. Akers', God forbid, demise, do you have any evidence that Mr. Akers actually bought a pig?
Nicholas Hardy (02:05:32):
No.
Mr. Steel (02:05:34):
Do you remember being part of communications via email with your coworker, Detective Hill? Do you know who Detective Hill is?
Nicholas Hardy (02:05:45):
Yes, he was my lieutenant.
Mr. Steel (02:05:46):
And the medical examiner from the GBI, his name is Dr. Keith Lehman. Do you remember?
Nicholas Hardy (02:05:52):
I do remember.
Mr. Steel (02:05:53):
And Lehman is L-E-H-M-A-N?
Nicholas Hardy (02:05:55):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (02:05:55):
Okay. And do you remember law enforcement, you and your Lieutenant Hill, telling Detective Lehman that... Answering some of Detective Lehman's questions?
Nicholas Hardy (02:06:13):
I haven't seen those emails. I don't recollect them.
Mr. Steel (02:07:49):
Okay. I'm going to show you some emails. If you want to see all of them, it's okay. I'm just going to pull out a couple, but if you want to see anything else, just say you'd like to see them while they're here, okay?
Nicholas Hardy (02:09:55):
Yes, sir.
Mr. Steel (02:09:55):
Okay. Okay. I'm going to show you what I will mark as Ms. Boles Number 140.
Nicholas Hardy (02:10:03):
Yes, sir.
Mr. Steel (02:10:26):
And this should be eight pages. May I approach, Your Honor?
Judge (02:10:42):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (02:10:42):
May I approach you?
Nicholas Hardy (02:10:50):
Yes, sir.
Mr. Steel (02:10:52):
Just orient yourself. They're emails so they read from the bottom up. If you don't know what I'm talking about, you can follow the dates, but just orient yourself when you get a chance. And if you don't mind, Detective, just make sure that you are on these emails and the other people during the conversation who are on the conversation.
Nicholas Hardy (02:12:29):
Yes, I've read these emails.
Mr. Steel (02:12:31):
Okay. Your Honor, for purposes of trial, I move for the admission of Ms. Boles Number 140.
Ray Lale (02:12:43):
Object, hearsay. Mr. Steele's own description of the exhibit contains messages from other people who are here in the cross-examine [inaudible 02:12:52].
Judge (02:13:20):
Any response, Mr. Steele?
Mr. Steel (02:13:21):
Yes. I'm not using it for the truth of the matter asserted. I'm actually using it for the falsity. It's not hearsay under 24-8-801.
Ray Lale (02:13:31):
It's offered for the truth of the matter asserted that the emails were sent, that emails exist. That's for the truth of the matter asserted, that those emails were communicated back and forth between parties who are not here to be subject to examination.
Mr. Steel (02:13:43):
I have two responses if the court wants.
Judge (02:13:49):
I will, but one second. Well, I have some questions and probably needs to be done outside of the presence of the jury. Let me ask you, and no pressure, but is there some other line of questioning you can move on to or this has to be-
Mr. Steel (02:14:18):
Sure.
Judge (02:14:19):
Okay. Let's do that.
Mr. Steel (02:14:22):
Did you ever advise Dr. Lehman, or to your knowledge, was Dr. Lehman advised that a pig was actually purchased?
Nicholas Hardy (02:14:37):
I did not advise Dr. Lehman.
Mr. Steel (02:14:40):
Did your coworker advise him of that?
Ray Lale (02:14:41):
Objection, hearsay.
Judge (02:14:45):
Any response?
Mr. Steel (02:14:46):
Yes. There's no pig purchase. It's not for the truth of the matter asserted.
Ray Lale (02:14:51):
When you respond to an objection, you can't just testify to what you're trying to get across. When the objection is hearsay, the response was just to blurt it out what's under Review for objection.
Judge (02:15:03):
All right. Response to the objection without telling me what it is.
Mr. Steel (02:15:04):
It's not offered for the truth.
Judge (02:15:06):
Overruled.
Nicholas Hardy (02:15:09):
I'm sorry, can you ask the question again, sir?
Mr. Steel (02:15:11):
Yeah. Did you know that your coworker advised Dr. Lehman that a pig was actually purchased?
Nicholas Hardy (02:15:22):
After refreshing my memory with the email, yes.
Mr. Steel (02:15:24):
Okay. Did you ever correct that?
Nicholas Hardy (02:15:26):
I did not.
Mr. Steel (02:15:28):
And Dr. Lehman was interested in knowing whether there was any depression on the part of the deceased, Mr. Akers. Is that true?
Ray Lale (02:15:38):
Speculation, what Dr. Lehman was interested in unless this defendant has personal knowledge of it. And personal knowledge through something that's not hearsay.
Nicholas Hardy (02:15:49):
Any response?
Mr. Steel (02:15:50):
Yes. It's part of the communications. I'm not asking for the truth. Just that's his understanding.
Ray Lale (02:15:56):
All hearsay objections involve communications. That's what hearsay is. So I object to that.
Judge (02:16:03):
Well, the objection was speculation. So I'll deal with that by instructing the witness do not speculate. If you don't know the answers, you don't know. If you have personal knowledge, you can answer the question.
Nicholas Hardy (02:16:15):
Can you ask the question again?
Mr. Steel (02:16:18):
Sure. Did you understand that Dr. Lehman was asking law enforcement whether Mr. Akers had any depression, sadness? Did you understand that that's what this colloquy is about?
Nicholas Hardy (02:16:33):
Based on that email, yes.
Mr. Steel (02:16:34):
Okay. And the answer that, and I know it wasn't you, I know it wasn't you, but Lieutenant Hill gave one of the answers is-
Ray Lale (02:16:45):
I'm going to object to that as hearsay. Again, Detective Hill has not been called before. He's not going to be called in the state's case. If the defense wants to call him, that's their right. But you can't just get in Detective Hill's statements. Now Mr. Steele looked down at his podium and he's literally reading communications from Detective Hill. That's hearsay.
Judge (02:17:05):
Well, I guess I need to hear the question. What's the question?
Ray Lale (02:17:09):
Well, Judge, you see here, I must have been outside the presence of jury because if the jury hears the question, that's the evidence. It's not admissible evidence. So the jury shouldn't hear it if it's not admissible.
Mr. Steel (02:17:21):
I can rephrase the question.
Judge (02:17:22):
All right. Let me hear the rephrased question and we'll see if there's an objection.
Mr. Steel (02:17:26):
Why didn't you correct at any time, I'm talking about at any time, Lieutenant Hill's erroneous statement that Mr. Akers bought a pig?
Ray Lale (02:17:37):
Objection, hearsay. That's hearsay part.
Mr. Steel (02:17:39):
I'm not asking for hearsay.
Ray Lale (02:17:40):
Detective Hill's statement.
Mr. Steel (02:17:43):
I'm not asking for Detective Hill's statement.
Ray Lale (02:17:45):
You said, why didn't you correct Detective Hill's statement that, and I'm assuming it's going to be the statement following word that, that's hearsay. He's not here. He hasn't testified. He's not going to be called.
Judge (02:17:56):
Response to the hearsay objection.
Mr. Steel (02:17:58):
It's not for the... It's already been admitted by the court over objection that Detective Hill told Dr. Lehman that a pig was bought. And I'm just asking why didn't this witness correct it?
Judge (02:18:14):
All right. Overruled. You can answer.
Nicholas Hardy (02:18:15):
I don't know, sir.
Mr. Steel (02:18:23):
Did you ever inform, and when I say ever, I'm talking about at any time, did you ever inform Dr. Lehman that Mr. Akers was depressed?
Nicholas Hardy (02:18:38):
No.
Mr. Steel (02:18:39):
Did you ever know him to be depressed through his phone, let's say?
Nicholas Hardy (02:18:45):
I'm sorry.
Mr. Steel (02:18:46):
Through his phone.
Nicholas Hardy (02:18:49):
I mean, you're asking my opinion on his mental state.
Mr. Steel (02:18:52):
No, no, no. I would not do that. And thank you. I'm not doing that. Just from reviewing the phone, did you ever advise Dr. Lehman that there are problems that Mr. Akers had at the time of his death, such as financial? Did you advise him of that?
Nicholas Hardy (02:19:11):
No.
Mr. Steel (02:19:11):
Marital?
Nicholas Hardy (02:19:14):
No.
Mr. Steel (02:19:17):
Losing his job, getting furloughed?
Nicholas Hardy (02:19:19):
No.
Mr. Steel (02:19:23):
That he was afraid or looking potentially to go to prison for four and a half years, whatever?
Nicholas Hardy (02:19:30):
I'm not familiar with that.
Mr. Steel (02:19:31):
You don't remember reading that in his text messages?
Nicholas Hardy (02:19:34):
I don't, sir. You'd have to... I don't remember that.
Mr. Steel (02:19:37):
We'll show you.
Nicholas Hardy (02:19:38):
Yes, sir. That's fine.
Mr. Steel (02:19:41):
None of that was told to Dr. Lehman, to your knowledge, right?
Nicholas Hardy (02:19:44):
No.
Mr. Steel (02:19:53):
Did you ever tell Dr. Lehman that Mr. Akers was extremely happy?
Mr. Steel (02:20:01):
Mr. Akers was extremely happy.
Witness (02:20:04):
Yes. In that email I did.
Mr. Steel (02:20:07):
And that he was excited about moving up on his job?
Witness (02:20:11):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (02:20:15):
And getting a new Christmas tree?
Witness (02:20:17):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (02:20:18):
Do you have any evidence that Mr. Akers got a new Christmas tree?
Witness (02:20:21):
I do not.
Mr. Steel (02:20:24):
I want to talk to you about his job, meaning Mr. Akers' job. The job that you're referring to, and it's on the recording with Ms. Boles, Lacy?
Witness (02:20:35):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (02:20:35):
Is at the airport. Is that fair to say?
Witness (02:20:38):
I can't remember, sir.
Mr. Steel (02:20:39):
Okay. Do you remember reviewing the phone at any time of Mr. Akers and him being concerned about being furloughed?
Witness (02:20:56):
I do remember there was some concerns about him being furloughed, and that was during an interview with one of his coworkers.
Mr. Steel (02:21:04):
And furloughed means, and people will know, but just what does furlough mean?
Witness (02:21:09):
Furlough means you're out of work for a period of time.
Mr. Steel (02:21:13):
Yeah, you're laid off.
Witness (02:21:14):
Basically.
Mr. Steel (02:21:15):
And also, Mr. Akers was concerned, if you remember, about taking whether a job, the next job will drug test him. You know what I mean by drug test?
Witness (02:21:35):
I don't remember that, sir.
Mr. Steel (02:22:03):
Okay. We're going to come back to the furlough drug test. Going to prison till 2024. And then some of that, we already heard you read out some texts about getting a divorce.
Witness (02:22:28):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (02:22:29):
Or marital problems, I'll say. How about that? And financial problems. You knew that, right?
Witness (02:22:38):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (02:22:39):
Okay. All right. Let's talk about the reason why that's potentially a topic for you to have with Dr. Lehman, and I know Lieutenant Hill, okay? The claim was suicide. That was clear, right? That Lacy Boles claimed that this was a suicide. She tried to actually stop her husband from committing suicide.
Witness (02:23:20):
Yes, that's her claim.
Mr. Steel (02:23:21):
And the issue of law enforcement, the task was, is that accurate? And that's what law enforcement did to this day, I guess we're seven years now, right?
Witness (02:23:37):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (02:23:37):
And that's really the issue in the case, right?
Witness (02:23:40):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (02:23:41):
And the conversation that you had with Dr. Lehman about sadness or happiness of Mr. Akers was just, it doesn't mean it's true, but a happy person may not be more inclined to commit suicide than a sad person. That's basic, but happy people commit suicide too, right? And sad people don't commit suicide. Is that all true?
Ray Lale (02:24:08):
It's outside the scope of this witness's understanding. He's not a psychiatrist, psychologist, just a detective on the county sheriff's [inaudible 02:24:17]-
Mr. Steel (02:24:17):
That's fine.
Ray Lale (02:24:19):
... how can he give a comment on who's liable to commit suicide and who's not?
Judge (02:24:23):
Sustained.
Mr. Steel (02:24:23):
But when you told Detective Lehman that Mr. Akers was happy and looking forward to the job, whatever it says, I'm not trying to quote you, I don't have it in front of me, but that was all about just background information, what was going on with Mr. Akers, true?
Witness (02:24:38):
That's what I told Dr. Lehman.
Mr. Steel (02:24:39):
I'd like to go through some of the phone information-
Witness (02:24:46):
Yes, sir.
Mr. Steel (02:24:47):
... of Mr. Akers and Ms. Boles. First of all, we'll continue, if you don't mind, with the exhibits. And this focuses on financial strain, okay?
Witness (02:25:22):
Yes, sir.
Mr. Steel (02:25:23):
Financial stress. Okay?
Witness (02:25:25):
Okay.
Mr. Steel (02:25:26):
Can you continue where we were?
Clerk (02:25:28):
Exhibit 194.
Mr. Steel (02:25:31):
So here is the Tractor Supply Company. We've already discussed some of it. I don't know if it's any clearer, but you already discussed it's changed mind, the item was returned and it's the pig food, right?
Witness (02:25:45):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (02:25:45):
And that's why it's in brackets. If you know, if you don't know, just say, "I don't know how they keep their receipts. It was returned for $19.99."
Witness (02:25:55):
That's fair.
Mr. Steel (02:25:57):
But then underneath it, there was attempted purchase. You see this? Attempted purchase of a tool, a wrench. Do you see that?
Witness (02:26:16):
I see it.
Mr. Steel (02:26:16):
For $9.99 with tax $10.70. You see that?
Witness (02:26:22):
Yep. Yes, sir.
Mr. Steel (02:26:24):
But that couldn't even go through. It's all the same day. It's the same ticket, the December 21, 2019. Even with the return, that couldn't go through on a debit card. It was declined, right?
Witness (02:26:36):
Yes, sir.
Mr. Steel (02:26:36):
So the debit card didn't even have $10.70 on it?
Witness (02:26:40):
I don't know the reason for it to be declined.
Mr. Steel (02:26:42):
But that's what the receipt says, true?
Witness (02:26:45):
It just says payment declined.
Mr. Steel (02:26:47):
Do you have any reason to believe other than it was declined by the bank?
Witness (02:26:52):
The bank declined it.
Mr. Steel (02:26:52):
Right. Okay. Can you go to the next, if you don't mind?
Clerk (02:27:00):
State's Exhibit 196.
Mr. Steel (02:27:09):
Do you remember this exhibit with the prosecution seeing this?
Witness (02:27:12):
Yes, sir.
Mr. Steel (02:27:13):
And this is a promise to pay for TitleMax, right?
Witness (02:27:19):
That's correct.
Mr. Steel (02:27:20):
And the amount is $579.12. And that's the account, right?
Witness (02:27:26):
That's correct.
Mr. Steel (02:27:28):
And it was taken out on or around, I see two dates here. I'm going to say November 7th, 2019, then four dates later, December 13th, 2019, 6:00 PM. Fair?
Witness (02:27:40):
Fair.
Mr. Steel (02:27:41):
And then this is Mr. Akers' printed name on the document that's already in evidence, right?
Witness (02:27:47):
Yes, sir. Fair.
Mr. Steel (02:27:48):
Okay. And I'd like to... Did you listen to... On Mr. Akers' phone, are you aware of the fact that the company was calling to tell him that it went to debt collector. That it was in collections instead wasn't paid? Are you aware of that?
Witness (02:28:20):
I am not aware of that.
Mr. Steel (02:28:22):
Are you saying it didn't happen or you just never-
Witness (02:28:24):
I'm not aware of it, sir.
Mr. Steel (02:28:25):
You never listened to his recordings on his phone?
Witness (02:28:28):
I listened to some of them, but I did not listen to those voicemails.
Mr. Steel (02:28:54):
So because you haven't listened to them, you'd have to go back to the phone basically? Yes, sir.
Ray Lale (02:29:01):
I'm going to object to that. I think Mr. Steel's well aware that the phone was broken and open and allowed to be accessed well after this detective left the sheriff's office and went to another agency. This detective would have no way to know any of this. Mr. Steel's aware of that through his line of questioning, given all these facts that this witness wouldn't even know about. Didn't even know about.
Judge (02:29:25):
Any response?
Mr. Steel (02:29:26):
Sure. I'll just ask some questions, follow-up questions-
Judge (02:29:31):
Okay.
Mr. Steel (02:29:31):
... as my response. May I continue?
Judge (02:29:36):
You're moving on to another question.
Mr. Steel (02:29:38):
I'm just going to follow with questions. I don't have a response. I'll just rephrase.
Judge (02:29:42):
Okay. Very good.
Mr. Steel (02:29:43):
When you started testimony before this honorable jury last week, do you remember being asked whether you reviewed, even recently, the contents of the phone of Ms. Akers?
Witness (02:29:57):
I did.
Mr. Steel (02:29:58):
So I'm just asking you at any time, did you listen to his recordings that were left? The messages from TitleMax?
Witness (02:30:05):
No, I did not.
Mr. Steel (02:30:08):
Okay. Okay. With regards to the next, if you don't mind, the next exhibit.
Clerk (02:30:18):
That's it.
Mr. Steel (02:30:18):
That's everyone?
Clerk (02:30:18):
Mm-hmm.
Mr. Steel (02:30:30):
Okay. So on State's Exhibit, remember the Cellebrite extraction?
Witness (02:30:44):
Yes, sir.
Mr. Steel (02:30:45):
That you went over with the jurors?
Witness (02:30:46):
Yes, sir.
Mr. Steel (02:30:49):
I'd like to discuss some of them with you. Do you still have it up there or do you need it? I didn't give it to you today?
Ray Lale (02:30:52):
No, you didn't give it to me.
Mr. Steel (02:30:52):
Do you remember what State Exhibit number it would be?
Clerk (02:30:52):
Is it on the back? It's on the back right there.
Mr. Steel (02:30:55):
Thank you. Number 185.
Witness (02:30:55):
Yes, sir.
Mr. Steel (02:31:08):
May I approach, Your Honor?
Judge (02:31:09):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (02:31:09):
May I approach you?
Witness (02:31:11):
Yes, sir.
Mr. Steel (02:31:11):
Can I grab that exhibit?
Witness (02:31:18):
Yes, sir.
Mr. Steel (02:31:19):
I'm going to show it to the jury.
Witness (02:31:20):
Oh, sorry.
Mr. Steel (02:31:24):
That's okay. May I approach the investigator, Your Honor?
Judge (02:31:26):
Sure.
Mr. Steel (02:31:26):
May I approach? That should be number 185, State's Exhibit. Now, this is something that the jurors have already seen and you went through, true?
Witness (02:31:36):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (02:31:37):
I'd just like to go through a couple of these exhibits with you, if that's okay.
Witness (02:31:41):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (02:31:50):
So let's look at... Let me see if I can get the page. It should be page 5, number 11. And if you could blow it up on the actual communication. And here, this is from Mr. Akers' number 5482 to Lacy's number 1698. Does that sound right?
Witness (02:33:02):
It does.
Mr. Steel (02:33:03):
So the communication... If the person is on the other... Using the device and sending this, I know we don't have a video of that, but in general, it's going from the phone of Mr. Akers, presumably by him, to Ms. Boles, presumably to her. Is that fair to say?
Witness (02:33:18):
That's fair to say.
Mr. Steel (02:33:19):
And here it says, "Look, I know your heart..." This is from Mr. Akers to Ms. Boles, fair?
Witness (02:33:28):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (02:33:28):
"Look, I know your heart is in the right place. We just don't have it like that, and we are not at all prepared for furlough." And that's what you were talking about earlier, the furlough of the job.
Witness (02:33:39):
Yes, sir.
Mr. Steel (02:33:40):
And that's losing the job, true?
Witness (02:33:42):
It's being laid off, yes.
Mr. Steel (02:33:44):
And then just to be complete, "Nobody knows how much the pig costs plus food, and I'm not trying to make the baby suffer because we want to fake have money." Right? Correct?
Witness (02:34:04):
Yes. Yes, sir.
Mr. Steel (02:34:05):
Okay. And that date is the 21st day of December 2019, the day before unfortunately, tragically, Ms. Akers is no longer with us, right?
Witness (02:34:20):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (02:34:21):
And it's in the afternoon at 3:24 PM. That's the afternoon, correct?
Witness (02:34:27):
That's correct.
Mr. Steel (02:34:28):
Okay. Now, losing a job is a lot different than what was told to Detective Lehman that he was looking forward to his job, right?
Witness (02:34:44):
Again, based on an interview I had with one of his coworkers, he was fine. He was going to be moving to the airport job. I believe it was the airport job.
Mr. Steel (02:34:52):
We're going to talk about that then, okay?
Witness (02:34:53):
Okay.
Mr. Steel (02:34:56):
But you never told Detective Lehman that Mr. Akers believed he was going to be furloughed, did you?
Witness (02:35:00):
I never told Dr. Lehman that, no.
Mr. Steel (02:35:07):
On page 18, or page 7, I mean, should be number 19, I believe. And just to orient again, once it's set up by the district attorney investigator, can you see that, sir?
Witness (02:35:45):
I can.
Mr. Steel (02:35:46):
This is again, Mr. Akers texting, what I'll call texting, to Lacy Boles's phone, true?
Witness (02:35:55):
Yes, sir.
Mr. Steel (02:35:56):
And we're talking the same date, just a couple of minutes later. It's 3:39 in the afternoon, and again, it's December 21, 2019, the day before Mr. Akers, God forbid, is no longer with us, true?
Witness (02:36:09):
Yes, sir.
Mr. Steel (02:36:10):
And what Mr. Akers wrote is the following, "Lacy, I'm not trying to say that you don't put your fair share... You don't put in," excuse me, "your fair share. What I'm saying is that I'm by myself right now." True? That's what he wrote.
Witness (02:36:31):
That's what it says.
Mr. Steel (02:36:35):
"I am no one looking out to keep a roof over your head and over our baby's head." Right?
Witness (02:36:47):
That's what it reads.
Mr. Steel (02:36:49):
And that, well, to use your word means, it's all on Ms. Akers' shoulders, the finances, right? That's what he's writing.
Ray Lale (02:37:01):
Object to having this witness interpret what he means by it, or speculate on what he means by it. You can just read it. It's for the jury to determine what he means. This is speculation.
Mr. Steel (02:37:12):
That's fine.
Judge (02:37:12):
I agree.
Mr. Steel (02:37:13):
"Everyone else..." I'm continuing reading.
Witness (02:37:15):
Yes, sir.
Mr. Steel (02:37:16):
"Everyone else has another roof to be under and have someone else feeding them." Did I read that correctly?
Witness (02:37:25):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (02:37:27):
"So this has nothing to do with you or your money or your money to come." That's what he wrote, right?
Witness (02:37:33):
That's what it reads.
Mr. Steel (02:37:36):
"This is about being smarter, stronger, and taking the best care of you and the ones that actually have to live and survive with us." And that's number 19, right?
Witness (02:37:48):
Yes, sir.
Mr. Steel (02:37:48):
Did you ever tell Dr. Lehman about what Mr. Akers wrote, that he's by himself right now and no one looking out to keep a roof over your head or over our baby's head? Did you ever tell him that?
Witness (02:38:07):
I did not.
Mr. Steel (02:38:08):
And this is just the day before the suicide, according to Lacy, right?
Witness (02:38:15):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (02:38:15):
I shouldn't say the day before. I see your hesitation. It's hours. It's... I don't know. It's about 10 hours until the death of Ms. Akers.
Witness (02:38:28):
Yes, sir.
Mr. Steel (02:38:30):
Okay. All right. If you could use number 20, if you don't mind, Mr. Investigator. This is again from Mr. Akers' number, the 5462 to Lacy's number. That's the 1698. And it's a few minutes later, but it's the same day. It's December 21, 2019, and now it's 3:46 in the afternoon. Fair to say?
Witness (02:38:54):
Fair.
Mr. Steel (02:38:55):
And then the writing from Mr. Akers to Lacy is, "This is my job and yours too. Either you mature to that, knock the games off, so we can be happy and possibly have something one day. There is a way more..." Excuse me. I'm going to start that again. "There is way more to it than just running the house. Are we going to work every day? I should have to explain..." Excuse me. "I should not have to explain this to you. I'm sorry if you don't agree, but you are not the one that gets looked at if we don't have money to pay the bills, if we don't have money to feed our kids, if we don't have the money to keep a roof over their heads."
(02:39:48)
"I wish I did have the money, and I wish I could do everything and anything for all the kids. But what you're asking is to take food out of the baby's mouths and give it to one of their siblings as a present. I am desperately trying to get caught up and ahead. We are 36 years old and should not have to ask for help from anyone." True how I read it?
Witness (02:40:22):
Yes, that's how it reads.
Mr. Steel (02:40:23):
Did you ever tell Dr. Lehman at any time that Mr. Akers wrote, "You are not the one that gets looked at if we don't have money to pay the bills"?
Witness (02:40:41):
I did not.
Mr. Steel (02:40:43):
Did you ever tell Dr. Lehman that if we don't have the money to feed the kids?
Witness (02:40:50):
I did not.
Mr. Steel (02:40:52):
Or if we don't have the money to keep a roof over their head?
Witness (02:40:55):
I did not.
Mr. Steel (02:41:57):
Page 11, number 33. It's number 33. Again, this is Mr. Akers to Lacy. Is that fair to say?
Witness (02:42:04):
It is fair.
Mr. Steel (02:42:05):
And then this time, we're a little later in the day. It's about six hours later, six plus hours later. It's 10:11 at night. You see that?
Witness (02:42:17):
I do, sir.
Mr. Steel (02:42:18):
But it's the same day. It's going to be now just two and a half hours before Ms. Akers is no longer with us. Is that the approximate time?
Witness (02:42:28):
Yes, sir.
Mr. Steel (02:42:28):
So it's the end of December 21, Saturday, December 21, 2019, going into the next day, which was Sunday, December 22.
Witness (02:42:38):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (02:42:39):
All right. And then what Mr. Akers wrote here is, "You never meet anyone 50/50 halfway. Oh, that's right. You go find someone else." I'm saying else, but it's E-L-S is what I read.
Witness (02:42:58):
That's correct.
Mr. Steel (02:42:59):
"You put your mind to it. All you do is use me and I'm sick of it. Find that someone to pay your rent bills and grocery, et cetera. I just stayed because you said your dad was coming. I don't run from no one, so you should know I'm not running from you or your stupidity you have going on there. I'm trying to leave you behind. My sentence has been served and you don't want to get right. So F," it's spelled out, but "F blank, C-K, it all." With two emojis. Fair to say?
Witness (02:43:42):
Fair.
Mr. Steel (02:43:43):
"You better learn fast or God bless you. I'm just a kid, right? Well, this kid ain't going for your fakery anymore. I'm doing me." True?
Witness (02:44:04):
That is true.
Mr. Steel (02:44:11):
That's a statement to his wife. Fair?
Witness (02:44:22):
That's fair.
Mr. Steel (02:44:23):
And from your understanding of this case and the facts, their marriage was ending?
Witness (02:44:30):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (02:44:34):
Both sides seem to indicate that from your understanding of this case?
Witness (02:44:38):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (02:45:04):
If you go to number 39, it should be on the same page, but it might be on the next page. If you could do 39, it should be on the next page. I apologize. And what page number is that, sir?
Clerk (02:45:31):
It is page 13.
Mr. Steel (02:45:31):
Thank you. This is Mr. Akers to Ms. Boles, and it's shortly after the last one. It's 10 minutes later. It's 10:21 now in the evening, same night before the death of, God forbid, Ms. Akers, right?
Witness (02:45:45):
Yes, sir.
Mr. Steel (02:45:47):
And then Ms. Akers wrote, "I guess I'd rather sound like him than look like him, like you do, walking geek face." That's what is written, right?
Witness (02:46:01):
Yes, sir.
Mr. Steel (02:46:02):
Okay. And then the next one is Lacy's reply to all these statements. It's the next in line. And we know that because it's number 1698 and it's recorded on Mr. Akers' phone as "my wife," right?
Witness (02:46:20):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (02:46:21):
And it's to Mr. Akers, the 5462 number, correct?
Witness (02:46:25):
That is correct.
Mr. Steel (02:46:26):
And it's just a few seconds after the 10:21 message we just wrote on the same day, true?
Witness (02:46:32):
Correct.
Mr. Steel (02:46:33):
And Lacy wrote, "You pay either way, hater. Keep making me greater. Blocked," and I'm not going to say it, but B-I-T blank H. "Talked to my lawyer. Mistake after 2018. Not a grower or a show," and then dot, dot, E-R-R-R, shower, right?
Witness (02:46:56):
That is correct.
Mr. Steel (02:46:57):
And here, you know from interviewing Lacy that she told you that, and it's corroborated, I guess, by the State exhibit, that she blocked the communication on Facebook Messenger with her husband?
Witness (02:47:10):
Yes. I believe she said on her phone and a Facebook Messenger.
Mr. Steel (02:47:13):
Okay. And she said that she's contacting a lawyer?
Witness (02:47:17):
That is correct.
Mr. Steel (02:47:19):
And we're talking about a divorce lawyer?
Witness (02:47:21):
I would assume.
Mr. Steel (02:47:24):
Okay. Okay. Number 44, if you don't mind. It might be page 14. Am I correct?
Clerk (02:47:52):
14, yes.
Mr. Steel (02:47:53):
Thank you, sir. And this is Mr. Akers, the 5462, texting to Lacy, the 1698 at 11:16 on the same day. So this is about an hour and a half before his demise. Is that fair to say?
Witness (02:48:12):
That's fair.
Mr. Steel (02:48:13):
Okay. And Mr. Akers wrote, "You pissed it away with the way you act. Don't want to be your man. You can't handle being real. So," it says, "F-U-K off, F-U-K yourself," spelled U-R-S-E-L-F, "or whatever you do, and since I pay for it, I'll sleep there or not. I don't care, dummy. You made me not give a," and then it says, F-U-K, "you're bad." Right?
Witness (02:48:46):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (02:48:47):
I mean, this is really falling apart at this time, according to this text message, right? This is a fight, an argument.
Witness (02:48:54):
It's an argument, yes.
Mr. Steel (02:48:55):
Okay. Next one, please. It should be page 15, number 45. And this is Lacy responding to... I shouldn't say responding, but replying or communicating, how about that, with Mr. Akers, fair? That's the direction of the communication?
Witness (02:49:18):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (02:49:19):
And this is a moment later, it's 11:42, so we're about an hour and maybe two minutes or so since when Mr. Akers is going to be taken from us. Fair to say?
Witness (02:49:31):
Fair to say.
Mr. Steel (02:49:32):
And Lacy wrote, "I'm about to have your job, your paycheck, your babies." Babies is spelled B-A-B-A-I-E-S. Does that look right?
Witness (02:49:45):
Yes, sir.
Mr. Steel (02:49:46):
Then it says, "B-I blank, C-H-N, blank, G-G-A, done F blank, C-K-E-D up," with an exclamation point, right?
Witness (02:49:58):
Yes, sir.
Mr. Steel (02:49:58):
"Call to Steve Langley. Already arranged Pronto in the AM." And then it said, "D-A-M blank, Dan," which is Ms. Akers' first name, "U-F-U blank, K-I-N-G, done, son." Right?
Witness (02:50:12):
That's correct.
Mr. Steel (02:50:13):
So Lacy is writing, you know who Steve Langley is. You remember him? He's the employer of Mr. Akers?
Witness (02:50:23):
Yes. I believe he was his union boss.
Mr. Steel (02:50:25):
So Lacy's saying that come the morning, whatever that is, Monday morning, Sunday morning, she's going to contact Mr. Langley about Mr. Akers. That's what it reads.
Witness (02:50:36):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (02:50:36):
And that deals with his job. And it says here that Lacy's going to take his job and his paycheck and his children, right?
Witness (02:50:45):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (02:50:46):
Did you tell any of that to Detective Lehman?
Witness (02:50:49):
I did not say that to Dr. Lehman.
Mr. Steel (02:50:51):
Okay. Then if you go down that page, this is Lacy to number 46 to Mr. Akers, it's a minute or two maybe later, I forget, but it's right there in short timeframe. It's the last one we read, December 21, 2019 and Lacy wrote, "F blank C-K with the next one ho, exclamation point, blocked N out." Do you remember reading that?
Witness (02:51:26):
I do.
Mr. Steel (02:51:28):
Okay. And then Mr. Akers responded number 47. He responded to Lacy or he wrote to Lacy at 12:11. So we're about 33 minutes until he's about to pass on, right?
Witness (02:51:48):
That's correct.
Mr. Steel (02:51:49):
And now it is the day of Sunday, December 22, 2019. We just bridged over into Sunday.
Witness (02:51:55):
Yes, sir.
Mr. Steel (02:51:56):
And Mr. Akers wrote, "Okay, kiddo." And then the next one, which is number 48, "I told you to stop U-R-S-H blank T." And that's the last communication that we have.
Witness (02:52:14):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (02:52:14):
Am I right?
Witness (02:52:14):
That is it.
Mr. Steel (02:52:14):
The last thing that Mr. Akers said was, "I told you to stop," right?
Witness (02:52:20):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (02:52:29):
Okay. Now, you communicated with Dr. Lehman, along with Lieutenant Hill, that Mr. Akers was happy. Do you remember that?
Witness (02:52:44):
I do.
Mr. Steel (02:52:47):
Do any of these sound happy?
Witness (02:52:51):
You're asking for my opinion, but they sound like they're arguing.
Mr. Steel (02:52:55):
Losing job, right? The furlough, that comes from Mr. Akers, right.
Witness (02:52:59):
Mm-hmm.
Mr. Steel (02:53:00):
True?
Witness (02:53:00):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (02:53:04):
No money for Christmas for the kids, right?
Witness (02:53:08):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (02:53:09):
That comes from Mr. Akers, right?
Witness (02:53:11):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (02:53:12):
Is that happy? I don't need an opinion. If you don't know, just say, "I don't know."
Witness (02:53:15):
I don't know.
Mr. Steel (02:53:22):
Okay. His marriage is seemingly over. I'm not saying people don't reconcile, but it's according to those messages, seemingly over, right?
Witness (02:53:32):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (02:53:32):
Okay. And none of that was told to Dr. Lehman?
Witness (02:53:37):
No.
Mr. Steel (02:53:48):
Okay. I'd like to talk to you about some of your conversation with Lacy, if that's okay.
Witness (02:54:01):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (02:54:02):
And it's State's Exhibit number 185. Again, it's the same document we were just working off of. If the court would allow, it's in evidence, if you can go to page 2, and it should be number 2 and 3. So on State's Exhibit number 185, this is now earlier. I'm not trying to confuse anyone, but just to make sure that we don't confuse anyone, this is Mr.-
Mr. Steel (02:55:00):
... don't confuse anyone. This is Mr. Akers communicating with Lacy and it is now Saturday, December 21, 2019 and during the day 12... I mean, excuse me, 2:28 in the afternoon. True?
Nicholas Hardy (02:55:17):
Yes, sir.
Mr. Steel (02:55:18):
So I went all the way to almost the time of, God forbid Mr. Akers, passing to now we're during the day, early in the day on Saturday. Fair? It's early afternoon.
Nicholas Hardy (02:55:29):
That's fair.
Mr. Steel (02:55:30):
Okay. And Mr. Akers wrote, it looks like a list. It says, "Bread, Oreos, cracker soup, boxes. Do they have your hair color at Family Dollar and do you want the burgundy again?" And then I'm just skipping to number three. And it says, "Yes, they do and yes, that's fine." And that's Lacy seemingly responding to about the hair color and the store Dollar General sells it, fair?
Nicholas Hardy (02:56:02):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (02:56:02):
Okay. And you did notice, did you not? May I approach, Your Honor?
Judge Dean Bucci (02:56:08):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (02:56:15):
I'm going to show you, this is already in evidence. May I approach you?
Nicholas Hardy (02:56:18):
Yes, sir.
Mr. Steel (02:56:28):
This is state's number 139, 143 and 142. Just-
Nicholas Hardy (02:56:28):
Yes, sir.
Mr. Steel (02:56:30):
... take a peek and just tell me whether... You could focus on those items that are already in evidence. May I approach, Your Honor?
Judge Dean Bucci (02:56:33):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (02:56:33):
May I approach you?
Nicholas Hardy (02:56:39):
Yes, sir.
Mr. Steel (02:56:40):
I'd like to give this to, Your Honor, the court to put on the screen if that's okay, Your Honor.
Judge Dean Bucci (02:56:45):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (02:56:45):
I'll give this to you, sir. Thank you, Mr. Investigator.
Nicholas Hardy (02:56:51):
State's 143.
Mr. Steel (02:56:55):
Do you see in State's Exhibit number 143, when you analyze this, this is like what I would call a bleach cleaner. If that's wrong, just tell me, "No, that's a different..." What is that?
Nicholas Hardy (02:57:09):
I just see cleaner.
Mr. Steel (02:57:10):
Okay. And any evidence that this was used in any way to clean up a scene December 22, 2019?
Nicholas Hardy (02:57:20):
I wasn't on the scene, sir.
Mr. Steel (02:57:21):
So your answer is?
Nicholas Hardy (02:57:23):
No.
Mr. Steel (02:57:23):
Right. Just like the fingernail, this could have been there for a week, true? Before.
Nicholas Hardy (02:57:29):
True.
Mr. Steel (02:57:29):
When I say, "A week," let me ask a much better question. This cleaner could have been there a month, but a week before, a day before December 22, 2019. True?
Nicholas Hardy (02:57:41):
True.
Mr. Steel (02:57:42):
It's in the corner. It doesn't look disturbed, right?
Nicholas Hardy (02:57:44):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (02:57:45):
And then this is a product here. If you could zoom in on it if you can. Did you ever know this to be a burgundy hair color product?
Nicholas Hardy (02:57:55):
I can't see the hair color, what the actual hair color is, but it does look like there's a picture of a female with hair.
Mr. Steel (02:58:04):
Okay. And it's another picture we're going to show right now.
Nicholas Hardy (02:58:06):
Yes, sir.
Mr. Steel (02:58:08):
If you could just zoom in and just make it clear for the jurors, if you don't mind. This is the female you're talking about right here-
Nicholas Hardy (02:58:14):
Yes, sir.
Mr. Steel (02:58:14):
... and it shows hair. Is that what you were referring to?
Nicholas Hardy (02:58:17):
Yes, sir.
Mr. Steel (02:58:18):
Okay. You never analyzed this, did you? You didn't focus your attention?
Nicholas Hardy (02:58:24):
I wasn't on the scene. No, sir. I wasn't on the scene.
Mr. Steel (02:58:26):
Even afterward though when you reviewed-
Nicholas Hardy (02:58:27):
No, but I noticed it was a box of hair dye.
Mr. Steel (02:58:29):
Okay. I'm not saying it's related, but it's similar to the hair dye discussed on State's Exhibit 185 we just discussed.
Nicholas Hardy (02:58:37):
I don't know if that's the one he bought or an old one.
Mr. Steel (02:58:39):
Okay. Can we show another one?
Speaker 8 (02:58:50):
State's one...
Mr. Steel (02:58:54):
42?
Speaker 8 (02:58:54):
... 42, yeah.
Mr. Steel (02:58:56):
Yes, sir. And same area of the hair dye, anything that this helps with you telling what color or anything about the hair dye?
Nicholas Hardy (02:59:06):
No, sir.
Mr. Steel (02:59:07):
Okay. That's fine. Then I'd like to go to the next state exhibit that you just looked at, if you don't-
Speaker 8 (02:59:13):
139.
Mr. Steel (02:59:16):
And if you could zoom out a little bit just for orientation. Thank you, sir. And Detective, what we're looking at here is the upstairs master bedroom. If you walk into the bathroom, is that true? It's off the master bedroom. It's the bathroom.
Nicholas Hardy (02:59:45):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (02:59:46):
And this is the basin, and we could give a photograph we just saw, but this is one of the two basins where the hair gel is all... Or the hair color rather, is all the way to the left. Is that true?
Nicholas Hardy (03:00:00):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (03:00:00):
And this is the basin farthest, I'll say, from where the hair color product is?
Nicholas Hardy (03:00:06):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (03:00:06):
On the night that it was filmed, true?
Nicholas Hardy (03:00:09):
True.
Mr. Steel (03:00:09):
And the reason that this is interesting to you is, and you spoke about this with Ms. Boles about washing her hands, right?
Nicholas Hardy (03:00:18):
I did.
Mr. Steel (03:00:19):
And the reason is because this appears to be... I'm not saying it is, but it appears to be blood in the sink, basically.
Nicholas Hardy (03:00:27):
It does appear to be blood.
Mr. Steel (03:00:29):
To be fair, no one took a sample, a swab of it, so we really don't know if it is blood, but it appears to be blood. Is that, what I'm saying, true?
Nicholas Hardy (03:00:37):
It is true.
Mr. Steel (03:00:38):
Okay. And maybe if you were on the scene, somebody would've swiped it and preserved it and tested it for blood, right?
Nicholas Hardy (03:00:45):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (03:00:46):
And whose blood was it, right?
Nicholas Hardy (03:00:48):
Exactly.
Mr. Steel (03:00:49):
But we got to deal with reality. It wasn't done and you come in later, true?
Nicholas Hardy (03:00:54):
True.
Mr. Steel (03:00:55):
I want to talk to you about this though. You have information. I know you're not on the scene. Everyone, I think, understands that, but Lacy, at some point, you learned from looking over the file and understanding where you are, when law enforcement's present, she is with her children and her mother in the bedroom upstairs. Is that fair?
Nicholas Hardy (03:01:22):
I believe they were in the living room.
Mr. Steel (03:01:24):
Do you ever remember them being in the bedroom? It's okay. I could show you something.
Nicholas Hardy (03:01:28):
I remember in her 911 call, she said that she was in the bedroom with her children.
Mr. Steel (03:01:32):
Okay. Then we'll just use the 911 call. I guess that's...
Nicholas Hardy (03:01:36):
Yes, sir.
Mr. Steel (03:01:36):
... perfect. Do you know whether her mother... Her mother, let me change. Lacy's mother came to the scene?
Nicholas Hardy (03:01:44):
I do know that, yes.
Mr. Steel (03:01:45):
Okay. Do you know whether Lacy ever embraced her mother or her mother embraced Lacy?
Nicholas Hardy (03:01:52):
I do not, sir.
Mr. Steel (03:01:53):
Do you know whether the six-year old at that time, Gage, ever embraced Lacy?
Nicholas Hardy (03:01:58):
I do not, sir.
Mr. Steel (03:01:59):
Do you know whether any blood that may or may not have been on Lacy got onto the mother?
Nicholas Hardy (03:02:05):
I do not, sir. I was not on scene.
Mr. Steel (03:02:07):
Do you know whether any of the blood of Mr. Akers... I'm talking about Ms. Akers' blood-
Nicholas Hardy (03:02:13):
I understood. Yes, sir.
Mr. Steel (03:02:14):
... got onto Gage?
Nicholas Hardy (03:02:16):
I do not.
Mr. Steel (03:02:20):
Assuming this is blood and assuming hands were washed, do you know whether the mother washed her hands in the sink?
Nicholas Hardy (03:02:27):
I do not.
Mr. Steel (03:02:28):
And got blood there?
Nicholas Hardy (03:02:28):
I do not.
Mr. Steel (03:02:31):
Do you know whether Gage, the six-year-old at that time, washed his hands in that sink, if his hands were bloody?
Nicholas Hardy (03:02:37):
I do not.
Mr. Steel (03:02:38):
And got blood in the sink? So the fact that Lacy said she didn't wash her hands, potentially other people, if that's blood, could have washed their hands and got in that basement to look like that in State's Exhibit 139. Is that fair?
Nicholas Hardy (03:02:54):
It's possible.
Mr. Steel (03:02:55):
We just don't know, true?
Nicholas Hardy (03:02:57):
Exactly. True.
Mr. Steel (03:02:58):
And we don't know because of the same things you've explained to the jury. No one took a photograph to see what Lacy's appearance was or her clothing or her hands or her face or her hair with blood, right?
Nicholas Hardy (03:03:11):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (03:03:12):
And no one took a photograph of what Gage hands, face, pajamas, whatever he wears, looked like that night, right?
Nicholas Hardy (03:03:20):
Correct.
Mr. Steel (03:03:21):
And no one took a photograph of the mother of Lacy and whether her hands, face, whatever, clothing had blood on it, right?
Nicholas Hardy (03:03:30):
Correct.
Mr. Steel (03:03:31):
We just don't know whose blood or who potentially washed their hands, if their hands were washed in that basin, do we?
Nicholas Hardy (03:03:38):
No.
Mr. Steel (03:03:52):
I'd like to go to 185. I may be wrong, but it should be page six... I mean, page five, rather, number 14. Your Honor, may I display?
Judge Dean Bucci (03:04:23):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (03:04:36):
And sir, this is from Lacy to Mr. Akers, fair to say?
Nicholas Hardy (03:04:41):
It is.
Mr. Steel (03:04:43):
And it is, again, not to confuse anybody, but it's the day before, God forbid the killing, and it's 3:29 in the afternoon. So I don't know, middle of the afternoon on Saturday, December 21, 2019, fair?
Nicholas Hardy (03:04:59):
That's fair.
Mr. Steel (03:05:00):
And what Lacy now wrote to Mr. Akers is, "Then you shouldn't have accused me stealing and returning Lindsay first game we bought her for," and it says, "60," then dollar sign with an exclamation point, right?
Nicholas Hardy (03:05:20):
Yes, that's what it reads.
Mr. Steel (03:05:22):
"Then turning around, buying her another one for another," and then it has the same 60 and then the dollar sign, that 120, 120, then a dollar sign, right?
Nicholas Hardy (03:05:36):
Yes, sir.
Mr. Steel (03:05:37):
Then I have her $30 with the dollar sign, or 30, excuse me, dollar sign cash, right?
Nicholas Hardy (03:05:45):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (03:05:46):
"Ava," A-V-A, "got her camera plus her package that went with her camera, her party, et cetera. Phoenix got 100," and then dollar sign cash. Who's not being real?" That's what it reads, right?
Nicholas Hardy (03:06:04):
That's what it reads.
Mr. Steel (03:06:05):
And you know Phoenix to be?
Nicholas Hardy (03:06:09):
Lacy's child, but not Dan's.
Mr. Steel (03:06:13):
Right. Her son-
Nicholas Hardy (03:06:14):
Her son.
Mr. Steel (03:06:15):
... from previous marriage?
Nicholas Hardy (03:06:16):
From a previous marriage, yes.
Mr. Steel (03:06:17):
And you know that Lacy had two children from a previous marriage-
Nicholas Hardy (03:06:21):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (03:06:22):
... before she married Mr. Akers or before she was in a relationship with Ms. Akers, true?
Nicholas Hardy (03:06:27):
True.
Mr. Steel (03:06:28):
And Mr. Akers had two children of his own before he was in a relationship with Ms. Boles, Lacy Boles, right?
Nicholas Hardy (03:06:35):
He did. He had two daughters.
Mr. Steel (03:06:36):
So the total we're talking about is three children that Lacy and Mr. Akers had together, Gage, Emerson, Daniel, Jr. right?
Nicholas Hardy (03:06:48):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (03:06:48):
And then each of them had two children, so if you add them up, that's seven children total?
Nicholas Hardy (03:06:54):
Yes, sir.
Mr. Steel (03:06:55):
And they're various ages, true?
Nicholas Hardy (03:06:57):
Yes, sir.
Mr. Steel (03:06:58):
Okay. If you could turn to the next page, if you don't mind.
Judge Dean Bucci (03:07:04):
I'm just chatting with the jury. It's about 20 till noon. My plan was to go to noon today to 12 and then break for lunch. Can everybody do that? Thank you.
Mr. Steel (03:07:17):
If you could turn, I think it's page six, number 15. This is from Lacy to Mr. Akers. And again, it's 3: 29 in the afternoon and it's that Saturday, December 21, 2019, fair?
Nicholas Hardy (03:07:34):
That's fair.
Mr. Steel (03:07:36):
And Lacy writes, "Argument to what exactly? You keep treating me this way. You won't have anyone to argue with, and that's a promise." Right?
Nicholas Hardy (03:07:48):
That's fair.
Mr. Steel (03:07:49):
Then you go down to number 16, and it's Lacy continuing to Mr. Akers writing at 3:33 PM the same date, "You make me feel so S-H-I blank Y for not having money, and I promise you I've spent my fair share and invested my fair amount!" with an exclamation point, right?
Nicholas Hardy (03:08:15):
That's correct. That's what it reads.
Mr. Steel (03:08:16):
"Gives you no right to continuously treat me like S-H blank T!" with an exclamation point, right?
Nicholas Hardy (03:08:23):
Yes, sir.
Mr. Steel (03:08:24):
"What's your ulterior motives here?" with a question mark, correct?
Nicholas Hardy (03:08:30):
Correct.
Mr. Steel (03:08:31):
"Someone else or something else your, Y-O-U-R, hiding?" With an exclamation point, right?
Nicholas Hardy (03:08:40):
That's what it reads.
Mr. Steel (03:08:41):
Excuse me, not an exclamation point. A-
Nicholas Hardy (03:08:43):
Question mark.
Mr. Steel (03:08:43):
... question mark. "Either way, cut the S-H blank T. I'm over it and have been!" with an exclamation point, right?
Nicholas Hardy (03:08:53):
That's what it reads, sir.
Mr. Steel (03:08:54):
"Very aware I'm just a mistake to you." Right?
Nicholas Hardy (03:09:01):
Yes, sir.
Mr. Steel (03:09:11):
Okay. And then the next one is 17. And Lacy continues and it's almost shortly thereafter, immediately thereafter, it's 3:36, same day, the Saturday, December 21, 2019, Lacy sends Mr. Akers this message, right? "Hope you feel better about yourself though, and especially when you look in the mirror and reflect A-N-N this H-E blank blank you're putting me through and treating me like a D-A-M blank piece of trash!" exclamation point, right? That's what it says.
Nicholas Hardy (03:09:56):
That's what it says.
Mr. Steel (03:10:07):
Okay. So I want to talk to you about the 911 recording if we can.
Nicholas Hardy (03:10:16):
Yes, sir.
Mr. Steel (03:10:18):
Do you have the 911 recording? Your Honor, can I approach?
Judge Dean Bucci (03:10:49):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (03:11:09):
This is State's Exhibit number two. Have you listened to the 911 recording?
Nicholas Hardy (03:11:13):
Yes, multiple times.
Mr. Steel (03:11:14):
And are you... We have it here. If you need to hear anything, you can listen to it if you want, okay?
Nicholas Hardy (03:11:24):
Yes, sir.
Mr. Steel (03:11:24):
May I approach the investigator?
Judge Dean Bucci (03:11:24):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (03:11:24):
Your Honor, this is already in evidence. Can I play parts of the 911 recording?
Judge Dean Bucci (03:11:28):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (03:11:35):
So the jurors have already heard this just for you to orient, but I would just like to discuss with you parts of the 911 call if I can, okay?
Nicholas Hardy (03:11:45):
Yes, sir.
Mr. Steel (03:11:46):
Now, when you interview Lacy on March 5th, 2020, you mentioned to her that you've listened to the 911 recording, right?
Nicholas Hardy (03:11:58):
I did.
Mr. Steel (03:11:59):
And to your knowledge, did Lacy ever hear the 911 recording at the time?
Nicholas Hardy (03:12:05):
No.
Mr. Steel (03:12:05):
Let me just finish the question.
Nicholas Hardy (03:12:06):
I'm sorry.
Mr. Steel (03:12:06):
No, you anticipate my question, but let me just finish the question, okay? Do you have any information that Lacy heard the 911 recording at or before the time of your interview with her on March 5, 2020?
Nicholas Hardy (03:12:20):
No.
Mr. Steel (03:12:21):
Okay. But the 911 recording is potential evidence for whatever it says, you can listen to it and try to understand what was going on based upon the communication with the 911 operator and Lacy, true?
Nicholas Hardy (03:12:36):
That is correct.
Mr. Steel (03:12:37):
All right. Does Lacy ever mention to you that one of her children was downstairs during the time that she was on the 911 recording?
Nicholas Hardy (03:12:52):
Not that I can recall.
Mr. Steel (03:12:54):
Did you ever hear that on the 911 recording?
Nicholas Hardy (03:12:57):
If I remember correctly, I heard her say, "Go back upstairs."
Mr. Steel (03:13:00):
Okay. And do you know who she was?
Nicholas Hardy (03:13:02):
I do not.
Mr. Steel (03:13:04):
Let me stop one second. Who said, "Go back upstairs"?
Nicholas Hardy (03:13:07):
Lacy.
Mr. Steel (03:13:08):
All right. And she never mentioned, to your knowledge, to you or Detective Ogden, anything about a child being downstairs, did she?
Nicholas Hardy (03:13:25):
No.
Mr. Steel (03:13:26):
And to be fair to everybody, you have dealt with people who've been unfortunately involved in traumatic events, right?
Nicholas Hardy (03:13:39):
Yes, sir.
Mr. Steel (03:13:40):
Because sometimes law enforcement comes over and they do the... It's a great reason to come over and you help get the cat home and everyone's applauding, or you're doing a parade, but other times you're coming into people's messes, really bad time in their life at times, true?
Nicholas Hardy (03:13:59):
It's very true.
Mr. Steel (03:14:00):
And when there's trauma involved or stress or hysteria, people handle it, if you know or if you've observed differently. Is that true?
Nicholas Hardy (03:14:10):
I have observed it, yes.
Mr. Steel (03:14:12):
I mean, some people become really stoic and they could just detail the best they can. I'm not saying they're right, but this is what I saw happen and there's no tears in their almost flat affect. Is that true?
Nicholas Hardy (03:14:23):
That is true.
Mr. Steel (03:14:25):
And other people can't even talk. They can't get out anything that goes on. Is that all true?
Nicholas Hardy (03:14:32):
It is.
Mr. Steel (03:14:33):
And sometimes over time, if the stress of the moment could affect the way that somebody remembers something. It's not saying they're lying. I'm not suggesting. I'm just saying there's a lot of factors that could go into memory, true?
Nicholas Hardy (03:14:48):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (03:14:49):
And that's why partly law enforcement collects all this physical evidence because relying on people sometimes, especially in a traumatic situation, could be mistaken, even innocently mistaken information, true?
Nicholas Hardy (03:15:04):
That is true.
Mr. Steel (03:15:06):
So I want to go back, if you don't mind, to the State's Exhibit number two. When the call first happens, when I say, "The call," when the 911 operator connects with Lacy, do you hear that through the genius of the 911, they actually pick up recording before the 911 operator picks up the phone? Are you aware of-
Nicholas Hardy (03:15:41):
Yes, I am. There's a-
Mr. Steel (03:15:42):
... that technology?
Nicholas Hardy (03:15:44):
... few second delay before the 911 operator picks up.
Mr. Steel (03:15:49):
So if we start right at the beginning, and this is jarring, this is a jarring 911 call. Is that fair to say?
Nicholas Hardy (03:15:56):
You're using a term. It's a 911 call. I've heard multiple 911 calls in my career.
Mr. Steel (03:16:02):
Okay, fine. It is what it is we'll just say. All right. If we could just start, Your Honor, with the court's permission, right at the beginning of the 911 call until about 11 seconds, if that's okay. Actually, until about 23 seconds.
Speaker 8 (03:16:24):
Until 23 seconds?
Mr. Steel (03:16:28):
Yes. Sorry about that.
Video: Lacy Boles (03:16:39):
Daniel, no. Daniel, no. [inaudible 03:16:40] Hello, hello, hello. Hello.
Video: 911 Operator (03:16:40):
What's the address of your emergency?
Mr. Steel (03:16:56):
Did you hear that before the 911 operator came on and said... Did you hear what the 911 operator originally said?
Nicholas Hardy (03:17:02):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (03:17:03):
And was it something to the effect of... And I know the recording speaks for itself, but something you heard, "What's the address of your emergency?" That's-
Nicholas Hardy (03:17:10):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (03:17:11):
And before that, before the 911 operator engaged her voice is a woman 911 operator, right?
Nicholas Hardy (03:17:17):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (03:17:19):
You hear Lacy screaming, "Daniel, no. Hello, hello, hello." Something like that. Did you hear that?
Nicholas Hardy (03:17:27):
I did not hear that. I just heard screaming, hysterical.
Mr. Steel (03:17:29):
Can you replay with the court's permission from zero until about 23 seconds? And listen to the very beginning before the 911 operator picks up.
Video: Lacy Boles (03:17:39):
Daniel, no. Daniel, no. [inaudible 03:17:56] Hello, hello, hello, hello.
Video: 911 Operator (03:18:00):
What's the address of your emergency?
Video: Lacy Boles (03:18:00):
I need you please. I need you real quick.
Mr. Steel (03:18:06):
You can stop. Did you hear that at the video?
Nicholas Hardy (03:18:06):
I did not hear Daniel, sir. I don't hear Daniel.
Mr. Steel (03:18:10):
Okay. You're not saying it didn't happen, or you're saying...
Nicholas Hardy (03:18:14):
I don't hear it.
Mr. Steel (03:18:15):
Okay. Did you hear, "No, hello, hello, hello"?
Nicholas Hardy (03:18:18):
I do hear, "Hello, hello."
Mr. Steel (03:18:19):
Okay. At that point in time, if you know, where is Lacy Boles?
Nicholas Hardy (03:18:26):
I do not know.
Mr. Steel (03:18:28):
Now, presumably she's in the house, fair to say?
Nicholas Hardy (03:18:32):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (03:18:33):
Is that true? Okay. But you're just being fair, you don't know where in the house she is?
Nicholas Hardy (03:18:37):
I do not.
Mr. Steel (03:18:39):
Okay. I'd like to go to the part that you mentioned, which should be, you're on about one minute and 19 seconds until one minute and 45 seconds. If we could listen to that.
Video: 911 Operator (03:19:02):
Take those deep breaths, okay?
Video: Lacy Boles (03:19:02):
[inaudible 03:19:13].
Video: 911 Operator (03:19:02):
I'm calling for dispatch [inaudible 03:19:14]
Video: Lacy Boles (03:19:02):
Oh, God, oh, God, help me, Jesus.
Video: 911 Operator (03:19:02):
Ma'am.
Video: Lacy Boles (03:19:02):
Okay. Okay. Please don't make me go down there. Oh my God.
Video: 911 Operator (03:19:02):
Ma'am, take deep, calm breaths.
Video: Lacy Boles (03:19:02):
Yeah. Go upstairs, go upstairs, please go upstairs
Video: 911 Operator (03:19:02):
Ma'am, I can't understand you.
Video: Speaker 8 (03:19:02):
Dead.
Video: 911 Operator (03:19:02):
Do you think he's dead?
Video: Lacy Boles (03:19:02):
[inaudible 03:21:58]
Mr. Steel (03:19:38):
I want to ask you a couple questions. It started at 1:19 and it stopped at 1:44. Were you able to hear the 911 operator tell Lacy, "Ma'am, take a deep breath"?
Nicholas Hardy (03:19:50):
I did.
Mr. Steel (03:19:51):
And the 911 operator said she called into dispatch and, "Is he conscious?" Meaning is Ms. Akers conscious? Did you hear that?
Nicholas Hardy (03:20:01):
I did.
Mr. Steel (03:20:02):
And then did you hear Ms. Boles or Lacy say, "Oh, God, oh, God, help me, Jesus"?
Nicholas Hardy (03:20:09):
I didn't hear, "Help me, Jesus."
Mr. Steel (03:20:11):
Okay. And then did you hear Ms. Boles say, "Go upstairs, go upstairs, please"?
Nicholas Hardy (03:20:19):
I did hear her go upstairs.
Mr. Steel (03:20:20):
Did you hear it three times?
Nicholas Hardy (03:20:23):
It's possible, yeah. I mean, she's... Yes.
Mr. Steel (03:20:27):
And then the 911 operator again says, "Ma'am, is he conscious?" Meaning Mr. Akers?
Nicholas Hardy (03:20:32):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (03:20:32):
Did you hear that?
Nicholas Hardy (03:20:33):
I did.
Mr. Steel (03:20:34):
And then Ms. Boles responded, "Yeah. Yes, ma'am. Yes, ma'am. No, he's unconscious. I think he's dead." Did you hear that?
Nicholas Hardy (03:20:41):
Yes. Something to that effect.
Mr. Steel (03:20:42):
And then the 911 operator saying, "Ma'am, I can't understand you. Do you think he's dead?" And then did you hear another voice, not Lacy's voice, and not the 911 operator voice saying, "Dead"?
Nicholas Hardy (03:20:53):
There's something in the background. I can't make out what they're saying, but you do hear another voice.
Mr. Steel (03:20:57):
And then Ms. Boles said, "Please don't make me go down there. Oh my God."
Nicholas Hardy (03:21:01):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (03:21:02):
That's what we said. I'm going to ask the court to just allow you to listen to it one more time and just tell me if you hear Ms. Boles say, "Help me, Jesus, help me, Jesus, help me, Jesus." And then really what I'm targeting is, "Go upstairs, go upstairs, please go upstairs." And then another voice, a third voice saying, "Dead." Okay? Your Honor, this will be the same times, 1:19 to 1:45, please.
Video: 911 Operator (03:21:25):
Take those deep breaths, okay.
Video: Lacy Boles (03:21:25):
[inaudible 03:21:31]
Video: 911 Operator (03:21:25):
I'm calling for dispatch.
Video: Lacy Boles (03:21:25):
Oh, God, oh, God, help me, Jesus.
Video: 911 Operator (03:21:25):
Ma'am.
Video: Lacy Boles (03:21:30):
Okay. Okay. Breathing.
Video: 911 Operator (03:21:30):
Ma'am, take deep, calm breaths.
Video: Lacy Boles (03:21:30):
Yeah. Go upstairs, go upstairs, please go upstairs. Please don't make me go down there. Oh my God.
Video: 911 Operator (03:21:30):
Ma'am, I can't understand you. Do you think he's dead?
Video: Speaker 8 (03:21:30):
Dead.
Mr. Steel (03:21:57):
Okay. Did you hear the multiple, "Help me Jesus"?
Nicholas Hardy (03:21:59):
I did hear the multiple, "Help me Jesus"
Mr. Steel (03:22:01):
And then you already heard it before, but Lacy's saying into the 911 call that's recorded, "Go upstairs, go upstairs, please go upstairs." You knew that, right?
Nicholas Hardy (03:22:10):
Yes, sir.
Mr. Steel (03:22:12):
And then did you hear towards the end a child's voice saying, "Dead"?
Nicholas Hardy (03:22:16):
I hear a voice. I can't determine who that voice is or what they're saying.
Mr. Steel (03:22:20):
Okay. But based upon this 911 call, there's somebody else that Lacy-
Nicholas Hardy (03:22:26):
Yes, there is another voice.
Mr. Steel (03:22:27):
And Lacy's telling that person to please go upstairs.
Nicholas Hardy (03:22:30):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (03:22:32):
And that would mean, if you're familiar and you could focus on the house, "Go upstairs," would mean that there is an upstairs to go to, true?
Nicholas Hardy (03:22:43):
Yes. There's from the basement to a landing, then another set of stairs to the split-level, the main part of the house.
Mr. Steel (03:22:52):
So at that time, Lacy's not in her bedroom, according to logic on the 911 call. Is that fair to say?
Nicholas Hardy (03:22:58):
That's fair.
Mr. Steel (03:23:00):
So at this time that Lacy is on the 911 call with the operator, she was not in the upstairs area of the house. When I say, "Upstairs," where the bedrooms are, true, according to this?
Nicholas Hardy (03:23:16):
According to her saying, "Go upstairs," then yes.
Mr. Steel (03:23:19):
Okay. I'd like to go to another part of the 911 call, if that's okay.
Nicholas Hardy (03:23:34):
Yes, sir.
Mr. Steel (03:24:01):
It's from... If we started at 3:17, and we'll stop it with the court's permission at 3:47.
Video: 911 Operator (03:24:24):
Okay. Explain to me. Take a deep breath. Where did he shoot himself?
Video: Lacy Boles (03:24:24):
In the head, in the head.
Video: 911 Operator (03:24:24):
Where?
Video: Lacy Boles (03:24:24):
[inaudible 03:24:30].
Video: 911 Operator (03:24:30):
Okay. Listen, do you think that CPR will help him? Or do you believe that he's beyond all help?
Video: Lacy Boles (03:24:30):
No, I can't. I'm shaking. Please don't make me go down there. Please don't make me go back down there now. Oh God.
Video: 911 Operator (03:24:30):
Lacy, Lacy.
Mr. Steel (03:25:03):
Stop, Your Honor. 3:46. Were you able to hear that?
Nicholas Hardy (03:25:05):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (03:25:06):
And on there, we heard the 911 operator tell Lacy to take a deep breath. And then, "Where did he shoot himself?" Meaning Ms. Akers, right?
Nicholas Hardy (03:25:15):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (03:25:16):
And then Lacy is saying, if you heard it, "In the head, in the head." Did you hear that?
Nicholas Hardy (03:25:21):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (03:25:22):
And then the 911 operator asked Lacy, "Do you think that CPR will help him?" Do you remember hearing that?
Nicholas Hardy (03:25:33):
I do.
Mr. Steel (03:25:34):
"Or do you believe that he's beyond all help?" That was the statement. Did that sound familiar?
Nicholas Hardy (03:25:39):
Yes, sir.
Mr. Steel (03:25:41):
And then Lacy said, "No, I can't. I'm shaking." Did you hear that?
Nicholas Hardy (03:25:45):
I did not hear that.
Mr. Steel (03:25:46):
Okay. "Please don't make me go down there. Please don't make me go back down there now. Oh, God." Did you hear that?
Nicholas Hardy (03:25:54):
I did hear that.
Mr. Steel (03:25:55):
Okay. And then the 911 operator said, "Lacy, Lacy." And that's where we stopped him. Does that sound right?
Nicholas Hardy (03:26:02):
That's correct.
Mr. Steel (03:26:03):
I'm just going to ask the court to play 3:33 to 3:47, just if you can listen for it, "No, I can't. I'm shaking. Please don't make me go down there." Okay? Is that okay, Your Honor?
Judge Dean Bucci (03:26:13):
It is okay.
Video: 911 Operator (03:26:13):
Listen. Do you think that CPR will help him? Or do you believe that he's beyond all help?
Video: Lacy Boles (03:26:32):
No, I can't. I'm shaking. Please don't make me go down there.
Nicholas Hardy (03:26:32):
I don't hear it, sir.
Mr. Steel (03:26:38):
Okay. That's fine. That's fine. You're not saying it doesn't say, "Please don't make me go back down there." Or you heard that part.
Nicholas Hardy (03:26:44):
Yes. It's the shaking hand or, "My hands are shaking." I don't hear that part.
Mr. Steel (03:26:47):
That's fine. Thank you. So just again, logic to say, "Please don't make me go back down there," then Lacy is either on the landing or on the upstairs area of the house. Does that sound right?
Nicholas Hardy (03:27:06):
She could be anywhere in the house, but not downstairs.
Mr. Steel (03:27:08):
Okay. That's fair. So she's not in the room where Ms. Akers is on the basement level, according to the 911 call.
Nicholas Hardy (03:27:15):
According to the 911 call, she says she's upstairs.
Mr. Steel (03:27:17):
Okay. Then I'd like to go into the weapon. Is it okay?
Judge Dean Bucci (03:27:22):
I'm going to stop at this point.
Mr. Steel (03:27:22):
Okay.
Judge Dean Bucci (03:27:26):
All right. So it is now noon. We'll break until 1:15. We'll resume at 1:15. Thank you. Let's address this exhibit that's labeled Ms. Boles 140. On the first page of it, I see communication between Mike Hill and Dr. Lehman. I tend to agree with the prosecution that these two people aren't even here. Maybe you can get it in later, but I think that would be hearsay. And then I see, flipping the page, kind of the same thing. This is between Mike Hill and Dr. Lehman. So I'll sustain the objection.
(03:28:58)
Then I've got, now I'm on the fourth page of this packet, Mike Hill and Nick Hardy. And you can ask Detective Hardy about what he said. Then I've got a statement from Mike Hill where he's given his opinion, basically who buys a pig and then buys the farm. So I think I'll exclude Mike Hill's statement there.
(03:29:39)
Then I've got, this is from earlier, it's just reprinted what Dr. Lehman's saying. And you can ask Dr. Lehman about that later, but not now. You know you can't ask this witness about it now. And then I flip a page and it's communication between the doctor-
Judge (03:30:00):
... and then I flip a page and it's communication between the doctor and Mike Hill again. So I think that would be improper to get into at this point. So basically I'm sustaining the objection except for statements from the witness on the stand at this point.
Ray Lale (03:30:22):
I asked for a curative instruction. They've all already heard that through Mr. Steel's cross examination. They've heard all the statements now. And they heard those statements in the context of having come from Mike Hill to Dr. Lehman.
Judge (03:30:35):
Did-
Ray Lale (03:30:35):
So they should at least be... I'm sorry.
Judge (03:30:38):
No, I'm sorry.
Ray Lale (03:30:39):
They should at least be instructed not to consider that. And the statement I'm specifically talking about is buying a pig and Detective Hill-
Judge (03:30:52):
Is that Hill?
Ray Lale (03:30:53):
... he was happy, things like that. Anything from Detective Hill should be stricken and jury should be told to disregard it. And another problem is I believe that the exhibit the court's holding has already been admitted in its entirety.
Judge (03:31:10):
Is that true? This is already in?
Ray Lale (03:31:12):
I believe it was admitted, but I can't remember. I objected to it, but I believe it was admitted.
Judge (03:31:17):
I admitted this just today?
Ray Lale (03:31:20):
I believe so.
Judge (03:31:21):
Is that true? Don't know?
Mr. Steel (03:31:24):
I don't know. I have to check the record.
Judge (03:31:26):
All right. Let me check during the break. If it's already in, then that changes things.
Ray Lale (03:31:36):
It was admitted [inaudible 03:31:37] objection.
Judge (03:31:37):
I thought it was tendered. I said, "I'm going to have some questions about this, so can you move to another line of questioning?" Mr. Steel said, "Sure." And I thought I reserved ruling on this.
Ray Lale (03:31:47):
I think you're right.
Judge (03:31:48):
Okay.
Ray Lale (03:31:48):
But the meat of the matter is the statement from Hill to Lehman and that's already well before the jury multiple times. And now it's being sustained as hearsay. So I think a curative instruction would be appropriate.
Judge (03:32:11):
Care to respond at all?
Mr. Steel (03:32:13):
Sure. It's not hearsay, respectfully, in my understanding of the law because I'm not offering it for the truth of the matter served by someone saying, "And then he bought a pig." And I asked the detective and detective is on these communications. When the court says it's to and from someone, there's also a CC. There should be a CC of this witness, Detective Hardy. And my questions were, "Did you ever correct at any time Dr. Lehman was told that there was a pig? Do you have any evidence there was a pig bought?" And he's answers truthfully, "No, I never corrected him. I never told him that." So I'm not eliciting hearsay.
(03:32:53)
In addition to that, Dr. Lehman, I assume, is going to be a witness. So it's all coming in anyway. And if the state doesn't call him, I'll just call Lieutenant Hill if needed. But none of this is for the truth. It's for the untruth. That's the whole point. A hearsay statement is only to prove the truth is something. I'm proving that the statements to Dr. Lehman were untruthful. And then I'm asking Detective Hardy, why didn't he correct it or did he correct it? And he's a gentleman who said, "No, I never did."
Ray Lale (03:33:27):
Judge, the matter that's being offered for the truth is the fact that this communication was made to Dr. Lehman. The communication could say the moon is made out of cheese. What Mr. Steel's concentrating on is, was that communication sent to Dr. Lehman? That is being offered for the truth of the matter asserted. It doesn't matter what the statement says. The truth of the matter asserted is that the statement was made and sent to the doctor under the defense theory that this communication somehow affected the doctor's ultimate finding as to the manner of death. So it is being offered for the truth of the matter asserted.
Mr. Steel (03:34:04):
That's just not my understanding of the law.
Judge (03:34:08):
All right. Well, I'm going to stick with my ruling that I've made. You can try again with Dr. Lehman or Mike Hill if you like. And as far as what's already been asked and answered, I'm just going to leave that alone. That's what's already in the records is already in the record. So you can have that back.
Mr. Steel (03:34:30):
Understood.
Judge (03:34:31):
See you at 1:15.
Ray Lale (03:34:37):
If we can discuss the admissibility of it, if it's sought to be tendered, I would assume it that'd be [inaudible 03:34:41]
Judge (03:34:42):
All right. Well, we'll address that later. Thank you.
Speaker 9 (04:05:00):
(silence)
Judge (04:44:13):
Ready?
Mr. Steel (04:44:14):
Yes, sir.
Judge (04:44:15):
Ready? Okay. Yes.
Mr. Steel (04:44:15):
We need a witness actually.
Judge (04:44:34):
We do. Let's get our witness back. I assume he's here. [inaudible 04:45:16]. Whenever you're ready.
Mr. Steel (04:45:50):
Thank you, sir. So sir, when [inaudible 04:46:08] broke at the last hour, we were transitioning into the 911 call.
Witness (04:46:20):
Yes, sir.
Mr. Steel (04:46:20):
Combined with... What I'm trying to do is juxtapose it with the March, 5 2020 interview you had with Ms. Boles, okay,-
Witness (04:46:31):
Yes, sir.
Mr. Steel (04:46:31):
... that the jury's heard.
Witness (04:46:33):
Yes, sir.
Mr. Steel (04:46:34):
So what I said was I'd like to go into... I'm focusing on the weapon on the 911 call, discussion of the weapon, the firearm. Okay?
Witness (04:46:44):
Yes, sir.
Mr. Steel (04:46:45):
So this is with the court's permission. If we could place state's exhibit number two, Your Honor, starting at 3:47 and going until 5:02, if you don't mind. Thank you.
Lacy Boles (04:47:00):
[inaudible 04:47:04].
911 Operator (04:47:00):
Where is the weapon now?
Lacy Boles (04:47:00):
[inaudible 04:47:09].
911 Operator (04:47:00):
Okay? Where is the gun now?
Lacy Boles (04:47:00):
[inaudible 04:47:37].
911 Operator (04:47:00):
[inaudible 04:48:12]. What's his name?
Lacy Boles (04:47:00):
[inaudible 04:48:17].
Mr. Steel (04:48:24):
And that, Your Honor, is at a 5: 06 stop. So this is a lot going on, fair to say?
Witness (04:48:30):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (04:48:30):
There's a lot of whatever the right word. It's not clear words. Is that fair?
Witness (04:48:38):
It's fair.
Mr. Steel (04:48:39):
But you listened to this to study this because this is a piece of evidence. Fair to say?
Witness (04:48:45):
It's fair to say.
Mr. Steel (04:48:47):
And I just want to go through it with you and you tell us what you hear. I understand, and you made that clear. I think the court made it clear, the jurors decide what they hear, but I just want to talk to you about what you heard on the 911 call, okay, at this point.
Witness (04:49:03):
Yes, sir.
Mr. Steel (04:49:04):
So do you hear at the beginning, and we'll play it again. I'm not asking you to absorb all this, but Ms. Boles is being asked by the 911 operator, "Where is the gun now?" Did you hear that?
Witness (04:49:20):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (04:49:20):
Okay. And Ms. Boles said, "It's in his hand. I was trying to take it out of his hand. I was trying to take it out of his hand." Did you hear that part?
Witness (04:49:31):
I do not hear "trying to take out of his hand," I do hear "on the ground."
Mr. Steel (04:49:34):
Do you mind if we just listen to that together and just tell me if you hear that?
Witness (04:49:38):
Yes, sir.
Mr. Steel (04:49:39):
Okay. And Your Honor, with the court's permission, start at, we'll say 3:49 if you could, and just stop at 4:09.
911 Operator (04:49:54):
Where is the weapon now?
Lacy Boles (04:50:03):
In his hand. [inaudible 04:50:04].
Mr. Steel (04:50:12):
Your Honor stopped at 4:05. Did you hear "in his hand on the ground?"
Witness (04:50:16):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (04:50:18):
Let me just make it clear. Lacy said "it's in his hand on the ground" pursuant to the question of the 911 operator, "Where's the weapon now?" Fair?
Witness (04:50:27):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (04:50:29):
Okay. And then did you hear Lacy say, "I was trying to take it out of his hand."
Witness (04:50:35):
I do hear it once.
Mr. Steel (04:50:36):
You did hear that?
Witness (04:50:37):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (04:50:38):
Okay. And you know that she told you that she was trying to take the gun out of Mr. Akers' hand when he was trying to commit suicide, true?
Witness (04:50:52):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (04:50:53):
Okay. I'm going to go to the next part, we've heard it, but I'm breaking it down, okay? Is that okay?
Witness (04:51:02):
Yes, sir.
Mr. Steel (04:51:02):
All right. And if you need to hear anything, just let me hear it again. Did you then hear after that, the 911 operator earlier, we stopped it right before, but earlier say she's trying to gain control and get information from Lacy, right? The 911 operator?
Witness (04:51:21):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (04:51:22):
And she's telling you, "You need to take a deep breath." She's trying to communicate, right?
Witness (04:51:28):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (04:51:30):
And did you hear Lacy say, "God, help me. Help me, Jesus." And then the 911 operator again said, "I need you to take a deep breath."
Witness (04:51:42):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (04:51:42):
Okay. And then after that, did you hear the 911 operator tell Lacy that, "I've called in for dispatch?" Okay?
Witness (04:51:53):
Yes, I heard that.
Mr. Steel (04:51:54):
And dispatch, jurors probably know, but dispatch would be... The help that she's calling for is on the way, police, EMTs, whomever, right?
Witness (04:52:03):
Correct.
Mr. Steel (04:52:04):
And dispatch just means that they're told, "Go to this scene." They're ordered or encouraged to go to this area, to this address, right?
Witness (04:52:13):
Yes, sir.
Mr. Steel (04:52:13):
All right. And then after that, and we'll play it again if you need to hear it, but the 911 operator then brings up the gun again and says, "Where is the gun now?" Do you remember that?
Witness (04:52:24):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (04:52:25):
And then Lacy said, "I don't know. I think, I think..." The 911 operator said, "You took it." Do you remember hearing that?
Witness (04:52:34):
I don't remember hearing that.
Mr. Steel (04:52:35):
We'll play it. We'll play it. But this is what I'm going to ask you. Did you hear the 91... If you don't mind listening for this, okay? We're listening for whatever you hear. And then Lacy answered, "No, I don't have it in my hand. It's still downstairs. I haven't touched it. It's downstairs. Do you need me to get the gun?" And then he says, "Yes?" Like a question. "Yes?" Did you hear that?
Witness (04:52:57):
I did hear that.
Mr. Steel (04:52:57):
Okay. We're going to play it just for completeness, if that's okay with the court. And then the 911 operator right after that says, it's basically, it's for your safety, and then she goes onto a new topic, "What is Mr. Akers' name or what is his name?" And then Lacy said, "Daniel Akers." Fair?
Witness (04:53:16):
Fair.
Mr. Steel (04:53:18):
All right. With the court's permission, can we start at 4:24 and stop, if you don't mind, at 5:02, if that's okay?
911 Operator (04:53:51):
[inaudible 04:53:51] dispatch, okay? Where is the gun now.
Lacy Boles (04:53:51):
[inaudible 04:53:56].
911 Operator (04:54:00):
[inaudible 04:54:00]. What's his name?
Lacy Boles (04:54:00):
Daniel Akers. Daniel Akers.
911 Operator (04:54:00):
[inaudible 04:54:06].
Mr. Steel (04:54:06):
Stop at 5:02, Your Honor. And just to recap, the 911 operator again asked, "Where's the gun now?" You heard that part?
Witness (04:54:31):
Yes, sir.
Mr. Steel (04:54:32):
And then you heard Ms. Boles or Lacy say, "I don't know. I don't know." The 911 operator said something to the effect of, "You took it?" Just asking a question.
Witness (04:54:41):
I believe she said, "Did you take it?"
Mr. Steel (04:54:43):
Okay. And then Lacy says, "No, I don't have it in my hand. It's still downstairs. I haven't touched it." Did you hear that?
Witness (04:54:49):
I did hear that.
Mr. Steel (04:54:50):
And then Lacy states, "It's downstairs. You need me to get the gun?" And then asked like a question, "Yes?" And her voice kind of rises. Did you hear that?
Witness (04:54:59):
I heard that.
Mr. Steel (04:55:02):
Okay. And then 911 operator says, "I need you to deal with it. It's for your safety," and then goes on to "What's his name?" And then Lacy says, "Daniel Akers."
Witness (04:55:10):
I believe the 911 operator said, "Do what is best for your safety."
Mr. Steel (04:55:14):
Okay.
Witness (04:55:15):
Not deal with it.
Mr. Steel (04:55:17):
We'll listen to it again, but then we'll move on. Whatever you heard is fine, and then the jurors can determine.
Witness (04:55:23):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (04:55:23):
Your Honor, can we just play from, we'll say 4:40 to 5: 02 with the court's permission. Thank you, sir.
Lacy Boles (04:55:31):
[inaudible 04:55:32].
911 Operator (04:55:31):
Lacy, I need you to do what's best for his safety. What's his name?
Lacy Boles (04:55:31):
Daniel Akers. Daniel Akers.
911 Operator (04:55:31):
Daniel Akers.
Mr. Steel (04:55:36):
You can stop the 5:02. And you heard, sir, something to the effect of the 911 operator said, "I need you to do what is best for your safety," or something like that?
Witness (04:56:09):
Yeah. She says, "Lacy, I need you to do whatever's best for your safety."
Mr. Steel (04:56:11):
And they're talking about the gun?
Witness (04:56:13):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (04:56:13):
Okay. All right. So in that passage, since we started up again after the break, Lacy is saying that she did try to take the gun out of Mr. Akers' hand. You heard that?
Witness (04:56:26):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (04:56:27):
And then later the 911 operator said, "Where's the gun now?" And Lacy explains it's downstairs, meaning where Mr. Akers is, that's how you understand downstairs, right?
Witness (04:56:38):
That's fair.
Mr. Steel (04:56:39):
And then the 911 operator says, and I'm just using your words, whatever the jurors hear, the jurors hear, and we respect whatever they find, right?
Witness (04:56:49):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (04:56:50):
That's why we're here.
Witness (04:56:52):
Exactly.
Mr. Steel (04:56:53):
But the 911 operator is asking about the gun and Lacy's asking, "Do you need me to get the gun?" And the 911 operator said something like, according to you, I'm not saying it's accurate, but just do what's best for your safety. Something like that.
Witness (04:57:08):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (04:57:09):
Okay. So when you met with Lacy on March 5th of 2020 on the video audio recording that the jurors heard?
Witness (04:57:22):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (04:57:23):
The interview, interrogation, whatever you want to call it, you told Lacy, I think, and please correct me if I'm wrong, you told her she was never asked by the 911 operator to get the gun.
Witness (04:57:36):
That's correct.
Mr. Steel (04:57:37):
Do you remember something like that? But on here, we do hear, even under your ears, and I'm not criticizing, I'm using your analysis, the 911 operator did say, when Lacy said, "Do you need me to go downstairs and get the gun? Do you need me to get the gun?" "Yes?" She did say, according to what you heard, "Do whatever's best for your safety," or whatever, right?
Witness (04:58:01):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (04:58:03):
All right. Now, we have, I believe, the 911 call that we heard starting where Lacy is telling the child, "Go upstairs." Remember we discussed that before lunch?
Witness (04:58:24):
Yes, sir.
Mr. Steel (04:58:25):
And we know, at least, I shouldn't say we know, the evidence seems to point to the fact that Lacy's had blood on her hands when she went to the room, her upstairs bedroom, to get the cell phone. Is that true?
Witness (04:58:38):
That is true.
Mr. Steel (04:58:39):
So in order to make the call, a person first needs a cell phone, right?
Witness (04:58:43):
Correct.
Mr. Steel (04:58:44):
And if Lacy did not have the cell phone with her in the basement area, I'll call it, or the downstairs area where Mr. Akers, God forbid, is going to lay, if she didn't have a cell phone there and Mr. Akers shoots himself or she shoots him, however, the blood coming out of his body, God forbid, Lacy has blood on her potentially at that time, right?
Witness (04:59:08):
That's correct.
Mr. Steel (04:59:09):
If she interacted with his body, right?
Witness (04:59:12):
That's correct, sir.
Mr. Steel (04:59:13):
And then if she needed her cell phone to call 911, she would go up the first flight, then you get the landing, go up the second flight where the upstairs bedroom areas are, and then grab the phone, and there's a corresponding blood smear transfer?
Witness (04:59:28):
Yes. It's on the window sill near the...
Mr. Steel (04:59:31):
Near where the phone is kept.
Witness (04:59:32):
I don't know where she kept the phone, I just know there's a smear going up the stairs on the railing and there's also a smear on the windowsill.
Mr. Steel (04:59:39):
So from what we pieced together through the 911 call, through the interviews, through the physical evidence of the photographs, Lacy is now in the basement with Mr. Akers, right?
Witness (04:59:57):
Correct.
Mr. Steel (04:59:58):
She says that, she admits that, right?
Witness (05:00:01):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (05:00:02):
Mr. Akers suffers, however he suffered, but he suffers a gunshot wound, a fatal gunshot wound, right?
Witness (05:00:07):
Yes, sir.
Mr. Steel (05:00:07):
There's massive amounts, this is my word, I'm not saying it couldn't be more, but there's a lot of blood, true?
Witness (05:00:13):
That's fair.
Mr. Steel (05:00:15):
And Lacy somehow interacts with that blood, right?
Witness (05:00:18):
That's fair.
Mr. Steel (05:00:19):
And then she goes upstairs, sequencing, according to her and according to the evidence, and gets the phone, and she has blood on her, right?
Witness (05:00:28):
Yes, sir.
Ray Lale (05:00:28):
Object to that. The question according to her is fine. It's proper. According to the evidence, the evidence is something that the defendant said. She says, "I went upstairs to get my phone." But that's speculation for this witness to say whether or not that's true, that's up to the jury to believe. Mr. Steel could ask, "Is that what she said?" And that's fine, but that's not a fact at issue that's been proven. That's for the jury to decide and to assume that's a fact or ask this witness if that's what happened would be speculation. And ask, "Did she say that?" and that's it, he's limited to that.
Witness (05:01:04):
All right. Free to respond if you like.
Mr. Steel (05:01:07):
I'll just re-ask the question a different way. So one way that that fits into evidence is if Lacy's telling the truth, right?
Witness (05:01:16):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (05:01:17):
And the second way is you've seen all the pictures of the scene, right, from December 22, 2019?
Witness (05:01:24):
Correct.
Mr. Steel (05:01:25):
And there's cast off blood going from the body where Mr. Akers is towards the wall, or there's blood, a seaming of blood, true?
Witness (05:01:35):
I wouldn't call it cast off, I'm not a blood expert. I know there's blood on the wall by the door. There's blood going up the railing, and then there's blood upstairs on the window sill.
Mr. Steel (05:01:48):
And there may be blood other places. I'm not limiting.
Witness (05:01:50):
Yes, sir.
Mr. Steel (05:01:52):
But that is also consistent with what Lacy said. Fair to say?
Witness (05:01:55):
Fair. Yes, sir.
Mr. Steel (05:01:56):
Now, so Lacy's downstairs with Mr. Akers and God forbid, he suffers a wound and then the evidence, whatever the jury is finding the evidence, then she's upstairs in her bedroom to grab the cell phone, true?
Witness (05:02:14):
I don't know where she got her cell phone from, sir.
Mr. Steel (05:02:17):
Okay. But that's... Okay. According to Lacy, that's where the cell phone was.
Witness (05:02:20):
If that's according to Lacy, then yes, the evidence matches.
Mr. Steel (05:02:22):
And there's blood evidence that matches, I think you said.
Witness (05:02:26):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (05:02:27):
Okay. So now we have Lacy downstairs and upstairs. That's all I'm trying to do here. True?
Witness (05:02:34):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (05:02:34):
And then we know from the 911 call that Lacy's asking a child to go upstairs, right?
Witness (05:02:43):
I don't want to presume it's a child. She tells somebody, "Go upstairs."
Mr. Steel (05:02:46):
That's fine.
Witness (05:02:47):
It's evident.
Mr. Steel (05:02:48):
So based upon that, do you know whether Lacy is also not in her bedroom anymore on the 911 call?
Witness (05:02:56):
I believe that's in the beginning of the 911 call.
Mr. Steel (05:02:58):
Yeah, that's true. It's right at the beginning. We listened to it earlier.
Witness (05:03:03):
Yes. So now I believe she's now upstairs.
Mr. Steel (05:03:06):
But when she's telling the child... Excuse me. When she's saying, when Lacy's being heard, saying, "Go upstairs, go upstairs, please go upstairs," at about 1:25, the beginning of the recording?
Witness (05:03:18):
Yes, the beginning of the call.
Mr. Steel (05:03:22):
You're not saying Lacy's not downstairs, are you? I'm not saying with Mr. Akers, but you're not saying she's not on that landing or somewhere?
Witness (05:03:30):
I have no idea where she's at at that point.
Mr. Steel (05:03:32):
She could be out of the bedroom at that point. We don't know.
Witness (05:03:34):
Out of the bedroom where Mr. Akers...
Mr. Steel (05:03:37):
No, the bedroom upstairs.
Witness (05:03:39):
The bedroom upstairs. I don't know where she's at in the house when she says that.
Mr. Steel (05:03:44):
Okay. Now, I'd like to go into when Lacy tells the 911 operator, "I tried to get the gun. I tried to get the gun," something like that. And I'll give you the term if you need it, but do you know what I'm talking about?
Witness (05:04:00):
Yes, sir.
Mr. Steel (05:04:00):
"I was trying to take the gun out of his hand." That's consistent with her statement as well, true?
Witness (05:04:07):
Which statement?
Mr. Steel (05:04:08):
That she was trying to stop Mr. Akers from...
Witness (05:04:13):
What she told me, yes.
Mr. Steel (05:04:14):
Okay. You do know she told Detective Ogden that at the hospital, did you?
Witness (05:04:23):
I believe it was something similar.
Mr. Steel (05:04:26):
Okay. And on the 911 call?
Witness (05:04:27):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (05:04:28):
All right. Now, I want to go through 5:12, I believe, until 6:05. And this is, again, the 911 call. It's state's exhibit number two. If you can listen to it and tell us whether, now we know that Lacy is in her bedroom, that's where I'm looking for, but if you could just listen to the whole thing then help us, okay? Your Honor, can we play 5:12 to 6:05?
Judge (05:04:58):
Yes.
Lacy Boles (05:04:58):
[inaudible 05:05:09].
Mr. Steel (05:06:08):
Okay. And on here, Lacy informed the 911 operator, according to state's exhibit number two, that she's actually in her bedroom, and you know that to be the upstairs bedroom, true?
Witness (05:06:20):
Yes, sir.
Mr. Steel (05:06:21):
And a child woke up.
Witness (05:06:23):
That's correct.
Mr. Steel (05:06:29):
Okay. The next one is, I want you to listen to whether Lacy leaves that bedroom, that upstairs bedroom, and goes downstairs. Okay? If you can help with that.
Witness (05:06:40):
Yes, sir.
Mr. Steel (05:06:41):
And this is going to be 6:05 to 6:55 with the court's permission.
Judge (05:06:45):
Yes, sir.
Lacy Boles (05:06:45):
[inaudible 05:06:51].
Mr. Steel (05:07:18):
And it stopped, Your Honor, at 6: 55. Detective, did you hear in that section of state's exhibit number two, the 911 call, where the 911 operator asked Lacy to see if it was safe for her to unlock the front door?
Witness (05:08:04):
Yes, I did.
Mr. Steel (05:08:05):
And did you hear Lacy said that... Well, first, the 911 operator asked, "Is the door locked?" And Lacy said that Mr. Akers locked the door. Do you remember that?
Witness (05:08:17):
Yes. "He locked the door behind him," I believe is what she said, or something to that effect.
Mr. Steel (05:08:21):
Say again?
Witness (05:08:21):
I think she said something to the effect, "He locked the door, unlocked the door, locked the door."
Mr. Steel (05:08:25):
And then the 911 operator asked Lacy if it's safe for her to go unlock the door for the police initial responders, right?
Witness (05:08:33):
That's correct.
Mr. Steel (05:08:34):
And Lacy said, "Yes, I can do that," and then reported that, "My door is unlocked." Did you hear that?
Witness (05:08:40):
Yes, I did.
Mr. Steel (05:08:41):
So at this point, Lacy then, according to 911 call, she was in the bedroom upstairs, her bedroom, with the baby, and now she's on what I'll call one flight down the entrance to the house and unlocks the door according to her. True?
Witness (05:09:00):
That's fair to say.
Mr. Steel (05:09:02):
And she turned on the porch light. They talked about that. Is that true?
Witness (05:09:06):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (05:09:06):
Okay. And in fact, you know from studying the case and the photographs, the porch light was on?
Witness (05:09:13):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (05:09:14):
And if you know, and if you don't know, just say, "I don't know," the front door was open or Lacy was there when law enforcement arrived.
Witness (05:09:21):
The front door was unlocked, yes.
Mr. Steel (05:09:23):
All right. So now we have Lacy at the bottom, because she interacts with Mr. Akers, then she's in a bedroom to get the phone potentially, right?
Witness (05:09:37):
Potentially, yes.
Mr. Steel (05:09:38):
So we go from the bottom of the floor to the highest floor, I know there's only two levels, but right?
Witness (05:09:43):
Yes, sir.
Mr. Steel (05:09:44):
And then we have her telling somebody, "Please go upstairs," which you said she doesn't have to be in the bedroom, you don't know where she is.
Witness (05:09:53):
That's correct.
Mr. Steel (05:09:54):
And then we have Ms. Boles back in the bedroom or in the bedroom she says, a baby just woke up, right?
Witness (05:10:00):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (05:10:01):
And then we have Ms. Boles or Lacy downstairs where the main entrance is to come in the house, the front door area, unlocks the door and opens the porch light.
Witness (05:10:13):
Correct.
Mr. Steel (05:10:14):
So we have her up and down a couple of times between the basement floor once, all the way at the bottom, and then somewhere in the bedroom and the porch area, the front door area.
Witness (05:10:28):
I would disagree with you, sir.
Mr. Steel (05:10:29):
Explain.
Witness (05:10:30):
I have her going up once when she goes up, then she's on the phone with the dispatcher. She never says that she goes downstairs, she says she's in the room with her babies. Then she's asked to go unlock the door. That's what I hear on the tape.
Mr. Steel (05:10:49):
Okay. And what do you reconcile about, "Please go upstairs, please go upstairs."
Witness (05:10:56):
That's at the same point of the 911 call, it's at the beginning of the 911 call.
Mr. Steel (05:11:00):
Right, but...
Witness (05:11:02):
We don't know where her cell phone was, sir.
Mr. Steel (05:11:03):
But she told you it's... Do you have any evidence it wasn't on the windowsill?
Witness (05:11:09):
I have no evidence it was on the windowsill. And I don't recall her telling me it was on the windowsill.
Mr. Steel (05:11:12):
Do you have any evidence it was not on the windowsill?
Witness (05:11:14):
I do not.
Mr. Steel (05:11:14):
In her bedroom?
Witness (05:11:16):
I do not.
Mr. Steel (05:11:18):
Okay. After that, with the porch light and the door unlocked, stopped at 6: 55, I'd like to continue from 6:55 to 7:22, 7:22, if that's okay with the court. Thank you.
Lacy Boles (05:11:47):
[inaudible 05:11:47].
Speaker 10 (05:11:47):
It's that same IT problem.
Judge (05:12:30):
All right, we'll get IT down here and we'll take a break. [inaudible 05:13:37].
Judge Dean Bucci (05:19:25):
Let's resume.
Mr. Steel (05:19:30):
Just to orient again, was it your position when you spoke with Lacy on March 5, 2020, when you were questioning her with what the jurors saw, the video-
Witness (05:19:49):
Yes, sir.
Mr. Steel (05:19:52):
... that she was always in the upstairs bedroom and didn't go downstairs to try to help Mr. Akers. Was that what you were asking her?
Witness (05:20:01):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (05:20:03):
Okay. I'd like to play where we got interrupted, I guess, 6:05 to 6:55, if that's okay with the court.
Audio: Lacy Boles (05:20:45):
[inaudible 05:20:46].
Audio: 911 Operator (05:20:45):
[inaudible 05:20:46].
Mr. Steel (05:21:05):
And on that segment of State's Exhibit Number 2, the 911 call, the 911 operator is asking Lacy to, same thing, take a deep breath to try to speak, communicate, right?
Witness (05:21:17):
Correct.
Mr. Steel (05:21:17):
And then the 911 operator asked Lacy, "Is your front door unlocked?" And Lacy explains, "No, he came in, locked it, locked it back. He just had a key made this morning."
Witness (05:21:31):
Correct.
Mr. Steel (05:21:32):
And then the 911 operator said, "Lacy, is it safe for you to go unlock the door for the responders?"
Witness (05:21:39):
Correct.
Mr. Steel (05:21:40):
And she said yes?
Witness (05:21:41):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (05:21:42):
And the 911 operator said, "Can you turn your front porch light on?" And Lacy said, "Yes."
Witness (05:21:48):
Correct.
Mr. Steel (05:21:49):
You heard all that?
Witness (05:21:50):
I did.
Mr. Steel (05:21:51):
And then Lacy said, "Yes, I can. My door is unlocked. Oh God, help me." And then the 911 operator said, "Lacy, take a deep breath. Your door is unlocked." And Lacy confirmed, "Yes." You heard that?
Witness (05:22:04):
I did.
Mr. Steel (05:22:05):
And then the 911 operator asked, "Did you turn your front porch light on?" And that's right when we stopped and Lacy said, "Yes." You heard all that?
Witness (05:22:13):
Yes, sir.
Mr. Steel (05:22:14):
And that's corroborated by the first responders who came on the scene. It seems like the light was on, you said, and the door was open?
Witness (05:22:21):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (05:22:22):
All right. Now, after that, it's your position when speaking with Lacy on March 5, 2020, that she didn't go back downstairs to where Mr. Akers was. Is that fair to say?
Witness (05:22:41):
That is fair to say.
Mr. Steel (05:22:45):
And she said she did go back downstairs.
Witness (05:22:49):
I believe she said she went down there and tried to do CPR, or went back down there and got the gun because the dispatcher told her to.
Mr. Steel (05:22:59):
Right. So yes, she went back downstairs-
Witness (05:23:02):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (05:23:02):
... where Ms. Akers was? Okay. And you don't hear that on the 911 call?
Witness (05:23:08):
I do not.
Mr. Steel (05:23:09):
All right. I want to play the next segment, which is, we'll start right here at 6:55 and let's go until 7:22, if that's okay with the court. Your Honor, is that okay?
Judge Dean Bucci (05:23:22):
It is okay.
Mr. Steel (05:23:22):
Thank you.
Audio: Lacy Boles (05:23:23):
[inaudible 05:23:39].
Audio: 911 Operator (05:23:23):
[inaudible 05:23:38].
Mr. Steel (05:24:00):
And did you hear that, that Lacy saying, "This cannot be real. Please help me," something to that effect?
Witness (05:24:06):
Yes, sir.
Mr. Steel (05:24:07):
And then the 911 operator asked Lacy, "Who's all in the house?" Do you remember that?
Witness (05:24:12):
I do.
Mr. Steel (05:24:13):
And then Lacy explains that it's her, her oldest child who's six, and she mentions Gage.
Witness (05:24:19):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (05:24:20):
And then she said, "I also have Emerson who's three, and Daniel who's two, and Daniel and Emerson just woke up and they're in the bedroom"?
Witness (05:24:28):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (05:24:28):
All right. And then that's pretty much where we stopped it at 7:22. Fair to say?
Witness (05:24:35):
Fair to say, sir.
Mr. Steel (05:24:36):
All right. Now, if we continue?
Audio: Lacy Boles (05:24:39):
[inaudible 05:24:45].
Mr. Steel (05:24:45):
Just give me one second. From 7:22, with the court's permission, to 8: 26, and then I can ask you some questions if that's okay?
Witness (05:25:04):
Yes, sir.
Mr. Steel (05:25:05):
Thank you, Your Honor.
Audio: Lacy Boles (05:25:06):
[inaudible 05:25:08].
Audio: 911 Operator (05:25:06):
[inaudible 05:25:08].
Mr. Steel (05:26:12):
Your Honor, stop at 8: 26. So in that segment, starting at 7:22, did you hear the 911 operator ask Lacy to, "Slow down. I cannot understand you. I cannot understand you"? Did you hear that part?
Witness (05:26:24):
I did.
Mr. Steel (05:26:25):
And the 911 operator said, "I know you're upset, Lacy. I'm trying to help you. I need you to take a deep breath." Did you hear that?
Witness (05:26:31):
I did.
Mr. Steel (05:26:32):
And then Lacy responded, "I don't know what to do. I'm so sorry. I don't know what to do." Did you hear that?
Witness (05:26:38):
I did.
Mr. Steel (05:26:39):
And then 911 operator told Lacy, "Lacy, it's just you and your kids that are in the residence." Did you hear that question?
Witness (05:26:45):
I did.
Mr. Steel (05:26:46):
And Lacy answered, "Yes, ma'am. Yes, ma'am. Yes, ma'am." Did you hear that?
Witness (05:26:51):
I did.
Mr. Steel (05:26:52):
And then the 911 operator said, "Okay, I want you to take deep breaths, Lacy." And then Lacy says, "Oh my God, help me. Oh my God, I'm trying. I'm trying." Did you hear that?
Witness (05:27:03):
I did.
Mr. Steel (05:27:05):
And then 911 operator said, "Breathe," or, "Lacy, breathe." Did you hear that?
Witness (05:27:08):
I did.
Mr. Steel (05:27:09):
And then Lacy states, "Dan, please. He's not breathing. He's not breathing. He's just not breathing." Did you hear that?
Witness (05:27:18):
I did.
Mr. Steel (05:27:20):
Where is Lacy Boles? Did you hear her voice change when she said, "Dan, please, he's not breathing. He's not breathing. He's not breathing"?
Witness (05:27:30):
I don't know where she's at.
Mr. Steel (05:27:32):
But did you hear the voice change?
Witness (05:27:34):
I hear a lot of voice changes in her throughout the 911 call.
Mr. Steel (05:27:39):
Okay. And thank you. But at that particular moment, did you hear Lacy Boles' voice change at all?
Witness (05:27:48):
She got more hysterical.
Mr. Steel (05:27:50):
Okay. Do you know at that point whether Lacy Boles was downstairs in the room with Dan Akers?
Witness (05:27:55):
I don't believe she was.
Mr. Steel (05:27:56):
Why?
Witness (05:27:57):
I believe she was still upstairs.
Mr. Steel (05:27:59):
But tell the jurors why.
Witness (05:28:00):
I never heard any movement on the 911 call.
Mr. Steel (05:28:04):
Did you ever hear any movement when Lacy was in the bedroom and then we go to the front door?
Witness (05:28:11):
No.
Mr. Steel (05:28:11):
Okay. So then explain to the jurors... And you know that happened, right?
Witness (05:28:18):
I know at some point, the front door was unlocked.
Mr. Steel (05:28:20):
Yeah. So if you didn't hear any movement at that time, tell the jurors another reason why you know that Lacy Boles was not down with Dan Akers when she's screaming, "Dan, please. He's not breathing. He's not breathing."
Witness (05:28:35):
I just didn't hear any movement on the phone call, sir.
Mr. Steel (05:28:38):
Besides that though, do you have any evidence?
Ray Lale (05:28:41):
Judge, he's answered the question. Doesn't fit Mr. Steele's theory on this cross. So he's asking him to supply another answer that might fit. He's answered the question.
Witness (05:28:55):
Can you ask the question again, sir?
Mr. Steel (05:28:56):
Yeah. Do you have any reason other than you didn't hear movement where Lacy Boles was when she's screaming, "Dan, please. He's not breathing, he's not breathing, he's not breathing"?
Witness (05:29:09):
No.
Mr. Steel (05:29:09):
Can you tell the jurors why there is a change in pattern of speech for Lacy when she's saying, "Dan, please. He's not breathing, he's not breathing, he's not breathing"? Can you explain that?
Witness (05:29:21):
I think you're asking more of an opinion question from me.
Mr. Steel (05:29:23):
I'm just saying, do you have any evidence why it changed?
Witness (05:29:26):
I have no evidence why she changed.
Mr. Steel (05:29:28):
Do you know for certain, as you sit here, that Lacy did not go in the room with Dan Akers when she's screaming, "He's not breathing, he's not breathing, he's not breathing"?
Witness (05:29:37):
I don't believe so, sir.
Mr. Steel (05:29:38):
But do you have any evidence?
Witness (05:29:40):
I do not have any evidence.
Mr. Steel (05:29:44):
Okay. And if she is in the room with Dan Akers at that point, that's consistent with what Ms. Boles told you on March 5th, 2020. Fair?
Witness (05:29:52):
Fair.
Mr. Steel (05:29:59):
We stopped at 8:26. Did you hear Lacy being asked by the 911 operator, "Lacy, do you want to do CPR?" Something to that effect. Did you hear that?
Witness (05:30:10):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (05:30:11):
And Lacy's saying, "No, ma'am, he's not breathing." Did you hear that?
Witness (05:30:14):
I did.
Mr. Steel (05:30:18):
Okay. With the court's permission, we'll just finish it it goes from 8:26 to 8:57. And here is a discussion that the first responders are on the scene, but make sure that you hear this and remember it, okay?
Witness (05:30:29):
Yes, sir.
Mr. Steel (05:30:30):
Can you start with the court's permission at 8:26, Your Honor.
Audio: Lacy Boles (05:30:32):
[inaudible 05:31:25].
Mr. Steel (05:30:32):
And the responders arrived, correct?
Witness (05:30:32):
Correct.
Mr. Steel (05:32:03):
Okay. I just want to take us back just for one moment to 7:48, with the court's permission, through 8:16, if we can, Your Honor. State's Exhibit 2.
Audio: Lacy Boles (05:32:48):
[inaudible 05:32:48].
Audio: 911 Operator (05:32:48):
[inaudible 05:33:03].
Mr. Steel (05:33:03):
Do you have any evidence of what happened to change the demeanor on that call from Lacy Boles' speech to, "Dan, please. He's not breathing, he's not breathing," the way that we just heard it?
Witness (05:33:19):
I don't know what you mean by that.
Mr. Steel (05:33:22):
Are you telling the jury that Lacy Boles did not go into that room with Dan Akers?
Witness (05:33:27):
I don't believe so, sir.
Mr. Steel (05:33:29):
I know, but do you have any evidence that she didn't?
Witness (05:33:31):
I believe I already answered that now.
Mr. Steel (05:33:33):
The answer is no, correct?
Witness (05:33:34):
Yes, sir.
Mr. Steel (05:33:37):
Lacy Boles also told you that at some point, that time, she picked up the gun and dropped it. Do you remember that?
Witness (05:33:46):
I do remember that.
Mr. Steel (05:33:48):
And that gun clearly is not in the trigger guard?
Witness (05:33:54):
No, it's actually underneath his thumb.
Mr. Steel (05:33:57):
I want you to explain everything. I promise you I won't interrupt you. Just let me ask the question.
Witness (05:34:02):
Yes, sir.
Mr. Steel (05:34:07):
You answered it, but the gun is not inside... The trigger of the gun is not attached to the person of Mr. Akers. Is that fair? It's not in his hand-
Witness (05:34:19):
No, it's not in-
Mr. Steel (05:34:20):
... typical way that a gun would be if it was about to be fired. Am I correct?
Witness (05:34:26):
So you're asking me after he fired it, or is I'm going to fire a gun, it's not typically?
Mr. Steel (05:34:31):
I'm saying where Mr. Akers, according to the photos we have, the gun... How about this, the gun is separated from his hand?
Witness (05:34:38):
It is. It's underneath his hand.
Mr. Steel (05:34:40):
And underneath is true because it's actually on the... It's like a carpeted surface, I'm going to say, and his hand is close to it, but on top of the gun.
Witness (05:34:49):
Correct.
Mr. Steel (05:34:50):
So the gun is not on top of the hand that-
Witness (05:34:52):
It's underneath his hand, yes.
Mr. Steel (05:34:53):
The hand is... underneath is relative, but clearly, the gun is touching the ground, the hand is touching the ground, but it's also touching the gun over-
Witness (05:35:02):
Yes, sir.
Mr. Steel (05:35:02):
... the top? Okay. And we have pictures and you've seen pictures of this in-
Witness (05:35:06):
Yes, sir.
Mr. Steel (05:35:07):
All right. Lacy told you though that she disturbed that gun, that she touched that gun, right?
Witness (05:35:19):
Yes, she did.
Mr. Steel (05:35:21):
And that she dropped it another time, if you remember, she threw it, but she said inconsistent things about the gun.
Witness (05:35:28):
She did.
Mr. Steel (05:35:30):
All right. What evidence do you have that Lacy did not touch that gun and drop that gun during the time that she's getting that... I think you said hysterical, but it's a 7:55 on the 911 call. What evidence do you have that that did not happen at that time?
Witness (05:35:47):
I have no evidence of that.
Mr. Steel (05:35:49):
All right. The ground, the carpet in the room where Mr. Akers is going to be found?
Witness (05:35:59):
Yes, sir.
Mr. Steel (05:36:01):
Was that carpet changed when you get there? Everyone knows you're not there December 22, 2019. Was that carpeting changed when you were there on March 5, 2020? And when I say you're there, I'm including your coworkers.
Witness (05:36:14):
Yes, I believe it was. I would have to go back and look at pictures and compare to be 100%, but I do believe it was.
Mr. Steel (05:36:21):
Okay. And that makes sense, right? I mean-
Witness (05:36:24):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (05:36:26):
It's a hard stain to get out. Is that fair to say?
Witness (05:36:29):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (05:36:29):
And same with walls, right? Painting walls and things like that can happen after there's been blood in the room, right? I mean, that's not abnormal is what I'm asking you.
Witness (05:36:45):
No, it's not abnormal.
Mr. Steel (05:36:47):
Okay. And again, we're there about 60 plus days later?
Witness (05:36:49):
Correct.
Mr. Steel (05:36:52):
Do you know whether... I know it changed for you, so you couldn't do this, I know that, but do you know whether anybody ever suggested, thought about, or attempted to take the... You remember the cup, the McDonald's cup that's on the floor near the boot, the left work boot of Mr. Akers? It's toppled over?
Witness (05:37:15):
Yes, sir.
Mr. Steel (05:37:16):
Did you ever discuss with anyone why they didn't or why they did take a similar cup, McDonald's cup, put the lid on with the straw, put water and ice in it, and just drop it from your waist or something? Do you ever ask them if they ever thought about doing that?
Witness (05:37:34):
No.
Mr. Steel (05:37:36):
Did you ever notice that the cup on the bottom doesn't have any defect in it? And I'm talking about December 22, 2019.
Witness (05:37:46):
No, I didn't.
Mr. Steel (05:37:48):
Okay. Do you have any evidence that cup wasn't placed on the ground before Mr. Akers suffered the fatal bullet?
Witness (05:38:00):
There's no evidence.
Mr. Steel (05:38:02):
Do you know whether that cup was toppled over accidentally, just kicked or pushed, or I don't know, fell? Do you know?
Witness (05:38:09):
I don't.
Mr. Steel (05:38:10):
How about the garbage? Look at me... No, that's wrong. The McDonald's bag. I'm not calling McDonald's garbage. The McDonald's bag, do you know whether that was placed on the ground before Mr. Akers suffered the fatal shot?
Witness (05:38:23):
I do not.
Mr. Steel (05:38:26):
And the bag was never collected. Do you realize that?
Witness (05:38:28):
I do.
Mr. Steel (05:38:29):
And that's not your fault, but is that something you may have thought was interesting to collect?
Witness (05:38:35):
I would've collected it.
Mr. Steel (05:38:36):
Right. Because all this stuff is potential evidence, right?
Witness (05:38:39):
Yes, sir.
Mr. Steel (05:38:39):
Including the cup, and the keys, and everything, right?
Witness (05:38:43):
Correct.
Mr. Steel (05:38:45):
All right. Same with the hat. I'm not excluding the hat, but same thing?
Witness (05:38:48):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (05:38:49):
All right. You have no evidence that the hat wasn't either on the floor the day before, or that day, or you have no idea when it got there. Is that true?
Witness (05:39:02):
It is true.
Mr. Steel (05:39:02):
Okay. I want to talk to you, if you don't mind, about on the 911 call and your discussion with Lacy about get the gun. There was a discussion about the gun and is it safe? Do you remember that?
Witness (05:39:30):
Yes. The 911 operator asked her if she was safe, or something to that effect.
Mr. Steel (05:39:36):
And Lacy told you that she believed that she was instructed, that may be my word, but to get the gun-
Witness (05:39:42):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (05:39:43):
... from the 911 operator? Okay. And you have no evidence that she didn't go downstairs afterwards as we just heard to get the gun, did you?
Witness (05:39:53):
I don't believe she did, but no.
Mr. Steel (05:39:54):
I know. But let's talk about evidence first and we can talk about your belief.
Witness (05:39:57):
Yes, sir. No.
Mr. Steel (05:39:59):
Am I correct there's no evidence that she did not go down and touch that gun?
Witness (05:40:02):
Correct.
Mr. Steel (05:40:03):
So I'm correct?
Witness (05:40:04):
Yes, sir.
Mr. Steel (05:40:04):
All right. Now, we talked about your discussion with Lacy about the gun, and you said the 911 operator never asked you to do that. I'm going to move on. We discussed that, fair to say?
Witness (05:40:20):
Fair to say.
Mr. Steel (05:40:21):
And I know it's not your opinion that that happened, but you're an honest person and you're saying yes, it's documented 911 call, whatever she did, she did, it's discussed. Fair?
Witness (05:40:32):
Fair.
Mr. Steel (05:40:32):
All right. I want to go to the next issue that you discussed with Lacy and the 911 call, joining them together. It was your position that she was always upstairs in her bedroom, except when she opened the door for the first responders. Fair to say?
Witness (05:40:51):
That is fair.
Mr. Steel (05:40:52):
And that's what you told her, right?
Witness (05:40:53):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (05:40:54):
But you're fair, and you told the jurors, actually, you don't know if she went downstairs to where Mr. Akers was while on the call?
Witness (05:41:00):
I said there was no evidence that she did.
Mr. Steel (05:41:02):
That she did not?
Witness (05:41:03):
She did not.
Mr. Steel (05:41:04):
So she may have, you don't know?
Witness (05:41:06):
No, sir. I wasn't there.
Mr. Steel (05:41:07):
But am I correct?
Witness (05:41:09):
You're correct.
Mr. Steel (05:41:09):
So I know you told her that, but the truth is she could have gone down there you're not saying she didn't?
Witness (05:41:14):
Like I said, sir, I didn't hear any movement on the 911 call.
Mr. Steel (05:41:19):
But it could have happened?
Witness (05:41:20):
It could have.
Mr. Steel (05:41:21):
Okay. And we talked about when it could have happened when the hysterics came in. Fair? What I played for, I think, two or three times already.
Witness (05:41:30):
So you're asking, sir... Can you repeat your question?
Mr. Steel (05:41:33):
Yeah. I played, I think it was at... Let me just check it. Approximately 7:55, the, "Dan, please. He's not breathing, he's not breathing." I'm not going to play it again, but you know what I'm talking about.
Witness (05:41:51):
Yes. Yes.
Mr. Steel (05:41:52):
It could have happened at that time, true?
Witness (05:41:56):
It could have.
Mr. Steel (05:41:57):
Okay. And you challenged Lacy on that, but we discussed that. I want to go to another one. Okay? Another issue. The blood in the sink. And I think we discussed it... You asked Lacy a couple of times during the March 5th, 2020 interview with her, or interrogation, whatever you want to call it, that she had to have washed her hands because there's blood in the sink, and we showed the jurors the pictures. Fair to say?
Witness (05:42:26):
Yes, sir.
Mr. Steel (05:42:27):
But you're also a fair man, and you acknowledge today you really don't know if the mother of Lacy had blood on her hands and washed her hands, or if the child, Gage, I just used Gage because he's six, washed his hand. You don't know, right?
Witness (05:42:41):
No, sir.
Mr. Steel (05:42:41):
So maybe Lacy was telling the truth. We don't know because, not you, but law enforcement didn't really report what was going on at that time. Fair to say?
Witness (05:42:53):
Fair.
Mr. Steel (05:42:54):
And that's because they didn't take pictures, videos, notes. We don't know who washed their hands in that sink. Fair?
Witness (05:43:01):
That's fair.
Mr. Steel (05:43:03):
Okay. So that was another issue you discussed with Lacy that the jurors heard on March 5 of 2020. The next one was blood on the holster. I think we discussed that too, but you discussed that with Lacy on March 5, 2020, and you got information that the presumptive test came up negative. That's what you were told.
Ray Lale (05:43:23):
This has all been asked and answered. All of this. I hope it's a summary toward an end. I hope all there's a light at the end of the tunnel. This has all been asked.
Judge Dean Bucci (05:43:30):
Okay. I think you did ask that question.
Mr. Steel (05:43:40):
Okay. The McDonald's cup and the bag, we talked about that. It may have been placed... And the hat and the keys. I'm really not trying to ignore this.
Ray Lale (05:43:49):
Again, asked and answered. Could the hat have been there a week ago? Yes. The bag, could it have just... Yes. All this has been asked.
Judge Dean Bucci (05:43:56):
All right. Go ahead and answer the question.
Mr. Steel (05:44:00):
You discussed that with Lacy, on the March 5th, 2020 interview?
Witness (05:44:05):
About the hat?
Mr. Steel (05:44:06):
Yeah. And the cup and the bag.
Witness (05:44:08):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (05:44:08):
Okay. And we discussed that.
Witness (05:44:11):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (05:44:11):
We don't know how it's got there, right? Fair?
Witness (05:44:14):
Fair.
Mr. Steel (05:44:15):
Okay. And then the next issue that you discussed with Lacy on March 5th, 2020 was you said that Dan Akers, according to your information, was drug tested for the airport. Do you remember that?
Witness (05:44:36):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (05:44:37):
And she was saying she doesn't believe that to be true. Do you remember that conversation with her?
Witness (05:44:42):
I think... Yes.
Mr. Steel (05:44:45):
And you were saying, "Well, he was drug tested, but that was years ago when he failed." But you're talking about recently. Remember that communication?
Witness (05:44:55):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (05:44:55):
All right. And the jurors heard all that with the March 5th, 2020 interview that they heard. Right?
Witness (05:45:01):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (05:45:01):
Okay. I want to ask you whether you at any time, at any time, when looking at Mr. Akers' phone, realized that he was asking others about the drug test at the airport. Do you remember that?
Ray Lale (05:45:21):
This is beyond the scope of this witness's ability to testify. The phone was unlocked after this witness left the department. Mr. Steele knows the timeline. He's just seeking to introduce testimony that this witness can't possibly answer in his narrative format by asking cross-examination questions. The phone was unlocked after this witness's involvement with the case ended.
Judge Dean Bucci (05:45:46):
All right. You can ask about the evidence.
Mr. Steel (05:45:48):
Okay. You already made it clear when you first started testifying that you reviewed currently Mr. Akers' phone, right?
Witness (05:45:56):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (05:45:56):
Yeah. So I'm asking you, at any time, when you reviewed his phone, do you remember seeing conversation with Mr. Akers, asking other people that he's concerned about failing the drug test for the airport? Do you remember?
Witness (05:46:11):
I don't remember those conversations.
Mr. Steel (05:46:13):
I'm going to show you a couple of things, okay? Just tell us if you remember this. Your Honor, I've marked this Ms. Boles number 121. May I approach?
Judge Dean Bucci (05:47:05):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (05:47:05):
May I approach you?
Witness (05:47:07):
Yes, sir.
Mr. Steel (05:47:09):
Show you what... It's a two-page document. It has a paperclip on it.
Witness (05:47:16):
Yes, sir.
Mr. Steel (05:47:17):
If you could just read it and tell us whether you recognize that as communication from Mr. Akers' cell phone.
Witness (05:47:40):
Yeah, I believe it is from his phone. I don't remember seeing these messages.
Mr. Steel (05:47:44):
Say it one more time.
Witness (05:47:45):
I don't remember seeing these messages, sir.
Mr. Steel (05:47:48):
What did you say about his cell phone?
Witness (05:47:49):
Oh, it appears to be from his phone number to a Chris.
Mr. Steel (05:47:53):
Okay. Do you feel comfortable testifying about that?
Witness (05:47:59):
No, I do not, because I didn't see these messages, sir.
Mr. Steel (05:48:01):
All right. Is there another person that you know about that downloaded his entire phone?
Witness (05:48:10):
I believe the state has downloaded his entire phone.
Mr. Steel (05:48:13):
And then they give it to us.
Witness (05:48:15):
Yes. And I believe they have another witness for that.
Mr. Steel (05:48:18):
Okay. All right. Don't tell me what's in those exhibits. I'm not going to yet to admit them, but does that refresh your memory that Mr. Akers was concerned about failing drug tests?
Witness (05:48:33):
No.
Mr. Steel (05:48:33):
Okay. You just never seen it?
Witness (05:48:35):
I never saw that. No, sir.
Mr. Steel (05:48:36):
All right.
Ray Lale (05:48:40):
I'm going to ask to strike the last question because you see what's happening. Mr. Steele cannot bring this evidence in, so he interjects the evidence in the format of his question. Now, is your memory refreshed on the fact that Mr. Akers was worried about failing drug tests? That's getting inadmissible evidence in front of the jury. It's very crafty like that. He knows what he's doing. I ask that he be admonished and asked for the jury instruction striking that answer, because he knows it's inadmissible. The guy already said he couldn't remember anything about that, that he'd never seen it before.
Judge Dean Bucci (05:49:10):
Well, I'll just remind the jury that the questions asked by the lawyers are not evidence. Proceed.
Mr. Steel (05:49:19):
With regards to... You talked about with Lacy that Mr. Akers was a convicted felon. Do you remember that?
Witness (05:49:31):
I believe so. I don't remember the entirety of that conversation.
Mr. Steel (05:49:34):
Okay. But the jurors heard-
Witness (05:49:36):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (05:49:37):
... the communication that was played for them? And you looked into his prior conviction, I presume. Is that true?
Witness (05:49:46):
I read his criminal history, yes.
Mr. Steel (05:49:48):
Yeah. And you knew that Mr. Akers... or did you know, I guess, on his phone was concerned that he would be looking at a probation revocation and being sentenced to prison for about four and a half years until 2024?
Witness (05:50:02):
I-
Mr. Steel (05:50:00):
... And being sentenced to prison for about four and a half years till 2024?
Witness (05:50:03):
I did not.
Mr. Steel (05:50:04):
You didn't know that either?
Witness (05:50:05):
No, sir.
Mr. Steel (05:50:06):
Even today in reviewing his phone?
Witness (05:50:09):
You're telling me for the first time, sir.
Mr. Steel (05:50:11):
Did the state ever share any of this information from his phone with you?
Witness (05:50:16):
I did have a download of his phone, yes.
Mr. Steel (05:50:21):
Okay. When you say you had a download of his phone, did anyone point out to you, "Hey, here's things of interest," or they just showed you the download?
Witness (05:50:32):
They showed me the download.
Mr. Steel (05:50:34):
The state has all the phone of Mr. Akers, you realize that?
Witness (05:50:38):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (05:50:38):
That's who gave it to you, right?
Witness (05:50:40):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (05:50:43):
Okay. Okay. Were you aware through your investigation, when you got involved, whether Mr. Akers was looking at a probation revocation in January of 2020?
Witness (05:50:57):
When I got involved in the case in February, I did not know he was looking at a probation revocation.
Mr. Steel (05:51:03):
Did you know that at any time?
Witness (05:51:07):
Until today, sir.
Mr. Steel (05:51:08):
Do you know it today?
Witness (05:51:09):
I know it today after you said it.
Mr. Steel (05:51:11):
Well, did you ever look at, in January of 2020, any of the documents that were filed in open court to revoke his probation?
Witness (05:51:22):
I did not.
Mr. Steel (05:51:22):
Okay. Do you remember talking with Lacy about the fact that Mr. Akers avoided guns? I don't know what the right word is, but do you remember telling her that?
Witness (05:52:01):
I told her that after speaking with his friends and family, that he did not carry a gun.
Mr. Steel (05:52:08):
Did you ever, from your analysis of his cell phone or otherwise, ever see that he had pictures of guns on his phone?
Witness (05:52:20):
I don't recall.
Mr. Steel (05:52:23):
Okay. All right. Fake urine, do you remember talking about that with Lacy?
Witness (05:52:29):
Yes. She claimed in her interview that there was fake urine in his car, or he had fake urine.
Mr. Steel (05:52:36):
Found by... Do you remember who found it?
Witness (05:52:40):
I do not.
Mr. Steel (05:52:41):
According to Lacy, her relative, her child?
Witness (05:52:44):
She said... I believe she said one of her children may have found it when they were cleaning out the car for her.
Mr. Steel (05:52:49):
Adult children?
Witness (05:52:50):
Adult children. Yes, sir.
Mr. Steel (05:52:51):
Did you ever speak with that adult child?
Witness (05:52:53):
I did not.
Mr. Steel (05:52:55):
To determine whether there was fake urine in the car?
Witness (05:52:57):
I did not.
Mr. Steel (05:52:58):
And when I say fake urine, I'm not saying the urine's fake. Do you know what I mean by-
Witness (05:53:02):
I know what you mean, sir. Somebody else's urine.
Mr. Steel (05:53:04):
Tell the jurors why somebody would possibly do that.
Witness (05:53:07):
To pass a drug test.
Mr. Steel (05:53:11):
Can you just explain it in more detail, if you don't mind?
Witness (05:53:14):
So they would use clean urine from somebody else and when they go to obviously give a urine sample, they use that urine instead of their own.
Mr. Steel (05:53:30):
Okay. So I believe it was you, please check it, but you wrote to Dr. Lehman in an email that Dan Akers was happy, true?
Witness (05:53:41):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (05:53:43):
But you don't tell Dr. Lehman about losing his job, right?
Witness (05:53:49):
I've already answered this, yes.
Mr. Steel (05:53:50):
Am I correct?
Witness (05:53:51):
I did not.
Mr. Steel (05:53:54):
You either didn't realize at the time about going to prison, you never told Dr. Lehman that, right?
Witness (05:53:59):
I did not.
Mr. Steel (05:54:01):
You did tell him about marital problems?
Witness (05:54:03):
I did not.
Mr. Steel (05:54:06):
Okay. Financial problems?
Witness (05:54:07):
I've already answered this.
Ray Lale (05:54:09):
Your Honor, this has been asked repeatedly. I think we're on round number three.
Judge Dean Bucci (05:54:12):
Sustained.
Mr. Steel (05:54:15):
I'd like to show you what I'll mark as Ms. Boles number 117 and 122. Thank you. Thank you. May I approach?
Judge Dean Bucci (05:55:04):
Yes, sir.
Mr. Steel (05:55:10):
I'm going to mark... I need to get the exhibit sticker, but they marked the postage. I'll make it clear. Ms. Boles, 117, Ms. Boles, 122. May I approach you?
Witness (05:55:20):
Yes, sir.
Mr. Steel (05:55:21):
Tell me... Read those. Tell me if you recognize that as messages from the phone of Mr. Daniel Akers.
Witness (05:55:43):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (05:55:46):
And yes to both of them?
Witness (05:55:47):
Yes, sir.
Mr. Steel (05:55:48):
I move for the admission. And I have to just put a sticker on it. I'll do that right now, but Ms. Boles 117 and 122.
Ray Lale (05:55:55):
I would ask that more voir dire be asked of this witness as far as his recollection. He sees... Like the last exhibit, he sees the name Daniel Akers and his phone number, so clearly purports to be possibly messages, but has this defendant seen them? Meaning, is he familiar with them at all or does he just know that they're from that phone and possibly discovered after he left Palm County Sheriff's Office? Which would mean he wouldn't be familiar with them at all. You can put an apple in front of somebody and say, "Hey, what fruit is this?" "It's an apple." They may have had no involvement with that whatsoever. I think that's what's happening here. He knows what it is, but he has no familiarity with it because it was discovered after he left.
Judge Dean Bucci (05:56:36):
Well... I heard him say he's... I'm not going to quote him, but I think he laid a sufficient foundation, so overruled.
Mr. Steel (05:56:50):
Your Honor, may I approach?
Judge Dean Bucci (05:56:51):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (05:57:02):
It was Ms. Boles 117 and 122?
Witness (05:57:09):
117, 122.
Mr. Steel (05:57:09):
Thank you, sir. May I approach you?
Witness (05:57:13):
Yes, sir.
Mr. Steel (05:57:15):
I'm going to ask the court if I can display it on the screen.
Judge Dean Bucci (05:57:21):
Yes.
Investigator (05:57:30):
Boles 117.
Mr. Steel (05:57:55):
And just to orient the jury, if you could remove... There's a sticker on it now. If you could remove the post-it from both, if you don't mind. Thank you, sir. And this is... You also looked at Lacy Boles' phone, true?
Witness (05:58:15):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (05:58:16):
And this is actually Lacy Boles' phone, the image, true?
Witness (05:58:19):
I'm sorry. Say that one more time, sir.
Mr. Steel (05:58:20):
It's also Lacy Boles' phone. This is from Lacy Boles' phone.
Witness (05:58:23):
Okay. Yes, sir.
Mr. Steel (05:58:25):
And here you recognize... You already identified them for us previously, but you have the date up here. It's an outgoing SMS message. Is that like a text message? You know that?
Witness (05:58:45):
Yes, sir.
Mr. Steel (05:58:47):
Okay. And it's Halloween 2019. Do you see that?
Witness (05:58:50):
I do.
Mr. Steel (05:58:52):
And it's at 8:26 in the morning our time, true?
Witness (05:59:00):
True.
Mr. Steel (05:59:00):
And it's to... It says, "My husband, Akers," but it's the same number, the 5462 number. You see that?
Witness (05:59:06):
I do.
Mr. Steel (05:59:07):
And Lacy wrote, "Have you been taking my brownies?" And then the next message is, SMS message, is from, it says here... Mr. Akers' phone, the 5462 number. You see that?
Witness (05:59:23):
I do.
Mr. Steel (05:59:24):
And it's at 9:02 in the morning?
Witness (05:59:26):
Yes, sir.
Mr. Steel (05:59:27):
Same day, Halloween, right?
Witness (05:59:28):
Correct.
Mr. Steel (05:59:30):
And it says, "Just one on Tuesday. Why?"
(05:59:33)
And then here we have Halloween 2019, and this is an incoming message. So it is from Mr. Akers, the 5462 number, correct? To Ms. Boles' number?
Witness (05:59:50):
That's correct.
Mr. Steel (05:59:50):
All right. And it reads, and it's... If you could blow it up just a little bit, if you don't mind, when you get a chance, investigator. And I'm just going to read it out loud just to make sure I'm trying to read it correctly, okay? And this is from Mr. Akers to Ms. Lacy Boles, right?
Witness (06:00:21):
Correct.
Mr. Steel (06:00:22):
"You want to be spared," and then it looks like four exclamation points, fair?
Witness (06:00:27):
Fair.
Mr. Steel (06:00:28):
"I mean, I know you're not that stupid and you cannot possibly think that I am that F-U blank K-I-N-G stupid. I'm serious." With three exclamation points, right?
Witness (06:00:39):
Yes, sir.
Mr. Steel (06:00:41):
"I sent you a nice loving song, and in return you sent me some F-U blank K-S-H blank T to be spiteful." True?
Witness (06:00:50):
That's what it reads.
Mr. Steel (06:00:51):
"So you legitimately think that I could send you something nice, you send me something, me, and then ask me to spare you. That's F-U blank K-I-N-G retarded." You see that?
Witness (06:01:04):
I see it.
Mr. Steel (06:01:07):
"I haven't said anything mean to you, and yet you continuously say I don't give a F-U blank K and that I don't love you and to keep jacking off, which I have not done because I'm so depressed, sad, and lonely." Right?
Witness (06:01:27):
That's what it reads.
Mr. Steel (06:01:29):
"I can't get my DI blank K hard because..." Well, it's BC. "You have my mind F-U blank K-E-D up." Right?
Witness (06:01:39):
Correct.
Mr. Steel (06:01:40):
"And you're going to ask me to please spared you." That's what it says, right?
Witness (06:01:45):
That's what it reads, sir.
Mr. Steel (06:01:48):
"That's even more F-U blank K-I-N-G retarded." Right?
Witness (06:01:54):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (06:01:55):
"And you do this every F-U blank K-I-N-G day. I'm so sick and tired of it." Right?
Witness (06:02:02):
Right.
Mr. Steel (06:02:03):
"No matter what I do, you have an attitude or you're worked up about something. You always find something to B-I-T-C-H about, will be mad about." Right?
Witness (06:02:22):
Correct.
Mr. Steel (06:02:23):
And then it says, "I don't," and we're going on to page two. And it starts in the second line here. "I don't want this anymore. I can't deal with you anymore. It's too much and you just won't stop." Fair?
Witness (06:02:46):
Correct.
Mr. Steel (06:02:47):
"And now you've been accusing me of cheating on you and talking to someone else, which is totally untrue." Right?
Witness (06:02:56):
Correct.
Mr. Steel (06:02:56):
"So let's make it through the holidays. Just don't talk to me at all about anything. I don't care. At the first of the year, we will go our separate ways. On the first day of the new year, I will move out and look for my mom's. You refuse to be sensible, logical, and even realistic. I just don't want to do it anymore." Fair?
Witness (06:03:20):
Correct.
Mr. Steel (06:03:23):
"I can't... I cannot F-U blank K-I-N-G take it anymore before I absolutely go crazy. I do love you, and I'm sorry if this is going to work. I tried being nice. I tried being happy and loving you, and you cut all goes off every day." Right?
Witness (06:03:45):
Correct.
Mr. Steel (06:03:47):
"I love you with all my heart. I don't know what has happened to you, and I don't know how to fix it or make it right because I didn't do anything wrong." True?
Witness (06:03:57):
Correct.
Mr. Steel (06:03:58):
"But I'm not going to live the rest of my life like this. It's time to realize this is not going to work and more on," move on, "With our lives while still young." Fair?
Witness (06:04:14):
That's fair.
Mr. Steel (06:04:14):
On the front page, it said... If you could put back the first page of 117 Boles. If you could scroll up a little bit. It says here, in context, you have to read the whole thing, but, "I am so depressed, sad, and lonely." Did you ever tell Dr. Lehman about that?
Witness (06:04:47):
No.
Mr. Steel (06:04:48):
Can you put on the next exhibit, if you don't mind? And that's Ms. Boles Exhibit 122.
Investigator (06:04:53):
Ms. Boles 122.
Mr. Steel (06:05:02):
And that was another holiday. That was Halloween 2019, fair to say?
Witness (06:05:07):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (06:05:08):
So it was approximately almost two months before the death of Mr. Akers?
Witness (06:05:15):
Approximately.
Mr. Steel (06:05:15):
Okay. And this one is the same thing. It's Lacy Boles' phone that was extracted by law enforcement, right?
Witness (06:05:24):
Correct.
Mr. Steel (06:05:25):
I mean, with her consent. I'm not saying anything wrong, true?
Witness (06:05:29):
Correct.
Mr. Steel (06:05:31):
And this is about a month and a week later. This is December 6th, 2019. Do you see the date?
Witness (06:05:38):
I do.
Mr. Steel (06:05:39):
And this will be approximately 16 days before Mr. Akers is no longer with us, fair?
Witness (06:05:46):
That's fair.
Mr. Steel (06:05:47):
All right. And this is, again, 5:01 in the afternoon, PM, and it is to the 5462 number, which is Mr. Akers' number, correct?
Witness (06:06:04):
Correct.
Mr. Steel (06:06:05):
So it's from Lacy to Mr. Akers, fair to say?
Witness (06:06:08):
Correct.
Mr. Steel (06:06:09):
And Lacy writes... Yeah, writes, I guess, "I will try to work on it." And then again to her husband, three minutes later, two and a half minutes later at 5:04, Lacy writes, "It's cool. I will just continue to get my throat cut, and then you will find something else that you don't like about me or that you think I do wrong." Fair?
Witness (06:06:35):
Correct.
Mr. Steel (06:06:36):
And then about 29 minutes later, Mr. Akers then responds to Lacy, writes to Lacy. Is that fair to say?
Witness (06:06:47):
Yes, sir.
Mr. Steel (06:06:48):
True?
Witness (06:06:49):
Yes, sir.
Mr. Steel (06:06:50):
And here it reads, "Lace, I just want you to be yourself and happy. I love you. I don't want you to change or do anything to be with me because I'm needy. I don't want you to force it. It will make you resent and hate me. It should be natural. I obviously have some inner issues. I don't know what they are, other than I'm desperately wanting this to work. I love you and our family so much it..." And then it says S-H and then A-N-D, "Without feeling so uncomfortable and stressed and inadequate because of every time we F-U blank K-R-N. So much anxieties. It feels like you are happy when I get it, but mad at the same time. Like a F-U blank K up disappointment, just a whirlwind of emotional torment every time." You see that?
Witness (06:07:59):
I do.
Mr. Steel (06:08:00):
And when Mr. Akers is writing that there's a whirlwind of emotional torment and his feelings of uncomfortable and stressed and inadequate, did you ever tell that to Dr. Lehman?
Witness (06:08:21):
I did not.
Mr. Steel (06:08:22):
Instead, you told Dr. Lehman that he was happy, right?
Witness (06:08:27):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (06:08:35):
Okay. I want to talk with you about the Swiffer, the mop. The mop?
Witness (06:08:46):
Yes, sir.
Mr. Steel (06:08:47):
And Lacy tells law enforcement that she set up that mop. I mean, it's a trade name called a Swiffer, right?
Witness (06:08:57):
Yes, sir.
Mr. Steel (06:08:58):
But it's a cleaning utensil, like a broom or a mop, similar to that, right?
Witness (06:09:02):
Yes. I believe it's a Swiffer and a broom.
Mr. Steel (06:09:07):
Swiffer and a...
Witness (06:09:09):
A broom.
Mr. Steel (06:09:09):
It's a Swiffer?
Witness (06:09:11):
Okay, Swiffer.
Mr. Steel (06:09:12):
And remember Lacy also said use a dust pan also?
Witness (06:09:18):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (06:09:18):
Okay. And that was... She told law enforcement that she wanted to know... She wasn't sure if Mr. Akers was going to come home. They were in an argument, right?
Witness (06:09:28):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (06:09:29):
But if he did come home, she wanted to hear if he was coming home, right?
Witness (06:09:33):
Yes. She said she wanted to hear him come home because he had a key made so he could come home and she wanted to hear when he came home.
Mr. Steel (06:09:39):
Right. And she was free with that information as far as you knew?
Witness (06:09:44):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (06:09:45):
And law enforcement did find a Swiffer there in the photographs. Do you remember seeing that? And if you don't, I could show you the photo.
Witness (06:09:51):
I do remember, and it was in the kitchen, if I recall correctly.
Mr. Steel (06:09:54):
Who moved that Swiffer? If Lacy's being truthful that it was against the door, who moved that Swiffer into the kitchen?
Witness (06:10:02):
I have no idea, sir.
Mr. Steel (06:10:04):
And it doesn't appear that there's any pictures of the Swiffer with any defects or blood on it. Do you realize that?
Witness (06:10:10):
I do.
Mr. Steel (06:10:12):
Do you know if law enforcement put it there? I mean, do you have any-
Witness (06:10:15):
I don't know, sir.
Mr. Steel (06:10:18):
Okay. All right. Now, I think you were asked questions about that Swiffer by the Honorable District Attorney when you were doing direct examination, and I think he called it a booby trap. Do you remember that?
Witness (06:10:30):
I don't remember that testimony, sir.
Mr. Steel (06:10:33):
Well, don't worry about what you were asked. Let me ask you, what is a booby trap?
Witness (06:10:41):
You want a definition?
Mr. Steel (06:10:42):
If you know. If you don't-
Witness (06:10:43):
I mean, I don't know the exact definition, but my interpretation is a booby trap is set up so that somebody either gets hurt or they're alerted to somebody coming into their property or house.
Mr. Steel (06:10:54):
And it comes from the name... If you know. If you don't agree with it, say, "I didn't study it," but it's booby because a booby could be a bruise, right?
Witness (06:11:03):
Okay. Yeah, I didn't study the definition of it.
Mr. Steel (06:11:09):
What was wrong, if anything, in determination of guilt here, the evidence here? What is that, the fact that Lacy told law enforcement that she put the Swiffer and the dust pan in front of the door? What does that have to do with the killing, if you have any idea?
Witness (06:11:27):
I think you're asking again an opinion. I don't understand your question.
Ray Lale (06:11:31):
I'm going to object to that. He's asking this witness what his opinion is on the fact that that was set up, and that's for the jury to decide, what weight they give to that fact, and if they believe that's a fact, that's an improper question again.
Judge Dean Bucci (06:11:40):
All right. Care to respond?
Mr. Steel (06:11:40):
No, Your Honor.
Judge Dean Bucci (06:11:53):
Okay. You want to... I'll sustain. Just ask another question.
Mr. Steel (06:11:54):
Okay. Let me show you what I'll mark as Ms. Boles number 141. While the district attorney is looking at that, remember the keys in the safe and Lacy Boles saying, "I don't have the key to the safe." Remember that?
Witness (06:12:43):
I'm sorry. I couldn't hear your last part of the question.
Mr. Steel (06:12:46):
Do you remember the keys to the safe?
Witness (06:12:48):
Yes, I remember the keys to the safe.
Mr. Steel (06:12:49):
And you told the jury, I believe, that Ms. Boles was... And you tell us, but constantly trying to put her keys in her purse to take them with her to the police station. Do you remember something like that?
Witness (06:13:02):
I do remember that.
Mr. Steel (06:13:04):
Do you remember writing a report about that incident with the keys?
Witness (06:13:09):
Yes, there should be one in the case file.
Mr. Steel (06:13:11):
Can you give it to me? Do you remember never notating that there was this constant trying to put the keys in the purse?
Witness (06:13:27):
I believe I put it in my report that she was putting the keys or was trying to get the keys. I don't remember the exact verbiage I put in there.
Mr. Steel (06:13:35):
But... So it's not that she was constantly trying to do that. I thought that's what you said on direct examination last-
Witness (06:13:42):
Yeah, I believe it was constantly. She did it a couple times, if I recall correctly, sir.
Mr. Steel (06:13:59):
I just want to ask you, the reason that you write reports is because if it's not memorialized on a body camera or a video audio recording, it's good to put things down, your notes on paper and reports early when it happens so that your memory might be fresher than it does seven years later, right?
Witness (06:14:39):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (06:14:40):
And that's just something... It doesn't mean that it's in your report, it means it's accurate, but you tried to be accurate in your report, true?
Witness (06:14:48):
Correct.
Mr. Steel (06:14:49):
And if it was that Ms. Boles was constantly trying to put her keys in her purse, and you remember to this day, that should have been in your report, would you agree with that?
Witness (06:15:01):
I should have put it in my report, yes.
Mr. Steel (06:15:03):
I'm going to show you, if the court permits me to approach, a page of your report. If you need to see something else though, just let us know, okay?
Witness (06:15:15):
That's fine, Yes.
Mr. Steel (06:15:16):
May I approach, Your Honor?
Judge Dean Bucci (06:15:17):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (06:15:18):
Just tell the jurors whether this is your report and then just look at it. You can read the whole thing, but I'm interested in the third, in the fourth paragraph.
Witness (06:15:29):
This is my report.
Mr. Steel (06:15:31):
Okay. And you can look at anything you want. I assume that you read it to prepare for coming into court to testify.
Witness (06:16:08):
Yes, sir.
Mr. Steel (06:16:09):
Is it fair to say that you did not put in your report that she was constantly trying to put the keys?
Witness (06:16:17):
No, I did not put in there. I put in there that she had went to get her keys and put it in the purse.
Mr. Steel (06:16:22):
Yeah. That's what you wrote, right?
Witness (06:16:24):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (06:16:26):
Okay. Nothing like what you testified to?
Witness (06:16:29):
I didn't use the word constantly. No, sir.
Mr. Steel (06:16:31):
Am I correct?
Witness (06:16:31):
No, I did not.
Mr. Steel (06:16:32):
But am I correct?
Witness (06:16:33):
You are correct.
Mr. Steel (06:16:34):
It's different than what you testified.
Witness (06:16:35):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (06:16:36):
Okay. I'm going to show you what's been marked as Ms. Boles 85, six, seven, eight, nine, and 90. May I approach, Your Honor?
Judge Dean Bucci (06:16:54):
Yes.
Witness (06:16:59):
Yes, sir.
Mr. Steel (06:17:04):
Just tell us... Take a peek and tell us whether you recognize those exhibits. Thank you.
Witness (06:17:11):
I do not recognize exhibit 85. I don't know where that picture was taken or what time or when. That's not one of our pictures. I do recognize exhibit 86. I do recognize 87. I do recognize 88, 89, and 90, sir.
Mr. Steel (06:17:49):
Okay. And the first one that you do not recognize, did you analyze the phone of Mr. Akers for conversations? Do you not recognize this image?
Witness (06:18:03):
I do not recognize that image. No, sir.
Mr. Steel (06:18:05):
That's fine. That's fine. Okay. Your Honor, except for Ms. Boles number 85, we move for the admission of 86 through 90.
Judge Dean Bucci (06:18:11):
No objection.
Investigator (06:18:15):
All right. Admitted.
Mr. Steel (06:18:24):
I want to ask you... May I approach?
Judge Dean Bucci (06:18:39):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (06:18:40):
May I get those from you, sir?
Witness (06:18:42):
Yes, sir. And that's 85.
Mr. Steel (06:18:49):
Your Honor, since I asked for, I marked it and I'll use it later, 85, can I read it to the court reporter? It's not in evidence.
Judge Dean Bucci (06:18:53):
Sure.
Mr. Steel (06:19:39):
Thank you. And I'd like to discuss, if you don't mind, number 88, I believe. [inaudible 06:19:11]. Okay. So I want to talk with you about Ms. Boles' exhibit number 88.
Witness (06:19:47):
Yes, sir.
Mr. Steel (06:19:49):
And I want to go over with you some of the keys. These are the keys that hold the key to the safe, fair to say?
Witness (06:19:58):
Correct.
Mr. Steel (06:19:59):
And this is March 5th, 2020, right?
Witness (06:20:03):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (06:20:04):
These keys here, do you see there are several different keys on this key holder? Can you see those different keys?
Witness (06:20:22):
Yes, there's several keys.
Mr. Steel (06:20:24):
Do you see this? What do you call this where I'm pointing right now, if you call it anything?
Witness (06:20:30):
The term just escaped my brain.
Mr. Steel (06:20:33):
Carabiner?
Witness (06:20:34):
A carabiner, correct.
Mr. Steel (06:20:35):
Okay. How about this? Do you see this strap?
Witness (06:20:38):
It's like a lanyard.
Mr. Steel (06:20:39):
Yeah. And do you know that this plugs into another lanyard? Are you aware of that?
Witness (06:20:44):
I can't see by that picture, but I see the plastic part.
Mr. Steel (06:20:47):
Okay. I want to show you at the scene of Mr. Akers, God forbid, lying on the ground, and I want to talk about those keys, okay?
Witness (06:20:57):
Yes, sir.
Mr. Steel (06:21:10):
I'm going to show you, with the court's permission, Ms. Boles number 40, and there'll be a series of them just to get closer to the keys.
Witness (06:21:15):
Yes, sir.
Mr. Steel (06:21:15):
May I approach, Your Honor?
Judge Dean Bucci (06:21:15):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (06:21:22):
Tell me if you're familiar with that.
Witness (06:21:23):
I am.
Mr. Steel (06:21:26):
Your Honor, may I give it to the investigator?
Judge Dean Bucci (06:21:28):
Sure. You can display it.
Mr. Steel (06:21:36):
And if you could zoom in on the keys. Now I want you to... I hope it doesn't get too distorted, but I want you to note, do you see this part right here that I'm pointing at? It's kind of, I think, blue and black in color. Do you see that?
Witness (06:22:06):
I can't make that out, sir.
Mr. Steel (06:22:07):
Okay. Let's get other ones. Your Honor, may we have just a minute?
Judge Dean Bucci (06:22:19):
Sure.
Investigator (06:22:19):
Okay.
Mr. Steel (06:22:41):
Mr. Lao is looking... Your Honor, may I approach?
Judge Dean Bucci (06:22:42):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (06:22:43):
Oh, let me show this. May I approach you?
Witness (06:22:54):
Yes, sir.
Mr. Steel (06:22:55):
Just announce what you're looking at and then tell us which one you can figure out what that black part is, if you don't mind.
Witness (06:23:03):
So I'm looking at state's exhibit, or I'm sorry, Mrs. Boles exhibit 23.
Mr. Steel (06:23:09):
Is that... And just tell us if that one's more helpful.
Witness (06:23:11):
It's not.
Mr. Steel (06:23:12):
Okay.
Witness (06:23:14):
26, maybe a little bit more helpful. 26 and 25, sir.
Mr. Steel (06:23:38):
Are the best ones so far?
Witness (06:23:40):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (06:23:40):
All right. Your Honor, may I approach?
Judge Dean Bucci (06:23:41):
You may.
Mr. Steel (06:23:43):
I'm also showing you what's already been marked and admitted into evidence as state's 100 and 103. May I approach you?
Witness (06:23:49):
Yes, sir.
Mr. Steel (06:23:49):
Tell me whether these may help as well, and then we'll organize it.
Witness (06:23:54):
Oh, these are... Yeah, that one and that one.
Mr. Steel (06:23:54):
And can you [inaudible 06:23:55] that one?
Witness (06:23:58):
I'm sorry. I apologize, sir. State's Exhibit 100 and State's Exhibit 103.
Mr. Steel (06:24:03):
May I take the ones that are more helpful? May I take these?
Witness (06:24:09):
Oh, yes, sir. I'm sorry.
Mr. Steel (06:24:10):
Your Honor, may I approach the investigator?
Judge Dean Bucci (06:24:11):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (06:24:14):
If you could just show the ones that the detective said are more helpful and just announce which ones are going on the screen first, please.
Investigator (06:24:26):
Boles 25.
Mr. Steel (06:24:32):
So here is near the ground where Mr. Akers lay, and we're talking about... I was asking about this clip, or I don't know what you call it, the black portion. Do you remember that?
Witness (06:24:42):
Yes, sir.
Mr. Steel (06:24:43):
Okay. And you said that's a little more helpful, right?
Witness (06:24:46):
Yes. It looks like a black clip.
Mr. Steel (06:24:48):
And if you can zoom in on that, if you don't mind.
Mr. Steel (06:25:00):
And the black clip has some blue right there. You see that?
Witness (06:25:10):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (06:25:11):
And there's also other items here, which appear to be keys and maybe something else, a blue metallic, maybe a fob or something.
Witness (06:25:21):
Yes, sir, true.
Mr. Steel (06:25:22):
And it has a carabiner. Do you see that sticking up?
Witness (06:25:26):
I see what... No, I can't confirm that that's a carabiner.
Mr. Steel (06:25:30):
Let's get a different picture.
Witness (06:25:31):
Yes, sir.
Mr. Steel (06:25:31):
And thank you for doing that. Maybe it's a key. We'll get a different picture.
Witness (06:25:35):
Yes, sir.
Mr. Steel (06:25:35):
Can you try a different picture if you don't mind?
Speaker 11 (06:25:39):
Boles Exhibit 26.
Mr. Steel (06:25:40):
This is a different angle of that same item. Is that true?
Witness (06:25:47):
It does. It does appear to be a carabiner.
Mr. Steel (06:25:49):
And again, we're talking about, this is in relation to Mr. Akers, God forbid, but this is December 22, 2019 photograph, fair?
Witness (06:25:58):
Yes. Those are the keys that were downstairs.
Mr. Steel (06:26:00):
And this is, as you just said, this is a carabiner with another item right here, another metal looking item. True?
Witness (06:26:07):
True.
Mr. Steel (06:26:08):
And there's a Kroger, you see a Kroger card. Do you recognize that as a Kroger card?
Witness (06:26:12):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (06:26:13):
And there's a key here around a key. Do you see that?
Witness (06:26:17):
I do.
Mr. Steel (06:26:17):
And then this black piece of what I asked you about with the little blue stripe, do you see that?
Witness (06:26:22):
Yes, sir.
Mr. Steel (06:26:22):
Okay. If you could do the next one.
Speaker 11 (06:26:27):
State's Exhibit 100.
Mr. Steel (06:26:30):
Now, nobody tried to fool anybody. This is just items that were on or near Mr. Akers. Can you blow it back just so the jurors... And this is state's exhibit number 100. Is that correct?
Speaker 11 (06:26:43):
100.
Mr. Steel (06:26:47):
And this is just shots of these items that were on or near Mr. Akers at the time of his God forbid, death, and they're put down with a white background for visibility. Fair to say?
Witness (06:27:02):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (06:27:03):
And we got the pink highlighter, Mr. Akers' cell phone, a dollar bill, his driver's license inside his wallet, right?
Witness (06:27:11):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (06:27:11):
And then the keys. And if you could zoom in on the keys. And this is December 22, 2019. And this is just a closer up picture of the keys, the carabiner, the other, I'll call it oval, metal looking item, another keychain over here, various keys, keys underneath the blue item. Do you see all that?
Witness (06:28:02):
I do.
Mr. Steel (06:28:02):
Okay. And then the Kroger card, it looks like fair to say?
Witness (06:28:06):
Yes, sir.
Mr. Steel (06:28:07):
And different types of key rings are attached to this. It's multiple keys, multiple key rings, carabiner car key here. You recognize that as a car key with the chip, the computer chip right here?
Witness (06:28:21):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (06:28:21):
All right. And you recognize the plastic piece here that something may plug into, right?
Witness (06:28:28):
Correct.
Mr. Steel (06:28:29):
All right. Can you show them that plastic?
Speaker 11 (06:28:35):
State's 103.
Mr. Steel (06:28:44):
And this is blown up, but you see the keys here, the round key, you see the same items, just a different view. Is that fair to say?
Witness (06:28:52):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (06:28:53):
All right. Now I'd like to go back to Ms. Boles Exhibit 88 with this understanding, because those keys that we just looked at or those images were from December 22, 2019, right?
Witness (06:29:09):
Correct.
Mr. Steel (06:29:13):
I want you to look at March, I think it's 66 days later. Fair to say?
Witness (06:29:19):
Fair to say.
Mr. Steel (06:29:20):
March 5th, 2020. Does this look remotely familiar, this item right here with the carabiner attached to it as compared to what we just saw in the other exhibits?
Witness (06:29:34):
It looks similar.
Mr. Steel (06:29:35):
And do you notice the blue part here with the black piece to it?
Witness (06:29:43):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (06:29:44):
And if you can go down, if you don't mind just scrolling out a little bit. Do you see now it's connected to another item? You see that? You see there's something plugged into that?
Witness (06:29:56):
Yeah, there's another lanyard connected to it.
Mr. Steel (06:29:58):
Yeah. And then if you can zoom out more, if you don't mind, Mr. Investigator. Do you recognize these as the keys that were laying near Mr. Akers on December 22, 2019 at the top part with the key that fits the safe?
Witness (06:30:28):
They're similar.
Mr. Steel (06:30:30):
Did you ever think about that before today in court?
Witness (06:30:33):
I mean, they're all together, so no.
Mr. Steel (06:30:35):
I couldn't hear you.
Witness (06:30:36):
All the keys are together, so no.
Mr. Steel (06:30:38):
You didn't think about it if somebody just joined the two sets of keys?
Witness (06:30:43):
No, I didn't think about that.
Mr. Steel (06:30:45):
Who joined the two sets of keys?
Witness (06:30:47):
I have no idea.
Mr. Steel (06:30:48):
When were they joined?
Witness (06:30:49):
No clue.
Mr. Steel (06:30:52):
These are the keys that Lacy Boles was trying to put into her purse, true?
Witness (06:30:57):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (06:30:59):
And this is what you were telling the jurors that Lacy Boles had the safe key on her keychain, true?
Witness (06:31:06):
True.
Mr. Steel (06:31:09):
But as of December 22, 2019, those keys were laying near Mr. Akers, not attached to these other keys, right?
Witness (06:31:23):
I believe the one... I mean, it looks like there's another car key on there, not the one with the chip.
Mr. Steel (06:31:28):
Yeah. Who put that on there?
Witness (06:31:31):
I don't know, sir.
Mr. Steel (06:31:32):
When did they get joined?
Witness (06:31:34):
I have no idea.
Mr. Steel (06:31:37):
What evidence do you have that Lacy Boles ever opened that safe that's in evidence, with that key?
Witness (06:31:49):
What do you mean, sir? I don't understand your question.
Mr. Steel (06:31:51):
Lacy Boles, you told the jury that... You identified this photograph for the jury. Remember that?
Witness (06:32:03):
I do.
Mr. Steel (06:32:04):
And you told the jury that Lacy Boles had on her keychain, the key that opens a safe, which is true, right?
Witness (06:32:11):
Correct.
Mr. Steel (06:32:12):
But my question to you is, what evidence do you have that Lacy Boles ever used that key to open that safe?
Witness (06:32:19):
I don't.
Mr. Steel (06:32:20):
And what evidence do you have that Lacy Boles was aware that that key fits that safe?
Witness (06:32:24):
I don't.
Mr. Steel (06:32:25):
And she said she didn't have the key to fit that safe, right?
Witness (06:32:29):
Correct.
Mr. Steel (06:32:30):
Okay. I'd like to talk to you about the gun, okay?
Witness (06:32:57):
Okay.
Mr. Steel (06:33:00):
The revolver. You've seen the revolver?
Witness (06:33:03):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (06:33:04):
And that's an important... You can take that down if you don't mind. And thank you, sir. And that's an important piece of evidence. Is that fair to say?
Witness (06:33:17):
It is.
Mr. Steel (06:33:19):
Because regardless of whether this is a suicide, whether it's, God forbid, a homicide, that's a piece of evidence that needs to be studied, correct?
Witness (06:33:32):
Correct.
Mr. Steel (06:33:33):
And it needs to be studied for various reasons, including, but I'm not limiting it to it, who was holding that gun at the trigger pull at the time the gun fired, right?
Witness (06:33:46):
Correct.
Mr. Steel (06:33:47):
Because that's really the key to this case. Would you agree with that?
Witness (06:33:51):
It's one of the major points, yes.
Mr. Steel (06:33:53):
And you said, you know, one of the major points, I'm not saying there's not other points, but if Mr. Akers, God forbid, pulled that trigger, that's what Lacy's claiming, right?
Witness (06:34:07):
Correct.
Mr. Steel (06:34:08):
And if he didn't pull that trigger, that's what the indictment claims, right?
Witness (06:34:13):
Yes, sir.
Mr. Steel (06:34:14):
That Lacy pulled the trigger from a distance, true?
Witness (06:34:17):
True.
Mr. Steel (06:34:18):
So when that evidence is collected, as far as we know, I'm not saying it is, but as far as we know, it was collected and preserved for testing, true?
Witness (06:34:28):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (06:34:29):
And that went to the Georgia Crime Lab. You know what I'm talking about in Decatur, Georgia?
Witness (06:34:34):
Yes, sir.
Mr. Steel (06:34:35):
And there are scientists besides Dr. Lehman, but there are other scientists who can test things like blood, right?
Witness (06:34:42):
Correct.
Mr. Steel (06:34:43):
Fingerprints?
Witness (06:34:44):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (06:34:45):
Drugs in system, drugs in blood?
Witness (06:34:47):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (06:34:49):
DNA, right?
Witness (06:34:51):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (06:34:52):
And firearms, right?
Witness (06:34:54):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (06:34:55):
And when you got the case in February 2020, you knew already, did you, or did you not, that there was a request to test for DNA on that gun?
Witness (06:35:11):
I have to go back and look at the file and refresh my memory, but I know that that was requested at some point. I don't know when.
Mr. Steel (06:35:18):
Okay. And you follow up, do you not, with things that are requested of various people, but including the crime lab?
Witness (06:35:27):
Correct.
Mr. Steel (06:35:27):
And you want to know for your file, if nothing else, what are the results?
Witness (06:35:31):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (06:35:34):
And in this case, was DNA taken from Lacy?
Witness (06:35:40):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (06:35:41):
And by taken from Lacy, some jurors may not know, but it's just like a Q-tip going on the inside of the cheek, is that fair?
Witness (06:35:48):
Yes. She voluntarily gave her DNA.
Mr. Steel (06:35:50):
And it's not an invasive process, it's just swabbing the inside of the cheeks. Is that true?
Witness (06:35:57):
It is correct, yes.
Mr. Steel (06:35:59):
And Dan Aker's DNA, clearly we have, right?
Witness (06:36:03):
Correct.
Mr. Steel (06:36:03):
We have his blood, true?
Witness (06:36:05):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (06:36:06):
And from both of their DNAs, we could determine if it was done, whose finger was on that trigger at the time it was pulled, true?
Witness (06:36:15):
No.
Mr. Steel (06:36:16):
How come?
Witness (06:36:17):
I'm not an expert to do DNA or testify on DNA.
Mr. Steel (06:36:21):
Okay. I don't want to get you beyond where you feel comfortable. I'm not trying to do that. Do you know... I don't want you to testify as a DNA expert. I'm just asking you, do you... How about this? Was the request made to check the gun for DNA? How about this?
Witness (06:36:35):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (06:36:38):
Okay. You don't have to give me results if you don't want to. I'm not asking you to repeat what someone else did or didn't do, but did you ever see any results for the DNA on the gun?
Witness (06:36:46):
I don't believe the GBI did any testing for DNA. I think they refused, if I remember correctly.
Mr. Steel (06:36:52):
Well, did you take the gun to somewhere else?
Witness (06:36:55):
No.
Mr. Steel (06:36:56):
The FBI?
Witness (06:36:57):
No.
Mr. Steel (06:36:58):
To some other crime lab, independent crime lab?
Witness (06:37:01):
No.
Mr. Steel (06:37:04):
Why?
Witness (06:37:06):
It requires funds. We always tested everything through the GBI.
Mr. Steel (06:37:12):
Did you say it requires money?
Witness (06:37:13):
Yes, sir. But I mean, we always have everything done through the GBI.
Mr. Steel (06:37:17):
GBI tests for DNA, you know that?
Witness (06:37:20):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (06:37:22):
Okay. So as of today, with that gun that's marked and admitted into evidence before this Honorable Court, to your knowledge, no one ever did that test for DNA, even though Dan Aker's DNA was known and Ms. Lacy Bole's DNA was known, am I correct?
Witness (06:37:43):
Correct.
Mr. Steel (06:37:52):
Your Honor, can I have just a moment to...
Judge (06:37:55):
Sure. Why don't we use this time to take a 10-minute break? All right. 3:10, see you at 3: 20.
Mr. Steel (06:49:56):
... For, there [inaudible 06:49:59] his state of mind. It's not hearsay. It's his own statements about state of mind giving the cases at the beginning of the case. I can give them to the court and the prosecutor again. But with that being said, Mr. Lenial has obtained certified copies of convictions, and as the Prosecutor Treadaway said, and probation revocations. And the import is, and I know the witness is here, but the import is that there is a probation revocation warrant filed on or about January 7th of 2020. That is within approximately, I don't know, two and a half weeks after December 22, 2019. And Mr. Akers talks about the fact that he's going to be revoked on parole. So it goes to his state of mind. It also goes to what was told to Dr. Lehman. I understand this court ruling. I will always abide by this Honorable Court, but it doesn't matter that it was written by, in my opinion, Lieutenant Hill to Detective Lehman, excuse me, Medical Examiner Lehman, because Lieutenant Hardy is on the exchanges.
(06:51:20)
And my questions are, why didn't you say to Dr. Lehman that what he's being told by Lieutenant Hill is wrong? That's not calling for hearsay. That's his own statements. And I'm not using the statements of Lieutenant Hill for truth because actually they're not true. I'm saying they're untrue, that Mr. Akers bought a pig. Categorically, I'm denying that, and I don't think it's hearsay at all. So with all that being said, I would like the court to admit, and I could show it to you so you're not ruling without seeing the evidence, but there are... And we just attached everything. It's from Douglas County and Cobb County. Mr. Akers has a conviction. It's a 2009 case, gets convicted 2010. It's a term of 15 years to serve time in prison. So his probation carries on till 2024. That's where you get the 2024 from. Mr. Akers writes about that to his friend in multiple text messages, which we have here, which I know that the witness said he doesn't remember them or can't identify them.
(06:52:37)
It doesn't matter. They came from the state of Georgia on the download. I'll call an expert who the state gave us a download and he'll just verify it's on the phone. But respectfully, it's coming in anyway.
Judge (06:52:52):
What's on the phone? The actual documents?
Mr. Steel (06:52:56):
The text messages.
Judge (06:52:57):
Text messages.
Mr. Steel (06:52:57):
Saying, "I'm going to prison till 2024." And then these documents just back it up. The state opened on the fact that Mr. Akers was on probation. I wasn't going to say that until we had a ruling from the court. And then of course I knew it was in the March 5th, 2020 interview where Detective Hardy tells Lacy Boles that Mr. Akers is a convicted felon. And his point was he's not around guns, which is not true either because if we have to call our expert on his phone, he's selling guns, selling long firearms. So I'm not here to hurt Mr. Akers. I'm just here to get out reality. And I think the fact that Mr. Akers is going through marital problems, financial problems, looking at going to prison for a number of years, four years, four plus years, it's the very end of 2019 and it goes to 2024.
(06:53:54)
So I'll just say four years, but more than four years. He gets furloughed from his job. That's in there too. He talks about fake urine. He talks about a strap. It's in those, which I'd like to get in. The fact he's asking people, "Are they going to drug test me if I try to get this job at the airport? I've been on drugs. I'm not going to pass it." Somebody says to him, "Do you have a strap?" He says, "Yeah, I know." The strap, I'm going to argue to the jury, I don't think it's a gun. I think it's fake urine. There's been testimony. I don't know why they brought it up, but it comes in that the detective never even bothers to go speak with Lacy Boles' daughter. She found the fake urine or the urine. I shouldn't say fake urine. I'm not saying it's not urine, but the urine in the car.
(06:54:39)
And that's a lot on somebody. And the State wants it to be, and they tell Dr. Lehman that, "Dr. Lehman's interested. Was Mr. Akers depressed?" And the answer from this witness was, "No, he was really happy and he was promoted at work." And then Detective Hill, Lieutenant Hill with Detective Hardy on the text chain, as you probably remember reading, talks about this pig that was never bought. And then he writes something whimsical, "Who buys a pig and then buys a farm?" I mean, I'll call Lieutenant Hill. I have him under subpoena. It's just, to me, this stuff just all comes in. It's not for the truth. I'm really going to show he's not skipping through life.
Judge (06:55:34):
I understand what you're saying. So I guess we've got two issues because you're objecting to these documents coming in that show, I guess, their arrests and probation hearings and that kind of thing.
Ray Lale (06:55:46):
Yes, sir. And there's one accusation out of Cobb County that the case was totally dismissed. So things like that. How is it relevant? I understand the defense theory of the case, he was afraid he was going to be revoked. He said that on his phone in his own words, that's enough. You don't have to run his name through the mud with stuff like this, stuff that ultimately ended up being dismissed. You don't have to show a probation revocation petition that was dismissed later because he's died. You don't have to show stuff like this. Plus you're getting into a lot of things. You get into hearsay issues on this. But one thing you get into also is expanding the scope of the trial, because to repeatedly insinuate to the jury, which are lay people, they're probably ignorant to the criminal process, he's going away for four years.
(06:56:36)
I mean, we do this for a living. We know that somebody on a revocation for drugs is probably not going to get the balance of four years revoked on a first revocation. So then you expand the nature of the hearing to have to call probation officers or how much is typical. I mean, it's just putting a lot that's unnecessary because his fear of being revoked is in evidence on the phone. We should just state that.
Judge (06:57:02):
All right. And then do we have a second issue, Mr. Steele, where you're asking me to reconsider the earlier ruling on the emails?
Mr. Steel (06:57:09):
Yeah.
Judge (06:57:09):
Okay.
Mr. Steel (06:57:10):
And could I just respond just very briefly?
Judge (06:57:13):
Sure.
Mr. Steel (06:57:18):
The text message, I'm not arguing mistake it's going to be revoked to 2024. I have no idea what a judge does, but he wrote in his text message that he's looking at spending time being revoked until 2024. Those are not my words. And the state objected. I plan on getting that in evidence to ask the court, but it should really come in now whether this detective saw it or not. If it's not on the phone, I will not raise it, but it is on the phone. The state gave it to me. I'm assuming they know it's on the phone. I mean, this is not an authenticity issue at all and it's not hearsay. It's his state of mind.
Judge (06:58:03):
Well, you gave me some cases and I read them and I read the Veltman case that you cited earlier and that there's a sentence in that case that kind of stands out. A homicide victim's state of mind is unquestionably relevant to the defense theory that she committed suicide. So I think that's unarguable. So yes, these emails where he's talking about, "I'm afraid, I'm afraid that I may get revoked." I think that's relevant. My question is if you've got that and those emails, are there emails or texts?
Mr. Steel (06:58:45):
Texts, or both-
Judge (06:58:46):
The texts are coming in, you're wanting to go further and get the underlying, I think, the underlying convictions or probation revocations. And that's beyond his state of mind, isn't it? You've got his state of mind in the texts.
Mr. Steel (06:59:04):
Okay. Well, let me just make sure and I hope I said it. The revocation warrant wasn't issued till after he died, so he wouldn't know about that. But he knew that he was in correspondence with his probation officer knowing that he's not complying with probation and he's going to be potentially revoked. And that's his text messages that we talked about.
Judge (06:59:26):
So I'm kind of with you on the text messages. I just question whether because he's worrying about and he's saying "I might get revoked," now that means you can, and I haven't even seen what you got there, but I'm just listening, that seems going beyond his state of mind. And then I heard the prosecutor say something like, however you put it, could you say drag his name through the mud or something?
Ray Lale (06:59:56):
[inaudible 06:59:57] reputation through the mud.
Judge (06:59:57):
So then I start thinking, well, that's kind of bad character.
Judge (07:00:00):
Well, that's bad character of the alleged victim, so it just seems like it should be enough that you get the text messages in.
Mr. Steel (07:00:11):
Okay. I understand.
Judge (07:00:14):
As to the emails, I'm willing to reconsider them if you'll show me again.
Mr. Steel (07:00:20):
I think they're with the court reporter. Your Honor, I will not move to admit it based upon this honorable court's ruling, but can I just put in for the record Ms. Boles' Exhibit Number 116, which is, and I'll count the pages, but it is the history of the felony from Douglas County, the arrest in Cobb County, the conviction in Cobb County, the probation revocation?
Judge (07:00:55):
Sure. You want to make that part of the record? Absolutely.
Mr. Steel (07:00:56):
Just part of the record. I understand it's not to be discussed in front of the jury.
Judge (07:01:01):
All right. Now, I have Ms. Boles' 140 again before me. These are the emails between Mike Hill and Detective Hardy and Dr. Lehman. And I'd earlier ruled that I guess I was a little uncomfortable with the fact that you've got emails here from between people that aren't even on the stand. And I said something like, "You can try again when you have one of them on the stand," but you're wanting me to reconsider now. The objection is hearsay. Your argument is they're not offered for truth. And so I'll start at the top. Mike Hill, "Doctor, you are correct in the fact that the family described no prior thoughts or ideation of suicide." You're saying that's not offered for truth, that's false?
Mr. Steel (07:02:03):
I don't know what the family thought, so I could excise that out.
Judge (07:02:07):
Okay. I don't want to write on this. Then I have an email from Dr. Lehman, "Regarding this case for which we met last week, I wanted to inquire about a possible history of depression for the decedent." That's just a question. I don't think that's a statement of fact. I don't think that sentence is hearsay, but it goes on. "I know we talked about it during at least one of our conversations, but I wanted to confirm." Well, there's a statement of fact, "We talked about it. My recollection from our conversation is that the decedent was not officially diagnosed with depression, though the wife stated he has expressed suicidal ideations in the past. That's not offered for truth?
Mr. Steel (07:03:02):
We could excise that.
Judge (07:03:03):
You say what?
Mr. Steel (07:03:05):
I don't think it's offered for the truth, but he's asking questions. Questions are not hearsay 'cause they're not assertions. Questions are not assertions. They're-
Judge (07:03:14):
I agree, but the sentence, "My recollection from our conversations is that the decedent was not officially diagnosed with depression, though the wife states he has expressed suicidal ideations in the past." That kind of feels like it's offered for truth.
Mr. Steel (07:03:32):
Okay. I mean, he's coming, so that's fine. When I say, "He's coming," Dr. Lehman's coming.
Judge (07:03:38):
All right. All right. So, I'm not changing my ruling, but when you have Dr. Lehman on the stand, you are free to try again.
Mr. Steel (07:03:46):
I'm more interested in the pig comment. I'm just trying to-
Judge (07:03:51):
Okay. I'll get to that.
Mr. Steel (07:03:56):
That he's doing great on job.
Judge (07:04:03):
Nick Hardy sent an email to Mike Hill dated March 23, 2020. "If I may add, the family also stated Daniel was extremely happy about a moving up in his job and was planning a getting new Christmas tree for his family." You want that in as non-hearsay?
Mr. Steel (07:04:33):
True. But to be quite frank, I think that's Detective Hardy's writing and I think that was testified to.
Judge (07:04:45):
Okay. Now, I'm looking for the pig. All right. I've got it. Mike Hill to Nick Hardy, March 23, 2020, " Not to mention that he bought a pig from Tractor Supply. Who buys an animal and buys the farm that evening?" CC Dr. Lehman. And he did not buy a pig?
Mr. Steel (07:05:16):
True.
Ray Lale (07:05:16):
Who says he didn't? It's not in evidence that he didn't. Brian Steel says he didn't. Where's the evidence that he didn't buy it? No one. No one said that. Nowhere.
Mr. Steel (07:05:28):
Well, this is a little hard to swallow. I asked Detective Hardy, "What evidence do you have that a pig was ever bought?" And his answer is, "Nothing."
Ray Lale (07:05:36):
That doesn't make it not true. That means one witness said he doesn't have any evidence of it. That doesn't make it a non-truth.
Judge (07:05:43):
But it's being offered to show that it's false, and false evidence or false information was given to Dr. Lehman. So I'll agree that's not hearsay.
Ray Lale (07:05:58):
Well, I don't understand. If you're saying that it's not being offered for the truth because it's false, there would have to be evidence that it's false. There's been none. There's a theory that it's false by the Defense. No one said it wasn't true, except Mr. Steel. No one. Hardy said, "I don't have evidence whether he did or not. I don't know." But Mr. Steel says, "Nobody bought this pig. That's false evidence." There's been no evidence that it's not true.
Mr. Steel (07:06:27):
Listen, there's no receipt. There's no pig. There's nobody saying, "Here's the pig." No one returning the pig. I mean, this is like getting into... I don't know.
Ray Lale (07:06:40):
There is evidence of the pig on his phone. There's evidence of a bunch of pigs in a cage, one of which could have been bought. It's possible. We'll just have to see how the evidence shakes out, but there was definitely evidence as if he's looking at these pigs to buy and they're in a cage, little miniature pet pigs. So, we don't know that that's false.
Mr. Steel (07:07:04):
We do know it's false. Mr. Akers has a conversation with a friend of his on his text messages, where he states that he's not buying the pig. I don't know how else to-
Judge (07:07:17):
Well, I'm pretty sure, respectfully, that that particular statement is not being offered for truth, for the purpose for which it's being offered. I'm pretty confident of that, but that's just one email, so I'm willing to reconsider that one as non-hearsay. Do you want me to go further?
Mr. Steel (07:07:41):
Sure.
Judge (07:07:42):
Well, is there a particular other one? 'Cause some of these, I mentioned a couple of their particular-
Mr. Steel (07:07:46):
I think it came in. Detective Hardy said that he described Mr. Akers to Detective Lehman as being happy, not depressed, something like that. I'm not looking at the email right now, but it's something to that effect. And I think Detective Hardy already testified that he did do that and was being promoted at a job. So I think that's in already.
Judge (07:08:08):
So I have one page. I've got the email from Lieutenant Hill that mentions that I read the statement about the pig. And then below that, from Detective Hardy to Mike Hill copying Dr. Lehman, "If I may add, the family also stated Daniel was extremely happy about moving up in his job and was planning a getting new Christmas tree for his family."
Mr. Steel (07:08:39):
I think I asked him about those already.
Judge (07:08:39):
Okay.
Mr. Steel (07:08:39):
I think that's covered, because my memory is I asked Detective Hardy about that and he answered.
Judge (07:08:43):
Well, you've changed my mind on at least one of these, the pig comment, so I'll admit that as non-hearsay. Is there anything in particular otherwise that you want me to look at?
Mr. Steel (07:08:58):
No. When Dr. Lehman testifies, though, I will be reasserting this same exhibit to ask him if he uses information in any way in his [inaudible 07:09:09].
Judge (07:09:09):
All right. So I change my ruling somewhat as to Exhibit 140. As to the email that I specified from Lieutenant Hill, I believe that's non-hearsay, and I'll admit that, but I stand on my ruling on the rest. So if you're going to tender this at this point, you're going to have to do a little redacting of some sort.
Mr. Steel (07:09:30):
Understood.
Judge (07:09:30):
All right?
Mr. Steel (07:09:30):
Yes, sir.
Judge (07:09:30):
Okay.
Mr. Steel (07:09:33):
And then, Your Honor, I'm just going to give, with the court's permission, district attorney's office, understanding Ms. Boles' Exhibit Number 116, which are the certified copies that we discussed of Mr. Akers throughout the time period, including the probation revocation notice, but not in evidence. I stand by my assertion, but I respect the court's ruling. I'm just going to give it for the record to the court reporter.
Judge (07:09:55):
Okay.
Mr. Steel (07:09:55):
Thank you. May I approach?
Judge (07:10:08):
Yes, sir.
Ray Lale (07:10:09):
Your Honor, I'm asking for clarification of the court's ruling regarding the text messages about state of mind of the decedent. There's answers from another party. Now, surely that would be hearsay. [inaudible 07:10:21]. We don't know who wrote it.
Judge (07:10:22):
Well, I'll have to see the particular text message we're talking about. I was just saying generally, I understand that the decedent's state of mind is relevant, and I was talking, I think, about, "I'm afraid that I'm about to go to prison."
Ray Lale (07:10:38):
I respect the court's ruling on what Dan Akers said. I would just ask the court to strike whatever the responses are from some unknown party like Chris. I don't even know who that is.
Judge (07:10:48):
Okay. I'm just not sure what exhibit we're talking about, or... I'd need to see.
Ray Lale (07:10:52):
Well, I stated in my place that there's a bubble from Mr. Akers. I'm afraid I'm going to go [inaudible 07:10:59] be revoked or whatever. And then there's another bubble from some responder that he's talking to back and forth, identifies himself as Chris W or something, and that would surely be hearsay. There's a total of four bubbles, two by Mr. Akers and two by the respondent. I don't even know who it is.
Judge (07:11:13):
I just need to see the exhibit.
Ray Lale (07:11:16):
I guess I'll need Mr. Steel to produce it.
Mr. Steel (07:11:19):
Give me one second.
Judge (07:11:20):
Okay.
Ray Lale (07:11:20):
I'm not propounding it, so I'll let him do it.
Mr. Steel (07:11:22):
Can I have one moment, Your Honor?
Judge (07:11:23):
Yes, sir.
Mr. Steel (07:11:41):
Is that it?
(07:11:41)
Your Honor, may I just have one moment?
Judge (07:11:42):
Sure.
Mr. Steel (07:11:42):
Thank you.
Speaker 12 (07:11:42):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (07:11:42):
Thank you.
(07:11:42)
Can you share with the prosecutor?
(07:11:42)
Yeah, of course.
Ray Lale (07:11:42):
Thank you.
Mr. Steel (07:11:42):
You're welcome.
Ray Lale (07:11:42):
I'm sorry?
Mr. Steel (07:12:52):
I didn't number, but I will [inaudible 07:12:43]. It should be a different date. This is 11/19. That might be... No, it may be the same exact one. It's the same one, it's just in a different... It's his cell. Right? [inaudible 07:12:55].
Ray Lale (07:12:57):
Is this the same date?
Mr. Steel (07:12:58):
Yeah.
Ray Lale (07:13:02):
Okay. So this is-
Mr. Steel (07:13:03):
It starts off same.
Ray Lale (07:13:03):
And what time? Okay. It's the same message now.
Mr. Steel (07:13:03):
I think it's the same message.
Ray Lale (07:13:05):
That's fine.
Mr. Steel (07:13:05):
But you said you just wanted his message, not the bubble, so it won't be that much better.
Ray Lale (07:13:10):
I guess. I mean, whatever, he's without a response from whoever. [inaudible 07:13:16].
Mr. Steel (07:13:16):
It's two different ones, but they're similar.
Ray Lale (07:13:21):
[inaudible 07:13:25].
Mr. Steel (07:13:24):
Yes.
Ray Lale (07:13:25):
That's fine. Okay.
Mr. Steel (07:13:28):
Can you just tell Detective Hardy, with the court's permission, what we're doing, 'cause he's going to want context this time?
Ray Lale (07:13:31):
Sure.
Mr. Steel (07:13:31):
[inaudible 07:13:31] took off the back. You can show the whole thing, if the court likes that.
Ray Lale (07:13:39):
It's not admitted yet, so I'd rather not show them, but I'll [inaudible 07:13:43].
Mr. Steel (07:13:40):
Okay.
Ray Lale (07:13:40):
Is that okay?
Mr. Steel (07:13:42):
With the court's permission.
Ray Lale (07:13:43):
Your Honor, may I step out just to let the witness know the parameters of court's ruling in recess?
Judge (07:13:50):
Yes, sir.
Ray Lale (07:13:50):
He has breached your ruling.
Judge (07:13:53):
Yes, sir.
Ray Lale (07:13:53):
Thank you.
Mr. Steel (07:14:06):
Okay. We sanitized, I guess.
Judge (07:14:38):
Okay.
Mr. Steel (07:14:39):
The State may now have an objection.
(07:14:40)
And then, Your Honor...
Ray Lale (07:17:04):
Your Honor, I explained to Detective Hardy the court's ruling about the first reversal of his prior ruling and the new ruling about the text messages. I'm not going to have an objection to the entry on the text messages. He asked me if I needed to talk to him about some other things and I said, "No." I don't want to talk to him while he's in the middle of his testimony, but we're ready to proceed.
Judge (07:17:26):
All right. Ready, Mr. Steel?
Mr. Steel (07:17:27):
Yes, sir.
Judge (07:17:27):
Jury, please.
Ray Lale (07:17:27):
May I call the detective?
Judge (07:17:27):
Please.
Ray Lale (07:17:27):
Okay. Thank you.
Judge (07:17:27):
All right, now let's resume.
Mr. Steel (07:17:27):
May I approach?
(07:17:27)
May I approach?
Witness (07:18:49):
Yes, sir.
Mr. Steel (07:18:49):
I'm showing you what has been marked as Ms. Boles number 118. If you could take a peek at that?
Witness (07:18:56):
Yes, sir.
Mr. Steel (07:18:59):
And do you recognize that as something that is from the phone of Mr. Akers?
Witness (07:19:05):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (07:19:06):
Your Honor, I move for the admission of 118, Ms. Boles.
Ray Lale (07:19:09):
No objection.
Mr. Steel (07:19:11):
Admitted. May I approach?
Judge (07:19:11):
Yes, sir.
Mr. Steel (07:19:13):
Thank you, sir. May I display it, Your Honor?
Judge (07:19:16):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (07:19:17):
Do you mind?
(07:19:17)
Can you blow up the bubble, if you don't mind? And you just saw it. I know it was quick, but this is a message from Dan Akers to another person, and once it's cleared up, we could see that person. And we know it's from Dan Akers. Could you see the 5462 number?
Witness (07:19:50):
Yes. Under the phone, and it says, "Owner."
Mr. Steel (07:19:53):
Yes. And then it's to... It says R.F. Knox, K-N-O-X. You see that?
Witness (07:20:00):
I see that, sir.
Mr. Steel (07:20:01):
And it reads on November 19th, 2019 at 4:35 in the afternoon, true?
Witness (07:20:12):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (07:20:13):
Okay. And it reads, "While I F up..." I mean, it's written out but, "F'd up and procrastinated, and most likely will get me laid off, but it is what it is. Probation gave till the end of the month to complete 32 hours of community service in order to get off." You see that?
Witness (07:20:38):
I see it.
Mr. Steel (07:20:39):
And then Mr. Akers wrote, "I know if they violate me, then it will violate my big probation, and they will most likely lock me up until 2024." You see that?
Witness (07:20:50):
That's what it reads.
Mr. Steel (07:20:52):
"I just wanted to get it all behind me." Right?
Witness (07:20:56):
Yes, sir.
Mr. Steel (07:20:58):
And it's just in that letter. "It's BS list they gave me, mostly has weekdays. Do I have tomorrow and Thursday? It's PHIT, possibly that's my fault for not wanting to take off for it earlier. And I know it's terrible timing, but I guess a layoff is better than jail for four years." Fair?
Witness (07:21:25):
That's what it reads, sir.
Mr. Steel (07:21:26):
Yeah. Okay. And that's Mr. Akers' writing, too. Do you know Mr. Knox being his employer?
Witness (07:21:33):
I do not.
Mr. Steel (07:21:36):
Okay. All right. Did you ever search Mr. Akers' phone at any time for-
Witness (07:21:48):
I went through some of the data that was provided to me.
Mr. Steel (07:21:53):
Were you ever shown, I guess, him taking images with his left hand or doing anything with his left hand? Did you ever see that on his phone?
Witness (07:22:04):
No, I can't recall anything.
Mr. Steel (07:22:05):
Okay. If it's there, you're not saying it-
Witness (07:22:07):
If it's there, I'm not saying. I can't recall anything.
Mr. Steel (07:22:10):
All right. That would be a different witness, not you?
Witness (07:22:14):
Yes, sir.
Mr. Steel (07:22:27):
True. Okay.
(07:22:27)
And you already testified you were unaware of the guns. Right? If there are guns on his phone, on Mr. Akers' phone?
Witness (07:22:35):
Yes. Yes. I've already testified to that.
Mr. Steel (07:22:37):
All right. The last question I want to ask you, if that's okay with you, is you remember a discussion with... And you can remove that if you want. A discussion with Lacy, that she stated that Mr. Akers was acting differently for the days before Sunday morning, December 22, 2019?
Witness (07:22:57):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (07:22:58):
And do you remember her mentioning the song entitled War, W-A-R, to you?
Witness (07:23:05):
I don't remember that, sir.
Mr. Steel (07:23:06):
Okay. Well, that may shorten our conversation. Did you ever look up the lyrics or do any research into that song?
Witness (07:23:15):
No, sir.
Mr. Steel (07:23:16):
All right. Your Honor, I don't believe I have any more questions.
Judge (07:23:20):
All right. Redirect.
Ray Lale (07:23:20):
I need that last picture back, please. Can you tell me? [inaudible 07:23:39]. It is Boles 118. So Detective Hardy, if you have to stand up, please do so that you see what I'm referencing. You may not be able to see it on your screen, but I got a little pointer. Do you see on Boles', the Defendant's 119, where it says in the bottom right that this was apparently sent November 19th, 2019?
Witness (07:24:03):
I do, sir.
Ray Lale (07:24:04):
Okay. Do you know the status of Mr. Akers having caught up on all his probation requirements in the next month of his life?
Witness (07:24:12):
I do not.
Ray Lale (07:24:13):
So you don't know if he was caught up with his community service?
Witness (07:24:16):
I do not, sir.
Ray Lale (07:24:17):
Do you know if he was caught up with any kind of evaluations or testings, or anything else he had to do, his fine payments? Do you know anything about whether or not he was caught up in that next 20 or 32, 33 days?
Witness (07:24:30):
No, sir.
Ray Lale (07:24:31):
No idea?
Witness (07:24:32):
No idea.
Ray Lale (07:24:38):
All right. And then do you see here where it says R.F. Knox?
Witness (07:24:44):
Yes, sir.
Ray Lale (07:24:45):
Do you remember speaking with Dan's family members at all to know that R.F. Knox was the name of his company that he worked for?
Witness (07:24:53):
I believe so. Yes, sir.
Ray Lale (07:24:55):
And do you know, from the nature or the context of this text or email, is it fair that Dwight Eason seems to be some sort of supervisor, because Mr. Akers seems to be asking for more time in the daytime to do community service?
Witness (07:25:09):
Yes.
Ray Lale (07:25:17):
And you were shown a picture by the Defense. I think it's Defendant's Exhibit 139. You were shown this on cross-examination, this sweatshirt. Do you remember seeing that?
Witness (07:25:40):
Yes.
Ray Lale (07:25:42):
It has a symbol on it?
Witness (07:25:43):
Yes, sir.
Ray Lale (07:25:44):
Isn't that the R.F. Knox symbol for his employer?
Witness (07:25:48):
I believe so.
Ray Lale (07:25:50):
Are you familiar with people getting sweatshirts or hoodies from their employer, multiple?
Witness (07:25:55):
Yes.
Ray Lale (07:25:56):
Have you ever encountered that in your life?
Witness (07:25:57):
Yes.
Ray Lale (07:25:58):
Can we have the lights back up a little bit? Thank you. And do you think it would be unusual that this defendant might have gotten some sweatshirts with his company logo and give one to his spouse, kids, whatever, family members?
Witness (07:26:11):
No.
Ray Lale (07:26:16):
You were asked about DNA testing on a gun. Do you remember being asked that?
Witness (07:26:20):
Yes, sir.
Ray Lale (07:26:21):
And Mr. Steel, the Defense asked you, "Was there a request to do DNA testing on the gun?" Do you remember?
Witness (07:26:27):
I believe so. Yes, sir.
Ray Lale (07:26:28):
And then Mr. Steel asked you, "What would ever happen with that?" And you said, "Well, GBI refused the testing." Do you remember that?
Witness (07:26:34):
I do.
Ray Lale (07:26:35):
Do you remember that being because their position was it was not a surface where DNA could normally be gathered from? Do you remember that?
Witness (07:26:41):
Correct.
Ray Lale (07:26:43):
Okay. And you didn't go out? Did you go out anywhere else, the FBI, or as Mr. Steel suggested, CIA to get that done?
Witness (07:26:50):
No.
Ray Lale (07:26:50):
I wanted to take a moment to look at these keys again, sir. I'll show opposing counsel what's been marked and entered into evidence as Defendant's Exhibit 88. Okay. May I publish 88, please, Your Honor?
Judge (07:27:24):
Yes, sir. It's in evidence.
Ray Lale (07:27:25):
It's in evidence, Your Honor. And just to save time, Your Honor, may I dispense with permission to publish from here on? Thank you, Your Honor. If you can show the jury what's been previously admitted into evidence as the Defense Exhibit 88. Go down a little bit and show those keys in the lock. Okay? So Detective Hardy, were these the keys that were obtained from this defendant on March 5th, 2020?
Witness (07:27:54):
Yes, sir.
Ray Lale (07:27:54):
Okay. May I approach the witness, please?
Judge (07:27:59):
Yes.
Ray Lale (07:28:00):
I want to show you, sir, what's been admitted into evidence as State's Exhibit 197. I want you to look at it. Okay?
Witness (07:28:10):
Yes, sir.
Ray Lale (07:28:12):
I want you to pick it up, show the front of it to the jury, if may him you do so, Your Honor?
Judge (07:28:22):
Yes.
Ray Lale (07:28:22):
Okay. May he step down just to the rail?
Judge (07:28:25):
Fine.
Ray Lale (07:28:25):
Thank you. That's fine. At the corner of the rail, I want you to show that State's 197 to the jury, okay? Now, I want you to go back to your seat and put it down on the witness box stand. I don't think there's any biohazard or anything with 197, so take that key off the front. Peel it off, peel off that tape. Is that the key that was on that key ring on March 5th, 2020?
Witness (07:29:00):
Yes.
Ray Lale (07:29:00):
Is that the key that was on this defendant's key ring?
Witness (07:29:04):
Yes. There's even some marks on the key that coincide with the picture.
Ray Lale (07:29:08):
Okay. Let me show the jury that key on the projector. Is that the key-
Witness (07:29:19):
Yes.
Ray Lale (07:29:19):
... with that conspicuous, angled head?
Witness (07:29:22):
Yes.
Ray Lale (07:29:23):
I'm going to show the jury, please publish to Detective Hardy what's been marked and admitted into evidence as State's Exhibit 100. Were these the keys that you know to have been removed from the floor of the basement on December 22nd, 2019?
Witness (07:29:41):
Yes.
Ray Lale (07:29:43):
Show the jury where that weird angled-head key is on this key ring.
Witness (07:29:49):
I don't see it.
Ray Lale (07:29:50):
It's not on there, is it, sir?
Witness (07:29:51):
No.
Ray Lale (07:29:58):
Daniel Akers didn't have that key on his key chain that was on the floor of that house, did he?
Witness (07:30:04):
No.
Ray Lale (07:30:10):
Sticking with State's Exhibit 100, I want to show you, if you'll concentrate on the... Investigator Burke, it's a little bit tough to see on the projector, but if you can zoom in as far as you can on the clip, the buckle. Or maybe zoom out. There you go. That's good. That's good.
Witness (07:30:31):
Whoa.
Ray Lale (07:30:31):
Okay. Still on State's Exhibit 100. Detective Hardy, if you can stand up. Do you see the bright blue right here of this key chain, this key clip? Do you see that bright blue fabric?
Witness (07:30:51):
I do, sir.
Ray Lale (07:30:52):
And I'll show you what's been marked and admitted into evidence as Defendant's 88. See this faded blue right here?
Witness (07:31:04):
I do.
Ray Lale (07:31:04):
You see this stain right here, or the rip or tear, or whatever that imperfection is on the defendant's key chain?
Witness (07:31:11):
I do.
Ray Lale (07:31:11):
Do you see that anywhere on Boles, I mean Mr. Aker's key chain that was found on December 22nd? Is that tear, that stain on that set of keys?
Witness (07:31:22):
No, sir.
Ray Lale (07:31:24):
Do you see on this, the Defendant's key chain on March 5th, 2020, you see this as a Ingles card, Ingles loyalty card?
Witness (07:31:34):
I do.
Ray Lale (07:31:36):
Where's the Kroger card on this? The defendant's key chain on March 5th, 2020. Where's the Kroger card here, sir?
Witness (07:31:45):
I don't see one.
Ray Lale (07:31:45):
Not there, is it? But the Kroger card's on Daniel Akers' key chain from December 22nd, 2019. Is that right?
Witness (07:31:55):
Correct.
Ray Lale (07:31:56):
All right. The Defense asked you, the Defense attorney asked you, "What evidence do you have, sir, that she did not open the safe with the key?" Do you remember that?
Witness (07:32:25):
Yes.
Ray Lale (07:32:30):
I'm sorry, sir. Let me take that. I apologize. State's 197 will go back to the evidence table. Sorry. And then let me keep the key with it just so it doesn't get lost. [inaudible 07:32:46]. Thank you. I'll just lay it on top and I'll tape it back later, Detective Hardy.
(07:32:51)
So, the Defense asked you, "What evidence do you have that this defendant did not use..." Sorry. "What evidence do you have that she did not open the key with the safe, the safe with a key? "What evidence do you have that she did not use a key to open the safe?" You said, "None." Right?
Witness (07:33:08):
Yes, sir.
Ray Lale (07:33:09):
Do you have any evidence that she opened the safe without a key?
Witness (07:33:14):
No.
Ray Lale (07:33:28):
I just want you to tell the jury, sir, in your own words, you were there. We weren't. Nobody was. You were there, this defendant was there. Just tell the jury what happened with that key chain that we saw just now, the Defendant's key chain on March 5th, 2020. What did she do constantly, time to time, once or twice? Just tell the jury in your own words what she did when you asked her, "Do you have a key to this safe?"
Witness (07:33:57):
She said she'd never had a key to the safe. And then as I asked her to go with me to the sheriff's office for the interview, she grabbed her purse, grabbed the set of keys. She put it in the purse. Then she tried to take her purse. I said, "Lacy, you don't need the purse. Leave everything right here. You're going to ride with me." She again tried to grab the purse.
Ray Lale (07:34:19):
It was twice?
Witness (07:34:21):
Twice.
Ray Lale (07:34:22):
All right. What did you say when she tries to grab the purse again?
Witness (07:34:26):
Again, I said, "We need to leave that stuff here. The deputies may need to lock the house up before we leave if we're not finished and they're finished."
Ray Lale (07:34:37):
All right.
Ray Lale (07:35:00):
I want to show you page two of defendant's Exhibit 117, Police Detective Hardy. Page two of defendant's 117. Do you remember being asked about these messages or this message from Daniel Akers to this defendant?
Witness (07:35:47):
I do.
Ray Lale (07:35:47):
Okay. Do you remember this independently of that questioning? Do you remember this message being from either the defendant's phone, the decedent's phone, or both?
Witness (07:35:59):
I think it was both.
Ray Lale (07:36:00):
Okay. If you go all the way so I can see the [inaudible 07:36:03] the last line, sir. All the way up. Keep going. Keep going. There you go. So I want you to see this. I want to make sure I understand this. So was this decedent to defendant, Daniel to defendant?
Witness (07:36:19):
Yes.
Ray Lale (07:36:21):
"It's time to realize this is not going to work and move on with our lives while still young." Is that what you understand Daniel wrote to this defendant?
Witness (07:36:33):
I do.
Ray Lale (07:36:34):
On Halloween?
Witness (07:36:38):
Correct.
Ray Lale (07:36:40):
Move on with our lives while we're still young. Is that it?
Witness (07:36:45):
That's it, sir.
Ray Lale (07:36:50):
Did you see any text messages back and forth between the decedent, Daniel Akers and this defendant? You had a chance to look at the messages, didn't you?
Witness (07:37:04):
Yes, sir.
Ray Lale (07:37:07):
I guess. Did you find them important or relevant?
Witness (07:37:10):
The ones of that day, yes.
Ray Lale (07:37:12):
Most importantly that day, but-
Witness (07:37:14):
Yes.
Ray Lale (07:37:15):
... others, Halloween, were they relevant to you?
Witness (07:37:16):
Were they relevant?
Ray Lale (07:37:17):
Yeah. Were they important to your investigation? I mean, you want to look at all the messages.
Witness (07:37:23):
Yes.
Ray Lale (07:37:23):
Okay. Tell the jury how many messages you saw from Daniel to this defendant that said, "That's it. My life is over. I'm ending my life." How many?
Witness (07:37:35):
Zero.
Ray Lale (07:37:38):
Tell the jury how many messages in all these hundreds of messages you saw in connection with your investigation, how many times Dan Akers said, "Oh, you'll be sorry when I'm dead," for example.
Witness (07:37:48):
Zero.
Ray Lale (07:37:49):
Anything like that, sir?
Witness (07:37:50):
No.
Ray Lale (07:37:55):
How many messages did you see, sir, that said, "I'm just going to end it all and then you'll be sorry."
Witness (07:38:02):
None.
Ray Lale (07:38:08):
Did it look instead to you, sir, that they were just ending the relationship? [inaudible 07:38:13]?
Witness (07:38:14):
That's what it appeared to me.
Ray Lale (07:38:15):
On both sides. This Mr. Steele asked you on cross-examination, on both sides?
Witness (07:38:19):
Yes, it was on both sides.
Ray Lale (07:38:21):
Okay. And do you remember a message from Daniel to this defendant that says, "Hey, I'm doing me." Do you remember that?
Witness (07:38:28):
That's the day of the incident or earlier that day.
Ray Lale (07:38:32):
Or maybe the day before he died, but we know he died at 12:30 AM on the 22nd, so maybe that was from the 21st.
Witness (07:38:38):
The 21st, yes.
Ray Lale (07:38:40):
"I'm doing me. It's time for me to do me." Do you remember that?
Witness (07:38:43):
I do remember, yeah.
Ray Lale (07:38:44):
Did you see it? "It's time for me to end me." Do you see that?
Witness (07:38:48):
No.
Ray Lale (07:39:09):
Did you see a message, sir, on 12/21 or earlier that said, that Mr. Steele asked you about, just said, "I can't deal with you anymore." Did you see that? "I can't deal with you anymore." The decedent, Daniel Akers, to this defendant?
Witness (07:39:30):
Yes.
Ray Lale (07:39:31):
Did he say, and I want to be clear on the language, "I can't deal with you anymore." Is that accurate?
Witness (07:39:35):
Yes.
Ray Lale (07:39:36):
Did he say, "I can't deal with life anymore"?
Witness (07:39:39):
No.
Ray Lale (07:39:43):
Did he say... Do you remember him saying, "Let's just make it through the holidays?"
Witness (07:39:48):
Yes.
Ray Lale (07:39:48):
And that was sent around when? Halloween?
Witness (07:39:52):
I believe it was the Halloween one.
Ray Lale (07:39:53):
"Let's just make it through the holiday season."
Witness (07:39:55):
Yes.
Ray Lale (07:39:56):
Would that imply to you a future thought of orientation or future beyond the holidays?
Witness (07:40:02):
Yes.
Ray Lale (07:40:11):
Now there's this concept, sir, this idea that there was, we call it fake urine, but obviously you know maybe it's urine, but it's somebody else's, right?
Witness (07:40:24):
Correct.
Ray Lale (07:40:24):
You heard testimony about that. He asked you about that.
Witness (07:40:27):
Yes.
Ray Lale (07:40:27):
Ms. Boles, this defendant said, "Hey, he had fake..." I think she called it pee. "He had fake pee in his car. Skyler found it, my daughter." Do you remember that?
Witness (07:40:39):
I don't remember the name, but yes.
Ray Lale (07:40:40):
"My daughter found it."
Witness (07:40:41):
Yes.
Ray Lale (07:40:42):
Okay. Sir, you've been a police officer how many years now?
Witness (07:40:47):
26.
Ray Lale (07:40:48):
Been involved with courts every now and then? Yes?
Witness (07:40:51):
Yes.
Ray Lale (07:40:51):
Revocations every now and then?
Witness (07:40:53):
Yes.
Ray Lale (07:40:53):
Probation problems every now and then. Aren't you familiar with urine having to have a certain temperature, a temperature of a human if you're going to use this urine?
Witness (07:41:04):
Yes.
Ray Lale (07:41:04):
Are you familiar with any detective involved in this investigation before or since, before your involvement, since your involvement, during your involvement that found bags of fake urine in Mr. Akers' Cadillac?
Witness (07:41:28):
Nothing was ever told to me, sir.
Ray Lale (07:41:44):
Well, Mr. Steele, he asked you, "What evidence do you have that that cup wasn't accidental... That McDonald's cup wasn't accidentally just kicked over?" You remember him asking that?
Witness (07:41:56):
Yes.
Ray Lale (07:41:57):
So he asked you, "What evidence do you have that the McDonald's cup wasn't just placed on the floor gingerly and some EMT or some police officer just happened to kick it over?" Do you remember being asked that?
Witness (07:42:11):
I do, sir.
Ray Lale (07:42:13):
And you said, "Sir, I don't have any evidence that that cup wasn't just accidentally kicked over." You understand that your answer, "I don't."
Witness (07:42:18):
Yes.
Ray Lale (07:42:24):
Sir, tell the jury what evidence do you have that shows that Mr. Akers wasn't just assassinated and drops everything in his hand. What evidence do you have that says that's not what happened? You don't have anything?
Witness (07:42:46):
No.
Ray Lale (07:42:47):
Those keys, hat, McDonald's bag, cup, stills ice, ice still fresh. Do you have any evidence, sir, that that's not how that cup got there?
Witness (07:43:03):
No.
Ray Lale (07:43:04):
That that's not how that McDonald's bag lands right by its leg with uneaten food in it. Do you have that evidence?
Witness (07:43:12):
No.
Ray Lale (07:43:12):
Do you have any evidence that he's not holding his keys, the McDonald's bag, the cup walking in and just drops it because he's ambushed? Do you have any of that evidence?
Witness (07:43:25):
No.
Ray Lale (07:43:29):
But you were asked, did you go to McDonald's and get another cup just like the cup you had and go out and fill it up with whatever drink might have been there and do these experiments? You were asked that?
Witness (07:43:40):
Yes, sir.
Ray Lale (07:43:41):
Did you do that, sir? Did you do little experiments?
Witness (07:43:44):
No, I wouldn't have known what level to put the cup at or any... Yeah, no.
Ray Lale (07:43:52):
I mean, you're not a physicist or a scientist?
Witness (07:43:53):
No, sir.
Ray Lale (07:44:06):
Okay. Mr. Steele asked you, did you have any evidence, sir, that she did not... This defendant did not go back downstairs? You said, "I don't believe... It's my belief she did not go downstairs." Do you remember saying that?
Witness (07:44:17):
Yes, sir.
Ray Lale (07:44:18):
And he asked you, "Well, what evidence do you have that she did not go downstairs?" "None." Right? Is that what you said?
Witness (07:44:25):
Yes, sir.
Ray Lale (07:44:26):
Well, what evidence, sir, do you have that she did go downstairs again?
Witness (07:44:31):
None.
Ray Lale (07:44:32):
None. Tell the jury, sir, on what part of the video... I'm sorry, the 911 audio, what part of that audio... It's about, what, nine minutes or so, would you agree?
Witness (07:44:49):
Yes, sir.
Ray Lale (07:44:49):
Tell the jury on what part of that audio tape, sir, and the jury will have it, jury can listen to it again in deliberations if they want to, but tell the jury in evidence and open evidence here, on what part of those nine minutes does a 911 operator tell this defendant, "Pick up the gun and throw it?"
Witness (07:45:11):
Never.
Ray Lale (07:45:12):
What part of those nine minutes does the operator say, "You need to pick up the gun," at all?
Witness (07:45:18):
None.
Ray Lale (07:45:19):
"Do what's best for your safety." Is that what the person said?
Witness (07:45:22):
Yes.
Ray Lale (07:45:24):
But this defendant, am I right, did she tell you that she was told to pick up this gun and get ready to throw it or move it?
Witness (07:45:32):
Yes.
Ray Lale (07:45:33):
Is that on there to your knowledge that you're listening to it?
Witness (07:45:36):
No.
Ray Lale (07:45:39):
And the gun, if I'm right, sir, and I just asked you in the form of the question, was the final resting place of the gun on the floor underneath Mr. Akers' left hand?
Witness (07:45:53):
Yes.
Ray Lale (07:45:54):
Was it even his... The webbing between his left thumb and index finger, was it even touching that stock of that [inaudible 07:46:02]?
Witness (07:46:03):
I don't believe so.
Ray Lale (07:46:04):
You don't think so?
Witness (07:46:04):
No, I don't.
Ray Lale (07:46:05):
Was it touch... Was any part of his hand touching it? Because you said it was under his hand.
Witness (07:46:09):
It was under, yes. I believe it might have been touching at some point.
Ray Lale (07:46:12):
His thumb?
Witness (07:46:13):
Thumb, yes.
Ray Lale (07:46:13):
You were asked a lot of parts about the 911 tape and I'd like to do the same. I'd like to go through a few portions of it with State's Exhibit 2. Investigator Burke, do you still have that?
Investigator Burke (07:46:33):
Yes, sir.
Ray Lale (07:46:34):
Can you please prepare State's Exhibit Two, sir? Okay. And let me ask you this. There was... I think Mr. Steele, the defense asked you, did it appear that this was a harrowing or stressful, obviously stressful event based on this defendant's demeanor on the 911 tape? Do you remember being asked something like that?
Witness (07:47:04):
Yes.
Ray Lale (07:47:04):
And you said, "Yeah. It seemed like she was stressed out or this awful thing," right? Do you remember that?
Witness (07:47:12):
Yes. I believe I said she was acting hysterical.
Ray Lale (07:47:14):
Hysterical, that was your word. Sorry, I couldn't remember. So hysterical. Sir, have you had an opportunity to review other 911 tapes in your career?
Witness (07:47:25):
Yes.
Ray Lale (07:47:25):
Have you ever heard somebody be hysterical on one before?
Witness (07:47:30):
No.
Ray Lale (07:47:32):
You've never seen somebody be upset and hysterical on a 911 tape?
Witness (07:47:36):
Not on a 911 tape, not like that.
Ray Lale (07:47:37):
Okay. Have you heard people be upset on a 911 tape?
Witness (07:47:40):
Yes.
Ray Lale (07:47:41):
Okay. Have you heard people be upset on a 911 tape, maybe out of breath?
Witness (07:47:46):
Yes.
Ray Lale (07:47:51):
And even people-
Speaker 13 (07:47:52):
Your Honor, I apologize. I'd like to move it along, but every question's leading. I will now start objecting. I'm objecting to that last question.
Ray Lale (07:48:01):
Have you heard other people be upset on a 911 tape does not suggest an answer to yes or no.
Judge (07:48:06):
Okay. I'll overrule that.
Ray Lale (07:48:08):
So have you heard people be upset and out of sorts and hysterical and confused on 911 tapes?
Witness (07:48:16):
Yes.
Ray Lale (07:48:17):
Have you heard people even do that, that later confess to committing the crime?
Witness (07:48:21):
Yes.
Speaker 13 (07:48:23):
Objection, relevance.
Ray Lale (07:48:24):
Relevance is there's nothing independently-
Judge (07:48:29):
I'll overrule the objection.
Ray Lale (07:48:30):
Thank you. May I please, Investigator Burke, have you play State's Exhibit 2, 640 to 710, please? I want you to listen to this, Detective Hardy, carefully.
AUDIO: 911 Call (07:49:06):
Can I get [inaudible 07:49:07].
Ray Lale (07:49:18):
So it's 6:40 to 7:10 and it looks like the volume was less than half. Can you turn it up please? 6:40 to 7:10. And if you just listen to this detective, please. Thank you.
AUDIO: 911 Call (07:49:29):
[inaudible 07:49:30].
Ray Lale (07:49:30):
Stop. Stopping at 7: 10. Did you hear that?
Witness (07:50:08):
Yes, sir.
Ray Lale (07:50:10):
Did you hear this defendant say, "Oh, please help me?"
Witness (07:50:14):
Yes, multiple times.
Ray Lale (07:50:15):
How many times? A dozen?
Witness (07:50:17):
There's multiple times in the 911 call total that she says, "Please help me."
Ray Lale (07:50:22):
We heard that, remember?
Witness (07:50:24):
Yes.
Ray Lale (07:50:29):
I want you to tell these people how many times on that 911 tape this defendant said, "Oh God, help Dan."
Witness (07:50:42):
Zero.
Ray Lale (07:50:44):
"Hurry. He needs help." How many times did she say that?
Witness (07:50:48):
"Never."
Ray Lale (07:50:49):
"You better get here. You got to help him." How many times did she say that?
Witness (07:50:54):
Never.
Ray Lale (07:50:56):
"Just help me. Help me."
Witness (07:50:59):
Yes.
Ray Lale (07:50:59):
Do you remember this defendant on the 911 tape being asked, "Can you go back down there and do CPR?" Do you remember that?
Witness (07:51:13):
Yes.
Ray Lale (07:51:13):
Being asked by the operator?
Witness (07:51:15):
Yes.
Ray Lale (07:51:15):
And do you remember this defendant, her husband down there having been shot? Do you remember her saying, "No, don't make me go back."
Witness (07:51:36):
Yes.
Ray Lale (07:51:37):
Go back to the messages just a minute. The messages between the parties, you looked at the messages, you said you had an opportunity to analyze the messages, review them both ways back and forth. Did you see the one message about in the time period you searched through the one message, "I'm sad, I'm depressed, I'm lonely," from Dan Akers?
Witness (07:52:00):
Yes.
Ray Lale (07:52:01):
Any other messages like that, even remotely like that on his phone? "I'm sad, lonely, depressed"?
Witness (07:52:07):
Not that I can recall.
Ray Lale (07:52:10):
So one, in how many months that you reviewed?
Witness (07:52:14):
I think I went back to around September on Lacy's phone.
Ray Lale (07:52:19):
September of 2019?
Witness (07:52:20):
'19.
Ray Lale (07:52:20):
Would you say that there were... How many messages would you say there were hundreds, thousands?
Witness (07:52:29):
There's hundreds.
Ray Lale (07:52:30):
And that was... That one message that the defense highlighted, "I'm sad, lonely, and depressed," is that the only one you saw?
Witness (07:52:36):
That's the only one I recall that the defense brought up.
Ray Lale (07:52:43):
There's been so much talk, examination and concentration and focus on the sink. I'm not going to go back into the photographs or anything like that, but there was evidence or questioning brought to you by the defense. There were the kids in the house, the defendant's mother was in the house. Did you... What evidence do you have that those people did not use the sink? Do you remember being asked that?
Witness (07:53:10):
Yes, sir.
Ray Lale (07:53:11):
Your answer, "I don't have any evidence that they did not... That they are not the ones that used the sink," right?
Witness (07:53:16):
Correct.
Ray Lale (07:53:17):
So they could have been.
Witness (07:53:18):
Yes, sir.
Ray Lale (07:53:20):
But you specifically asked this... Did you specifically ask this defendant about the nature or the origin of blood in the sink?
Witness (07:53:27):
I did.
Ray Lale (07:53:28):
And her response, sir, was it not... What did she say there? What was the origin or the source of blood in the sink according to this defendant when you asked her?
Witness (07:53:39):
She said if there was any blood in the sink, it was because she was on her period.
Ray Lale (07:53:43):
That was menstrual blood, according to this defendant?
Witness (07:53:45):
Yes.
Ray Lale (07:53:53):
There was some question about a hair dye was on the sink. Did you see that hair dye that had been opened at all?
Witness (07:54:00):
I couldn't tell from the pictures. No, sir.
Ray Lale (07:54:02):
Well, when you opened it, I guess... I mean, I used hair dye, but I guess when you open it's got some kind of a... I guess it's got some kind of a bottle in it or some bag of color on it. I don't know. I guess there's something in that box, right?
Witness (07:54:15):
Yes.
Ray Lale (07:54:17):
Did you see things that were around that hair dye that looked like they might have been used that were associated with that hair dye?
Witness (07:54:23):
No.
Ray Lale (07:54:23):
I mean, we saw the picture, you had the cleaner and then the box. Did you see any kind of bottles or empty bottles, half empty bottles of hair dye?
Witness (07:54:32):
No.
Ray Lale (07:54:33):
Do you have any suspicion that Amanda Carter mistook blood in the sink for some kind of hair dye in the sink?
Witness (07:54:49):
No.
Ray Lale (07:54:49):
The defense attorney asked you on cross examination if there was some communication with Dr. Lehman that this defendant... Excuse me, this decedent was happy, was generally happy. Do you remember that?
Witness (07:55:01):
Yes.
Ray Lale (07:55:03):
And the defense, the Honorable Brian Steele, he said to you he was really fighting with his spouse. And did you tell Dr. Lehman that? Do you remember that?
Witness (07:55:13):
Yes.
Ray Lale (07:55:13):
So was he fighting with his spouse?
Witness (07:55:15):
They were... Yes.
Ray Lale (07:55:19):
Have you had an opportunity to see people fight and go back and forth with their spouse without committing suicide, sir?
Witness (07:55:27):
Yes.
Ray Lale (07:55:28):
Would you say that committing suicide is kind of extreme if you're just fighting with your spouse?
Witness (07:55:34):
Yes.
Ray Lale (07:55:36):
And speaking of stuff like that, let me ask you this. Speaking... This is incredibly important. Speaking of stuff that you told Dr. Lehman, okay? Speaking specifically of stuff you told Dr. Lehman, stuff Lieutenant Mike Hill told Dr. Lehman, stuff anybody told Dr. Lehman, okay? Is it true, sir? Did you know that-
Speaker 13 (07:55:56):
Objection to leading.
Ray Lale (07:55:57):
Did Mr... Did the medical examiner... I don't think this is a leading question. Did the medical examiner, to your knowledge, have full access to the entire sheriff's office file before making his final determination on manner of death?
Witness (07:56:13):
I believe so.
Ray Lale (07:56:15):
Did he ask you, and maybe he didn't because you came in later, but did he ask you, "I really need all of the information you have, all the case files."
Witness (07:56:25):
Yes, I believe.
Ray Lale (07:56:27):
And did he ask Ogden earlier on, "Something's not right about this. Can you forward me all your file?"
Witness (07:56:33):
Yes.
Speaker 13 (07:56:34):
I'm going to object to confrontation clause, hearsay, leading.
Ray Lale (07:56:41):
I'll rephrase it. Did the medical examiner make a request of Detective Ogden to get the entire file?
Speaker 13 (07:56:49):
Objection, hearsay.
Ray Lale (07:56:50):
That doesn't... That's not even a statement. It was a request for the file made.
Witness (07:56:56):
I'm not sure.
Judge (07:56:57):
Overruled the objection as to hearsay.
Ray Lale (07:56:59):
Did Dr. Lehman request that the file of the Paulding County Sheriff's Office be forwarded to him from Ogden?
Witness (07:57:05):
I can't recall for sure, but I know we at least sent initially the crime scene photos.
Ray Lale (07:57:12):
Okay. And did anybody... Did you send the reports, do you remember?
Witness (07:57:14):
I don't recall, sir.
Ray Lale (07:57:16):
Do you remember sending the contents of the phone messages?
Witness (07:57:20):
No.
Ray Lale (07:57:20):
Okay. Do you remember sending the file at all?
Witness (07:57:22):
No.
Ray Lale (07:57:23):
The totality of the file?
Witness (07:57:25):
No.
Ray Lale (07:57:25):
You don't remember? Did Ogden?
Witness (07:57:27):
I don't remember, sir.
Ray Lale (07:57:28):
Okay. We'll ask Lehman. Thank you. The defendant told you in the interview, sir, your interview, Ogden's interview with her, or both perhaps. Do you remember the defendant saying that Dan was acting paranoid?
Witness (07:58:19):
Yes.
Ray Lale (07:58:20):
Do you remember anything about the defendant stating to you, sir, that Dan believed that he was on a reality TV show and this defendant was part of it, and that she was recording him for this reality show?
Witness (07:58:34):
She said something to that effect about the microphones and...
Ray Lale (07:58:37):
This defendant said that to you?
Witness (07:58:39):
Yes.
Ray Lale (07:58:40):
Do you remember that?
Witness (07:58:41):
Yes.
Ray Lale (07:58:42):
In all those messages you reviewed, sir, on this decedent's phone, on the victim's phone, the defendant's phone, tell the jury how many messages there were Dan saying he was on a reality show and being watched by others.
Witness (07:58:57):
None.
Ray Lale (07:59:39):
Let me show you, again, let me reference you for the record to State's Exhibit 185, specifically message number 20. Specifically, sir, message number 20 on State's Exhibit 185. Message number 20. Who is that from and who is that to? 20.
Witness (08:00:26):
It's from... It's from Mr. Akers to Ms. Boles.
Ray Lale (08:00:31):
This is Akers to the defendant, right?
Witness (08:00:33):
Yes.
Ray Lale (08:00:35):
12/21/19. Is that what it says?
Witness (08:00:37):
Yes, sir.
Ray Lale (08:00:38):
So nine hours before he would die. Is that right?
Witness (08:00:43):
Yes, sir.
Ray Lale (08:00:44):
And read this.
Witness (08:00:47):
I'm sorry-
Ray Lale (08:00:47):
"Either you mature to that, knock the games off, so we can be happy and possibly have something one day." Is that what it said?
Witness (08:00:58):
Yes, sir. That's what it says.
Ray Lale (08:00:59):
"So we could possibly have something one day," right?
Witness (08:01:05):
Yes, sir.
Ray Lale (08:01:06):
And did he write this nine hours before he supposedly committed suicide, sir?
Witness (08:01:11):
Yes.
Ray Lale (08:01:11):
You were asked about a purchase at Tractor Supply and there was a decline, looked like the pig food was returned. Do you remember being asked that?
Witness (08:01:49):
Yes, sir.
Ray Lale (08:01:49):
And then once the pig food was returned, there was some kind of a ratcheting wrench or something that was attempted to be purchased. Do you remember being asked about that?
Witness (08:01:56):
I do, sir.
Ray Lale (08:01:57):
And then the defense brought out that even with the return, once the wrench was attempted to be purchased, there was a decline. Do you remember that?
Witness (08:02:07):
Yes, sir.
Ray Lale (08:02:09):
And do you remember, sir, finding a number or Ogden finding a number of cards in the defense... Excuse me, the decedent's squad?
Witness (08:02:17):
I do believe so. I believe there was a number of credit cards or different cards.
Ray Lale (08:02:21):
Several different cards.
Speaker 13 (08:02:21):
Objection, leading.
Ray Lale (08:02:24):
How many cards were there?
Witness (08:02:26):
I don't know, sir.
Ray Lale (08:02:27):
Were there multiple?
Witness (08:02:28):
Yes.
Ray Lale (08:02:29):
Do you remember finding or members of your team finding the receipt bag? In fact, the receipt bag is in evidence here as defense exhibit... Excuse me, State's Exhibit 22. Do you remember finding this racetrack bag of receipts?
Witness (08:02:42):
Yes, sir.
Ray Lale (08:02:43):
Do you remember whether or not there were receipts from multiple different banks?
Witness (08:02:50):
I believe there was, yes.
Ray Lale (08:02:52):
Multiple different credit companies, credit card companies?
Witness (08:02:55):
Yes.
Ray Lale (08:02:55):
Do you remember that?
Witness (08:02:56):
Yes, sir.
Ray Lale (08:03:23):
Do you know whether or not the pig was actually purchased?
Witness (08:03:26):
I don't know.
Ray Lale (08:03:28):
Do you remember, and it may have been after the phone was broken and you had left, did you ever have access to a photograph of a bunch of pigs, little pigs in a cage, little miniature pigs like pets, on this decedent's phone?
Witness (08:03:40):
I do remember seeing that photo.
Ray Lale (08:03:42):
Okay. Did those look like pet pigs to you?
Witness (08:03:44):
Yes.
Ray Lale (08:03:44):
For sale?
Witness (08:03:45):
Yes.
Ray Lale (08:03:47):
And that was on whose phone?
Witness (08:03:50):
I believe it was on Dan's phone, sir.
Ray Lale (08:04:06):
Okay. Let me ask you this. Can you show opposing counsel please for the record what I'll mark for identification purposes only as State's Exhibit 215 and 216?
(08:04:53)
Thank you. May I approach your witness, please?
Judge (08:04:56):
Yes.
Ray Lale (08:04:57):
Sir, let me show you what's been marked for identification purposes... Only as State's Exhibit 215 and 216. And take a look at these and see if you recognize them at all.
Witness (08:05:12):
Yes, it's pictures that were taken during the search warrant.
Ray Lale (08:05:16):
Okay. Do you believe that those pictures 215 and 216 accurately depict what was found shown to you later as being discovered at the [inaudible 08:05:26] home during the execution of the search warrant?
Witness (08:05:28):
Yes.
Ray Lale (08:05:30):
Do you believe Detective Parker, excuse me, Detective Pouch that was out there photographing, do you believe he conducted a thorough photographic documentation of the scene as he found it?
Witness (08:05:41):
Yes.
Ray Lale (08:05:42):
Did he go room by room?
Witness (08:05:43):
Yes.
Ray Lale (08:05:44):
Okay. Anything different about 215, State's 215 and 216 that make it not accurate as to what was recovered and shown to you as far as being recovered during the search warrant execution?
Witness (08:05:55):
Not that I can see, sir.
Ray Lale (08:05:57):
Respectfully, move the court to admit into evidence what's been marked for identification purposes only as State's Exhibit 215 and 216.
Speaker 13 (08:06:04):
We don't object.
Ray Lale (08:06:07):
Now that that's in evidence, let me show you a 215 and 216 on the screen and just show me if you know, tell the jury if you know what 215 depicts, sir. Do you know what that is?
Witness (08:06:24):
It looks like a box to a toy and then there's some bags. It's in a, I think like a crawl space or a little closet that I believe was downstairs.
Ray Lale (08:06:35):
Specifically over to the left side, you got neon green and some brown things. What is that?
Witness (08:06:41):
It's like a traffic vest or a safety vest, I don't know, and then a jacket.
Ray Lale (08:06:47):
216. State's 216, a little better viewpoint on it perhaps, sir. Do you see what that is now?
Witness (08:06:59):
Yes. It's a Dickey's work jacket, I believe. And then the neon worker, construction worker type vest.
Ray Lale (08:07:09):
Safety type vest?
Witness (08:07:10):
Safety type vest and then an umbrella.
Ray Lale (08:07:13):
Do you remember what this decedent, Dan Akers, did for a living, sir?
Witness (08:07:17):
Contractor, worked for the union. I think electrical contracting.
Ray Lale (08:07:22):
Okay.
Witness (08:07:23):
If I remember correctly.
Ray Lale (08:07:24):
Would you disagree with me if I said sheet metal?
Witness (08:07:28):
Sheet metal, yes. I'm sorry-
Speaker 13 (08:07:29):
Objection, leading.
Witness (08:07:29):
... sheet metal.
Ray Lale (08:07:31):
So you see this clothing was where?
Witness (08:07:37):
There was like-
Speaker 13 (08:07:38):
Objection, asked and answered.
Ray Lale (08:07:43):
I was up there pointing. I didn't hear what you said. I'm sorry. We're getting the exhibits ready. Where was it found?
Witness (08:07:47):
In a closet type area that I believe was in the basement near the room in question at Raymill.
Ray Lale (08:08:10):
All right. Thank you. Let me show you this, sir. This was entered in as defense exhibit. Let's see. Thank you. I'm going to show you this, please. This is Defendant's Exhibit 139. If I can show you this. Do you remember seeing this earlier?
Witness (08:09:26):
Yes, sir.
Ray Lale (08:09:26):
And this, if you bring it, pull it up please. Raise it up as far as you can. There you go. All the way. Keep going. This is Mr. Akers. Is that right?
Witness (08:09:41):
Yes.
Ray Lale (08:09:42):
And our attention was drawn. Do you remember attention being drawn to this little logo right here?
Witness (08:09:49):
Yes, sir.
Ray Lale (08:09:50):
But I want to draw your attention right here. You see a little ball right there, like a spray, some type of spray bottle? What does that... Just tell me what you think it is.
Witness (08:10:01):
When I see it, I see a spray can.
Ray Lale (08:10:03):
Some kind of spray...
Witness (08:10:01):
When I see it, I see a spray can.
Ray Lale (08:10:03):
Some kind of spray can. Is that what you see?
Witness (08:10:06):
Yes, sir.
Ray Lale (08:10:10):
Tell the jury what hand he's holding that spray can in.
Witness (08:10:14):
His right hand.
Ray Lale (08:10:15):
A left-handed person holding a spray can in the right hand. Is that what you see?
Witness (08:10:20):
Yes, sir.
Ray Lale (08:10:46):
Defense Exhibit 134. I'll ask you if you remember that.
Judge (08:10:50):
Okay.
Ray Lale (08:10:54):
Now, when I asked you if you saw any pictures of Mr. Akers on March 5th, 2020, you said you didn't remember any. Is that right?
Witness (08:11:03):
Yes, sir.
Ray Lale (08:11:04):
But up on that board, and we've seen that board, there's been some talk about it, this making memories by the minute board. You did see, and Mr. Steel said, "Well, didn't you see this?" And you said, "I just missed it." Is that what you said?
Witness (08:11:17):
Yes, sir.
Mr. Steel (08:11:19):
Can I just ask what exhibit number that is?
Ray Lale (08:11:21):
134, defense.
Mr. Steel (08:11:23):
Thank you.
Ray Lale (08:11:25):
Tell the jury what wrist the guy's watch is on right here in this picture.
Witness (08:11:29):
It's on his left.
Ray Lale (08:11:33):
You see his watch on his left wrist?
Witness (08:11:37):
Yes, sir.
Ray Lale (08:11:37):
Of a left-handed person?
Witness (08:11:41):
Yes, sir.
Ray Lale (08:11:41):
Is that what you see there?
Witness (08:11:42):
Yes, sir.
Ray Lale (08:11:43):
Now, this picture, is this the only picture you saw in the house that you remember? Or you said you didn't even see it?
Witness (08:11:52):
I didn't see it, sir.
Ray Lale (08:11:53):
Okay. Did you see any more pictures of the decedent in the home?
Witness (08:11:57):
No, sir.
Ray Lale (08:11:58):
60 ... I was going with Mr. Steel yesterday, 100 days, but now we've whittled it down to say 62, 3 days after the death of Mr. Akers. Is that right?
Witness (08:12:06):
Yes.
Ray Lale (08:12:06):
Okay. Now this picture, you remember the Defendant looking quite different than this picture when you interviewed her on March 5th? Do you remember that?
Witness (08:12:22):
Yes.
Ray Lale (08:12:23):
Remember she had a full sleeve of tattoos, including on her hands?
Witness (08:12:27):
Yes.
Ray Lale (08:12:28):
You remember her having that on March 5th?
Witness (08:12:32):
Yes, sir.
Ray Lale (08:12:32):
Do you see any tattoos here?
Witness (08:12:34):
No.
Ray Lale (08:12:35):
Do you think it'd be fair to say that this is an old picture, rather old?
Witness (08:12:40):
Yes. They actually both look very young in that.
Ray Lale (08:12:43):
Did you see any recent photos of Dan Akers in the home on March 5th?
Witness (08:12:47):
Not that I can recall.
Ray Lale (08:12:53):
I'm going to ask you finally, sir, to ... May I have just a second, please?
(08:13:06)
Can I please have you, sir, Mr. Investigator Burke play State's Exhibit 2 at 3:45 and stop at 4 minutes even, sir? And Detective Hardy, you really listen here. State's Exhibit 2, 3:45 to 4 minutes. If you'll turn it up.
(08:13:27)
Do you remember State's Exhibit 2, the 911 tape?
Witness (08:13:36):
Yes, sir.
Speaker 14 (08:13:36):
[inaudible 08:13:55].
Ray Lale (08:14:04):
Did you hear the 911 operator say, "Where is the gun now?"
Witness (08:14:10):
Yes.
Ray Lale (08:14:13):
Could you hear that clearly?
Witness (08:14:13):
Yes.
Ray Lale (08:14:17):
Did you hear this Defendant right there say, "I took it down there, ma'am." Did you hear it? "I took it down there, ma'am." Play it again, Investigator Burke, 3:45 to 4 minutes. Listen for me and tell me if you hear it or not.
Speaker 14 (08:14:53):
[inaudible 08:14:54].
Ray Lale (08:14:53):
Did you hear that?
Witness (08:14:54):
I hear, "I took it down." I can't hear anything else after that, sir.
Ray Lale (08:14:58):
No further questions. Thank you.
Judge (08:14:59):
We've got about 15 minutes before we wrap it up for the day. [inaudible 08:15:03]
Mr. Steel (08:15:07):
Thank you, Your Honor. Just where we stopped, and we covered this already, but what you heard was, "I took it down. No, ma'am. I was trying to take it out of his hand?"
Witness (08:15:20):
Can you play the other part of it on the other end?
Mr. Steel (08:15:22):
Sure. Prosecutor asked it to be stopped before that, so we'll just play it a little further. You can start at 3: 50 and please stop it, let's say 4:09.
Speaker 14 (08:15:33):
[inaudible 08:15:39].
Mr. Steel (08:15:45):
Did you hear-
Witness (08:16:04):
I don't hear hand.
Mr. Steel (08:16:04):
... Trying to take it out of his hand.
Witness (08:16:05):
I don't hear hand. I hear, "Take it out," and then they're screaming.
Mr. Steel (08:16:07):
You testified earlier that you heard, "Take it out of his hand."
Witness (08:16:10):
Well, I mean, I'm hearing it again. I can't hear hand.
Mr. Steel (08:16:12):
Okay. That's okay. May I approach, Your Honor?
Judge (08:16:32):
Yes, sir.
Mr. Steel (08:17:05):
Do you remember writing a report in this case?
Witness (08:17:06):
Yes, sir.
Mr. Steel (08:17:08):
Do you remember writing a report detailing what you heard?
Witness (08:17:10):
Yes, sir.
Mr. Steel (08:17:11):
On the 911 call?
Witness (08:17:12):
Yes, sir.
Mr. Steel (08:17:12):
Do you remember writing in your report, "Dispatcher asked where the weapon is now." Remember that?
Witness (08:17:17):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (08:17:18):
And remember writing the female, meaning Lacy?
Witness (08:17:21):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (08:17:22):
States, "In his hand on the ground?"
Witness (08:17:25):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (08:17:26):
And the female, meaning Lacy, then states, "I took it down." The dispatcher says, "In his hand." And Lacy says, "No, I was trying to take it out of his hand," then starts screaming. That's what you wrote?
Witness (08:17:38):
I can't hear that on this audio right now, sir.
Mr. Steel (08:17:41):
May I approach, Your Honor? Let me show you a report that you may recognize.
Witness (08:17:46):
Yes. I'm familiar with the report.
Mr. Steel (08:17:48):
Well, isn't that what you wrote?
Witness (08:17:50):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (08:17:50):
Nothing like what the prosecutor said.
Witness (08:17:52):
I can't hear what they're saying. I can't hear the audio part of it.
Mr. Steel (08:17:56):
Okay. But you wrote in your report that Lacy said, "I was trying to take it out of his hand."
Witness (08:18:00):
Okay. If it's in the report, then that's what I wrote.
Mr. Steel (08:18:03):
You need to see it.
Witness (08:18:04):
No, I've already ... I've saw it, sir.
Mr. Steel (08:18:07):
So this whole thing about, "I took it down," Lacy introduced the gun downstairs, that's not in your report?
Witness (08:18:18):
Which part, sir?
Mr. Steel (08:18:19):
That Lacy took the gun downstairs. That's not in the report.
Witness (08:18:22):
I didn't testify to that.
Mr. Steel (08:18:23):
Right. He asked you a question, you said, "No, that's not what I heard."
Witness (08:18:26):
Exactly.
Mr. Steel (08:18:26):
Okay. And thank you. I want to talk with you, I know you said that you searched back in the phones from about September till the date, September 1, I assume, until December 22, 2019, fair?
Witness (08:18:47):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (08:18:47):
That's what you said. I want to show you from Mr. ... I'll mark it as an exhibit. I just have to get the next exhibit number from the phone of, I believe Mr. Akers. Actually, it's Lacy Boles, that is correct. While the State is looking that over, can you put up, if you don't mind, Ms. Boles Exhibit Number 34? I think you just showed it. Is that okay, Your Honor? It's in evidence.
Judge (08:19:23):
Yes, sir.
Mr. Steel (08:19:26):
What's the last exhibit number?
Speaker 15 (08:19:27):
You're on 142.
Mr. Steel (08:19:37):
Thank you.
(08:19:49)
Do you not have it?
Speaker 16 (08:19:51):
34 or 134?
Mr. Steel (08:19:52):
134. It was just up.
Speaker 16 (08:19:55):
134, yes.
Mr. Steel (08:19:55):
If you don't mind. Remember being asked questions about this?
Witness (08:20:03):
Yes, sir.
Mr. Steel (08:20:04):
And you remember the prosecutor asking you, saying that, "Look at Lacy's hand. This must be an old picture. There's no tattoos?"
Witness (08:20:12):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (08:20:13):
Remember those questions just a couple of minutes ago? Tell the jurors whether Lacy has any tattoos that you ever noticed on her right hand.
Witness (08:20:23):
On her right hand?
Mr. Steel (08:20:24):
Yeah.
Witness (08:20:25):
I'm not sure.
Mr. Steel (08:20:25):
They're on her left hand?
Witness (08:20:28):
I'm not sure. I know she has tattoos.
Mr. Steel (08:20:30):
None are in this picture. The prosecutor said this is an old picture. This is not an old picture, is it?
Witness (08:20:34):
They both look very young, sir.
Mr. Steel (08:20:36):
Well, is it an old picture?
Witness (08:20:37):
I believe it's an old picture.
Mr. Steel (08:20:39):
Do you see Lacy Boles today? You can look. Can you see her?
Witness (08:20:44):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (08:20:44):
Does she have any tattoos on her right hand?
Witness (08:20:47):
I can't see her right hands. Okay. No.
Mr. Steel (08:20:51):
But in the video, I'm not going to play it again, but the juror saw it, it's her left hand that has tattoos, you do remember tattoos?
Witness (08:20:58):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (08:20:59):
Left hand. Why does it matter that she doesn't have tattoos on her right hand in this picture?
Witness (08:21:05):
I don't know, sir.
Mr. Steel (08:21:06):
Okay. What is Dan Akers ... You see him here?
Witness (08:21:11):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (08:21:11):
Prosecutor asked you about a watch on his left hand for some reason?
Witness (08:21:16):
Yes, sir.
Mr. Steel (08:21:16):
Lacy made it clear that he's predominantly right-handed, correct?
Witness (08:21:20):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (08:21:21):
But Dan Akers is holding what in his left hand?
Witness (08:21:24):
A cup.
Mr. Steel (08:21:25):
Yeah, he can use his left hand?
Witness (08:21:28):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (08:21:28):
Okay. I'd like to show you since you ... I've marked it number 142, Ms. Boles, may I approach, Your Honor?
Judge (08:21:34):
Yes, sir.
Mr. Steel (08:21:35):
This is within the timeframe when you reviewed the phones. Just take a look at that and I'm going to display it to the jurors. You recognize that as coming off the phones, Ms. Boles' phone?
Witness (08:21:47):
Yes, sir.
Mr. Steel (08:21:47):
May I approach, Your Honor?
Judge (08:21:47):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (08:21:50):
May I approach, Your Honor? I move for the admission of Ms. Boles, Number 142.
Ray Lale (08:21:53):
No objection.
Judge (08:21:53):
It's admitted.
Mr. Steel (08:22:01):
If you could blow it up, if you don't mind Investigator. Okay. And do you see here, just to orient everyone, this is a text message from the 45462 number, that's Mr. Akers' number, and it's incoming to Ms. Boles' cell phone, correct?
Witness (08:22:25):
Correct.
Mr. Steel (08:22:25):
All right. And it's September 24th, 2019, 7: 24 in the evening, fair?
Witness (08:22:32):
Yes, sir.
Mr. Steel (08:22:33):
And Mr. Akers wrote to Lacy, "I really don't even care. Just please, please leave me before you ever cheat again, and I'll do the same, because if you ever cheat on me or do anything sneaky behind my back or have anyone over while I'm not there, then they will be burying both of us." Remember that?
Witness (08:22:58):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (08:22:59):
And burying both of us potentially is killing us?
Witness (08:23:04):
Potentially.
Mr. Steel (08:23:04):
Mr. Akers is saying, "He'll kill both of them?"
Witness (08:23:09):
He's not saying kill, he's saying bury.
Mr. Steel (08:23:11):
Yeah. Well, do you bury live people?
Witness (08:23:13):
No.
Mr. Steel (08:23:16):
"And putting our kids in foster care." This is from Mr. Akers?
Witness (08:23:21):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (08:23:23):
"If I can't live through it ..." Excuse me, I said it wrong. I apologize. "I can't live through it again, and I won't. So if we both keep it honest, then no one has to die." You see that?
Witness (08:23:36):
I do.
Mr. Steel (08:23:39):
"But I love you that much." That's what Mr. Akers is saying about Lacy?
Witness (08:23:42):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (08:23:42):
Am I correct? "I can't live without you." You read that?
Witness (08:23:49):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (08:23:51):
"You are the one I want to spend forever with."
Witness (08:23:57):
That's what it reads.
Mr. Steel (08:23:58):
And on December 22, 2019, did Lacy Boles make it clear that she is leaving Dan Akers?
Witness (08:24:08):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (08:24:09):
And did Dan Akers just two months before, just two months, almost to the day before, three months before, almost to the day, make it clear in that writing that he can't live without Lacy Boles?
Witness (08:24:28):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (08:24:29):
And he's talking about killing in that?
Witness (08:24:34):
That's what it reads, sir.
Mr. Steel (08:24:35):
Yeah. Why didn't you bring that up to the jurors earlier?
Witness (08:24:39):
I'm sorry?
Mr. Steel (08:24:40):
Why didn't you introduce that to the jurors earlier?
Witness (08:24:42):
I didn't remember that text.
Mr. Steel (08:24:46):
I want to talk with you about the DNA. The district attorney asked you, said that there's no smooth surfaces on the gun to get DNA. That's what he asked you. Remember that?
Witness (08:25:12):
I don't think he said smooth. I think he said surfaces.
Mr. Steel (08:25:14):
Okay. Well, you do know from your vast experience that DNA is gotten off the trigger pull of a gun?
Witness (08:25:24):
It has in the past, yes.
Mr. Steel (08:25:26):
Yeah. And there's a trigger pull on a revolver?
Witness (08:25:29):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (08:25:31):
And for whatever reason, it was never even attempted to be done in this case, even though requested?
Witness (08:25:39):
Correct.
Mr. Steel (08:25:40):
Even though DNA of Ms. Boles was in possession of law enforcement?
Witness (08:25:44):
Correct.
Mr. Steel (08:25:45):
Even though the DNA of Mr. Akers was in possession of law enforcement?
Witness (08:25:48):
Correct.
Mr. Steel (08:25:52):
The keys, the prosecutor put up keys and told you there's some, I don't know, discoloration, and he's asking you about whether the key to the safe and put it in the safe, you remember all those questions?
Witness (08:26:05):
Yes, sir.
Mr. Steel (08:26:05):
Where are the keys now that the jurors can see what is on that keychain?
Witness (08:26:13):
They're not in evidence.
Mr. Steel (08:26:14):
Where are they?
Witness (08:26:17):
I don't know.
Judge (08:26:26):
A couple more minutes.
Mr. Steel (08:26:39):
Okay. The Cadillac with the urine supposedly found by Skylar, the daughter, remember that?
Witness (08:26:45):
Yes, sir.
Mr. Steel (08:26:46):
The district attorney asked you about, "Oh, it doesn't have to be warm." You know people who fake drug tests by using other people's urine?
Witness (08:26:55):
I've heard of it before, but I've never encountered it.
Mr. Steel (08:26:57):
Okay. Do you know that they have to smuggle it into the bathroom when they're urinating?
Witness (08:27:02):
I'm sure they would have to smuggle it, sir.
Mr. Steel (08:27:04):
Right, because you can't just walk in with urine?
Witness (08:27:05):
Yeah.
Mr. Steel (08:27:06):
And there's typically, not always, but a faucet with maybe warm water in the bathroom?
Witness (08:27:13):
Yes, but if I may, when I have to take a drug test for work, we're not allowed to turn on the sink or flush the toilet. We have to empty our pockets. I would assume it would be the same for probation.
Mr. Steel (08:27:24):
Let's not assume.
Witness (08:27:26):
But I'm giving you my experience.
Mr. Steel (08:27:28):
But let's not assume.
Witness (08:27:29):
Okay.
Mr. Steel (08:27:29):
And I'm not really actually talking about probation of Dan Akers. I'm talking about his job.
Witness (08:27:34):
Okay. I don't know how they ... My job is not-
Mr. Steel (08:27:36):
You don't know?
Witness (08:27:37):
No.
Mr. Steel (08:27:38):
Right. Now, the Cadillac search, Dan Akers was driving a Cadillac that night, December 22, 2019?
Witness (08:27:46):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (08:27:47):
An older model Cadillac, fair?
Witness (08:27:48):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (08:27:50):
Show us any picture of the interior of that Cadillac that it was searched.
Witness (08:27:55):
There are interior pictures, sir. I noted it on my ...
Mr. Steel (08:27:58):
Open the ... I mean, they already heard from Investigator Crime Scene Technician Carter, opening the console, opening the glove compartment-
Witness (08:28:06):
Yes. I don't know if it was searched.
Mr. Steel (08:28:07):
Right. So to say that somehow urine wasn't found in the car, you're not going to make that claim? Law enforcement didn't look.
Witness (08:28:17):
I wasn't there, sir.
Mr. Steel (08:28:19):
Right. But you know ... Do you have any evidence that they looked throughout the car?
Witness (08:28:23):
I do not.
Mr. Steel (08:28:24):
Okay. Now, a lot of this, in the interest of time, you were showed State's Exhibit Number 215 or 216, either one, if you don't mind, while you're queuing that up, I'm going to ask you a couple questions. Do you remember the room with the vest and the work clothing, work type clothing you were describing?
Witness (08:28:52):
Yes, sir.
Mr. Steel (08:28:53):
Who put that clothing in that location?
Witness (08:28:56):
I do not know.
Mr. Steel (08:28:57):
You don't know, do you?
Witness (08:28:58):
No.
Mr. Steel (08:28:58):
When did it go in that location?
Witness (08:29:01):
I don't know, sir.
Mr. Steel (08:29:02):
It could have been before December 22, 2019, fair?
Witness (08:29:06):
Fair.
Mr. Steel (08:29:06):
Could have been after December 22, 2019?
Witness (08:29:09):
Yes, but it was found on March, I believe, March 5th.
Mr. Steel (08:29:11):
Sure. It's where it is on March 5, 2020?
Witness (08:29:15):
Correct.
Mr. Steel (08:29:15):
That's all we really know?
Witness (08:29:17):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (08:29:20):
The bottom line is, that's what your job is. And when I say you, collective you, law enforcement, prosecution, you bring in evidence to prove a case?
Witness (08:29:35):
Yes, sir.
Mr. Steel (08:29:36):
It's not just it could have been, you're supposed to try to prove something is, true?
Ray Lale (08:29:42):
Again, this witness has no burden of proof. He's not part of the prosecution team. He's just a police officer. There's no burden of proof. He doesn't collect evidence to try to prove something. This table has to prove everything, not his.
Mr. Steel (08:29:54):
I'm not asking for a burden of proof instruction. I'm asking, is that what he does?
Ray Lale (08:30:00):
Okay. It's not what he does.
Judge (08:30:03):
I'll let you ask. Overruled. Try to find a stopping point.
Mr. Steel (08:30:06):
Yes. That's what you're charged to do, correct?
Witness (08:30:11):
To collect evidence and-
Mr. Steel (08:30:13):
And prove things.
Witness (08:30:15):
And prepare facts.
Mr. Steel (08:30:16):
Not just ... What did you say, verify facts? Is that what you said?
Witness (08:30:21):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (08:30:21):
Yeah. You're not here just to say, "I don't know. It could have been one way or it could have been another way." You're here to determine what the evidence shows, whatever way it is. And if it's split that you're not sure, you admit, "I don't know." True?
Witness (08:30:37):
Yes.
Mr. Steel (08:30:38):
And in this case, you don't know a lot of answers to the questions such as ... I'm just going to give it to you. Who washed their hands in the sink? You don't know?
Witness (08:30:57):
Correct.
Mr. Steel (08:30:58):
You don't know if Lacy Boles went downstairs to Dan Akers and tried to give him CPR on his chest and touched the gun right before the EMT show up. You just don't know.
Witness (08:31:09):
Correct.
Mr. Steel (08:31:10):
You don't know whether Dan Akers carried that gun in that house from outside being at a bar and McDonald's. You just don't know?
Witness (08:31:22):
Correct.
Mr. Steel (08:31:24):
You don't know whether Dan Akers had that holster with him when he walked in the house and discarded it somewhere on the ground when he pulled out the gun. You just don't know?
Witness (08:31:37):
Correct.
Mr. Steel (08:31:38):
You don't know, [inaudible 08:31:41] drops his bottle of water, but you don't know if that McDonald's cup or the McDonald's bag or the keys or the hat were placed down, thrown down even before Lacy Boles came into that room. You just don't know.
Witness (08:31:57):
Correct.
Judge (08:32:02):
All right. It's about five after five.
Mr. Steel (08:32:04):
That's fine, Your Honor. Let's stop-
Judge (08:32:06):
... So we'll wrap it up in the evening. Please remember my instructions and we'll see you back at 8:30 tomorrow.
(08:32:12)
All right. Anything before we break for the evening?
Mr. Steel (08:32:49):
No, sir.
Ray Lale (08:32:49):
Yes, Your Honor. I'd like the court respectfully to inform me if Mr. Steel is finished with his recross or will there be more tomorrow morning?
Mr. Steel (08:32:55):
I think there's more ... If the witness doesn't mind coming back at the appropriate time, Your Honor, and I will text the district attorneys if that changes so he doesn't have to waste time.
Ray Lale (08:33:08):
I will be redirecting, so we'll be here no matter what, but I need to know what are we starting with, the continuation of recross or redirect?
Judge (08:33:14):
Well, he said there will be more, so I think that means there will be more recross.
Ray Lale (08:33:23):
The second point is, respectfully, Your Honor, if it please the court, I ask that the last exhibit entered by the Defense be stricken and disallow the curative instruction given. And here's why. The Defense moved in pretrial in limine to forbid any mention of this Defendant's supposed infidelity. And we had extensive pretrial motions on that, and the Court ruled, "Yes, I believe that's not relevant." And what's important about it is the Court instructed the State to redact from the videos all mention of this supposed infidelity on the part of the Defendant. And we did that. We carefully went through and there were no mentions allowed to be made of her supposed infidelity. And what does the Defense do? They enter this text that brings the infidelity or the supposed infidelity right full focus to the jury after we were made to redact every mention of that from the video.
(08:34:17)
So now, because of the strategic move by the Defense, purposeful calculated move, we were prevented from talking about this possible infidelity issue with regards to the two participants, but they go into it when it suits their fancy, and that's disingenuous. There are standards of substantial justice and fair play involved, and that's despicable, honestly. And I move that it not be admitted and that it be stricken, because now we can't go back and show an unredacted version of the video, but that's what they asked for. And I understand they have a right to put on their case, and I understand they have due process rights to present their evidence, but not at the exclusion of our evidence, but that's what they did.
Judge (08:35:04):
Response?
Mr. Steel (08:35:07):
I don't know what the response needs to be. It's in admitted evidence. There was no objection to it. It's been testified to, and if there's something that comes down the pipe that changes the Court's ruling, that's fine, but I don't understand what I'm supposed to say to that.
Judge (08:35:59):
Just looking at the pretrial order. So there's an order on motions that the Court entered back in June, and at paragraph or number section five, it reads a state six ruling on the admissibility of a recording that we found on the decedent's phone. And it goes on to state, "Regarding the hearsay objection, the Court notes that most of the recording captures speech, which does not meet the definition of hearsay, et cetera. On the other hand, statements apparently made by the decedent at or around minute 8:12 concerning what Defendant's family told him in 8:35, suggesting the Defendant cheated on the decedent appear to be hearsay and therefore must be redacted." So that's what you're referring to?
Ray Lale (08:36:49):
That was part of it. And then it opened up a broader discussion of this theme that the Defendant was somehow cheating on the decedent, and that subject was broached in the law enforcement interviews until it had to be redacted heavily.
Judge (08:37:07):
Well, I see your point, but this does refer to the recording and not a text. And then when you were shown the text, I don't think you objected, and so it went in without objection. So I overrule your objection. What else?
Mr. Steel (08:37:40):
Nothing on behalf of Ms. Boles, Your Honor. Your Honor, it's 8:30 to 8:00 tomorrow night?
Judge (08:37:45):
That's the plan.
Mr. Steel (08:37:45):
Okay. Understood.
Judge (08:37:45):
Okay.