Live Weekly Demo | Led by a Rev Workflow Specialist
Save Your Spot
FL v. Dwain Hall Day 3

FL v. Dwain Hall Day 3

Dwain Hall stands trial for the alleged murder of Sonia Exelby, day three. Read the transcript here.

Dwain Hall stands trial for the alleged murder of Sonia Exelby, day three.
Hungry For More?

Luckily for you, we deliver. Subscribe to our blog today.

Thank You for Subscribing!

A confirmation email is on it’s way to your inbox.

Share this post

Copyright Disclaimer

Under Title 17 U.S.C. Section 107, allowance is made for "fair use" for purposes such as criticism, comment, news reporting, teaching, scholarship, and research. Fair use is permitted by copyright statute that might otherwise be infringing.

Speaker 1 (30:27):

All rise. Circuit Court in and for Marion County is now in session. The Honorable Timothy T. McCourt presiding.

Judge McCourt (30:30):

Y'all can be seated. Thank you. We are here in state of Florida versus Dwain Hall, 2025 CF4516. Will counsel identify for the record?

Amy Berndt (30:43):

Amy Berndt for the State.

Rich Buxman (30:44):

Rich Buxman for the State.

Junior Barrett (30:47):

Junior Barrett representing Mr. Hall.

Jacques Ward (30:48):

Jacques Ward, also representing Mr. Hall.

Judge McCourt (30:50):

Okay. Mr. Hall is present in the courtroom. Mr. Hall, can I have you raise your right hand, sir? Do you swear to tell the truth, the whole truth, nothing but the truth, so help you God?

Dwain Hall (30:56):

Yes.

Judge McCourt (30:57):

Okay. Mr. Hall, are you handcuffed?

Dwain Hall (30:58):

No.

Judge McCourt (30:59):

Are you shackled?

Dwain Hall (30:59):

No.

Judge McCourt (31:00):

Okay. I'm going to have you stand up, take a couple steps back so I can describe your clothing for the record. I can see Mr. Hall from head to toe. He's neither handcuffed or shackled. He is wearing a black button up dress shirt, open collar, pair of charcoal pants, black belt and dress shoes. It's appropriate dressed for court. Neither handcuffed or shackled. All right. You be seated, sir. Thank you. State defense, anything that we need to take up before we bring in the jury?

Rich Buxman (31:24):

No, your Honor.

Junior Barrett (31:24):

No, your Honor.

Judge McCourt (31:26):

Okay. Oh, stipulation.

Rich Buxman (31:30):

Yes, sir. Thank you.

Judge McCourt (31:31):

Could you hand me a copy of that, Mr. Buxman? Thank you. All right. Mr. Hall, I've been presented by the state and your attorney with a document entitled Identity Stipulation. What it reads is, "The State and the defendant have stipulated that the identity of the deceased in this case is Sonia Exelby. As a result of this stipulation, you may consider that fact proven beyond a reasonable doubt." And then there's a signature line here for Dwain Hall, and I see a signature. Is that your signature?

Dwain Hall (32:05):

Yes.

Judge McCourt (32:06):

Okay. Now Mr. Hall, you entered into this stipulation with an understanding that that by agreeing to this, the state does not have to prove that fact. Do you understand that?

Dwain Hall (32:15):

Yes.

Judge McCourt (32:16):

And there are strategic reasons why a person on trial in a case such as this would want to enter into that stipulation. Now, have you talked with your attorneys about the decision to enter into this stipulation?

Dwain Hall (32:29):

Yes.

Judge McCourt (32:30):

Okay. And are you doing this freely and voluntarily?

Dwain Hall (32:33):

Yes.

Judge McCourt (32:33):

Has anybody forced you, threatened you, or coerced you to get you to enter into this stipulation?

Dwain Hall (32:37):

No.

Judge McCourt (32:38):

Again, you understand by agreeing to this that this fact will be considered conclusively proven for the jury and the State will need to present no further evidence on this?

Dwain Hall (32:46):

Yes.

Judge McCourt (32:47):

Okay. Very well. I will find that the stipulation has been freely and voluntarily, knowingly and intelligently entered by the defendant. I will read it to the jury, state at the appropriate time. Do you have any idea when?

Rich Buxman (32:59):

We could probably read it before the medical examiner testifies. She'll be the last witness.

Judge McCourt (33:03):

Okay...

Mr. Buxman (33:00):

... read it before the medical examiner testifies. She'll be the last witness.

Judge (33:03):

Okay. All right. Madam Clerk, I'll just hand this to you for now. Okay. Let's go ahead and bring in the jury.

(33:10)
Ladies and gentlemen, welcome back. Everyone can go ahead and be seated. Members of the jury, when we broke for our recess yesterday evening, I instructed all of you to not allow anybody to communicate with you about the case or discuss the case with you. I instructed all of you to not communicate about the case with any other person. I also gave you all comprehensive instructions on avoiding social media and avoiding use of the internet, not communicating about the case in that fashion or reading about the case in that fashion. By a show of heads, nodding your heads up and down or shaking them back and forth with the case as the case may be, have all of you been able to follow that instruction again? Okay. All the jurors have nodded their heads in the affirmative. Very well. We're going to proceed then with the next witness. State?

Mr. Buxman (36:05):

State calls Clark Chestnut. May I have presentation with, Your Honor?

Judge (36:13):

Yes, sir.

Mr. Buxman (36:25):

Thank you.

Judge (36:26):

Good morning, sir. Raise your right hand. Face the clerk here to be sworn.

Clerk (36:49):

Do you swear or affirm the testimony you're about to give will be the truth, the whole truth, and nothing but the truth, so help you God?

Clark Chestnut (36:49):

Yes.

Judge (36:49):

All right. You can go ahead and be seated.

Mr. Buxman (36:52):

Good morning, sir.

Clark Chestnut (36:53):

Good morning.

Mr. Buxman (36:54):

Can you please introduce yourself to the jury?

Clark Chestnut (36:56):

I'm Clark Chestnut. I'm the senior asset protection manager for Lowe's.

Mr. Buxman (37:01):

How long have you worked for Lowe's in that position?

Clark Chestnut (37:03):

13 years.

Mr. Buxman (37:04):

All right. What do you do on a day-to-day basis?

Clark Chestnut (37:07):

Variety of things. Anywhere from dealing with inventories, catching shoplifters, internal investigations, safety hazmat, basically anything that could cause a loss.

Mr. Buxman (37:18):

Do you work at one Lowe's store or do you work at several?

Clark Chestnut (37:20):

I have several.

Mr. Buxman (37:21):

Is one of your stores located at 3535 Southwest 36th Avenue in Ocala?

Clark Chestnut (37:26):

Yes.

Mr. Buxman (37:27):

Let me direct your attention to October 20th of 2025. Did a Florida Department of Law Enforcement agent come to your store and ask for some assistance in locating some store surveillance and some transaction details?

Clark Chestnut (37:38):

Yes.

Mr. Buxman (37:39):

And were you asked by this agent to search transactions for a purchase totaling $11.99 that occurred at 9:03 AM on October 12th of 2025?

Clark Chestnut (37:49):

Yes.

Mr. Buxman (37:50):

Were you also asked to search for the video surveillance reflecting that transaction?

Clark Chestnut (37:54):

Yes.

Mr. Buxman (37:55):

Were you able to do that?

Clark Chestnut (37:56):

Yes.

Mr. Buxman (37:56):

How do you go about doing those things?

Clark Chestnut (37:59):

Well, so we'll have a journal entry. Every time that we sell anything, it goes off our system. And I believe in that case it was our Genesis system and it shows every single transaction, like time, date, everything as it goes on throughout the day.

Mr. Buxman (38:17):

Okay. And who has access to that system to be able to search for those things?

Clark Chestnut (38:21):

Myself and any upper management.

Mr. Buxman (38:23):

Does it require a login and a password to access the system?

Clark Chestnut (38:26):

Yes. Yes.

Mr. Buxman (38:27):

And where is that system kept in the store?

Clark Chestnut (38:30):

Several computers throughout the store. At that time, it was at several registers as well. Now we only have it at a few because it's a outdated system, a DOS system.

Mr. Buxman (38:40):

Okay. What were you able to find regarding that purchase for that amount and that date and time?

Clark Chestnut (38:47):

That item was purchased on that date and time.

Mr. Buxman (38:50):

And do you remember what the item was?

Clark Chestnut (38:51):

I think it was a tarp.

Mr. Buxman (38:52):

Okay. Were you able to pull up the actual... Those records in the normal course of business at Lowe's?

Clark Chestnut (38:57):

Yes.

Mr. Buxman (38:58):

Are those records maintained in the normal course of business at Lowe's?

Clark Chestnut (39:00):

Yes.

Mr. Buxman (39:01):

And are those records made at or about the time the transaction actually...

Clark Chestnut (39:04):

Yes.

Mr. Buxman (39:05):

May I approach, Your Honor?

Judge (39:11):

Yes, sir.

Mr. Buxman (39:11):

Showing you what's be marked as State's Exhibit UUU. Do you recognize that receipt?

Clark Chestnut (39:16):

Yep, that's the one.

Mr. Buxman (39:17):

What is that? What is it?

Clark Chestnut (39:19):

So that right there shows that the tarp was purchased on October 12th at 9:04 AM.

Mr. Buxman (39:25):

And does that fairly and accurately reflect the receipt that you pulled from your system and eventually provided to the agent?

Clark Chestnut (39:32):

Yes. Yes.

Mr. Buxman (39:33):

At this time, state would move UUU into evidence as State's 75.

Speaker 2 (39:37):

No objection, Judge.

Judge (39:39):

Without objection, what's been marked for identification as State's Exhibit UUU will be admitted into evidence as State's Exhibit 75.

Mr. Buxman (39:45):

May I publish?

Judge (39:46):

Yes, sir.

Mr. Buxman (39:49):

Can you explain to the jury what we're looking at, what these entries kind of show?

Clark Chestnut (39:52):

Yeah. So at the top there where it has the numbers 186785, that is the item number. Every single item that we sell at Lowe's has an item number attached to it and it'll show the price right there along with how in the invoice number, which is right next to it, the 83863, the total amount, it was purchased by a debit card and what the total amount was. And at the very bottom, you will see the date and the time and the store number, which that Lowe's number is 440 on the left.

Mr. Buxman (40:28):

And what were the last four numbers of the debit card used to make the purchase?

Clark Chestnut (40:32):

8343.

Mr. Buxman (40:35):

Okay. Does Lowe's also have a surveillance system set up in the store?

Clark Chestnut (40:41):

Yes.

Mr. Buxman (40:42):

And does that cover both the inside of the store and the parking lot area?

Clark Chestnut (40:45):

Yes.

Mr. Buxman (40:46):

Are part of your duties as a loss prevention officer to check that surveillance footage and pull footage if needed?

Clark Chestnut (40:53):

Yes.

Mr. Buxman (40:55):

If there is a problem with the system, would you know about it?

Clark Chestnut (40:59):

Yes.

Mr. Buxman (40:59):

Okay. What kind of system does Lowe's have? Is it a DVR-based system or a cloud-based?

Clark Chestnut (41:04):

It's cloud-based nowadays.

Mr. Buxman (41:07):

And is that system motion activated or does it record all the time?

Clark Chestnut (41:10):

24/7.

Mr. Buxman (41:13):

Do you need a password or login to access the surveillance system?

Clark Chestnut (41:16):

Yes.

Mr. Buxman (41:17):

And who has that password and login?

Clark Chestnut (41:19):

Myself and any other persons that's also in asset protection and/or an ASM, which is assistant store manager, or the store manager.

Mr. Buxman (41:31):

And where is that, I guess the system that you would go to check? Where is that located?

Clark Chestnut (41:36):

It's in the asset protection office.

Mr. Buxman (41:37):

And is that in a locked area?

Clark Chestnut (41:39):

Yes.

Mr. Buxman (41:40):

Do only certain people have access to it?

Clark Chestnut (41:41):

Yes.

Mr. Buxman (41:42):

Who?

Clark Chestnut (41:42):

The same people I just mentioned, asset protection, store manager, and ASM.

Mr. Buxman (41:45):

Were you able to locate surveillance footage reflecting this transaction that we looked at in State's 75?

Clark Chestnut (41:52):

Yes.

Mr. Buxman (41:53):

And how were you able to do that?

Clark Chestnut (41:55):

I just logged on to the camera system, looked up the date and time, and looked at the purchase. And then pretty much backtracked to when the person walked in, selected the item and went to the register and bought it.

Mr. Buxman (42:10):

Did you actually download the footage or did the Florida Department of Law Enforcement agent?

Clark Chestnut (42:14):

I did.

Mr. Buxman (42:15):

Okay. So you download it, you take it, you give it to the agent?

Clark Chestnut (42:17):

Yes.

Mr. Buxman (42:18):

Understood. Was the timestamp on the surveillance footage accurate?

Clark Chestnut (42:22):

Yes.

Mr. Buxman (42:23):

Was there any problems with the system?

Clark Chestnut (42:24):

No.

Mr. Buxman (42:25):

Any problem with the download process?

Clark Chestnut (42:26):

No.

Mr. Buxman (42:28):

Any indication that the footage had been altered or tampered with in any way?

Clark Chestnut (42:32):

No.

Mr. Buxman (42:32):

Do you or anybody that has access to the system have the ability to go in and change any footage?

Clark Chestnut (42:37):

No.

Mr. Buxman (42:37):

May I approach, Judge?

Judge (42:39):

Yes, sir.

Mr. Buxman (42:40):

Showing you what's been marked as State's Exhibit VVV as in Victor, do you recognize that item?

Clark Chestnut (42:44):

Yes.

Mr. Buxman (42:45):

How do you recognize it?

Clark Chestnut (42:46):

That's the disc I brought.

Mr. Buxman (42:49):

Okay. And did you do anything to the disc to show that it's the same disc you watched? Did you initial it?

Clark Chestnut (42:53):

Yes, I did.

Mr. Buxman (42:55):

Okay. And does that disc fairly and accurately depict the surveillance footage reflecting this transaction that you provided to the agent?

Clark Chestnut (43:01):

Yes. Mm-hmm.

Mr. Buxman (43:03):

Is that a yes?

Clark Chestnut (43:03):

Yes.

Mr. Buxman (43:04):

At this time, State would move VVV into evidence as State's 76.

Speaker 2 (43:07):

No objection, Judge.

Judge (43:08):

Without objection, what's been marked for identification as State's Exhibit VVV will be admitted into evidence as State's Exhibit 76.

Mr. Buxman (43:19):

Once you downloaded the footage, did you provide that footage and the receipt to the Florida Department of Law Enforcement agent?

Clark Chestnut (43:25):

Yes.

Mr. Buxman (43:25):

Thank you, sir. No other questions, Your Honor.

Judge (43:27):

Any-

Speaker 2 (43:27):

No questions, Judge.

Judge (43:28):

Members of the jury, do any of you all have questions of this witness? If you do, please raise your hands. Seeing no hands, State, is he released?

Mr. Buxman (43:35):

He is, Your Honor.

Judge (43:36):

Defense?

Speaker 2 (43:36):

No objection, Judge.

Judge (43:37):

All right, sir, you're free to go about your day. Thank you for your time.

Mr. Buxman (43:39):

Thank you.

Judge (43:40):

State, next witness.

Mr. Buxman (43:42):

State recalls Christopher Perryman.

Judge (43:55):

Members of the jury, I meant to mention to y'all yesterday when we broke in the afternoon, there was a brief recess we took around four o'clock when I heard a sound that sounded like a phone recording going on. We looked into it during the recess. One of the bailiffs had sent a text message and as he apparently put his phone down, that sound went off. It was definitively that, so you don't have to worry about anybody having made a recording of the court proceedings, other than obviously the news camera here. Come on in, sir. Raise your right hand. Face the clerk to be sworn.

Clerk (44:30):

Do you swear or affirm the testimony you're about to give will be the truth, the whole truth, and nothing but the truth, so help you God?

Christopher Perryman (44:31):

I do.

Judge (44:32):

You can go ahead and be seated, sir.

Mr. Buxman (44:33):

Good morning.

Christopher Perryman (44:36):

Good morning.

Mr. Buxman (44:37):

Can you please reintroduce yourself to the jury and tell the jury where you work again?

Christopher Perryman (44:41):

So I'm a special agent with the Florida Department of Law Enforcement. My name is Christopher Perryman.

Mr. Buxman (44:45):

All right. Let me direct your attention to... Well, were you asked in the course of your duties, as far as this case is concerned, to try to track down information regarding a purchase made by Dwain Hall on October 12th, 2025 at Lowe's in Ocala?

Christopher Perryman (45:01):

Yes, I was.

Mr. Buxman (45:01):

And were you tasked with also trying to find if there was surveillance that could be recovered showing that purchase?

Christopher Perryman (45:07):

Yes, I was.

Mr. Buxman (45:07):

And how did you learn that Dwain Hall had made a purchase on that specific date and time at Lowe's?

Christopher Perryman (45:13):

Through prior bank records of Dwain Hall's.

Mr. Buxman (45:15):

Okay. So did you go to the Lowe's store where that item was purchased according to the bank records?

Christopher Perryman (45:21):

Yes, I did.

Mr. Buxman (45:22):

And how did you determine from which store that purchase was made?

Christopher Perryman (45:26):

So the bank records indicated which store it was purchased from.

Mr. Buxman (45:29):

Okay. And what did you do when you got there?

Christopher Perryman (45:32):

So when I got there, I met with an employee named Clark Chestnut.

Mr. Buxman (45:38):

Okay. And what'd you do?

Christopher Perryman (45:39):

So I met with Mr. Chestnut and I asked if he could help assist me by locating transaction data or transaction history and surveillance footage.

Mr. Buxman (45:49):

And so did you give him the date and time of the purchase as was indicated by the defendant's bank records?

Christopher Perryman (45:54):

I did.

Mr. Buxman (45:54):

All right. Was he able to locate the transaction or the receipt for that purchase?

Christopher Perryman (45:58):

He was.

Mr. Buxman (45:59):

Showing you State's 75. Do you recognize this?

Christopher Perryman (46:03):

I do.

Mr. Buxman (46:04):

All right. Did you also receive the surveillance footage regarding this purchase from Mr. Chestnut?

Christopher Perryman (46:15):

I did.

Mr. Buxman (46:23):

At this time, Your Honor, may I publish State's 76?

Judge (46:26):

Yes, sir.

Mr. Buxman (46:47):

You see a black Jeep pull up and park there?

Christopher Perryman (46:51):

Yes, sir. I do.

Mr. Buxman (52:00):

Were you able to determine what item was purchased?

Christopher Perryman (52:04):

Yes, I was.

Mr. Buxman (52:05):

What was it?

Christopher Perryman (52:06):

It was a eight by six green and blue tarp.

Mr. Buxman (52:09):

Did you locate a tarp from the store stock that was the same as the one that the defendant bought?

Christopher Perryman (52:16):

I did.

Mr. Buxman (52:16):

How'd you do that?

Christopher Perryman (52:18):

The transaction history of the receipt showed an item number, which I was able to determine was in the garden section. So I located the tarp with the same item number, I was able to photo document it.

Mr. Buxman (52:29):

Okay. May I approach?

Judge (52:31):

Yes, sir.

Mr. Buxman (52:31):

Showing the State's Exhibit WWW. Can you take a look at those photos and tell me if you recognize them?

Christopher Perryman (52:35):

I do.

Mr. Buxman (52:39):

And what do they show?

Christopher Perryman (52:40):

These are the photos of the tarp that I located in the garden section with the same item number.

Mr. Buxman (52:47):

Do they fairly and accurately depict what that tarp looked like when you photographed it?

Christopher Perryman (52:52):

They do.

Mr. Buxman (52:52):

At this time, state would move WWW into evidence as 77.

Speaker 2 (52:56):

No objection, Judge.

Judge (52:57):

Without objection, what's been marked for identification as State's Exhibit WWW will be admitted into evidence as State's Exhibit 77.

Mr. Buxman (53:03):

May I publish?

Judge (53:04):

Yes, sir.

Mr. Buxman (53:06):

Showing you photo one of State's 77, what do we see?

Christopher Perryman (53:10):

A picture of the tarp.

Mr. Buxman (53:11):

Okay. And photo two?

Christopher Perryman (53:13):

Same picture of the tarp.

Mr. Buxman (53:15):

Photo three?

Christopher Perryman (53:16):

A spread out picture of the blue side of the tarp.

Mr. Buxman (53:18):

And you said it was six by eight?

Christopher Perryman (53:20):

Six by eight, yes.

Mr. Buxman (53:21):

Photo four?

Christopher Perryman (53:22):

The other side of the tarp.

Mr. Buxman (53:24):

And photo five?

Christopher Perryman (53:26):

It's the label that shows the item number of the tarp.

Mr. Buxman (53:32):

Okay. Thank you, sir. No other questions, Your Honor.

Speaker 2 (53:33):

No questions, Your Honor.

Judge (53:34):

Members of the jury, do any of y'all have questions of this witness? If you do, please raise your hands. Seeing no hands, state, is he released?

Mr. Buxman (53:40):

He is, Your Honor.

Speaker 2 (53:41):

No objection, Your Honor.

Judge (53:42):

All right. Sir, you're free to go about your day. Thank you for your time.

Christopher Perryman (53:44):

Thank you.

Judge (53:45):

All right. State, you can call your next witness.

Mr. Buxman (53:47):

State calls Robert Dean.

Judge (54:24):

Please raise your right hand, face the clerk to be sworn.

Clerk (54:31):

Do you swear or affirm the testimony you're about to give will be the truth, the whole truth, and nothing but the truth, so help you God?

Robert Dean (54:31):

I do.

Judge (54:31):

You can go ahead and be seated.

Robert Dean (54:32):

Thanks, Your Honor. Thank you.

Mr. Buxman (54:32):

Morning, sir.

Robert Dean (54:32):

Morning.

Mr. Buxman (54:36):

Could you please introduce yourself to the jury?

Robert Dean (54:37):

I'm Special Agent Robert Dean with the Florida Department of Law Enforcement.

Mr. Buxman (54:41):

How long have you worked for FDLE?

Robert Dean (54:43):

Since January of 2024.

Mr. Buxman (54:45):

What'd you do before that?

Robert Dean (54:46):

I was a master police officer with the City of Altamonte Springs.

Mr. Buxman (54:50):

And what did you do for Altamonte Springs PD?

Robert Dean (54:53):

Various roles. Started in patrol. I was in the drug unit, intelligence unit. In the last six years, I was assigned to the ICAC Task Force conducting Internet Crimes Against Children investigations, as well as digital forensics with the Florida Department of Law Enforcement.

Mr. Buxman (55:08):

And what have you done for FDLE since you transitioned over to work for them?

Robert Dean (55:12):

Maintained my position in the ICAC Task Force, conducting internet crimes against children investigations, as well as digital forensics.

Mr. Buxman (55:19):

And ICAC is Internet Crimes Against Children?

Robert Dean (55:20):

Yes, sir.

Mr. Buxman (55:21):

What do you do on a day-to-day basis now?

Robert Dean (55:28):

My primary job is conducting digital forensics investigations for the ICAC Task Force, as well as other agents within FDLE or a smaller agency that do not have the capabilities.

Mr. Buxman (55:42):

Can you explain to the jury your educational background, your training, and your experience that'll let you do that job?

Robert Dean (55:47):

Since 2020, I have been completing digital forensics investigations and trainings. I have attended the National Computer Forensics Institute provided by the Secret Service. That included a five-week computer investigation course, a three-week mobile investigation course. I have completed the IACIS certified computer forensic certified examiner course, which is a two-week course followed by four months of testing and practical applications.

Mr. Buxman (56:23):

Are you also trained in a program called Cellebrite?

Robert Dean (56:25):

I am. Yes, sir.

Mr. Buxman (56:26):

We've heard a bunch about that, so I'm not going to ask you to describe what that is, but have you digitally extracted data using Cellebrite before?

Robert Dean (56:31):

Yes, sir. I have.

Mr. Buxman (56:34):

Are you also trained in a program called Axiom.

Robert Dean (56:36):

Yes, sir.

Mr. Buxman (56:37):

And describe for your training as far as that program is concerned.

Robert Dean (56:41):

Magnet Axiom is a proprietary tool for either extracting or examining digital evidence. I've completed multiple courses with AXIOM and I am titled a Magnet Computer Forensic Examiner and a Magnet Mobile Forensic Examiner, it requires specific classes as well as follow through with a practical test and written test.

Mr. Buxman (57:05):

During the course of your job, have you used that program to extract data from computers?

Robert Dean (57:10):

Yes, sir.

Mr. Buxman (57:13):

We've heard how a cell phone is extracted. How is the data extracted from a computer and examined?

Robert Dean (57:21):

The actual physical hard drive is removed from the device and attached to either a physical write blocker, which is built into the computer, or they also have standalone write blockers, which prevents data to be written or changed from the actual hard drive. So we can collect what's called a mirror image, which is a... Computers are ones and zeros. It's a bit for bit image, so there's no change of the actual evidence.

Mr. Buxman (57:53):

So the process of extracting the data and creating a exact copy doesn't change or alter any of the original data?

Robert Dean (57:59):

Correct.

Mr. Buxman (57:59):

That's what the write blocker is supposed to do?

Robert Dean (58:01):

Yes, sir.

Mr. Buxman (58:01):

Understood. Your Honor, at this time, the state would request permission to allow this witness to provide opinion testimony in the area of digital forensics.

Judge (58:10):

Okay. Any voir dire?

Speaker 2 (58:10):

No voir dire, Judge.

Judge (58:10):

Okay. You can continue.

Mr. Buxman (58:12):

Did you become involved in the case of State of Florida v. Dwain Hall?

Robert Dean (58:15):

Yes, sir.

Mr. Buxman (58:16):

Okay. And were you asked to extract data from two laptops recovered from Dwain Hall's residence?

Robert Dean (58:22):

Yes, sir.

Mr. Buxman (58:22):

And was a search warrant obtained that permitted you to access those laptops and extract that data?

Robert Dean (58:27):

Yes, sir.

Mr. Buxman (58:33):

I meant to ask you, why do you create a mirror, a copy of the original laptop? Why don't you just plug the laptop in and start working off of it?

Robert Dean (58:40):

As soon as the laptop is booted with the original data is in there, times change on the device. So by taking it and making a physical image of it, there's no change to the actual evidence. It maintains its integrity.

Mr. Buxman (58:52):

May I approach, Your Honor?

Judge (58:52):

Yes, sir.

Mr. Buxman (58:58):

I'm showing you what's introduced into evidence as State's Exhibit 58. Take a look at that item and first describe what it is. It's already in evidence, so you can take it out.

Robert Dean (59:23):

It's a black HP Pavilion laptop.

Mr. Buxman (59:24):

Okay. Did you attempt to extract data from that laptop?

Robert Dean (59:29):

I did.

Mr. Buxman (59:30):

Were you successful?

Robert Dean (59:30):

I was not.

Mr. Buxman (59:31):

Why not?

Robert Dean (59:32):

The hard drive appeared to have internal damage. When it was plugged in, it wouldn't be read by the write blocker or the computer, and it provided a clicking noise, which would indicate damage to the actual internal platters.

Mr. Buxman (59:44):

So were you able to extract any data from this laptop whatsoever?

Robert Dean (59:46):

I was not.

Mr. Buxman (01:00:03):

May I approach again?

Judge (01:00:04):

Yes, sir.

Mr. Buxman (01:00:04):

Showing you State's 59 in evidence, another laptop seized from Mr. Hall's residence. Did you attempt to examine that laptop?

Robert Dean (01:00:15):

Yes, sir. I did.

Mr. Buxman (01:00:16):

Okay. If you could go ahead and take it out.

Robert Dean (01:00:17):

Take it out.

Mr. Buxman (01:00:17):

It's in evidence.

Robert Dean (01:00:18):

Yes, sir.

Mr. Buxman (01:00:18):

Okay. What is that laptop?

Robert Dean (01:00:28):

It's a silver HP laptop.

Mr. Buxman (01:00:30):

And when you attempted to extract the data, did you use the same procedure you just described, creating a mirror image and then working off the mirror image?

Robert Dean (01:00:36):

Yes, sir, I did.

Mr. Buxman (01:00:39):

Okay. Were you able to recover any data from that laptop?

Robert Dean (01:00:41):

Yes, sir.

Mr. Buxman (01:00:42):

Were there any problems with the extraction process?

Robert Dean (01:00:44):

No, sir.

Mr. Buxman (01:00:45):

Once the extraction process is complete, how is the data from the laptop organized in a manner that you can actually go look around and find what you're looking for?

Robert Dean (01:00:56):

We use a program called Magnet Axiom Forensics. It's a digital forensics tool that actually pulls the data from the image and organizes it, parses out into different categories, so you can just click through and find what you're looking for.

Mr. Buxman (01:01:13):

When you examined the data from that silver HP laptop, did you search generally for any communications such as texts, chats, emails, things like that?

Robert Dean (01:01:22):

Yes, I did.

Mr. Buxman (01:01:22):

Specifically, did you search for communications between Dwain Hall and Sonia Exelby?

Robert Dean (01:01:27):

Yes, I did.

Mr. Buxman (01:01:28):

Did you find any communications between those two on that laptop?

Robert Dean (01:01:31):

No, I did not.

Mr. Buxman (01:01:33):

Did you also examine something called Edge browser Autofill information?

Robert Dean (01:01:37):

Yes, sir. I did.

Mr. Buxman (01:01:38):

What is that?

‍

Robert Dean (01:01:40):

Whenever you go to a website on any web browser, be it Chrome or Edge, and you go into, let's say, a form fillable website and you start putting in names, addresses, phone numbers, email addresses, the browser has the option to save that data. So when you click on it next time, it has a dropdown and you can just click it instead of having to reinput the information all the time.

Mr. Buxman (01:02:08):

So just ease for the user?

Robert Dean (01:02:10):

Correct. Yes, sir.

Mr. Buxman (01:02:13):

And what type of information does that Edge browser Autofill data contain usually?

Robert Dean (01:02:18):

It could contain different categories, first name, last name, full name, email address, phone number, address. It's a wide variety of things.

Mr. Buxman (01:02:29):

Okay. May I approach?

Judge (01:02:31):

Yes, sir.

Mr. Buxman (01:02:31):

Showing you State's Exhibit XXX. Take a look at that document. Let me know if you recognize it.

Robert Dean (01:02:37):

Yes, sir.

Mr. Buxman (01:02:38):

What is that?

Robert Dean (01:02:39):

This is the Axiom showing the Autofill information for the silver HP's laptop Edge browser.

Mr. Buxman (01:02:47):

And does that fairly and accurately reflect the data from the Edge Autofill browser that you found on the defendant's laptop?

Robert Dean (01:02:53):

Yes, sir.

Mr. Buxman (01:02:54):

At this time, State would move XXX into evidence as State's 78.

Speaker 2 (01:02:59):

No objection, Your Honor.

Judge (01:03:01):

Without objection, what's been marked for identification as State's Exhibit XXX will be admitted into evidence as State's Exhibit 78.

Robert Dean (01:03:05):

Yes, sir. Yes, sir.

Mr. Buxman (01:03:25):

May I publish?

Judge (01:03:26):

Yes, sir.

Mr. Buxman (01:03:30):

Showing you one of the records from that Autofill data, what name was associated with that Edge browser Autofill data?

Robert Dean (01:03:37):

Dwain Hall.

Mr. Buxman (01:03:40):

And what phone number was associated with the data?

Robert Dean (01:03:43):

330-575-4894.

Mr. Buxman (01:03:46):

Was there an email associated with the data?

Robert Dean (01:03:49):

Yes.

Mr. Buxman (01:03:49):

What was it?

Robert Dean (01:03:52):

Darkwolf44646@gmail.com.

Mr. Buxman (01:03:56):

Did you also examine the Edge browser web history?

Robert Dean (01:04:00):

Yes, sir.

Mr. Buxman (01:04:01):

What is that?

Robert Dean (01:04:02):

That stores... It collects a database of all the websites you go to. It generally logs a date or timeframe. Sometimes you can show how many times you go to it, but all the web browsers to keep that data.

Mr. Buxman (01:04:16):

Did you find any history showing that a site called motherless.com was visited on the defendant's silver laptop?

Robert Dean (01:04:22):

Yes, sir.

Mr. Buxman (01:04:24):

We've heard what Motherless is so I'm not going to ask you about that again. But during what period of time was that motherless. com website visited using that specific laptop?

Robert Dean (01:04:34):

I believe it was January of 2025. January to February.

Mr. Buxman (01:04:40):

Do you remember if it was visited in December of 2024?

Robert Dean (01:04:45):

I'd have to-

Mr. Buxman (01:04:46):

If it would refresh your memory to look at your report with the court's permission.

Judge (01:04:48):

Yes, sir. You may do that.

Robert Dean (01:04:49):

Thank you, sir. Yes, sir. December 2024 to February 2025.

Mr. Buxman (01:05:06):

Okay. Were you also asked to extract data and examine another laptop specifically belonging to Sonia Exelby?

Robert Dean (01:05:25):

Yes, sir.

Mr. Buxman (01:05:26):

May I approach, Judge?

Judge (01:05:28):

Yes, sir.

Mr. Buxman (01:05:29):

Showing you State's Exhibit 5 for identification. Take a look at that item and tell me if you recognize it.

Robert Dean (01:05:40):

Yes, sir.

Mr. Buxman (01:05:41):

So what is that?

Robert Dean (01:05:42):

A silver Asus laptop belonged to the victim.

Mr. Buxman (01:05:44):

Okay. Did you follow the same procedure you just described about doing a mirror image of the hard drive to analyze this laptop?

Robert Dean (01:05:52):

Yes sir, I did.

Mr. Buxman (01:05:52):

And were you successful in being able to extract the data from that laptop?

Robert Dean (01:05:56):

Yes, sir.

Mr. Buxman (01:05:57):

Did you also analyze that data?

Robert Dean (01:05:58):

Yes, sir.

Mr. Buxman (01:05:59):

During your analysis of that laptop data, did you locate-

Mr. Buxman (01:06:00):

During your analysis of that laptop data, did you locate communication between Sonia Exelby and the name Alpha Sadist?

Robert Dean (01:06:07):

Yes, sir, I did.

Mr. Buxman (01:06:08):

What did you find?

Robert Dean (01:06:09):

I found a screenshot of a conversation that had the username on top of Alpha Sadist.

Mr. Buxman (01:06:17):

May I approach, your Honor?

Judge (01:06:17):

Yes, sir.

Mr. Buxman (01:06:18):

Showing you State's Exhibit YYY for identification. Take a look at that, tell me if you recognize it.

Robert Dean (01:06:23):

Yes, sir. This is the screenshot.

Mr. Buxman (01:06:28):

And when was that communication? Again, if you have to look at your report to refresh your memory.

Robert Dean (01:06:32):

Yes. It was in July of 2024, I believe. Don't have that one specifically in my report.

Mr. Buxman (01:06:56):

Okay. Is there a date on the screenshot itself?

Robert Dean (01:07:00):

There is.

Mr. Buxman (01:07:00):

Okay. What's the date?

Robert Dean (01:07:04):

Looks like July 28th, around 8:21.

Mr. Buxman (01:07:08):

PM?

Robert Dean (01:07:09):

Yes, sir.

Mr. Buxman (01:07:09):

2021. And there's no year listed on that?

Robert Dean (01:07:11):

Correct. No year, sir.

Mr. Buxman (01:07:12):

Okay. Does that fairly and accurately depict the screenshot you found on Sonia Exelby's laptop?

Robert Dean (01:07:19):

Yes, sir.

Mr. Buxman (01:07:20):

At this time, state would move YYY into evidence as 79.

Mr. Barrett (01:07:25):

No objection, Your Honor.

Judge (01:07:27):

Without objection, what's been marked for identification as State's Exhibit YYY will be admitted into evidence as State's Exhibit 79.

Mr. Buxman (01:07:33):

May I publish?

Judge (01:07:34):

Yes, sir.

Mr. Buxman (01:08:19):

And to be clear, the bubbles, the messages in gray, are those coming from Alpha Sadist?

Robert Dean (01:08:26):

Correct, yes.

Mr. Buxman (01:08:26):

And the green would be coming from Sonia Exelby or Sonia from the laptop?

Robert Dean (01:08:33):

Yes, sir.

Mr. Buxman (01:08:33):

Okay. Except for that screenshot, did you locate any other communication between Sonia Exelby and Dwain Hall or Alpha Sadist?

Robert Dean (01:08:43):

No, sir.

Mr. Buxman (01:08:44):

Did you see any evidence on the victim's laptop that she also visited or that computer also visited motherless.com?

Robert Dean (01:08:51):

Yes, sir.

Mr. Buxman (01:08:51):

And what'd you find?

Robert Dean (01:08:52):

There were several email communications received by the website, noreply@motherless. com, or there were several emails received saying, "This is me, so-and-so from Motherless." So there was a lot of communication in her email about motherless.com.

Mr. Buxman (01:09:23):

Okay. Thank you, sir. No other questions, Your Honor.

Mr. Barrett (01:09:24):

No questions, Judge.

Judge (01:09:25):

Members of the jury, do any of y'all have questions of this witness? If you do, please raise your hand. I see one hand. Lawyers, if y'all can come up and approach. Remember write your question down on a clean sheet of paper and hand that to the bailiff if you could. Thank you, ma'am. Thank you, sir.

(01:09:54)
Members of the jury, I'm going to put the white noise on. Sir, the jury has posed a question for you. It's a single question. It's kind of written in two parts, but I'll read it all to you at once. "When examining the black HP laptop, could you determine how or why the hard drive was inaccessible? Was it an intentional damaging or could it be just wear and tear damage?"

Robert Dean (01:10:34):

No, there was no physical damage seen to the drive. It appeared to be an older laptop, an older drive. So it could have just been wear and tear or with those older drives with the spinning platters, even a minor fall could cause it to go out of place.

Judge (01:10:50):

Okay. State, any follow up?

Mr. Buxman (01:10:51):

No, Your Honor.

Judge (01:10:52):

Defense, any follow-up?

Mr. Barrett (01:10:53):

No, Your Honor.

Judge (01:10:53):

Members of the jury, any additional questions? If so, please raise your hands. Seeing no hands, State is he released?

Mr. Buxman (01:10:59):

He is, Your Honor.

Judge (01:11:00):

Defense.

Mr. Barrett (01:11:00):

No objection, Your Honor.

Judge (01:11:00):

Sir, you're free to go about your day. Thank you for your time.

Robert Dean (01:11:04):

All right.

Judge (01:11:04):

Ladies and gentlemen, anybody need a break? Okay. State next witness.

Mr. Buxman (01:11:09):

State calls Marissa Delaney.

Judge (01:11:59):

If you could raise your right hand, ma'am. Face the clerk to be sworn.

Clerk (01:12:07):

Do you swear or affirm the testimony you're about to give will be the truth, the whole truth, and nothing but the truth, so help you God?

Marissa Delaney (01:12:07):

I do.

Judge (01:12:07):

You can be seated, ma'am.

Mr. Buxman (01:12:08):

Good morning, ma'am.

Marissa Delaney (01:12:12):

Good morning.

Mr. Buxman (01:12:13):

Would you please introduce yourself to the jury?

Marissa Delaney (01:12:15):

Marissa Delaney.

Mr. Buxman (01:12:17):

Where do you work?

Marissa Delaney (01:12:18):

I work for the Florida Department of Law Enforcement.

Mr. Buxman (01:12:20):

And how long have you worked there?

Marissa Delaney (01:12:21):

Since 2013.

Mr. Buxman (01:12:23):

And what do you do for them?

Marissa Delaney (01:12:24):

I'm a crime intelligence analyst.

Mr. Buxman (01:12:25):

What does that involve? What do you do on a day-to-day basis?

Marissa Delaney (01:12:29):

So I am assigned to support the violent crimes squad, and in that capacity, I typically will do biographical research for investigative subjects as well as analyze historical location-based records, such as call detail records.

Mr. Buxman (01:12:49):

So on a regular basis, do you gather information from various companies to assist in tracking people's movements?

Marissa Delaney (01:12:58):

Yes.

Mr. Buxman (01:12:58):

Okay. Are you familiar with an application called Life360?

Marissa Delaney (01:13:03):

Yes.

Mr. Buxman (01:13:03):

And what is Life360 and kind of generally how does it work?

Marissa Delaney (01:13:07):

Life360 is a mobile application that allows users to share their real-time location with a small group of private users. That group is known as Circles within Life360, and those within your Circle can view your last known location in the application.

Mr. Buxman (01:13:28):

And where does the data as far as the location come from?

Marissa Delaney (01:13:36):

Life360 derives the locations from the location-based services on your phone. Those location-based services derive a location from three primary sources, GPS, WiFi, and cellular.

Mr. Buxman (01:13:53):

Did you receive records from Life360 associated with the username of darkwolf44646@gmail.com in the name Dwain Hall?

Marissa Delaney (01:14:04):

The username, correct, but only the first name was in the records.

Mr. Buxman (01:14:08):

Okay, just Dwain?

Marissa Delaney (01:14:09):

Yes.

Mr. Buxman (01:14:10):

At this time, Your Honor, the state would move State's Exhibit ZZZ into evidence. The Life360 results from Life360. Business record certification is included and proper notice has been given.

Mr. Barrett (01:14:26):

No objection, Judge.

Judge (01:14:27):

Without objection, what's been marked for identification as State's Exhibit ZZZ will be admitted into evidence as State's Exhibit 80.

Mr. Barrett (01:14:34):

Generally, what information was provided to you through the Life360 records?

Marissa Delaney (01:14:39):

The Life360 records generally contain a timestamp, latitude and longitude of that location, as well as estimated speed, potentially direction, device information, user information, things of that nature.

Mr. Buxman (01:14:57):

Does the Life360 track a cell phone's movements continuously, like every second constantly, or are there different factors that cause Life360 to log a person's location?

Marissa Delaney (01:15:14):

Life360 locations are generated more frequently with movement of the device. So if you're driving, there's going to be more frequent location, but if you're staying still, you're at home, it's going to be a less frequent interval of locations.

Mr. Buxman (01:15:32):

Okay. Based on the information provided to you by Life 360, are you able to take that information in the longitude and latitude coordinates and plot those on a map to make it understandable?

Marissa Delaney (01:15:45):

Yes.

Mr. Buxman (01:15:46):

Okay. And how do you go about doing that?

Marissa Delaney (01:15:48):

I will import those records into our mapping software, which we utilize a company called Gladiator Forensics and their analysis product, ESPA.

Mr. Buxman (01:15:58):

And does that process of importing the data from Life360 into the mapping program alter or change any of the original information?

Marissa Delaney (01:16:08):

No.

Mr. Buxman (01:16:09):

Did you in fact do that and create maps to help you analyze the movements of the phone?

Marissa Delaney (01:16:16):

Yes.

Mr. Buxman (01:16:16):

May I approach again, Judge?

Judge (01:16:21):

Yes, sir.

Mr. Buxman (01:16:22):

Showing you State's Exhibit AAAA. Can you take a look at those and tell me if you recognize them?

Marissa Delaney (01:16:43):

Yep, this is my presentation.

Mr. Buxman (01:16:44):

Okay. And do those maps fairly and accurately depict the maps that you created that were based on the actual results from Life360?

Marissa Delaney (01:16:53):

Yes.

Mr. Buxman (01:16:53):

At this time, State would move State's Exhibit AAAA into evidence as State's 81.

Mr. Barrett (01:17:01):

No objection, Judge.

Judge (01:17:02):

Without objection, what's been marked for identification as State's Exhibit AAAA will be admitted to evidence as State's Exhibit 81.

Mr. Buxman (01:17:11):

May I publish?

Judge (01:17:11):

Yes, sir.

Mr. Buxman (01:17:14):

Showing you the first page of that exhibit. Is this kind of just a general informational page?

Marissa Delaney (01:17:19):

Yes. It provides the information on the results and who requested it.

Mr. Buxman (01:17:24):

It includes the phone number and the email address associated with the records review?

Marissa Delaney (01:17:28):

As well as the timeframe of interest.

Mr. Buxman (01:17:37):

Okay. And for the record, what was the spelling of Dwain on the account?

Marissa Delaney (01:17:40):

D-W-A-I-N.

Mr. Buxman (01:17:44):

And for the record again, what was the email associated with the account?

Marissa Delaney (01:17:49):

Darkwolf44646@gmail.com.

Mr. Buxman (01:17:52):

And what was the phone number?

Marissa Delaney (01:17:52):

330-575-4894.

Mr. Buxman (01:17:58):

And we see an inference of, in the red section on the bottom, information about time zones.

Marissa Delaney (01:18:04):

Correct.

Mr. Buxman (01:18:04):

Can you explain what time zone the records are provided in?

Marissa Delaney (01:18:11):

So the two types of records that I applied on the maps, one is provided in local Eastern Standard Time or daylight time, and the other set of records is provided in Pacific Daylight Time.

Mr. Buxman (01:18:26):

I'm showing you image two of State's 81. Did the records also provide you something called geo points associated with the account?

Marissa Delaney (01:18:39):

So that is one of the two types of records I referred to, yes.

Mr. Buxman (01:18:52):

Okay. And what does this image show here? This is a closeup of the previous page we just looked at.

Marissa Delaney (01:18:57):

This is a snapshot or screenshot of the account information that provided by Life360.

Mr. Buxman (01:19:03):

Okay. And we talked about the geo points. What are the geo points? What does that mean?

Marissa Delaney (01:19:10):

Geo points are generated by movements such as driving, and they'll be generated at a more rapid frequency.

Mr. Buxman (01:19:19):

And what does this show in this image?

Marissa Delaney (01:19:23):

So these are how the raw records look. You see the column headers at the top, such as user ID, trip ID, the start time of the trip that they're taking. So if they start driving, they'll be the first geo point, and then accuracy indicator, that's in meters, and a bearing, which is a direction, latitude, longitude, and the timestamp, which is in Eastern.

Mr. Buxman (01:19:51):

And the information contained in the red box, is that generally the information you are focused on in tracking somebody's location?

Marissa Delaney (01:19:57):

Generally, yes.

Mr. Buxman (01:19:58):

Okay. And is that just a closeup of what we looked at?

Marissa Delaney (01:20:01):

Yes. Okay.

Mr. Buxman (01:20:05):

Did it also provide you different information regarding location?

Marissa Delaney (01:20:10):

They're both location, just how they name them, their naming convention. So yes.

Mr. Buxman (01:20:17):

And what does this image show from the second page of your exhibit?

Marissa Delaney (01:20:20):

So that is a screenshot of their locations records.

Mr. Buxman (01:20:25):

And are these, we see at the top, are these the records you referred to that are sent in Pacific Time?

Marissa Delaney (01:20:29):

Yes.

Mr. Buxman (01:20:30):

And how do you convert Pacific Time to Eastern Time?

Marissa Delaney (01:20:32):

We add three hours to Pacific Time.

Mr. Buxman (01:20:35):

All right. When you created the maps that we're going to look at in a few minutes, are all of the times in Eastern Time?

Marissa Delaney (01:20:43):

Yes.

Mr. Buxman (01:20:44):

Yes. Okay. Did you also plot various locations on those maps relevant to this case, such as a Walmart, an Airbnb, the defendant's residence, the grave site, things like that?

Marissa Delaney (01:20:57):

Yes.

Mr. Buxman (01:21:03):

All right. Showing you page 3 of State's 81. Can you explain for the jury, because we're going to see several of these, can you explain for the jury just what we're looking at, orient them to the different portions of what this shows?

Marissa Delaney (01:21:15):

Sure. So this is what I call an overview slide. I'll start at the top and work my way around. At the top, I'll give you, so the type of records, so it says Life360 and then the username associated with the data that I'm looking at. And then underneath that we have the timeframe depicted in the image, and then we'll go down to the bottom where that box is on the left, that's the legend. So any of the symbols represented on the map are explained there. And then we have different boxes. The blue ones are call out boxes for the locations indicated on the map, and then the purple ones are associated with those Life360 data points that we have already talked about.

Mr. Buxman (01:22:00):

So the purple boxes come directly from the data from the Life360 records?

Marissa Delaney (01:22:05):

Yes.

Mr. Buxman (01:22:12):

Okay. And we see this blue line going down the center of the map. What does that represent?

Marissa Delaney (01:22:18):

So it looks like a line, but really it's all those points just super close together and zoomed out pretty far, but they are actually individual Latin long data points.

Mr. Buxman (01:22:30):

So this individual latitude and longitude data points that are plotted, do those also come from the actual Life360 records?

Marissa Delaney (01:22:37):

Yes.

Mr. Buxman (01:22:38):

So each time Life360 logs a location, it appears in the map and there are a bunch of them which makes it look like a line?

Marissa Delaney (01:22:45):

Yes.

Mr. Buxman (01:22:45):

Understood. In some of these records, for instance, this purple record here, we see in the beginning, 10/10/2025 at 8:02 and 14 seconds PM. What does that represent?

Marissa Delaney (01:23:15):

That is the Eastern Daylight Time.

Mr. Buxman (01:23:17):

Okay. And we also see at the bottom of that entry, a different time, exactly seven hours difference. What does that represent?

Marissa Delaney (01:23:26):

So in the records, specifically the locations which are in Pacific Time, confusing bit in that records is after the timestamp, there's a Z which indicates Zulu, which the mapping software in its helpful nature converted those to UTC. So then that's a minus four from UTC to make it Eastern, but we had to add three to make it in Eastern from Pacific Time. And that was a little confusing, but that makes a seven-hour difference between those two timestamps.

Mr. Buxman (01:24:00):

And UTC is what?

Marissa Delaney (01:24:02):

Universal Coordinated Time.

Mr. Buxman (01:24:04):

Okay. And what is the point of that? What is that?

Marissa Delaney (01:24:08):

It's a universal standard to denote time.

Mr. Buxman (01:24:13):

Okay. So when we see records showing that seven hour difference, that is simply a conversion process that the mapping program does to try to account for the records?

Marissa Delaney (01:24:24):

Yes.

Mr. Buxman (01:24:25):

Am I right? When we're looking at these records, is it fair to say that the initial record that we see in Eastern time is what we should be focused on?

Marissa Delaney (01:24:34):

Yes.

Mr. Buxman (01:24:35):

And that again-

Marissa Delaney (01:24:36):

The one in bold.

Mr. Buxman (01:24:40):

Okay. And that comes directly again from the Life360 records?

Marissa Delaney (01:24:41):

Records. Yes.

Mr. Buxman (01:24:44):

Does the mapping program itself do this conversion or is this something you did?

Marissa Delaney (01:24:49):

So for the Pacific time records, I had to manually adjust for that timeframe so that they would match with the other records.

Mr. Buxman (01:24:57):

Okay. So generally, can you explain to the jury what this map shows regarding the location and path of travel of the cell phone associated with this account?

Marissa Delaney (01:25:08):

It's a little hard to tell from here, but in this map, we see travel between Gainesville and approximately the Ocala region.

Mr. Buxman (01:25:21):

Okay. And did you create some maps showing some close up portions and more narrow timeframes?

Marissa Delaney (01:25:28):

Yeah. I broke it into smaller chunks of time so that we can see the detail.

Mr. Buxman (01:25:39):

So I'm showing you image four. Can you explain to the jury what we're looking at here?

Marissa Delaney (01:25:47):

So again, at the top, I have the username of the records we're looking at, what type of records, and then the timeframe that we're looking at. I've broken it into 14:45, which is 2:45 to 17:00 or five o'clock, and then a sort of summary of the travel we're seeing. So we see from the area of the Hall residence up north towards Gainesville area.

Mr. Buxman (01:26:14):

And this is equate to traveling I-75?

Marissa Delaney (01:26:18):

Yes, it appears to, yes.

Mr. Buxman (01:26:21):

And this is between 2:45 and 5:00 PM on October 10th?

Marissa Delaney (01:26:27):

Yes.

Mr. Buxman (01:26:29):

Showing you image five, a kind of a close up view of the end of that period of time. What does this show?

Marissa Delaney (01:26:35):

Here we see continued travel into Gainesville up to the area of Walmart.

Mr. Buxman (01:26:45):

And at what time does he generally arrive at Walmart or in the area of Walmart?

Marissa Delaney (01:26:51):

In the area of Walmart, the Life360 records indicate 5:11 to 6:00 PM.

Mr. Buxman (01:27:01):

Did you create a closer version of the narrow time period of the time at Walmart?

Marissa Delaney (01:27:05):

Yes.

Mr. Buxman (01:27:05):

What do we see in image six?

Marissa Delaney (01:27:08):

Initially, we see Life360 records in the neighborhood behind Walmart, and then if we track along those timestamps, we see it go back towards the Walmart and in the general vicinity of that Walmart.

Mr. Buxman (01:27:23):

And what period of time was the phone in the general vicinity of Walmart?

Marissa Delaney (01:27:28):

We see Life360 data around the Walmart between 5:32 and 6:00 PM.

Mr. Buxman (01:27:37):

If several receipts were found at an Airbnb and video surveillance showed the defendant making purchases at Walmart in Gainesville at 5:47 and 5:54 PM, is that consistent with the Life360 data?

Marissa Delaney (01:27:51):

Yes.

Mr. Buxman (01:27:54):

Showing you image seven. Where do the records show the phone left after it left Walmart?

Marissa Delaney (01:28:00):

The Life360 data travels from the area of Walmart to the Gainesville airport.

Mr. Buxman (01:28:08):

Okay. By the Gainesville airport, is that over in this area by the plane?

Marissa Delaney (01:28:15):

Yes.

Mr. Buxman (01:28:16):

Okay. And photo or image eight, what does this show?

Marissa Delaney (01:28:20):

Here we have a zoomed in of around the Gainesville airport and we see Life360 data all around, presumably going around the pickup line.

Mr. Buxman (01:28:34):

We see a box with a whole bunch of entries here. What does that signify?

Marissa Delaney (01:28:40):

So those are only clumped together like that if they're the exact same latitude and longitude, otherwise they're going to be different boxes. And oftentimes the lat and long are just off by a little bit, but those are all exactly the same, which could be consistent with being still.

Mr. Buxman (01:28:58):

During what period of time did the Life360 records show the phone in the area of Gainesville Airport?

Marissa Delaney (01:29:07):

From approximately 6:17 to roughly 7:00. I believe it continued on the next slide.

Mr. Buxman (01:29:25):

Okay. If the defendant picked up Sonia Exelby at the Gainesville Airport, or excuse me, if Sonia Exelby landed at the Gainesville Airport, the defendant picked her up, she landed at 6:22 PM on October 10th of '25, is that consistent with the Life360 records?

Marissa Delaney (01:29:39):

The Life360 records are consistent with being at the airport at that time.

Mr. Buxman (01:29:45):

Okay. Showing you image nine from State's 81, where do the Life360 records show Dwain Hall going after the airport?

Marissa Delaney (01:29:58):

The Life360 records indicate travel from the area of the Gainesville airport towards the location of the Airbnb.

Mr. Buxman (01:30:10):

And at about what time do the records show the phone arriving in the area of the Airbnb?

Marissa Delaney (01:30:17):

Approximately 8:02 PM.

Mr. Buxman (01:30:19):

Is that what we see here in this entry?

Marissa Delaney (01:30:21):

Yes.

Mr. Buxman (01:30:22):

And the Airbnb at the bottom?

Marissa Delaney (01:30:22):

Correct.

Mr. Buxman (01:30:25):

Showing you image 10 from State's 81, what do we see here?

Marissa Delaney (01:30:30):

Here we have a zoomed in image of the area of the Airbnb and have a couple of call out boxes there depicting that passage of time at that location.

Mr. Buxman (01:30:43):

And during what period of time does the Life360 results reflect the phone being at the Airbnb?

Marissa Delaney (01:30:49):

Between 8:11 PM and 8:45 the next morning.

Mr. Buxman (01:30:57):

So showing you image 11, I believe.

Marissa Delaney (01:31:03):

Yes.

Mr. Buxman (01:31:06):

What period of time does this image now cover?

Marissa Delaney (01:31:09):

We are now on October 11th, between 8:00 AM and 11:59 PM.

Mr. Buxman (01:31:13):

Okay. And what do the records show regarding the movement of that phone at that time?

Marissa Delaney (01:31:24):

We see Life360 data indicating movement from the area of the Airbnb towards Gainesville, and I believe it comes back down towards that Airbnb again.

Mr. Buxman (01:31:46):

Did the records show the phone moved from the Airbnb to a Dunkin Donuts and then back to the Airbnb?

Marissa Delaney (01:31:53):

Yes.

Mr. Buxman (01:31:54):

And then after that, do the records show that it went to a Dollar General or eventually ending up at a TA travel center, a Petro Station by the interstate?

Marissa Delaney (01:32:11):

Yes, I believe, if I recall correctly.

Mr. Buxman (01:32:14):

And there, where did it go after the Petro Station? That's okay. We'll get to it. It's fine. All right. Showing you image 12 of State's 81. What does this show?

Marissa Delaney (01:32:29):

Here we have Life360 data in the vicinity of the TA Petro Station.

Mr. Buxman (01:32:35):

During what period of time did the data show the phone was at the TA Petro Station near the Wendy's?

Marissa Delaney (01:32:42):

Approximately around 12:01 PM to 12:08 PM.

Mr. Buxman (01:32:49):

If a transaction history and surveillance footage showed the defendant buying some food items at that station at 12:06, is that consistent with the Life360 records?

Marissa Delaney (01:32:59):

Those times are consistent with the Life360 records.

Mr. Buxman (01:33:03):

Showing you image 13 of State's 81, what do the records show about where the phone went from the Petro Station after it left?

Marissa Delaney (01:33:14):

Following the Petro Station, returned to the Airbnb Life360 records.

Mr. Buxman (01:33:20):

And during what period of time did the phone stay at the Airbnb after it arrived there?

Marissa Delaney (01:33:26):

Again, I have a couple of call-outs there depicting that passage of time, and it's between 12:20 PM to 8:24 AM the next morning.

Mr. Buxman (01:33:38):

12:20 hours would be 10:20... I'm sorry, 12:20 in the afternoon, right?

Marissa Delaney (01:33:44):

Yes.

Mr. Buxman (01:33:44):

Okay. So basically arrives at about 12:20 in the area of the Airbnb and stays there all night?

Marissa Delaney (01:33:52):

Yes.

Mr. Buxman (01:33:55):

Okay. Showing you image 14 of State's 81. Moving on to the next day, generally, what do those records show the path of travel of that phone throughout that day?

Marissa Delaney (01:34:10):

If I recall correctly, starts out from the Airbnb, goes to Dunkin', comes... I don't know if it's Lowe's, right?

Mr. Buxman (01:34:21):

Did it at some point go to Lowe's?

Marissa Delaney (01:34:22):

Yes.

Mr. Buxman (01:34:24):

Okay. We'll get to the individual-

Marissa Delaney (01:34:27):

Lowe's and then Dunkin'.

Mr. Buxman (01:34:30):

All right. Let's look at image 15 of State's 81. When the phone left the Airbnb, where did it go?

Marissa Delaney (01:34:39):

When the phone left, the Airbnb, Life360 records indicate approaching the vicinity of Lowe's.

Mr. Buxman (01:34:46):

And this is on what day?

Marissa Delaney (01:34:48):

This is on October 12th.

Mr. Buxman (01:34:51):

And at what time does the phone arrive in the area of Lowe's?

Marissa Delaney (01:34:57):

Approximately 8:50 AM.

Mr. Buxman (01:35:00):

Showing you image 16 of State's 81, what does this show?

Marissa Delaney (01:35:03):

We have Life360 records in the vicinity of the Lowe's and a closer look at it with the times on the right there depicting a sampling of the times there.

Mr. Buxman (01:35:22):

And again, during what period of time was the phone near Lowe's?

Marissa Delaney (01:35:28):

Approximately around 8:52 to 9:03 AM.

Mr. Buxman (01:35:44):

Showing you image 17 from State's 81. After the phone left Lowe's, where did it go?

Marissa Delaney (01:35:53):

After Lowe's, the Life360 data showed travel to a nearby Dunkin' Donuts.

Mr. Buxman (01:35:58):

Okay. And then where'd it go after that?

Marissa Delaney (01:36:00):

From the Dunkin', we see Life360 data going southbound towards the vicinity of the burial site.

Mr. Buxman (01:36:08):

And about what time do the records show the phone arrived near the area of the burial site?

Marissa Delaney (01:36:20):

We see an approach with the Life360 data to the burial site area at around 9:25 AM.

Mr. Buxman (01:36:29):

Showing you image 18 of State's 81. Is this a zoomed in area?

Marissa Delaney (01:36:33):

Yes.

Mr. Buxman (01:36:34):

What does this show?

Marissa Delaney (01:36:36):

Here we see Life360 data indicating traveling west along, I believe that's 484, and then coming back east on 484 and then kind of stopping just off of the road there.

Mr. Buxman (01:36:53):

And we see some little directional arrows here?

Marissa Delaney (01:36:57):

Yes.

Mr. Buxman (01:36:58):

Does that just show the path of travel?

Marissa Delaney (01:37:00):

Yes. And in the records, I mentioned earlier that there's bearing, which means direction in those records. So if we looked at it, we'd see approximately 270 degrees indicating west and back east with 90 degrees.

Mr. Buxman (01:37:15):

So again, the direction of travel, does that come directly from the Life360 records?

Marissa Delaney (01:37:20):

Yes.

Mr. Buxman (01:37:20):

You're not making assumptions?

Marissa Delaney (01:37:21):

No.

Mr. Buxman (01:37:21):

Okay. Showing you image 19 of State's 81. What does this show?

Marissa Delaney (01:37:27):

This is again a spot just off 484 where there seems to be a moment of time spent.

Mr. Buxman (01:37:44):

Okay. And image 20 of State's 81, what does this show?

Marissa Delaney (01:37:45):

More Life360 data in the vicinity of the burial site.

Mr. Buxman (01:37:49):

And this red box here, is that the burial site?

Marissa Delaney (01:37:52):

Approximate burial site, yes.

Mr. Buxman (01:37:53):

And during what period of time do the records show the phone in that area?

Marissa Delaney (01:38:00):

We have records in that area from approximately 9:39 AM to 10:41 AM.

Mr. Buxman (01:38:11):

And which direction did the phone head after it left the burial site?

Marissa Delaney (01:38:16):

At 10:50 AM, we see a eastbound direction.

Mr. Buxman (01:38:25):

Okay. Showing you image 21 of State's 81. Where did the phone go after it left the burial site at about 10:50 AM?

Marissa Delaney (01:38:33):

Life360 indicates traveling north on 75 or along 75 approximately there towards the Circle K in Gainesville.

Mr. Buxman (01:38:41):

You see the Circle K up here at the top?

Marissa Delaney (01:38:46):

Yes.

Mr. Buxman (01:38:46):

Okay. Showing you image 22 of State's 81, what does this show?

Marissa Delaney (01:38:52):

From the Circle K, Life360 data indicates traveling towards the area of a Kohl's.

Mr. Buxman (01:39:00):

And again, we see a box with a whole bunch of entries there.

Mr. Buxman (01:39:01):

And again, we see a box with a whole bunch of entries there near the Kohl's. What does that mean?

Marissa Delaney (01:39:08):

Those all have the exact same lat mall.

Mr. Buxman (01:39:14):

And it appears the records show that he's outside the Kohl's business, but around the parking lot area; am I right?

Marissa Delaney (01:39:22):

It does appear to be around the perimeter of the Kohl's there.

Mr. Buxman (01:39:25):

And where did the phone generally remain throughout the rest of the afternoon?

Marissa Delaney (01:39:29):

Generally in the area of Gainesville, Florida.

Mr. Buxman (01:39:34):

Showing you image 23 of State's 81. Later on that night, what did the records show regarding the phone based on the Life360 results?

Marissa Delaney (01:39:48):

So, this is later in that day. The Life360 from Gainesville descended south. And here we see a moment in time where it appears to do maybe a drive by of the burial site.

Mr. Buxman (01:40:07):

Okay. The burial site again is the red box?

Marissa Delaney (01:40:10):

Yes.

Mr. Buxman (01:40:10):

And are there geolocation data placing him or placing the phone in that general area?

Marissa Delaney (01:40:14):

Yes.

Mr. Buxman (01:40:15):

And you said it appeared to be a drive by. What do you base that on?

Marissa Delaney (01:40:20):

The Life360 data follows along the road there. And if we look at the times, it looks like went west first and then circled back around and then looped up and back.

Mr. Buxman (01:40:36):

So, it's a pretty short period of time where the Life360 results put the phone in?

Marissa Delaney (01:40:39):

I actually plotted it in Google Maps and it's about a five-minute drive, three minute drive, I believe. So, that's about the right time.

Mr. Buxman (01:40:48):

Okay. And during what period of time did the records show the phone near the area of the burial site the evening of October 12th of '25?

Marissa Delaney (01:40:58):

Around 7:10 PM.

Mr. Buxman (01:40:59):

Okay. And where did the records show the phone went and spent the rest of the night?

Marissa Delaney (01:41:05):

It traveled towards the Hall residence.

Mr. Buxman (01:41:07):

Okay. Showing you image 24. What period of time does this image reflect?

Marissa Delaney (01:41:17):

This is October 14th in the morning.

Mr. Buxman (01:41:24):

In the morning? What period of time in the morning?

Marissa Delaney (01:41:27):

So, we have approximately 8:00 AM to 9:31.

Mr. Buxman (01:41:33):

And what do the Life360 records show regarding the phone's location and path of travel that morning?

Marissa Delaney (01:41:41):

Life360 indicates travel from the vicinity of the Hall residence to the UPS store on 34th Avenue in Ocala.

Mr. Buxman (01:41:50):

And about what time did he arrive near the area of the UPS store?

Marissa Delaney (01:41:55):

Around 9:31 AM.

Mr. Buxman (01:41:58):

Okay. I'm showing you image 25 of State's 81. Did you create a zoomed-in section of the map for the UPS store?

Marissa Delaney (01:42:06):

Yes.

Mr. Buxman (01:42:07):

What does this show?

Marissa Delaney (01:42:09):

This indicates the vicinity of the UPS store where the Life360 data coincides. We have approximately 9:14 AM to 9:19, in that vicinity.

Mr. Buxman (01:42:28):

And if a UPS for shipping receipt was found in the defendant's Jeep at that UPS store on October 14th of 2025 at 9:23 AM, is that consistent with the Life360 records?

Marissa Delaney (01:42:42):

The Life360 records are consistent with being in that vicinity.

Mr. Buxman (01:42:45):

Okay. Thank you, ma'am. No other questions, Your Honor.

Speaker 4 (01:42:49):

No questions, Judge.

Judge (01:42:50):

Members of the jury, do any of y'all have questions of this witness? If you do, please raise your hands. I see no hands. State, is she released?

Mr. Buxman (01:42:57):

Yes, Your Honor.

Speaker 4 (01:42:57):

No objection, Your Honor.

Judge (01:42:58):

Okay. Ma'am, you're free to go about your day. Thank you for your time. Members of the jury, anybody need a break? Okay. State, next witness.

Amy Berndt (01:43:06):

State recalls Rebecca McKenzie.

Judge (01:44:04):

Good morning, ma'am. If you could raise your right hand and face the clerk to be sworn. Can you also hand me that exhibit there? Thank you, ma'am.

Speaker 3 (01:44:12):

Do you swear or affirm the testimony you're about to give will be the whole truth and nothing but the truth, so help you God?

Rebecca McKenzie (01:44:15):

I do.

Judge (01:44:17):

Go ahead. Be seated, ma'am. Thank you.

Rebecca McKenzie (01:44:18):

Thank you.

Amy Berndt (01:44:19):

Good morning.

Rebecca McKenzie (01:44:20):

Good morning.

Amy Berndt (01:44:22):

Can you please tell the jury your name again?

Rebecca McKenzie (01:44:24):

My name's Rebecca McKenzie.

Amy Berndt (01:44:26):

And when we last spoke with you, Sonia's body had been found and you had obtained the defendant's DNA?

Rebecca McKenzie (01:44:33):

Correct.

Amy Berndt (01:44:34):

Now, over the next several months, did you continue to investigate this case?

Rebecca McKenzie (01:44:38):

Yes, I did.

Amy Berndt (01:44:38):

Did that include obtaining more search warrants, including warrants for the social media accounts of almost everyone involved in this case?

Rebecca McKenzie (01:44:46):

Yes, it did.

Amy Berndt (01:44:47):

Did you also travel to England?

Rebecca McKenzie (01:44:49):

I did.

Amy Berndt (01:44:50):

What did you do there?

Rebecca McKenzie (01:44:51):

While I was in England, I collaborated with the local law enforcement to conduct interviews with the family and friends of Sonia, as well as collect evidence.

Amy Berndt (01:45:02):

Was Sonia communicating with friends and family via Facebook Messenger, Discord, and Telegram during the timeframe October 10th of 2025 to October 11th of 2025?

Rebecca McKenzie (01:45:14):

She was.

Amy Berndt (01:45:15):

All right. And using all of the information from the social media accounts and interviews, were you able to verify the last time Sonia had communicated with friends and family before she was murdered?

Rebecca McKenzie (01:45:24):

I was.

Amy Berndt (01:45:27):

All right. I first want to talk about her sister, Gemma. When is the last time that Sonia communicated with or sent a message to her sister, Gemma, during that timeframe?

Rebecca McKenzie (01:45:36):

Would it be okay for me to refer to my notes?

Amy Berndt (01:45:38):

If that refreshes your recollection.

Judge (01:45:39):

Yes, ma'am.

Rebecca McKenzie (01:46:08):

You would like the time for Gemma? I just want to make sure.

Amy Berndt (01:46:11):

Yes. The last time Sonia communicated with or sent a message to her sister, Gemma.

Rebecca McKenzie (01:46:15):

The last time that Sonia communicated with Gemma was at 8:42 AM Eastern Daylight Time on October 11th, 2025.

Amy Berndt (01:46:27):

And then I want to talk about her fiance, Stevie Hunt. When is the last time Sonia communicated with or sent a message to Stevie Hunt?

Rebecca McKenzie (01:46:41):

The last time that Sonia communicated with Stevie was 1:26 PM Eastern Daylight Time on October 11th.

Amy Berndt (01:46:51):

And then I want to talk about Sara, her sister Sara. When is the last time Sonia communicated with or sent a message to her sister Sara?

Rebecca McKenzie (01:46:59):

The last time that Sonia communicated with Sara was 1:27 PM Eastern Daylight Time on October 11th, 2025.

Amy Berndt (01:47:07):

All right. And so, even if any of those people sent her messages after those times, she never responded to those people, any of those people?

Rebecca McKenzie (01:47:16):

Correct.

Amy Berndt (01:47:16):

All right. And then I want to talk about some communication with Ari Peterson. Was Sonia communicating with a person named Ari Peterson during this timeframe, October 10th to October 11th of 2025?

Rebecca McKenzie (01:47:29):

Yes, she was.

Amy Berndt (01:47:31):

All right. And during your investigation, did you actually speak with and interview Ari Peterson?

Rebecca McKenzie (01:47:35):

I did.

Amy Berndt (01:47:36):

All right. And where did he live?

Rebecca McKenzie (01:47:37):

He lived in Sweden.

Amy Berndt (01:47:40):

And was he an online friend of Sonia's?

Rebecca McKenzie (01:47:43):

Yes.

Amy Berndt (01:47:44):

All right. Now, when we learned that Sonia sent Ari Peterson a letter through Discord platform on October 11th of 2025, based on the records, when was the letter sent through Discord in Eastern Time?

Rebecca McKenzie (01:48:03):

That message was sent at 4:47 PM on October 11th.

Amy Berndt (01:48:11):

And the letter we're talking about is the letter Sonia sent to Ari Peterson and then Ari sent that letter to her sister, Sara?

Rebecca McKenzie (01:48:18):

Correct.

Amy Berndt (01:48:19):

All right. And besides that letter on October 11th of 4:47, that communication she sent to Ari, when is the last time she communicated with or sent Ari Peterson a message, besides that letter?

Rebecca McKenzie (01:48:35):

The last communication that Sonia had with Ari was approximately 11:06 PM Eastern Daylight Time, October 11th, 2025.

Amy Berndt (01:48:47):

And she sent that letter to him by Discord. What platform did she send that very last communication to him on?

Rebecca McKenzie (01:48:56):

Telegram.

Amy Berndt (01:48:56):

All right. So, she was communicating with Ari on Discord and Telegram?

Rebecca McKenzie (01:49:01):

Correct.

Amy Berndt (01:49:01):

All right. Were you able to get any records from Telegram?

Rebecca McKenzie (01:49:04):

‍

I was not. Telegram is an app where the messages are encrypted, so unless you have the device, you're unable to recover the messages.

Amy Berndt (01:49:12):

All right. And were you able to get that last time that Sonia communicated with Ari or sent him a message as October 11th at 11:06 PM from some screenshots that Ari provided you when you interviewed him?

Rebecca McKenzie (01:49:24):

Correct.

Amy Berndt (01:49:25):

All right. So, we don't have the official Telegram records then?

Rebecca McKenzie (01:49:27):

Correct.

Amy Berndt (01:49:30):

Now, did you do a subpoena or a search warrant to obtain the defendant's bank records from Regions Bank?

Rebecca McKenzie (01:49:36):

So, there were two subpoenas. I did one and then another agent did a second.

Amy Berndt (01:49:41):

So, between the two of those, you were able to obtain his bank records from Regions Bank?

Rebecca McKenzie (01:49:44):

Correct.

Amy Berndt (01:49:56):

Your Honor, at this time we would move CCCC into records, the Regions Bank records. We filed a notice of intent to rely on a business record certification and there is a business record certification attached.

Speaker 4 (01:50:06):

No objection, Judge.

Judge (01:50:08):

That objection was marked for identification as State's Exhibit quadrupleC. Will be admitted into evidence as State's Exhibit 82.

Amy Berndt (01:50:14):

Your Honor, may I approach the witness?

Judge (01:50:15):

Yes, ma'am.

Amy Berndt (01:50:15):

I'm going to show you these records that have been entered into State's 82, the Regions Bank records. Do you recognize those?

Rebecca McKenzie (01:50:45):

I do.

Amy Berndt (01:50:47):

Okay. And have you had a chance to review those before coming in here today?

Rebecca McKenzie (01:50:49):

I have.

Amy Berndt (01:50:49):

All right. Do all those bank records of the defendants from Regions Bank confirm all of the purchases the defendant made that you and other law enforcement officers found video and receipts for?

Rebecca McKenzie (01:51:01):

Yes.

Amy Berndt (01:51:03):

Is the time actually off on those bank records?

Rebecca McKenzie (01:51:06):

It is. So, the main branch for Regions Bank is in Birmingham, Alabama, which is an hour behind our time, and so the records are one hour behind.

Amy Berndt (01:51:18):

So, if you wanted to convert those to Eastern Standard Time, you would just add an hour to whatever time is in those records?

Rebecca McKenzie (01:51:23):

Correct.

Amy Berndt (01:51:24):

But the date is correct and everything else is correct?

Rebecca McKenzie (01:51:25):

Yes.

Amy Berndt (01:51:28):

Now, based on those records, did the defendant, Dwain Hall, receive any money in October of 2025 from Sonia Exelby into his Regions account?

Rebecca McKenzie (01:51:38):

Yes, he did.

Amy Berndt (01:51:39):

And how much money did he receive?

Rebecca McKenzie (01:51:40):

He receives $1,200.

Amy Berndt (01:51:42):

All right. And was that on October 11th of 2025 at 1:10 PM?

Rebecca McKenzie (01:51:48):

Correct.

Amy Berndt (01:51:50):

Did the defendant receive any money from Sonia Exelby into his Regions account in March of 2025?

Rebecca McKenzie (01:51:55):

He did.

Amy Berndt (01:51:55):

Okay. How much money did he receive from Sonia in March of 2025?

Rebecca McKenzie (01:52:01):

He received two amounts. I would like to check my records if that's okay.

Judge (01:52:12):

Yes, ma'am.

Rebecca McKenzie (01:52:52):

On March 11th, 2025, Sonia's card number ending in 0804 made a payment to Solver Wolfs Roadside Assistance in the amount of three US dollars. This payment was reflected in Dwain Hall's Region Bank account on March 12th. And then there was another charge on March 17th, 2025 from Sonia's card number ending in 0804, which made a payment to Solver Wolfs Roadside Assistance in the amount of 500 US dollars. This payment is reflected in Dwain Hall's Region Bank account on March 18th, 2025.

Amy Berndt (01:53:30):

Thank you. And during the investigation, did you learn that the defendant sent a package to a person in Ohio named Rick Snyder on October 14th of 2025?

Rebecca McKenzie (01:53:40):

I did.

Amy Berndt (01:53:41):

Your Honor, may I approach the witness?

Judge (01:53:45):

Yes, ma'am.

Amy Berndt (01:53:45):

I'll show you what's been marked for identification as State's Exhibit BBBB. Tell me, do you recognize the person in that photograph?

Rebecca McKenzie (01:53:52):

Yes, this is Rick Snyder.

Amy Berndt (01:53:54):

All right. Is that a fair and accurate depiction of the way Rick Snyder looked?

Rebecca McKenzie (01:53:57):

Yes.

Amy Berndt (01:53:57):

Thank you. Your Honor, at this time we would move State's Exhibit BBBD into evidence.

Speaker 4 (02:06:07):

No objection, Judge.

Judge (02:06:08):

Without objection, what's been marked for identification as State's Exhibit quadruple B will be admitted into evidence as State's Exhibit 83.

Amy Berndt (02:06:13):

And how did you learn that the defendant sent a package to Rick Snyder in Ohio?

Rebecca McKenzie (02:06:13):

Through Facebook messages that were retrieved from Dwain Hall's phone.

Amy Berndt (02:06:13):

All right. Was there also a UPS label that was found in the defendant's car, showing that he went to UPS and mailed a package?

Rebecca McKenzie (02:06:13):

Yes, as well as bank records verifying that.

Amy Berndt (02:06:13):

Okay. And I think you just said this, but there were messages recovered from the defendant's cell phone between Rick Snyder and the defendant about the package?

Rebecca McKenzie (02:06:13):

Yes, there was.

Amy Berndt (02:06:13):

Your Honor, may I approach the witness?

Judge (02:06:13):

Yes, ma'am.

Amy Berndt (02:06:13):

I'm going to show you what's been entered into evidence already as State's 37. If you can look at those and tell me, do you recognize those to be the messages between the defendant and Rick Snyder about the package that he sent?

Rebecca McKenzie (02:06:13):

I do.

Amy Berndt (02:06:13):

Okay. Your Honor, at this time, may I publish State's 37?

Judge (02:06:13):

Yes, ma'am.

Amy Berndt (02:06:13):

Okay. All right. First, who are we looking at here?

Rebecca McKenzie (02:06:13):

That would be Rick Snyder.

Amy Berndt (02:06:13):

Okay. And then can we turn the lights off and see if that makes that easier to see? Now, when we're looking up here in the right-hand corner, this is obviously Defendant. Is this the first message that is sent over Facebook Messenger about this package?

Rebecca McKenzie (02:06:13):

Yes.

Amy Berndt (02:06:13):

Okay. And is that October 13th, obviously the date and the time at 8:34 PM?

Rebecca McKenzie (02:06:13):

Correct.

Amy Berndt (02:06:13):

Okay. If you could tell us, what does Dwain Hall say?

Rebecca McKenzie (02:06:13):

"I need your address again, please."

Amy Berndt (02:06:13):

All right. And then what is this we're looking at right here on your left?

Rebecca McKenzie (02:06:13):

That is an indication that there was a message, but it was deleted.

Amy Berndt (02:06:13):

Okay. Deleted a message from whom?

Rebecca McKenzie (02:06:13):

From Rick.

Amy Berndt (02:06:13):

Okay. That that was deleted?

Rebecca McKenzie (02:06:13):

Yes.

Amy Berndt (02:06:13):

All right. And then would this be the next entry in this chain between the two of them?

Rebecca McKenzie (02:06:13):

Correct.

Amy Berndt (02:06:13):

All right. And then if you can just tell us who is this Rick Snyder, and he says why?

Rebecca McKenzie (02:06:13):

Correct.

Amy Berndt (02:06:13):

All right. And then-

Rebecca McKenzie (02:06:13):

Dwain Hall responds, saying, "Correct spelling of you. Last name is S-N-Y or S-N-I."

Amy Berndt (02:06:13):

All right. And then again, does this indicate that a message was sent by Rick, but it was deleted by Rick?

Rebecca McKenzie (02:06:13):

Yes.

Amy Berndt (02:06:13):

Okay. And then in response to the question for the spelling of his name, this is sent by Rick Snyder?

Rebecca McKenzie (02:06:13):

Correct. Multiple question marks.

Amy Berndt (02:06:13):

All right. And then after that, again, is it showing us a message sent by Rick that's deleted?

Rebecca McKenzie (02:06:13):

Correct.

Amy Berndt (02:06:13):

All right. And then tell us, go through these columns for us.

Rebecca McKenzie (02:06:13):

So, Dwain Hall sends a message stating, "Delete that." Then he says, "Thank you." And then says... sends a third message, "LOL," which typically means laugh out loud. "Need your address, though."

Amy Berndt (02:06:13):

All right. And again, this is on October 13th. We're 8:39, 8:40, 8:40. And then Rick Snyder responds to the request again for his address with?

Rebecca McKenzie (02:06:13):

"Huh?"

Amy Berndt (02:06:13):

All right. And then the defendant responds?

Rebecca McKenzie (02:06:13):

"I need your address put back, please."

Amy Berndt (02:06:13):

All right. And then Rick Snyder?

Rebecca McKenzie (02:06:13):

Says, "I'm why," and then says, "Um."

Amy Berndt (02:06:13):

All right. And the defendant responds?

Rebecca McKenzie (02:06:13):

"Can't tell you here. Least I say the better."

Amy Berndt (02:06:13):

All right. Then go ahead. You can just go through the rest of them on this page.

Rebecca McKenzie (02:06:13):

Okay. And then Rick asks, "Is your number the same?" Dwain responds, "Yeah, but may be tapped." Rick responds, "Fuck you, do now." And then Dwain responds, "Thank you. LOL. Need your address though."

Amy Berndt (02:06:13):

All right. And then this is indicating that Rick sent some sort of image that was deleted or that couldn't be recovered. We don't know what that is?

Rebecca McKenzie (02:06:13):

Correct.

Amy Berndt (02:06:13):

All right. And then what happens?

Rebecca McKenzie (02:06:13):

Dwain says, "Might be a big storm coming for me." Rick responds, "If you sign me up for Mormons, I'm prank trapping your house again." Dwain responds, "LOL." Rick responds, "If you need somewhere, I might be able to find room for you."

Amy Berndt (02:06:13):

And what is this?

Rebecca McKenzie (02:06:13):

And then Dwain sends a picture of a label.

Amy Berndt (02:06:13):

All right. Is that the label from the UPS?

Rebecca McKenzie (02:06:13):

Yes.

Amy Berndt (02:06:13):

All right. And is this a closeup of that UPS label that was recovered?

Rebecca McKenzie (02:06:13):

Correct.

Amy Berndt (02:06:13):

All right. It's showing that he sent something to Rick Snyder?

Rebecca McKenzie (02:06:13):

Correct.

Amy Berndt (02:06:13):

And then if we can start up here with the defendant.

Rebecca McKenzie (02:06:13):

Dwain says, "We'll need this back in six months. If this storm passes over with no lingering fallout, please, for the love of shadows, don't lose this box. There's no need to even open it. These are very precious and valuable personal items." Rick responds, "Should I bury it in the yard? LOL." And then says, "I'm joking. I'll keep your stuff safe." Dwain says, "Thanks, man. I appreciate it. Just make sure you message Ginger and ask her about the return in six months, just in case this storm is as bad as expected."

Amy Berndt (02:06:13):

And who is Ginger?

Rebecca McKenzie (02:06:13):

Ginger is Dwain Hall's wife.

Amy Berndt (02:06:13):

All right.

Rebecca McKenzie (02:06:13):

Rick responds, "What?" And then Dwain says, "I need your address put back, please." Rick asks, "Is it child support again?" And then, "I thought that was done with that." Dwain Hall says, "Can't say."

Amy Berndt (02:06:13):

All right. And then there's a 24-hour gap in the conversation about this package between the two of them?

Rebecca McKenzie (02:06:13):

Correct.

Amy Berndt (02:06:13):

Then it continues on. We're on October 16th now of 2025, and Rick's responding.

Rebecca McKenzie (02:06:13):

"Check what time your stuff is supposed to get here." Dwain responds, "I can't check it right now. Why? What's going on?" "Nothing. I'm just going to the grocery store and trying not to miss UPS guy." Dwain responds, "Okay." Rick then says, "You're jumpy." And then, "Why you like long tail cat on a room full of rocking chairs?" And Dwain responds, "Mostly because that box contains two of my most prized possessions." And then says, "I really don't trust the mail systems. UPS is usually okay though. I feel strangely naked without them." Rick responds, "I get it, so how do I help you unfuck yourself out of whatever mess you are in?" Dwain responds, "I don't know because I don't know what kind of mess it is yet. For now, just hold onto the box. If anybody asked about the box that isn't Ginger, it doesn't exist." And Rick responds, "Okay."

Amy Berndt (02:06:13):

And this conversation is happening the night before Sonia's body is found?

Rebecca McKenzie (02:06:13):

Yes.

Amy Berndt (02:06:13):

All right. Go ahead.

Rebecca McKenzie (02:06:13):

"I got a box, but it looks like a Walmart order." Oh, I'm sorry. Dwain says, "Thanks, man. I always knew I could count on you." Rick then responds, "I got a box, but it looks like a Walmart order." There's an image that was initially deleted, but it was able to be recovered and it's an image of a box. Dwain responds, "LOL. I know best way to secretly send something." Rick responds, "Okay. Should I open it or no?" Dwain says, "You can, just don't lose or misplace the contents. Oh, and beware of the sterling silver, probably a good pound of silver that is the silver."

Amy Berndt (02:06:13):

And is this the image that was sent by Rick of the package?

Rebecca McKenzie (02:06:13):

Yes.

Amy Berndt (02:06:13):

Go ahead.

Rebecca McKenzie (02:06:13):

Rick says, "Okay, not opening it." Dwain responds, "LOL. Okay." And then, "Thank you again. This means a lot to me." Rick then says, "No problem."

Amy Berndt (02:06:13):

Again, this is the Thursday evening before Sonia's body's found?

Rebecca McKenzie (02:06:13):

Yes.

Amy Berndt (02:06:13):

Now, after you see all these messages on the defendant's phone and the UPS label is found, did you actually go to Ohio to attempt to recover this package?

Rebecca McKenzie (02:06:13):

I did.

Amy Berndt (02:06:13):

All right. And when did you go to Ohio?

Rebecca McKenzie (02:06:13):

From November 3rd to November 5th of 2025.

Amy Berndt (02:06:13):

All right. And what county in Ohio did Rick Snyder live in?

Rebecca McKenzie (02:06:13):

Washington County.

Amy Berndt (02:06:13):

And once you arrived in Ohio, did you meet with detectives from the Washington County Sheriff's Office?

Rebecca McKenzie (02:06:13):

I did.

Amy Berndt (02:06:13):

All right. And did those detectives obtain a search warrant to search Rick Snyder's house?

Rebecca McKenzie (02:06:13):

They did.

Amy Berndt (02:06:13):

Okay. And when was the search warrant executed?

Rebecca McKenzie (02:06:13):

November 4th, 2025.

Amy Berndt (02:06:13):

And were you present when the search warrant was executed?

Rebecca McKenzie (02:06:13):

I was.

Amy Berndt (02:06:13):

All right. Was the package that the defendant sent to Rick Snyder located during the search?

Rebecca McKenzie (02:06:13):

The package was not located, but the contents of the package were located.

Amy Berndt (02:06:13):

All right. And was Rick Snyder cooperative with law enforcement?

Rebecca McKenzie (02:06:13):

He was initially adversarial, but then as I spoke with him, he became reluctantly cooperative.

Amy Berndt (02:06:13):

Okay. And did he eventually indicate where the contents of the package were in his house?

Rebecca McKenzie (02:06:13):

He did.

Amy Berndt (02:06:13):

Okay. And where were the contents of the package located in Rick Snyder's house?

Rebecca McKenzie (02:06:13):

He told me that he sewed the contents of the package into a cloth bag and hid it in his dresser in his bedroom.

Amy Berndt (02:06:13):

And what was in the contents of the package that the defendant sent to Rick Snyder?

Rebecca McKenzie (02:06:13):

There was a knife, a knife sheath, and a bracelet.

Amy Berndt (02:06:13):

And was that evidence collected by Washington County Sergeant Robert McKee?

Rebecca McKenzie (02:06:13):

It was.

Amy Berndt (02:06:13):

Did you then bring that evidence back to Florida and place it into evidence?

Rebecca McKenzie (02:06:13):

I did.

Amy Berndt (02:06:13):

What were you able to determine about the bracelet that was sent with that knife?

Rebecca McKenzie (02:06:13):

What we determined was that it belonged to Dwain Hall. A search of Ginger Stein's Google with a search warrant showed a couple of pictures where he was wearing that bracelet or at least a bracelet that was extremely similar to the bracelet that we recovered.

Amy Berndt (02:06:13):

Okay, Was the knife, the sheath, and the bracelet all swabbed for DNA?

Rebecca McKenzie (02:06:13):

It was.

Amy Berndt (02:06:13):

All right. And would that have been analyzed by somebody in Jacksonville, in Florida Department of Law Enforcement?

Rebecca McKenzie (02:06:13):

Yes.

Amy Berndt (02:06:13):

All right. Now, did you obtain a search warrant for the defendant's Google account?

Rebecca McKenzie (02:06:13):

Another agent did get a search warrant for his Google account to assist me.

Amy Berndt (02:06:13):

All right. And did those results show searches made through the Gemini app?

Rebecca McKenzie (02:06:13):

It did.

Amy Berndt (02:06:13):

Okay. And is the Gemini app kind of like Siri on an Apple phone?

Rebecca McKenzie (02:06:13):

Correct.

Amy Berndt (02:06:13):

Your Honor, may I approach the witness?

Judge (02:06:13):

Yes, ma'am.

Amy Berndt (02:06:13):

I'm going to show you what's been marked for identification as State's Exhibit PPPP. Can you just tell me you recognize those to be the results?

Rebecca McKenzie (02:06:13):

Yes.

Amy Berndt (02:06:13):

Okay. Your Honor, at this time we would move State's Exhibit PPPP into evidence as a self-authenticating document. We filed a notice of intent to rely on the business record certification and there is a business record certification attached.

Speaker 4 (02:06:13):

No objection, Judge.

Judge (02:06:13):

Without objection, what's been marked for identification as State's Exhibit quadruple P will be admitted into evidence as State's Exhibit 84.

Amy Berndt (02:06:15):

And can you tell the jury what the defendant's phone searched on October 13th of 2025? And this would be the day after his phone was in the area of the burial site on Sunday.

Rebecca McKenzie (02:06:33):

There was a search... there was a prompt that asked, "How long will it take my large family dog to decompose Barry," spelled B-A-R-R-Y, "with the number two to three feet down in Florida?"

Amy Berndt (02:06:48):

All right. So, that was a prompt he was asking the Gemini app [inaudible 02:06:52]?

Rebecca McKenzie (02:06:52):

Correct. I don't have any other questions, Judge.

Speaker 4 (02:06:58):

No questions, Judge.

Judge (02:07:00):

Members of the jury, any of y'all have questions of this witness? We have two hands going up. Please write them down on a clean sheet of paper, verbatim like you'd like me to ask them and hand them to the bailiff. Lawyers, if y'all will approach. Special Agent McKenzie, the jury's posed two questions to you. I'm going to ask one of them. Members of the jury, the question that I'm not asking is going to be given to the clerk. As I explained to you all when I gave you the instruction on Monday about asking questions, the rules of evidence apply in the courtroom regardless of whether a question is asked by the lawyers, by the court or by a jury. So, there is a legal reason why I cannot ask that question. Therefore, if you wrote the question, you are not to discuss with your fellow jurors that you wrote a question that wasn't asked, including what the question was.

(02:09:43)
And you cannot discuss that during deliberations. You cannot speculate on what the answer might have been had the witness been asked the question, and you cannot hold it against either of the parties that the question is not asked. With that being said, the jury has asked a question or written a question that I will ask, ma'am. You can answer it to them. What is the relationship between Rick Snyder to the defendant?

Rebecca McKenzie (02:10:08):

So, speaking to both Rick Snyder and Dwain Hall, they knew each other starting several years ago in Ohio and they were close friends. And Dwain moved here and they continued their relationship and communicated online.

Judge (02:10:23):

Okay. State, any follow up?

Amy Berndt (02:10:25):

No, Your Honor.

Judge (02:10:26):

Defense, any follow up?

Speaker 4 (02:10:27):

No, your Honor.

Judge (02:10:28):

Members of the jury, do any of you all have any additional questions of this witness? Seeing no hands, state issue release?

Amy Berndt (02:10:33):

We ask that she be released and excused from her subpoena.

Judge (02:10:36):

Okay.

Speaker 4 (02:10:36):

No objection, Judge.

Judge (02:10:37):

All right ma'am, you're free to go back to your day. Thank you for your time.

Rebecca McKenzie (02:10:39):

Thank you.

Judge (02:10:41):

Members of the jury, it's about 10:25. This is probably a good stopping point for the morning. Take a morning recess here. We'll let Special Agent McKenzie gather up her belongings. While she's doing that, I'm going to give you the instructions I've given you, I think about every other recess that we've had, which is during this recess, you may not communicate about the case with one another or any other person. So you happen to turn on your phones or other electronic devices, you cannot use them to communicate about the case or do any research about the case or come into contact with any information about the case. We'll take about a 15-minute break here, pick up at 10:40. Lunches are set to arrive at about noon. So, that's kind of the plan of the day. See you shortly. No pads here. The record should reflect the jurors have left the courtroom. You all can be seated. Before we break, State, you've got-

Judge (02:12:00):

You all can be seated. Before we break, state, you've got three other folks you anticipate this morning?

Speaker 5 (02:12:07):

Yes, Your Honor.

Judge (02:12:10):

Do we anticipate Mr. Morse?

Speaker 5 (02:12:14):

Actually, we moved up Brooke Hoover from the afternoon to the morning, so we'll have time. We did that yesterday.

Judge (02:12:20):

Okay. Very good. Very good. We'll probably, we may break a little afternoon. I'd like to get through what we can as early as possible. I do intend to finish the presentation of evidence today.

Speaker 5 (02:12:30):

Yes, Your Honor.

Judge (02:12:31):

All right. Very good. Mr. Hall, you'll have an opportunity to use the restroom and we'll see you all back shortly.

Mr. Hall (02:12:35):

Yes, Judge.

Judge (02:23:54):

Are we ready to bring the jury back in, state?

Speaker 7 (02:23:55):

Yes, Your Honor.

Speaker 5 (02:23:56):

Yes, Judge.

Judge (02:23:57):

Okay, let's bring them in. Ladies and gentlemen, welcome back. Counsel, everybody can be seated. State, you can call your next witness.

Speaker 7 (02:26:01):

State called Robert McKee.

Judge (02:26:02):

Come on off, sir, raise your right hand, face the clerk here to be sworn.

Clerk (02:26:40):

Do you swear or affirm the testimony you're about to give will be the truth, the whole truth, and nothing but the truth, so help you God?

Robert McKee (02:26:42):

Yes, ma'am.

Judge (02:26:45):

You go ahead and be seated.

Robert McKee (02:26:46):

Thank you.

Speaker 7 (02:26:46):

Good morning, sir.

Robert McKee (02:26:51):

Good morning.

Speaker 7 (02:26:52):

Would you please introduce yourself to the jury?

Robert McKee (02:26:54):

Hello, my name's Robert McKee.

Speaker 7 (02:26:57):

Where do you work?

Robert McKee (02:26:58):

I work for the Washington County Sheriff's Office in Marietta, Ohio.

Speaker 7 (02:27:01):

And what do you do for Washington County Sheriff's Office?

Robert McKee (02:27:04):

I am a detective in the Detective Bureau.

Speaker 7 (02:27:09):

Okay. And how long have you worked there?

Robert McKee (02:27:11):

I've worked there for 16 years now.

Speaker 7 (02:27:14):

What do you do on a day-to-day basis as a detective?

Robert McKee (02:27:18):

We investigate the most heinous of crimes that come into our county, which also includes assisting other agencies too.

Speaker 7 (02:27:30):

Let me direct your attention to November 4th of 2025. Did you and other officers from your agency come to assist Florida Department of Law Enforcement or Special Agent Rebecca McKenzie in a murder investigation here in Florida?

Robert McKee (02:27:45):

Yes, we did.

Speaker 7 (02:27:46):

And how did you first become aware that your involvement was needed?

Robert McKee (02:27:51):

I was informed through my boss, Lieutenant Smicks, that we were going to be assisting the Florida Department of Law Enforcement.

Speaker 7 (02:27:59):

Okay. And was a search warrant drafted and eventually signed by a judge up in Ohio, which allowed you and other officers to search a residence located at 10420 State Road 550 in the Barlow Township of Washington County, Ohio?

Robert McKee (02:28:14):

Yes.

Speaker 7 (02:28:15):

Did you go to that residence?

Robert McKee (02:28:16):

I did.

Speaker 7 (02:28:17):

Along with Florida Department of Law Enforcement Special Agent Rebecca McKenzie?

Robert McKee (02:28:21):

Yes, correct.

Speaker 7 (02:28:21):

All right. Who else went with you from your department?

Robert McKee (02:28:25):

My other detectives that I work with, Lieutenant Smicks, Lieutenant McPeak, Detective Schwenman, but also the special response team.

Speaker 7 (02:28:34):

Describe the property for the jury that you were in.

Robert McKee (02:28:37):

This is a rural residential area. The specific property we were at is a old farmhouse and I'd say deplorable conditions.

Speaker 7 (02:28:52):

Were the residents or were the occupants of that residence there when you arrived?

Robert McKee (02:28:55):

Yes.

Speaker 7 (02:28:56):

And who were they?

Robert McKee (02:28:57):

Ms. Heather Stark and Richard Snyder.

Speaker 7 (02:29:03):

What happened when you got there?

Robert McKee (02:29:06):

We introduced ourselves to Ms. Stark and introduced ourselves to Mr. Snyder. And ultimately the residence was secured by the special response team and a search warrant was executed.

Speaker 7 (02:29:21):

And were you part of the team that actually executed the search warrant and processed the scene?

Robert McKee (02:29:25):

Yes.

Speaker 7 (02:29:26):

All right. Were photographs taken of the inside of the house and items you located of relevance to the inside of the house?

Robert McKee (02:29:32):

Yes.

Speaker 7 (02:29:32):

May I approach, Judge?

Judge (02:29:36):

Yes, sir.

Speaker 7 (02:29:36):

Showing you what's been marked for State's Exhibit 4D for identification. Do you recognize those photos?

Robert McKee (02:29:44):

I do.

Speaker 7 (02:29:45):

And generally, what do they show?

Robert McKee (02:29:47):

The photographs taken of certain pieces of evidence during this search warrant.

Speaker 7 (02:29:54):

Do they fairly and accurately depict what those pieces of evidence looked like during the execution of the search warrant?

Robert McKee (02:30:00):

Yes, sir.

Speaker 7 (02:30:00):

At this time, state would move DDDD into evidence as 85.

Speaker 6 (02:30:04):

What was the number again? I'm sorry.

Judge (02:30:06):

4 DDDD as in Delta.

Speaker 6 (02:30:09):

I thought [inaudible 02:30:10]. Okay. No objection to it being admitted [inaudible 02:30:14].

Judge (02:30:14):

That objection was been marked for identification as state's exhibit DDDD will be admitted into evidence as state's exhibit 85.

Speaker 7 (02:30:20):

May I approach?

Judge (02:30:21):

Yes, sir.

Speaker 7 (02:30:25):

During the execution of the search warrant, referring to the kitchen area of the residence, did you locate anything of interest in the kitchen area?

Robert McKee (02:30:35):

Yes. A large knife and a black sheath was located on the kitchen table, which is the knife in the photograph there.

Speaker 7 (02:30:44):

Okay. And that's photograph one of state's 85, I'm showing you. Was that knife collected?

Robert McKee (02:30:49):

It was.

Speaker 7 (02:30:52):

And photograph two of state's 85, what does that show?

Robert McKee (02:30:55):

That is the same knife showing what item number that we gave it when we took it and where it was found.

Speaker 7 (02:31:04):

May I approach, Judge?

Judge (02:31:06):

Yes, sir.

Speaker 7 (02:31:06):

Showing you state's exhibit 4E for identification. Do you recognize that item?

Robert McKee (02:31:12):

I do.

Speaker 7 (02:31:12):

Can you open it up, look inside, tell me if you recognize the contents? [inaudible 02:31:36]. Do you recognize what's inside?

Robert McKee (02:32:00):

Yes, sir.

Speaker 7 (02:32:01):

Go ahead. Okay.

Robert McKee (02:32:01):

Should I open this one?

Speaker 7 (02:32:01):

Yes, sir, please.

Robert McKee (02:32:01):

All right.

Speaker 7 (02:32:28):

If you could just go ahead and keep that in your lap so the side introduced into evidence the other day?

Robert McKee (02:32:30):

Yes, sir.

Speaker 7 (02:32:31):

Do you recognize the contents of that item?

Robert McKee (02:32:32):

I do.

Speaker 7 (02:32:32):

What is it?

Robert McKee (02:32:34):

That is the large knife and a black sheath located in the kitchen.

Speaker 7 (02:32:41):

The one we see in the photo here?

Robert McKee (02:32:42):

Yes, sir.

Speaker 7 (02:32:43):

Is it the same or substantially the same condition as when you collected it?

Robert McKee (02:32:47):

The packaging is. I haven't looked at the knife itself yet.

Speaker 7 (02:32:50):

Go ahead and take a look at the knife.

Robert McKee (02:32:51):

Okay. Besides the writing on it, yes.

Speaker 7 (02:33:04):

Okay. At this time, the state would move 4E into evidence as State's 86.

Speaker 6 (02:33:08):

No objection, Judge.

Judge (02:33:10):

Without objection, what's been marked identification as State's Exhibit EEEE will be admitted into evidence as State's Exhibit 86.

Robert McKee (02:33:18):

Back inside, please.

Speaker 7 (02:33:25):

Showing you photograph three of State's 85. Did you also search a bedroom dresser in that residence?

Robert McKee (02:33:31):

Yes, I did.

Speaker 7 (02:33:32):

What do we see here in this photo?

Robert McKee (02:33:35):

That is a Mr. Snyder's dresser, top dresser drawer, and you see the contents of that drawer.

Speaker 7 (02:33:45):

Showing you photograph four, State's 85. What was found of significance in the dresser?

Robert McKee (02:33:50):

Below the paracord item there is a black sewn fabric bag with contents inside that bag.

Speaker 7 (02:34:00):

Okay. Showing you photograph five of State's 85. What does this show?

Robert McKee (02:34:03):

That is that homemade sewn bag with the contents of the bag.

Speaker 7 (02:34:11):

Did you open up that black homemade sewn fabric?

Robert McKee (02:34:14):

I did.

Speaker 7 (02:34:15):

How'd you do that?

Robert McKee (02:34:16):

As least intrusive as I could, using all proper protective equipment, a sterile scalpel opened the side of it to see what was inside.

Speaker 7 (02:34:26):

Okay. So the item wasn't just slick, it was actually sewn into it?

Robert McKee (02:34:29):

Yes.

Speaker 7 (02:34:30):

So you had to cut the thread?

Robert McKee (02:34:32):

Yes, sir.

Speaker 7 (02:34:34):

Okay. And showing you photograph six of state's 85, what was found inside?

Robert McKee (02:34:39):

That is a metal bracelet with a animal's head on each side.

Speaker 7 (02:34:47):

And photograph seven of state's 85, what else did you find inside that fabric container?

Robert McKee (02:34:53):

A large fixed blade knife and a plastic sheath.

Speaker 7 (02:35:00):

Okay. May I approach again, Your Honor?

Judge (02:35:01):

Yes, sir.

Speaker 7 (02:35:01):

Showing you what's marked as State's Exhibit 4F. Can you take a look at that item, open it up, look inside, tell me if you recognize the contents.

Robert McKee (02:35:42):

I'm having trouble seeing where the tape is.

Speaker 7 (02:35:44):

That's okay. Open up that package as well. Do you recognize that package?

Robert McKee (02:36:34):

I haven't-

Speaker 7 (02:36:35):

Do you recognize the package itself?

Robert McKee (02:36:36):

Yes, I do. Yeah, that is my handwriting.

Speaker 7 (02:36:38):

Okay.

Robert McKee (02:37:00):

Go ahead and-

Speaker 7 (02:37:01):

Please.

Robert McKee (02:37:09):

Like me to remove it?

Speaker 7 (02:37:11):

Do you recognize what's inside looking at it from that way? And you can remove it and just keep it in your lap outside the jury view right now.

Robert McKee (02:37:20):

Yes, I do.

Speaker 7 (02:37:21):

What is it?

Robert McKee (02:37:21):

It is the homemade sewn bag with the contents of the knife and the bracelet.

Speaker 7 (02:37:27):

Is it in the same or substantially the same condition as when you collected it up in Ohio?

Robert McKee (02:37:32):

Yes.

Speaker 7 (02:37:32):

At this time, state would move 4F into evidence as 87.

Speaker 6 (02:37:36):

No objection to those.

Judge (02:37:38):

[inaudible 02:37:38] identification of State's Exhibit FFFF will be admitted into evidence as State's Exhibit 87.

Speaker 7 (02:37:43):

Can you describe the knife?

Robert McKee (02:37:45):

A large fixed blade knife. I personally have not seen the knife itself. It was not removed from the sheath.

Speaker 7 (02:37:52):

Okay. And why was that?

Robert McKee (02:37:53):

To preserve any evidence that might be or not be on it.

Speaker 7 (02:38:17):

Okay. Thank you.

Robert McKee (02:38:17):

It never goes back in the way it-

Speaker 7 (02:38:18):

Okay. Put it all here.

Robert McKee (02:38:18):

Thank you.

Speaker 7 (02:38:35):

You mentioned that the occupants of that residence, Rick Snyder and Heather Stark were there, right?

Robert McKee (02:38:40):

Correct.

Speaker 7 (02:38:41):

Was an Officer Josh Windham also there with you during the execution of the search warrant?

Robert McKee (02:38:46):

Yes. Detective Windham was there.

Speaker 7 (02:38:48):

Do you know him?

Robert McKee (02:38:49):

I do.

Speaker 7 (02:38:49):

Okay. Work closely with him?

Robert McKee (02:38:50):

We do, yeah.

Speaker 7 (02:38:57):

All right. Were DNA standards collected from both Rick Snyder and Heather Stark?

Robert McKee (02:39:02):

Yes.

Speaker 7 (02:39:02):

May I approach again, Your Honor?

Judge (02:39:07):

Yes, sir.

Speaker 7 (02:39:07):

Showing you first what's been marked as State's Exhibit 4G, and then also State's Exhibit 4H. For the record, 4G is represented as being from who?

Robert McKee (02:39:25):

That is Richard Snyder's swab.

Speaker 7 (02:39:26):

And what about 4H?

Robert McKee (02:39:28):

This is Heather Stark's swab.

Speaker 7 (02:39:31):

And do you recognize the handwriting on those packages?

Robert McKee (02:39:34):

I do. The security seal on both of them is mine.

Speaker 7 (02:39:38):

Okay. Can you open those two up, look inside? And what's inside both of those packages?

Robert McKee (02:41:00):

These are the buccal swabs that Detective Windham obtained from Heather Stark and Richard Snyder.

Speaker 7 (02:41:07):

And do you recognize Detective Windham's handwriting and ID number and the information on those packages?

Robert McKee (02:41:12):

I do.

Speaker 7 (02:41:12):

And does it also have the case number associated with the execution of this search warrant?

Robert McKee (02:41:17):

Yes, it does.

Speaker 7 (02:41:18):

Okay. And were you aware that Detective Windham collected these DNA standards?

Robert McKee (02:41:24):

Yes, I am.

Speaker 7 (02:41:25):

Once they were collected, were they given to you?

Robert McKee (02:41:26):

Yes, they were.

Speaker 7 (02:41:27):

Is that how your signature or your handwriting came to be on the back of those packages?

Robert McKee (02:41:32):

Correct.

Speaker 7 (02:41:33):

Are they in the same or substantially the same condition as when you collected them?

Robert McKee (02:41:36):

Yes.

Speaker 7 (02:41:36):

At this time, State would move State's Exhibit 4G into evidence as 88.

Speaker 6 (02:41:40):

No objection, Judge.

Judge (02:41:41):

Without objection, what's been marked for identification as State's Exhibit GGGG will be admitted into evidence as State's Exhibit 88.

Speaker 7 (02:41:47):

And the State would move 4H into evidence as 89.

Speaker 6 (02:41:50):

No objection.

Judge (02:41:51):

Without objection, what's been marked for identification as State's Exhibit HHHH will be admitted into evidence as State's Exhibit 89.

Speaker 7 (02:41:57):

Once all of these items that we had looked at were collected, what did you do with them?

Robert McKee (02:42:02):

After they were entered into our evidence system package and they were provided straight to Special Agent Rebecca McKenzie.

Speaker 7 (02:42:13):

All right. Thank you, sir. No other questions, Your Honor.

Speaker 6 (02:42:15):

No questions, Your Honor.

Judge (02:42:17):

Members of the jury, do any of you all have questions of this witness? If you do, please raise your hand. Okay. Seeing no hands, state is he released?

Speaker 7 (02:42:23):

He is, Your Honor.

Speaker 6 (02:42:23):

No objection.

Judge (02:42:24):

Defense? Sir, you're free to go about your day. Thank you for your time.

Robert McKee (02:42:25):

Thank you.

Judge (02:42:27):

All right. State next witness.

Speaker 5 (02:42:28):

State calls Catarina Burton.

Judge (02:43:35):

Raise your right hand. Face the clerk to be sworn.

Clerk (02:43:42):

Do you swear or affirm the testimony you're about to give will be the truth, the whole truth, and nothing but the truth, so help you God?

Catarina Burton (02:43:42):

I do.

Judge (02:43:42):

You can be seated, ma'am.

Catarina Burton (02:43:43):

Thank you.

Speaker 5 (02:43:49):

Good morning.

Catarina Burton (02:43:50):

Good morning.

Speaker 5 (02:43:50):

Can you please tell the jury your name?

Catarina Burton (02:43:52):

My name is Catarina Burton.

Speaker 5 (02:43:55):

Where do you work?

Catarina Burton (02:43:56):

I work with the Marion County Sheriff's Office.

Speaker 5 (02:43:58):

And how long have you worked with the Marion County Sheriff's Office?

Catarina Burton (02:44:01):

I've been employed with them for almost two years.

Speaker 5 (02:44:04):

What is your current position with the Marion County Sheriff's Office?

Catarina Burton (02:44:07):

I'm a latent print examiner.

Speaker 5 (02:44:10):

What are your duties as a latent print examiner?

Catarina Burton (02:44:13):

I collect and analyze fingerprints. With every evidence that is submitted, we evaluate them and I write up reports.

Speaker 5 (02:44:21):

Does that also involve on occasion taking known standards of individuals?

Catarina Burton (02:44:26):

That is correct.

Speaker 5 (02:44:27):

And what does it mean when you take a known standard of an individual?

Catarina Burton (02:44:30):

The known standards comprise of all 10 fingers of an individual, where we record the fingerprints for the friction ridge skin.

Speaker 5 (02:44:39):

All right. Is that when we maybe see on TV, you put the finger in ink and then you put it on a piece of paper?

Catarina Burton (02:44:44):

That is correct. However, we do roll them from one side of the nail bed to the other to take the full impression.

Speaker 5 (02:44:51):

All right. I want to direct your attention to September 17th of 2026. On that date, did you roll the finger and palm prints of a person named Dwayne Hall?

Catarina Burton (02:45:00):

I did.

Speaker 5 (02:45:01):

Do you see the person you know to be Dwayne Hall in the courtroom today?

Speaker 8 (02:45:00):

I did.

Amy Berndt (02:45:01):

Do you see the person you know to be Dwain Hall in the courtroom today?

Speaker 8 (02:45:04):

I do.

Amy Berndt (02:45:05):

Can you please point to him and describe something he's wearing?

Speaker 8 (02:45:08):

He's sitting right over there wearing a black polo.

Amy Berndt (02:45:11):

Okay. At the table, what position is he in?

Speaker 8 (02:45:15):

Position on the left side.

Amy Berndt (02:45:17):

All the way to the left?

Speaker 8 (02:45:17):

Yes.

Amy Berndt (02:45:18):

Thank you. Your Honor, may the record reflect the witness has identified the defendant?

Junior Barrett (02:45:21):

No objection, Judge.

Judge (02:45:22):

Without objection, the record will reflect the witness has identified the defendant.

Amy Berndt (02:45:26):

All right. And did you roll the defendant's prints in the same way that you just explained to us?

Speaker 8 (02:45:30):

That is correct.

Amy Berndt (02:45:30):

Your Honor, may I approach the witness?

Judge (02:45:31):

Yes, ma'am.

Amy Berndt (02:45:34):

I'm showing you what's been marked for identification as State's Exhibit IIII. You can look at that because you may need to cut the top off and have you look in there. Do you recognize that?

Speaker 8 (02:46:24):

I do.

Amy Berndt (02:46:24):

And what is that?

Speaker 8 (02:46:26):

These are the known standards for Dwain Hall.

Amy Berndt (02:46:29):

Are they in the same or substantially the same condition as when you rolled them?

Speaker 8 (02:46:33):

Yes.

Amy Berndt (02:46:33):

Your Honor, at this time we have moved State's Exhibit IIII into evidence.

Junior Barrett (02:46:37):

‍

No objection, Judge.

Judge (02:46:38):

Without objection was marked for identification as State's Exhibit quadruple I will be admitted into evidence as State's Exhibit 90.

Amy Berndt (02:46:44):

Now, even though you are a latent print examiner as well, were those sent to the Florida Department of Law Enforcement to be compared with any items of evidence?

Speaker 8 (02:46:52):

Yes, that is correct.

Amy Berndt (02:46:53):

And did that end your involvement in this case?

Speaker 8 (02:46:55):

That is correct.

Amy Berndt (02:46:56):

I don't have any other questions, Your Honor.

Junior Barrett (02:46:57):

No questions, Your Honor.

Judge (02:46:58):

Members of the jury, do any of y'all have questions of this witness? If you do, please raise your hand. Okay. Seeing no hands. State, is she released?

Amy Berndt (02:47:05):

Yes, Your Honor.

Junior Barrett (02:47:05):

No objection.

Judge (02:47:07):

Ma'am, you're free to go about your day. Thank you for your time.

Speaker 8 (02:47:09):

Thank you, Judge. Thank you so much.

Judge (02:47:15):

State, you can call your next witness.

Amy Berndt (02:47:16):

The State calls Brandon Morse.

Judge (02:48:09):

Raise your right hand if you could. Face the clerk to be sworn.

Speaker 9 (02:48:12):

Do you swear or affirm the testimony you're about to give will be the truth, the whole truth, and nothing but the truth, so help you God?

Brandon Morse (02:48:15):

I do.

Judge (02:48:15):

You can be seated. Thank you.

Amy Berndt (02:48:23):

Good morning.

Brandon Morse (02:48:24):

Good morning.

Amy Berndt (02:48:25):

Can you please tell the jury your name?

Brandon Morse (02:48:27):

My name is Brandon Morse. Last name is spelled M-O- R-S-E.

Amy Berndt (02:48:31):

And where are you employed?

Brandon Morse (02:48:33):

I am employed with the Florida Department of Law Enforcement in Jacksonville, also known as FDLE.

Amy Berndt (02:48:38):

How long have you worked for FDLE?

Brandon Morse (02:48:41):

I have been with FDLE since roughly May of 2018.

Amy Berndt (02:48:46):

And what is your current position with FDLE?

Brandon Morse (02:48:49):

I am a Crime Laboratory Analyst in the Friction Ridge section.

Amy Berndt (02:48:54):

How long have you been in the Friction Ridge section with FDLE?

Brandon Morse (02:48:57):

I've been with the Friction Ridge section since June of 2019.

Amy Berndt (02:49:03):

All right. And what are your duties as an analyst in the Friction Ridge section?

Brandon Morse (02:49:08):

Part of my duties include receiving items of evidence from submitting agencies, processing those items for the potential presence of latent prints for development. I also utilize the computer program that we have to make comparisons in order to determine identifications and exclusions. I also utilize a database search system that we do for comparisons and stuff.

Amy Berndt (02:49:40):

Can you describe your educational background for the jury?

Brandon Morse (02:49:43):

Sure. I have a Bachelors of Science from Texas A&M University, as well as a Masters of Science from the University of Florida in forensic science.

Amy Berndt (02:49:55):

And can you describe your training that allows you to be an analyst in the Friction Ridge section?

Brandon Morse (02:50:00):

So the FDLE training program is roughly an 18-month-long training program. The first 12 months is mainly testings, readings, practical examinations. That culminates in an oral board. The second portion of our training is a six months under a qualified analyst doing supervised case work. The end of that culminates in a mock trial.

Amy Berndt (02:50:28):

Do you undergo proficiency testing?

Brandon Morse (02:50:31):

I do.

Amy Berndt (02:50:31):

How often do you do that?

Brandon Morse (02:50:33):

Yearly.

Amy Berndt (02:50:34):

Have you ever failed one?

Brandon Morse (02:50:36):

I have not.

Amy Berndt (02:50:38):

Can you tell the jury what a latent print is? What does that mean?

Brandon Morse (02:50:42):

A latent print is the chance or unintentional recording of the friction ridge skin, being the skin on the fingers, palms, and the soles of the feet.

Amy Berndt (02:50:52):

And how are latent prints developed on items of evidence?

Brandon Morse (02:50:56):

There's multiple different processes that can be utilized, depending on the type of item that is being processed. That depends on whether it's non-porous or porous, so whether it absorbs water or it doesn't.

Amy Berndt (02:51:09):

So a latent print is one that somebody leaves on an item of evidence. What's a known print?

Brandon Morse (02:51:14):

A known print is an intentional inked recording or a digital recording with something such as live scan.

Amy Berndt (02:51:22):

And how do you compare a latent print with a known print?

Brandon Morse (02:51:27):

So the comparison process begins with the latent print. I look at it, I determine potential ridge flow, pattern type, important characteristics that are visible within that latent print. I take the totality of the information and determine whether or not the print is of value for comparisons. If I determine that it is, the next step is to do a side-by-side comparison with known exemplars. So I will find the characteristics that are the minutia that are within the latent print and see if I can locate that same set of characteristics in the same orientation, same distancing within that known set of exemplars. And I will go back and forth between the two sets, trying to determine whether or not there is sufficient information to draw a conclusion from that comparison.

Amy Berndt (02:52:21):

So utilizing that information, it's possible to identify the person who touched a surface or an object?

Brandon Morse (02:52:27):

That is correct.

Amy Berndt (02:52:28):

Have you had the opportunity to examine items of evidence for the presence of latent prints?

Brandon Morse (02:52:33):

I have.

Amy Berndt (02:52:34):

Many, many times?

Brandon Morse (02:52:35):

Yes.

Amy Berndt (02:52:36):

And have you had the opportunity to compare latent prints recovered from various items with the known finger and palm prints of individuals?

Brandon Morse (02:52:44):

I have.

Amy Berndt (02:52:45):

Approximately how many latent print comparisons have you conducted?

Brandon Morse (02:52:48):

It's in the thousands. I don't have an exact number.

Amy Berndt (02:52:51):

And have you had the opportunity to give opinion testimony in the field of latent print examination?

Brandon Morse (02:52:56):

I have.

Amy Berndt (02:52:57):

About how many times?

Brandon Morse (02:53:00):

About nine, I believe.

Amy Berndt (02:53:02):

Your Honor, I'd ask that the witness allowed to give opinion testimony in the field of latent print examination.

Junior Barrett (02:53:05):

[inaudible 02:53:06].

Judge (02:53:06):

No voir dire? Okay. You can continue.

Amy Berndt (02:53:08):

Thank you. All right. I want to talk first about some known fingerprints and latent palm prints that you received in this case. Did you receive a DVD containing one digital image of fingerprint exemplars bearing the name Sonia Marie Exelby?

Brandon Morse (02:53:22):

I did.

Amy Berndt (02:53:23):

And where were these fingerprint exemplars from?

Brandon Morse (02:53:26):

I believe they were from a visa applicant record.

Amy Berndt (02:53:33):

Your Honor, may I approach the witness?

Judge (02:53:34):

Yes, ma'am.

Amy Berndt (02:53:35):

I'm going to show you what's been marked for identification as State's Exhibit JJJJ, here's a scissor if you need to open that. Do you recognize that?

Brandon Morse (02:53:43):

I do.

Amy Berndt (02:53:43):

And what is that?

Brandon Morse (02:53:46):

It is the fingerprint exemplars. Well, there's a CD in here. I'm sorry, a DVD, but it would be bearing the exemplars for Sonia Exelby.

Amy Berndt (02:53:58):

All right. And are those the known prints of Sonia Exelby that you used to compare to latent prints of value in this case?

Brandon Morse (02:54:04):

They were, yes.

Amy Berndt (02:54:06):

Your Honor, at this time we move State's Exhibit JJJJ into evidence.

Junior Barrett (02:54:10):

No objection, Judge.

Judge (02:54:11):

Without objection, what's marked for identification as State's Exhibit quadruple J will be admitted to evidence as State's Exhibit 91.

Amy Berndt (02:54:17):

And did you also receive known fingerprints of the defendant, Dwain Hall?

Brandon Morse (02:54:21):

I did.

Amy Berndt (02:54:22):

Your Honor, may I approach again?

Judge (02:54:23):

Yes, ma'am.

Amy Berndt (02:54:24):

I'm going to show you what's been entered into evidence as State's Exhibit 90. You can look at that and tell me if you recognize what's in there.

Brandon Morse (02:54:36):

Yes, I do.

Amy Berndt (02:54:38):

Okay. And what is that?

Brandon Morse (02:54:40):

It was a FedEx envelope that contained fingerprint exemplars bearing the name Dwain Hall.

Amy Berndt (02:54:48):

All right. And were those known exemplars bearing the name Dwain Hall used to make a comparison in this case?

Brandon Morse (02:54:53):

They were.

Amy Berndt (02:54:55):

All right. Now, in addition to the known prints of Sonia Exelby and Dwain Hall, did you actually receive items of evidence in this case that you yourself processed for latent fingerprints?

Brandon Morse (02:55:06):

Yes, I did.

Amy Berndt (02:55:07):

All right. And I think you touched on this earlier, but what does it mean if you have a latent fingerprint of value?

Brandon Morse (02:55:13):

Essentially, what a latent print of value is means that the totality of information present within that latent print, the ridge flow, the pattern type, the minutia and characteristics that are present are sufficient enough to make a comparison and draw a conclusion from that comparison.

Amy Berndt (02:55:35):

So does it happen frequently that a latent print may be lifted from an object, but it's not of value and you can't try to compare it to anybody's known print?

Brandon Morse (02:55:44):

Yes.

Amy Berndt (02:55:44):

All right. What items of evidence did you receive that you yourself processed for latent prints?

Brandon Morse (02:55:52):

There were quite a few. I would have to look at my notes to see exactly what all was received.

Amy Berndt (02:55:57):

If that would refresh your recollection, Your Honor.

Judge (02:56:00):

Yes, you may, sir.

Brandon Morse (02:56:12):

During the case, I received a cell phone that was in a cell phone case, a folding knife, a pair of scissors, another folding knife, sorry, the first one being Schrade brand, second knife being Case brand, a shovel, a shovel label. And in addition to those items, I also received a tube of mascara, a firearm, and lift cards for examination.

Amy Berndt (02:56:57):

All right. I want to talk about those items that you processed yourself, that you just listed. Did you process all of those items the same way to see if there were latent fingerprints?

Brandon Morse (02:57:08):

Yes, I did.

Amy Berndt (02:57:09):

Okay. And how did you do that? Explain that to the jury.

Brandon Morse (02:57:12):

So for the examination of the items of evidence, it begins with a visual exam. I take a look at the exhibit that was submitted and determine whether or not I can visually see any latent prints that may or may not be present. After the visual exam, I conducted what's called the full spectrum imaging system. It is a specialized camera that utilizes a UV light source for visualization. Following use of the FSIS, which is what the full spectrum imaging software system is, that is the abbreviation for it. Apologies. Following the FSIS, I conducted what is known as cyanoacrylate ester fuming, also known as superglue fuming, to determine if any prints would develop. After the superglue fuming, I then used the FSIS again. It is then followed up with dye stains, which adheres to the superglue residue as well as powder. And if blood was present, a blood reagent was applied.

Amy Berndt (02:58:21):

And you did that with all of the items that you processed that you just listed out?

Brandon Morse (02:58:25):

Yes.

Amy Berndt (02:58:26):

All right. Now of all of the items that you processed yourself, did any of them have latent prints of value?

Brandon Morse (02:58:33):

I believe there were two items that had prints of value on them.

Amy Berndt (02:58:36):

Okay. Was that the cell phone and the shovel?

Brandon Morse (02:58:39):

Yes, that is correct.

Amy Berndt (02:58:40):

So the cell phone case, the knife from the Jeep, scissors, the knife from the defendant, the shovel label, firearm and the purple mascara tube did not have any latent fingerprints of value?

Brandon Morse (02:58:54):

That is correct.

Amy Berndt (02:58:55):

All right. Now, did you also receive 13 latent lift cards that were lifted by Aaron Morris from the defendant's black Jeep?

Brandon Morse (02:59:04):

Yes, I did.

Amy Berndt (02:59:19):

May I approach, Your Honor?

Judge (02:59:20):

Yes, ma'am.

Amy Berndt (02:59:22):

You can look at that and tell me you recognize that I'm showing you State's 55.

Brandon Morse (02:59:33):

Yes, I do recognize it.

Amy Berndt (02:59:35):

And what do you recognize that to be?

Brandon Morse (02:59:37):

It is an envelope containing 13 lift cards, sorry, 13 latent lift cards.

Amy Berndt (02:59:43):

All right. And did you have the chance to examine those to see if they contained any latent lifts of value?

Brandon Morse (02:59:49):

I did.

Amy Berndt (02:59:50):

All right. And did any of those latent lift cards obtain finger or palm prints of value?

Brandon Morse (02:59:56):

There were, yes.

Amy Berndt (02:59:57):

Okay. Can you tell us how many?

Brandon Morse (02:59:59):

If I may look... So present on six of the latent lift cards, there were a total of five palm prints and three fingerprints that were of value for comparison.

Amy Berndt (03:00:16):

So the other five lift cards from the defendant's black Jeep did not have any prints of value?

Brandon Morse (03:00:23):

It would've been seven.

Amy Berndt (03:00:24):

Seven?

Brandon Morse (03:00:25):

Yes.

Amy Berndt (03:00:26):

Now, so we have the lift cards from the defendant's Jeep that had some finger and palm prints of value, and then we had the shovel and the cell phone.

Brandon Morse (03:00:35):

That is correct.

Amy Berndt (03:00:36):

Okay. So those were the only items that were of value that you could potentially compare with the known prints of somebody?

Brandon Morse (03:00:42):

Yes.

Amy Berndt (03:00:42):

All right. Did you compare the latent fingerprints and palm prints that were of value to the known prints of Sonia Exelby and the defendant, Dwain Hall?

Brandon Morse (03:00:52):

I did.

Amy Berndt (03:00:53):

All right. Were any of the latent fingerprints of value identified to Sonia Exelby?

Brandon Morse (03:00:58):

They were not.

Amy Berndt (03:01:00):

All right. Were any of the latent fingerprints of value identified to the defendant, Dwain Hall?

Brandon Morse (03:01:05):

The fingerprints were not.

Amy Berndt (03:01:09):

Were any of the latent palm prints identified to the defendant, Dwain Hall?

Brandon Morse (03:01:13):

Yes.

Amy Berndt (03:01:14):

Okay. Can you tell us which ones?

Brandon Morse (03:01:19):

Of the latent palm prints, all five of the prints of value were identified to the fingerprint exemplars bearing the name Dwain Hall.

Amy Berndt (03:01:27):

All right. So the latent palm prints that were lifted from his black Jeep matched him?

Brandon Morse (03:01:31):

Yes.

Amy Berndt (03:01:32):

And if you can look at E7, the fingerprints on the shovel that were of value.

Brandon Morse (03:01:47):

Yes, ma'am.

Amy Berndt (03:01:48):

Okay. Did that match anybody, either of them?

Brandon Morse (03:01:51):

The latent fingerprint that was present on the shovel was identified to the fingerprint exemplars bearing the name Dwain Hall.

Amy Berndt (03:01:59):

All right. And were any of the latent prints of value inconclusive as to the defendant, Dwain Hall?

Brandon Morse (03:02:08):

Yes. There was one latent fingerprint that was determined to be inconclusive.

Amy Berndt (03:02:12):

And where was that from?

Brandon Morse (03:02:15):

I believe that was from one of the latent lift cards.

Amy Berndt (03:02:20):

From the black Jeep?

Brandon Morse (03:02:21):

Yes.

Amy Berndt (03:02:22):

All right. So latent fingerprint identified the Dwain Hall and the shovel and latent palm prints identified the Dwain Hall from the black Jeep?

Brandon Morse (03:02:30):

That is correct.

Amy Berndt (03:02:32):

And not identified to Sonia Exelby?

Brandon Morse (03:02:34):

Correct.

Amy Berndt (03:02:35):

Thank you. I don't have any other questions, Judge.

Judge (03:02:37):

Any cross examination?

Junior Barrett (03:02:38):

Yes, Judge. Good morning, sir.

Brandon Morse (03:02:47):

Good morning.

Junior Barrett (03:02:49):

When you refer to the prints as being of value, is that similar to what's sometimes called readable prints?

Brandon Morse (03:02:59):

I'm not sure I follow the question.

Junior Barrett (03:03:00):

Okay. These are prints that you can actually have enough characteristics that you can identify, correct?

Brandon Morse (03:03:06):

Yes, that is correct.

Junior Barrett (03:03:07):

How many characteristics do you actually need to do an identification?

Brandon Morse (03:03:12):

There is no standard for number of characteristics necessary for an identification.

Junior Barrett (03:03:16):

Does your office have any standards for that?

Brandon Morse (03:03:19):

We do not.

Junior Barrett (03:03:20):

Does the absence of prints mean that someone else did not touch the item?

Brandon Morse (03:03:29):

Could you rephrase?

Junior Barrett (03:03:30):

The fact that you were not able to get prints of value, does that mean that someone else may not have handled the item itself?

Brandon Morse (03:03:43):

The lack of latent prints does not necessarily mean that somebody did not touch or touched an item.

Junior Barrett (03:03:49):

And in fact, you were actually saying that there was a lack of print, you're just saying whatever prints you had, these are the ones that was of value, meaning these are the ones that you could use to compare, correct?

Brandon Morse (03:04:02):

Yes, that is correct. If I called it of value, it meant it was usable for comparison.

Junior Barrett (03:04:08):

And some of the prints you received, you said someone else had done the lifting?

Brandon Morse (03:04:13):

Yes, that is correct.

Junior Barrett (03:04:14):

And obviously you don't know what process they may have used?

Brandon Morse (03:04:18):

That's correct. I was not present for the lifting of those prints.

Junior Barrett (03:04:22):

And the same thing would apply in terms of the fact that they may not have been readable prints does not mean that someone else may not have had contact with this object, meaning touch, held, things like that, correct?

Brandon Morse (03:04:38):

That is correct. Just because there's not a print of value does not mean somebody did or did not touch an item.

Junior Barrett (03:04:46):

And obviously the presence of prints that you found to be of value doesn't tell you when the prints actually got there?

Brandon Morse (03:04:54):

That is correct. There's no way to judge the time of a latent print.

Junior Barrett (03:04:58):

And I may have misheard you, but were there prints that you weren't able to identify to the two known samples you were given?

Brandon Morse (03:05:10):

I believe there were two latent fingerprints that were excluded to both the Dwain Hall and Sonia Exelby, as well as one print that was considered inconclusive to Dwain Hall.

Junior Barrett (03:05:24):

Okay. And what does inconclusive mean?

Brandon Morse (03:05:27):

In this case, inconclusive means that there was not sufficient information within that latent print to conclusively determine an identification or exclusion.

Junior Barrett (03:05:37):

What about to the other person, Sonia? Was it inconclusive as to her as well?

Brandon Morse (03:05:46):

If you don't mind me checking my notes.

Junior Barrett (03:05:47):

Please.

Brandon Morse (03:05:55):

For the latent print that was inconclusive to Dwain Hall, it was excluded to Sonia Exelby.

Junior Barrett (03:06:02):

Okay. I don't have any other questions, Judge.

Judge (03:06:05):

Any redirect examination, state?

Amy Berndt (03:06:06):

No, Your Honor.

Judge (03:06:06):

Members of the jury, do any of you all have questions of this witness? If you do, please raise your hands. Okay. See no hands. State is he released?

Amy Berndt (03:06:13):

We'd ask that he be excused.

Judge (03:06:14):

Defense?

Junior Barrett (03:06:15):

No objection, Judge.

Judge (03:06:15):

All right sir, you're free to go about your day. Thank you for your time.

Brandon Morse (03:06:17):

Thank you.

Judge (03:06:17):

All right. State, next witness.

Mr. Buxman (03:06:20):

State calls Brooke Hoover.

Judge (03:06:30):

Jurors, this will be our last witness of the morning, I anticipate, just so you all know where we're going. If you could raise your right hand, ma'am, face the clerk over here to be sworn in.

Speaker 9 (03:07:27):

Do you swear or affirm the testimony you're about to give will be the truth, the whole truth, and nothing but the truth, so help you God?

Brooke Hoover (03:07:27):

Yes, I do.

Judge (03:07:27):

Okay. You can go ahead be seated, ma'am.

Brooke Hoover (03:07:27):

Thank you.

Mr. Buxman (03:07:27):

Good morning, ma'am.

Brooke Hoover (03:07:27):

Good morning.

Mr. Buxman (03:07:27):

Would you please introduce yourself to the jury?

Brooke Hoover (03:07:29):

My name is Brooke Hoover. I'm a Crime Laboratory Analyst in the Biology and DNA section at the Florida Department of Law Enforcement.

Mr. Buxman (03:07:36):

How long have you worked at FDLE?

Brooke Hoover (03:07:38):

About 15 years.

Mr. Buxman (03:07:39):

And have you been in the biology section the entire time?

Brooke Hoover (03:07:41):

Yes, I have.

Mr. Buxman (03:07:43):

Can you describe for the jury your educational background and your training that allows you to do that job?

Brooke Hoover (03:07:48):

I have an Associate of Arts degree from St. Johns River Community College, and I have a Bachelor of Science and Biology from University of North Florida. While I was in college, I took courses in genetics, biochemistry, molecular and cellular biology, as well as statistics.

Mr. Buxman (03:08:05):

And what do you do on a day-to-day basis at FDLE?

Brooke Hoover (03:08:07):

I examine items collected from crime scenes for the presence of bodily fluids, most common blood, semen, saliva. I will swab items in order to determine who possibly wore or handled the item. I'll run DNA testing on those questioned samples from the crime scene. I will run DNA testing on known reference standards from individuals. I'll make comparisons between the two and report out the results of those comparisons.

Mr. Buxman (03:08:35):

As a DNA analyst, do you have to undergo proficiency training or testing?

Brooke Hoover (03:08:39):

Yes. Yes.

Mr. Buxman (03:08:40):

How often?

Brooke Hoover (03:08:41):

Twice a year we undergo proficiency testing.

Mr. Buxman (03:08:43):

And have you passed those tests?

Brooke Hoover (03:08:44):

Yes.

Mr. Buxman (03:08:48):

Have you ever been permitted to provide opinion testimony in a court in the area of DNA testing and analysis as well as statistical analysis?

Brooke Hoover (03:08:57):

Yes, I have.

Mr. Buxman (03:08:57):

Can you estimate about how many times?

Brooke Hoover (03:08:59):

This is trial 122 for me.

Mr. Buxman (03:09:01):

Your Honor, I would request the permission for this witness to provide opinion testimony in the area of DNA analysis as well as statistical analysis.

Judge (03:09:10):

Any voir dire?

Junior Barrett (03:09:10):

No, Your Honor.

Judge (03:09:11):

You can continue.

Mr. Buxman (03:09:14):

Can you give the jury a very brief, simple explanation of what DNA is?

Brooke Hoover (03:09:19):

DNA stands for deoxyribonucleic acid. It is a molecule found in every cell in your body except for mature red blood cells. The reason it's important for forensic science is because with the exception of identical twins, no two people are expected to have the same DNA profile.

Mr. Buxman (03:09:41):

What method of DNA testing is used by FDLE?

Brooke Hoover (03:09:45):

We do a type of testing called STR DNA testing. STR means short tandem repeats. So 99% of the DNA between individuals is in fact the same. It's less than 1% that's different. Of this 1%, we're looking at 24 specific areas called short tandem repeats. So you can think of it like a word being typed over and over again. We're counting the number of repeats at each location. You have two copies at each location. So overall, we get this combination of numbers that we call your forensic DNA profile.

Mr. Buxman (03:10:26):

And why do you have two copies at each location?

Brooke Hoover (03:10:28):

You get one copy from mom and one copy from dad.

Mr. Buxman (03:10:32):

Can you describe briefly to the jury how you logistically go through the DNA analysis? The step-by-step process?

Brooke Hoover (03:10:40):

A sample is taken from the evidence, usually a cutting or a swabbing, it's placed in the tube. The first step in the process is extraction. So we need to get the DNA off of the cutting and into liquid. So we add liquid, we use a series of chemical heat, shaking steps to extract the DNA. And although we have DNA, we have other things. We could have heme from blood, [inaudible 03:11:06] from dye. So the next step is we have to purify this. So it goes through a purification process, which is a series of washes with different buffers and alcohols.

(03:11:16)
At the end, we're left with pure DNA extract. Next step is quantitation. We need to know the quantity and the quality of the DNA in the sample we're working with. So we take a small amount and we perform quantitation. The next step is amplification. So we are making millions and millions of copies, but only of those specific areas that we're interested in. The last step is genetic analysis. So we have an instrument that reads this DNA information and it gives it to us in the form of a graph with peaks and valleys.

Mr. Buxman (03:11:49):

Does anything about that process change, alter, or modify the DNA in any way?

Brooke Hoover (03:11:55):

No.

Mr. Buxman (03:11:58):

What are controls?

Brooke Hoover (03:11:59):

Controls are substances that are known to contain or known to be absent of the substance being tested.

Mr. Buxman (03:12:06):

And what are their purpose in DNA testing?

Brooke Hoover (03:12:09):

To ensure quality of results. So one control that we use is for blood testing. So before I test blood in casework, I test my reagents and I do that by using a positive control that I know is blood, and a negative control, which I know is absent of blood. I record the results of those tests to make sure both are working properly. We also use what's called a negative control throughout DNA testing. A negative control goes through all of the same processes, gets all of the same chemicals. It's on the same robotic platforms. It's measured at quantitation as it is supposed to be absent of DNA. It goes all the way through genetic analysis and we read those results to make sure it is absent of DNA. So all of the controls are to ensure the quality and reliability of the DNA results that we get.

Mr. Buxman (03:13:02):

What steps do you take when you're analyzing different items of evidence to make sure you don't contaminate things or transfer DNA from one item to another?

Brooke Hoover (03:13:14):

We have very specific evidence handling procedures. I wear PPE, personal protective equipment. My hair is tied back. I'm wearing a hairnet. I'm wearing a mask. I'm wearing a lab coat. I'm wearing disposable gloves, which I change frequently. We are only allowed to work one item of evidence at a time. I clean my workspace. I clean any tools that I use. I put down a fresh piece of butcher paper. I open the evidence package. I change my gloves. I remove the evidence because I don't want my gloves that have touched the outside of a package to touch the inside of the package. I only work one item of evidence at a time. I'll take my samples. I'll return that piece of evidence to the package. I seal it. I throw away my butcher paper. I throw away my gloves. Everything is clean before I open another item.

Mr. Buxman (03:14:03):

Are there things that can destroy or cause DNA to degrade?

Brooke Hoover (03:14:08):

Yes.

Mr. Buxman (03:14:09):

Like what?

Brooke Hoover (03:14:10):

Well, Florida, UV light, heat, humidity, moisture, all of these things can degrade or completely destroy DNA.

Mr. Buxman (03:14:20):

Is it also standard procedure in DNA analysis if you find DNA from an item that matches DNA from a known person to apply a statistical analysis to give weight or importance to that finding?

Brooke Hoover (03:14:36):

Yes.

Mr. Buxman (03:14:37):

Can you explain to the jury what that means and generally what you do?

Brooke Hoover (03:14:40):

Yes. So if I'm reporting that there is a match or an inclusion, I'm providing statistics in order to give weight or meaning to that match. So what I'm doing is, I am comparing the probability of the observed evidence, given that it either originated from the person of interest or an unknown individual. This is called a likelihood ratio. When we get very high likelihood ratios, what it means is that a random coincidental occurrence is not a likely explanation for the DNA evidence. We also have something called excluded, which means that the DNA did not originate from that person. They're not the source. We also have something called the inconclusive zone. So this is when I have a statistical value, but it falls in a range that we know that false inclusions and false exclusions can happen. So what's going on is I don't have enough weight to say if someone's truly included or excluded, and that is what an inconclusive result is.

Mr. Buxman (03:15:44):

Were you provided several items of evidence in the case of State of Florida versus Dwain Hall, FDLE case number 2025-0405138?

Brooke Hoover (03:15:54):

Yes.

Mr. Buxman (03:15:55):

And when you receive a piece of evidence, do you open it up? Is it normally sealed?

Brooke Hoover (03:16:00):

Yes.

Mr. Buxman (03:16:01):

And do you open it up?

Brooke Hoover (03:16:02):

Yes, I do.

Mr. Buxman (03:16:03):

And then when you're done with that piece of evidence, do you reseal that package somehow?

Brooke Hoover (03:16:07):

Yes, I do.

Mr. Buxman (03:16:07):

How do you do that?

Brooke Hoover (03:16:09):

With tape and yeah, regular tape, evidence tape, and then I initial my seal.

Mr. Buxman (03:16:14):

Okay. So if we see a bunch of pieces of evidence in this case with BH on it, is that you?

Brooke Hoover (03:16:19):

Yes, it is.

Mr. Buxman (03:16:20):

Okay. Were you provided a known DNA standard from Sonia Exelby?

Brooke Hoover (03:16:27):

Yes, I was.

Mr. Buxman (03:16:28):

Were you provided one from Dwain Hall?

Brooke Hoover (03:16:30):

Yes.

Mr. Buxman (03:16:30):

Were you provided one from a Richard Snyder?

Brooke Hoover (03:16:32):

Yes.

Mr. Buxman (03:16:33):

And a Heather Stark?

Brooke Hoover (03:16:34):

Yes, I was.

Mr. Buxman (03:16:35):

And did you analyze those four known DNA standards for the presence of DNA?

Brooke Hoover (03:16:39):

Yes.

Mr. Buxman (03:16:40):

Did you use the same process, that four step process you described earlier?

Brooke Hoover (03:16:43):

Yes, I did.

Mr. Buxman (03:16:44):

And what were the results when you analyzed those four known standards?

Brooke Hoover (03:16:48):

I obtained complete DNA profiles for all four standards. Complete DNA profile means I had complete information at every area testing.

Mr. Buxman (03:16:57):

So now that you have a complete DNA profile from the known DNA standards of Sonia Exelby, Dwain Hall, Richard Snyder, and Heather Stark, are you able to take those four known profiles and compare them to the DNA profiles you obtained from other pieces of evidence?

Brooke Hoover (03:17:13):

Yes.

Mr. Buxman (03:17:20):

Were you also provided other items collected from various scenes related to this case and asked to analyze those items for the presence of DNA?

Brooke Hoover (03:17:29):

Yes, I was.

Mr. Buxman (03:17:30):

If sufficient DNA was found on any of those items, did you compare the DNA found to the known profiles of Dwain Hall, Sonia Exelby, Richard Snyder, and Heather Stark?

Brooke Hoover (03:17:40):

Yes, I did.

Mr. Buxman (03:17:42):

All right. So I'm going to go through and organize my questions based on location of these items that were seized to make it a little easier, okay?

Brooke Hoover (03:17:50):

Okay. And can I refer to my report?

Mr. Buxman (03:17:52):

With the court's permission, yes.

Judge (03:17:53):

Yes, ma'am. You may.

Brooke Hoover (03:17:54):

Thank you.

Mr. Buxman (03:17:57):

Were you provided a phone retrieved from the center console of Dwain Hall's Jeep?

Mr. Buxman (03:18:00):

... retrieved from the center console of Dwain Hall's Jeep, your item would be C09?

Brooke Hoover (03:18:06):

Yes.

Mr. Buxman (03:18:06):

And what did you do with that item first?

Brooke Hoover (03:18:10):

I noticed reddish brown staining on the item. I tested it for the presence of blood. It did not give chemical indications for the presence of blood. The phone was also slated to go to our friction ridge or latent print section., So I did contact the analyst. We consulted on what portions of the phone would be sampled for DNA and what portions of the phone would be preserved so latent prints could examine it. So the decision was made. I swabbed the power button. I swabbed some textured areas. I left smooth surfaces for friction ridge and I swabbed areas that we hoped were likely that some skin or sweat material may have been left behind.

Mr. Buxman (03:19:02):

So do you then use that swab as what you analyze for DNA, not the phone itself?

Brooke Hoover (03:19:09):

That is correct.

Mr. Buxman (03:19:10):

Okay. Did you analyze that swab that you collected from those areas of the defendant's phone for the presence of DNA?

Brooke Hoover (03:19:16):

Yes, I did.

Mr. Buxman (03:19:17):

What were your results?

Brooke Hoover (03:19:18):

Due to the limited nature of the DNA results obtained, the data was not interpretable.

Mr. Buxman (03:19:23):

And why would there be too little DNA? We see on TV they get DNA from anything and everything.

Brooke Hoover (03:19:28):

Absolutely, and cell phones are something that is handled, but just because you handle something doesn't mean that usable DNA results will be left behind. I'm not saying that it was never touched, never handled, just it was not a usable amount of DNA. I could not use it to make comparisons.

Mr. Buxman (03:19:49):

Okay. Still referring to the defendant's Jeep, were you given... Did you analyze a knife found from the center console, scissors taken from a back crate, and a multicolored towel from the rear passenger seat of that Jeep? Specifically your item numbers were C15, C16 and C28.

Brooke Hoover (03:20:07):

Yes, I did.

Mr. Buxman (03:20:08):

Were those items analyzed for the presence of blood?

Brooke Hoover (03:20:11):

Yes. I examined them for any reddish brown staining and collected samples to test for the possible presence of blood. None of the samples gave chemical indications for the presence of blood. I did not perform any DNA testing or anything else on those items.

Mr. Buxman (03:20:29):

And why would you not perform DNA testing?

Brooke Hoover (03:20:32):

It didn't give chemical indications for the presence of blood, and at that point we are looking for an item that could have possibly been used as a murder weapon. So no blood, no further testing.

Mr. Buxman (03:20:44):

Okay. Were you also given a blue paper towel with possible blood on it from the Jeep door driver's side door pocket?

Brooke Hoover (03:20:54):

Yes.

Mr. Buxman (03:20:55):

Did you analyze it for the presence of blood?

Brooke Hoover (03:20:57):

Yes. The paper towel did give chemical indications for the presence of blood, and I did take a sample forward for DNA testing.

Mr. Buxman (03:21:04):

And what were the results of your DNA analysis?

Brooke Hoover (03:21:07):

I obtained a partial DNA profile. It was consistent with a male individual.

Mr. Buxman (03:21:12):

What's a partial profile?

Brooke Hoover (03:21:14):

Well, for this one, I did get information at every area tested, but there were two locations where I didn't get complete information. So I had one piece of information, but not the other. However, this is a partial DNA profile and I can use it to make comparisons.

Mr. Buxman (03:21:31):

Okay. And did you then compare that partial DNA profile from that blue towel to the known profiles of Richard Snyder and Dwain Hall because you said it was originated from a male?

Brooke Hoover (03:21:42):

Yes. We compare it to everybody, but yes, the partial DNA profile matched the DNA profile from Dwain Hall. The observed profile is greater than 700 billion times more likely to occur if the sample originated from Dwain Hall than if it originated from a unrelated individual.

Mr. Buxman (03:22:05):

Can you kind of explain what that means? Kind of elaborate on that.

Brooke Hoover (03:22:09):

Sure. FDLE calculates the likelihood ratio for the three most common population groups in the United States, Caucasian, African American, and Hispanic. We will report the most conservative of those three likelihood ratios. If the number exceeds 700 billion, our agency caps the reporting at greater than 700 billion. So that is why I'm reporting a statistic of greater than 700 billion.

Mr. Buxman (03:22:42):

So it's 700 billion times more likely that the DNA in that blue towel came from the defendant as opposed to coming from somebody else, some unknown person?

Brooke Hoover (03:22:51):

Well, what I'm calculating is this observed DNA profile. How rare or how common would we expect to find this DNA profile in the population? So again, I'm comparing the probability that this observed profile originated from Dwain Hall versus the possibility that it came from a random individual. And that is the statistic that I am providing.

Mr. Buxman (03:23:14):

Understood. Did you also analyze a purple top tube of mascara?

Brooke Hoover (03:23:20):

Yes.

Mr. Buxman (03:23:20):

And did you analyze it for the presence of blood?

Brooke Hoover (03:23:23):

I did.

Mr. Buxman (03:23:24):

What'd you find?

Brooke Hoover (03:23:26):

It failed to give chemical indications for the presence of blood. I did not perform any further testing on the mascara.

Mr. Buxman (03:23:32):

Did you analyze a swab collected by a crime scene technician from a firearm located in the defendant's Jeep, your item C17?

Brooke Hoover (03:23:42):

Yes, I did.

Mr. Buxman (03:23:43):

And what were your results when you analyzed it for the presence of DNA?

Brooke Hoover (03:23:51):

I obtained a mixture. It was consistent with three donors. At least one of those donors was a male contributor.

Mr. Buxman (03:23:58):

And what's meant by a mixture?

Brooke Hoover (03:24:00):

A mixture means that the DNA profile originated from more than one person.

Mr. Buxman (03:24:05):

And how can you tell that it was a mixture containing three different DNA profiles for three people?

Brooke Hoover (03:24:11):

Again, when you get a DNA profile, you get one piece of information from your mother, one piece of information from your father. At each location, one person, their DNA profile at most will have two pieces of information at that location. So if I have a DNA profile where I have three markers or four markers or five markers at a single location, I know that I am dealing with a mixed DNA profile. So one of the methods for determining the number of donors in a mixture is counting the number of alleles at a location dividing by two, but it can be more complicated than that, and we also look at the ratio of the alleles to each other because if there is imbalance, it can indicate that there's an extra person. So mixture determination is done by counting the number of alleles and also looking at the balance between those alleles.

Mr. Buxman (03:25:07):

And you said that at least one of the contributors of this mixture was male. How do you know that?

Brooke Hoover (03:25:11):

We test gender markers. So males have Y chromosome. If we get results for a Y chromosome, we know that there is a male in the mixture.

Mr. Buxman (03:25:19):

Are you sometimes able to separate the contributors to this mixture and then compare the individual DNA profiles to known profiles?

Brooke Hoover (03:25:28):

Yes. So we do try to deconvolute to tell who is who in the mixture. However, when we're comparing a standard to a mixture, the standard is compared to the overall mixture.

Mr. Buxman (03:25:39):

Did you compare the DNA from the mixture from the swab on the gun to the known DNA profile of Sonia Exelby?

Brooke Hoover (03:25:47):

Yes, I did.

Mr. Buxman (03:25:47):

What were your results?

Brooke Hoover (03:25:48):

The comparison of the DNA profile from Sonia Exelby to the mixture obtained from the gun failed to demonstrate sufficient statistical support for inclusion or exclusion. Therefore, no determination can be made regarding the contribution of Sonia Exelby to the item.

Mr. Buxman (03:26:06):

So what does that mean? Why could she not be included or excluded?

Brooke Hoover (03:26:10):

I could not tell if she was truly there or not. I can't give a... I did obtain a statistical value, but this is where we know that false inclusions and false exclusions can happen, so for that reason we say no determination.

Mr. Buxman (03:26:27):

Did you compare the mixture of the DNA from the swab from the gun in the defendant's Jeep to the known DNA profile of Dwain Hall?

Brooke Hoover (03:26:35):

Yes.

Mr. Buxman (03:26:36):

What'd you find?

Brooke Hoover (03:26:36):

Dwain Hall is included as a possible contributor to the mixed DNA profile. The observed mixed DNA profile is greater than 700 billion times more likely to occur if the sample originated from Dwain Hall and two unrelated individuals than if it originated from three unrelated individuals.

Mr. Buxman (03:26:57):

Moving on to items collected from Dwain Hall's body. Did you analyze a red knife collected from his body, a brown shirt he was wearing, and some shoes he was wearing?

Brooke Hoover (03:27:09):

Yes.

Mr. Buxman (03:27:10):

Were those items tested for the presence of blood?

Brooke Hoover (03:27:13):

Yes, they were.

Mr. Buxman (03:27:13):

What were the results as to all three of those items?

Brooke Hoover (03:27:16):

They did not give chemical indications for the presence of blood. I did not perform DNA testing on those items.

Mr. Buxman (03:27:23):

Moving on to items recovered from the defendant's house. Did you analyze a shovel collected from the garage of the defendant's house?

Brooke Hoover (03:27:30):

Yes, I did.

Mr. Buxman (03:27:31):

And what were the results when you analyzed it for the presence of blood?

Brooke Hoover (03:27:35):

It did give chemical indications for the presence of blood. I noticed reddish brown staining on the handle. This was also an item that was going to the latent print section, so I did consult with the latent prints analyst to determine which areas would be sampled for DNA and what areas would be preserved for latent prints.

Mr. Buxman (03:27:57):

So did you analyze that area of blood on the handle for the presence of DNA?

Brooke Hoover (03:28:03):

Yes. I took a swab from the reddish brown staining on the handle. It did give chemical indications for the presence of blood. I then took that swab forward for DNA testing and I transferred the shovel to the latent print section.

Mr. Buxman (03:28:16):

All right. May I approach, Your Honor?

Judge (03:28:17):

Yes sir.

Mr. Buxman (03:28:19):

Showing you what's been marked as State's Exhibit 4K for identification. You said you personally took a swab from that shovel?

Brooke Hoover (03:28:25):

Yes, I did.

Mr. Buxman (03:28:26):

Do you recognize that item I've handed you?

Brooke Hoover (03:28:28):

Yes, I do.

Mr. Buxman (03:28:30):

And what is that item?

Brooke Hoover (03:28:32):

This is the swab that I collected from the shovel.

Mr. Buxman (03:28:34):

Is that in the same or substantially the same condition as when you collected it?

Brooke Hoover (03:28:37):

Yes, it is.

Mr. Buxman (03:28:38):

At this time, state would move 4K into evidence as State's 92.

Junior Barrett (03:28:44):

No objection, Judge.

Judge (03:28:46):

Without objection what's marked for identification as State's Exhibit quadruple K will be admitted into evidence as State's Exhibit number 92.

Mr. Buxman (03:28:52):

When you analyzed that swab from the shovel, the handle of the shovel for DNA, what were your results?

Brooke Hoover (03:28:58):

I obtained the... It was a mixture of at least two donors, including at least one male contributor. A complete DNA profile for the major contributor could be determined and is suitable for comparisons. That major DNA profile was a female. The major DNA profile matched the DNA profile from Sonia Exelby. The observed major DNA profile is greater than 700 billion times more likely to occur if the sample originated from Sonia Exelby than if it originated from an unrelated individual. Dwain Hall, Heather Stark, Richard Snyder are excluded as the major contributor. And due to the limited nature for the additional contributors to that mixed DNA profile, it was not suitable for comparison.

Mr. Buxman (03:29:47):

Okay. Moving on to items taken from Sonia Exelby's body at the time of the autopsy. Did you receive nail clippings from Sonia Exelby's hands, specifically ME3 and ME4 for your report numbers?

Brooke Hoover (03:30:05):

Yes, I did.

Mr. Buxman (03:30:07):

Did you analyze those different finger clippings for the presence of blood?

Brooke Hoover (03:30:15):

Yes, I did. They did... Give both the left and right hand fingernail clippings gave chemical indications for the presence of blood.

Mr. Buxman (03:30:23):

And did you analyze those swabbings or the clippings for the presence of DNA?

Brooke Hoover (03:30:27):

Yes, I did. Sonia Exelby is expected to be a donor to any DNA results from these fingernails. They were collected from her body. I did not obtain any DNA results foreign to Sonia Exelby from the fingernail clippings.

Mr. Buxman (03:30:43):

Did you also receive swabs taken from Sonia Exelby's external genitalia, anal swabs, as well as vaginal swabs?

Brooke Hoover (03:30:51):

Yes, I did.

Mr. Buxman (03:30:52):

Did you analyze those for the presence of foreign DNA?

Brooke Hoover (03:30:55):

Yes, I did.

Mr. Buxman (03:30:56):

And what were the results?

Brooke Hoover (03:30:57):

No DNA results foreign to Sonia Exelby were obtained from the external genitalia swabs, the vaginal swabs, or the anal swabs.

Mr. Buxman (03:31:06):

Did you look at any hairs when you examined the genital swabs?

Brooke Hoover (03:31:10):

Yes. Hairs were present on the genital swabs. They were collected and examined. Only one of these possible hairs was suitable for DNA testing. I did perform DNA testing, but once again, I did not obtain any DNA results foreign to Sonia Exelby.

Mr. Buxman (03:31:26):

Okay. Moving on to an item that was collected from the burial site. Were you given a label from a shovel that was recovered at the burial site, your item B9?

Brooke Hoover (03:31:39):

Yes.

Mr. Buxman (03:31:40):

Did you analyze that for the presence of any stains or DNA or blood?

Brooke Hoover (03:31:45):

Yes. This was also an item that was scheduled to be analyzed by both biology and latent prints. I did consult with latent prints. Because there was no staining, like reddish brown staining, anything of serological interest, it was decided that I would not sample the label from the shovel. Instead, I preserved it and transferred it to latent prints for further analysis.

Mr. Buxman (03:32:14):

Moving on to a black backpack recovered in Tampa. Did you analyze or examine a black backpack recovered from a truck in Tampa?

Brooke Hoover (03:32:25):

Yes, I did.

Mr. Buxman (03:32:25):

Okay. And did you analyze it for the presence of blood?

Brooke Hoover (03:32:28):

I did. It did not give chemical indications for the presence of blood.

Mr. Buxman (03:32:32):

Did you analyze it for the presence of DNA?

Brooke Hoover (03:32:34):

Yes, I did take some samples. I swabbed the zipper pulls. I swabbed the handle and the shoulder straps. I also found a bobby pin inside of the backpack and I swabbed that for DNA as well.

Mr. Buxman (03:32:49):

Starting with the swab from the zipper pull, did you analyze that swab for the presence of DNA?

Brooke Hoover (03:32:54):

Yes, I did.

Mr. Buxman (03:32:55):

What were your results?

Brooke Hoover (03:32:56):

It demonstrated the presence of a mixture consistent with two donors, including at least one male contributor. Sonia Exelby is included as a possible contributor to the mixed DNA profile. The observed mixed DNA profile is greater than 700 billion times more likely to occur if the sample originated from Sonia Exelby and one unrelated individual, than if it originated from two unrelated individuals. When I compared Dwain Hall, Dwain Hall was included as a possible contributor to the mixed DNA profile. The observed mixed DNA profile is approximately 72 million times more likely to occur if the sample originated from Dwain Hall and one unrelated individual than if it originated from two unrelated individuals.

Mr. Buxman (03:33:45):

Okay. And what about the swab from the handle and shoulder strap?

Brooke Hoover (03:33:58):

The swab from the handle and the shoulder straps demonstrated the presence of a mixture consistent with four donors, including at least one male contributor. Sonia Exelby is included as a possible contributor to the mixed DNA profile. The observed mixed DNA profile is greater than 700 billion times more likely to occur if the sample originated from Sonia Exelby and three unrelated individuals than if it originated from four unrelated individuals. I compared Dwain Hall. Dwain Hall is included as a possible contributor to the mixed DNA profile. The observed mixed DNA profile is greater than 700 billion times more likely to occur if the sample originated from Dwain Hall and three unrelated individuals than if it originated from four unrelated individuals.

Mr. Buxman (03:34:49):

‍

You also mentioned you found a bobby pin and a person swabbed that.

Brooke Hoover (03:34:52):

I did. Due to the limited nature of the DNA results obtained from the bobby pin, the DNA information is not interpretable.

Mr. Buxman (03:35:03):

Finally I want to talk to you about a couple items collected from Rick Snyder's house in Ohio. Were you provided a knife and a sheath that was collected from a kitchen counter table?

Brooke Hoover (03:35:14):

Yes.

Mr. Buxman (03:35:14):

Was that item analyzed for the presence of blood?

Brooke Hoover (03:35:17):

Yes.

Mr. Buxman (03:35:18):

What were the results?

Brooke Hoover (03:35:24):

The knife with sheath from the kitchen?

Mr. Buxman (03:35:27):

INV-12, yes, ma'am.

Brooke Hoover (03:35:28):

Okay. Just wanted to make sure.

Mr. Buxman (03:35:29):

Yes, ma'am.

Brooke Hoover (03:35:36):

The knife and the sheath failed to give chemical indications for the presence of blood. Therefore, I didn't perform any further testing with that knife.

Mr. Buxman (03:35:45):

Referring to a knife and a bracelet that was found in a cloth bag in a dresser drawer in Rick Snyder's house in Ohio, did you analyze that... First starting with the bracelet. Did you analyze the bracelet for the presence of blood?

Brooke Hoover (03:36:01):

I did. The bracelet did not give chemical indications for the presence of blood.

Mr. Buxman (03:36:06):

And did you analyze that bracelet for the presence of DNA?

Brooke Hoover (03:36:09):

I did. It demonstrated the presence of a mixture consistent with three donors, including at least one male contributor.

Mr. Buxman (03:36:20):

Go ahead.

Brooke Hoover (03:36:21):

Okay. Sonia Exelby is included as a possible contributor to the mixed DNA profile. The observed mixed DNA profile is approximately 130 million times more likely to occur if the sample originated from Sonia Exelby and two unrelated individuals than if it originated from three unrelated individuals. Dwain Hall is included as a possible contributor to the mixed DNA profile. The observed mixed DNA profile is greater than 700 billion times more likely to occur if the sample originated from Dwain Hall and two unrelated individuals than if it originated from three unrelated individuals. And then the comparison of the DNA profiles from Heather Stark and Richard Snyder to this mixture failed to demonstrate sufficient statistical support for inclusion or exclusion. Therefore, no determination can be made regarding the contribution of Heather Stark or Richard Snyder to this bracelet.

Mr. Buxman (03:37:19):

Referring to the knife sheath, did you also analyze that sheath for the presence of blood?

Brooke Hoover (03:37:24):

Yes, it did give chemical indications for the presence of blood.

Mr. Buxman (03:37:28):

Okay. And did you analyze that area that gave chemical indications for the presence of blood for DNA also?

Brooke Hoover (03:37:33):

Yes, I took that sample forward for DNA testing and the sample from the sheath demonstrated the presence of a mixture. It was consistent with three donors, including at least one male contributor. Sonia Exelby was included as a possible contributor to the mixed DNA profile from the knife sheath. The observed mixed DNA profile is greater than 700 billion times more likely to occur if the sample originated from Sonia Exelby and two unrelated individuals than if it originated from three unrelated individuals. Dwain Hall is included as a possible contributor to the mixed DNA profile. The observed mixed DNA profile is greater than 700 billion times more likely to occur if the sample originated from Dwain Hall and two unrelated individuals than if it originated from three unrelated individuals. Richard Snyder is included as a possible contributor to the mixed DNA profile. The observed mixed DNA profile is greater than 700 billion times more likely to occur if the sample originated from Richard Snyder and two unrelated individuals than if it originated from three unrelated individuals. And finally, Heather Stark is excluded as a contributor to the mixed DNA profile.

Mr. Buxman (03:38:49):

Now referring to the knife itself, may I approach again? Showing you what's been marked as State's Exhibit 4L. Do you recognize the knife in that photograph?

Brooke Hoover (03:38:59):

Yes, I do.

Mr. Buxman (03:39:00):

And how do you recognize it?

Brooke Hoover (03:39:01):

I took this photograph and above the photograph are the FDLE case number, item number, the date that I took the photo, and my initials.

Mr. Buxman (03:39:09):

And does that fairly and accurately depict what the knife looked like when you analyzed it?

Brooke Hoover (03:39:13):

Yes.

Mr. Buxman (03:39:13):

At this time, state would move state's 4L into evidence as 93.

Junior Barrett (03:39:18):

No objection, Judge.

Judge (03:39:19):

Without objection, what's been marked for identification as State's Exhibit quadruple L will be admitted into evidence as State's Exhibit 93.

Mr. Buxman (03:39:25):

Publish?

Judge (03:39:26):

Yes, sir.

Mr. Buxman (03:39:29):

Showing you a photograph of the knife, State's 93. Does that look familiar?

Brooke Hoover (03:39:33):

Yes, it does.

Mr. Buxman (03:39:34):

Okay. Is there anything written on the knife?

Brooke Hoover (03:39:37):

Yes.

Mr. Buxman (03:39:38):

What was written?

Brooke Hoover (03:39:39):

Dorkworf pointy end goes in the other guy.

Mr. Buxman (03:39:42):

Okay. Did you analyze that knife for the presence of blood?

Brooke Hoover (03:39:46):

Yes, I did.

Mr. Buxman (03:39:47):

What were your results?

Brooke Hoover (03:39:49):

I actually ended up taking the handle apart and I tested underneath the handle and I did find reddish brown staining that did give chemical indications for the presence of blood.

Mr. Buxman (03:40:03):

And why did you take the handle off?

Brooke Hoover (03:40:05):

Well, I did have information that this item may have been cleaned. I also noticed an oily substance, you can see it on the paper, it was oily. So I just took the knife apart to see if there was anything under the handle. So I did find reddish brown staining on both the threads of the screws and underneath the handle on both sides of the knife. I took a sample from the staining under the handle. I tested that for blood. It gave chemical indications for the presence of blood. I then took that forward for DNA testing.

Mr. Buxman (03:40:42):

When you compared that blood to the known DNA profiles of... We'll start with Heather Stark and Richard Snyder, what were your results?

Brooke Hoover (03:40:52):

I obtained a complete DNA profile. It was consistent with a female contributor. Heather Stark, Richard Snyder were excluded as the source of the DNA profile.

Mr. Buxman (03:41:01):

I'm assuming if the blood was consistent with a female, what about Dwain Hall?

Brooke Hoover (03:41:04):

Dwain Hall was excluded as the source.

Mr. Buxman (03:41:07):

And when you compared the blood from the knife to the known DNA profile of Sonia Exelby, what did you find?

Brooke Hoover (03:41:12):

The DNA profile matched the DNA profile from Sonia Exelby. The observed DNA profile is greater than 700 billion times more likely to occur if the sample originated from Sonia Exelby than if it originated from an unrelated individual.

Mr. Buxman (03:41:29):

Thank you, ma'am. No other questions, Your Honor.

Judge (03:41:31):

Any cross examination?

Junior Barrett (03:41:38):

I guess it's still before lunch, so good morning.

Brooke Hoover (03:41:41):

Good morning.

Junior Barrett (03:41:46):

If I'm understanding your testimony, you only tested for blood?

Brooke Hoover (03:41:52):

Correct.

Junior Barrett (03:41:53):

But DNA can come from other bodily fluid, correct?

Brooke Hoover (03:41:58):

That is correct.

Junior Barrett (03:41:59):

Including saliva, sweat, things like that, correct?

Brooke Hoover (03:42:02):

That is correct.

Junior Barrett (03:42:03):

But you didn't test for any of those?

Brooke Hoover (03:42:06):

No, I did not.

Junior Barrett (03:42:07):

And also, how long can the DNA last on an object?

Brooke Hoover (03:42:11):

If the object is stored at room temperature, DNA can persist for months, even years.

Junior Barrett (03:42:17):

All right. And DNA can also be transferred, correct?

Brooke Hoover (03:42:20):

DNA can be transferred.

Junior Barrett (03:42:22):

Meaning it can come from even a jacket of someone if it transfers over to the object, another object, correct?

Brooke Hoover (03:42:30):

Yes. So direct DNA is when it came directly from the body onto an object. Transfer is when the DNA was transferred through an intermediary object. So you step in a pool of blood, then you walk to your car, the blood is still wet on your shoe and it gets on the gas pedal. Well, the gas pedal was never in contact with the blood, but you transferred it from your shoes. So that's an example of transfer.

Junior Barrett (03:43:00):

All right. And in this case, the presence of Mr. Hall's DNA on a blue paper towel, that could have been there days, weeks, months before, correct?

Brooke Hoover (03:43:15):

That is correct.

Junior Barrett (03:43:16):

And in fact, it's your understanding that this came from a vehicle that belonged to Mr. Hall, correct?

Brooke Hoover (03:43:21):

That is correct.

Junior Barrett (03:43:28):

And again, that was blood, at least the presence of presumptive blood, correct?

Brooke Hoover (03:43:34):

Correct.

Junior Barrett (03:43:35):

And again, no way of knowing when this blood got on this towel?

Brooke Hoover (03:43:40):

That is correct. DNA testing will not tell you when DNA was deposited on an object.

Junior Barrett (03:43:45):

And so for example, for someone who has a towing company, changing a tire, could have gotten cut, and the blood could have been from that onto the paper towel, correct?

Brooke Hoover (03:43:57):

Again, I have no explanation for how, when, where, or under what circumstance that the blood or possible blood on the paper towel got there.

Junior Barrett (03:44:06):

And the same as to the shovel itself, excuse me, her profile or her DNA being on the shovel could also be transferred, correct?

Brooke Hoover (03:44:19):

That is correct. I have no explanation. My testing will not tell you how DNA got there, whether it was direct or transfer.

Junior Barrett (03:44:27):

The nail clippings, no foreign DNA.

Brooke Hoover (03:44:30):

That is correct. No foreign DNA.

Junior Barrett (03:44:35):

As part of your examination and testing, did you check to see if any skin tissues or anything like that was...

Brooke Hoover (03:44:42):

I just took the sample. So I directly sampled the fingernails and took that sample directly for DNA. I did not perform anything other than the blood presumptive test. It just went straight to DNA.

Junior Barrett (03:44:55):

So no presumptive blood coming from Mr. Hall was found on her nails? I'm assuming since you said no foreign DNA, that would be the conclusion, correct?

Brooke Hoover (03:45:09):

Correct. It did give chemical indications for blood and the DNA results I did not obtain anything foreign to Sonia Exelby on the fingernails.

Junior Barrett (03:45:22):

The bracelet, you indicated that Sonia could be a possible contributor, correct?

Brooke Hoover (03:45:32):

Correct.

Junior Barrett (03:45:33):

Again, you're not saying she is, she's just saying it's possible, correct?

Brooke Hoover (03:45:36):

That is correct. We report possible inclusion anytime we're making a comparison to a mixture, and then we provide the statistic to give weight to that inclusion.

Junior Barrett (03:45:45):

And again, going back to what we discussed earlier, if, for example, Mr. Hall was wearing this bracelet during a sexual activity and it involved... It could have been transferred that way if it's one of those activity where she may have been cut or in an open sore, something that would transfer blood from her to this bracelet, correct?

Brooke Hoover (03:46:14):

Again, how DNA ended up on an object is outside of something I can test and report. I have no opinion to render on how DNA came to be on an item.

Junior Barrett (03:46:25):

I don't have any other questions, Judge.

Judge (03:46:27):

Any redirect examination, State?

Mr. Buxman (03:46:31):

No, Your Honor.

Judge (03:46:32):

Members of the jury, do any of y'all have questions of this witness? If you do, please raise your hands. Seeing no hands. State, is she released?

Mr. Buxman (03:46:39):

She is, Your Honor.

Junior Barrett (03:46:40):

No objection, Judge.

Judge (03:46:41):

All right, ma'am, you're free to go about your day. Thank you for your time. Ladies and gentlemen, we've reached a pretty good stopping point. Do you know if lunches are here yet?

Speaker 10 (03:46:50):

They are here.

Judge (03:46:51):

They are? All right, excellent. Lunches have arrived. We're going to take a recess until one o'clock to allow you all to eat. Over the recess, again, I remind you, the case is not concluded yet. You are therefore prohibited from speaking with one another about the case and there to be no discussion about the case with one another or obviously any other person. If you use your eligible electronic devices on the break, don't use them to read anything about the case, do any research or try to come into contact with any information about the case, avoid all news and streaming sites and enjoy your lunch. I'll see you all back at one o'clock. Notepads here also and the chair's closed. Thank you. Door's still cracked. The record should reflect the jury has left the courtroom. We have lunch for Mr. Hall, correct?

Speaker 10 (03:48:29):

Yes, Judge.

Judge (03:48:30):

All right. Is there anything we need to take up before we break for lunch?

Mr. Buxman (03:48:33):

No, Your Honor.

Junior Barrett (03:48:34):

No, Your Honor.

Judge (03:48:35):

Okay. I'll see you all back, I'd like y'all back here about 12:50, 12:55, lawyers. We'll plan to start properly at 1:00.

Mr. Buxman (03:48:41):

Yes, sir.

Judge (03:48:41):

Thank you. I've got two witnesses remaining, state, on what you had told me Monday the witness order would be. Is that holding?

Speaker 11 (03:49:04):

Yes, sir.

Mr. Buxman (03:49:04):

Yes, sir.

Judge (03:49:04):

Okay. All right. Very good. All right. We'll see you all about an hour.

Mr. Buxman (03:49:04):

Okay.

Speaker 12 (03:51:00):

(silence)

Your Honor (04:35:33):

Who's going to cover Mr. Brandy's cases while he's waiting? He's only got two on trial priority-

Speaker 13 (04:35:37):

And I'm getting rid of one of them on Monday.

Your Honor (04:35:39):

Okay.

Speaker 13 (04:35:40):

We don't know officially.

Your Honor (04:50:56):

It's 105. Lawyers are present as well as the defendant. State, are we ready to bring the jury back in?

Speaker 13 (04:50:59):

Yes, Your Honor.

Your Honor (04:51:00):

Defense?

Speaker 14 (04:51:01):

Yes, Your Honor.

Your Honor (04:51:02):

Okay. Anything to take up before we bring in the jury?

Speaker 13 (04:51:04):

No, sir.

Speaker 14 (04:51:04):

No, Your Honor.

Your Honor (04:52:36):

Okay. Let's bring them in. Ladies and gentlemen, welcome back. Everyone can be seated. State, you can call your next witness.

Speaker 15 (04:52:41):

State calls Dr. Jason Demery. He's out this way.

Your Honor (04:53:09):

Raise your right hand, sir. Face the clerk to be sworn.

Clerk (04:53:15):

Do you swear or affirm the testimony you're about to give will be the truth, the whole truth, and nothing but the truth, so help you God?

Dr. Jason Demery (04:53:15):

Yes, ma'am. I do. All right.

Your Honor (04:53:16):

You can be seated, sir.

Speaker 15 (04:53:17):

Good afternoon.

Dr. Jason Demery (04:53:17):

Good afternoon.

Speaker 15 (04:53:29):

Can you please tell the jury your name?

Dr. Jason Demery (04:53:31):

Sure. My name's Dr. Jason Demery.

Speaker 15 (04:53:33):

What's your current occupation?

Dr. Jason Demery (04:53:34):

I'm a state of Florida licensed psychologist and board certified neuropsychologist.

Speaker 15 (04:53:39):

Can you describe your educational background for the jury?

Dr. Jason Demery (04:53:41):

Sure. I completed my bachelor's degree in psychology in 1995 at the University of West Florida while on active duty in the US Marine Corps. In 1996, I completed a master's degree in clinical psychology at Southern Illinois University. I then worked full-time at Washington University School of Medicine in St. Lewis, Missouri in the Department of Neurology for about two years. And then I applied to and was accepted to the University of Florida's PhD program in clinical psychology with a specialization in neuropsychology.

Speaker 15 (04:54:14):

What's the difference between a psychologist and a neuropsychologist?

Dr. Jason Demery (04:54:18):

Sure. A clinical neuropsychologist is a clinical psychologist, but with additional specialty training in how the brain functions, the structure of the brain, the pathophysiology of the brain, like brain trauma, stroke, Alzheimer's disease, that sort of thing. So we tend to specialize not only in clinical psychology, but again, we can look at folks with neurologic disease as well.

Speaker 15 (04:54:40):

What additional training did you have to be a neuropsychologist?

Dr. Jason Demery (04:54:43):

So I completed predoctoral specialization at UF in the PhD program there. I also completed a postdoctoral fellowship in neuropsychology and I became board certified in the field of clinical neuropsychology in 2014.

Speaker 15 (04:55:00):

Do you belong to any organizations?

Dr. Jason Demery (04:55:02):

Yes. The American Psychological Association, the American Academy of Clinical Neuropsychology, and the American Board of Clinical Neuropsychology.

Speaker 15 (04:55:10):

Have you done any teaching at the University of Florida?

Dr. Jason Demery (04:55:12):

Yes, ma'am. I've been a clinical assistant professor in the Department of Clinical and Health Psychology over there at Shands Hospital, performing neuropsychological evaluations. I was also the assistant director of forensic psychology in the forensic psychiatry division in the College of Medicine. I would actually teach physicians about forensic psychological assessment and that sort of thing.

Speaker 15 (04:55:36):

During the course of your career, have you treated patients clinically?

Dr. Jason Demery (04:55:39):

Yes.

Speaker 15 (04:55:40):

Can you tell the jury about that?

Dr. Jason Demery (04:55:42):

Sure. I've treated hundreds of patients, if not thousands, to include the evaluation piece, but also the psychotherapeutic or counseling intervention that psychologists do. As a psychologist, I don't prescribe medication. I perform psychotherapy.

Speaker 15 (04:55:58):

And what do you do now on a daily basis?

Dr. Jason Demery (04:56:00):

Well, after nearly 30 years of practice, I'm in full-time medical legal work where I come to courtrooms and I explain mental health issues to the triers of fact, whether it be a jury or perhaps even a judge.

Speaker 15 (04:56:13):

Have you been permitted to give opinion testimony in court in the area of psychology before?

Dr. Jason Demery (04:56:17):

Yes, ma'am. I have.

Speaker 15 (04:56:18):

Approximately how many times?

Dr. Jason Demery (04:56:19):

Approximately 300 times.

Speaker 15 (04:56:22):

Your Honor, I would ask that the witness be allowed to give opinion testimony in the area of psychology.

Your Honor (04:56:25):

Any voir dire?

Speaker 14 (04:56:26):

No, your Honor.

Your Honor (04:56:27):

Okay. You can continue.

Speaker 15 (04:56:27):

Thank you, Judge. Did you do some work in this case, the State versus Dwayne Hall?

Dr. Jason Demery (04:56:32):

Yes, ma'am. I did. What were you asked to do? I was asked to research and potentially opine on the mental state of Ms. Exelby at the time of this unfortunate incident.

Speaker 15 (04:56:43):

All right. And what records did you review in this case? And besides records, other things as well.

Dr. Jason Demery (04:56:48):

So all of the NHS, the British, the UK medical records and mental health records stating as far back as 2006. In addition to that, I watched and listened to interviews with various family members and...

Dr. Jason Demery (04:57:00):

I watched and listened to interviews with various family members and friends. I conducted my own interview with Mr. Stevie Hunt, Ms. Exelby's fiance. I also looked at the investigative reports. I looked at crime scene photos. I listened to an interrogation that was quite lengthy. I also observed or watched a video of Ms. Exelby on a couch that was from an iPhone or a cell phone of some sort. I also looked at, again, some of the police investigative information and those sorts of things.

Amy Berndt (04:57:40):

Did you review a letter that appeared Ms. Exelby wrote from a plane?

Dr. Jason Demery (04:57:45):

Yes. It appears she drafted that on a plane. I also did look at Discord communications, Motherless communications, these sorts of things.

Amy Berndt (04:57:54):

All right. And were you able to review communications between Ms. Exelby and an Ari Petursson?

Dr. Jason Demery (04:57:58):

Yes, ma'am. I was.

Amy Berndt (04:58:00):

All right. Now, based on your review of the mental health records from the United Kingdom, when did Sonia first begin suffering from mental illness?

Dr. Jason Demery (04:58:08):

Well, according to the notes, it was 2006 when she was approximately 13 years old. She was first diagnosed with depressive disorder.

Amy Berndt (04:58:15):

All right. And at some point in her early teenage years, did she suffer from self-harm?

Dr. Jason Demery (04:58:21):

Yes.

Amy Berndt (04:58:22):

Okay. Can you tell us a little bit about that?

Dr. Jason Demery (04:58:23):

Yeah. So originally the self-harm, which is the intentional infliction of typically physical pain on oneself, it really began in the area of bulimia and anorexia, and then it morphed into cutting where she would intentionally cut her own skin. And again, these are forms of when a person attempts to seek emotional relief. It also included other forms of self-harm, including bloodletting where she would use a syringe and actually extract her own blood, so much so that she needed medical care on one occasion. There were also other indications of self-harm as well.

Amy Berndt (04:59:05):

And why does someone cut themselves?

Dr. Jason Demery (04:59:07):

So again, it's an immediate relief of the emotional or affective distress that a person is experiencing. One would rather experience the physical pain of tissue damage rather than the ongoing persistent and severe emotional stress that they're currently under. It actually gives an alleviation of that psychological stress despite it being painful.

Amy Berndt (04:59:32):

And are you familiar with Sonia's childhood based on your review of the interviews and the records?

Dr. Jason Demery (04:59:37):

Yes, ma'am. I am.

Amy Berndt (04:59:39):

All right. What can you tell us about that?

Dr. Jason Demery (04:59:40):

Well, she was born, unfortunately, in a situation where both her biological parents suffered from mental illness. They were adopted, the children were. And now Ms. Exelby, although her adoptive childhood was a positive experience for her, she did experience some childhood and even adolescent inappropriate sexual abuse exposure. And again, the mental health issues began when she was approximately 13 years old, around 2006 or so.

Amy Berndt (05:00:13):

Is self-harm commonly seen in teenagers who have a history of childhood trauma such as Sonia's?

Dr. Jason Demery (05:00:20):

Yes. It's a risk factor for that. Yes.

Amy Berndt (05:00:22):

And I think you've already said this, but both of Sonia's biological parents did suffer from mental illness?

Dr. Jason Demery (05:00:27):

Very much so, yes.

Amy Berndt (05:00:29):

Do many mental illnesses have a hereditary component?

Dr. Jason Demery (05:00:32):

Yes, they do. If your biological parents are mentally ill, it's just an increased chance of developing mental illness yourself.

Amy Berndt (05:00:40):

Did Sonia receive treatment or counseling for the cutting and the bulimia as a teenager?

Dr. Jason Demery (05:00:44):

Yes, she did. In fact, in talking with Mr. Hunt, he indicated that she had done reasonably well in terms of being able to manage the impulse to cut, but unfortunately she developed other sources of self-harm.

Amy Berndt (05:00:59):

And did she continue to struggle with her mental health issues as she got older?

Dr. Jason Demery (05:01:04):

Yes, she did. She continued to require both psychotherapeutic, that is talk therapy and pharmacomanagement or medication management, psychiatric medication.

Amy Berndt (05:01:15):

Would it be fair to say that Sonia had a longstanding history of mental illness?

Dr. Jason Demery (05:01:19):

Yes, ma'am. I would agree with that.

Amy Berndt (05:01:21):

And can you tell the jury what mental illnesses she suffered from?

Dr. Jason Demery (05:01:24):

Sure. So initially, again, it was bulimia, anorexia, emotionally unstable personality disorder is what one diagnosis was from the UK. So again, in a situation where a person has a very difficult time regulating their emotion, borderline personality disorder, which again is characterized by difficulty regulating negative emotion or negative affect. The depressive disorder, bipolar disorder, there was a cannabis use disorder at one point that was also diagnosed.

Amy Berndt (05:02:03):

How does the bipolar disorder affect a person?

Dr. Jason Demery (05:02:06):

Well, bipolar disorder is quite a serious mental illness, left untreated certainly, but it is characterized by changes in mood state where you have elevated mood followed by very low mood and cycles. And during that elevated mood, you might go days on end without any need for sleep. You might have mania. There could be some manifestation of irritability. Hypersexuality can be an element of that as well. But again, it's characterized by wide swings of mood between highs and lows.

Amy Berndt (05:02:38):

And you had mentioned that she suffered from borderline personality disorder. Is that a significant disorder, like bipolar disorder?

Dr. Jason Demery (05:02:45):

It's actually a characterological or personality disorder that's marked by an intense fear of abandonment and stormy relationships as a result of that. There's, again, the classic difficulty regulating one's emotions. So oftentimes will cry out for help engage in this suicidal or parasuicidal or self-injurious behavior. Very serious personality.

Amy Berndt (05:03:13):

Did Sonia attempt suicide?

Dr. Jason Demery (05:03:15):

Yes, ma'am. On at least two occasions. Two to three, depending upon on who you ask, but on two occasions it was associated with inpatient psychiatric care.

Amy Berndt (05:03:25):

How did she attempt suicide?

Dr. Jason Demery (05:03:27):

This was substance use overdose or substance overdose.

Amy Berndt (05:03:31):

And do you know around when those suicide attempts happened?

Dr. Jason Demery (05:03:34):

Yes, ma'am. 2014, 2015 timeframe.

Amy Berndt (05:03:39):

And did she receive counseling and therapy basically on and off for her whole adult life?

Dr. Jason Demery (05:03:43):

She did. She actually, again, had the medication management. She had psychotherapy. She had a very specific form of psychotherapy that was geared toward folks with this affective dysregulation problem that we see in borderline personality at times. She actually completed several sessions of that and she was up to do sort of a second phase of that type of treatment. I believe it was in the summer of 2025, but that never materialized.

Amy Berndt (05:04:13):

I want to focus in on Sonia's mental health during the two years or so preceding her murder. During that timeframe, did she begin communicating with some very violent people on online forums such as Discord sessions and Motherless?

Dr. Jason Demery (05:04:26):

Yes. It devolved into that, yes.

Amy Berndt (05:04:29):

All right. And have you had the opportunity to read some things from Discord, some records from Discord, people she was communicating with?

Dr. Jason Demery (05:04:37):

Yes, ma'am.

Amy Berndt (05:04:38):

All right. And based on your review of the records, did it appear Sonia was trying to find someone to kill her?

Dr. Jason Demery (05:04:43):

Yes.

Amy Berndt (05:04:45):

Were there some very sexually violent messages sent to Sonia from different men offering to kill her?

Dr. Jason Demery (05:04:49):

Yes.

Amy Berndt (05:04:51):

If someone suffers from self-harm, is it common for them to try to find other outlets once they actually stop doing the cutting, I think as you talked about earlier?

Dr. Jason Demery (05:05:00):

Yes. It's not atypical at all. And in this particular case, I think seeking out this sort of masochistic relationships, even if in talking with Mr. Hunt, he agreed that this was a sort of a substitute variation of self-harm as a substitute for things like the cutting and the bloodletting.

Amy Berndt (05:05:20):

So visiting these websites with these kind of violent sexual fantasies was kind of another outlet for her when she wasn't cutting?

Dr. Jason Demery (05:05:28):

That's correct.

Amy Berndt (05:05:31):

And Stevie had talked about a plan that he and Sonia's therapist had come up with where she had a good phone and a bad phone. Are you familiar with that?

Dr. Jason Demery (05:05:39):

Yes, ma'am.

Amy Berndt (05:05:40):

All right. And I believe she would be only allowed to get on these websites when she was on the bad phone and she was somewhat monitored by Stevie when she was on the bad phone?

Dr. Jason Demery (05:05:48):

That's correct. Chloe, the counselor, and Stevie did a very good job trying to put some bookends around her access to these online groups. They actually had a dedicated line where Stevie could control that much easier than her sort of in an unsupervised way on this other cell phone of hers. So they were doing everything that they could in an effort to kind of control the amount of exposure she had online. And there's a mantra in psychotherapy that you never blow up a bridge before you build a path to a new one. And this is what I think they were trying to do is they were trying to decrease the sort of unrestricted access to these groups that she had by adopting this two phone approach.

Amy Berndt (05:06:36):

Because basically you couldn't just cut her off from that, that would not work just with someone with Sonia's mental health issues.

Dr. Jason Demery (05:06:41):

That's exactly right.

Amy Berndt (05:06:42):

So you agree with the therapy that they were doing with the good phone and the bad phone?

Dr. Jason Demery (05:06:45):

Yes. I think that was a very reasonable thing to do at that point,

Amy Berndt (05:06:49):

Yes. And how does cutting or self-harm alleviate emotional distress?

Dr. Jason Demery (05:06:53):

So again, it's when a person is in such intense emotional distress, the actual intentional affliction or the intentional affliction of physical pain on yourself brings psychological relief to you. You identify with the physical pain, so the emotional pain actually lessens and it not only stops, it actually brings you a significant degree of relief. Over time, obviously that affective distress will start to come back, but there is at least a temporary, easy way to alleviate psychological distress by cutting.

Amy Berndt (05:07:35):

And during this time when she was communicating with these people, would you consider Sonia a mentally ill, vulnerable adult?

Dr. Jason Demery (05:07:41):

Yes. Her level of vulnerability I would say was exceptionally high.

Amy Berndt (05:07:45):

And was her decision making somewhat impaired during this time as well?

Dr. Jason Demery (05:07:48):

Yes, especially as it pertained to her suicide risk.

Amy Berndt (05:07:53):

And would her mental illness have been obvious to anyone who came into contact with her?

Dr. Jason Demery (05:07:58):

I don't think for folks that had brief periods of interaction with her would've noticed. In the work that I've done in this case, I've come to learn that she was a very beautiful person inside and out and she brought a lot of joy to a lot of different folks, but it was the longer you spent with her, the more time you spent with her, you could start to detect the presence of some of the emotional pain that she was suffering from.

Amy Berndt (05:08:24):

So she could pass as mentally stable for a short amount of time with someone maybe she just met or someone on the street?

Dr. Jason Demery (05:08:31):

Yes, ma'am. That's correct.

Amy Berndt (05:08:32):

So if someone had repeated contact with Sonia over the course of two years, it would be obvious that she was not capable of making rational decisions?

Dr. Jason Demery (05:08:39):

Over that period of time, yes.

Amy Berndt (05:08:41):

And would Sonia have been easily manipulated?

Dr. Jason Demery (05:08:44):

Yes. I think that speaks to her vulnerability, yes.

Amy Berndt (05:08:48):

And was she actually receiving treatment in the months preceding her murder?

Dr. Jason Demery (05:08:52):

She was. She was what we call lost to follow up in July of 2025. She had had several sessions where she did not present for her counseling sessions and that kind of psychological non-adherence to a treatment plan is not atypical with folks with mental illness. And unfortunately that was the case with her. She was lost to follow, but she had been prescribed medication all the way up until the time of this incident.

Amy Berndt (05:09:19):

So July of 2025, she had missed several scheduled appointments?

Dr. Jason Demery (05:09:22):

And she was dropped from the counseling program at that point, yes, with the opportunity certainly to return.

Amy Berndt (05:09:28):

And at the time Sonia was murdered, in your opinion, was she experiencing serious mental illness?

Dr. Jason Demery (05:09:33):

Yes, ma'am.

Amy Berndt (05:09:35):

Now we've heard that the defendant's username on Motherless was Alpha Sadist. From a psychological standpoint, what is a sadist?

Dr. Jason Demery (05:09:43):

Well, a sadist is a person who gains sexual satisfaction and gratification by intentionally inflicting physical or sexual pain onto somebody else and seeing that suffer.

Amy Berndt (05:09:56):

Thank you, doctor. I don't have any other questions.

Judge (05:09:58):

Any cross examination?

Junior Barrett (05:09:59):

Yes, Your Honor.

(05:10:05)
Good afternoon, Dr. Devery.

Dr. Jason Demery (05:10:05):

Good afternoon, sir.

Junior Barrett (05:10:09):

Okay. You indicated that if someone just had a brief interaction with her, they may not have noticed the extent of her mental illness, correct?

Dr. Jason Demery (05:10:23):

Yes, sir. That's correct.

Junior Barrett (05:10:26):

And the fact that someone is corresponding with her over two years, would that also depend on how often they would correspond?

Dr. Jason Demery (05:10:34):

Well, sure. I mean, if there was a significant period of time between correspondence, that's possible, yes. Obviously the frequency and the intensity of that communication gets above, yes.

Junior Barrett (05:10:45):

And could the way of the correspondence also make a difference by that? I mean, if I'm sitting or standing in front of someone and we're talking, I may be able to see signs of some kind of a mental illness as opposed to someone somewhere else typing something up.

Dr. Jason Demery (05:11:08):

I think that in this particular case, her mental illness is quite clear based on the correspondence that I've read, and I think that'd be clear to most anyone.

Junior Barrett (05:11:17):

Were these correspondence she had with Mr. Hall?

Dr. Jason Demery (05:11:21):

There were three, I believe, on Motherless that I saw between Mr. Hall and Ms. Exelby.

Junior Barrett (05:11:27):

And those three correspondence led you to believe that it would've been clear to him the extent of her mental illness?

Dr. Jason Demery (05:11:36):

I think that there are some indications. Obviously they had more communication, but I think that there should be some aspects of that that should strike a chord. Not only that, but the context in which the communication was occurring on that particular site, I think should raise a flag as well.

Junior Barrett (05:11:56):

Well, I'm more concerned with the ones that you reviewed. Do you recall what those correspondence actually were?

Dr. Jason Demery (05:12:02):

Yes.

Junior Barrett (05:12:02):

What was said in those correspondence?

Dr. Jason Demery (05:12:04):

Those were... The correspondence I saw were messages from Ms. Exelby to Mr. Hall indicating that it had been a while since they'd communicated and she was pleased that they were communicating again.

Junior Barrett (05:12:19):

And from reading those, you believe that Mr. Hall, the person on the other side, would be able to tell that she had some serious mental illness?

Dr. Jason Demery (05:12:29):

I think that there would be some potential clues, yes.

Junior Barrett (05:12:32):

From those three correspondence that you just told me?

Dr. Jason Demery (05:12:34):

If you look at the content of the three of those and the context in which that communication is occurring, I think it at least raises some issues.

Junior Barrett (05:12:43):

What's the context in which those three communications were occurring?

Dr. Jason Demery (05:12:47):

Well, this is a young lady, a young, vulnerable woman on a website that is discussing profoundly vile sexual behavior. And I think given what she said in that context, it raises a flag, frankly. It should.

Junior Barrett (05:13:09):

So is it your testimony that if you had set aside all the other information you have about her history, et cetera, just those three correspondence would've told you that she was young and vulnerable?

Dr. Jason Demery (05:13:23):

I think vulnerable, yes. She didn't say her age, obviously, but I know what her age was.

Junior Barrett (05:13:29):

And again, from just those correspondence...

Dr. Jason Demery (05:13:31):

Well, I think her vulnerability shines through. Her age does not though.

Junior Barrett (05:13:34):

Okay. And part of the diagnosis that she had was bipolar, correct?

Dr. Jason Demery (05:13:47):

Yes, sir.

Junior Barrett (05:13:47):

What does that mean?

Dr. Jason Demery (05:13:49):

Two poles, literally.

Junior Barrett (05:13:50):

Means one point she may be what? Good? One point bad in terms of the disease?

Dr. Jason Demery (05:13:56):

I don't think in good and bad.

Junior Barrett (05:13:58):

Okay.

Dr. Jason Demery (05:13:58):

I think of depressed and happy, yes. So her mood would fluctuate from extremes so much so that she may have mania and then she may experience periods of depression.

Junior Barrett (05:14:11):

And the periods from one stage to another, could that be lengthy in the sense that could it be days, weeks before she goes from one to the other?

Dr. Jason Demery (05:14:27):

Yes. Yes, it could.

Junior Barrett (05:14:29):

Okay. So if she's in that good stage and you're corresponding with her during that good stage, you would not necessarily notice that there was a problem there, correct?

Dr. Jason Demery (05:14:38):

I don't know what the good stage would be. Could you clarify that?

Junior Barrett (05:14:42):

Going back to where you said it, you said it's mood changes. There's one mood where she, I would imagine... Let me let you do it as opposed to me imagining. The two stages again were what?

Dr. Jason Demery (05:14:54):

Mania and depression.

Junior Barrett (05:14:55):

Depression?

Dr. Jason Demery (05:14:56):

Yeah.

Junior Barrett (05:14:56):

Okay. And are you saying that at all times she would have the mania and if not mania and depression, there was no time where she would have been essentially left off where she can communicate without any signs of any kind of problems or mental illness?

Dr. Jason Demery (05:15:12):

I think if you look at the totality of the communications, it's pretty clear across the board. However, there are individual messages here and there that appear reasonably written from a stable person.

Junior Barrett (05:15:24):

Okay. You talking about totality of communications. You mean that she had on that website?

Dr. Jason Demery (05:15:30):

Yes. I'm sorry if you're referring to just the three Motherless communications.

Junior Barrett (05:15:33):

I'm talking about the ones with her, with Mrs. Hall.

Dr. Jason Demery (05:15:36):

Okay. Okay.

Junior Barrett (05:15:38):

So from those three with Mr. Hall, it is your opinion, your expert opinion, that it would've been clear to him that she was bipolar and had all these issues associated with-

Dr. Jason Demery (05:15:52):

I don't think the bipolar diagnosis would necessarily come through. In my opinion, I think it does show some vulnerability as a red flag.

Junior Barrett (05:16:03):

Someone being vulnerable, is that always a mental health issue?

Dr. Jason Demery (05:16:07):

No.

Junior Barrett (05:16:08):

Okay.

Dr. Jason Demery (05:16:10):

Just in this case.

Junior Barrett (05:16:12):

And again, that's based upon the total document and information you have been provided, correct?

Dr. Jason Demery (05:16:21):

Ms. Exelby was a highly vulnerable adult.

Junior Barrett (05:16:23):

Based upon all the information you were provided and was able to review?

Dr. Jason Demery (05:16:27):

Well, based on the totality of information that I've reviewed, she was a highly vulnerable, mentally ill adult female.

Junior Barrett (05:16:34):

Okay. I believe you said that part of what you reviewed suggested to you or showed to you that she was looking for someone to take her life.

Dr. Jason Demery (05:16:58):

There were indications of that in other chats, yes.

Junior Barrett (05:17:01):

Okay. Was that one of those communications you saw she had with Mr. Hall?

Dr. Jason Demery (05:17:05):

No.

Junior Barrett (05:17:06):

Okay. And from her history, she was capable of harming herself, correct?

Dr. Jason Demery (05:17:17):

Yes.

Junior Barrett (05:17:19):

Were you also shown photograph of her with a knife or some kind held to her own throat, I believe?

Dr. Jason Demery (05:17:25):

Yes, sir.

Junior Barrett (05:17:26):

Okay. Was there anyone else in the background of that photograph that you saw?

Dr. Jason Demery (05:17:30):

No.

Junior Barrett (05:17:46):

And again, from the document you reviewed, you came to the opinion that when she left the UK to come to the US, the intent was for her essentially die, correct?

Dr. Jason Demery (05:17:58):

I think she was conflicted and I think she was ambivalent about it. She went back and forth. She was fearful and she was scared. She didn't know for sure if she was going to follow through with it or not.

Junior Barrett (05:18:13):

But again, based upon the information you reviewed, part of her getting upset was the fact that she didn't realize that dying would take that long, correct?

Dr. Jason Demery (05:18:24):

When you say-

Junior Barrett (05:18:24):

That her dying or being killed would take that long. That was part of what affected her moods, correct?

Dr. Jason Demery (05:18:33):

Well, I would agree with the first part of what you said. She was curious as to why her death did not occur more...

Junior Barrett (05:18:41):

More quickly.

Dr. Jason Demery (05:18:42):

Yes.

Junior Barrett (05:18:43):

Okay. And again, from the documents you reviewed, she was capable of obviously booking a home flight, correct?

Dr. Jason Demery (05:19:03):

Yes, sir.

Junior Barrett (05:19:04):

Capable of doing day-to-day activities prior to her coming to the US, correct?

Dr. Jason Demery (05:19:09):

In terms of her basic self-care, yes.

Junior Barrett (05:19:11):

Basic self-care. And you said you spoke to her boyfriend/fiance?

Dr. Jason Demery (05:19:17):

Yes.

Junior Barrett (05:19:18):

Did he tell you that at least for the days leading up to her trauma, she was in a great mood?

Dr. Jason Demery (05:19:23):

He did say that. I think that's a little bit contrasted with the actual WhatsApp communications with another individual, but yes, he did say that.

Junior Barrett (05:19:32):

But he's the one that lived with her, right?

Dr. Jason Demery (05:19:33):

Yes.

Junior Barrett (05:19:34):

He's the one that sees her every day?

Dr. Jason Demery (05:19:36):

Yes.

Junior Barrett (05:19:36):

And he's the one that told you she was in a great mood then, correct?

Dr. Jason Demery (05:19:40):

I don't recall if you used the term great mood, but-

Junior Barrett (05:19:42):

Well, she was in a good mood.

Dr. Jason Demery (05:19:43):

Yes.

Junior Barrett (05:19:43):

And he's the one that also made the arrangement for her to meet with an expert, correct?

Dr. Jason Demery (05:19:48):

In terms of a therapist?

Junior Barrett (05:19:49):

Therapist.

Dr. Jason Demery (05:19:51):

I don't know if he made the arrangements, but he would certainly go to her appointments and sit in the waiting room, yes. He was an active participant in getting care for her.

Junior Barrett (05:20:01):

When you make diagnosis for someone or about someone, you take into consideration any reports filed, any evaluation that's been done, correct?

Dr. Jason Demery (05:20:12):

Yes.

Junior Barrett (05:20:12):

You also speak to whoever the evaluator is, correct?

Dr. Jason Demery (05:20:17):

Well, I would... I mean, I would be the evaluator in that context if you're saying... Would consult with another doctor perhaps that had seen a particular person?

Junior Barrett (05:20:25):

I'm talking about whether or not you would consult with someone who have had a history of speaking to this young lady.

Dr. Jason Demery (05:20:32):

I might. It just depends on how extensive their notes were. If it's quite clear in notes, then there may or may not be a need to do that.

Junior Barrett (05:20:39):

She was... To your knowledge, was she just seeing one therapist?

Dr. Jason Demery (05:20:42):

No, sir. No.

Junior Barrett (05:20:43):

Okay. How many of the therapists she was seeing did you actually speak to?

Dr. Jason Demery (05:20:47):

I didn't speak to any. I just read the records that the therapist wrote.

Junior Barrett (05:20:50):

How many of the therapists that she was seeing did you actually make an attempt to speak to?

Dr. Jason Demery (05:20:55):

I didn't make an attempt to speak to any of them. Again, I had their notes.

Junior Barrett (05:21:00):

And you didn't find it necessary to speak to the therapist? The notes were sufficient to you?

Dr. Jason Demery (05:21:06):

That's correct, yes.

Junior Barrett (05:21:07):

Okay. When was the last note in terms of her treatment?

Dr. Jason Demery (05:21:14):

July or August, I believe, of 2025. Again, they were related to the issue of her not attending therapy. There were actual notes on 10/12, and then in about a week or so following that, that's just simply documenting the fact that she had disappeared and there was concern, but those weren't... I wouldn't consider those treatment notes per se.

Junior Barrett (05:21:37):

Did you talk to her fiance to see whether or not she had seen anyone since that July date that's in the notes as to the last time she actually went to this agency for treatment?

Dr. Jason Demery (05:21:51):

I believe we did discuss that, yeah.

Junior Barrett (05:21:53):

Did you tell her whether or not she had?

Dr. Jason Demery (05:21:55):

I believe that she hadn't, no, but she was lost to follow up, but invited to return when she was ready to attend therapy. Sometimes therapy can be very painful for folks.

Junior Barrett (05:22:04):

And that was from the notes you read, correct?

Dr. Jason Demery (05:22:06):

Yes. Yes.

Junior Barrett (05:22:07):

Did he actually tell you that that was the last time she actually saw someone?

Dr. Jason Demery (05:22:12):

I don't recall if he actually said that or not. I had the notes, so I knew.

Junior Barrett (05:22:19):

And you didn't think it necessary to see whether or not there was more information that may not have been the notes that you could have gotten from someone who see this woman on a daily basis, well, during the therapist, see her more often than you came in?

Dr. Jason Demery (05:22:34):

Well, I had the notes from the therapist that was working with her, and I interviewed the fiance that was with her daily. I felt that was sufficient. By the way, I didn't make a diagnosis, by the way, of her. I'm simply here to articulate the diagnoses from the NHS record.

Junior Barrett (05:22:50):

Yeah, but the NHS record wouldn't tell you what kind of mental state she was in when she came to the US, correct?

Dr. Jason Demery (05:22:56):

Correct. That's correct.

Junior Barrett (05:22:57):

But you told the jury that when she came to the... Didn't you address that issue?

Dr. Jason Demery (05:23:01):

Yes.

Junior Barrett (05:23:03):

Okay. And that couldn't have come from the notes because again, the notes didn't go that far forward, correct?

Dr. Jason Demery (05:23:08):

Correct.

Junior Barrett (05:23:10):

And you obviously hadn't met with her personally, correct?

Dr. Jason Demery (05:23:13):

That's correct. I just read the correspondence between herself on WhatsApp, proximate to the actual incident on the 12th, the 10th, 11th, and 12th. Frankly, all those communications are available.

Junior Barrett (05:23:28):

And the last time family and friends had interaction with her, she was in a good mood.

Dr. Jason Demery (05:23:36):

I believe that's what was testified to, yes.

Junior Barrett (05:23:39):

Okay. I don't have any more. [inaudible 05:23:41].

Judge (05:23:40):

Any redirect?

Amy Berndt (05:23:43):

Is it common for people that are suicidal and they believe that that's going to happen relatively soon to be in a good mood or happier than they would've been? Can you tell us about that?

Dr. Jason Demery (05:23:54):

Yes, that's sort of classic. There's final resolution, if you will, to one's life. But again, there is some conflicting, I think, information because she clearly was distressed in her correspondence to, I believe it was Ari, on the 10th, 11th, and 12th of October 2025.

Amy Berndt (05:24:11):

And so you had that letter that she wrote to Ari as well as the letter she wrote on the Friday, October 10th from the plane where she was talking about having some conflicted feelings and being scared?

Dr. Jason Demery (05:24:22):

Yes.

Amy Berndt (05:24:22):

Okay.

Dr. Jason Demery (05:24:22):

She was highly conflicted, in my opinion.

Amy Berndt (05:24:24):

All right. And you're basing your opinion on those actual letters that she wrote that you read?

Dr. Jason Demery (05:24:28):

Yes. The power of that material is that it's proximate to the incident itself. And to me, I weigh that heavily in my opinion.

Amy Berndt (05:24:40):

And even though the notes didn't go all the way up to October of 2025, do things like bipolar disorder and borderline personality disorder just disappear and she was fine in October? Does that happen?

Dr. Jason Demery (05:24:54):

No, it does not happen that way.

Amy Berndt (05:24:58):

All right. Mr. Barrett asked you a lot about whether Mr. Hall would've known the extent to which she was mentally ill. You didn't base anything you've testified on just on those three correspondence between them on Motherless?

Dr. Jason Demery (05:25:12):

No, I have not.

Amy Berndt (05:25:13):

Okay. You actually watched the over four-hour interview that the defendant did with Special Agent Rebecca McKenzie?

Dr. Jason Demery (05:25:20):

Yes, I watched it two or three times.

Amy Berndt (05:25:21):

Okay. And in that interview, did the defendant admit that he knew Sonia was seeking out people to kill her?

Dr. Jason Demery (05:25:31):

Yes.

Amy Berndt (05:25:32):

Okay. Did he actually admit that he knew she had paid other men and that they had taken advantage of her and not killed her?

Dr. Jason Demery (05:25:39):

Yes.

Amy Berndt (05:25:40):

Okay. So would it be fair to say that he was well aware that she was seeking out many different men to kill her?

Dr. Jason Demery (05:25:45):

Yes.

Amy Berndt (05:25:45):

Okay. As well as she came here to be killed by him?

Dr. Jason Demery (05:25:50):

Yes.

Amy Berndt (05:25:51):

Okay. So does that take into account the fact that somebody that had that much correspondence with her that knew those details would know that she was mentally ill?

Dr. Jason Demery (05:26:00):

You certainly would expect that, yes.

Amy Berndt (05:26:02):

Thank you. I don't have any other questions.

Judge (05:26:03):

Any recross examination?

Junior Barrett (05:26:05):

No, Your Honor.

Judge (05:26:05):

Members of the jury, do any of y'all have questions of this witness? If you do, please raise your hand. Okay. Go ahead and write your questions down on a clean sheet of paper verbatim unless you would like me to read them to the witness. Lawyers, if y'all can approach. We've got two. Any others coming by a show of hands? I'm going to put on the white noise, ladies and gentlemen.

‍

(05:27:20)
Dr. Devery, the jury has posed two questions to you. I will read them to you. You can answer it to them. The first question is, I'll read it verbatim. If someone stopped the medication for mental illness, does it affect a person's behavior to get it worse? What advice should you recommend?

Dr. Jason Demery (05:28:10):

Well, if somebody does stop taking their medication, it depends what kind of medication they were taking. They could have some pretty significant side effects acutely or early on. We certainly would encourage folks to continue taking medication. Their symptoms could come back in the weeks after spontaneously stopping medication. Again, some medications are fast acting and so the effects may be seen shortly, but other medications that may take quite some time. So of course my recommendation would be a combination of continued medication management adherence coupled with individual or group psychotherapy.

Judge (05:28:50):

Okay. And the next question is, could the fact that Sonia booked a round trip ticket for the trip show she was not completely committed to ending her life?

Dr. Jason Demery (05:28:58):

I think that certainly could be deduced from her decision, her intent there with a round trip ticket. There's also ample other evidence, in my opinion, that speaks to her ambivalence and her conflicted nature of what was actually going to happen.

Judge (05:29:18):

State, do you have any follow up?

Amy Berndt (05:29:19):

No, your Honor.

Judge (05:29:19):

Defense, any follow up?

Junior Barrett (05:29:20):

Yes, Judge. Do you know whether or not she had stopped taking her medication?

Dr. Jason Demery (05:29:28):

I do not.

Junior Barrett (05:29:28):

Okay. Now as to the second question, you said you did speak to the boyfriend, correct?

Dr. Jason Demery (05:29:38):

Mr. Hunt, yes.

Junior Barrett (05:29:39):

And I believe at least one sister. Did you speak to another sister?

Dr. Jason Demery (05:29:43):

I listened to the interviews.

Junior Barrett (05:29:45):

Okay.

Dr. Jason Demery (05:29:45):

Yes.

Junior Barrett (05:29:46):

And so part of what you learned is that she had told them that she was going to meet with them that weekend, correct? There was supposed to be a gathering of the sisters. Were you aware of that?

Dr. Jason Demery (05:29:56):

Going to meet with the sisters that weekend?

Junior Barrett (05:29:58):

Correct.

Dr. Jason Demery (05:29:59):

That's correct, yes.

Junior Barrett (05:30:00):

Okay. And so the fact that she booked a return-

Junior Barrett (05:30:01):

And so the fact that she booked a return ticket doesn't necessarily mean that she had intended on returning. That could be also part of her not wanting the family to know what she intended on doing, correct?

Dr. Jason Demery (05:30:13):

I think the intent to return to England speaks for itself.

Junior Barrett (05:30:17):

Let me try the question again. Let's talk about the ticket itself also. Well, before I get to that, when you say "speaks for itself," what do you mean by that?

Dr. Jason Demery (05:30:26):

I think it shows there's intent to come back on a return flight.

Junior Barrett (05:30:32):

The fact that she booked a return flight to you shows she intended to make it back?

Dr. Jason Demery (05:30:37):

Especially in the context of her ambivalence and conflict, yes.

Junior Barrett (05:30:41):

And the ambivalence started when she was on the plane, that's when she did this letter, right?

Dr. Jason Demery (05:30:45):

She was ambivalent and conflicted for a long period of time based on the correspondence that I read about if she was going to follow through with this, to include the day or two before this actually happened.

Junior Barrett (05:30:57):

Tell us which correspondence you read where she said that she was ambivalent about coming to the U.S.

Dr. Jason Demery (05:31:02):

She didn't use the word ambivalent, but it's all throughout the WhatsApp communications with Ari-

Junior Barrett (05:31:08):

With who?

Dr. Jason Demery (05:31:10):

It's throughout the communications.

Junior Barrett (05:31:13):

With who?

Dr. Jason Demery (05:31:14):

Ari.

Junior Barrett (05:31:15):

With Ari?

Dr. Jason Demery (05:31:15):

Yes.

Junior Barrett (05:31:16):

Okay. When was the last correspondence she had? Do you recall?

Dr. Jason Demery (05:31:21):

With Ari?

Junior Barrett (05:31:21):

The date, yes.

Dr. Jason Demery (05:31:23):

10/12, I believe. 10/12, the Sunday morning. Early, 05 something, I believe.

Junior Barrett (05:31:29):

Do you know what time the flight was?

Dr. Jason Demery (05:31:32):

On Sunday?

Junior Barrett (05:31:33):

No, when she actually came to the U.S.

Dr. Jason Demery (05:31:34):

Yes, on Friday.

Junior Barrett (05:31:36):

What was the date of that?

Dr. Jason Demery (05:31:37):

10/10.

Junior Barrett (05:31:38):

Okay. So we're talking about the booking of the ticket, which would've occurred obviously before she got on the plane, correct?

Dr. Jason Demery (05:31:46):

I would agree with you, yes.

Junior Barrett (05:31:47):

So the fact that after she got to the U.S., she may have been ambivalent. How does that speak to the fact that when she booked a round trip ticket, she had intended on going back to the UK?

Dr. Jason Demery (05:32:01):

Well, the booking of a two-way round trip ticket, in my opinion, implies an intent to potentially, at least, be on a flight back to the UK. Otherwise, she would've purchased a one-way ticket. Now, I think she was ambivalent for quite some time to include all the way up to the morning of this incident.

Junior Barrett (05:32:23):

Okay. Let's focus on the question I'm asking [inaudible 05:32:27]. Okay.

(05:32:28)
This ticket was purchased sometime in September, the month before.

Dr. Jason Demery (05:32:32):

Yes.

Junior Barrett (05:32:32):

You're aware of that?

Dr. Jason Demery (05:32:33):

Yes.

Junior Barrett (05:32:33):

Okay. If you are coming from another country like the UK, I'm sure you're aware there's no visa requirement to travel from the UK to the U.S., correct?

Dr. Jason Demery (05:32:47):

Sure.

Junior Barrett (05:32:48):

But there is a requirement in terms of residency in the U.S. Do you know, and again, if you don't know, that's fine. Would you need some kind of paperwork to be legally in the U.S?

Dr. Jason Demery (05:33:00):

I don't know the answer to that, sir.

Junior Barrett (05:33:01):

Okay. If someone intended to take their life or to have their life taken, but don't want the family to know, wouldn't it be reasonable that that person may do things that the family wouldn't realize what their intent were?

Dr. Jason Demery (05:33:16):

Yes.

Junior Barrett (05:33:17):

One of those things that a person could do is buy a round trip ticket even though they don't intend on making it back.

Dr. Jason Demery (05:33:24):

It's possible, yes.

Junior Barrett (05:33:25):

One of the reasons to indicate that it is your intent not to go back is to get upset when you're not dying as soon as you thought you would, when your life is not being taken as soon as you thought it would. Do you understand what I'm asking?

Dr. Jason Demery (05:33:41):

No, sir. I don't.

Junior Barrett (05:33:42):

Okay. Let me try that a different way. Part of what we discussed and part of what you would've reviewed was some correspondence where she said she was, I guess, upset about how long it was taking for her to die, correct?

Dr. Jason Demery (05:33:56):

Well, I think that she didn't expect to have a line to the outside, is the verbiage she actually said. I don't recall there being a lot of upsettiness associated with that, but she said that it's taking longer than she otherwise thought.

Junior Barrett (05:34:17):

Again, it taking longer, is her dying? Isn't that what was intended?

Dr. Jason Demery (05:34:24):

I think that's a fair position to take, yes.

Junior Barrett (05:34:29):

Okay. So wouldn't that indicate that when she came to the U.S., she did not intend on making it back because she came with intent of dying in the U.S., but it was taking longer than she had anticipated?

Dr. Jason Demery (05:34:41):

I don't agree with that, no. Her ambivalence far outweighs a clear plan in my opinion.

Junior Barrett (05:34:46):

Okay. I don't have any questions [inaudible 05:34:46].

Judge (05:34:46):

Any examination?

Amy Berndt (05:34:46):

I just have one question, Judge. Mr. Barrett's insinuating that she maybe bought the round trip taken to trip her family. But isn't it true that her family never knew that she even booked a ticket until after she was already dead?

Dr. Jason Demery (05:35:05):

That is true.

Amy Berndt (05:35:05):

So she would never need to buy a return trip ticket, so her family didn't find out?

Dr. Jason Demery (05:35:09):

That's correct.

Amy Berndt (05:35:09):

She could have just bought the one-way ticket.

Dr. Jason Demery (05:35:11):

Correct.

Amy Berndt (05:35:11):

I don't have any other questions.

Judge (05:35:12):

Any other questions, Mr. Barrett?

Junior Barrett (05:35:14):

No, Judge.

Judge (05:35:14):

Members of the jury, any of y'all have any additional questions of this witness? If you do, please raise your hand. Okay. Go ahead and write your question down on the blank piece of paper [inaudible 05:35:22].

Junior Barrett (05:35:18):

She didn't understand that.

Speaker X (05:35:18):

[inaudible 05:36:16].

Judge (05:36:40):

Doctor, the jury's posed another question. I'll read it to you again verbatim as I have written it.

Dr. Jason Demery (05:36:44):

Yes, sir.

Judge (05:36:45):

Could the fact that it was taking longer been upsetting to her because of the extra unexpected suffering being inflicted in the meantime versus quick and painless?

Dr. Jason Demery (05:36:54):

It's certainly possible. I think that she obviously had this Airbnb with a checkout date of Sunday. So I saw no indication that there was a clear plan for this incident to meet its final conclusion on Saturday as opposed to Sunday. But it's possible that her mental and emotional state, perhaps fueled in part by her physical abuse that she had experienced on Friday night, apparently, could have been making it seem as though that it was taking a lot longer than she expected.

Judge (05:37:36):

State, any follow up?

Amy Berndt (05:37:37):

No follow up, your Honor.

Judge (05:37:38):

Mr. Barrett, any follow up?

Junior Barrett (05:37:39):

No, Judge.

Judge (05:37:40):

Members of the jury, any additional questions? If so, please raise your hands. Okay. Seeing no hands, this witness released, State?

Amy Berndt (05:37:46):

Yes. We'd ask that you be excused.

Junior Barrett (05:37:47):

No objection, Judge.

Judge (05:37:50):

Okay. Sir, you're free to go back to your day. Thank you for your time.

Dr. Jason Demery (05:37:52):

Thank you, sir.

Judge (05:37:52):

Members of the jury, we've been back from lunch for about an hour. Anybody here feel like they need a break in the jury box? I see no hands. State, you can call your next witness.

Mr. Buxman (05:38:00):

State calls Dr. Rachel Lange.

Judge (05:38:04):

Is Dr. Lange in the hallway or the back hallway?

Speaker X (05:38:05):

[inaudible 05:38:06].

Amy Berndt (05:38:05):

[inaudible 05:38:06], is Dr. Lange in the back?

Speaker 16 (05:38:05):

Yes. She's here.

Amy Berndt (05:38:05):

She's in the back.

Mr. Buxman (05:38:06):

She's in the back, Your Honor.

Judge (05:38:06):

Come on up, ma'am. If you could raise your right hand, face the clerk to be placed under oath.

Speaker 17 (05:39:08):

Do you swear or affirm the testimony you're about to give will be the truth, the whole truth, and nothing but the truth, so help you God?

Dr. Rachel Lange (05:39:08):

I do.

Judge (05:39:09):

You go ahead, ma'am. Be seated.

Mr. Buxman (05:39:11):

Thank you, Your Honor.

Judge (05:39:12):

Would you like me, Mr. Buxman, now to read the stipulation?

Mr. Buxman (05:39:14):

Yes, sir.

Judge (05:39:16):

Ladies and gentlemen, when lawyers and parties agree that certain facts are true, that is called a stipulation of fact. You must accept stipulated facts as having been proven. However, the significance of these facts, as with all facts, is for you to decide. In this case, the stipulated facts that you must accept as true is as follows. The state and the defendant have stipulated that the identity of the deceased in this case is Sonia Exelby. As a result of this stipulation, you may consider that fact proven beyond a reasonable doubt. Signed Amy Berndt, Assistant State Attorney, Junior Barrett, attorney for the defendant, and Dwayne Hall, defendant.

Mr. Buxman (05:39:52):

Thank you, Your Honor. Good afternoon, doctor.

Dr. Rachel Lange (05:39:54):

Good afternoon.

Mr. Buxman (05:39:56):

Would you please introduce yourself to the jury?

Dr. Rachel Lange (05:39:58):

Yes. I'm Dr. Rachel Lange. That's R-A-C-H-E-L L-A-N-G-E. I'm an associate medical examiner with the District 5 Medical Examiner's Office.

Mr. Buxman (05:40:09):

And what do you do as an associate medical examiner?

Dr. Rachel Lange (05:40:11):

My primary job is to determine the cause and manner of death, which I do by performing autopsies, and when appropriate ancillary studies like toxicology.

Mr. Buxman (05:40:21):

Can you explain for the jury your educational background, your training, and your experience that allows you to do this job?

Dr. Rachel Lange (05:40:26):

Yes. I'm a medical doctor. I got my medical degree at the University of Miami in Miami, Florida. I did residency training in the field of pathology at Mount Sinai Hospital in New York, followed by fellowship training in forensic pathology at the Office of Chief Medical Examiner of the City of New York.

Mr. Buxman (05:40:44):

And how long have you been a medical examiner?

Dr. Rachel Lange (05:40:47):

Over 15 years.

Mr. Buxman (05:40:49):

Does your work as a medical examiner include the performance of autopsies?

Dr. Rachel Lange (05:40:52):

Yes.

Mr. Buxman (05:40:53):

What is an autopsy?

Dr. Rachel Lange (05:40:54):

An autopsy is an examination performed on the body after death, which typically consists of an external examination of the body, followed by an internal examination where an incision is made on the body so that the organs can be viewed.

Mr. Buxman (05:41:07):

Can you estimate about how many autopsies you've done in your career?

Dr. Rachel Lange (05:41:11):

Conservatively, a few thousand.

Mr. Buxman (05:41:12):

All right. You used the term pathology or pathologist. What is pathology?

Dr. Rachel Lange (05:41:17):

Pathology is a field of medicine, the definition of which is the study of disease. This is the field where we look at either laboratory tests like blood tests or biopsies of tissues, or in the case of an autopsy, the entire body to determine disease processes or in what I do, injuries.

Mr. Buxman (05:41:36):

And what does forensic pathology mean?

Dr. Rachel Lange (05:41:39):

Forensic pathology is a extra specialization in the field of pathology in which we take our pathological findings and apply them to matters of the courtroom like we are today, for example.

Mr. Buxman (05:41:51):

Have you in your career been permitted to give opinion testimony in court in the area of forensic pathology?

Dr. Rachel Lange (05:41:56):

Yes.

Mr. Buxman (05:41:57):

Can you estimate about how many times?

Dr. Rachel Lange (05:41:58):

A few dozen times.

Mr. Buxman (05:42:00):

At this time, Your Honor, I'd request permission to allow this witness to provide opinion testimony in the area of forensic pathology.

Judge (05:42:05):

Any voir dire?

Junior Barrett (05:42:06):

No, Your Honor.

Dr. Jason Demery (05:42:06):

Okay. You can continue.

Mr. Buxman (05:42:09):

Did you and your office become involved with an autopsy performed on Sonia Exelby?

Dr. Rachel Lange (05:42:15):

Yes.

Mr. Buxman (05:42:15):

Now, is it common for a medical examiner/investigator from your office to go out to the scene where a body is located?

Dr. Rachel Lange (05:42:23):

Yes.

Mr. Buxman (05:42:24):

And where was Ms. Exelby's body located based on your information?

Dr. Rachel Lange (05:42:28):

It was located in Marion County, Florida in Ocala.

Mr. Buxman (05:42:31):

Okay. And is that why, because the grave site was located in Marion County, why it comes into your jurisdiction?

Dr. Rachel Lange (05:42:38):

Yes. My office covers six different counties in Florida, so they all come to my office, which is in Leesburg, Florida in Lake County.

Mr. Buxman (05:42:45):

And one of those counties is obviously Marion?

Dr. Rachel Lange (05:42:47):

Yes.

Mr. Buxman (05:42:47):

Understood. Can you explain to the jury how somebody's body comes from the scene to the medical examiner's office? What's the process?

Dr. Rachel Lange (05:43:03):

Yes. So an investigator from our office, as you mentioned, is generally present at the scene to document everything at the scene. And then under his or her supervision, the body is sealed in a body bag and is transported to our office by, basically, in a sealed bag to preserve evidence. And then it is brought out at the time of autopsy in our office in the morgue.

Mr. Buxman (05:43:30):

Okay. And how old was Sonia Exelby at the time of your autopsy?

Dr. Rachel Lange (05:43:34):

She was 32 years old.

Mr. Buxman (05:43:35):

How tall was she?

Dr. Rachel Lange (05:43:35):

Let me refresh my memories. She was 5'8".

Mr. Buxman (05:43:42):

And how much did she weigh?

Dr. Rachel Lange (05:43:44):

157 pounds.

Mr. Buxman (05:43:46):

In what condition did her body arrive at the medical examiner's office? I know you said she was in a body bag, but was she clothed, things like that?

Dr. Rachel Lange (05:43:53):

Yes. Her clothing had been removed already by law enforcement when she came to our office.

Mr. Buxman (05:44:02):

Okay. Was she in some degree of decomposition?

Dr. Rachel Lange (05:44:08):

Yes.

Mr. Buxman (05:44:09):

Okay. First, can you explain to the jury what decomposition is?

Dr. Rachel Lange (05:44:12):

Yes. After death, the body goes through a number of physical and chemical changes. Once our body is no longer actively able to keep bacteria in check and keep our cells intact as things start to break apart, the body goes through decomposition. It's a predictable stage of changes that the body goes through until ultimately is a skeleton.

Mr. Buxman (05:44:39):

And what degree of decomposition was Ms. Exelby's body in when it arrived and you did your autopsy?

Dr. Rachel Lange (05:44:46):

She was in an earlier stage of decomposition.

Mr. Buxman (05:44:49):

And what kind of signs would be indicative of early stages decomposition?

Dr. Rachel Lange (05:44:54):

Yes. So she had already gone through the initial phases of things that many of you may have heard of, like rigor mortis, which is the stiffening of the body after death or liver mortis, which is the way the blood settles. She'd already passed through those things and starting to see the next phase where we typically see color changes in the body and the skin getting loose and slipping, the hair slipping off, bloating, things like that.

Mr. Buxman (05:45:18):

And what kind of color changes would the body undergo during this decomposition process?

Dr. Rachel Lange (05:45:23):

Generally, when the body starts to decompose, we see green discoloration followed by reddish to purple discoloration. It's somewhat objective, obviously.

Mr. Buxman (05:45:34):

Are you able to, when doing an autopsy on a body that has gone through that early stage of decomposition, the decoloration changes, are you able to tell the difference between a bruise or an injury in the natural decomposition process?

Dr. Rachel Lange (05:45:49):

Sometimes you can, and other times the decomposition process can make interpretation of injuries more difficult.

Mr. Buxman (05:45:56):

Did you locate any, what you categorize as, bruising on her body?

Dr. Rachel Lange (05:46:01):

Yes.

Mr. Buxman (05:46:02):

Where were those?

Dr. Rachel Lange (05:46:07):

She had a number of areas of discoloration on her skin, some of which are, in my opinion, consistent with bruises, specifically on her left buttock. And there were other areas of red discoloration around the breasts and on the abdomen, on the back, which may represent injuries, but could be affected by decomposition changes. Those were less obvious.

Mr. Buxman (05:46:35):

Are you able to tell how long prior to her death the bruises were inflicted?

Dr. Rachel Lange (05:46:41):

No.

Mr. Buxman (05:46:41):

Why not?

Dr. Rachel Lange (05:46:44):

In general, even in a body that hasn't been decomposed, dating a bruising is very difficult. As you probably know from having bruises yourselves, they look different, first of all, depending on what part of the body you're on and what color your skin is. And the way that they change colors as they age is variable. So it's already very difficult to date bruises. And then if you add in the changes of the color changes that go along with decomposition, it's very, very difficult to date a bruise.

Mr. Buxman (05:47:13):

I'm assuming the bruising that you saw when you described her left buttock, did that have any involvement or any contributor to the cause of her death in any way?

Dr. Rachel Lange (05:47:21):

No.

Mr. Buxman (05:47:21):

Okay. Did you see any signs of strangulation?

Dr. Rachel Lange (05:47:24):

No.

Mr. Buxman (05:47:25):

Okay. What type of things would you look for?

Dr. Rachel Lange (05:47:28):

The typical things we would see with strangulation are marks on the outside of the neck, either from hands or ligatures or anything else that used to compress the neck. Also externally, we may see dots in the linings of the eyes. Those are called petechiae. And internally we look for damage to the structures of the neck, like hemorrhages in the neck, muscles or fractures of the structures of the neck, like the hyoid bone or the thyroid cartilage.

Mr. Buxman (05:48:00):

And did you see any evidence of that?

Dr. Rachel Lange (05:48:00):

No.

Mr. Buxman (05:48:00):

Did you see any indication of any bruising in the back of her neck?

Dr. Rachel Lange (05:48:03):

No.

Mr. Buxman (05:48:06):

Did you examine her genital area to see if there was any evidence of sexually related trauma?

Dr. Rachel Lange (05:48:12):

Yes.

Mr. Buxman (05:48:13):

And what type of things do you do? What do you look for?

Dr. Rachel Lange (05:48:18):

Well, I mean, just, I look visually at the genitalia, the external genitalia, the labia, and internally at the vagina to see if there is any evidence of blunt injury.

Mr. Buxman (05:48:28):

Did you see any obvious injuries of blunt injury?

Dr. Rachel Lange (05:48:30):

No.

Mr. Buxman (05:48:31):

Based on her state of decomposition, would you expect to be able to see evidence of blunt injury in light of the discoloration of the decomposition process?

Dr. Rachel Lange (05:48:42):

It could be obscured by decomposition.

Mr. Buxman (05:48:44):

Okay. Did you locate any evidence of scarring on her thighs or her forearms?

Dr. Rachel Lange (05:48:51):

Yes.

Mr. Buxman (05:48:52):

What did you find?

Dr. Rachel Lange (05:48:53):

She had many linear scars, both on her arms and legs.

Mr. Buxman (05:49:00):

And if we have heard that the victim engaged in cutting or self-harm, would that be consistent with the scarring that you saw in those locations?

Dr. Rachel Lange (05:49:07):

Yes. They were in a typical pattern of that activity.

Mr. Buxman (05:49:12):

Okay. Did you locate other more substantial injuries to her body?

Dr. Rachel Lange (05:49:15):

Yes.

Mr. Buxman (05:49:16):

And can you describe those injuries, what you saw and where they were located?

Dr. Rachel Lange (05:49:20):

Yes. The significant injuries to her body were stab wounds, which there were four, all on the left side of her body.

Mr. Buxman (05:49:30):

What is the definition of a stab wound?

Dr. Rachel Lange (05:49:32):

A stab wound is a sharp force injury, so it occurs by use of some type of sharp object such as a knife. And by definition, it's as opposed to an incised wound, which is another sharp force injury, a stab wound is smaller on the skin then it goes deep into the body, whereas an incised wound is longer on the body than it goes deep into the skin.

Mr. Buxman (05:49:57):

Could you do me a favor and stand up and just kind of point to the jury where those wounds were located on your body?

Dr. Rachel Lange (05:50:02):

Yes. The stab wounds that she had were on the left side of her torso, two of them just more towards the front and two of them just more towards the back. So all more or less in the left chest, left flank area.

Mr. Buxman (05:50:21):

During the course of your autopsy, thank you, ma'am, did you label those wounds A, B, C, and D?

Dr. Rachel Lange (05:50:28):

Yes.

Mr. Buxman (05:50:28):

Now, does the sequence or labeling of that mean that those were the order in which the wounds were inflicted?

Dr. Rachel Lange (05:50:35):

No. In general and in this specific case, when injuries are labeled, it's generally for descriptive purposes rather than to imply a sequence.

Mr. Buxman (05:50:44):

Are you able to tell in what order those wounds were inflicted?

Dr. Rachel Lange (05:50:47):

No.

Mr. Buxman (05:50:47):

Why not?

Dr. Rachel Lange (05:50:49):

Just more than likely they were all inflicted around the same time. It's really not possible to tell which one was first or last.

Mr. Buxman (05:50:57):

Are you able to determine the position of the victim when those wounds were inflicted?

Dr. Rachel Lange (05:51:02):

No.

Mr. Buxman (05:51:02):

Why not?

Dr. Rachel Lange (05:51:04):

Because we can all visualize a body in different positions and still be able to obtain the same wound track.

Mr. Buxman (05:51:13):

And are you able to tell the position of the person who stabbed the victim at the time those were inflicted?

Dr. Rachel Lange (05:51:19):

No.

Mr. Buxman (05:51:20):

Why not?

Dr. Rachel Lange (05:51:21):

Because again, you can put two people in various scenarios in which you can still achieve the same location of a wound.

Mr. Buxman (05:51:43):

Showing you photograph 15 from State's 63. As far as wounds are concerned, what does this photograph show?

Dr. Rachel Lange (05:52:06):

We are looking at a photograph of the body of Sonia Exelby. She's lying on her right side. The right side of the screen is the head end. The left side of the screen, you can see her leg end. So we're looking at down onto the left side of her body. And if you look just under where the black lace bra is, we see four wounds, which are stab wounds.

Mr. Buxman (05:52:33):

I'm showing you photograph 16 from that same exhibit. Is that just a closeup?

Dr. Rachel Lange (05:52:39):

Yes.

Mr. Buxman (05:52:41):

Okay. Referring to wound A, according to how you designated them in your report, which one is wound A?

Dr. Rachel Lange (05:52:47):

Wound A is designated as the wound that is closest to the top of the screen, the most anterior wound, anterior on her body.

Mr. Buxman (05:52:58):

Anterior meaning the back?

Dr. Rachel Lange (05:53:00):

Front. I'm sorry, front.

Mr. Buxman (05:53:00):

Oh, front. I'm sorry, front. Posterior is the back. Okay. Can you describe that wound to the jury?

Dr. Rachel Lange (05:53:06):

Yes. That wound was 1 1/2 inch long on the skin surface. It had two sharply angled ends, and by that I'm referring to the edges of the wound, whether they come to a point or whether they're blunted. We look at those things to try to compare a possible weapon. So this wound had two sharp ends. The path of the wound went through the muscles on the left side of her chest, the sixth rib, and then continued into the body cavity and perforated her stomach and spleen.

Mr. Buxman (05:53:49):

And how deep into her body did that blade pierce?

Dr. Rachel Lange (05:53:54):

The depth of the wound is approximately four to six inches. The reason that it's not an exact number is that body tissues are compressible. So if you envision a knife, say for example, a two-inch knife, you can press it further into the body than two inches because our tissues are elastic. So typically wound depths are given as a range.

Mr. Buxman (05:54:14):

Would this wound have been fatal?

Dr. Rachel Lange (05:54:17):

Yes. This wound could have been fatal. Yes.

Mr. Buxman (05:54:20):

Moving on to the second wound, wound B, according to your report. Where would that be located in this photograph?

Dr. Rachel Lange (05:54:26):

Wound B is the next wound down, so slightly more towards the back on her. This wound was 1 1/4 inch long, and also had two sharply angled ends on the surface. And its wound track went through the eighth rib on the left side and perforated her stomach and pancreas.

Mr. Buxman (05:54:53):

And how deep did that wound penetrate?

Dr. Rachel Lange (05:54:55):

Again, it estimated four to six inches in depth.

Mr. Buxman (05:54:58):

And would that wound have been fatal?

Dr. Rachel Lange (05:55:00):

Yes, this wound could have been fatal.

Mr. Buxman (05:55:02):

Moving on to wound C, I'm assuming that is the one below the other two?

Dr. Rachel Lange (05:55:06):

Let me just double check. Wound C actually is the more proximal, which means more towards the head. So actually it's the bottom wound that we're seeing in this photograph.

Mr. Buxman (05:55:20):

Okay. The one where the pointer is at right now?

Dr. Rachel Lange (05:55:22):

Yes.

Mr. Buxman (05:55:23):

Okay. Describe that wound for the jury.

Dr. Rachel Lange (05:55:26):

This wound was, again, 1 1/4 inch long, also had two sharply angled ends. The path of this wound was through the back muscles. The 10th rib on the left side went through the left side of the diaphragm, the left kidney, and the aorta.

Mr. Buxman (05:55:48):

What is the aorta?

Dr. Rachel Lange (05:55:51):

The aorta is the major blood vessel that comes out of your heart, drops more or less through the center of your body and sends branches to the rest of the body.

Mr. Buxman (05:56:01):

Okay. And how deep did that wound penetrate?

Dr. Rachel Lange (05:56:04):

Five to seven inches is the estimated depth of that wound.

Mr. Buxman (05:56:07):

Could that wound have been fatal?

Dr. Rachel Lange (05:56:08):

Yes.

Mr. Buxman (05:56:09):

And finally, he's talking about wound D, is that the long the pointer is at right now?

Dr. Rachel Lange (05:56:13):

Yes.

Mr. Buxman (05:56:14):

Okay. Can you describe that wound for the jury?

Dr. Rachel Lange (05:56:16):

Wound D was one inch long on the skin surface, also had two sharply angled ends, and its path went through the 10th rib on the left side and perforated the diaphragm and spleen. And its estimated depth is four to six inches.

Mr. Buxman (05:56:33):

Would this wound have been fatal?

Dr. Rachel Lange (05:56:34):

Yes, this wound could have been fatal.

Mr. Buxman (05:56:37):

Were all four stab wounds roughly the same size on the skin?

Dr. Rachel Lange (05:56:42):

Yes.

Mr. Buxman (05:56:42):

Were they all roughly the same depth?

Dr. Rachel Lange (05:56:45):

Yes.

Mr. Buxman (05:56:46):

Were the wounds consistent with being caused by a similarly shaped knife?

Dr. Rachel Lange (05:56:50):

Yes.

Mr. Buxman (05:56:50):

And how do you know that? How do you come to that conclusion?

Dr. Rachel Lange (05:56:54):

Well, just in that they are more or less the same shape and all of them had sharply angled ends, so it's consistent with having been from the same knife.

Mr. Buxman (05:57:04):

Okay. At some point, did Florida Department of Law Enforcement Agent Rebecca McKenzie bring you a knife to look at to see whether or not the knife could be consistent with the wounds inflicted?

Dr. Rachel Lange (05:57:15):

Yes.

Mr. Buxman (05:57:15):

Okay. Showing you what's been introduced into evidence as State's 87. If you could [inaudible 05:57:27] glove up for me. Thank you. If you open that and have them up, it's already been moved to evidence.

Dr. Rachel Lange (05:57:43):

Shall I [inaudible 05:57:56].

Mr. Buxman (05:57:57):

You [inaudible 05:57:56]. And looking at that knife, does that look familiar?

Dr. Rachel Lange (05:58:01):

Yeah.

Mr. Buxman (05:58:01):

Okay. Based on the shape, you said that all the wounds had angled edges on both ends?

Dr. Rachel Lange (05:58:09):

Yes.

Mr. Buxman (05:58:10):

And based on the appearance of that knife, could that knife be consistent with causing the four wounds we looked at?

Dr. Rachel Lange (05:58:14):

Sorry, I don't know how to get it out of its... [inaudible 05:58:21]. I'm afraid I'm going to cut myself.

Mr. Buxman (05:58:24):

There you go.

Dr. Rachel Lange (05:58:29):

Yes.

Mr. Buxman (05:58:29):

Thank you.

Dr. Rachel Lange (05:58:31):

Thank you. Do I still need... Are we done with these?

Mr. Buxman (05:59:00):

Yes. Go ahead. We're done with those. Yes, thank you. Were all four of the stab wounds inflicted prior to her death?

Dr. Rachel Lange (05:59:06):

Yes.

Mr. Buxman (05:59:08):

Or prior to or at the time of her death?

Dr. Rachel Lange (05:59:10):

Yes.

Mr. Buxman (05:59:11):

How do you know that?

Dr. Rachel Lange (05:59:12):

Because there was hemorrhage within the wound tracks. So in general, if wounds are inflicted after the heart is no longer beating, so after death, you see little if any, blood in a wound track.

Mr. Buxman (05:59:30):

Were X-rays taken during the course of your autopsy?

Dr. Rachel Lange (05:59:33):

Yes.

Mr. Buxman (05:59:34):

And is that standard procedure?

Dr. Rachel Lange (05:59:35):

Yes.

Mr. Buxman (05:59:36):

Okay. Did you locate any foreign objects inside her body, like a bullet or anything like that?

Dr. Rachel Lange (05:59:42):

No.

Mr. Buxman (05:59:42):

All right. Was there anything noteworthy about the X-rays?

Dr. Rachel Lange (05:59:45):

Not that I recall.

Mr. Buxman (05:59:47):

Was a toxicology screen also conducted on her blood?

Dr. Rachel Lange (05:59:50):

Yes.

Mr. Buxman (05:59:51):

What did that reveal?

Dr. Rachel Lange (05:59:53):

It revealed a small amount of ethanol or alcohol.

Mr. Buxman (05:59:57):

Does the decomposition process affect a potential alcohol finding in a person's blood?

Dr. Rachel Lange (06:00:05):

Yes. The decomposition process is largely driven by bacteria, and some bacteria do produce alcohol as a byproduct of their metabolism.

Mr. Buxman (06:00:15):

Are you able to tell if some or all of the alcohol concentration in her blood was due to the decomposition process versus she drank alcohol prior to her death?

Dr. Rachel Lange (06:00:27):

It would test the same, but based on the level that it was, it is consistent with her state of decomposition.

Mr. Buxman (06:00:34):

And were there any other illegal drugs or anything in her system?

Dr. Rachel Lange (06:00:37):

No.

Mr. Buxman (06:00:37):

Okay. Are these wounds consistent with being self-inflicted?

Dr. Rachel Lange (06:00:47):

No.

Mr. Buxman (06:00:47):

Why not?

Dr. Rachel Lange (06:00:50):

The location of the wounds being on the left side of her body, the direction, the overall paths of the wounds being more or less horizontal from left to right are typically not consistent with self-inflicted wounds.

Mr. Buxman (06:01:05):

Okay. Are you able to pinpoint, like on TV, the date and time the victim was killed?

Dr. Rachel Lange (06:01:16):

No.

Mr. Buxman (06:01:16):

Why not?

Dr. Rachel Lange (06:01:19):

Because referring back to the changes that we talked about, although we know that these decomposition changes occur in a sequential manner, the rate at which they occur is actually quite variable. It's highly dependent on the environment that a body is in. And in this case, there are just too many unknowns about where she was or where her body was for me to be very specific about when her time of death was.

Mr. Buxman (06:01:47):

Were you able to determine what you felt that Sonia Exelby's cause of death was?

Dr. Rachel Lange (06:01:52):

Yes.

Mr. Buxman (06:01:52):

What was that?

Dr. Rachel Lange (06:01:53):

The stab wounds of the body.

Mr. Buxman (06:01:56):

Did you determine her manner of death?

Dr. Rachel Lange (06:02:02):

Yes.

Mr. Buxman (06:02:02):

What?

Dr. Rachel Lange (06:02:02):

Homicide.

Mr. Buxman (06:02:02):

Can I have one moment, Your Honor?

Judge (06:02:06):

Yes, you may.

Mr. Buxman (06:02:07):

Thank you, Doctor.

(06:02:07)
No other questions, Your Honor.

Judge (06:02:08):

Any cross examination?

Junior Barrett (06:02:09):

Brief, Judge.

(06:02:16)
Good afternoon, Doctor.

Dr. Rachel Lange (06:02:17):

Good afternoon.

Junior Barrett (06:02:19):

Just essentially one question. Hopefully it'll be one and you'll follow up. The phrase you use, typically not consistent. What does that mean?

Dr. Rachel Lange (06:02:28):

I'm sorry, can you say that again?

Junior Barrett (06:02:29):

You said, "Typically not consistent with." Do you recall that phrase?

Dr. Rachel Lange (06:02:34):

Yes.

Junior Barrett (06:02:35):

What does that mean?

Dr. Rachel Lange (06:02:36):

Well, just that phrase itself means it's... I mean, the finding is not consistent with something that you're comparing it to.

Junior Barrett (06:02:45):

Okay. But you said typically. Does that mean that it is possible, but just not typical?

Dr. Rachel Lange (06:02:52):

Yes.

Junior Barrett (06:02:53):

Okay. So it is possible it could have been, but that's not the typical what you would expect it to be?

Dr. Rachel Lange (06:02:59):

Yes.

Junior Barrett (06:03:01):

Okay. I don't have anything [inaudible 06:03:02].

Judge (06:03:02):

Any follow-up state?

Junior Barrett (06:03:00):

Okay. I don't have anything further.

Judge McCourt (06:03:02):

Any follow-up, State?

Mr. Buxman (06:03:05):

In your opinion, would it be nearly impossible for these wounds to be self-inflicted?

Dr. Rachel Lange (06:03:13):

It's not outside the realm of physical possibility. I mean, we all know that we can hold a knife in our left hand, and I don't know her handedness and I don't know her strength.

Mr. Buxman (06:03:29):

Assume she's right-handed.

Dr. Rachel Lange (06:03:30):

Okay. So with a non-dominant hand, that's a very awkward position to hold a knife in and to generate enough force four times to achieve that wound track and wound depth. So again, it's not outside the realm of physical possibility, no, but it's highly unlikely.

Mr. Buxman (06:03:48):

And what about using your right hand? You talk about left hand, but what about using your right hand?

Dr. Rachel Lange (06:03:53):

I mean, with the right hand, it would be even more difficult to get that direction of wound path, more or less horizontal, coming from right around, reaching your right hand around to the left.

Mr. Buxman (06:04:02):

Thank you, doctor.

Judge McCourt (06:04:03):

Any additional questions?

Junior Barrett (06:04:04):

Just one. Again, that would depend on the strength she has in her hands, correct?

Dr. Rachel Lange (06:04:09):

Yes. Among other things, yes.

Junior Barrett (06:04:10):

No other questions, Judge.

Judge McCourt (06:04:12):

Any additional questions, Mr. Buxman?

Mr. Buxman (06:04:15):

No, Your Honor. Thank you.

Judge McCourt (06:04:16):

Members of the jury, any of y'all have questions of this witness? If you do, please raise your hands. I see two hands up. Ladies, write your questions down on a clean piece of paper and hand it to the bailiff.

(06:04:26)
Lawyers, if y'all will approach. I'm going to put the white noise on, ladies and gentlemen.

(06:04:27)
Okay, doctor, the jury has two questions for you. I'm going to ask them and read them exactly as they're written verbatim. I'm going to put on the presentation mode. This references a photograph. Okay. "On the photo number one is the white coloring the dress? Was this..."

(06:06:26)
Well, let me actually ask that question. There's actually three questions, two questions here. So let's ask that one. "On the photo number one is the white coloring the dress?"

Dr. Rachel Lange (06:06:36):

So this is a photograph taken at the scene, which I was not present at the scene. This was taken by one of our investigators. But as far as I can tell from this photograph, the white coloring is her skin. So all we're seeing is just her bra, and then we can see that she has sandals on, but I do not see clothing on her torso other than the bra.

Judge McCourt (06:07:00):

The second part of the question, I'm going to go ahead and read it to you. "On the photo number one is the white coloring the dress?" The question continues, "Was this worn by a victim at the time of stabbing or placed there afterwards? I.e. Was she dressed or naked at time of stabbing?"

Dr. Rachel Lange (06:07:17):

To my recollection, I did not see the dress because as I mentioned, the clothing is taken by law enforcement at the time. So I don't recall that I was able to examine the dress to see if there were defects in it. So I can't tell you if she was wearing a dress or not at the time she was stabbed.

Judge McCourt (06:07:35):

The next question is, "Can you identify the speed of the knife that was stabbed on the body's wound?"

Dr. Rachel Lange (06:07:41):

Unfortunately, we don't really quantify stab wounds in, for example, a speed or say put pounds of pressure because we don't have that kind of data when these injuries occur. And of course we can't do studies where we stab people and measure these things. So it's difficult to know the speed. But in general, I can just say it would need to be a significant force and speed to be able to perforate the skin and the entire wound track that I described.

Judge McCourt (06:08:11):

Okay. Mr. Buxman, any follow up?

Mr. Buxman (06:08:14):

No follow up, Your Honor.

Judge McCourt (06:08:15):

Mr. Barrett?

Junior Barrett (06:08:16):

No, Your Honor.

Judge McCourt (06:08:16):

Members of the jury, any additional questions, raise your hands. I see one hand. Lawyers approach. I'm going to put the white noise on, ladies and gentlemen.

(06:08:46)
The jury has another question for you. "Would there have been blood visible on the body? Are there signs that it was cleaned after death?"

Dr. Rachel Lange (06:09:08):

Again, I don't know where the actual stabbing occurred. It's likely that there would be blood at that scene wherever it was. At the point that we're seeing her in that photograph and after I saw her, she was already buried, covered in dirt, so I didn't visibly see blood on her body at the time.

Judge McCourt (06:09:30):

State, any follow up?

Mr. Buxman (06:09:30):

No, Your Honor.

Judge McCourt (06:09:34):

Defense, any follow up?

Junior Barrett (06:09:35):

No, Your Honor. Members of the jury, any additional questions from any of you? So you know [inaudible 06:09:41], is this witness released?

Mr. Buxman (06:09:42):

She is, Your Honor.

Judge McCourt (06:09:42):

Defense?

Junior Barrett (06:09:43):

No objection, Your Honor.

Judge McCourt (06:09:44):

Ma'am, you're free to go about your day. Thank you for your time.

Dr. Rachel Lange (06:09:45):

Thank you.

Judge McCourt (06:09:47):

State, you can call your next witness.

Mr. Buxman (06:09:48):

Can I get one moment, Your Honor.

Judge McCourt (06:09:49):

Yes, sir.

Mr. Buxman (06:09:50):

The State rests, Your Honor.

Judge McCourt (06:09:56):

Ladies and gentlemen, the state of Florida has rested. So there are some procedural matters I have to take up now outside of your presence. So we're going to have a recess here for you all. We'll probably tack a short five to 10 minute break on for the lawyers and court personnel once we're done here. Okay? But leave your notepads here on your chairs, closed up, face down. Don't discuss the case with one another. Electronic devices, if you happen to use them, don't use them to learn about the case or communicate about the case. Okay? We'll get you back in as soon as we're able.

(06:10:24)
This may take a little longer than our other recesses, but bear with us. We'll give you a five-minute warning or so and we'll get you back up. Okay? See you back shortly.

(06:10:28)
Jurors have left the courtroom. You all can be seated. Mr. Barrett, where do you expect you'll be going from here?

Junior Barrett (06:11:27):

Well, you want me to make the JO arguments or just in terms of this, because I think I have this maybe.

Judge McCourt (06:11:34):

Whatever you would like, the floor is yours.

Junior Barrett (06:11:35):

Thank you, Judge. As to Count I, Judge, I think I don't have a good faith argument to make as to the murder based upon what's been introduced. Certainly sufficient for it to be submitted to the jury. I would argue as to Count II, the kidnapping, that there hasn't been sufficient evidence to submit this case to a jury on that second count. I would suggest that at most there may be some evidence of some kind of a false imprisonment based upon that note letter.

(06:12:07)
But my understanding of kidnapping, and truthfully, I haven't dealt with this issue in a long time, but that there has to be some kind of a movement from one location to the other. The place that she was staying is a place that she had herself procured. So her being in that place unless she was moved and there's evidence that she was moved to some other location against her will, I think at the most, again, based upon the letter on the note, there may be some evidence of a false imprisonment, but I would argue that there isn't sufficient evidence of a kidnapping to submit to the jury.

Judge McCourt (06:12:47):

So you would agree, because the elements of kidnapping and false imprisonment, as I understand, are the same, except a kidnapping has an additional element. The one element is that the person, in this case, was confined and forcibly secretly or by threat. That was done without any lawful authority. Those are the elements of false imprisonment and the two elements of kidnapping.

(06:13:08)
The third element of kidnapping, which based on the charging document here is that it was done with the intent to terrorize or inflict bodily harm upon Ms. Exelby. So you agree that the evidence here is legally sufficient at least to allow a false imprisonment to go to the jury?

Junior Barrett (06:13:23):

I would not Judge as to the third part that the court talked about.

Judge McCourt (06:13:27):

That would be for the kidnapping.

Junior Barrett (06:13:29):

Right.

Judge McCourt (06:13:30):

I will find based upon the evidence that's been presented today, the evidence for this week, the evidence is sufficient to put this case to the jury as to both offenses as charged. Whether or not Ms. Exelby was confined against her will, forcefully, secretly or by threat or some type of coercion and whether or not Mr. Hall had any lawful authority to do that, whether he did that with the intent to terrorize her, if he did it at all. The jury could find that to have been proven beyond a reasonable doubt. They may find it not proven beyond a reasonable doubt. This is not a case where the evidence is such that the court should decide the verdict and direct the verdict in favor of the defendant. This is a case where the verdict needs to be left in the capable hands of the jury.

Junior Barrett (06:14:10):

Understood.

Judge McCourt (06:14:12):

I would also say I commend your professionalism in not moving for a motion or not moving for judgment acquittal as to Count I. The evidence is more than legally sufficient to support a charge of first degree premeditated murder. Had such a motion been made, it would've been denied. Just for the benefit of the record, there is that. So motion for judgment acquittal is denied. The case will go to the jury. All right. What do you expect we're going to be doing in terms of Mr. Hall testifying or not?

Junior Barrett (06:14:38):

Judge, yesterday around seven o'clock in the rain, I went out to the jail and met with him and spoke to him until about nine o'clock. Based upon my discussion then and brief discussion this morning, he's indicated to me that he does not intend to testify. Obviously as I told him at the jail, the court is going to make an inquiry anyway, but it's my understanding that he does not intend to testify.

Judge McCourt (06:15:02):

Okay. Mr. Hall, raise your right hand, sir. Do you swear to tell the truth, the whole truth, nothing but the truth, so help you God?

Dwain Hall (06:15:06):

Yes, sir.

Judge McCourt (06:15:07):

Okay. All right. Mr. Hall, your attorney's indicated that as of last night about 9:00 PM, your indication or your wish to him was that you did not want to become a witness and he's apparently heard nothing today that leads him to believe that you've changed your mind. So I'm going to ask you, what do you want to do today, Mr. Hall? Do you wish to testify in your own defense or exercise your right to remain silent?

Dwain Hall (06:15:28):

After careful... Words are bad right now. After speaking with my attorney thoroughly and being advised properly, I've decided not to take the stand and to remain silent?

Judge McCourt (06:15:43):

Yes, sir.

Dwain Hall (06:15:43):

Yeah.

Judge McCourt (06:15:44):

Yes, sir. All right. I'm going to make sure you're making that decision freely and voluntarily, knowingly and intelligently, so I'm going to ask you a couple more questions. First, do you understand that you have a constitutional right to remain silent?

Dwain Hall (06:15:54):

Yes.

Judge McCourt (06:15:55):

If you do not testify, I will instruct the jury that the fact that you did not testify cannot be looked upon as any evidence of guilt and should not be considered by them in any manner whatsoever during their deliberations. Do you understand?

Dwain Hall (06:16:06):

Yes.

‍

Judge McCourt (06:16:07):

Do you understand that if you choose to testify, I will instruct the jury that your testimony is to be considered like that of any other witness?

Dwain Hall (06:16:13):

Yes.

Judge McCourt (06:16:13):

Do you understand that if you testify, the State can cross-examine you?

Dwain Hall (06:16:15):

Yes.

Judge McCourt (06:16:17):

Do you understand that if you testify, the jury in this courtroom will also have the ability to pose questions to you?

Dwain Hall (06:16:22):

Yes.

Judge McCourt (06:16:22):

Do you understand that if you testify and you have previously been convicted of a felony or a misdemeanor crime involving dishonesty or false statement, you could be asked how many times you've been convicted of such offenses. Do you understand?

Dwain Hall (06:16:33):

Yes.

Judge McCourt (06:16:33):

Okay. State, are there any certified convictions that could be used to impeach Mr. Hall?

Mr. Buxman (06:16:38):

No, Your Honor.

Judge McCourt (06:16:40):

Now, Mr. Hall, understand the right to remain silent belongs to you and to you alone. Do you understand that?

Dwain Hall (06:16:45):

Yes.

Judge McCourt (06:16:46):

This right does not belong to anybody else, including your attorneys. Do you understand?

Dwain Hall (06:16:50):

Yes.

Judge McCourt (06:16:51):

Now, I expect Mr. Barrett and Mr. Ward have given you their advice and their opinion and the benefit of their collective years of experience, but ultimately the decision whether to become a witness is your decision. Do you understand that?

Dwain Hall (06:17:02):

Yes.

Judge McCourt (06:17:03):

Have you had enough opportunity to talk with Mr. Ward and Mr. Barrett about your decision here today?

Dwain Hall (06:17:07):

Yes, sir.

Judge McCourt (06:17:10):

Now, I don't want to know what you've talked about, but do you feel that they have adequately advised you on the pros and cons of testifying?

Dwain Hall (06:17:17):

Absolutely, sir.

Judge McCourt (06:17:19):

And do you believe that had you made the election here today to become a witness, that you would've been adequately prepared to testify?

Dwain Hall (06:17:26):

No.

Judge McCourt (06:17:26):

Okay. And is that because of anything your attorneys did or simply because you don't believe that you would've been prepared because your thoughts and whatnot wouldn't have been in order?

Dwain Hall (06:17:37):

The latter, my thoughts and whatnot would not have been in order.

Judge McCourt (06:17:40):

Okay. But in terms of being prepared to testify, your attorneys did with what you believe they reasonably could have done?

Dwain Hall (06:17:45):

Yes, sir.

Judge McCourt (06:17:46):

Okay. And are you making this decision here today, Mr. Hall, to not become a witness voluntarily?

Dwain Hall (06:17:51):

Yes.

Judge McCourt (06:17:52):

Has anybody forced, coerced, pressured or threatened you to get you to agree to not testify?

Dwain Hall (06:17:56):

No.

Judge McCourt (06:18:01):

Your question to me had to intonate... Or your answer to me had the intonation of a question.

Dwain Hall (06:18:05):

It's kind of a lack of understanding of the language is all.

Judge McCourt (06:18:08):

All right. Fair enough. You've made the decision to not become a witness.

Dwain Hall (06:18:11):

That's correct.

Judge McCourt (06:18:12):

And to remain silent, correct?

Dwain Hall (06:18:13):

Yes.

Judge McCourt (06:18:14):

Is anyone forcing you to make that decision?

Dwain Hall (06:18:16):

No.

Judge McCourt (06:18:16):

Coercing you?

Dwain Hall (06:18:17):

No.

Judge McCourt (06:18:17):

Pressuring you?

Dwain Hall (06:18:18):

No.

Judge McCourt (06:18:19):

Threatening you?

Dwain Hall (06:18:19):

No.

Judge McCourt (06:18:20):

Threatening anybody?

Dwain Hall (06:18:21):

No.

Judge McCourt (06:18:21):

Pressuring anybody?

Dwain Hall (06:18:22):

No.

Judge McCourt (06:18:23):

Forcing anybody?

Dwain Hall (06:18:24):

No.

Judge McCourt (06:18:24):

Coercing anybody?

Dwain Hall (06:18:25):

No.

Judge McCourt (06:18:26):

Okay. And when we spoke on Monday, you indicated there were no additional witnesses you wanted your attorneys to investigate or call. Does that hold true here today?

Dwain Hall (06:18:34):

Yes.

Judge McCourt (06:18:36):

Okay. And are you satisfied up through this point with your attorney's services?

Dwain Hall (06:18:39):

Yes.

Judge McCourt (06:18:40):

Have you answered all of my questions truthfully today?

Dwain Hall (06:18:42):

Yes.

Judge McCourt (06:18:43):

Has anybody told you how to answer my questions?

Dwain Hall (06:18:45):

No.

Judge McCourt (06:18:46):

Okay. Is there anything that you believe at this point you need to bring to the court's attention?

Dwain Hall (06:18:49):

No.

Judge McCourt (06:18:50):

Okay. All right. Mr. Barrett, I will make a finding that Mr. Hall has elected to exercise his Fifth Amendment privilege against self-incrimination, his right to not be a witness, and he's done that freely and voluntarily, knowingly and intelligently. So you need to, at this point in time, figure out what we're going to do from here. So we're at 2:35, roughly. Lawyers, do y'all have a preference?

Amy Berndt (06:19:20):

Judge, I would ask that we send the jury home, do the charge conference, and then do the closing statements tomorrow at 8:30 as we originally had planned.

Judge McCourt (06:19:27):

Okay.

Junior Barrett (06:19:27):

Agreeable, Judge.

Judge McCourt (06:19:29):

Okay. All right. If y'all want to wait till morning, we can do that.

Junior Barrett (06:19:32):

Yes. Very well.

Judge McCourt (06:19:33):

All right. I'll bring the jury back in. At that point in time, Mr. Barrett, you can rest in the presence of the jury.

Junior Barrett (06:19:37):

Yes.

Judge McCourt (06:19:37):

I will then tell the jury the case is closed, give them their instructions for the evening and we'll see them back tomorrow morning. We'll spend our afternoon here getting the instructions in order. Okay? Sound good to everybody?

Mr. Buxman (06:19:51):

Yes, sir.

Junior Barrett (06:19:51):

Yes, Your Honor.

Judge McCourt (06:23:32):

Okay. Let's go ahead and bring them in. Two in the bathroom? Okay. Y'all can have a seat for me.

(06:23:32)
Ladies and gentlemen, welcome back, counsel. Everybody can be seated. Thank you. Mr. Barrett, you may call your first witness.

Junior Barrett (06:23:37):

Judge, at this time, the Defense would also rest.

Judge McCourt (06:23:40):

Okay. Members of the jury, both the State and the defense have now rested their cases, which means that you've heard all the evidence that you're going to hear during this trial. As I explained to you on Monday, you should not form any definite or fixed opinion on the merits of the case until you have heard all the evidence, the argument of the lawyers and the instructions on the law by the judge.

(06:23:55)
So what we're going to do now is we're going to break for the rest of the afternoon. We're going to come back tomorrow morning. The lawyers and I have to get the jury instructions in order. That's your instruction on the law. I have a draft I have prepared. I've sent it to the lawyers. We've looked at it. I trust everyone here has looked at it. It'll still take, even with that, probably about an hour to an hour and a half to go through the instructions thoroughly to make sure that everything's correct, and then also to print out copies for all of you and the parties and the lawyers. It takes a little bit of time.

(06:24:22)
Rather than start closing argument at 3:30, four o'clock and then potentially be here without you even beginning deliberations until seven, eight o'clock this evening. I think it'd be a better idea to bring you back in the morning fresh and give you all the afternoon off. Okay? So your notepads will remain here on your chairs, closed up. They'll be collected by the bailiff, handed out to you again tomorrow morning.

(06:24:46)
Now, tonight, the same rules continue to govern you that have governed you over the other overnight recesses. First, do not discuss the case with one another or any other person, okay? Second, you cannot use your cell phone or electronic device or any other means at all to communicate about the case, do research about the case, look up information about the case or the people or places or things or concepts involved, okay?

(06:25:09)
So go home and just make it a quiet night. I would instruct you all again to continue to avoid social media as we don't know what kind of information will pop up in any of our algorithms. Also, avoid any local news. I'm not a big consumer of evening news myself, so I don't know what has been on the evening news, so probably best to avoid the news altogether at this stage. You can catch up tomorrow on what's been going on in the world, okay? If there's anything super important, you'll probably know about it. For example, it's been raining lately.

(06:25:45)
So with that little bit of levity, I understand your lunch orders have been taken for tomorrow. It's going to be Jimmy John's again, so hope you like it. But y'all get a good night's sleep. Get back here at 8:10 tomorrow morning. I've got two short matters at 8:00. I should not be delayed past 8:30. Like I will say that we had a lawyer run late because of traffic and rain and whatnot. But we should start promptly at 8:30 tomorrow and you should have a case for deliberations probably by mid to late morning, okay? All right. Have a good night. Jury's left the courtroom y'all can go ahead and be seated. Thank you. Are y'all ready to go into jury instructions?

Junior Barrett (06:27:08):

Yes, sir.

Judge McCourt (06:27:08):

Yes, Judge. All right. What I'm going to do is I'm going to put this on video conference mode. I'm going to pull a draft of the instructions up on Microsoft Word on a share screen. I've got to get onto Zoom to do that, so y'all give me a minute to get logged in.

Automated (06:27:39):

Welcome to Zoom. Please press pound, then enter your meeting ID followed by the... You are in the meeting now. Recording in progress.

Judge McCourt (06:29:06):

Oh, yeah. We'll talk about that too. Yeah, [inaudible 06:29:10] reminding me, if y'all want to put media on the laptop [inaudible 06:29:14]-

Amy Berndt (06:29:14):

Oh, yes.

Judge McCourt (06:29:14):

... y'all can do that.

Mr. Buxman (06:29:15):

Yes, sir. We can do that this afternoon.

Judge McCourt (06:29:17):

All right. We can go ahead and bring it out now. I'm fine with y'all starting now if you want with that.

Mr. Buxman (06:29:22):

I'm going to do the evidence probably, so true.

Judge McCourt (06:29:25):

Okay.

Mr. Buxman (06:29:28):

To put it all on the laptop.

Amy Berndt (06:29:30):

Yeah, yeah.

Judge McCourt (06:29:47):

Cabrera, could we angle the TV there over toward defense counsel [inaudible 06:29:50]?

Cabrera (06:29:50):

All right. Without these glasses, I can't see anything.

Judge McCourt (06:30:00):

I'm going to make that bigger for y'all.

Cabrera (06:30:05):

It's the same.

Judge McCourt (06:30:10):

All right. So let's take a look here. I'm going to go through each one of these one at a time. All right. 3.1: Introduction to Final Instructions. Any objection, State?

Mr. Buxman (06:30:31):

No, Your Honor.

Judge McCourt (06:30:32):

Any objection, Defense?

Junior Barrett (06:30:33):

No, Your Honor.

Judge McCourt (06:30:34):

3.2: Statement of the Charges. Any objection, State?

Mr. Buxman (06:30:37):

No, Your Honor.

Judge McCourt (06:30:38):

Defense?

Junior Barrett (06:30:39):

No, Your Honor.

Judge McCourt (06:30:40):

7.1: Introduction to Homicide. Any objection, State?

Mr. Buxman (06:30:43):

No, sir.

Judge McCourt (06:30:44):

Any objection Defense?

Junior Barrett (06:30:45):

No, Your Honor.

Judge McCourt (06:30:47):

Okay. Justifiable homicide. I intend to give that. State any objection?

Mr. Buxman (06:30:52):

No, sir.

Judge McCourt (06:30:53):

Defense?

Junior Barrett (06:30:54):

No, Your Honor.

Judge McCourt (06:30:54):

Excusable homicide. State agreeable today?

Mr. Buxman (06:30:56):

No objection.

Judge McCourt (06:30:57):

Defense?

Junior Barrett (06:30:58):

No objection.

Judge McCourt (06:31:02):

All right. 7.2: First Degree Murder. Now I went ahead and added... The State had made a request that the court include an instruction regarding non-consent being a defense to the crime of first degree murder. So that's a request for a special instruction. State, what is your argument for it? I'd like to just make that for the record.

Mr. Buxman (06:31:26):

Based on the case law I provided through the email to both the court and the Defense, those cases both indicate that exactly what that says, consent is not a defense to a violent crime against person. I think the case I cited dealt with aggravated battery, so if it doesn't apply to aggravated battery, it surely can't apply to murder.

Judge McCourt (06:31:45):

In those cases, Mr. Buxman, I'm going to print out this email and just file it in the court file.

Mr. Buxman (06:31:51):

Yes, sir.

Judge McCourt (06:31:52):

And Mr. Barrett was copied on the email. It was sent November 13th, 8:38 AM. The cases are Lyons versus State, L- Y-O-N-S, 437 Southern Second 711, First District Court of Appeal, 1983. The State versus Conley, 799 Southern Second 400, Florida Fourth District Court of Appeal, 2001, and Jaske v. State, J-A-S-K-E, Indiana, 539 Northeast 2nd 14. Mr. Barrett, what is the Defense position on the propriety of these special instructions?

Junior Barrett (06:32:35):

Judge, it's the Defense position that the instructions as it stands as to first degree murder is sufficient and that this special instruction is not necessary and should not be given.

Judge McCourt (06:32:46):

All right. The standard of law that governs whether I give a special jury instruction, I believe to be one, whether or not the law, the standard jury instructions as prepared, whether it fails to adequately instruct the jury on all the law that is applicable to the theories of defense and prosecution, and two, that it is an accurate statement of the law. You're not objecting to what the State has proposed based on its accuracy or lack thereof, correct?

Junior Barrett (06:33:14):

I mean, clearly consent is not an element of first degree murder, but I think since all the elements in first degree murder are in the instructions that any additional instruction, be it special or otherwise, it's not necessary and shouldn't be given.

Judge McCourt (06:33:32):

So I understand your argument, lewd or lascivious battery though, 11.10 C, consent of the victim is, or lack of consent is not an element. But we still instruct the jury on consent and coercion because it's not defense. The idea I think with the lewd and lascivious battery is that if a person, if a 15-year-old girl consented to have sex with a 30-year-old man, a jury may equitably or what have you be inclined to find, well, she agreed to have sex with him.

(06:34:03)
So the jury understanding that that's not a legal defense is helpful in an L&L battery trial because you're explaining, "Hey, this is not a defense." So put it out of your mind. That would be a defense to the 30-year-old man having sex with a 15-year-old girl.

Junior Barrett (06:34:18):

But that's actually written in the instruction, Judge. And again, it goes to argument that as is, I don't think there's a need to change the instructions.

Judge McCourt (06:34:26):

Right. But it's not in the instruction because I don't know that many murder prosecutions involve the defense of, call it an equitable defense of consent or possible defense of consent.

Junior Barrett (06:34:42):

Yeah, but by definition, murder cannot be consented to. It was not my intention to say to the jury she consented. I mean, obviously I'm going to argue the facts, but I don't think I could say to the jury she consented.

Judge McCourt (06:34:54):

Yeah. I expect the Defense argument to be that this was a suicide.

Junior Barrett (06:34:58):

Right.

Judge McCourt (06:34:59):

That would be my expectation based on my observing the trial. So you agree that it is not a defense to first degree murder and that if I gave the instruction, it would be an accurate statement on the law, correct?

Junior Barrett (06:35:23):

I understand what the court's saying, but the argument is that the instructions as written is sufficient and that instruction is not necessarily because the definitions in the instructions are sufficient to let the jury know that in this case consent is not an issue. And the state can very well argue what the elements are.

Judge McCourt (06:35:55):

Right.

Judge McCourt (06:36:00):

I'm going to find that the standard jury instruction does not adequately explain this highly unique factual circumstance. And although it may not be what you will argue, Mr. Barrett, the jury is free to reach their own conclusion. And what they do with, if they reach a conclusion that she consented to her death, is going to be driven by the law that they are instructed on. So if they're instructed that consent is not offense of first degree murder, second degree murder or manslaughter, it'll be an accurate statement of the law and it would I think ensure that the jury does not mistakenly believe that that is a defense and misapply the law because they weren't provided the law. So I'm going to give the special instruction.

(06:37:34)
So I'm going to agree Sonia Exelby's consent is not a defense to the crime of first degree murder.

(06:37:42)
I then need to define consent and coercion. Consent and coercion are defined in the standard jury instructions, they're defined in sexual battery, they're defined in human trafficking, defined in L&L battery. I have proposed up here, the human trafficking definitions specific to that statute or that chapter 787 doesn't apply here, it includes all kinds of stuff that we're not concerned with. But the consent and coercion definitions, I pulled those from, I think I pulled the consent one from sexual battery. The L&L battery, it just ends, it does not include submission by coercion. So it's a very similar definition for consent. And I've defined coercion consistent with lewd or insidious battery. Sexual battery definition also contains some language about failing to offer physical resistance that doesn't apply to this case.

(06:38:38)
So as far as my definitions of consent and coercion, given that I have made the election to give the instruction on the basis that I've given it, is there any argument that this is a misleading or incorrect statement of the law by either the State or the defendant?

Speaker 18 (06:38:53):

No objection, Your Honor.

Mr. Barrett (06:38:57):

Judge, my caution is that I've never been in this situation with that. And I don't want to be in a situation where it may be construed that I'm somehow agreeing on waiving any defect. And so-

Judge McCourt (06:39:09):

I will say this-

Mr. Barrett (06:39:12):

I understand that may be the definition that's elsewhere in the instruction relating to other crimes. But clearly, again, I don't agree that it should be given in this case.

Judge McCourt (06:39:22):

Understood.

Mr. Barrett (06:39:23):

So I just don't want the record to in any way, shape or form suggest that I am agreeing.

Judge McCourt (06:39:27):

Understood.

Mr. Barrett (06:39:30):

Okay.

Judge McCourt (06:39:30):

And if you would like to maintain that position after my next question, you can, okay? But I think that the record should be clear that Mr. Barrett is objecting to the court instructing the jury that Ms. Exelby's consent is not a defense to the crime charged or any lesser included offense. And because of that, he would necessarily object to defining consent and coercion. That objection's understood. It's been considered. I'm going to give the instructions anyway. So being that I'm going to give it, what I'm now asking is, and this would not and should not be construed as a waiver of your objection to the consent instruction, but insofar as I'm going to give an instruction on consent and on coercion, is there any objection to the language of those instructions?

Mr. Barrett (06:40:22):

No, Judge.

Judge McCourt (06:40:23):

Okay. State, you said you had no objection.

Speaker 18 (06:40:26):

No objection, Your Honor.

Judge McCourt (06:40:27):

I cannot find a better definition that's plug and play. So I think that would be sufficient to adequately outline that. I will give that. All right.

(06:40:43)
So with that being said, other than the objection to the consent defense, Mr. Barrett, is there any objection by the defense to 7.2 first degree murder?

Mr. Barrett (06:40:52):

No, Your Honor.

Judge McCourt (06:40:54):

I then need to instruct the jury on lesser included offenses as to first degree murder. I'm going to instruct on lesser separately. The way I typically do is I do all the charged offenses at once, give the 3.4 instruction, then go through all the lessers.

Mr. Barrett (06:41:09):

Okay.

Judge McCourt (06:41:09):

Here, because we have the introduction to homicide instruction, it made more sense to me preparing these to go through all the murder, homicide-related lessers, and then separately deal with the kidnapping, false imprisonment. Fair?

Mr. Barrett (06:41:22):

Right. That's fine Judge.

Judge McCourt (06:41:24):

All right. Any objection to 3.4, State?

Speaker 18 (06:41:26):

No, sir.

Judge McCourt (06:41:27):

Defense?

Mr. Barrett (06:41:29):

No objection, no objection.

Judge McCourt (06:41:30):

Okay. All right. 7.4 second degree murder, any objection to that State?

Speaker 18 (06:41:36):

No, sir.

Mr. Barrett (06:41:38):

No objection.

Judge McCourt (06:41:38):

Okay. Now Mr. Barrett, just to be clear, do you object to the inclusion of the instruction regarding consent not being an offense?

Mr. Barrett (06:41:45):

Yes, Judge.

Judge McCourt (06:41:46):

Okay. All right. So same ruling as first degree murder, I will be giving a definition of consent and coercion. In so far as I will be giving those, any objection to those definitions?

Mr. Barrett (06:42:01):

Oh, I'm sorry, I thought you just said you were going to give it.

Judge McCourt (06:42:04):

Yeah. Any objection to the definitions of consent and coercion?

Mr. Barrett (06:42:08):

Judge, based on the discussion we had it would be the same argument, same conclusion and I would understand that the court is basically saying the same thing we said in terms of the language.

Judge McCourt (06:42:18):

You object to me giving them, but insofar as I'm going to give them, if I'm going to give them, you're happy with the language as much you're ever going to be?

Mr. Barrett (06:42:22):

Understood. Yes.

Judge McCourt (06:42:28):

Okay. All right. I think that the Fifth DCA will understand that should they have occasion to review the record here. 7.7, manslaughter. All right, let's talk about element two.

Speaker 18 (06:42:36):

Judge, I don't know if there's any evidence or any support to a culpable negligence. We have four stab wounds. I think intentionally committed act is appropriate, but culpable negligence is not.

Judge McCourt (06:42:52):

Yeah, I'll defer to the defense on this one, it doesn't apply, y'all can argue it. But if they believe it could somehow conform to some theory of their case, I'm inclined to leave it in if needed. [inaudible 06:43:10]

Speaker 18 (06:43:13):

I don't see any evidence of B either, intentionally procured.

Judge McCourt (06:43:19):

Let me see defense's-

Speaker 18 (06:43:21):

Yes, sir.

Judge McCourt (06:43:22):

A, B, C, which, if any, I guess, I suppose you want at least one of them because you want manslaughter as the lesser?

Mr. Barrett (06:43:30):

I would agree with the State as to A, intentionally committed an act or act that caused the death ... Well, hold on.

(06:43:46)
I am going to ask for it. I think part of my argument would include some act that he did that led to her committing suicide. So I would ask that and I would argue that, again, based upon the argument I intend to make, that A does apply.

(06:44:13)
And I would ask that C also will apply based upon my arguments, I would ask for instructions I understand. Without getting specifics of my argument, and again, can be revisited, I guess, I have to argue it if the court finds that it doesn't apply. But based upon what I intend to argue, I would want C to be part of the instruction.

Judge McCourt (06:44:42):

Okay. State?

Speaker 18 (06:44:43):

Judge, if the defense wants those two in there, we're not going to object to it.

Judge McCourt (06:44:47):

Okay. [inaudible 06:44:51] You can argue it's culpability or lack thereof. So I'll go ahead and we'll leave all the manslaughter in. Mr. Barrett, I again have the defense is not a consent instruction. Do you object to that instruction being given?

Mr. Barrett (06:45:08):

Based upon previous arguments, yes.

Judge McCourt (06:45:27):

All right. Same ruling.

(06:45:27)
Okay. Let's move on to 9.1, kidnapping.

Speaker 18 (06:45:37):

No objection.

Mr. Barrett (06:45:38):

Are we at nine?

Judge McCourt (06:45:41):

Yes, 9.1, kidnapping.

Mr. Barrett (06:45:43):

No objection to the instruction.

Judge McCourt (06:45:47):

3.4, lesser included crimes. My understanding is the only lesser included crime of kidnapping, false imprisonment.

Speaker 18 (06:45:53):

Correct.

Mr. Barrett (06:45:53):

No objection to that instruction.

Judge McCourt (06:45:55):

Any objection to 9.2?

Speaker 18 (06:45:57):

No, Your Honor.

Mr. Barrett (06:45:59):

No objection.

Judge McCourt (06:46:01):

The State had requested, I wouldn't say requested, asked to include in the draft the instruction on principles at one point potentially. I think you were lukewarm about whether or not you want it.

Speaker 18 (06:46:11):

I don't think we need that, Your Honor.

Judge McCourt (06:46:13):

Mr. Barrett, agreeable to it coming out?

Mr. Barrett (06:46:15):

I don't want it, so if the State doesn't want it, I'm not complaining.

Judge McCourt (06:46:18):

Okay. Okay. We have 3.7, plea of not guilty, reasonable doubt, burden of proof. State, any objection?

Speaker 18 (06:46:37):

No, Your Honor. I believe that's the new version.

Mr. Barrett (06:46:39):

That's correct, it is. And I have no objection.

Judge McCourt (06:46:39):

I believe it to be the newest new version.

Speaker 18 (06:46:40):

Yes, correct. U.S.

Judge McCourt (06:46:49):

3.8A, evidence of other crimes, wrongs or acts.

Mr. Barrett (06:46:57):

This is based on my Williams Rule objection, Judge. My concern here is obviously that I don't think that the evidence allowed in on the Williams Rule should come in. I think I need to maintain that also since it shouldn't have been in the instruction itself, shouldn't apply.

Judge McCourt (06:47:21):

Okay. Yes, I understand your argument that I shouldn't even be giving the instruction to begin with, because your argument is that I erred in admitting the photographs.

Mr. Barrett (06:47:33):

But I understand based on the court's ruling, that instruction would apply based on the court's ruling.

Judge McCourt (06:47:37):

And based on my ruling, is there any other way you want me to instruct the jury other than how I have proposed 3.8A? Because I need to instruct them on this given my ruling. If my ruling was wrong, then obviously there are other problems. But if my ruling to admit it was correct.

Mr. Barrett (06:47:52):

I don't see a problem with the wording of 3.8A.

Judge McCourt (06:47:57):

Very good, very good. Let's move on to 3.9, weighing the evidence. Paragraph three, I typically change to remove the phrase "the attorney's questions" because the jurors ask questions in this courtroom. Y'all agree with that coming out?

Mr. Barrett (06:48:09):

Yes, Judge.

Speaker 18 (06:48:09):

Agree.

Judge McCourt (06:48:11):

Okay. Let's talk about considerations on witness credibility one through five, we've given all cases. Let's talk about six through 10. We'll go in reverse order. Number 10. State agree that came out?

Speaker 18 (06:48:25):

Agree, come out. [inaudible 06:48:28].

Judge McCourt (06:48:25):

Defense?

Mr. Barrett (06:48:33):

I don't think 10 applies, Judge.

Speaker 18 (06:48:34):

So it comes out.

Mr. Barrett (06:48:35):

Yeah.

Judge McCourt (06:48:36):

Take out number nine?

Speaker 18 (06:48:37):

Yes, sir.

Mr. Barrett (06:48:39):

Agreed.

Judge McCourt (06:48:41):

I'm inclined to leave number eight in. Y'all agree with that?

Speaker 18 (06:48:48):

I don't know of any impeachment, but I have no argument to leave it out, Judge, whatever the defense wants.

Mr. Barrett (06:49:00):

I agree. I don't see how it applies. I don't think eight applies.

Judge McCourt (06:49:03):

Okay. I'll take it out prior to this statement. I agree that there was not any what I would call typical impeachment.

Mr. Barrett (06:49:11):

Yeah.

Judge McCourt (06:49:15):

Number seven, pressure threats.

Speaker 18 (06:49:19):

I don't think there's been any evidence of any of that in this case.

Mr. Barrett (06:49:21):

Agreed.

Judge McCourt (06:49:24):

Receiving money, preferred treatment or other benefits, State?

Speaker 18 (06:49:29):

We have had experts, but there's been no testimony regarding finances.

Mr. Barrett (06:49:33):

I don't think it applies to evidence either, Judge.

Judge McCourt (06:49:36):

Number six will come out. All right. So we'll do one through five. Let's go through these paragraphs here. Quality, quantity paragraph, given all cases, consideration of law enforcement testimony. We'll give that here, agreed?

Speaker 18 (06:49:48):

Yes, sir.

Mr. Barrett (06:49:49):

Yes, Judge.

Judge McCourt (06:49:50):

We'll give the expert paragraph, agreed?

Speaker 18 (06:49:51):

Yes, sir.

Mr. Barrett (06:49:52):

Yes, Your Honor.

Judge McCourt (06:49:53):

We're going to take out the accomplice, co-defendant, immunity type witness paragraph, agree?

Speaker 18 (06:49:59):

Yes, sir.

Mr. Barrett (06:49:59):

Agreed.

Judge McCourt (06:50:01):

Agree taking out testimony of a child, agree?

Speaker 18 (06:50:03):

Yeah.

Mr. Barrett (06:50:03):

Agreed.

Judge McCourt (06:50:05):

We're taking out defendants become a witness, agreed?

Speaker 18 (06:50:06):

Yes, sir.

Mr. Barrett (06:50:07):

Agreed.

Judge McCourt (06:50:09):

Okay. We'll leave in defendant not testify.

Mr. Barrett (06:50:14):

I would ask for the instruction of defendant not testifying.

Judge McCourt (06:50:19):

We have 3.9B, defendant statements?

Mr. Barrett (06:50:21):

Yes, Judge, I would ask for that also.

Judge McCourt (06:50:26):

I want to talk to you all about potentially appending onto 3.9 some part of, is it 2.12 that I read yesterday about the cautionary instruction about the law enforcement statements during the interview?

Mr. Barrett (06:50:42):

Okay.

Speaker 18 (06:50:42):

Yes, sir.

Judge McCourt (06:50:42):

I started kind of going around in my head where I thought that would logically fit in with the remainder of the instructions. 3.9B struck me as a logical place for it because we are talking about the defendant's statements. Or we can include it in just 3.9, weighing the evidence.

Speaker 18 (06:50:58):

I think if you're going to include it it would make sense to put it in the defendant's statement section.

Mr. Barrett (06:51:04):

Agreed.

Judge McCourt (06:51:04):

And I'm going to ask you, Mr. Barrett, because if you tell me you don't want it, I will not give it, but-

Mr. Barrett (06:51:10):

No, I would ask that the court give it.

Judge McCourt (06:51:20):

Okay. All right. Well, what I'm going to do is I'm going to plug in 2.8 after 3.9.

(06:51:24)
There were, as I recall, three recorded interviews given by the defendant, correct?

Ms. Burn (06:51:56):

Correct.

Speaker 18 (06:51:56):

Yes.

Mr. Barrett (06:51:56):

Yes.

Judge McCourt (06:51:59):

I don't recall whether the controlled phone calls contained any type of opinion statement by law enforcement that I would consider noteworthy.

Ms. Burn (06:52:10):

I don't think they did.

Speaker 18 (06:52:10):

I don't remember any of them.

Mr. Barrett (06:52:12):

Agree.

Judge McCourt (06:52:12):

With that said, Mr. Barrett, do you want me to instruct the jury using the 2.8 instruction only for the statement Mr. Hall gave to Ms. McKenzie and Mr. Miller and specifically reference them?

Mr. Barrett (06:52:30):

Yes, Judge, as to the one he gave in the video interview.

Judge McCourt (06:52:33):

Okay.

(06:52:33)
What do you all think of this instruction, 2.8, effect of law enforcement [inaudible 06:54:45]

Mr. Barrett (06:54:44):

I can't read that far, so you're just going to tell me what it says, Judge.

Judge McCourt (06:54:48):

I'll go ahead and read it. It says, "During the trial, a recorded interview was admitted into evidence that contains opinions and statements by Special Agent Rebecca McKenzie and Sergeant Miller to Dwain Hall." I'm going to say "opinions and statements made by," that seems to make more sense to me. Yeah. Actually, I'm going to say, "The opinions of and statements made by." Okay. "During the trial, a recorded interview was submitted into evidence that contains the opinions of and statements made by Special Agent Rebecca McKenzie and Sergeant Joseph Miller to Dwain Hall." Could structure that sentence better. Yeah. Okay. "During the trial, a recorded interview was admitted into evidence between Special Agent Rebecca McKenzie, Sergeant Joseph Miller, and Dwain Hall. This recording contains the opinions and statements of Special Agent Rebecca McKenzie and Sergeant Joseph Miller. These opinions and statements are pertinent only to explain the reactions and responses they elicited. You are not to consider these opinions and statements by Special Agent Rebecca McKenzie or Sergeant Joseph Miller as true, but only to establish the context of Dwain Hall's reactions and responses." State?

Speaker 18 (06:56:54):

I think that reads well, Your Honor. No objection.

Mr. Barrett (06:56:55):

Agreed, Your Honor.

Judge McCourt (06:56:55):

Okay. Okay. 2.7, closing argument. State, any objection?

Speaker 18 (06:57:09):

No, Your Honor.

Judge McCourt (06:57:10):

And defense, any objection?

Mr. Barrett (06:57:11):

No objection, Judge.

Judge McCourt (06:57:12):

I know y'all have tried cases with me before. When I read the instructions tomorrow, I will read up to 2.7, closing argument, I will give that instruction. And then we'll break and y'all can have the time you need for closing. How long State do you think you all need? Who's making the close tomorrow? Ms. Burn?

Ms. Burn (06:57:27):

In total?

Speaker 18 (06:57:27):

Yeah, in total.

Ms. Burn (06:57:31):

Not more than an hour and a half.

Judge McCourt (06:57:33):

Okay. All right. 90 minutes a side sufficient?

Ms. Burn (06:57:38):

I believe so.

Mr. Barrett (06:57:38):

That's more than enough time for me, Judge.

Judge McCourt (06:57:41):

Okay. If either of y'all need any additional time, provided you use your time wisely and you're not going over by hours or days, I'm sure the jury would be fine listening to a few more minutes, and you'll get that, okay?

Ms. Burn (06:57:50):

Thank you, Judge.

Mr. Barrett (06:57:50):

Thank you.

Judge McCourt (06:57:52):

Hope it's quiet on 90 in the morning.

(06:57:59)
All right. Rules for deliberation. One through six and eight are given in all cases. I believe we should give seven here.

Speaker 18 (06:58:10):

Yes, sir.

Mr. Barrett (06:58:11):

Agreed.

Judge McCourt (06:58:13):

Any other objections to 3.10, rules for deliberation?

Speaker 18 (06:58:21):

No objection, Your Honor.

Mr. Barrett (06:58:22):

No objection.

Judge McCourt (06:58:23):

Okay. Cautionary instructions, standard, any objection, State?

Speaker 18 (06:58:26):

No, sir.

Judge McCourt (06:58:27):

Defense?

Mr. Barrett (06:58:28):

No, Your Honor.

Judge McCourt (06:58:29):

All right. Verdict form. Let's look at the language. We'll move to the forms themselves in a minute. Any objection to language of 3.12, State?

Speaker 18 (06:58:37):

No, Your Honor.

Judge McCourt (06:58:38):

Defense?

Mr. Barrett (06:58:47):

No, no, Your Honor, no objection.

Judge McCourt (06:58:50):

Let's look at the [inaudible 06:58:51] for count one, style of the case at the top.

Speaker 18 (06:58:55):

You have two, the defendant is not guilty listed there.

Mr. Barrett (06:59:02):

That's fine.

Speaker 18 (06:59:04):

It should be bold, actually.

Judge McCourt (06:59:06):

We have A, B, C, D, guilty of first degree murder, guilty of second degree murder, guilty of manslaughter, not guilty.

Speaker 18 (06:59:12):

No objection to count one.

Judge McCourt (06:59:14):

Defense?

Mr. Barrett (06:59:15):

No objection, Judge.

Judge McCourt (06:59:18):

Verdict as to count two?

Speaker 18 (06:59:20):

No objection.

Judge McCourt (06:59:22):

Defense?

Mr. Barrett (06:59:24):

No objection, Judge.

Judge McCourt (06:59:27):

We have 3.12 here, 3.12A, single defendant, multiple counts.

Speaker 18 (06:59:33):

No objection.

Mr. Barrett (06:59:34):

No objection.

Judge McCourt (06:59:35):

We have 3.13, submitting the case to the jury.

Speaker 18 (06:59:38):

No objection.

Judge McCourt (06:59:41):

The only thing I want to talk with y'all about is the audio and video recording. You all want those to go back, correct, State?

Speaker 18 (06:59:59):

Yes, sir. We can load them on the laptop if the defense agrees to that process.

Judge McCourt (07:00:02):

Yeah. Defense?

Mr. Barrett (07:00:03):

I don't have a problem with that, Judge.

Judge McCourt (07:00:05):

We'll have the laptop brought in in a moment.

Speaker 18 (07:00:08):

I have it, Your Honor.

Ms. Burn (07:00:08):

It's right here, we already have it.

Speaker 18 (07:00:09):

I have it.

Judge McCourt (07:00:10):

The court laptop?

Speaker 18 (07:00:11):

Yes.

Judge McCourt (07:00:12):

Excellent. Good. Who got that for you, but excellent that they did. Probably my assistant.

(07:00:23)
All right. With that in order. Anything else in the instructions, State?

Speaker 18 (07:00:29):

No, Your Honor.

Judge McCourt (07:00:29):

Defense?

Mr. Barrett (07:00:29):

No, Your Honor.

Judge McCourt (07:03:06):

Laura, if you don't mind looking these over before we photocopy them. This is the final packet here.

Mr. Barrett (07:03:28):

Judge, I'm assuming the court's going to just ... Is this my copy or the court-

Judge McCourt (07:03:34):

No, no, just email it to you.

Mr. Barrett (07:03:34):

Just to make sure?

Judge McCourt (07:03:35):

Yeah. I want you to y'all double check them. Yeah, because that copy that y'all are holding, that's going to be photocopied for the jurors.

Mr. Barrett (07:03:43):

Okay.

Judge McCourt (07:05:16):

I also have verdict forms, lawyers, if you want to look at them, they'll be separate. Mr. Barrett, do you want that paper copy?

Mr. Barrett (07:05:25):

That's fine, Judge, I'm going to make copies tomorrow.

Judge McCourt (07:05:28):

Yah. I'm going to email this digital copy to both of you so y'all can-

Mr. Barrett (07:05:33):

That's fine, I have a printer.

Judge McCourt (07:05:37):

Yeah. My printer's low on toner, so it's a little light in the middle, I don't like it.

Speaker 18 (07:05:42):

Both the State and the defense have looked over the copy you've given us, it seems to reflect all the changes we've discussed.

Judge McCourt (07:05:47):

Okay. Very good.

Mr. Barrett (07:05:47):

Agreed.

Judge McCourt (07:05:48):

Forms of verdict are acceptable?

Speaker 18 (07:05:50):

Yes, Your Honor.

Mr. Barrett (07:05:51):

Yes, Your Honor.

Judge McCourt (07:05:53):

Okay.

Speaker 18 (07:05:53):

You want this copy back?

Judge McCourt (07:05:55):

Actually, if you all want to keep it, I'm going to print new stuff off on a different printer.

Mr. Barrett (07:05:58):

Thank you.

Judge McCourt (07:06:05):

State, defense, is there anything that we have to take up before morning?

Speaker 18 (07:06:09):

No, your Honor.

Mr. Barrett (07:06:09):

No, your Honor.

Judge McCourt (07:06:13):

Okay. All right, Mr. Hall, we will see you tomorrow morning, okay?

Dwain Hall (07:06:15):

Yes, sir.

Judge McCourt (07:06:15):

All right.

Speaker 19 (07:06:15):

[inaudible 07:06:29]

‍

Topics:
No items found.
Hungry For More?

Luckily for you, we deliver. Subscribe to our blog today.

Thank You for Subscribing!

A confirmation email is on it’s way to your inbox.

Share this post

Copyright Disclaimer

Under Title 17 U.S.C. Section 107, allowance is made for "fair use" for purposes such as criticism, comment, news reporting, teaching, scholarship, and research. Fair use is permitted by copyright statute that might otherwise be infringing.

Subscribe to The Rev Blog

Sign up to get Rev content delivered straight to your inbox.